ace cash advance bakersfield credit cards abroad compare best flight points credit card canada apply for student credit card visa payday lenders uk only capital one hbc credit card disadvantages of cash advances on credit cards new credit cards canada 2013 hhgregg credit card payment ge capital canada credit card selector what are the best credit cards in canada secured visa credit card application international credit card processing toys r us rewards credit card login credit card with good exchange rates annual credit card report free citibank credit card online application malaysia how to apply credit card in icici best credit card company to work for formula to calculate interest paid on a credit card best cashback credit cards uae 0 credit cards transfer fee santander credit card balance transfer overdraft unsecured horizon credit card payday advance service compare travel credit cards canada 2013 best cash back no fee credit card canada where to buy prepaid visa cards in singapore barclays credit card payment online what is credit card apr clark howard best credit cards for college students canadian visa credit cards bad credit visa debit cards wikipedia business credit cards rewards reviews instant pay loans uk credit cards for bad credit instant approval no deposit bank of america credit card payment deadline best travel credit cards with no annual fee cash back offer credit cards india apple store credit card swipe no foreign transaction fee credit card usa top 10 best store credit cards e payment of hdfc credit cards credit card acquiring bank definition payday loans uk bad credit wells fargo visa credit card customer service phone number standard chartered credit card apply now hsbc credit card balance transfer fee is there an app for barclays credit card get a free visa gift card online best business credit card canada standard bank platinum card requirements best travel credit cards offers american express prepaid credit card promotion code credit cards with low apr for students ambank transfer credit card balance credit card bank islam application how to accept credit card payments scotiabank scene visa card application visa credit cards bad credit will visa debit cards work in europe credit card 0 interest for 24 months canada quick payday loans for bad credit credit card offers for students with no credit black credit card visa limits tips for getting a secured credit card standard chartered credit card travel offers icici credit card charges for international transactions td canada trust visa application mastercard securecode citibank balance transfer 2013 how to redeem hdfc credit card points online cash advance loans online south africa platinum card post office my credit rating visa card security code free visa credit card offers how to get credit cards paid off fast south west trains network gold card bank of america small business credit card reader negotiate credit card debt settlement chase wells fargo international credit card fees use us credit card in uk psn can i consolidate my credit card debt into a home loan visa air miles credit card canada credit card late fees law sear credit card rewards chase credit card spending limits compare business credit cards uk magnum cash advance payday loan first time credit card applications online vanilla gift visa card check balance activate new cibc credit card all ge money bank credit cards miles and more credit card review capital one guaranteed credit card sunoco gas credit card account 0 balance transfer and purchase credit cards hdfc credit card instant payment online credit card applications for bad credit no fee storing credit card information in mysql quickbooks online processing credit cards best bad credit cards unsecured icici credit card offers on jewellery how to use facebook credits cards credit card loan interest rate calculator best payday loans over 3 months sbi bank corporate credit card hdfc credit card payment from other credit card consumer reports best credit card rewards mbna low interest credit card canada bank of america corporate credit card rewards apply for credit card bad credit rating uk credit card debt 2012 apply for a orchard bank credit card online payday advance loans for bad credit hsbc new credit card apply redwood credit union secured credit cards can you pre pay credit cards best credit cards 2010 top credit cards for cash rewards hsbc credit card cash loan hsbc canada credit card rewards how do i accept credit cards online 100 guaranteed secured credit cards anz low rate platinum credit card hdfc credit card travel offers 2013 citibank credit card offer on snapdeal best rewards cards for average credit united airlines credit card uk bonus miles best capital one business credit card best transfer balance credit cards city bank credit card apply india how to install free apps on ipad without credit card how does credit card balance transfers work best buy credit cards login credit cards with low interest rates canada malaysia credit card comparison lloyds student credit card ppi apply credit cards yes bank credit cards india travel credit cards canada 2013 anz credit card insurance features best credit cards to reestablish credit after bankruptcy tesco credit card online account manager prepaid visa card canada fees what is a secured credit card and how does it work credit cards for poor credit history uk air mile credit cards canada reviews on citi student credit cards best mobile credit card apps citibank credit cards for bad credit understanding credit and credit cards chevron texaco credit card login do i need a credit card to rent a car in florida zero balance transfer no fee credit cards low rate credit card comparison most popular credit cards in australia do visa debit cards work in europe best credit cards usa 2013 instant credit card approval and use online amazon uk credit card online cash advance payday loans paypal pro test credit card numbers credit cards for no credit and no bank account small cash loans uk get a credit card with no credit and no job apply for sears credit card online what credit cards can i apply for with no credit cibc visa air miles credit card how to get us credit card for foreigners credit card companies that use experian only credit card after bankruptcy discharge canada what is the best credit card rewards program in canada loan with bad credit and no bank account toys r us credit card ge capital no credit credit cards instant approval canada rbc visa cards rewards capital one credit card first four numbers walmart credit card payments login citibank credit card balance transfer rates how to get an online payday loan lost visa card canada rbc view icici credit card status best cash back business credit cards 2012 psn credit card information not valid 2013 post office credit card balance transfer existing customers applying for credit card with bad credit score best credit card offers for students 2012 discover credit card application phone number which credit card should i get if i have no credit best travel reward credit card offers jail sentence for credit card fraud south west trains gold card free weekend travel need help with credit card debt united credit card hotel deals best credit card promotions best deals on credit card balance transfers city bank credit card customer care number gujarat sears credit card rewards hsbc credit card fraud detection using data mining techniques costco credit card processing rates for small business lenders for home loans with bad credit best corporate credit card programs capital one platinum credit card limits online payday lenders shut down air miles credit cards instant approval student credit cards best credit card to build credit history compare visa rewards cards square credit card review cnet visa cards start with what numbers granite credit card uk free credit card numbers with cvv best cashback credit card comparison free valid credit card numbers with cvv2 2012 i need a unsecured credit card for bad credit 12 month payday loans payday loan uk direct lender no fee no credit credit card capital advance payday loans visa credit cards canada credit card application online bpi payday loans online same day south africa online loans in south africa hdfc credit card apply online in hyderabad citibank credit cards uk best buy application for credit card cash back credit card offers 2013 chicago cta credit card machines how to get approved for a credit card with no job virgin prepaid credit card south africa canara bank credit card apply online in india aqua credit card contact standard chartered credit card promotions singapore apply for credit card with bad credit in canada guaranteed unsecured credit card bad credit household credit card application 0 balance transfer credit cards poor credit rating belk credit card benefits best no annual fee visa card in canada no credit check loans ireland best credit card company for students top credit card rewards 2013 best united airlines credit card bank of america merchant services credit card rates credit card terminal rental ireland new business credit cards instant approval reloadable prepaid credit card australia prepaid disney visa card icici credit card settlement noc natwest credit card online services review email care credit for pets paypal not accepting prepaid credit cards why do i need a credit card for free apps on kindle fire credit card companies with best rewards program hack valid credit card numbers with cvv numbers credit card bad credit unsecured no deposit nordstrom visa credit card phone number where is credit card number on visa 0 credit card offers for good credit how to apply for a credit card in axis bank paypal non-profit credit card processing fees cimb platinum credit card application form are credit card annual fees vatable cheapest credit card rates canada types of credit cards in south africa credit card debt settlement letter uk what is the best secured credit card to get in canada wells fargo credit card cash advance help paying off credit card debt new payday lenders not brokers apply visa credit card fair credit discovery credit card statement is it worth getting a disney credit card my tesco credit card online credit card numbers for testing natwest black card review whats the cheapest way to accept credit cards halifax credit card online application valero gas credit card login low interest rate credit cards with no annual fee loans with bad credit rating in australia sbi credit card eligibility calculator test credit card numbers india are cash advances on credit cards bad mis sold ppi credit card calculator shell business credit card login halifax platinum credit card minimum payment singapore credit card merchant charges valid credit card number and security code guaranteed approval credit cards for poor credit sbi platinum credit card credit limit generate us credit card number american express corporate credit card credit check need a credit card to build credit manual credit card machine slips free balance transfer credit card canada wireless credit card machine reviews online virtual credit cards uk shell gas credit card offers interest free balance transfer credit cards canada how can credit cards offer cash back guaranteed approval credit cards unsecured easiest store credit cards to get approved for with bad credit best credit cards for bad credit unsecured citi credit card offers for bad credit cash advance online in minutes australia virtual credit card number usa how to get approved for a car loan with bad credit website to pay shell credit card instant payday advance online credit card travel insurance commonwealth bank barclays visa credit card uk sbi credit card customer care number for bangalore how to transfer chase credit card balance to another card best buy credit card login mastercard payday loans like wonga where do you get prepaid credit cards in canada chase visa card security code visa black card reviews 2012 the best credit card to use abroad capital one credit card app iphone marriott premier credit card status chevron credit card hold 126 no fee prepaid credit card canada walmart discover credit card customer service is the united credit card a good deal hsbc credit card application online status payday loans no fees no calls how to reduce your credit card debt yourself venture capital one credit card no annual fee paypal ebay credit card payment free apple credit card reader online credit cards instant approval unsecured credit card with bad credit apply for a mastercard debit card sear credit card offers citibank singapore credit card minimum payment business credit cards offering air miles small business options for accepting credit card payments visa credit card phone number canada walmart credit card frauds visa business credit card no personal guarantee how to choose a credit card singapore cibc credit card services online capital one secured credit card guaranteed approval top credit card deals 2012 best secured credit cards 2013 myer visa card annual fee 4 major credit card companies hsbc credit card apply capital one journey credit card for students cash back visa card cash back credit card reviews canada delta skymiles credit card good deal best first credit card non prepaid virtual credit card best gas credit card deals 2012 get credit card with bad credit no deposit payday cash advance loans maryland where is the credit card number located on an american express credit card best balance transfer credit cards for good credit best marriott rewards credit card online loan lenders direct best cash back rewards credit cards td debit visa cards how to apply for hsbc credit card online credit card services bank of ireland contact ebay buyer protection credit card best gas credit cards for students walmart credit card payment login page shell credit card application online best credit card no annual fee no foreign transaction fee best buy credit card mobile app bank of ireland visa debit card locked marriott rewards visa signature credit card login real direct payday loan lender business credit card 0 apr balance transfer barclay credit card virtual credit card indonesia gratis valid credit card numbers with cvv 2012 prepaid credit cards org uk tesco travel card best store credit cards after bankruptcy best business cash back credit cards 2011 chase toys r us credit card mailing address amazon chase credit card services buy visa gift card online instant prepaid visa credit card australia halifax credit card contact address where can i get online loan southwest rapid rewards credit card upgrade tesco credit card 0 balance transfer barclays business credit card online post bankruptcy credit cards offers cibc visa cards with rewards personal bad credit loans california credit cards for business with bad credit best credit cards for bad credit history do visa debit cards work in japan nab credit card travel insurance key ring reward cards app review how to get a business loan with bad credit in canada secured visa credit cards bank of america corporate credit card login what credit card has no international transaction fees pay lic premium using credit cards does applying for secured credit card hurt your credit score barclay credit card login online how long does a bank of america credit card application take sample visa card number iphone credit card app no monthly fee credit card purchase protection mastercard what does it mean to get pre approved for a credit card visa card number and security code credit card balance transfer comparison calculator best loans to pay off credit card debt best credit card app compare credit card terminals uk chase sapphire credit card interest rates how to reduce credit card debt without ruining credit new credit card law minimum payment black cardboard boxes nz halifax credit card services postal address what us credit cards are accepted in the uk best buy rewards credit card make payment what credit card has the lowest interest rate in the philippines no interest credit cards credit card apr comparison calculator sbi irctc credit card helpline online payday advance no credit check td visa gold cash back starbucks credit card balance gold credit card uk safe online cash advance loans martin lewis best balance transfer credit cards how to get an itunes account without a credit card in uk how to accept credit cards online small business capital one ventureone rewards credit card reviews pro score credit card scale chase credit card approval odds best secured credit cards in canada 2013 credit report free uk lowest interest credit card australia do i need a credit card to build credit history how to accept credit cards on iphone 4 business credit card natwest online iphone credit card case kickstarter secure credit card capital one td canada trust visa gold sign up for a visa credit card canada hdfc platinum credit cards redeem points what kind of credit card should i get with no credit free bad credit bank accounts get uk credit card number black card visa canada one time credit card authorization form template virgin low rate credit card review how to apply citibank credit card philippines credit limit increase capital one canada best business credit cards for small business 2011 credit card loan emi calculator low interest credit card for average credit hsbc credit card settlement department shell citi credit card contact pnc everyday rewards credit card online payday loans south africa hdfc credit card deals and offers citibank credit card application status singapore cash back credit card comparison uk how to get a car loan with bad credit in ireland hyatt credit card offer review how to get an amscot cash advance credit card balance transfer instant approval miles and more credit card usa barclay free credit card numbers that work 2012 delta skymiles credit card companion tickets amazon uk credit card login credit card fraud detection project source code best buy credit card no interest 12 months what;s the best credit card for balance transfers free fico score no credit card fake credit cards that work online 2013 compare credit card balance transfer rates credit card bad credit no deposit bad credit loan companies list discover card approval with bad credit instant cash loans no brokers where can i pay my bestbuy credit card payday loan bad credit direct lenders only get a credit card with bad credit unsecured best canadian credit card to use in usa biggest credit card issuers uk air canada credit card rewards personal loan to reduce credit card debt stolen credit card numbers forum best payday lenders bad credit how to get a personal loan with bad credit and a cosigner what are credit cards made out of should i get another credit card to improve my credit score
Home MLB Network / Extra Innings Extra Innings Deal Makes Poor Long-Term Business Sense

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 627 guests online

Atom RSS

Extra Innings Deal Makes Poor Long-Term Business Sense Print
User Rating: / 23
Written by Maury Brown   
Wednesday, 28 March 2007 06:21

Maury BrownYesterday saw several principle players in the Extra Innings saga testify before the US Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation at a hearing entitled Exclusive Sports Programming: Examining Competition and Consumer Choice. Rob Jacobson President and Chief Executive Officer for iN DEMAND Networks, Bob DuPuy President and Chief Operating Officer for Major League Baseball, Chase Carey Chief Executive Officer for DIRECTV Group, Inc., and Carl Vogel President & Vice Chairman EchoStar Satellite L.L.C. all had time at the microphone.

As the prepared statements provided here on The Biz of Baseball show, there are some key facets—namely the upcoming The Baseball Channel—that are creating the impasse on getting all the incumbents in a place to carry Extra Innings.

In a nutshell, DirecTV has offered to pay for the rights to show The Baseball Channel up-front, and now. Given the fact that ratings for NFL Network have not exactly been stellar (the heavily hyped debut game on the fledgling network pulled an averaged 4.2 million total viewers and a 2.3 household rating according to Nielsen, nearly one-third what Monday Night Football pulls on ESPN), you might understand why Robert Jacobson of iN Demand offered up a compromise deal in his opening statement. “If The Baseball Channel launches in 2009, we would give MLB the right to cancel the Extra Innings deal if it cannot reach a satisfactory agreement for carriage of the new channel with our owners,” Jacobson said. “This would put off the issue of The Baseball Channel until it actually launches and ensure that for the next two years at least, all baseball fans will have access to the Extra Innings package.”

After the statement was made, Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) asked Bob DuPuy, “"What's the matter with that?”

Well, here’s what’s the matter with that: If MLB re-negotiates with iN Demand, MLB has to renegotiate with DirecTV, and possibly EchoStar if they get onboard. The exclusive deal takes the risk off MLB and places it on DirecTV. As mentioned, if ratings for the NFL Network are not high by comparison to games shown on ESPN, how will MLB fair? After all, the NFL enjoys a vastly more popular product. Also, by DirecTV offering an up-front payment as opposed to iN Demand’s offer make The Baseball Channel available on a per subscriber basis, MLB has those funds available for any start-up costs involved in launching The Baseball Channel.

(Select Read More to view the rest of Maury Brown's article) 

Back to iN Demand, it seemed more than a bit ironic that they played themselves up as the “good guys” in this deal. After all, there are exclusive deals for cable that involve the Mets, White Sox, Padres and Phillies. As reported by Richard Sandomir of the NY Times in late February:

The owners will also have their own interests at heart. The Mets are partners in SNY with two cable operators, Time Warner and Comcast; the White Sox and Cubs are also partners with Comcast in Chicago. The Atlanta Braves are caught between being sold by Time Warner, which owns cable networks like TBS, to Liberty Media, which is taking over DirecTV.

The Padres' cable games are not licensed to satellite, so if their local fans switch to DirecTV to continue to watch Extra Innings, they will not get their own team's games unless they buy both services.

Comcast SportsNet in Philadelphia is not delivered by satellite as most regional sports networks like YES and SNY are, which leaves 300,000 or more DirecTV subscribers (at least 50 percent more than total national cable subscribership to Extra Innings) in that market without access to those cable games. Comcast's refusal to put its sports network on satellite has been challenged by DirecTV and EchoStar but affirmed by the federal government.

So, it’s not as if cable isn’t playing a roll in the exclusivity matter, as well. It should be interesting if you live in San Diego, have to watch the Padres on cable due to an exclusive deal with Cox, and you want to watch Extra Innings. In that instance, it appears you’ll have to have DirecTV, AND cable.

As for DirecTV, Chase Carey provided some analysis by dartboard. “DIRECTV estimates that there are relatively few viewers – no more than three percent of the cable segment (approximately 180,000 Extra Innings subscribers) – who cannot receive DIRECTV service,” Carey said in his opening statement. “This translates to roughly 5,000 subscribers – each of whom can access the games over the Internet.”

This is analogous to saying, “When a breeze blows through pile of leaves, 5,000 of them will be displaced.” It’s wholly arbitrary. How Carey and DirecTV came about this figure had to come with sticking their finger in the wind, but it did, none the less, create a case where the figure will be published and the myth will, in time, become engrained as revisionist history.

The other issue that got a lot of play regarded MLB’s willingness to offer a 20% ownership equity in The MLB Channel to DirecTV, while not giving this same offer to the incumbents. As Carl Vogel of EchoStar said, “However, in its entirety must be apples to apples, which will require EchoStar to acquire a pro-rata ownership of The MLB Channel,” Carey said in his opening statement. “In a letter dated March 22nd, from Major League Baseball, they state they are not in a position to offer any equity in connection with this ‘opt-in’ opportunity without DirecTV’s consent. It will be interesting to see whether that consent is forthcoming, and with what conditions, as DirecTV reconciles whether it wears its ownership hat for the MLB Channel or its hat as a competitive distributor.”

While DISH has seemed almost a secondary player in all of this, word came late yesterday by way of the Sports Business Journal, that EchoStar has offered up, what they feel, matches MLB’s terms as it pertains to financials, and distribution. For the deal to fly, EchoStar is asking for an ownership stake in The Baseball Channel, as well. The sides were reportedly mulling the offer over.

The biggest question is, what is MLB’s endgame in all of this?

As I’ve reported before, the exclusive deal does not make good long-term business sense. Limiting viewers is a poor growth model, beyond the ill-will that has been created in this process. No matter how many times you turn the deal over in your head, one asks if by not making the deal exclusive, if MLB would have come out financially in the long run.

iN Demand offered $70 million per-year in a non-exclusive arrangement. If DirecTV offered half of what they are offering in an exclusive arrangement ($50 million), MLB would come out $20 million a year ahead of where they are now, and that’s without DISH in play. Maybe it’s a matter of driving consumers to MLB.TV. After all Bob DuPuy said yesterday, “If iN Demand and Dish choose not to step up to the plate as DirecTV has done, fans will still have several options.  They can switch to DirecTV, they can subscribe to MLB.TV and watch the games on the Internet, and they can watch the roughly 400 games that every fan in every Major League market has available without the out-of-market package.” That’s convenient. MLB will pull in revenues from the displaced through their online offering. Still, is it going to be enough to offset the revenues that could have been pulled in by keeping all the incumbents in the fold?

Added to this, there is more of the “ill-will” factor as it pertains to the relationship that MLB needs to keep with cable. Is it simply not a matter of time before MLB comes to cable looking to get The MLB Channel carried?

So, to repeat, the deal makes poor long-term business sense, outside of fan ill-will.

Lastly, I should note (once again) that I’ve been a DirecTV subscriber for some time and chose to do so for reasons outside of Extra Innings. Still, I’ve subscribed to EI in the past, and will continue to do so in the future. With that, and the season on the cusp, I looked up the schedule. Sunday, there was a limited slate of games on tap. Now, DirecTV is showing a more complete slate of games to choose from. At least that’s one less matter to be critical of in what might be deemed “ExtraInningsGate”.

 Maury Brown is the founder and president of The Biz of Baseball and an author for Baseball Prospectus. He can be contacted here. 



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?