best credit card travel rewards program instant no credit check payday loans uk bad credit credit cards instant approval no deposit delta miles credit card deals legal requirements for storing credit card information how long does it take to get credit card from chase visa card canada royal bank 0 credit card bad credit rating paypal accept credit cards fees best no fee transfer balance credit cards zero interest credit card calculator us bank credit card processing elavon credit card balance transfer comparison calculator visa cards numbers start with storing credit card information law canada sacramento payday loan cash advance online credit cards australia rbs credit card services southend uob credit card rewards redemption thailand home loan quotes online can you get cashback on a capital one credit card best credit card bad credit score quick credit card approval online payday loans with bad credit online credit card rewards uk activate td visa card number best credit card terminal rates uk wells fargo credit card services business how to accept credit card payments with paypal best credit cards 2013 for travel what credit card to get at 18 how to set up a small business to accept credit cards cibc credit card balance phone number prepaid credit cards for business use emirates platinum credit card credit cards cash back offers best bad credit card offers help with credit card debt canada best free credit card reader lord and taylor credit card sign in virgin credit card transfer fee credit card cash advance fee wells fargo applying for credit card with bad credit rating best canadian credit cards cash back credit card company payday cash advance reviews premier credit card processing apply credit cards horizon bank credit card login best low interest credit card balance transfer hsbc apply credit card online types of orchard bank credit cards best credit card to have in singapore compare the market credit cards purchases unsecured credit cards for poor credit 2012 national city credit card application jcpenney credit card pay my bill online credit card apply hdfc bank credit card no credit history no deposit credit card address verification phone number best first credit card for young adults with no credit best no fee credit card canada 2011 should i apply for paypal credit card what does your credit score need to be to get a best buy credit card top zero interest credit cards tesco bank credit card login best credit card merchant account service best secured credit cards for poor credit hsbc credit cards online bill pay direct online payday advance lenders payday online loan lenders compare credit card offers 2013 hsbc balance transfer offers existing customer virgin credit card 0 interest capital one secured credit card cash advance best unsecured credit card for bad credit rating bank of america credit card processing rates best credit card student uk apply for a credit card online with bad credit unfair credit card fees uk canadian tire cash back credit cards credit card comparison site australia barclays platinum card dubai secured credit cards after bankruptcy small online loans uk i need a credit card to help build my credit best cash rewards visa credit card marriott reward credit card promotion sbi international credit card application best mobile credit card processing canada best bonus offer credit card credit card payoff calculator dave ramsey hdfc credit card apply online in mumbai zero percent interest credit card offers bank of america credit card customer service uk free credit card machines for small business uk rak bank credit card payment machine best buy credit card app schnucks stores credit card fraud 2012 best mobile credit card processing hdfc credit card loan calculator best buy credit card no interest westpac visa credit card travel insurance credit cards no foreign transaction fees 2013 what are the best credit cards to earn points american express gold delta skymiles credit card login post bankruptcy credit cards offers template letter to credit card company does chase increase credit limit automatically payday lenders not brokers uk new credit card offers october 2013 best cashback credit card payday loans bad credit direct lender uk cimb islamic credit card application form credit card rewards comparison 2013 visa credit card fraud protection secured business credit cards without personal guarantee payday loan no credit check interest free credit cards on purchases and balance transfers prepaid virtual visa credit cards paypal vcc which credit card is best for international travel free credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date visa debit cards canada android credit card reader paypal how to pay off bad credit card debt random visa card security code ge money bank store credit card list balance transfer barclaycard best small business credit card reviews td emerald visa card benefits apply for credit cards online with no credit credit card cash advance without pin number what credit score do i need for a toys r us credit card hdfc credit card bank chennai can you use walmart prepaid credit card paypal prepaid credit card visa germany comparing credit cards rewards can you get cashback on a visa gift card best cashback credit card on the market amazon visa rewards card car rental insurance valid credit card information 2012 credit card processing software free chase credit card machine for iphone obama credit card debt relief act online payday loans no credit check canada credit cards with bad credit rating in australia toyota rewards visa credit card website best credit card deal online cash advances no credit check best buy reward zone credit card review best deals credit cards canada black pc mastercard best visa card for travel abroad capital one credit card app status rewards credit cards 2013 aaa credit cards bank of america login bank of america power rewards visa card best rewards credit card canada no annual fee how to get reward points in hdfc credit card no credit check loans ireland credit card business analyst linkedin halifax platinum credit card cash back credit card cash advance credit score halifax visa card issue number compare credit card apps for iphone reset verifone credit card machine rfid scanner credit card reader pay my first premier bank credit card bill free credit card no credit check usa credit card number sample eliminate credit card debt fast best 0 balance transfer credit card register online visa card what credit card company will accept me pay sbi credit card bill online icici credit card repayment calculator fnb american express credit card with no annual fee in india compare credit card offers uk best buy credit card payment credit card after bankruptcy discharge canada southwest airlines rapid rewards visa signature credit card low interest credit card with no balance transfer fee how do debit visa cards work permohonan credit card bank rakyat using credit card abroad barclays credit card eligibility in india can you apply for more than one capital one credit card customer care no for icici bank credit cards icici coral credit card movie offer best united airlines credit card halifax balance transfer to current account huge credit card fraud bust in new jersey credit cards with no credit check instant approval ambank credit card balance transfer promotion axis bank credit card reward points claim best buy household bank credit card chase marathon gas credit card icici credit card online payment billdesk shell credit card phone number td bank visa debit card rewards login lenders for home loans with bad credit how to use credit cards for your business best reward credit cards 2014 how does square credit card app work ed sheeran nandos black card neiman marcus credit cards accepted ntuc income credit card authorisation form how to negotiate with credit card companies to reduce debt uk credit card for bad credit no deposit instant approval prepaid credit card post office australia best airmiles credit card offers credit card offers with 0 balance transfer fees platinum credit card lloyds rewards credit card uk virgin atlantic credit card mbna login apply for bank of america student credit card difference between gold and platinum hdfc credit cards credit card machine for iphone cost hdfc credit card points claim nedbank apply online for a credit card credit card authorization form australian embassy vienna chase student visa credit card hsbc credit card cash advance malaysia british airways credit card offer chase mastercard business credit cards rewards business credit cards cash back no annual fee ge capital credit card application payday lenders uk bad credit easy credit card to get 2013 virgin mbna credit card minimum payment is chase credit card a visa credit card offer opt out website is it safe to apply for payday loans online td visa card balance protection insurance track sbi credit card status online non prepaid virtual credit card best credit card to build credit for the first time scotia bank secured credit cards canada credit cards with guaranteed approval for no credit ways of reducing credit card debt hdfc master credit card offers us airways mastercard free credit card machine for iphone uk credit card size go compare credit card balance transfers best secured credit card to build credit history virgin credit card ppi phone number bank of america credit card phone numbers santander 123 cashback credit card annual fee best credit cards for college students studying abroad best buy credit card payment chase hdfc platinum credit card reward points value discover credit card payment address ba master credit card trust ii what is the best credit card to have to build credit chase walt disney credit card 0 credit cards transfer natwest business credit cards online login find credit cards for bad credit scores barclays credit card payment number icici credit card helpline number hyderabad credit card to build credit rating american airlines credit card login page easy credit cards to get approved for ireland indusind bank credit cards offers credit card rates merchant accounts how to reduce credit card debt legally using personal credit card for business travel easy to get unsecured credit cards with poor credit kmart sears credit card virgin credit card australia sign in best credit card app for iphone uk kotak mahindra bank credit card apply online online hdfc credit card offers pay off credit card debt planner top 10 zero interest credit cards marriott rewards credit cards reviews how much does a credit card machine cost to rent bank of america student credit card application pay american airlines credit card online chase contractor visa business credit card capital one credit card limit increase pay hdfc credit card bill online without login apply for credit card 0 interest rate best credit cards canada no fee top bad credit loan companies free credit check target visa card activation what does referred mean on a credit card application bank of canada credit card debt what kind of credit card should i get if i have bad credit apr credit card calculator uk canada credit cards easy approval hsbc cash advance fee barclays us airways credit card application status compare cheap credit cards american express zync card credit score axis bank credit card application form download household bank credit card customer service number visa credit card number and cvv code no fee rewards credit cards canada barclays premier credit card insurance vanquis credit card payment plan procedure to pay advance tax online visa credit card company uk get a prepaid credit card today pentagon federal credit union credit cards canada post reloadable prepaid credit card bank of america prepaid debit cards visa credit card for international students singapore credit card balance transfer offers for life credit cards for bad credit no bank account needed best credit card to get in canada best visa credit card for business westpac credit card application form pdf payday loans cash advance for bad credit credit cards no transfer fee sbi credit card status number walmart credit card cash advance limit online loan calculator uae where can i compare credit card offers landlord credit check hsbc old orchard credit card low interest no fee credit card mbna trueline mastercard which credit card balance transfer virtual visa card wiki santander 0 balance transfer credit card how do i accept credit cards over the phone ontario credit card debt settlement virgin america credit card contact number visa credit cards start with what 4 numbers jcpenney credit card pay wells fargo secured credit card graduation payday loans for bad credit uk only credit cards 0 interest balance transfers and no fee best low fixed rate credit cards pay my orchard bank credit card bill online credit card offers 0 purchases guaranteed unsecured credit card approval canada travel credit cards best canada best buy rewards credit card credit card login buy prepaid credit card online sbi credit card customer care number in kolkata intuit portable credit card machine spending natwest credit card points what us credit card has chip and pin process credit card payments mobile discover or capital one student credit card what is a bad credit score 2013 flyertalk delta credit card offer easy to get credit cards with no credit history small business credit card machine portable singapore airlines credit card verification form cash out prepaid visa card visa card protection scheme credit card verification code location apply for student credit card bank of america reputable online loan companies guaranteed unsecured credit cards with bad credit how long does it take to get credit card approved citibank credit card balance transfer online sbi credit card online payment neft is capital one a good credit card for students credit card apply now online are visa gift cards credit or debit orchard bank credit card for bad credit apply walt disney world credit card benefits i have no credit which credit card should i get average credit limit on credit card 24 hour online instant cash loans south africa apply for a usa shopping club credit card corporate credit cards for employees with bad credit toys r us gold card coupons what is a cash advance on my credit card low rate credit card australia history of growth and development of credit card in india credit cards for bad credit no credit check canada are major credit cards accepted in mexico personal loans with bad credit score visa black credit card reviews unsecured credit cards fair credit instant approval discover credit card login payment best credit card deal canada business credit card comparison australia us bank flexperks credit card review pay standard chartered credit card bill online where to buy preloaded credit cards standard chartered online credit card payment pakistan credit card fraud bust nj td bank visa gift card balance cimb credit card travel promotion instant payday loan lenders malaysia credit card interest rate calculator merchant fees for credit cards comparison canada payday cash advance loans in georgia credit cards instant approval and use chevron visa credit card login post office mastercard prepaid us credit card issuers list wells fargo health advantage credit card payment student credit card no credit check virgin credit card interest free balance transfer chunky black cardigan where to buy facebook credits cards no foreign transaction fee credit card nz credit card payment protection apply for a credit card online with instant approval accept credit cards online free uk barclays credit card login page prepaid visa credit card walmart sbi bank credit card online application status best online payday loan companies sign up for credit card and get free flight best travel reward credit cards canada 2013 my next payday advance discover card credit score tracker tesco credit card minimum payment calculator track sbi credit card application status travel pass and credit card holder reward credit cards with no annual fee who has the best cash rewards credit card sampath credit card offers 2013 credit card fraud for dummies watch online accept credit card payments mobile small business reduce credit card fees average household credit card debt in america sbi online credit card activation td canada trust credit card customer service number vanilla prepaid visa card canada balance instant approval unsecured credit cards for poor credit walmart credit card cash back rewards best deals on credit card balance transfers cash advance payday loans chicago il intuit mobile phone credit card processing best credit cards uk 2013 low credit card rates canada how do credit card swipe machines work hdfc gold credit card reward points redemption catalogue how old do you have to be to get a credit card in ontario canada apply for a sears mastercard online sears application for credit card credit cards with low interest rates for college students best credit cards to rebuild credit after bankruptcy the best credit card to have yahoo answers how to hack a credit card number visa 2012 credit card terminal till rolls hsbc credit card machine rolls tesco credit card login payday loan direct lender only citibank credit card insurance travel can i cash out a walmart visa gift card do i get credit checked for a company credit card credit card 0 balance transfer hdfc corporate credit card review credit card helpline number icici bank best american airlines credit card deals free prepaid credit card numbers visa prepaid credit card online average merchant credit card transaction fees how does a cibc visa debit card work td canada trust visa debit verified by visa what is cash advance rate on credit cards best merchant credit card processing companies anz credit card travel promotion best credit cards canada cash back best australian credit card to use in usa how to apply visa credit card in the philippines intuit credit card machine for iphone lord and taylor credit card pay by phone chase credit card with disney rewards balance transfer natwest best way to use a credit card to build your credit capital one credit card uk sign in royal bank of scotland india credit cards apply discover credit card payment center address list of visa credit cards numbers easiest store credit card to get approved for with bad credit average household credit card debt in canada secured credit cards canada scotiabank best american express cash back cards is credit card protection insurance necessary new credit card charges free real visa credit card numbers can i buy visa gift cards with a walmart credit card compare credit card interest rates uk capital credit card services chelsea al sears mastercard solutions credit card login chase credit card fraud call horizon gold credit card complaints online payday loan lender how to apply for a credit card online with no credit how to use a credit card machine without a phone line american airlines credit card offer 2011 credit card machines for small business with bad credit contact help directory financial services credit card companies visa limitation of online credit card payment system applying for credit card online vs phone travel rewards cards compared current best credit card offers credit card abroad hsbc
Home Maury Brown The BBWAA, Bryant Gumbel, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, and the Hall of Fame

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 546 guests online

Atom RSS

The BBWAA, Bryant Gumbel, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, and the Hall of Fame PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 12
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 17 July 2012 17:23

Maury BrownWondering when would be a good time to write this column, it seems that opportunity has finally landed in my lap. The issue is the Hall of Fame, and the inclusion process, namely as it pertains to those players in the “Steroid Era.”

Grappling with the subject really means an examination of the Hall of Fame, the players in the Steroid Era, and those in the voting process, many of whom are part of the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA).

As is often the case when one goes about selecting anything for inclusion into a group, the more defined you set the criteria, the easier it is to place items into one bucket or the other. When it comes to players in baseball, the use of statistics is often the measure of defining greatness.

But, it isn’t the “Hall of Greatness” it’s the “Hall of Fame” and with it, the criteria for inclusion has become muddied. Throw in that there are players that have been out-and-out proven to use performance-enhancing drugs, or worse, suspected of using, and the waters are as clear as split-pea soup on who should, or should not, get votes.

Into the fray, people like myself weigh in, but others as well. Such will be the case when Bryant Gumbel has his closing remarks on HBO’s Real Sports with Bryant Gumbel (10pm ET/PT). Bryant will close with the following:

“Finally tonight comes word that Reggie Jackson has wisely decided to pass on this weekend’s induction ceremonies at Cooperstown. You may have seen that Jackson recently caused a stir by suggesting that a variety of baseball notables didn’t merit inclusion in the Hall of Fame. Now, because his judgment was personal and his timing terrible, Reggie has since retreated from his stated views. But here’s hoping that the gist of what he said isn’t altogether lost on the Hall’s voters.

You see Reggie was basically right in contending that the hall should be special and its doors should not be opened just because someone stuck around long enough to collect 3,000 hits or 300 wins. Yes, the numbers are proof of some very good players. But as the former star pitcher Jim Kaat has often noted so astutely, Cooperstown’s supposed to be a Hall of Fame – not a hall of achievement.

If the voters are really so obsessed with honoring guys with the numbers, they’d be wise to start rethinking the exclusion of those megastars linked to steroids, and do it quickly. Because the next Cooperstown ballot will, for the first time, include among others, both the seven-time MVP Barry Bonds and the seven-time Cy Young winner Roger Clemens. And while both men have a suspect past, it’s going to be hard to argue they don’t deserve a bust in Cooperstown. After all, a hall of fame that somehow excludes the game’s homerun king and its most honored pitcher and its all-time hits leader, would really be making a mockery of itself.”

The debate about whether a player is worthy of inclusion means you have to understand the mind of the voters, and with that, you get wildly divergent opinions, often passionately so. Many of the writers I’ve spoken with have held fast to the position that they will not vote for a player that fits Barry Bonds or Roger Clemens for the Hall of Fame, falling into two camps: “never” and “not on the first ballot.”

It’s here where there’s some wiggle room. It’s here that I side with the non-voters of the latter ilk. No, I do not have a vote, but if the good graces ever fall upon me, it seems more than reasonable to make a statement on the issues of performance-enhancing drugs and its effects on the statistics by which we should measure “greatness” by saying a voter deserves the right to consider a player such as Bonds or Clemens for the Hall of Fame, but it won’t be on the first ballot.” You’re not saying you won’t vote for him; just not now.

Finally, the larger question surrounds the fact that it is the Hall of “Fame” and therefore, you’re talking about something subjective. Bonds and Clemens certainly meet the “fame” criteria. Whether their greatness was fueled in part by better- performance-through-chemistry, is ultimately a question that can’t definitively be answered.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes.He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network (select his name in the dropdown provided).

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on TwitterTwitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?