lisinopril 20 mg tablet costo lasix 25 mg buy propecia where aricept precio mexico pharmacy online no prescription review clomid 50 mg pct thuoc erythromycin 250 mg buy strattera us strattera speech disorder buy fda approved cialis kendle no priscription meds diflucan nombre generico compazine fda approved to buy without prescription rumalaya for daily use canada blopress plus generico generic cialis kolkata pramipexole dihydrochloride msds viagra canadian online doxycycline 100mg nl zoloft generics acquistare cialis 20 mg 100. mg kamagra online tentang xenical 120 mg buy clomid 25 mg xenical 120 mg dose can you buy unisom online tegretol delivery uk cialis 40mg overnight buying viagra romania propranolol 40mg tablet plavix prescription assistance application generic actos available canadian herbal ed pills doxycycline 100mg bronchitis celebrex capsulas 100 mg propecia vs generic prednisone 5mg 6 taller target pharmacy wellbutrin is it safe to order zyrtec celebrex 200 mg prijs neo medrol uk buy cialis generic lilly where can you buy acai pulp elocon ointment price buy doxycycline rite aid buy periactin pills generic augmentin 875 mg buy cipro best anti anxiety medication for women zoloft mgs brand cialis 40 mg 20mg lexapro reviews rumalaya liniment billig kaufen glucophage online no prescription methotrexate shortage ra prescription drug terramycin generic biaxin cost priligy 30mg filmtabletten diclofenaco sodico dosis where to buy protonix drugs online elocon mg order levitra 20mg walgreens thailand viagra online tadalis sx barato cytotec 400 mg clomid dosage pct forum buy genuine procardia uk abilify mexico no prescription injecting 80 mg cialis 2 x 10mg cialis can ortho tri-cyclen side effects buy diflucan 200 mg generic levitra store levitra 10mg pills valtrex generic walmart sublingual cialis 50mg glucophage vs generic levitra 10mg avis buy caverta mg where to buy alligator meat in jacksonville fl a good web page to buy voltaren with no script online actoplus met purchase order strattera mastercard metformin er 500mg what is the normal dosage for celebrex buy levitra mg levitra super active prescription only rocaltrol buying viagra men lexapro 20mg gotas prednisone 50mgm generic wellbutrin lawsuits 50 mg clomid 100 mg speman discounts codes hytrin canada companies only generic viagra guidelines can you buy periactin pfizer celebrex 200mg strattera 40 mg information glucotrol xl com where can you buy viagra over the counter in canada cialis 20mg malaysia safe to buy generic seroquel from canada preco xenical 240 mg australian online viagra priligy 30mg tablets viagra cialis generici benicar hct for sale buy rosuvastatin overseas sertralina bula anvisa ultra low dose allegra prescription levitra 20mg where can i purchase proventil erfahrung levitra 10mg generic sildenafil viagra nexium granulado 10 mg micardis no prrescription differenza viagra generico cialis buy generic buy xenical cheapest levitra 10 mg sarajevo robaxin uk boots viagra 25mg flashback metformin 1000 mg dose generic propecia germany singulair cost in canada obat nexium 20 mg biaxin delivery london doxycycline 50mg dogs zithromax 250 mg pfizer zoloft 50 vs. 100mg viagra generico pacheco purchase levaquin in usa mycelex-g online cheap generic cialis egypt wellbutrin lawsuit generic midamor spain over counter online viagra drugs cost of aceon what is zantac 150 prescribed for how to buy nootropil ditropan discount voucher online pharmacy uk capoten buy nymphomax online what is lasuna made of buy toradol in uk nexium 20 mg cost manila generic cialis lasix cheap australia pharmacy take 2 cialis 20mg. what does zyprexa make you feel like propecia online malaysia side effects of isoniazid and rifapentine prednisone 20 mg efectos roxithromycin 300mg dosierung buy diamox singapore suhagra discount medications how can i order viagra online generic celebrex online buy nolvadex philippines viagra vanzari online diflucan generic walgreens side effects of diflucan 200 mg hydrea order by phone canadian alliance of dance artists bc chapter membership help buying nexium kamagra 100mg najtaniej generic keppra uk paypal generic zithromax walmart how to import aceon cefixime tablets omnicef buy on line levitra 10 mg nebenwirkungen cialis 20 mg venda levitra cheap uk prendre 2 cialis 5mg diflucan cp 200 mg forum buy seroflo online fluticasone cheap viagra 800mg generic lisinopril price purchase strattera 100 mg getting grifulvin v in australia 10 mg doxycycline buy chloramphenicol next day lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg cialis online erfahrungen cheap cialis 200 mg what is the generic name for aspirin what is micronase silagra from europe ceftin order canada keftab with no rx side effects of glycomet 500 sr brown viagra 150mg cheapest soft viagra viagra online malta nolvadex 20 mg pct pharmacy viagra generic amantadine hydrochloride tablets buy xenical china nexium 40mg pret metformin hcl 750 mg retino-a cream 0,025 usa cvs prices celebrex 500 mg buy alligator garr when do you ovulate after taking clomid metformin online bestellen amitriptyline and alcohol consumption buy plavix online from usa suprax 2003 cialis super active online aciclovir generic reviews purchase feldene cheap pro cialis 20 mg viagra sublingual pharmacy online prednisone 10 mg identification over the counter imuran generic lasix drug viagra 120 mg canada viagra 100mg tablet what does the drug bystolic do max viagra 100mg cialis 1800 mg 10 pills nizoral tablets reviews generic viagra quick mytab generics viagra generico de wellbutrin viagra pago paypal how to import avalide canada cipro online clomid buy propranolol xr without prescription seroflo india cialis 100 mg kullananlar omeprazole dosage infants periactin cheap price order cialis generic prednisone ten mg how to take suhagra 50 purchase cialis 40mg valtrex medication side effects generico cialis venezuela promethazine tablets price orlistat dosage prescription safe place order tadalis sx cleocin tablets dosage buy alli at asda chemists generic eulexin safe cardura with american express cialis 20mg doctissimo kegunaan doxycycline 100 mg buy femara online no prescription clomid 200mg success cheap cytotec generic cialis jelly for sale on line 200mg cialis generic zoloft 50 mg precio reviews on pravachol finns viagra 200mg order bupropion online us customer reviews on generic viagra propecia generic australia cialis 5 mg bph minipress brands india lisinopril 10 mg lupin cialis 5 mg works cialis 10mg us xenical 120 mg 84 cap atarax mg canadian rx xenical uk buy wellbutrin 100mg sr isoniazid components omifin embarazo multiple 2010 nizagara shipping overseas xenical online in stock strattera 25 mg generic doxycycline mg uti best viagra super active prices cialis canadian z pack dosage instructions propranolol dak 10mg indian generics online cleocin glucophage in usa viagra 100 mg kaufen benicar hct tablets side effects billig lisinopril online kaufen best drugstore makeup products dove comprare cialis generico online 100 mg of wellbutrin kamagra fxt pas cher what is the generic name for antivert metformin 1500 mg daily amlodipine interactions with simvastatin fluoxetine mg mexico is levitra generic lisinopril tablets 10 mg xenical order clorhidrato de amantadina formula is the generic form of lexapro the same levitra 20mg anwendung buy prednisone 1 mg generic zoloft 50 mg buying viagra ireland does generic propecia cheapest cialis uk viagra for men in indian market what is snovitra super power drugs propranolol max dose for anxiety generic zestoretic overnite shipping what are the main side effects of depakote augmentin 125 mg administrare levitra goes generic medicamento levitra generico forzest no prescription canada pill lisinopril 5mg zithromax 3 pack 250 mg obat clomid 50mg online cialis unbeatable beconase aq daily use reviews levitra 20mg used order cialis uk suhagra brands india order finpecia online uk comprar nexium barato avis generic cialis generic strattera .80 mg cefixime side effects long term use prescription online cialis cialis online order levitra 20mg alcohol seroquel canada drug mail order celebrex mgr. frantisek cipro how to take topamax and phentermine top 100 otc meds cialis 100 mg opinioni otc generic clomid lasix 80 mg tablets canadian alli online needed buy prescription cipro overnight delivery zestoretic mg tablet order hydrochlorothiazide online midamor australia viagra online schweiz ic propranolol 80 mg lasix 40 mg medicine generic viagra sales pharmacy side effects of bentyl 10 mg remedio generic viagra purchase generic wellbutrin sr order viagra cialis cialis 20 mg purchase lariam delivery viagra price in saudi arabia buy cheap adderall online uk can i make kamagra gold generic cialis illegal uk viagra buy australia cheapest viagra 100 amoxil brand generic buy zoloft thailand 200 mg clomid ovulation safe crestor buy cialis buy israel lisinopril 20 mg wikipedia cheap abilify tablets 28 filmtbl. cialis 2.5 mg does celebrex generic strattera 18 mg where to ashwagandha where is levaquin metabolized voveran online overnight shipping what is prevacid good for terramycin delivery no prescription acivir pills sale arimidex discount medications doxycycline 300mg order nolvadex on line usa long term effects of accutane in men cialis spain over counter are drugs from india safe retail cost of crestor cialis 5mg box hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg buy take 40mg levitra cialis 10mg street new cialis 50 mg cialis 50 mg ask ic lisinopril 10 mg what is methocarbamol 750 35mg green cialis ambien wiki side effects generic pills for alesse amitriptyline without food lexapro 40mg dose tetracycline price fixing brand cytoxan for sale prednisone dog medicine side effects zyvox sales 2010 totaled generic cialis 100 viagra generico europa online viagra ads online pharmacy minipress generic 150 mg viagra cialis brazil buy buy zyvox usa generic cialis pharmacy albendazole generico online generic geriforte for sale on line augmentin generico mylan metformin prescription information uk cheap fluoxetine free delivery xenical online prices cheap viagra 150 strattera online australia buy nexium iv over the counter zantac while pregnant norvasc delivery doxycycline 150 mg capsules order lasix online propranolol 1mg buying diclofenac gel from canada no prescription singulair prescription drug lisinopril 2.5 mg tablet propranolol inderalici 10 mg buy sr wellbutrin se puede comprar propecia sin receta levitra 10 mg orodispersible betnovate rd cream pregnancy cialis pills cheap 800 mg viagra knockoff buy cheap acyclovir online prednisone 10 mg effects amlodipine besylate 10mg tab price discover stratford upon avon cheap 2.5 mg cialis viagra 25 mg r levitra 40 mg price cialis 20 mg information lisinopril hctz 10 12.5 mg pharmacy assistant salary canada kesan propranolol 20 mg cialis cheap visa ordering diclofenac here in canada mexico viagra online buy lexapro internet differin topical gel reviews levitra 180 pills online valtrex generic patent amoxil tm 500 mg depakote on line in the usa zithromax 250 mg malaysia brahmi powder price in india reviews cialis 5mg lasix 800 mg cialis superactive 100 mg 30 mg of buspar buy levitra without generic lasix 100 mg crestor price australia online prescription propecia priligy 60 mg reviews where can i buy testosterone order apcalis sx pill buy augmentin cheap viagra 100mg prices cialis 2,5 mg online lexapro 6mg prednisone ordering online medicamentos zoloft 50 mg lexapro withdrawal time cheap levitra 10mg buy cialis edmonton viagra professional mg no prescription generic viagra quality sominex online pay paypal rabeprazole side effects domperidone how to get purim in australia generic aceon usa pharmacy cytoxan western australia where to get clomid remeron online pharmacy can order strattera online does half inderal cause weight gain cialis 20 mg yahoo nolvadex astrazeneca 10mg precio celebrex generico topamax uk no prescription brand aceon buy can you order promethazine codeine online speman uk buy priligy 30 mg brand mycelex-g online bestellen lisinopril sandoz 20mg safe cialis order cost of ventolin inhaler ireland how to get finpecia bentyl patient reviews amoxil 500 mg canada atrovent prices usa order propecia 1mg cheap decadron online
Home Maury Brown MLBPA Fighting A-Rod Suspension Really About Punishment Fitting the Crime

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 458 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA Fighting A-Rod Suspension Really About Punishment Fitting the Crime PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 49
Written by Maury Brown   
Wednesday, 07 August 2013 13:44
Alex Rodriguez has the MLBPA in his corner, but it's likely over how long
his suspension is, not if he's deserving of one

UPDATE: According to The Associated Press, the MLBPA has formally filed a grievance in the Rodriguez case. He will continue to have his 211 game suspension stayed until Fredric Horowitz, the independent arbitrator, hears the case. According to the report, that will not be until November or December meaning that barring injury, Rodriguez will be allowed to play through the remainder of the 2013 season. - Maury Brown

+++++ +++++ +++++

On Thursday, MLB’s suspension of Alex Rodriguez kicks in, and at some stage the collectively bargained process around his rights to a grievance will officially start. An army of writers have spilled gallons of ink on the subject with the particulars around all the Biogenesis suspensions at the heart of it. Some have vilified baseball’s highest-paid player, while others have said that Bud Selig has done something that most thought impossible by making Rodriguez a sympatric figure. Out of the 14 players suspended, A-Rod will be the only one to file a grievance. The reaction by some has been, “You’re going to tell me 13 players said, ‘You caught me,’ but only one is going to say, he’s innocent?” In looking at the situation, that’s not what this appeal is all about. It’s about much more.

It’s not just A-Rod “fighting for his life” it’s about the MLBPA and assuring that the punishment fits the crime as defined by the jointly agreed upon drug policy. The league has said that they have a mountain of evidence, including “his use and possession of numerous forms of prohibited performance-enhancing substances, including Testosterone and human Growth Hormone, over the course of multiple years.” To add, the league said, “Rodriguez's discipline under the Basic Agreement is for attempting to cover-up his violations of the Program by engaging in a course of conduct intended to obstruct and frustrate the Office of the Commissioner's investigation.” Based upon that, the suspension length reached subjectively by the league was 211 regular games and any 2013 Postseason games in which Rodriguez otherwise would have been eligible to play. The ambiguity with which the suspension length was rendered is the concern of the MLBPA.

When questioned, Rodriguez would not deny he used the PEDs, but rather that he would have his day to make his case before arbitrator Fredric Horowitz (see The Most Important Man in Baseball You’ve Never Heard of). In reports prior to the suspension it was said that lawyers representing Rodriguez were willing to have him forgo the grievance if the league held to a 50 game suspension. That’s the issue. Not that he is, or is not, guilty. It’s about the length of the suspension.

The drug agreement goes into detail about how long suspensions should be, should a player test positive for PEDs. The league has decided that since the findings on the players involved in Biogenesis did not test positive, suspension lengths could vary. All but Ryan Braun and Rodriguez were slapped with 50 game suspensions. Braun, who tested positive for elevated levels of testosterone in 2011, but had his case rescinded in 2012 over the handling of his sample was given a 65 game suspension. As one official put it, he was hit with 50 games for his first offense, and 15 games for lying, etc.

This is a slippery slope for the MLBPA, and for the first time in years brought out aggravation and a strong sense that labor peace is under strain. As MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner said of Rodriguez’ case, “we agree with his decision to fight his suspension. We believe that the Commissioner has not acted appropriately under the Basic Agreement.” To add an exclamation point on where the MLBPA has been in the past on fighting labor disputes, Weiner added, “ Mr. Rodriguez knows that the Union, consistent with its history, will defend his rights vigorously.“

The union, which also added that the players  have made it clear that they want a clean game and that they support efforts to discipline players, and harshly, to help ensure an even playing field for all, also is going to go to the mat to ensure that the process by which players are suspended doesn’t get back into the lordship that former commissioners such as Bowie Kuhn and Fay Vincent tried to conduct. What they’re ostensibly saying is, “You’re kidding. You want to take a player that’s never tested positive under the program, threaten through the media of a lifetime ban, and then throw the largest suspension ever on a player behind only Pete Rose and the Black Sox players at him? He might be guilty but we’ll fight you on the punishment.”

The MLBPA is in the right here. The league and Commissioner Selig are trying to make a strong statement, but this is shooting a gnat with a shotgun. In going so far over the top, they’ve not only harmed labor relations, they have a good chance of getting egg on their face. Horowitz is going to have a heck of a time reading the drug agreement and seeing anything within it that allows for such overstepping. He can see 50 games based on the agreement, but beyond that gets into areas that are not defined. A rational, subjective comment might be, “Sorry, Major League Baseball. You guys reached this agreement jointly with the union for the players. If you want it to go to the lengths that you want, try that in the next round of collective bargaining.”

Fans will likely not care about all this. On the face of it, A-Rod appears to be making a case for innocence and the MLBPA is supporting that. While that could be the case, it’s looking more and more about insuring MLB doesn’t turn into judge, jury, and executioner. That’s a larger issue that affects not only Alex Rodriguez, but all the players.

Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes. He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted here.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?