ophthacare rezeptfrei länder billig citalopram unterschied zoloft rezeptfrei lady era preis oscar chloramphenicol durchschnittliche kosten führerschein eulexin online bestellen schweiz alesse generika indien prednisone pills yasmin online apotheke bestellen anacin online bestellen günstig billig glucovance kaufen erexin v efekty lipothin pille online bupropion sr verkauf causing anxiety diarex online bestellen wien billig slim tea spa unisom durchschnittliche kosten actos kaufen bupropion sr cash price beconase aq preisvergleich price serpina online bestellen schweiz lithium pulver kaufen furosemide online apotheke holland rabatt lamisil schwangerschaft celadrin generika günstig glucophage price usa clonidine durchschnittliche kosten implantat confido preis usa endep rabatt online zalando coreg online apotheke yokebe ginseng rabatt online panax glucovance online apotheke xanten detrol online apotheke pharmacy voltaren emulgel kaufen lady era preis fl flexisyn rabatt online provera rabatt online znanja engleskog kaufen erexin v erexin-v side effects venlor rezeptfrei schweiz tulsi blätter bestellen lasix online apotheke water pills singulair rabatt online for sale rabatt alli logistik entocort retail price regaine 5 männer preisvergleich voltaren preisvergleich 150g preisvergleich aspirin protect 100 kosten maxalt preis billig liv 52 leberschutz 100 tabletten elavil durchschnittliche kosten lebensmittel zithromax online apotheke ordering kaufen billig moduretic levitra generika (vardenafil) 20mg billig lipitor wirkung colchicine generika indien china penegra bestellen lamisil preis loesung kaufen vasotec rabatt tulasi uses nexium online apotheke to buy calcium carbonate medikamente where to buy benicar rezeptfrei holland neurontin online bestellen order rosuvastatin online apotheke xanten rabatt clindamycin gel kaufen billig endep yugioh karten phenergan generika liste atorlip-20 online apotheke deutschland colchicine online apotheke juvalis renagel online apotheke schweiz seroquel rezeptfrei kaufen vasodilan preis usa beconase aqueous medikamente hay fever lady era preis basketball bystolic preisvergleich stromectol online bestellen in u.k procardia pille online crestor pillen zyrtec generika schweiz orlistat online apotheke españa arcoxia 90 mg bestellen shatavari preis malaysia penegra generika preisvergleich digoxin rezeptfrei kaufen kamagra gold preis himcolin generika tadalis generika kaufen adalat eins micardis rabatt online coupons diltiazem online bestellen cream buy mestinon durchschnittliche kosten qm billig rogaine 5 instructions kaufen billig viagra online motrin durchschnittliche kosten führerschein ditropan generika suche voltaren rabatt online resinat mestinon preisvergleich yokebe clomid generika viagra liponexol online bestellen bentyl rabatt online apotheke proscar online apotheke italia lasuna rezeptfrei wien femara pille mycelex-g rezeptfrei brahmi rezeptfrei wo baclofen rezeptfrei spanien avalide rezeptfrei länder fosamax medikamente zofran odt price ginseng rabatt online super calcium carbonate medikamente chalk gyne lotrimin preis effects chloroquine preis keppra generika preis kaufen benadryl saft detrol generika kaufen aciclovir nebenwirkungen gyne-lotrimin generika indien brahmi online bestellen extrakt clindamycin rezeptfrei holland chloramphenicol rabatt online pumpspray cozaar generika tabelle lotrisone rezeptfrei italien digoxin generika indien china minomycin generika hersteller finast generika indien cialis billig liv 52 vs silimarina kaufen billig voltaren nebenwirkungen cytotec rezeptfrei kaufen zyban tablet price in india osteoporose medikamente actonel remeron rabatt online shop strattera rabatt online purchase terramycin rezeptfrei online lady era preis hombre terramycin rezeptfrei usa cialis kaufen zürich geriforte rezeptfrei niederlande finast generika indien tadalafil betapace rezeptfrei günstig abana rezeptfrei länder rabatt methotrexate nebenwirkungen rizact generika suche calcium carbonate preis antacid bupropion sr rezept ohne diovan online apotheke pharmacies methotrexate durchschnittliche kosten lebensmittel xalatan rabatt online eye drops carbozyne rezeptfrei zyprexa rabatt online order propecia medikamente und andere provera rabatt online jmbg combivent rabatt online prescription feldene generika viagra voltaren emulgel novartis preis tricor bestellen lamisil fußpilz erfahrungen periactin online apotheke xanten xalatan online bestellen vergleich detrol online apotheke xanten viagra billig kaufen deutschland kaufen billig buspar online rogaine 5 preisvergleich dose shatavari kalpa kaufen rabatt desyrel uyku rabatt calan forcat kaufen cozaar furosemide online apotheke uk arcoxia online apotheke test kaufen advair nizagara rezeptfrei schweiz erfahrung kamagra-europa.eu bentyl rabatt online youtube omnicef pille danach accutane kopen nederland maxalt rabatt online mlt effexor online bestellen ikea carbozyne rezeptfrei schweiz naltrexone durchschnittliche kosten qm antivert verkauf cialis kaufen nachnahme cialis kaufen eu bupropion sr rezeptfrei benefits saw palmetto verkauf menopause orlistat online apotheke cheap uk benicar online bestellen canada motrin durchschnittliche kosten aciphex pille atorlip 20 preis tabletas prednisolone online bestellen deutschland procardia online apotheke schweiz amoxicillin online apotheke liquid precose generika zoll zenegra generika tamoxifen kaufen ohne rezept nasonex online bestellen ikea flagyl er verkauf reseptfritt yasmin online apotheke watch kosten rogaine 5 year study calcium carbonate preis hcl lynoral generika apotheke noroxin preis grifulvin v rezeptfrei manufacturer endep online apotheke schnelle lieferung zyban pille preis beconase aq rezeptfrei kaufen kaufen billig rogaine 5 xbox speman generika zoll atorlip-5 medikamente liste benzac online apotheke test tulsi samen bestellen rabatt fml forte jundiai zenegra generika zulassung yougara online apotheke nicotinell kaufen seroquel rezeptfrei deutschland erexin-v online apotheke dilantin online apotheke prevacid rezeptfrei deutschland anafranil rezeptfrei viagra charboleps online bestellen test rabatt cialis dauer elavil bestellen isoptin online bestellen günstig indinavir rezeptfrei niederlande ciplox rezeptfrei günstig torsemide durchschnittliche kosten implantat colospa online bestellen wien azulfidine rezeptfrei wien abana rezeptfrei italien emsam generika schweiz zofran online apotheke uk billig slim tea kaufen neu rabatt cardura lek keflex online apotheke juvalis pristiq medikamente taking tulasi rezeptfrei deutschland arimidex durchschnittliche kosten implantat kaufen bupropion sr coupons losartan hct generika cefixim online kaufen kosten atorlip-20 uroxatral rezeptfrei online arcoxia online apotheke xanten prograf rezeptfrei apotheke fluoxetine online apotheke canada reminyl rabatt online youtube periactin rabatt online h&m forzest rezeptfrei holland kosten terramycin kaninchen orlistat online apotheke shop kaufen tretinoin kaufen plaquenil kaufen clarina preisvergleich yokebe bupropion sr bestellen cut in half pyridium pille slim tea online bestellen jeans yasmin online apotheke venta wellbutrin online apotheke buying adalat rabatt online apni tv billig bupropion sr quit smoking tetracycline generika liste hydrea 500 mg preis singulair medikament wirkung epivir-hbv online bestellen deutschland duphalac durchschnittliche kosten lebensmittel crestor online bestellen pharmacy lynoral generika türkei detrol online apotheke buy himcocid online bestellen ikea allegra preis pirate kosten rocaltrol wirkung voltaren plus rezeptfrei proscar online apotheke bestellen styplon rezeptfrei bestellen kaufen billig bupropion premarin verkauf kosten betapace wellbutrin online apotheke sr buy prazosin rezeptfrei viagra top avana generika indien china tulsi extrakt kaufen generika tamoxifen nolvadex yasmin online bestellen keppra saft preis nizagara pille online cialis kaufen ebay exelon generika suche kaufen serophene schwanger kaufen nootropil erfahrungsberichte kosten rogaine 5 effects dutas t price uroxatral rezeptfrei niederlande clindamycin online bestellen nederland femcare rabatt online zetia online apotheke doxazosin rezeptfrei holland grifulvin v rezeptfrei alcohol baclofen medikament alkohol rabatt wellbutrin quit robaxin preis imdur online apotheke test kytril generika indien premarin online bestellen cream rogaine 5 generika results kaufen nicotinell erfahrungen rabatt eulexin manufacturer bupropion sr price walgreens furosemide online bestellen australia vantin generika apotheke kaufen billig hoodia unilever endep rabatt online karstadt kaufen billig trileptal benzac online bestellen gel compra big appeal medikamente limited paroxetine rezeptfrei viagra benemid preisvergleich yokebe rabatt pilex noroxin generika liste beconase aq rezeptfrei inhaler endep rabatt online gutscheine billig liv 52 contraindicatii proscar pille strattera kopen online anafranil online bestellen purchase beconase aqueous verkauf ear tulasi rabatt online movie watch allegra online apotheke niederlande grifulvin v rezeptfrei cvs medikament citalopram dura 20mg calcium carbonate verkauf quarry septilin generika günstig kaufen bupropion sr anxiety lipitor brand price bupropion sr verkauf you gain weight kaufen gyne lotrimin or mycelex skelaxin online apotheke niederlande diltiazem online bestellen online skelaxin rabatt online apotheke furosemid durchschnittliche kosten mg trileptal rabatt online youtube buspar generika kaufen kaufen cephalexin hund rabatt avodart kosten erexin v mega opinie trial erection packs preis qm vasodilan generika finax rabatt online kaufen augmentin online apotheke bestellen zoloft generika erfahrungen billig rogaine 5 walgreens colospa online bestellen schweiz myambutol online bestellen nederland kaufen billig zyban rezeptfrei pletal rabatt online order rogaine 5 generika year kaufen olanzapine ditropan generika zulassung uroxatral rezeptfrei holland finasterid online bestellen schweiz dapoxetine online bestellen uk bupropion rezeptfrei usa prometrium generika indien ralista online bestellen xenos serpina online bestellen test ginseng pille siberische rabatt big appeal ltd rabatt naprosyn fort kosten liv 52 year round xenical generika rezeptfrei citalopram pille taking diflucan rezeptfrei frankreich proscar pille preis viagra rezeptfrei verboten glucophage best price tadapox pille danach nebenwirkungen citalopram mepha minocycline price walmart voltaren rabatt online youtube proscar online apotheke consultation zetia online apotheke schweiz zyprexa rabatt online h&m kosten saw palmetto hair kaufen epivir-hbv procardia pille top avana durchschnittliche kosten lebensmittel glucovance online apotheke test benzac medikamente liste yasmin online apotheke españa rabatt provera nebenwirkungen voltaren tabletten rezeptfrei kosten saw palmetto online bestellen xxl kaufen billig seroquel rezept allegra durchschnittliche kosten kosten zithromax bestellen kaufen billig moduretic wirkstoff aspirin preisvergleich europa celebrex online bestellen test coreg price walmart rabatt mobic uses rogaine 5 generika topical foam kaufen gyne lotrimin clotrimazole dutas medikamente liste lotrisone rezeptfrei holland big appeal rezeptfrei dig rabatt levitra lithium online bestellen amoxicillin online bestellen get tofranil generika indien reisen arcoxia online bestellen buy kosten epivir-hbv depakote rezeptfrei holland kaufen entocort penegra generika apotheke cialis rezeptfrei günstig carbozyne rabatt online h&m voltaren dolo liquid preis serevent online apotheke xanten kaufen billig hoodia lady era preis un uomo fucidin pille hautantibiotikum rabatt paroxetine hcl diarex durchschnittliche kosten lebensmittel celebrex rezeptfrei online kosten liv 52 tabletki crestor rabatt online purchase rabatt cialis kaufen mestinon durchschnittliche kosten metformin online bestellen ohne rezept viagra rezeptfrei zoll speman forte price in india evista online apotheke juvalis cialis rezeptfrei england minocin akne pille prevacid generika indien youtube kaufen benadryl fass tulsi zaden kopen zanaflex online apotheke purchase liponexol durchschnittliche kosten implantat prednisone online apotheke epocrates rabatt terramycin pariet preis kaufen billig dapoxetine in deutschland kosten rogaine 5 strength aciclovir online bestellen order phenergan rezeptfrei bestellen beconase aq verkauf price rizact generika türkei coreg online apotheke testsieger flagyl er online apotheke schweiz hydrea medikamente liste ophthacare generika preisvergleich olanzapin medikamentengruppe top avana rabatt online free billig lady era fl liv 52 bestellen apotheke malegra online apotheke juvalis kaufen billig valtrex wirkstoff lamisil preis qm kaufen aceon rein bupropion sr pille xl for weight loss trileptal 600 preis effexor pille preis arcoxia durchschnittliche kosten führerschein nimotop online apotheke buy amitriptylin durchschnittliche kosten neuraxpharm bupropion sr rezeptfrei erowid pilex medikamente lipitor atorvastatin kaufen billig bupropion sr and alcohol serpina online bestellen online clonidine generika tabelle orlistat via internet bestellen imdur generika indien synthroid rezeptfrei viagra zoloft durchschnittliche kosten rogaine 5 preisvergleich comprar billig accutane erfahrung triamterene durchschnittliche kosten lebensmittel carafate generika rezeptfrei coreg rezeptfrei viagra geriforte rezeptfrei holland minomycin pille vergessen kosten naltrexone bestellen colchicine online bestellen buy billig lady era maschio allegra rabatt online coupon code amitriptyline rezeptfrei italien beconase aq medikamente reviews precose generika schweiz billig bupropion sr usp ciplox rezeptfrei niederlande kosten feldene gel etodolac pille online aristocort durchschnittliche kosten führerschein erexor online apotheke test endep rabatt online gutschein fluoxetine price kroger septilin rezeptfrei online
Home Maury Brown The History of MLB Antitrust Exemption and San Jose’s Effort to Land the A’s

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 301 guests online

Atom RSS

The History of MLB Antitrust Exemption and San Jose’s Effort to Land the A’s PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 91
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Thursday, 20 June 2013 13:46

Oakland A'sOn Tuesday, the City of San Jose filed an antitrust lawsuit charging Major League Baseball has thwarted efforts to allow the Oakland Athletics to relocate there. The Giants currently have the rights to Santa Clara Co. and have said that they are not willing to relinquish it, even though former A’s owner Walter Haas gave it to the Giants in 1990 to allow the Giants to potentially move to the Santa Clara area. After the Giants saw not one, but two referendums fail that would have allowed the Giants to relocate to San Jose, a last ditch-effort resulted in what is now AT&T Park. The problem was, the territory was reaffirmed as the Giants’ even though they no longer were looking to move to the territory that Haas had relinquished.

The lawsuit at hand (you can read it here) is the latest attempt to overturn MLB antitrust exemption. Although the NFL sees limited antitrust exemption for television, baseball is the only N. American sports league to still see such sweeping antitrust privileges.

In 1922, the Supreme Court first considered the application of federal antitrust law to professional sports in Federal Baseball Clubs, Inc. v. National League of Professional Baseball Clubs (read here). In the opinion delivered by Oliver Wendell Holmes, he said that baseball was not interstate commerce, and therefore not subject to the Sherman Act:

The business is giving exhibitions of base ball, which are purely state affairs. It is true that in order to attain for these exhibitions the great popularity that they have achieved competitions must be arranged between clubs from different cities and States. But the fact that in order to give the exhibitions the Leagues must induce free persons to cross state lines and must arrange and pay for their doing so is not enough to change the character of the business.

Since then, there have been other antitrust cases surrounding relocation. Most notably, Al Davis sued the NFL in 1982 saying that they were blocking his efforts to move to the Raiders from Oakland to Los Angeles. Indeed, the court ruled in his favor. On the other hand, the court did not rule in favor of the Clippers in the ‘80s when they looked to move from San Diego to Los Angeles (see NBA v. SDC Basketball Club, Inc.). In that case, the Ninth Circuit held that sports league created restrictions on franchise movement do not constitute per se violations of antitrust law. In other words, each case must be individually evaluated against the Sherman Act which seeks to prevent monopolies in business.

Since then, the court has been leery of weighing in on league powers over relocation. Most recently a US Bankruptcy judge refused to address relocation as part of an attempt by former Blackberry co-CEO Jim Balsillie to purchase the Phoenix Coyotes and relocate them to Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. In his decision, Judge Redfield T. Baum wrote, "In hockey parlance, the court is passing the puck to the NHL who can decide to take another shot at the sale net or it can pass off the puck."

Back to the San Jose lawsuit, there are some problems that if allowed to fully move forward do not bode well for the city. For one, this isn’t a case where ownership of the A’s is filing the suit, such as the case was with Al Davis and the Raiders. Davis argued he was being monetarily damaged for the NFL’s efforts to block him. The City of San Jose is ostensibly trying to make the argument that the A’s would make (the complaint seeks action for violation of California’s Unfair Competition Law, Tortious Interference with Contractual Advantage, and Tortious Interference with Prospective Economic Advantage, and for violation of the federal Sherman Act, and violation of California’s Cartwright Act, adding, “Plaintiffs have suffered and continue to suffer damages and antitrust injury in the millions of dollars due to Defendants’ unreasonable restraint of trade.”), but it’s difficult to say that the city is being damaged to a level of extent that might allow antitrust exemption for baseball to be overturned.

But, the question is, does San Jose need this case to run the distance?

The fact that the last real challenge to baseball’s antitrust exemption was in 1972 in Flood v Kuhn (read here) in which Curt Flood sought to break the reserve clause and allow for free agency says that baseball has been able to dodge the matter. But, recently, not only has San Jose been involved in going after MLB’s antitrust exemption, but they are named in a class-action suit by fans over league broadcast blackout policies. Is San Jose simply doing this as a test case to see if they can garner the same result?

Major League Baseball’s Executive Vice President for Economics & League Affairs Rob Manfred issued a statement in response to the lawsuit filed by the City of San Jose and was quick to defend the league’s position.

“In considering the issues related to the Oakland Athletics, Major League Baseball has acted in the best interests of our fans, our communities and the league,” said Manfred. “The lawsuit is an unfounded attack on the fundamental structures of a professional sports league. It is regrettable that the city has resorted to litigation that has no basis in law or in fact.”

If MLB were concerned enough to prevent the antitrust case to go the distance, it could act as a forcing function to achieve the move by the A’s. First off, the league constitution (read here) would need to be amended. While the complaint against MLB claims that the A’s and Giants are currently the only single market in which territory is not shared, the fact is, the league has always seen Oakland and San Francisco as two distinct markets. In that, the Giants physical territory would need to be amended to move Santa Clara Co. back to the A’s as it currently reads as follows:

City of San Francisco; and San Francisco, San Mateo, Santa Cruz, Monterey and Marin Counties in California; provided, however, that with respect to all Major League Clubs, Santa Clara County in California

To do this would require 75 percent approval by the league’s owners. On top of that, 75 percent of the owners would have to vote in favor of allowing the A’s to move to San Jose. It is safe to say that if one aspect was voted in favor, so would the other.

In the midst of all of this are the Giants who will be continuing to fight the matter tooth and nail. In order to have Selig, the league and the owners push the relocation  through it will require indemnifying the Giants. To what extent and how that would happen is a question difficult to answer. While the league got the last relocation through in 2005 with the Expos relocating to Washington, DC against the Orioles’ will, that was done with the creation of a regional sports network when MASN was created. At the time, the league agreed to the following:

  • A guarantee that will keep Baltimore’s annual revenues no lower than $130 million. If they do drop below that threshold, MLB will make up the difference;
  • A minimum franchise value for the Orioles at around $360 million; and
  • A 90 percent equity in MASN to the Orioles while the Nationals initially received only 10 percent. That increases for the Nationals over the life of the 23-year agreement to 33 percent.

The problem is  the Giants already own 30 percent of CSN Bay Area, and the A’s are on CSN California. Both clubs would need to be able to back out of their agreements and allow for the creation of a new RSN, something that would flood the market with another RSN.

The other option would be for some form of revenue-sharing from the A’s to the Giants. This would seem to run counter to one of the core issues at hand which is relocation to San Jose is designed to increase revenues from the state that they are now in Oakland. The A’s could move to San Jose, but still be at a revenue disadvantage.

None of this is easy, even if the league were to finally stand up and say that they need to allow for the A’s to relocate. From the beginning the issue has been one of self-preservation by the league and its clubs. After all, if San Jose were able to force MLB’s hand, then it would set a precedent for other clubs in the league to relocate. The Tampa Bay Rays are still trying to figure out how to get out of Tropicana Field. If the A’s went to San Jose, could that open up the possibility of Northern New Jersey pressing to get the Rays there against the will of the Yankees and Mets?

All we know is this… there will be many months for this to play out. The league may try to get the case dismissed, but that doesn’t seem likely. San Jose may prevail in getting the case heard, but chances of them winning seem long. And finally, while it’s likely a long shot, the league could lose antitrust exemption—a most coveted and fought after advantage for the league—at the risk of trying to fight the case. There will be many months to see if this is a game of chicken or not.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes. He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted here.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on TwitterTwitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?