capital one bank secured credit card chase freedom credit card status best credit card to get american airline miles best credit card processing fees for small business amazon credit card score requirements dillards credit card login how to pick a bedroom door lock with a credit card best cash back visa canada cash back no fee credit card chase visa credit card payment find a direct payday loan lender hsbc credit card customer care toll free number bangalore top credit card companies in india visa cards india online payday loans bad credit canada international travel credit card usage gas credit card payday loan online visa credit card for students with no credit history best visa credit card to use abroad chase disney credit card reviews citifinancial credit card bill pay credit card instant approval india completely online loans no phone calls capital one credit card address best credit cards for students with no income how to get a loan with bad credit and no guarantor credit cards for small business with bad credit no credit check payday loans direct lenders only 0 balance transfer credit cards for bad credit rating maximum sentence for credit card fraud can you still file bankruptcy on credit cards zero percent interest credit cards no balance transfer fee low or no interest credit cards setup paypal virtual credit card generator small online loans uk sample visa credit card number format where do i mail my bank of america credit card payment clark howard choosing a credit card credit card online application ireland disney visa card promo code where can i pay my orchard bank credit card pay my bestbuy credit card by phone get credit card online bad credit rewards credit card comparison chart personal car loans with bad credit credit cards with low interest rates free credit card numbers and security code and expiration date that work 2012 hdfc online credit card payment link how do you work out minimum payments on credit cards best credit card to get for first time user how to prevent credit card fraud as a merchant united cash loans online visa platinum credit card wiki will a secured credit card help rebuild credit fake credit card numbers that work 2012 credit card help non profit joint credit card company td bank visa debit card balance personal bad credit loan lenders top student credit cards with no credit how to get lower interest rates on credit cards canada rbc royal bank credit card low rate balance transfer commonwealth bank australia visa debit card cash advance rate commonwealth bank icici bank credit card settlement hyderabad citibank credit card settlement offer does applying for credit cards hurt your credit score hdfc credit cards rewards points redemption good unsecured credit cards for bad credit bank of ireland post office credit card ppi united chase visa credit card java credit card number validator first progress secured credit card reviews credit report uk personal loans for credit card debt consolidation 24 months interest free credit card on purchases review bank of america cash rewards credit cards which is the best credit card available in india how does walmart credit card cash back work free credit card numbers generator download yes bank credit cards india sbi online credit card application status best student credit cards 2012 canada what;s the easiest credit card to get approved for apply visa credit card online cash advance rate calculator delta airlines credit card deal credit card cashback singapore instant payday loans no fees rbs apply for credit card online 21 month no interest credit card instant same day cash loans south africa types of hdfc credit cards in india secured credit card 10000 limit ez payday advance watertown sd virgin air miles credit card uk can you transfer credit card balance to another person credit card compare malaysia usaa secured credit card reviews easiest credit card to get approved virtual credit cards free from paypal business credit card comparison canada instant bad credit loans canada best free prepaid credit card student credit cards visa mastercard instant payday loans no credit check no brokers gap credit card services phone how to increase credit limit capital one valid credit card information 2012 cancel anz credit card insurance credit card companies with uk call centre chase slate request credit limit increase everyday rewards credit card australia same day online cash loans south africa what is the best uk credit card to use abroad cash fast payday loans credit cards in canada for newcomers best rewards credit cards 2013 rbs black credit card review city bank credit card statement alaska air miles credit card reviews compare best credit cards 2011 best iphone credit card processing are there any secured credit cards with rewards citibank credit card interest calculator india icici credit card interest rates calculator how to get an amscot cash advance visa credit card applications canada best payday lenders 2012 view my credit score for free no credit card best small business credit cards 2011 capital one apply credit card credit card protector sleeve australia apply online for credit card pnb no credit check credit cards uk hdfc credit card offer on flipkart credit card fraud uk statistics td rebate rewards visa card login credit card interest rates comparison south africa poor credit credit cards uk walmart credit cards pay bill credit card bank mega food check chase credit card application status tesco 0 credit card review how do i find my usaa credit card pin cash advance payday loans columbus ohio 30 day payday loans verifone credit card machine instructions how to download free applications from itunes without credit card malaysia credit card interest rate calculator bad credit car leasing deals citibank corporate credit card online southwest credit card review 2013 what stores have free reward cards how to apply for a credit card with little to no credit best buy credit card no interest 12 months credit card repayment calculator australia compare interest free balance transfer credit cards virgin credit card minimum payment credit card rewards points taxable does canadian tire sell prepaid credit cards best credit card loans first time credit card applications the best credit card in canada credit cards visa applications best cashback credit card deals uk online credit card processing for small business orchard bank credit card bill pay login aircel to airtel balance transfer guaranteed approval credit cards with $10000 limits for bad credit score 0 percent credit card deals uk top credit cards in india snowball credit card debt calculator 3d secure credit card validation corporate credit cards best practices best way to build credit fast with credit card anz low rate credit cards prepaid credit cards business plan compare credit card balance transfer offers bank credit cards fair credit best credit cards to apply for with low credit score canadian tire credit card payment address credit card transfer deals nz nordstrom credit card visa signature unsecured credit card debt consolidation loan fidelity cash back visa easy approval credit cards for bad credit canada online payday loan 100 approval make vanquis credit card payment tesco credit card bank citibank business credit card uk westpac credit card travel insurance policy best card to transfer credit card balance disney credit card review 2013 visa signature cards india fast online cash loans nz student credit cards no income requirements same day payday loan direct lender best credit card company in india formula to calculate interest paid on a credit card best cash advances online get pre approved for citibank credit card how to check bpi credit card application status online hsbc bank credit card customer care number apply for credit card instant decision toys r us gold card coupons personal online loan lenders minimum payment credit card calculator uk bajaj finance standard chartered credit card application status virgin credit card uk contact credit card reward program comparison canada credit card balance transfer rates nz goodyear credit card sign in credit card fraud penalties texas best no interest credit card offer chase credit card cashback calendar can you get an american express card with no credit history us bank credit card td canada trust visa card login how bad does applying for credit cards hurt your credit online credit card payment hdfc commonwealth bank credit cards compare sbi credit card charges free credit rating visa credit card for students with bad credit hsbc credit card settlement process india how to make cash advance in bpi credit card sbi credit card helpline number payday loan no credit check no broker no fees visa credit card uk jobs black credit card visa limits best credit card travel miles virgin credit card transfer fee credit union credit card consolidation loan new york and company credit card login what is a good first credit card for a student capital one secured credit card $3000 limit generic credit card authorization form doc how to get free prepaid credit cards can i ask my credit card company for a settlement figure natwest credit cards online services premier credit card reviews sign up for chase credit card rewards accept credit cards online without a merchant account uk new look black cropped cardigan how to get credit card with bad credit rating report credit card fraud australia bank of america login page credit cards can you use personal credit cards for business expenses canada credit card rewards compare best reward credit card canada 2011 how to pay off high interest credit cards platinum credit card icici bank fake american express black card how to get a cash advance on your credit card without a pin axis bank credit card reward points credit card approval with bad credit in canada personal loan to consolidate credit card debt can you get cashback with a capital one credit card business credit cards travel rewards need for speed carbon reward cards cheat icici credit card customer care number chennai guaranteed approval credit cards for poor credit 3 basic types of credit cards http capital one credit cards compare credit card numbers generator mastercard credit card bank of america instant credit card approval number credit cards deals for balance transfers airtel balance transfer system hdfc credit card points offers credit card limit 10000 citibank joint credit card costco credit card application target visa gift card cash back how to get cash advance from capital one credit card chase freedom credit card bonus categories best payday loan online lenders citibank credit card credit limit calculator credit cards uk apply online paypal instant credit card number visa credit card travel insurance south africa cash back credit cards my first credit card no credit history nordstrom credit card master note trust ii intuit credit card reader for pc best credit cards for rewards 2013 walmart canada credit card review best new credit card bonus application for credit card reissue no credit credit cards to build credit credit card minimum payment law 2011 best credit card business rewards amazon store credit card apr bank of america credit card cash advance transaction fee what;s the best credit card with no annual fee credit cards with 0 apr and rewards virgin credit card payment protection best uk credit cards 2013 sears sears mastercard credit card reviews tesco credit card application process high cash back credit card canada store reward cards on android marathon gas credit card phone number virgin business credit card uk which credit card sbi corporate credit card application capital one credit card international atm bad credit mortgage lenders airline credit cards with no annual fee citi corporate credit card customer care how to build your credit rating with a credit card united credit card 50000 bonus miles can you pay your best buy credit card with gift cards best credit cards in canada 2013 ebay buyer protection credit card how can i get credit card with bad credit chase starbucks credit card us airways mastercard uk ipad credit card app canada best credit cards for travel benefits how can i get a credit card with no credit yahoo american express gold credit card uk anz credit card balance transfer 0 ambank credit card balance transfer malaysia discover credit cards fair credit legit fast cash loans online free annual credit report score without credit card car loans with bad credit paypal credit card reader where to buy sunoco gas card bad credit rooms to go ge credit card payment belk credit card credit score requirements credit card fraud alert number can i pay for a money order with a credit card at the post office sbi gold credit card limit credit card reward miles apply credit cards instant approval chase visa card application status personal online loans with installment mbna canada credit card payments online payday loan lenders reviews most popular credit cards 2013 will my credit card company settle for less uk marriott rewards credit card promotion code full list of payday loan lenders amex cash advance uk poor credit credit cards uk instant approval instant online cash loans credit cards no credit check instant approval australia sbi corporate credit card helpline number fidelity 2 cash back cards applied bank secured visa gold credit card review lord and taylor credit card contact number chase secured credit card application united credit card premier status credit cards with no credit checks uk hsbc international credit card charges aspire credit card payment online how fast does a secured credit card help your credit cibc visa credit card balance city bank credit card customer care phone number delhi bank of america cash reward credit cards different types of credit cards visa mastercard which credit card is best for me virgin credit cards ppi claims easy credit cards with bad credit credit card for no credit history student does td canada trust have visa debit cards rbs 18 month interest free credit card apply for chase credit card with no credit history best black credit card uk pay bank of america credit card with paypal rewards credit card best buy aadvantage credit card offer 75000 credit card verification form qatar airways uob credit card online application malaysia how to apply for credit card online in india dillards lost credit card phone number dillards credit card phone number capital one online banking credit cards canada ntuc income credit card authorisation form credit card machines for small business with bad credit cibc student visa credit card standard chartered credit card customer care number bangalore calculate credit card interest rate calculator how does a credit/debit card work online reloadable credit cards green dot guaranteed payday loans direct lenders no credit check wells fargo health advantage credit card reviews free credit card numbers and security codes 2011 hsbc credit card cash advance limit credit card for bad credit instant decision buy online prepaid credit card black cardigan women;s sweater renew gold card derbyshire bad credit credit cards unsecured instant approval canada pnb credit card application form free download new uk credit card laws ann taylor credit card review when to apply for secured credit card after bankruptcy credit card terminal barclay credit card login uk apr for cash advances how are business credit card limits determined new payday lenders 2013 mastercard credit card us bank secured business credit card smartphone app for accepting credit cards capital one credit card pre approved offer major uk credit card providers credit card for international students singapore lowest interest credit card 2013 installment loans online instant approval list of credit card companies in canada capital one credit card customer service phone number nedbank american express gold credit card non prepaid virtual credit card visa gold credit card average credit score for walmart card capital one credit cards banking auto loans checking credit card number font download credit card rewards blog cash reward credit cards review wells fargo cash advance fee prepaid credit cards in canada walmart unsecured bad credit loan nz fake valid credit card number blank automatic credit card billing authorization form best credit card students no credit toys r us gold card offers canadian credit cards at us gas stations best free credit cards usa chase toys r us credit card ge capital best credit card apps android credit card visa number format natwest credit card online services activation buy virtual credit card usa 12 month 0 balance transfer no fee spicejet offers on icici credit cards phone number for first premier credit cards sbi credit card loan credit card student australia did virgin credit cards charge ppi apply for credit card with no processing fee lowest merchant credit card fees are merchant cash advances good travel credit cards comparison cheap interest credit cards canada can a secured credit card help rebuild credit best credit card interest rates balance transfer black card visa canada cheapest way to accept credit cards emirates platinum card staff 0 cash advance credit card deals uk credit card reviews 2013 wireless credit card terminals for sale kroger us bank credit card rei us bank credit card british airways credit card 100 000 points how long after chapter 7 bankruptcy can i get a credit card hsbc credit cards online payment credit cards with zero percent interest on balance transfers visa credit cards with no international fees best visa card for international travel sbi credit card eligibility calculator commonwealth bank business low rate credit card australian credit cards with free travel insurance moneysavingexpert soft search credit card credit cards no interest until 2015 royal bank of canada us visa card free list of valid credit card numbers credit card credit limit singapore discovery credit card benefits hsbc credit card travel insurance 12 month payday loan bad credit no fax bad credit payday loans online credit card debt help for veterans bpi balance transfer calculator iphone credit card case speck citi american airlines credit card 50000 average credit card rate us does paypal accept visa debit cards pay jcpenney credit card with gift card best way to refinance auto loan with bad credit cash advance online reviews business loans against credit card sales easy approval credit cards for poor credit how to apply for hsbc credit card in sri lanka payday loans direct lender no credit check online uk credit cards with gas and grocery rewards first credit card company in the world credit card merchant account no monthly fee 0 apr credit cards for 12 months walgreens prepaid visa credit cards what is the security code on your credit card instant cash loans online uk vanilla prepaid credit card visa credit card with no credit check philippines
Home Maury Brown MLBPA Fighting A-Rod Suspension Really About Punishment Fitting the Crime

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 490 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA Fighting A-Rod Suspension Really About Punishment Fitting the Crime PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 49
Written by Maury Brown   
Wednesday, 07 August 2013 13:44
Alex Rodriguez has the MLBPA in his corner, but it's likely over how long
his suspension is, not if he's deserving of one

UPDATE: According to The Associated Press, the MLBPA has formally filed a grievance in the Rodriguez case. He will continue to have his 211 game suspension stayed until Fredric Horowitz, the independent arbitrator, hears the case. According to the report, that will not be until November or December meaning that barring injury, Rodriguez will be allowed to play through the remainder of the 2013 season. - Maury Brown

+++++ +++++ +++++

On Thursday, MLB’s suspension of Alex Rodriguez kicks in, and at some stage the collectively bargained process around his rights to a grievance will officially start. An army of writers have spilled gallons of ink on the subject with the particulars around all the Biogenesis suspensions at the heart of it. Some have vilified baseball’s highest-paid player, while others have said that Bud Selig has done something that most thought impossible by making Rodriguez a sympatric figure. Out of the 14 players suspended, A-Rod will be the only one to file a grievance. The reaction by some has been, “You’re going to tell me 13 players said, ‘You caught me,’ but only one is going to say, he’s innocent?” In looking at the situation, that’s not what this appeal is all about. It’s about much more.

It’s not just A-Rod “fighting for his life” it’s about the MLBPA and assuring that the punishment fits the crime as defined by the jointly agreed upon drug policy. The league has said that they have a mountain of evidence, including “his use and possession of numerous forms of prohibited performance-enhancing substances, including Testosterone and human Growth Hormone, over the course of multiple years.” To add, the league said, “Rodriguez's discipline under the Basic Agreement is for attempting to cover-up his violations of the Program by engaging in a course of conduct intended to obstruct and frustrate the Office of the Commissioner's investigation.” Based upon that, the suspension length reached subjectively by the league was 211 regular games and any 2013 Postseason games in which Rodriguez otherwise would have been eligible to play. The ambiguity with which the suspension length was rendered is the concern of the MLBPA.

When questioned, Rodriguez would not deny he used the PEDs, but rather that he would have his day to make his case before arbitrator Fredric Horowitz (see The Most Important Man in Baseball You’ve Never Heard of). In reports prior to the suspension it was said that lawyers representing Rodriguez were willing to have him forgo the grievance if the league held to a 50 game suspension. That’s the issue. Not that he is, or is not, guilty. It’s about the length of the suspension.

The drug agreement goes into detail about how long suspensions should be, should a player test positive for PEDs. The league has decided that since the findings on the players involved in Biogenesis did not test positive, suspension lengths could vary. All but Ryan Braun and Rodriguez were slapped with 50 game suspensions. Braun, who tested positive for elevated levels of testosterone in 2011, but had his case rescinded in 2012 over the handling of his sample was given a 65 game suspension. As one official put it, he was hit with 50 games for his first offense, and 15 games for lying, etc.

This is a slippery slope for the MLBPA, and for the first time in years brought out aggravation and a strong sense that labor peace is under strain. As MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner said of Rodriguez’ case, “we agree with his decision to fight his suspension. We believe that the Commissioner has not acted appropriately under the Basic Agreement.” To add an exclamation point on where the MLBPA has been in the past on fighting labor disputes, Weiner added, “ Mr. Rodriguez knows that the Union, consistent with its history, will defend his rights vigorously.“

The union, which also added that the players  have made it clear that they want a clean game and that they support efforts to discipline players, and harshly, to help ensure an even playing field for all, also is going to go to the mat to ensure that the process by which players are suspended doesn’t get back into the lordship that former commissioners such as Bowie Kuhn and Fay Vincent tried to conduct. What they’re ostensibly saying is, “You’re kidding. You want to take a player that’s never tested positive under the program, threaten through the media of a lifetime ban, and then throw the largest suspension ever on a player behind only Pete Rose and the Black Sox players at him? He might be guilty but we’ll fight you on the punishment.”

The MLBPA is in the right here. The league and Commissioner Selig are trying to make a strong statement, but this is shooting a gnat with a shotgun. In going so far over the top, they’ve not only harmed labor relations, they have a good chance of getting egg on their face. Horowitz is going to have a heck of a time reading the drug agreement and seeing anything within it that allows for such overstepping. He can see 50 games based on the agreement, but beyond that gets into areas that are not defined. A rational, subjective comment might be, “Sorry, Major League Baseball. You guys reached this agreement jointly with the union for the players. If you want it to go to the lengths that you want, try that in the next round of collective bargaining.”

Fans will likely not care about all this. On the face of it, A-Rod appears to be making a case for innocence and the MLBPA is supporting that. While that could be the case, it’s looking more and more about insuring MLB doesn’t turn into judge, jury, and executioner. That’s a larger issue that affects not only Alex Rodriguez, but all the players.

Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes. He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted here.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?