line of credit loans for bad credit canadian reloadable prepaid credit cards marriott rewards credit cards reviews free balance transfer credit cards no fee rent wireless credit card machine citifinancial credit card contact number chase credit card services pay online how to check tesco credit card points hdfc credit card payment information hdfc credit card balance transfer chase freedom credit card ratings pay my first premier credit card bill credit card application referred for review how to start an online payday loan business does walgreens sell prepaid credit cards application for credit cards online reward cards ks2 gold delta skymiles credit card canada i don;t have any credit how do i get a credit card payday loans uk direct lenders chase pre approved credit card low interest credit card balance transfer life does chase bank have a student credit card payday loans bad credit ok direct lender american express corporate credit card customer care number what credit card is best for me rbc visa canada credit card best reward credit cards 2012 canada what is an issue number on a credit card visa debit virgin money credit card contact number sbi credit card apply online southwest rapid rewards business credit card quick online loans for unemployed approved cash advance store hours long term online loans south africa credit card payment app for ipad which bank easiest to get credit card master credit card number generator application for reissue of credit card list of all credit cards for bad credit td us visa card benefits chase credit cards rewards redemption chase credit card visa customer service standard chartered credit card promotions sri lanka credit card magnetic strip protector sleeve westpac credit card balance transfer rate 10 best online payday loans orchard credit card phone number hsbc amanah credit card balance transfer hdfc platinum master credit card offers what happens when a credit card company sues you visa card services online instant approval business credit cards old orchard bank credit card payment paypal vs credit card conversion rates credit cards longest interest free period student credit cards with no credit no cosigner best no fee visa credit card canada payday loan online canada credit card insurance uk absa credit card fraud insurance best rewards credit card 2013 uk standard chartered online credit card payment online how to accept credit cards on iphone 4 0 intro apr business credit cards tesco clubcard credit card lost stolen 3d secure credit card us bank credit card comparison tool manual credit card machine canada list of all chase credit cards is credit card protection insurance necessary intuit credit card scanner for ipad visa cash back cards canada capital one uk credit card login fixed rate credit card calculator best credit card bad credit unsecured credit cards with airmiles and no annual fee citibank business credit card contact credit card terminal for ipad inner fence list of premium credit cards in india cash rewards gas credit cards credit cards deals usa need a credit card credit card protection on purchases via paypal get a no credit check credit card best buy credit cards contact number best credit card to earn air miles singapore preloaded credit cards for international travel chase visa card lost icici bank credit cards e statement axis bank credit card apply phone number best credit card protection plan best rate credit cards canada mastercard uk management services ltd walmart credit card payments online credit card review singapore is magnum cash advance legal chase credit card no interest for a year where can i buy reloadable prepaid credit cards loft mastercard credit card payments credit cards after bankruptcy discharge 2012 how do credit card interest rates differ by company define the strategies credit card apply online in chennai create virtual paypal credit card shell gas credit card offers low interest credit cards balance transfer canada td visa card expires corporate credit card policy santander visa card issue number check debit visa card balance best small business credit cards for fair credit greenwoods personal credit gold card sears secure credit card login fast cash loans online lenders toys r us gold card change of address visa credit card for bad credit canada british airways visa card uk reducing credit card debt yourself fixed low rate credit cards canadian credit cards comparison ocbc great eastern credit card application form international credit card provider in bangladesh indusind bank credit cards offers 70 000 mile american express delta credit card best visa card manual credit card machine instructions bad credit visa cards australia top 25 credit card processing companies desjardins visa student credit card lloyds tsb credit card charges abroad chase credit card merchant services standard chartered online credit card payment pakistan i need a credit card to build my credit low fixed rate for life credit cards best credit cards for bad credit score myfico credit card finder credit card history check credit card rewards programs australia i need to apply for a visa credit card cancel cibc credit card online ace payday loans reviews gap visa card make payment best personal online loans cash advance payday loans scams how to get a credit card with no credit history yahoo answers hdfc credit card login bill payment online how to get free credit card information uk credit cards for new immigrants credit card machines for iphone uk legacy visa credit card application status credit rewards cards travel commonwealth bank credit card interest rates wells fargo business credit card machine kohls credit card pay which credit card offers the best cash back reward visa credit cards for college students reward credit card uk what is cash advance interest rate credit cards with free worldwide travel insurance prepaid credit card australian dollars best credit cards in canada credit limit increase capital one mastercard sbi platinum card annual fee new payday loans like wonga best corporate credit cards rewards apply for credit card credit union aib visa debit cards hsbc premier credit card rewards uk home depot canada credit card application sbi credit card application form status average credit card fees for business credit rating agencies best airmiles credit card usa what is a credit card that offers a 0 transfer balance secured credit card offers for bad credit td visa infinite cash back will a secured credit card help your credit what is my minimum credit card payment myer visa card fees need a credit card to rebuild credit walmart credit card account login best buy credit card app status compare credit cards india how do you calculate interest on credit card balances payday loans no fees unemployed city bank credit card login page corporate credit card credit check www.chase.com/creditcards online payment walmart credit card 20 cash back best credit cards for students with no income interest free credit card transfer offers best air miles rewards credit card canada get pre-approved for chase credit card best ways to pay off credit card debt reloadable visa cards uk bestbuy credit card credit card limit increase good or bad my prepaid credit card canada post black cardamom tea obama credit card debt relief grant is there an app for walmart credit card bsnl to vodafone balance transfer best business travel credit card canada credit card numbers that work prepaid credit cards canada review capital one balance transfer rates existing customers womens black cardigan sweater can you get cash from a prepaid visa card random credit card number and name what is a credit card cvv cheap interest payday loans online credit card balance transfer comparison calculator uob credit card shell promotion walmart prepaid visa card canada how to hook up a verifone credit card machine android credit card app uk halifax 22 month balance transfer credit card dubai first credit card payment chase united plus credit card login military pay advance pcs sear credit card login citi tips on how to pay off credit card debt fast unsecured business cash advances capital one credit cards no foreign transaction fees nfinanse prepaid debit visa card uk payday loans with bad credit free virtual credit card for paypal verification chase credit card apr cheapest virtual credit card terminal best platinum credit cards uk wells fargo credit card rewards mortgage free credit report no card details required new credit card fees in canada student credit card for students with bad credit pay bank of america credit card at branch credit card with no annual fee for bad credit compare reward credit cards australia shell credit card login iphone credit card case best buy best buy rewards credit cards payment military pay advance rules new credit card rules for stay at home parents which is the best credit card for students with no credit history i have bad credit and want to get a credit card fast easy cash loans south africa hsbc credit card balance transfer promotion apply for capital one platinum credit card credit card limit calculator hdfc iphone credit card case 5 best delta rewards credit card major credit card logos for website credit card fraud uk statistics credit card for bad credit no credit check personal loan calculator bad credit black credit card natwest what is the credit score range for american express card mastercard amazon 10 off 100 reset verifone credit card machine travel rewards credit card with no annual fee credit card payment processing bad credit cash loans online short term loan bad credit history apply credit card online abn amro 500 fast cash loans prepaid credit cards canada bankruptcy can i get a credit card without having a job is closing a credit card account bad for your credit score loans for bad credit and no debit card pay circuit city credit card 4 major credit cards companies is magnum cash advance legal in florida intuit small business credit card processing top 5 credit cards in india 2012 chase credit card rewards gift cards best credit card for students traveling abroad top ten best credit cards to have what are good apr rates for credit cards apply for visa student credit card td canada premium credit cards who has best credit card reward program direct payday loan lenders no brokers visa prepaid credit card usa credit card charges ez payday advance watertown sd bankruptcy credit cards bad credit loans no fees consumer reports best credit card balance transfers jcpenney rewards credit card payment address do i need a credit card for itunes match how fast does a secured credit card help your credit square credit card reader ipad 2 credit cards for average credit no annual fee unsecured loans with bad credit australia best travel points credit card canada 2013 credit card payment machine hire cash advance direct lenders for bad credit us bank secured business credit card cheapest credit card transfer rate hdfc credit card status complaint very bad credit loans no guarantor no broker online payday loan scams review do you need a credit card for itunes match visa credit card offers small business credit cards with high limits tips for getting a first credit card apply for a visa credit card with no credit history hdfc credit card settlement process instant online no fax payday loan tips for getting a credit card with bad credit 12 month 0 balance transfer no fee best business credit card canada 2012 government small business loans with bad credit i need a bad credit loan of 5000 aspire credit card hdfc credit card apply halifax student credit card terms and conditions credit cards apply online icici vanquis credit card contact number abroad how to get verified on paypal without a bank account or credit card loans you can pay back monthly sbi international credit card charges credit card comparisons australia walmart pre approved credit card offers hdfc credit card loans test credit card visa number accept credit card payments mobile portable credit card terminal rental citibank online credit card application status india td visa card activation number compare cheapest credit card rates dcu visa platinum secured credit card reviews granite credit card online statement accepting credit cards with paypal iphone credit card case kickstarter hdfc credit card payment online from sbi credit card best credit cards for college students with no income bdo credit cards online application bad credit credit card offers very bad credit car leasing aqua student credit card review how to get a us dollar credit card in canada best chase credit card offers 2013 delta miles credit card login is there a secured credit card with rewards unsecured credit card with no credit check fixed rate credit cards definition old fashioned credit card machine united miles credit card deal british airways credit card offer online application for credit card philippines what does pdq credit card machine stand for 0 on cash advances on credit cards credit card reviews canada 2012 loans for bad credit uk credit card calculator excel template what is the best credit card deal for balance transfers sallie mae pay loans fast cash loans online south africa first premier bank credit card for bad credit reviews cheapest credit card terminal rates quick cash loans for unemployed uk walmart credit card number phone best visa credit card usa which credit card is best for international students best credit cards to use in the uk different types of bank of america credit cards how do i find my usaa credit card pin gas credit cards for poor credit reporting credit card settlement to irs bad credit loans compare the market natwest business credit card helpline apply for a student mastercard credit card best cashback credit cards with annual fee nedbank platinum card requirements secured credit cards to rebuild credit google wallet credit card security united mileage plus credit card uk guaranteed unsecured credit card for bad credit companies that reduce credit card debt minimum age to apply for credit card in canada state bank of india apply online credit card cash advance loans direct lenders only credit card prime rate definition credit card 0 balance transfer to current account activate vanilla visa card nordstrom credit card visa signature direct payday loan lenders only no teletrack walmart credit card approval time free credit card logos vector no credit check payday loans direct lender lowest credit card rate in us purchasing bad credit card debt citibank virtual credit card download sign up for a free visa credit card apply for credit card visa online prepaid visa credit cards india can i get a credit card with no credit rating loan with bad credit history india best airline rewards credit cards 2011 i need a credit card asap bad credit best credit card transfer balance offers should i get credit card protection i don;t want a credit card va loan with bad credit score legit payday online loans credit card business loans credit card minimum payment affect credit score hdfc bank credit card help desk payday cash loans online first capital connect annual gold card bad credit payday loan lenders online best wifi credit card terminal what is the best prepaid credit card for online use credit card to earn air miles singapore canadian credit cards with travel insurance credit card interest free period australia prepaid virtual credit cards usa working visa card generator usaa college credit card review nedbank credit card limit increase hdfc credit cards reward points catalogue credit card visa mastercard number best starter credit cards for college students best online payday loans uk hsbc best buy credit card reviews united airlines credit card good deal is a secured credit card a good way to rebuild credit what does your credit score need to be to get a best buy credit card best portable credit card scanner get paypal credit card uk hdfc gold credit card apply online virgin 0 credit card balance transfers what credit cards companies only use experian free high risk credit cards i have no credit what credit card can i get united mileage plus club credit card review credit card with 0 interest on balance transfers for 12 months what is the best secured credit card to get in canada gnc gold card uk what is the best visa credit card to get capital one venture rewards credit card review post office credit card contactless delta credit card offer payday lenders uk 2013 small cash loans with bad credit cash converters payday advance pretoria can you transfer a personal loan to a credit card hdfc online credit card payment india compare credit cards for business what does your credit score have to be to get a sears card how do payday cash advances work american express reward credit cards credit score range credit card approval ikea credit card application online usa prepaid international credit card visa american express platinum credit card travel insurance discover credit card in canada citibank credit card apply hdfc flight offer credit card money back credit cards uk natwest credit card customer services contact number us bank credit card standard chartered credit card malaysia chase mastercard credit card activation phone number hdfc credit card reviews india nedbank apply online for a credit card government of canada credit card regulations free credit card reader for ipad best credit cards to apply for with bad credit shell drive for five credit card login store credit cards with instant approval change mastercard securecode pay hdfc bank credit card bill online zurich credit card insurance reviews secured credit card reviews 2012 best credit cards for good credit scores american express corporate credit card india login hsbc credit card balance transfer offers instant virtual credit card online comparing credit cards canada online tracking of icici credit card status best rate credit cards 2013 application for credit card indian bank small personal loans with bad credit how to hack a credit card number visa 2012 nab credit card balance transfer offers can you get cashback on visa gift cards bank of ireland credit card insurance on purchases which credit card is easy to get approved in australia short term loans online ireland capital one prepaid credit card credit card consolidation loan calculator citibank credit card loan emi calculator credit card rate comparison australia credit card online validator 2.11 what is the best student credit card to get hsbc credit card online application malaysia best installment loans online cash payday loans fast credit card points
Home Maury Brown The Mock Salary Arbitration Case in Favor of Max Scherzer Seeking $7.4 million

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 669 guests online

Atom RSS

The Mock Salary Arbitration Case in Favor of Max Scherzer Seeking $7.4 million PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 27
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Saturday, 09 February 2013 12:58

On Thursday, I took part in a series of mock salary arbitration cases that are appearing on Baseball Prospectus. In the case, I covered the Tigers’ side if Max Scherzer had gone to hearing. It was a tough case to make. Scherzer certainly anchored the rotation behind Justin Verlander.

The process of doing mock hearings is so enjoyable that I decided to play both sides of the street. On Thursday it was a case for the Tigers. Today, it’s my case for Scherzer. -- Maury Brown

+++++   +++++   +++++

In the case of Max Scherzer seeking a one-year salary arbitration salary for 2013 with the Detroit Tigers, a strong case is made that the $7.4 million salary he is seeking is fair, not only in comparison to his peers within his service time class this year, but in the year prior.

Scherzer compiled the finest season of his career, posting a 16-7 record, 3.74 ERA and 231 strikeouts in 32 starts. He was the #2 starter on the roster behind only Justin Verlander. His achievements on the season show clearly why the salary he is seeking is warranted. Scherzer’s 2012 platform season display that he is not only one of the best pitchers on the Tigers’ staff, but in all baseball for his ability to gain strikeouts and his winning percentage places him at the top of his salary arbitration class for starting pitchers. His season accomplishments provide ample evidence.

  • He ranked second in all of Major League Baseball in strikeouts behind only Verlander (231)
  • Led the American League in stikeouts per 9 innings (1.08)
  • His winning percentage of .696 ranked ahead of teammate Verlander and fourth behind only CC Sabathia, Jered Weaver, and David Price in the American League,
  • Scherzer struck out nine-or-more batters in 13 of his starts during the season and topped all major league pitchers with 13 such outings. His 13 such games marked the most by a Tigers pitcher since Mickey Lolich posted 15 games with nine-or more strikeouts in 971.
  • Finished 4-0 with a 4.04 ERA (35.2IP/16ER) and 51 strikeouts in six starts during May -- according to the Elias Sports Bureau, it marked only the fourth time a Tigers pitcher posted an unbeaten record with at least four wins and 50 strikeouts during a calendar month, In doing so, he joined Jack Morris (August of 1983) and Justin Verlander (May of 2009 and June of 2011) in accomplishing the feat.
  • Scherzer led the American League with 51 strikeouts during May, while he tied for the lead with four wins.
  • He struck out at least eight batters in 10 consecutive starts July 19-September 7 which marked the longest such streak of outings by a Tigers pitcher since at least 1918.
  • Scherzer won five straight starts August 10-September 1, compiling a 1.03 ERA (35.0IP/4ER) and 44 strikeouts -- according to the Elias Sports Bureau, he became the first pitcher in Tigers history to win five straight starts while averaging more than one strikeout per inning and not allowing more than two runs during any of the starts.
  • He was the Tigers Pitcher of the Month for August after compiling a 4-0 record, 2.25 ERA (32.0IP/8ER) and 44 strikeouts in five starts during the month -- tied for the lead in the American League with four wins during August, while he tied for second with 44 strikeouts and was seventh with a 2.25 ERA.
  • Finished 2-1 with a 2.17 ERA (29.0IP/7ER) and 33 strikeouts in five starts during September
  • Limited righthanded hitters to a .201 batting average (66x329) while lefties batted .292 (113x387) with him on the mound
  • He received votes for AL Pitcher of the Month in August (4-0, 2.25 ERA, 9 BB, 44 SO) and in September (2-1, 2.17 ERA, 29.0 IP, 4 BB, 33 SO).

Compared to his peers in his service group, he is at the top of several statistical categories:


Platform

IP

G

GS

ERA

W

L

W PCT

H

Ks

Homer Bailey

2012

208

33

33

3.68

13

10

.565

206

168

Jason Hammel

2012

118

20

20

3.43

8

6

.571

104

113

Max Scherzer

2012

187.2

32

32

3.74

16

7

.696

179

231

 

In comparison to Jason Hammel of the Orioles: Scherzer is seeking a salary of $7.4 million compared to Hammel’s $8.25 million. And yet, Scherzer posts twice as many wins (16), and struck out a staggering 122 more batters faced.

Compared to Homer Bailey: he has a higher winning percentage, gave up 27 less hits, and struck out 68 more batters in 20.8 less innings pitched.

Scherzer’s salary of $7.4 million he is seeking is also warranted based on comparable players in the year prior with the same amount of service time.

 

Platform

IP

G

GS

ERA

W

L

W PCT

H

R

ER

HR

BB

Ks

Max Scherzer

2012

187.2

32

32

3.74

16

7

.696

179

82

78

23

60

231

Matt Garza

2011

198

31

31

3.32

10

10

.500

186

90

73

14

63

197

 

In 2011, Matt Garza of the Chicago Cubs was within the same Major League service time range as Scherzer is now (4 years). Garza had sought a salary of $12.5 million—a staggering $5.1 million more than what Scherzer is seeking. Ultimately, Garza and the Cubs reached a settlement of $9.5 million, still more than $2 million than what Scherzer is seeking. And yet, they are very closely matched statistically. While Scherzer gave up more home runs, he had less walks. When adjusting for the amount of innings pitched, the amount of hits, runs, and earned runs are within a very small margin. Scherzer’s winning percentage is 196 points higher than Garza, and yet he is seeking far less in pay.

Based upon the performance and pay of his peers, Max Scherzer clearly deserves the $7.4 million he is seeking. The $6.5 million that the Tigers are offering would be a disservice to a stellar 2012 season for the Tigers’ starter.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes. He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network (select his name in the dropdown provided).

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on TwitterTwitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?