how to negotiate a debt settlement with your credit card company when do chase credit card payments post prepaid credit cards abroad easiest department store credit cards for bad credit whats a good first credit card unsecured credit card consolidation loan icici credit card rewards points catalogue best cash rewards visa credit card citibank credit card online application india hdfc credit card customer care toll free number credit cards with best cash back rewards 2012 mastercard apr for cash advances how to apply for add on credit card in sbi how do i pay hdfc credit card bill online aadvantage credit card offer 75000 credit card promotions 2012 malaysia best credit cards deals 2013 natwest credit card 0800 high credit card limits for bad credit how to view my hdfc credit card statement does discover credit card work in canada usaa credit card travel benefits prepaid credit card online canada lowest interest rate credit card in uae easiest credit card to get with no credit guaranteed approval credit cards for poor credit royal bank of scotland india credit cards apply business credit card comparison uk credit card review singapore instant cash loans for the unemployed what is the best credit card to apply for to build credit credit card loan interest rate calculator best business credit card 2013 uk payday lenders bad credit chase disney credit card application status best credit card offers for students 2013 legit online loan lenders credit card verification form (ccvf) citibank virtual credit card mobile top 10 credit cards balance transfers 100 guaranteed payday loans online how to stop pre approved credit cards is it bad for your credit rating to cancel a credit card setting up a credit card merchant account can add funds paypal credit card best visa credit cards for bad credit credit card online application ireland how to get credit card limit increase chase benefits of not accepting credit cards best buy credit card payments does applying for credit card affect credit rating secured visa card canada cibc credit loans reviews canadian credit card comparison cash back platinum credit card icici bank best secured credit cards in canada 2013 credit cards uk bad credit cibc credit card online bill fund virtual credit card paypal best online prepaid credit card generic credit card authorization form word apply for a mastercard debit how to download free applications from itunes without credit card mastercard credit card application low rate credit card offers best travel credit card deals 2011 credit card holder leather do i need a credit card to rent a car in canada online loan bad credit instant hsbc credit card app for ipad chase student credit card karma points get a credit card online instantly best balance transfer credit cards for good credit best gas credit cards for students 0 credit cards transfer fee hdfc credit cards customer care number hyderabad barclays credit card statement online best balance transfer credit card no fee apply for credit card hsbc bank can applying for credit cards hurt credit score black visa card visa credit card travel insurance australia value city credit card customer service phone number do you need a credit card for paypal on ebay lloyds tsb airmiles duo credit card interest rate pre approved credit cards canada american express platinum card travel are air mile credit cards worth it most secure credit card companies us department of education pay loans online government travel credit card rules calculate credit card minimum payment excel can;t pay sallie mae loans orchard credit card login online how do i accept credit card payments capital one balance transfer credit card processing fees tax deductible rbs credit card services telephone number get instant payday loan online travel rewards cards for students natwest credit card late payment charges how to apply for joint credit card account android credit card reader uk southwest rapid rewards business credit card best credit cards cash back offers getting a credit card machine for a business credit card scanner for computer iphone credit card case speck apply for student credit card discover paypal not accepting prepaid credit cards number activate cibc credit card apply visa credit card online how to activate hsbc debit visa card buy gold uk credit card low interest credit cards for good credit best credit card reward system credit card number checker generator should i get credit card with annual fee low credit credit cards australia factors to consider when choosing a loan or credit card ge capital city furniture credit card the good the bad and the ugly of credit cards part 2 free credit card advice how to get a fake credit card number and security code toyota rewards visa credit card website best buy credit card login hrsa visa credit card with rewards and no annual fee united chase visa card login 0 credit card balance transfers halifax cash back credit card terms and conditions payday loans uk does american express gold card improve credit history skywards platinum card emirates nbd fnb silver credit card interest rates best gas cards for bad credit best online credit card processing companies credit card number search tool unsecured discover card for bad credit comments amazon credit card review guaranteed unsecured credit card bad credit no credit check credit cards no deposit uk do i really need a credit card for itunes account sears credit card customer service payment online credit card application philippines ofw ge capital retail bank credit card payment address new horizon secured credit card mbna credit card canada login best credit card rewards canada joint credit card application bad credit free air miles credit card canada halifax credit card contact address how to use apps store without credit card how to apply for a credit card online with hsbc mbna credit card canada phone number walmart credit card canada phone number guaranteed credit card acceptance uk credit card loan emi calculator priceline rewards visa card customer service capital one credit card online virtual visa card canada what are the best credit cards to have in singapore online payment for hsbc credit cards in india credit card rates ireland comparison bad credit credit cards guaranteed approval australia credit card processing software linux visa cash card walmart application format for credit card limit increase credit card verification process india get credit card now bank of america sign up for credit card test credit card numbers sagepay apply for a barclay credit card online india top 5 best secured credit cards has advantage credit card hdfc gold credit card how long does it take to get a credit card rbc halifax credit card transfer deals new credit cards 2012 canada best online credit card processing canada advance travel pay calculator best credit card for business reimbursement credit card frauds statistics usaa visa credit card foreign transaction fees how to do online credit card fraud check walmart credit card application status prepaid credit card paypal reload visa student credit cards no credit credit card monthly interest calculator india capital one credit card debt settlement credit card comparison australia frequent flyer compare credit cards online australia credit card offers best reward points best rewards credit cards usa instant virtual credit card prepaid credit card comparison usaa credit card travel notification chase credit card with travel rewards credit card bank numbers wiki sbi credit card customer care number in gurgaon credit cards for bad credit history barclay credit card login india credit cards with low interest rates and rewards aspire credit card payment online pay as you go credit card processing canada top 10 bad credit credit cards uk best credit card deal 2012 standard chartered credit card promotions malaysia hdfc virtual credit card emi real visa credit card numbers 2013 sbi credit card application process pay ge credit card payment orchard bank credit cards pay online top rated credit cards for students secured cibc credit cards value city credit card account icici credit card offers on mobiles check best buy credit card application no credit credit cards chase compare credit card interest rates australia hdfc titanium credit card travel offers sbi advantage credit card online apply disney premier credit card rewards accept all major credit cards bridging loan online quote best visa credit cards with rewards credit card fraud punishment pennsylvania how to get a credit card with no credit history yahoo answers low interest credit cards canada 2013 how do i pay sbi credit card bill online manage rewards cards app comparing credit cards in india free sim card with credit for pay as you go apply for chase british airways credit card free credit score horizon gold credit card toys r us credit card ge capital anz credit card promotions singapore bad credit personal loans direct lenders only best 0 credit cards how to apply visa credit card in the philippines hdfc instant credit card against fixed deposit hsbc credit card settlement process india credit card debt after death california credit card for no credit rating paypal credit card reader uk credit card scanner for android capital one credit card visa signature best options for credit card consolidation clark howard best credit cards for students prepaid credit card ukash instant payday loan lenders uk where can i buy visa cash cards how do i get a credit card machine 5 best credit cards for travel american express credit limit increase bank credit cards fair credit mastercard exchange rate bmo how to get small business loans with bad credit are cash advances bad for your credit canadian visa credit card platinum cardcaptor sakura lyrics standard chartered credit card customer care number malaysia hdfc master credit card password change my first premier credit card customer service cheapest credit card machine for small business compare visa and mastercard credit cards reputable online loan lenders i have lost my barclays credit card sears citi credit card customer service phone number credit cards visa mastercard mbna virgin credit card customer services easiest store credit card to get with bad credit chase increase credit limit automatically online cash advance lenders in georgia dillards credit card payment login barclay credit card apply online pay monthly loans unemployed pc mastercard login get credit card for bad credit rating chase prepaid visa debit cards quick bad credit payday loans credit card settlement india android credit card app uk credit card verification agreement bodog quick credit card approval online virtual credit cards paypal verification hbc mastercard lost card miles and more credit card swiss air natwest black credit card criteria lloyds credit card application declined capital credit card application status heartland credit card processing reviews aib visa debit card fees virtual credit cards indian banks google credit card search credit card fees uk how to get loans with bad credit and no job i need a car loan with bad credit coast capital business credit card get uk credit card number best credit card deals 0 balance transfer credit card application declined philippines should i pay off credit card debt or save malaysia credit card comparison hdfc credit card helpline number quick and easy pay day loans best credit cards no interest 12 months reloadable credit cards canada credit card application rejected india sears ca credit cards login kotak mahindra credit cards online apply free reward cards for stores credit card debt relief companies 0 credit cards online decision free credit card numbers and security code and expiration date that work 2013 how do i stop pre approved credit card offers instant bad credit loans canada low interest rate credit cards with no transfer fee 0 percent credit cards chase freedom student credit card who has the best small business credit card top credit cards for business travelers best canada credit cards alaska airlines credit card deal fake credit card numbers that are valid in canada lowest interest credit card best buy credit card activation track barclay credit card application credit card help from government canada credit card protector rfid wallet ipad credit card reader anz low rate credit cards free iphone credit card processing top gas rewards credit card short term loans online free credit card payoff calculator cute free prepaid credit cards credit card rewards best canada consolidating credit card debt canada how to increase credit card limit icici axis bank silver credit card apply online capital one best buy credit card application credit card with no credit check uk transfer credit card balance 0 interest australia kohls credit card online best credit cards for low income earners get free prepaid credit card online barclays business commercial credit card apply for a walmart credit card paypal online credit card processing secure online cash advance loans chase freedom credit card 150 cash back citibank credit card travel insurance zurich types of credit card fraud small business credit card comparison 2013 secured credit card 10000 limit mastercard credit card insurance coverage visa card number uk where to find credit card number on visa free prepaid credit card generator walmart credit card credit check wells fargo cash advance fee credit card reward schemes compared prepaid credit cards business plan no credit check loans ireland does applying for credit cards hurt credit score best buy credit card no interest calculate credit card interest payment ace cash advance bakersfield top 10 credit card issuers uk valid credit card numbers and security codes and expiration dates best buy credit cards hsbc square slices credit-card processing fees apply online for credit card pnb citibank credit card rewards corporate credit cards with airmiles travel rewards credit cards no annual fee what;s the best credit card to get with no credit major credit card companies wiki citibank credit card application status bangalore credit card payment application bank of america commercial prepaid credit card best new small business credit cards gold platinum or reserve delta skymiles credit cards credit card low interest check status of toys r us credit card zero interest credit cards no balance transfer fee cash advance usa payday loan zara black cashmere cardigan canadian prepaid credit card companies credit card selector tool canada best travel reward cards canada tesco clubcard credit card online air canada credit card offers best canadian cash back credit card 2011 best american express cash back cards payday loan lenders online uk cimb credit card travel promotion home loan with bad credit 2012 which credit card is easiest to get approved for with bad credit best cash advance loans for bad credit what do i need to apply for a credit card in canada best reward credit cards 2011 australia mbna credit card canada review why do i need a credit card for free apps kindle compare travel credit cards canada fake credit cards that work online 2013 personal loans for credit card debt consolidation credit card cash advance credit score free prepaid visa debit cards discovery credit card partners south africa credit card company jointly liable hsbc advance platinum credit cards is it easy to apply for target credit card lost virgin credit card uk aqua classic credit card credit limit how to check hsbc credit card points capital city bank credit card online payments getting a credit card machine for small business best credit card for bad credit 2012 joint credit card accounts death how to get an american express platinum card balance transfer fee 0 quickbooks online processing credit cards td low interest credit cards how to lower credit card apr rate cash back credit card offers does wi dmv accept credit cards jcpenney credit card payment center address citibank virtual credit card ipad bad credit credit cards unsecured payday advance loans for bad credit marks and spencer credit card charges abroad prepaid mastercard uk easy credit cards to apply for with bad credit chase business credit card bad credit instant loans online for unemployed small business credit cards canada debt consolidation loans for bad credit how to calculate credit card interest payments in excel firestone credit card login cfna 28 degrees mastercard exchange rate hsbc credit card settlement department best value for money credit card india documents required for sbi credit card application bank of america credit card minimum payment new credit card law minimum payment dbs visa debit card application form southwest rapid rewards credit card upgrade how does walmart credit card cash back work sears kmart credit card login credit cards with no credit check best 0 credit cards balance transfers can you apply for a walmart credit card in store virtual credit card generator 2010 citibank credit card information stolen does the chase liquid card help build credit jcpenney credit card payment mailing address personal credit loans ireland best united credit card offer how to get reward points in sbi credit card legit payday loan lenders online how to apply credit card maybank first time credit card applications delta credit card uk air miles credit card comparison credit card online abn amro ics credit card apr comparison credit card search tool secured credit cards no credit check credit card ratings money magazine student credit card with no credit history application for credit card reissue cibc canada credit card login how to pay hdfc master credit card bill navy federal credit union credit cards review lane bryant credit card customer service phone number can i get a credit card if im under 18 legality of storing credit card information anz credit card travel insurance claim what;s the best credit card company best credit cards to use in the uk teachers federal credit union credit cards help consolidating credit card debt easy payday advance online easiest credit card to get with bad credit 2012 walmart prepaid credit cards phone number say no to 0870 natwest credit card online cash advance payday loans atlanta ga best credit card to get with no credit history goodyear tire credit card sign in free virtual credit card paypal verify chase bank student credit card major credit cards accepted in hong kong credit cards no interest for 12 months cash back rewards credit cards 2012 business gas cards for bad credit ebay buyer requirements credit card on file credit card offers usaa disney rewards credit card phone number
Home Maury Brown MLBPA Fighting A-Rod Suspension Really About Punishment Fitting the Crime

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1030 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA Fighting A-Rod Suspension Really About Punishment Fitting the Crime PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 49
Written by Maury Brown   
Wednesday, 07 August 2013 13:44
Alex Rodriguez has the MLBPA in his corner, but it's likely over how long
his suspension is, not if he's deserving of one

UPDATE: According to The Associated Press, the MLBPA has formally filed a grievance in the Rodriguez case. He will continue to have his 211 game suspension stayed until Fredric Horowitz, the independent arbitrator, hears the case. According to the report, that will not be until November or December meaning that barring injury, Rodriguez will be allowed to play through the remainder of the 2013 season. - Maury Brown

+++++ +++++ +++++

On Thursday, MLB’s suspension of Alex Rodriguez kicks in, and at some stage the collectively bargained process around his rights to a grievance will officially start. An army of writers have spilled gallons of ink on the subject with the particulars around all the Biogenesis suspensions at the heart of it. Some have vilified baseball’s highest-paid player, while others have said that Bud Selig has done something that most thought impossible by making Rodriguez a sympatric figure. Out of the 14 players suspended, A-Rod will be the only one to file a grievance. The reaction by some has been, “You’re going to tell me 13 players said, ‘You caught me,’ but only one is going to say, he’s innocent?” In looking at the situation, that’s not what this appeal is all about. It’s about much more.

It’s not just A-Rod “fighting for his life” it’s about the MLBPA and assuring that the punishment fits the crime as defined by the jointly agreed upon drug policy. The league has said that they have a mountain of evidence, including “his use and possession of numerous forms of prohibited performance-enhancing substances, including Testosterone and human Growth Hormone, over the course of multiple years.” To add, the league said, “Rodriguez's discipline under the Basic Agreement is for attempting to cover-up his violations of the Program by engaging in a course of conduct intended to obstruct and frustrate the Office of the Commissioner's investigation.” Based upon that, the suspension length reached subjectively by the league was 211 regular games and any 2013 Postseason games in which Rodriguez otherwise would have been eligible to play. The ambiguity with which the suspension length was rendered is the concern of the MLBPA.

When questioned, Rodriguez would not deny he used the PEDs, but rather that he would have his day to make his case before arbitrator Fredric Horowitz (see The Most Important Man in Baseball You’ve Never Heard of). In reports prior to the suspension it was said that lawyers representing Rodriguez were willing to have him forgo the grievance if the league held to a 50 game suspension. That’s the issue. Not that he is, or is not, guilty. It’s about the length of the suspension.

The drug agreement goes into detail about how long suspensions should be, should a player test positive for PEDs. The league has decided that since the findings on the players involved in Biogenesis did not test positive, suspension lengths could vary. All but Ryan Braun and Rodriguez were slapped with 50 game suspensions. Braun, who tested positive for elevated levels of testosterone in 2011, but had his case rescinded in 2012 over the handling of his sample was given a 65 game suspension. As one official put it, he was hit with 50 games for his first offense, and 15 games for lying, etc.

This is a slippery slope for the MLBPA, and for the first time in years brought out aggravation and a strong sense that labor peace is under strain. As MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner said of Rodriguez’ case, “we agree with his decision to fight his suspension. We believe that the Commissioner has not acted appropriately under the Basic Agreement.” To add an exclamation point on where the MLBPA has been in the past on fighting labor disputes, Weiner added, “ Mr. Rodriguez knows that the Union, consistent with its history, will defend his rights vigorously.“

The union, which also added that the players  have made it clear that they want a clean game and that they support efforts to discipline players, and harshly, to help ensure an even playing field for all, also is going to go to the mat to ensure that the process by which players are suspended doesn’t get back into the lordship that former commissioners such as Bowie Kuhn and Fay Vincent tried to conduct. What they’re ostensibly saying is, “You’re kidding. You want to take a player that’s never tested positive under the program, threaten through the media of a lifetime ban, and then throw the largest suspension ever on a player behind only Pete Rose and the Black Sox players at him? He might be guilty but we’ll fight you on the punishment.”

The MLBPA is in the right here. The league and Commissioner Selig are trying to make a strong statement, but this is shooting a gnat with a shotgun. In going so far over the top, they’ve not only harmed labor relations, they have a good chance of getting egg on their face. Horowitz is going to have a heck of a time reading the drug agreement and seeing anything within it that allows for such overstepping. He can see 50 games based on the agreement, but beyond that gets into areas that are not defined. A rational, subjective comment might be, “Sorry, Major League Baseball. You guys reached this agreement jointly with the union for the players. If you want it to go to the lengths that you want, try that in the next round of collective bargaining.”

Fans will likely not care about all this. On the face of it, A-Rod appears to be making a case for innocence and the MLBPA is supporting that. While that could be the case, it’s looking more and more about insuring MLB doesn’t turn into judge, jury, and executioner. That’s a larger issue that affects not only Alex Rodriguez, but all the players.

Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes. He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted here.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?