valtrex over the counter equivalent what is clomiphene for men betagesic tablets for toddlers obat metronidazole 500 mg can viagra lower blood pressure lamotrigine 25mg and alcohol hong kong viagra northern canadian pharmacy levofloxacin 500 mg orally flomist nasal spray allergy viagra alternatives in india cheap vardenafil no prescription dyazide generic sandozdynamogen seroquel xr 300mg furosemide 40 mg what is it used for apcalis sx tablets 20 mg side effects clomiphene citrate sale viagra generico europa buy xanax online canadian pharmacies ropinirole hcl 0.25 mg online pharmacy 365 pills viagra doxycycline 100mg for sinus infection garlic mashed potatoes buy orlistat in usa periactin appetite cyproheptadine dose diamox side effects medication cheap cipro augmentin antibiotic generic name erectalis tadalafil trazodone 100mg topiramate for migraine crestor side effects patients 50 mg viagra price buy combivent online no prescription amazon bactroban secure pharmacy ordering robaxin from candadian pharmacy norlevo effectiveness of plan latisse side effects eye twitching canada online non prescription pharmacy actos lawsuit news can i get cymbalta in mexico canadarx bahamas online pharmacy calcis 100 mg lasik online no prescription medicinenet boils comptar cialis sin receta medica en usa pronil 30 pastillas whats the difference between sotalol and sotalol af comprar cialis barato toradol vs tramadol preise viagra kaufen furolin dosage for amoxicillin forzest tadalafil sold in europe pcos glucophage and pregnancy cialis extra dosage alli weight loss pills uk lialda mesalamine generic atenolol drug interactions side effects vimax video converter downloadvimedicvinaworkviprogra non generic prednisone online legitimate online pharmacies india buy glucophage on line no prescription synthroid and weight gain doctor online pharmacy 1 800 490 0365 dormidina 25 sleeping tablets where to buy unisom 2 flurazepam 30mg capsule strattera for sale cialis professional belgique libre online prescription viagra finasteride 5mg proscar for hair loss lamisil tablets price fluoxetine prozac side effects nizagara gold 120 united pharmacies zopiclone dermasone cream 0.025 vitamix blender recipes mercury drugstore medicine price list viagra 24 hr delivery order synthroid online no prescitption propecia generic version silagra medicine buy metronidazole caps uk methocarbamol 750 mg street value sildenafil generico prezzo lisinopril hctz side effects for men lopid 600 mg triglycerides and diabetes generic levitra prednisone for humans buy cialis online uk no prescription overseas pharmacy xanax edrugstore md online pharmacy best price viagra 100mg costco detrol generic drug craigslist usa buy lisinopril hctz online viagra priser mexico prescriptions hydrocodone what is betagesic where can i one buyeao elifemeds review dyazide generic shortage erectile pills over the counter diclobru instructions ezetimibe 10mg simvastatin 80mg side order on line levitra clomiphene citrate for men how long to work fluzol 200mg caffeine stanozolol steroids for poison carbimazole mechanism of action over the counter colchicine precose contraindications for tpa canadian pills esomeprazole sodium molecular weight backache and spotting after clomiphene cialis for sale in uk viagra online uk good high quality low cost viagra 50 mg ritalin side effects children adhd ciprodex otic suspension 7.5ml coupon yasmin online aus rx from mexico doxycycline monohydrate 100mg reviews lasix from usa withought a prescription ninth street pharmacy cialis and alcohol xatral 10 mg milanuncios alquiler valencia extenze pills review trimetabol medicamento para where can i purchase generic cialis article 91 viagra no prescription clozapine monitoring forms ambassador university cilas pills on line male erection pills online procalisx reviews on 50 lantus vs levemir studies viagra sales ireland what is amantadine poisoning aleve dosage by weight lisinopril 20 mg side effects casodex 50 mg treatment non prescription tamoxifen zovirax cheap with next day shipping flovent hfa inhaler pharmacy in canada advantage rent a car denver prilosec coupons arthrotec medication pergotime tablets for sale epimedium donde comprar en bs as nugenix vs virectin reviews best price on ed drugs cheapest viagra generic prozac and alcohol consumption big 3 finasteride cheap cialis overnight delivery androgel 1.62 discount card valtrex no prescription cataflam medication taking owerseas viraga alli tablets online edolacc cheep fluconazole 150mg how long does it take to work potassium levels normal range cocaine and viagra voltaren gel 1 reviews salzarex pharmaceuticals generic viagra minocycline for sale omifin clomifeno 50mg suprax side effects in children online vigara no cheapest finasteride on the web using subutex for pain cost of colcrys medication therapy dog certification buy propecia 1mg online obetrol adhd diet viagra samples from canada chlamydia medication mail cytotec for miscarriage not working kamagra paypal uk diprosone cream ointment for ringworm buy one viagra pill ventiline without rx budesonide inhalation suspension for adults omnicef side effects antibiotics for dogs buy tadalafil online canada femara no prescription canada pharmacy irbesartan drug class dalacin t gel reviews canadian health care mall pharmacy can you take valtrex and breastfeedingvalvirexvantin 40 viagra pills for 99 dollars estrogen pills at walgreens promethazine codeine 6.25 10 cenveo envelope jobs soviclor tabs for sweet so easy say againe roxithromycin for dogs works like viagra over counter online pharmacy safe sertraline hcl 50 mg tab orderpharma uk national lottery zyrtec allergy medication dosage cost of alprazolam without insurance buy primatene mist in canada buy antibiotics canada synthroid thyroid medication and weight loss rollbox game ventolin by mail retirides otc tools goodrx com prescription drugs captopril drug side effects buy clomid generic viagra provigil depression treatment topical minoxidil for women side effects buy lisinopril 12 5 percocet dosage side effects viagra dapoxetine online purchase 259 buy coversyl online canada super active levitra prednisone for free generic viagra super force spermiogramm in greifswald canadian health club viagara diane keaton hairstyle pictures obestat 10 mg lantus cost without insurance fucidin antibiotic pills confidex ingredients in cigarettes best on line viagra sellers advair inhaler side effects dose cyrux medicamentos letrozole infertility success stories yagara sashimiyasmin actos side effects diabetes cenveo st louis closing antibiotics without a doctor micardis hct side effects comprar levitra buying cialis online forum eutirox 75 levothyroxine sodium zyprexa medication what is it used for navidoxine drugstore florinef acetate 0.1 mg tab buy verapamilo online cialis 20 mg price ciplactin online store vitamin b12 femara no prescription cialis 30 day trial coupon australian pharmacy no prescriptions rimonabant drug information keflex side effects flos medicinae viagra cialis powder mirtazapine for cats 15mg carprofen 100 mg navidoxine drug emporium hydrochlorizide for sale cialis professional vs cialis pharmacy 4 u uk clomid steroid online amantadine medication caffeine and pregnancy studies cialis online sales domperidone breastfeeding side effects no prescription needed online pharmacy dicyclomine 10 mg espanol linezolid antibiotics drugs ppt obetrol adderall dosage how to take letrozole for fertility percocet dosage cialis samples without prescrpition phexin bd tablets sale betneval 0 1 pour cent cialis inghilterra buying priligy online noprescription meds paypal kamagra next day uk suhugra online false aciphex generic name drug store health tablet caffeine content of drinks coffee non prescription azelastine abilify generic date eutirox 75 mcg synthroid remeron for anxiety ativan side effects in elderly renagel 800 mg genzyme cara penggunaan cytotec ciallis in canada buy viagra in india online romanian pharmacy online wintomylon vademecum farmaceutico escitalopram 20 mg reviews garlic mashed potatoes paula deen minocycline 100 mg should you take 5mg or 1mg propecia protonix medication class seroflo 250 multihaler mobicool cooler parts celecoxib capsules ranitidine for infants side effects aggrenox drug class buy super p force pills farmacia premature ejaculation levitra drug store online buy librium online free viagra sample tramadol controlled substance illinois order revia online albendazole canada doxepin hcl and weight gain provera to start period doctor flonase nasal spray coupon benemid dosage for infantbenicar meclizine buy online sibutramine hydrochloride side effects can i buy subutex online generic viagra trusted site imitrex nasal spray patient instructions no prescription needed bactrim cialis 800mg reviews cialis 50mg domperidone tablets buy starcef capsule levitra in ireland amoxicillin overnight no prescription anxiety in children under 10 zolpidem tartrate 10 mg tablet canada metazole tablets effexor and weight loss or gain evista generic alternative can you buy nasonex nasal spray over the counter generic viagra pay by check norvasc medication side effects ospamox 1000 mg prospective definition glucovance 5 500 espanol generic viagra combo male chastity digoxin level monitoring reviews on mylan bupropion xl buy cheap nolvadex online ranitidine zantac for babies levothyroxine canada 24h local viagra stores buy cialis in israel 217 olanzapine medications renagel 800 generic free viagra from gibraltar ru486 buy online uk paxil reviews for social anxiety achat viagra paiement securise rogaine for eyebrows grow spironolactone uses bupropion hcl 150mg for smoking cessation digoxin side effects mayo seroquel withdrawal symptoms patients buy hydromorphone online without script indomethacin dosages kamagrafast crookston get free trial of viagra with no money doxitab 100mg to g chlamydia symptoms after treatment oracea side effects sores percocet dosages prescription cheapest place to buy doxycycline all top meds viprogra professional financial services no prescription antibiotics generic propecia sales viagra soft tabs revatio 20 mg order online lowrx a\u0080\u0093 discount prescription card propecia finasteride side effects thyroxine levels elevated dog itching prednisone viagra tesco pharmacy moduretic dosage for melatonin valium vs xanax alli purchase online lasixs medicine cabaser reviews for 50 atepros drug mart mupirocin over the counter generic viagra paypal buy 240 800mg viagra retin a cream .025 ospamox 1000mg pret isoptin sr side effects zofran pregnancy category medicine prozac and weight gain prozac side effects buy test booster uk dikloron tabletop cyproheptadine 4 mg weight gain viagra walgreens cost unisom sleep tabs epogen injections family medicine viagra ranigast ulotka kaufland poison ivy medicine canada pharmacy what is the difference in sotalol and sotalol af sostanze di provigrax viagra 100mg price without rx buy suhagra anxiety in children medication cheap doxycycline and prednisone ampicillin sulbactam unasyn mesterolone bodybuilding forums risk free viagra use of aldactone for hair loss sunsuria avenue map over counter water pills hyzaar medication where can i buy cialis on line viagra in japan eprex injection site nizoral cream for yeast infection viagra rezeptfrei preisvergleich viagra for women over the counter ambien side effects sleep walking paroxetine 10 mg and weed duvadilan tablet indication viagra soft tabs review zovirax cream for cold sores levothroid no prescription dyazide generic capsule pictures praziquantel for horses and dogs dormidina information security sunsuria avenue sale cealis india sildenafil acquisto ranbaxy labs in india is ezetimibe generic aviagra 4 birds on whats vpxl for sale avodart side effects dutasteride tamsulosin androfin reviews on 50 amoxicillin buy canada 168 provera and clomid together lopressor 50 mg cost what supplement acts like viagra albuterol online prescription verapamil for migraines free voucher for cialis online pharmacy medazole 200mg of caffeine avelox 400mg moxifloxacin side effects avapro generic does not work xylocaine jelly 2 usage enalapril matea for sale uk generic strattera mastercard motrin vs advil difference online pharmacies that accept paypal silagra tablets hoodia weight loss drink costco lialda medication prices cyclidox 100 oxybutynin hydrochloride gel viagra side effects medications ssl pharmacy cost of generic 5mg cialis atarax medication dosage nexium 18 dollars a month coumadin levels risk how much does a lidoderm patch cost buy zoloft cheap no rx buy dilantin no prescription donormyl reviews want to order viagra cialis online kosovarja chat meds order order submitted famvir dosage for genital herpes valium generico india sildegra nedirajte alli diet pills buy online buy doxepin no prescription buy ventolin no prescription software programs safe generic pills septrin antibiotic side effect latisse side effects forum wiki silagra omnicef for uti patients kosovarja tu u qi astelin nasal spray azelastine eye levaquin side effects in elderly viagra generic date ed pills at gnc raymeds generic viagra viagra originale paypal plendil lisinopril side effects medication metoprolol succ er 100 mg does viagra work with alcohol adderall side effects in children flomax for kidney stones women
Home Maury Brown MLBPA Fighting A-Rod Suspension Really About Punishment Fitting the Crime

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 506 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA Fighting A-Rod Suspension Really About Punishment Fitting the Crime PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 49
Written by Maury Brown   
Wednesday, 07 August 2013 13:44
Alex Rodriguez has the MLBPA in his corner, but it's likely over how long
his suspension is, not if he's deserving of one

UPDATE: According to The Associated Press, the MLBPA has formally filed a grievance in the Rodriguez case. He will continue to have his 211 game suspension stayed until Fredric Horowitz, the independent arbitrator, hears the case. According to the report, that will not be until November or December meaning that barring injury, Rodriguez will be allowed to play through the remainder of the 2013 season. - Maury Brown

+++++ +++++ +++++

On Thursday, MLB’s suspension of Alex Rodriguez kicks in, and at some stage the collectively bargained process around his rights to a grievance will officially start. An army of writers have spilled gallons of ink on the subject with the particulars around all the Biogenesis suspensions at the heart of it. Some have vilified baseball’s highest-paid player, while others have said that Bud Selig has done something that most thought impossible by making Rodriguez a sympatric figure. Out of the 14 players suspended, A-Rod will be the only one to file a grievance. The reaction by some has been, “You’re going to tell me 13 players said, ‘You caught me,’ but only one is going to say, he’s innocent?” In looking at the situation, that’s not what this appeal is all about. It’s about much more.

It’s not just A-Rod “fighting for his life” it’s about the MLBPA and assuring that the punishment fits the crime as defined by the jointly agreed upon drug policy. The league has said that they have a mountain of evidence, including “his use and possession of numerous forms of prohibited performance-enhancing substances, including Testosterone and human Growth Hormone, over the course of multiple years.” To add, the league said, “Rodriguez's discipline under the Basic Agreement is for attempting to cover-up his violations of the Program by engaging in a course of conduct intended to obstruct and frustrate the Office of the Commissioner's investigation.” Based upon that, the suspension length reached subjectively by the league was 211 regular games and any 2013 Postseason games in which Rodriguez otherwise would have been eligible to play. The ambiguity with which the suspension length was rendered is the concern of the MLBPA.

When questioned, Rodriguez would not deny he used the PEDs, but rather that he would have his day to make his case before arbitrator Fredric Horowitz (see The Most Important Man in Baseball You’ve Never Heard of). In reports prior to the suspension it was said that lawyers representing Rodriguez were willing to have him forgo the grievance if the league held to a 50 game suspension. That’s the issue. Not that he is, or is not, guilty. It’s about the length of the suspension.

The drug agreement goes into detail about how long suspensions should be, should a player test positive for PEDs. The league has decided that since the findings on the players involved in Biogenesis did not test positive, suspension lengths could vary. All but Ryan Braun and Rodriguez were slapped with 50 game suspensions. Braun, who tested positive for elevated levels of testosterone in 2011, but had his case rescinded in 2012 over the handling of his sample was given a 65 game suspension. As one official put it, he was hit with 50 games for his first offense, and 15 games for lying, etc.

This is a slippery slope for the MLBPA, and for the first time in years brought out aggravation and a strong sense that labor peace is under strain. As MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner said of Rodriguez’ case, “we agree with his decision to fight his suspension. We believe that the Commissioner has not acted appropriately under the Basic Agreement.” To add an exclamation point on where the MLBPA has been in the past on fighting labor disputes, Weiner added, “ Mr. Rodriguez knows that the Union, consistent with its history, will defend his rights vigorously.“

The union, which also added that the players  have made it clear that they want a clean game and that they support efforts to discipline players, and harshly, to help ensure an even playing field for all, also is going to go to the mat to ensure that the process by which players are suspended doesn’t get back into the lordship that former commissioners such as Bowie Kuhn and Fay Vincent tried to conduct. What they’re ostensibly saying is, “You’re kidding. You want to take a player that’s never tested positive under the program, threaten through the media of a lifetime ban, and then throw the largest suspension ever on a player behind only Pete Rose and the Black Sox players at him? He might be guilty but we’ll fight you on the punishment.”

The MLBPA is in the right here. The league and Commissioner Selig are trying to make a strong statement, but this is shooting a gnat with a shotgun. In going so far over the top, they’ve not only harmed labor relations, they have a good chance of getting egg on their face. Horowitz is going to have a heck of a time reading the drug agreement and seeing anything within it that allows for such overstepping. He can see 50 games based on the agreement, but beyond that gets into areas that are not defined. A rational, subjective comment might be, “Sorry, Major League Baseball. You guys reached this agreement jointly with the union for the players. If you want it to go to the lengths that you want, try that in the next round of collective bargaining.”

Fans will likely not care about all this. On the face of it, A-Rod appears to be making a case for innocence and the MLBPA is supporting that. While that could be the case, it’s looking more and more about insuring MLB doesn’t turn into judge, jury, and executioner. That’s a larger issue that affects not only Alex Rodriguez, but all the players.

Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes. He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted here.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?