novolog vs humalog diabetes where to buy protonix online where to buy korean red ginseng in singapore zithromax prescription only buy viramune boots does ventolin hfa cause weight gain allegra prescription vs otc generic uk paypal elavil the vitamin shoppe coupons health canada brand levitra buy abana pharmacy online eurax hydrocortisone cream where to coumadin asacol hd price increase buy tetracycline antibiotics dipyridamole 40 mg pharmacy overnight pharmacy bupron sr online bupron sr by mail calcium carbonate delivery uk famvir dosage for herpes para que se usa cleocin acheter venlor pas cher sinemet order can we trust claritin online meclizine dosage by weight mentat for sale avandamet online legally 40 mg levitra online generic oxytrol patch atrovent for men in usa generic name for endep side effects of bentyl injection azithromycin 250mg tablet use generic metformin online canadian methotrexate buy nitroglycerin bulk legal buy viagra online ireland extendaquin brands india prescription drug sales online glucophage 850 mg 100 film tablet ilac, tricor tablets generic does levaquin cause weight gain taking accutane alcohol garden greens 48 hour acai berry detox liquid reviews will generic prandin available brand cialis how to buy nizoral pills used for medicine ciprofloxacin hcl used nexium mups venlor price india alli uk reviews what is chloramphenicol used to treat what category drug is unisom renova cream amazon premarin mail order india korean panax ginseng 100 mg benefits use promethazine coupon online bactrim prices at costco coreg sale like paxil overnight no prescription better than exelon best cialis soft prices discount cheapest colospa with no rx zoloft weight gain study generic lipitor for sale on line best drugstore makeup 2012 uk generic vasodilan switzerland bactroban 2 cream cost buy brand levitra naproxen 500 mg tabletki can meclizine hydrochloride get you high half price hydrochlorothiazide cheapest place to buy alli weight-loss aid canadian pharmacy online androgel medrol dosepak mg buy imipramine over the counter acai berry supplements in india toprol xl supplier in uk zoloft cheap us pharmacy what does norvasc 10 mg look like what is metronidazole used for std pharmacie qui vend viagra order eldepryl 120 mg order zithromax online no prescription cheap uk pills generic actos order viagra super active without prescription long term side effects of nexium 40 mg etodolac 300 mg dogs glycomet pas cher what is amitriptyline hcl side effects canadian pharmacy viagra with prescription bactroban order by phone buy viagra tablets australia stieva-a tretinoin cream 0.1 warfarin foods to avoid nhs can you buy orlistat in spain buy acivir pills australia cheap avapro sale uk bentyl abuse what is the drug revia used for indian pharmacy zantac what does liquid arimidex taste like bactrim ds generic equivalent where to buy albuterol sulfate yagara buy usa buy cephalexin for fish healthy man dramamine drugstore.com order ephedraxin without rx common accutane side effects buy brand levitra online amazon pharmacie kirchberg lu preco do cialis no brasil alli diet pill facebook suhagra over the counter usa rian dawson reaction to one man one jar toronto pharmacy online application can you buy aciclovir genital pharmacy diclofenac gel tablets purchase on line lioresal cheap price zoloft 100mg and alcohol generic differin gel 0.3 side effects of alli pills crestor usa today buy colchicine boots alli simpson tumblr 2012 is glyset a prescription drug lozol medicine online pletal purchase in canada no prescription oblong blue pill with watson 853 how to use silagra 50 do people buy alligators buy cialis soft in ireland free coupon for propecia benicar generico italiano where do i buy bystolic canadian pharmacy 24 hour drugs purchase viagra cheap hotels in yasmine hammamet buy kamagra perth buy allopurinol without rx s g petch endep medication for pain tricor share price lipitor 4 copay card list participating pharmacies how to take ephedraxin mg buy citalopram 200 high blood pressure pills online stilnox online order order combivent pill worldwide pharmacy wellbutrin buy extendaquin greece purchase benadryl dogs sinemet medicinenet cordarone pill shop discount code buy sinemet hong kong canadian alliance party leadership lansoprazole dose for cats amlodipine besylate tablets 10mg cialis 5 pas cher viagra date to go generic trental 400 mg alkohol robaxin no prescription reviews buy zyrtec online pharmacy donde comprar cytotec septra ds online vytorin tab 10-40 mg finax canada prescription what is topamax 50mg used for which is better prevacid or prilosec south australian pharmacies cheap calan 100 mg most common types of drugs used in sport cheapest actoplus met in the uk sale prescription cod lopressor compazine 10 mg cost wellbutrin experiences anxiety pharmacy technician pay in canada can you get high off meclizine hcl actoplus met coupon citalopram side effects weight loss gain order levitra on line india diclofenac breastfeeding safety atorlip-10 canadian medications without prescription buy celebrex online side effects of premarin .3mg arjuna awards in india 2012 buy brand ortho tri-cyclen topamax weight loss 50 mg ortho tri-cyclen perth australia cytotec in labor and delivery pletal with paypal payment dutas tablets side effects can you get diamox in kathmandu ultra low dose pyridium what is robaxin like what is clorhidrato de amantadina maximum aciphex dosage where to buy phenamax in canada safely cephalexin 500mg missed dose uk version of viagra super active glycomet cost where to get reglan buy female cialis in uk buy glucophage online in usa nizagara canada overnight delivery speman mg tablet lipitor online overnight shipping how to import pariet best nolvadex dosage pct tetracycline hcl 500 mg used buy zetia 100 is generic clonidine available in usa how much to buy an alligator capoten no prescription compare prices lithium drug canadian pharmacy brand amoxil online pharmacy uk 12v lithium ion car battery for sale buy accutane with paypal long term side effects of prednisolone liquid prevacid review erexin-v prix en pharmacie en france safe cialis soft buy prevacid dose by weight vermont yankee sale exelon wellbutrin wikipedia deutsch canadian online prescription amaryl spain buy alli diet pills philippines discount sildenafil ratiopharm pret wellbutrin sr available canada chloromycetin without a prescription overnight delivery cialis generic dose propecia hair loss long term side effects of prednisolone in cats side effects of taking chlamydia medication order elocon cream 0.05 where to levitra professional wellcome ordering metformin hydrochloride exelon in italia florida ventolin albuterol inhaler side effects infants generic zovirax cream 5g where to buy cheap accutane buy cheap altace online hyzaar drugstore losartan medicine coumadin side effects metoclopramide comprar purchase crestor 10 mg rosuvastatin keflex dose pediatrica clonidine refill pack zyrtec uk brand name where to buy pyridium drugs online beconase aq online australia guide to buying viagra online costco pharmacy amitriptyline price mexican pharmacy no prescription coreg renagel mail order how to by terramycin online rico rico bakery restaurant grifulvin v tablets from buy digoxin toxicity australia zebeta comprare cheap mexican pharmacies no rx order dilantin coreg tablets uk buy roaccutane cheap online canadian pharmacy online flagyl buy generic avodart online with prescription where can i get advair diskus from generic cymbalta india suhagra online order antivert canada no prescription what is clomid for steroids best place buy atarax pct buy retin a micro online how to buy coversyl online colchicine 0.6 mg price tetracycline shortage why discount cialis no prescription uk version of zestoretic antibiotic doxycycline 100 mg warfarin mechanism of action diagram buy zovirax quick viagra professional ordering online pharmacy cialis annual sales 2011 ordering viagra super active online drug shop discount buy levaquin online overnight buy tadacip 200 advair diskus 40mg clonidine 10 mg cost maxalt 10mg cost flovent weight gain what is clomid used for with steroids free printable plavix coupons want to buy alligator gar online pharmacy orlistat available over counter uk a good web page to buy celexa with no script where to buy lithium supplement when will a generic be available for abilify purinethol without script order generic prozac no prescription cheap genuine paroxetine online can you get a tattoo while on coumadin can i order xeloda no prescription in the usa canadian prescription drug costs avodart from usa pharmacy purchase actos 30mg can we trust reminyl online non prescription fucidin pharmacy zyban brand order suprax 400mg uses cost of depakote medication effexor vs lexapro for anxiety buy alli online cheap pharmacy low dose lithium for children nike air max 95 womens running shoes revatio on line purchase side effects of femara for infertility is mail order arjuna safe trazodone maximum daily dosage discount valaciclovir online seroxat side effects hair loss generic danazol uk paypal cleocin gel overnight shipping cheap cialis reviews for men purchase minocin 100mg minipress tablets what is tamoxifen 20 mg arjuna online latino without cleocin online cheapest fertomid where to buy trileptal ointment best online pharmacy generic nizagara buy cheap suprax using pay pal cipro precio mexico discount benicar levitra 20mg en ligne metformin hcl er 750 mg tablet side effects buy metoclopramide online in usa cheap generic lipitor over the counter rumalaya gel starlix express canada gonorrhea treatment guidelines 2011 do i need antibiotics for sinusitis reglan tablets pregnancy z pack side effects rash safe buy nimotop online side effects of amoxicillin during pregnancy warfarin interactions chart drugs like lexapro cephalexin capsules bp 250 mg renova paper goods acai berry better than blueberry metformin lactic acidosis diabetes blue cross blue shield anthem mail order prescriptions tetracycline mail order neurontin for men sale in uk antabuse discount voucher lithium buy canada american express canada costco login most reliable place to buy lady era online buy cymbalta paypal accepted paxil pill shop discount code amitriptyline 20 mg zyvox lawsuit settlements is zofran sold over the counter buy lisinopril greece cialis comprar mexico cystone tablet price in india natural antibiotics garlic nexium discount program very cheap tretinoin 0,025 metformin manufacturers usa side effects of korean ginseng extract purchase seroquel on line in the uk levlen combined pill buy diovan pills in the mexico what is lincocin generic omnicef antibiotic compazine 20mg tab avalide com coupons budesonide entocort capsules side effects cheapest bupron sr in the uk aciphex in croatia order risperdal consta increasing sperm count naturally confido online in usa costco pharmacy trazodone price adalat generic reviews long time side effects tadacip is hoodia legal in uk buy xenical online no prescription us cheap nolvadex pct in canada what is brand viagra pills used for to buy kamagra jelly actonel sales 2008 lopressor sr 100mg amaryl 4/1000 precio how to by isoniazid online sildenafil 100mg manufacturers serevent for sale comprar cytoxan online xenical orlistat diet plan generic cialis pay with paypal all types of drugs wiki bupron buy online canada stromectol 12mg online albendazole online overnight shipping where can i buy ginseng yagara to buy in england lincocin im dosage now panax ginseng reviews clomiphene for men and women haldol usa 1 man 1 jar original video cleocin gel purchase in canada no prescription maxalt for sale usa can buy ranitidine online cheapest actos minocycline side effects uk female viagra rx order voltaren pill buy bactrim in india online zenegra sale pills cheap diclofenac online without canadian canadian pharmacy pfizer viagra hydrea women buy generic propecia store order actos 48 mg friv 10000 net abilify next day side effects of accutane in males where to buy dulcolax drugs online viagra without prescriptions south africa s club juniors 2013 andkon arcade 1000 free flash games online med cab benadryl is viagra legal in saudi arabia tadapox sale cialis pills amoxil pink medicine buy cheap ditropan using pay pal buy zenegra greece zithromax affect birth control pills zerit mg buy reminyl tablets from buy find pharmacy express scripts non prescription viagra uk best medicine for back muscle pain what is the generic for diovan buy eulexin quick furosemide reviews side effects nizoral mg mexico buy diclofenac gel online reviews viagra women blogs safe proscar online no prescriptionsafe generic maxalt india how to take trazodone for sleep generic tadapox in usa buy cheap lasix using pay pal non prescription ethionamide pharmacy lexapro generic release primatene mist discontinued replacement cost of atorlip-20 without insurance yasmin indian restaurant newcastle emlyn order diclofenaco voltaren atrovent in children best place to buy dutasteride tamsulosin in women uk buy floxin with visa how to buy cialis in mexico wellbutrin online no prescription strattera medication order on scriptmeds brand amoxil from canadian pharmacy generic for bactroban how to get mirapex in australia canada meds no prescription stieva a review acne.org purchase baclofen cheap 10mg online pharmacy cleocin gel medicine reviews on hyaluronic acid omifin precio 2011 generic priligy india western drug kamagra oral jelly health canada innopran xl cost of ciprofloxacin ointment keppra comprare why can;t you open flomax capsules sumycin wanted online review ciplox online overnight buy differin 100mg online benicar tablets purchase on line precio alli 42 capsulas amaryl spain over counter depakote lawsuit settlements order cialis professional usa fluoxetine hcl 20 mg tablet walmart pharmacy prices adderall buy diflucan over the counter doctor prandin generic patent
Home Maury Brown The History of MLB Antitrust Exemption and San Jose’s Effort to Land the A’s

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 916 guests online

Atom RSS

The History of MLB Antitrust Exemption and San Jose’s Effort to Land the A’s PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 91
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Thursday, 20 June 2013 13:46

Oakland A'sOn Tuesday, the City of San Jose filed an antitrust lawsuit charging Major League Baseball has thwarted efforts to allow the Oakland Athletics to relocate there. The Giants currently have the rights to Santa Clara Co. and have said that they are not willing to relinquish it, even though former A’s owner Walter Haas gave it to the Giants in 1990 to allow the Giants to potentially move to the Santa Clara area. After the Giants saw not one, but two referendums fail that would have allowed the Giants to relocate to San Jose, a last ditch-effort resulted in what is now AT&T Park. The problem was, the territory was reaffirmed as the Giants’ even though they no longer were looking to move to the territory that Haas had relinquished.

The lawsuit at hand (you can read it here) is the latest attempt to overturn MLB antitrust exemption. Although the NFL sees limited antitrust exemption for television, baseball is the only N. American sports league to still see such sweeping antitrust privileges.

In 1922, the Supreme Court first considered the application of federal antitrust law to professional sports in Federal Baseball Clubs, Inc. v. National League of Professional Baseball Clubs (read here). In the opinion delivered by Oliver Wendell Holmes, he said that baseball was not interstate commerce, and therefore not subject to the Sherman Act:

The business is giving exhibitions of base ball, which are purely state affairs. It is true that in order to attain for these exhibitions the great popularity that they have achieved competitions must be arranged between clubs from different cities and States. But the fact that in order to give the exhibitions the Leagues must induce free persons to cross state lines and must arrange and pay for their doing so is not enough to change the character of the business.

Since then, there have been other antitrust cases surrounding relocation. Most notably, Al Davis sued the NFL in 1982 saying that they were blocking his efforts to move to the Raiders from Oakland to Los Angeles. Indeed, the court ruled in his favor. On the other hand, the court did not rule in favor of the Clippers in the ‘80s when they looked to move from San Diego to Los Angeles (see NBA v. SDC Basketball Club, Inc.). In that case, the Ninth Circuit held that sports league created restrictions on franchise movement do not constitute per se violations of antitrust law. In other words, each case must be individually evaluated against the Sherman Act which seeks to prevent monopolies in business.

Since then, the court has been leery of weighing in on league powers over relocation. Most recently a US Bankruptcy judge refused to address relocation as part of an attempt by former Blackberry co-CEO Jim Balsillie to purchase the Phoenix Coyotes and relocate them to Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. In his decision, Judge Redfield T. Baum wrote, "In hockey parlance, the court is passing the puck to the NHL who can decide to take another shot at the sale net or it can pass off the puck."

Back to the San Jose lawsuit, there are some problems that if allowed to fully move forward do not bode well for the city. For one, this isn’t a case where ownership of the A’s is filing the suit, such as the case was with Al Davis and the Raiders. Davis argued he was being monetarily damaged for the NFL’s efforts to block him. The City of San Jose is ostensibly trying to make the argument that the A’s would make (the complaint seeks action for violation of California’s Unfair Competition Law, Tortious Interference with Contractual Advantage, and Tortious Interference with Prospective Economic Advantage, and for violation of the federal Sherman Act, and violation of California’s Cartwright Act, adding, “Plaintiffs have suffered and continue to suffer damages and antitrust injury in the millions of dollars due to Defendants’ unreasonable restraint of trade.”), but it’s difficult to say that the city is being damaged to a level of extent that might allow antitrust exemption for baseball to be overturned.

But, the question is, does San Jose need this case to run the distance?

The fact that the last real challenge to baseball’s antitrust exemption was in 1972 in Flood v Kuhn (read here) in which Curt Flood sought to break the reserve clause and allow for free agency says that baseball has been able to dodge the matter. But, recently, not only has San Jose been involved in going after MLB’s antitrust exemption, but they are named in a class-action suit by fans over league broadcast blackout policies. Is San Jose simply doing this as a test case to see if they can garner the same result?

Major League Baseball’s Executive Vice President for Economics & League Affairs Rob Manfred issued a statement in response to the lawsuit filed by the City of San Jose and was quick to defend the league’s position.

“In considering the issues related to the Oakland Athletics, Major League Baseball has acted in the best interests of our fans, our communities and the league,” said Manfred. “The lawsuit is an unfounded attack on the fundamental structures of a professional sports league. It is regrettable that the city has resorted to litigation that has no basis in law or in fact.”

If MLB were concerned enough to prevent the antitrust case to go the distance, it could act as a forcing function to achieve the move by the A’s. First off, the league constitution (read here) would need to be amended. While the complaint against MLB claims that the A’s and Giants are currently the only single market in which territory is not shared, the fact is, the league has always seen Oakland and San Francisco as two distinct markets. In that, the Giants physical territory would need to be amended to move Santa Clara Co. back to the A’s as it currently reads as follows:

City of San Francisco; and San Francisco, San Mateo, Santa Cruz, Monterey and Marin Counties in California; provided, however, that with respect to all Major League Clubs, Santa Clara County in California

To do this would require 75 percent approval by the league’s owners. On top of that, 75 percent of the owners would have to vote in favor of allowing the A’s to move to San Jose. It is safe to say that if one aspect was voted in favor, so would the other.

In the midst of all of this are the Giants who will be continuing to fight the matter tooth and nail. In order to have Selig, the league and the owners push the relocation  through it will require indemnifying the Giants. To what extent and how that would happen is a question difficult to answer. While the league got the last relocation through in 2005 with the Expos relocating to Washington, DC against the Orioles’ will, that was done with the creation of a regional sports network when MASN was created. At the time, the league agreed to the following:

  • A guarantee that will keep Baltimore’s annual revenues no lower than $130 million. If they do drop below that threshold, MLB will make up the difference;
  • A minimum franchise value for the Orioles at around $360 million; and
  • A 90 percent equity in MASN to the Orioles while the Nationals initially received only 10 percent. That increases for the Nationals over the life of the 23-year agreement to 33 percent.

The problem is  the Giants already own 30 percent of CSN Bay Area, and the A’s are on CSN California. Both clubs would need to be able to back out of their agreements and allow for the creation of a new RSN, something that would flood the market with another RSN.

The other option would be for some form of revenue-sharing from the A’s to the Giants. This would seem to run counter to one of the core issues at hand which is relocation to San Jose is designed to increase revenues from the state that they are now in Oakland. The A’s could move to San Jose, but still be at a revenue disadvantage.

None of this is easy, even if the league were to finally stand up and say that they need to allow for the A’s to relocate. From the beginning the issue has been one of self-preservation by the league and its clubs. After all, if San Jose were able to force MLB’s hand, then it would set a precedent for other clubs in the league to relocate. The Tampa Bay Rays are still trying to figure out how to get out of Tropicana Field. If the A’s went to San Jose, could that open up the possibility of Northern New Jersey pressing to get the Rays there against the will of the Yankees and Mets?

All we know is this… there will be many months for this to play out. The league may try to get the case dismissed, but that doesn’t seem likely. San Jose may prevail in getting the case heard, but chances of them winning seem long. And finally, while it’s likely a long shot, the league could lose antitrust exemption—a most coveted and fought after advantage for the league—at the risk of trying to fight the case. There will be many months to see if this is a game of chicken or not.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes. He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted here.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on TwitterTwitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?