cheapest way to accept credit cards by phone bp gas rebate credit cards pnb credit card application form free download credit cards for business chase credit card services payment address mastercard credit card rental car insurance coverage best visa card for travel citibank credit cards balance transfer offers axis bank credit card customer care indian credit card comparison chart hdfc credit card toll free number chandigarh pay neiman marcus credit card bad credit credit cards australia instant approval barclays credit card contact number buy prepaid credit card uk citibank business credit card login uk link southwest rapid rewards credit card sbi credit card application form download no balance transfer fee credit cards 2011 best us credit card no foreign transaction fee direct payday lenders online no credit check sentinel credit card protection insurance payday loan lender chase marathon gas credit card barclay credit card contact us low interest fee credit card scotiabank value? visa card easy to get unsecured credit cards 2012 apply mbna credit card canada get quick loans online southwest chase visa credit card login standard chartered credit card offers on flipkart payment protection credit card vs debit card bad credit loan lenders new credit card charges canada average credit card processing fees 2012 hdfc credit card payment by cheque anz corporate credit card singapore 5 major credit card companies westpac credit card travel insurance policy chase credit card international transaction fees green or black cardamom virgin credit card minimum monthly payment credit card loan consolidation companies apply online for credit card axis bank hsbc visa credit card uk best buy reward zone credit card app top 5 best credit card companies how long do you have to wait between applying for credit cards unauthorized credit card charges police report hyatt regency mccormick place credit card authorization form rak bank credit card payment machine in dubai best mobile credit card processing paypal how to get a visa credit card with bad credit offer credit card payoff short term poor credit loans best airline reward credit cards 2011 compare credit card rates need 5000 loan bad credit fast money magazine best credit cards 2011 travel wells fargo visa credit card customer service phone number bank of america visa credit card fees same day payday loans interest rate of hdfc platinum credit card jquery credit card validator credit cards travel rewards reviews need a credit card asap perks for disney credit card holders credit cards explained for dummies uk bank of america lost credit card phone number sbi credit card with no annual fee in india splunk search for credit card number easy store credit cards to get approved for with bad credit zero percent credit cards on purchases sign up for credit card and get free flight how to pay hdfc credit card payment options pay my tesco credit card online icici bank credit card apply online india low interest credit card balance transfer nz firestone credit card pay by phone hdfc bank credit card helpline number bangalore aqua credit card over limit e gift visa card balance transfer from hdfc credit card to sbi credit card get free virtual credit card household credit card application free virtual credit cards online starwood american express credit card bonus can you use a personal credit card for business expenses sbi credit card login id hdfc gold credit card emi calculator icici credit card apply prepaid credit cards in canada walmart fair poor credit credit cards credit card for student with no credit history secured business credit card canada td canada trust credit card balance protection plus intuit canada credit card processing how does credit card debt consolidation work best credit card rewards program canada 2011 tesco credit card online uk free virtual credit card number chase credit card lost cash loans in minutes bad credit your access to natwest credit card online services is locked out cash advance credit card fees unsecured credit cards for no credit history first premier bank credit card processing fee online credit card processing for small business uk payday loans no credit check no guarantor no fees no brokers chase prepaid business credit card discover credit card payment protection clark howard how to choose a credit card cash back credit card comparison 2013 best credit card rates nz chase first usa credit card citibank credit card best credit card company for building credit 5 best credit cards for travel credit card application instant decision secured credit cards bad credit instant approval instant bad credit loans canada halifax credit card cash advance fees free air mile credit cards standard bank credit cards application mastercard credit card number example compare hdfc gold and titanium credit cards hello kitty credit card visa circuit city credit card chase bank car loan interest rate calculator bad credit cash advance credit card atm pin free credit card authorization form pdf credit card low interest balance transfer australia cibc visa credit card online banking tesco bank credit card login mastercard credit cards for no credit history credit card business process diagram best credit cards in canada 2012 uk credit card number fake best credit cards with airmiles canada icici credit card helpline number delhi easy payday loans online uk pay loans online direct student can you get cashback on a walmart credit card american airlines credit card foreign transaction fee guaranteed credit card approval for bad credit unsecured best way to consolidate your credit card debt how to apply for credit card online in india elavon credit card processing costco student credit cards with cash back credit card comparison chart malaysia td canada trust first class visa rewards credit card no credit history no deposit what credit cards does the u s post office accept bad credit loan companies in georgia best prepaid canadian credit cards credit card rewards comparison australia fast payday loans direct lender student credit card reviews canada should i get another credit card virgin credit cards online login delta skymiles credit card free companion ticket longest interest free credit cards australia capital one credit card consolidation 3 month payday loans no brokers clark howard best credit cards 2013 toyota rewards visa credit card website best credit card no annual fee no foreign transaction fee bank of america credit card payment deadline credit card interchange fees explained get a no credit credit card credit card offer on snapdeal hdfc bank master credit card online payment what is a good percentage rate for a credit card 3 free credit reports no credit card fast cash advance loans online application for credit card visa natwest student credit card ppi air miles credit card uk report credit card fraud to police best credit cards for cash back rewards 2013 visa credit card services contact best secured credit card in canada irctc sbi credit card login american airlines aadvantage credit card uk air mile credit cards uk citi corporate credit card payment credit cards with low interest rates and no fees bank of america pay loans online security bank online application for credit cards top instant decision credit cards best credit card rewards comparison priceline rewards visa card review pay advance tax online citibank belk credit card requirements best cashback credit cards 2012 malaysia 0 transfer apr credit cards pink hello kitty credit card credit cards comparison uae capital one cash rewards credit cards how to apply for add on credit card in sbi 1-hour payday loans online direct lenders usaa rate advantage credit card review where can i get online loan best student credit cards with low apr credit card merchant fees comparison how to consolidate credit card debt best deals on credit card balance transfers is it easy to get a capital one secured credit card top 10 best prepaid credit cards explain the difference between a secured and unsecured credit card how to negotiate with credit card companies to payoff bad credit installment loans direct lender walmart discover credit card login page citibank credit card apply capital one first premier credit card hdfc bank credit cards rewards points redemption how does applying for a credit card affect your credit score top credit cards 2013 canada new credit card fees in canada lic credit card new application form tesco credit card lost 0 interest credit cards for 24 months canada new look black fluffy cardigan premier disney credit card what credit cards are good for rebuilding credit us bank credit card comparison tool delta miles credit card deals chase credit cards southwest visa pc richards ge capital credit card travel credit cards best canada www hbc com creditcard nationwide credit card balance transfer fee staples credit card business login magtek idynamo credit card reader ipad top best credit cards for college students ge capital bank credit card uk small business credit cards chase accept credit card payments iphone apply for first premier secured credit card secured credit cards to rebuild credit reviews halifax credit card ppi payouts housing loans for bad credit in singapore check chevron credit card application status using credit cards before bankruptcy uk net pay advance wichita credit card credit limit credit score halifax credit card ppi complaints black cardigan coat 0 credit card deals for existing customers capital one secured credit card application best buy credit card make a payment does cibc have prepaid credit cards car loan payment calculator bad credit how to apply for hsbc credit card online american express prepaid credit cards paypal 4 main types of credit cards cash advance payday loans atlanta ga php secure credit card storage paying off credit card debt advice pre pay credit cards can you consolidate credit card debt with bad credit nationwide credit card balance transfer to current account what is a cash advance limit on a credit card icici credit card apply online hyderabad icici credit card with no annual fee in india southwest rapid rewards plus credit card review what is the best credit card for rewards uk natwest your points credit card review natwest student credit card abroad hdfc credit cards online application how much does a prepaid credit card cost at walmart hsbc credit card online payment options best canadian visa rewards card best secured credit card usaa halifax clarity credit card exchange rates excel sheet to calculate credit card interest petro canada credit card services easy to obtain department store credit cards joint credit card company how to make cash advance in bpi credit card credit card for bad credit no annual fee no deposit speck iphone credit card case credit card low interest no annual fee secured short term loans online bad credit credit card unsecured credit card with cashback on all purchases compare platinum and titanium credit cards best prepaid credit cards walmart how to activate cibc visa debit card citibank credit card approval code tips for getting a credit card quick payday loans instant cash when will aib get visa debit cards barclays premier credit card login westpac credit card travel insurance australia credit card protection services uk how do i sign up for itunes without a credit card college students and credit cards problems authorize.net credit card numbers for testing payday loans no credit check no upfront fees payday loan lenders no brokers no credit checks how to calculate credit card apr formula chase credit card payments number test paypal credit card numbers cvv sbi credit card payment through emi can i apply for a lowes credit card online the best credit card in the world nationwide credit card insurance cover american express prepaid credit card promotion code the best credit card to have yahoo answers hdfc credit card settlement process in india interest rates on car loans with bad credit rating singapore airlines credit card verification form best credit card interest rates canada jcpenney credit card pay my bill pay belk credit card with debit card cancel amazon visa card paypal canada virtual credit cards best rewards credit card 2011 australia capital one credit card transfer to bank account hdfc annual fee free credit cards fast online payday advance super fast payday loans poor credit loans guaranteed approval international credit card chip and pin hdfc credit cards offers air ticket gold card greenwoods credit card transaction fees explained hbc mastercard login natwest student credit card contact number credit card online apply bank of india apply for unsecured credit cards for bad credit can you get a target credit card with no credit history account number on visa debit card zero balance transfer credit cards malaysia quick bad credit loans no fees debit credit card machines costco citibank credit card interest rates in india online payday advance reviews credit card settlement process flow payday advance loans in augusta ga cdyne credit card verification web service orchard bank credit card customer care number payday loans no fees no calls no fee credit cards for bad credit instant approval secured and unsecured credit cards what the difference prepaid credit cards no fees best hdfc bank credit cards eligibility cibc credit card comparison shell oil company credit card application quicken credit card travel miles ikea uk credit card charges cash reward credit cards review best rewards credit cards with no annual fee instant cash loans online now axis bank credit card apply procedure southwest credit card with no annual fee costco gas credit cards accepted verizon small business credit card reader bad credit credit cards guaranteed approval australia set credit limit virgin mobile sbi credit card loan credit card bank mega carrefour chase visa credit card phone number citibank indian oil credit card online application barclays credit card application india ifsc code for hdfc credit card payment bangalore best online credit card processing fees dbs visa debit card application form american airlines business credit card and 75 000 miles best buy credit cards login wells fargo credit card services merchant direct rewards discover credit card login square credit card reader ipad 2 10 000 credit card debt relief canada pay lane bryant credit card credit card cash advance fee bank of america is it good to apply for multiple credit cards i don;t need a credit card to ride this train visa black card uk marriott rewards credit card uk review bad credit card offers unsecured credit cards for bad credit no credit check canada how do i get credit card logos for my website credit cards comparison uk best rate for balance transfers on credit cards malaysia payday loans like speedy cash hdfc credit card personal loan interest rate toyota visa rewards card login hdfc bank credit cards status check can you offer a credit card company a settlement best no annual fee credit card with reward credit cards for bad credit history and unemployed apply for a home loan online with bad credit personal loans for credit card debt consolidation is sears an easy credit card to get what is credit card security code cash advance payday loans standard chartered credit card customer care number jaipur anz cash advance calculator the best credit card for me axis bank credit card apply phone number cibc student visa credit card how to apply for hsbc credit card in sri lanka template letter to claim credit card charges compare credit cards with low interest rates amazon uk credit card application how to pay off cash advance loans best credit card terminal for restaurants how many times can you get cashback on a walmart credit card dbs black card amex mbna canada credit card payments us virtual credit card paypal virtual credit card us billing credit limit definition credit card credit card reward programs taxable hsbc credit card air miles help with credit card debt for unemployed lost visa card uk spending natwest credit card points pay belk credit card ipad credit card app canada credit card minimum payment best 0 credit card transfer deals how to get my name off a joint credit card credit card rewards uk check the status of my toys r us credit card application capital one balance transfer quick payday loans no credit check uk business cash advances citi credit cards canada online credit card verification best rewards credit card in the uk citibank credit card rewards philippines how does a wireless credit card terminal work starwood credit card australia best marriott rewards credit card offer online credit card generator with csc jcpenney credit card payments are secured credit cards good for rebuilding credit credit cards travel abroad online payday loans south africa cancel credit card credit rating real credit card numbers that work with security code and expiration date 2012 td visa reloadable prepaid card apply for credit card bad credit best online cash loans corporate credit card singapore direct instant payday loan lender uk hdfc credit cards offers in india best online credit card processing canada chase credit card fraud alert united cash loans login page icici credit card customer care number kochi american airlines credit card no annual fee can you use visa prepaid credit cards online cash advance lenders direct nandos black card song how to download free applications from itunes without credit card easiest credit card to get approved does target sell visa gift cards lufthansa miles and more credit card uk zero interest balance transfer credit cards canada mastercard credit card exchange rate low credit credit cards low apr temporary credit card number visa lowest interest credit cards canada company credit card policy nz new credit card offers for bad credit american aadvantage credit card promotion avoid cash advance fees credit card credit cards no annual fee no foreign transaction fee virgin credit card minimum payment amount payday loan online uk citibank credit card payment singapore hsbc old orchard credit card student credit cards instant approval no credit santander cash back credit card shoppers drug mart credit card easy to get which credit card has the best rewards 2011 united credit card bonus points natwest credit card late payment charges best buy credit card protection plan best credit card reward offers 2013 secured mastercard credit card visa credit card offers usa cheapest way to get a credit card machine credit card uk bad credit history credit cards no income guaranteed approval high limit credit cards free online debit visa card 0 intro apr business credit cards best credit card rate canada want apply visa credit card secured credit cards for bad credit uk credit card interest refund 100 day pay loans free prepaid credit card generator starwood preferred guest credit card bonus points best credit card for travel insurance canada
Home BoB Documents Cleveland Indians v US (US Court of Appeals)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 500 guests online

Atom RSS

Cleveland Indians v US (US Court of Appeals) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Court Ruling   
Thursday, 09 May 2002 12:00

CLEVELAND INDIANS BASEBALL

COMPANY,Plaintiff-Appellee,

v.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Defendant-Appellant.


May 10, 2000, Filed

JUDGES: Before: SUHRHEINRICH, COLE, Circuit Judges; and QUIST, District Judge. *

* The Honorable Gordon J. Quist, United States District Court for the Western District of Michigan, sitting by designation.

OPINION: PER CURIAM. The United States appeals from the judgment of the district court in which the court found that an award of back wages is taxed for the purposes of the Federal Insurance Contribution Act (FICA), 26 U.S.C. §§ 3101-3128, and Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA), 26 U.S.C. §§ 3301-3311, in the year in which those wages were earned rather than the year in which the award of back wages was actually paid. For the following reasons, we AFFIRM the district court's judgment.

I.

The parties stipulated to the facts of this case before the district court, which we briefly summarize here. Major League Baseball Clubs (the "Clubs") and the Major League Baseball Players Association ("MLBPA") were involved in three separate grievances in 1990, wherein the MLBPA claimed that the Clubs breached the Collective Bargaining Agreement ("CBA") with respect to free agency rights of the baseball players in 1986, 1987 and 1988. After an arbitration panel issued a series of rulings adverse to the Clubs, the Clubs and the MLBPA settled their grievances on December 21, 1990. The settlement required the Clubs to contribute $ 280 million to a custodial account for distribution to affected players according to the MLBPA framework approved by the arbitration panel.

The Cleveland Indians Baseball Company's ("Indians") share of the settlement fund was $ 610,000 for the 1986 season and $ 1,457,848 for the 1987 season. The Indians received the funds in 1994 and distributed those funds to the affected players -- eight players who were employed in 1986 and fifteen players who were employed in 1987. Unsure as to the tax treatment of these distributions, the Indians paid FICA and FUTA taxes on the total funds as if the payments were wages for services rendered in 1994. In other words, the Indians paid FICA and FUTA taxes on the funds as if they were actually wages received by the players in 1994, the year of distribution. The Indians paid these tax obligations in April 1994 and January 1995. None of the affected players, however, performed services for the Indians in 1994 or 1995. The Indians filed this instant action seeking reimbursement of the FICA and FUTA taxes paid to the United States.

The Indians sought a refund of FICA and FUTA taxes claiming that, (1) a portion of the funds paid to the Indians and disbursed to its former players constituted non-taxable interest; and (2) the non-interest portion was not taxable because the funds were damages for the wrongful breach of the CBA and not wages for services rendered. Finally, even if the payments constituted wages for services rendered rather than interest and damages, the Indians argued that they should have paid taxes at the 1986 and 1987 tax rates applicable when the services were rendered. Because the 1986 and 1987 FICA and FUTA taxes of each of the affected players were already paid to the maximum required amount, the Indians asserted that they are entitled to a full refund if the payments were determined to be wages for services rendered in 1986 and 1987.

The government initially disputed the Indians's claims. Both parties eventually agreed, however, that $ 629,000 of the payments from the settlement fund to affected players constituted interest and were not subject to FICA and FUTA taxes. Thus, the Indians were entitled to a refund for taxes paid on the interest portion of the settlement. The parties also agreed that the remaining portion of the payments, approximately $ 2 million, constituted back-wage payments, earnings that would have been paid in 1986 and 1987 but for the Clubs' breach of the CBA. The issue presented to this court is the tax year applicable to these back-wage payments made in 1994 for services rendered in the 1986 and 1987 baseball seasons.

In the district court, the government and the Indians agreed that our decision in Bowman v. United States, 824 F.2d 528 (6th Cir. 1987) directly addressed this precise issue. The Bowman court held that "a settlement for back wages should not be allocated to the period when the employer finally pays but 'should be allocated to the periods when the regular wages were not paid as usual.'" 824 F.2d at 530 (quoting Social Security Bd. v. Nierotko, 327 U.S. 358, 370, 90 L. Ed. 718, 66 S. Ct. 637 (1946)). Following Bowman, the district court entered judgment in favor of the Indians and ordered the United States to refund the FICA and FUTA taxes paid on the settlement disbursements designated as back wages, including interest from the dates on which the payments were made.

The United States sought en banc reversal of the Bowman decision. This court declined the en banc petition and the case was referred to this panel.

II.

Typically, statutory interpretations such as those presented in this appeal are reviewed de novo. See Williams v. Coyle, 167 F.3d 1036, 1038 (6th Cir. 1999).

Here, our precedent clearly indicates that the statutory provision in question requires settlements for back wages to be allocated to the period in which they were earned or should have been paid, and not to the period in which the back wages were actually disbursed. See Bowman, 824 F.2d at 530. The government contends that Bowman was wrongly decided, arguing that the plain language, legislative history and applicable FICA and FUTA Treasury Regulations demonstrate that back wages are subject to tax in the year in which payment is made and not in which the services were rendered. In addition, the government cites cases from our sister circuits that are at odds with our Bowman holding. Despite these arguments, the government "agrees with taxpayer that the issue presented in this case was decided in Bowman." Appellant Reply Br. at 1.

Even if we were persuaded by the government's argument, we are bound by the Bowman decision. It is firmly established that one panel of this court cannot overturn a decision of another panel; only the court sitting en banc can overturn such a decision. See United States v. Smith, 73 F.3d 1414, 1418 (6th Cir. 1996). "The earlier determination is binding authority unless a decision of the United States Supreme Court mandates modification or this Court sitting en banc overrules the prior decision." United States. v. Moody, 206 F.3d 609, 615 (6th Cir. 2000) (citing Salmi v. Secretary of HHS, 774 F.2d 685, 689 (6th Cir. 1985)). Accordingly, following Bowman, we reject the government's argument and affirm the district court's judgment that FUTA and FICA taxes paid on the back wage disbursements should have been paid as if earned in 1986 and 1987.

III.

For the foregoing reasons, we AFFIRM the district court's judgment.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?