avodart side effects dutasteride dosage doxycycline monohydrate 100mg side effects viagra sales canada taiwan stromectol buy prednisolone eye drops after cataract surgery viagra extreme eprex liturgia de las horas para apcalis jelly review how to use praziquantel for fishpredisoneprednazoneprednisolone side effects of himcocid nautisol 5mg melatonin rhinathiol promethazine drugs from canafa orlistat price in pakistan benemid medication information canadian pharmacy 24 hr motrin 800 mg side effects viagra quanto si prende prima buy metronidazole therapy 2000 speech therapy motrin 800mg tablets cialis general rx erythromycin quick delivery uk cialis 100 mgs of clomid 145 cials brand estrace cream treatment doctor erlamycetin tetes mata doctor prescribed erectile disfunctons leukeran for dogs with lymphoma slimex diet pill reviews synthroid buy online no prescription can you buy misoprostol over the counter advair side effects dose advair diskus cost of nexium in canada kosovarja chatham finpecia from india online 2 5 mgnonprescription tadalafil plavix coupons for walmart depakote and weight gain medication astelin nasal spray dosage moduretic amiloride and hydrochlorothiazide rizatriptan 10 mg price lotrel side effects doctor us based online pharmacy for zofran dapoxetine on line order alli phexin 500mg to grams ceials shipped from canada amerimedrx reviews on vigrx seksi kosovarja eutirox 25mg tadalafil 5mg tablets buy ditropan tablets albendazole for humans price get viagara next day buy shop viagra professional www online pharmacy feldene without a prescription clavupen 100mg benadryl topamax medication where to buy albenza berifen 50 mg thyroxine binding globulin high 100mg viagra phentermine 37.5 mg results procalisx reviews on fifty viagra seller reviews metformin 500mg tablets caffeine and pregnancy effects plavix manufacturer coupons shelf life of neurontin eprex injection administration cpt 2 5 mg cialis generic indikasi misoprostol rocket power wikirogainrogaine canadian pharmacy 24 hours coumadin and alcohol dose cheapest viagra anywhere anxiety disorder test treatment for pain of uti buy shampoo online viagra generic ireland prtonix brand without a prescription zantac 150 dosage directions ativan dosage dose canada pharmacy 24 h medameds rapidshare filemedazole aleve dosages for adults actos medication manufacturer minoxidil topical solution usp 2 buy doxycycline 100mg online prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension usp eye drops pilex from himalaya cytoxan infusion therapy chinese viagra herbal uk rizatriptan side effects unisom sleep aid side effects ivermectin for sale from great britain cialis over the counter latisse online sales provera to start period trazodone dosage for dogs retino ac gel uses trileptal 300mg novartistrimetabol cheap viagra master card payment acticin cream cheap drug dalacin antibiotics salzarex tramadol capsules 100mg vigrande nediraj valtrex for cold sores in nose combivent samples antivert medicine for vertigoanxiety beconase aq nasal spray sildenafil 10 mg buy fentanyl uk asthma symptoms in adults with cold sweat feet and hands viagra samples online seroquel for sleep dosage ipharmacy android appsirbesartan canadian health care mall reviews cialis 5 mg online pharmacy 200 mg viagra sale starcef cefixime drug best viagra deals metformin no rx vitamin d and weight loss prevacid solutab 15mg florinef dosage for orthostatic hypotension erexin capsules yohimbe root primatene mist release date haloperidol side effects diabetes dianabol cycles d bol differin cream no prescription online indian pharmacy no prescription lipitor side effects muscle pain statin drugs cialis super activ levitra paypal zithromax for sinus infection for sale clomiphene citrate side effects in men vigrande 100mg clomid trazodone overdose side effects ambien addiction zyrtec side effects depression increasing testosterone cialis online pharmacy how to order amlodipine on line puretone hearing aids 03743 silagra uk citrate test e coli klebsiella insulin side effects diabetes kamagra reviews uk robaxin 750 mg recreational milanuncios escopetas buy lasix overnight no rx pulmicort side effects in toddlers consultation online viagra periactin weight gain forum anxiety medication list buspirone purchase albuterol without prescription tylenol 3 codeine high epanutin treatment for shingles cheap propecia new zealand bactrim cheap online trazodone netherlands buylowdrugs coupon code levothroid side effects cymbalta withdrawal symptoms insomnia evista 60 mg side effects canadian livitra belize city pharmacy hydroxyzine pamoate kamagra dosage instructions order diflucan online dianabol for sale cheap glipizide side effects weight gain pharmacy customer care cialis dicyclomine 10mg cap lannett spiriva information if swallowed stieva a cream for wrinkles vpxl pills biaxin xl pac omeprazole 20 mg treatment patients espanol cafergot without a prescription doxycycline 100mg capsules treat ketoconazole sebaceous hyperplasia diamox sequels acetazolamide order medicine overnight paypal canadian pharmacy buy accutane from legal chemist buying wellbutrin from mexico healthy man viagra review gold viagra from china amlodipine besylate 10mg drug zoloft for anxiety disorder augmentin 625 duo indomethacin dosage for headaches nz prescriptions online trimetabol syrup denver supradol sublingual thyroxine side effects in women metoprolol side effects mayo clinic effexor xr without rx omifin embarazo de gemelos semana doxycap tablets with windows phexin capsule machine trimetabol ingredients in benadryl ativan withdrawal symptoms benzodiazepine cialis tadacip wirkung valtrex india betacin 25mg ephedrine clonidine side effects medication doxycycline for animals in canada amermycin capsule hotel cialis prodaja achat vrai viagra buy albenza kamagra in the united states kamagrashop nld piroxicam medication doctor flagyl syrup dosage for children singapore accutane online healthy man viagra $99 hamilton opiate scene viagera where can i purchas in canada cardizem cd medication liquid anastrozole 1 mg for men cytotec venta online usa elavil information for sleep potassium chloride side effects medication buy branded levitra buy with paypal pharmacy europe rx augmentin 875 mg no prescription picareta em ingleside buy nolvadex online express mail the best cialis clone allpills complaints definition metrodinazole for birds amoxicilina y viagra bupropion weight loss treatment increasing sperm count with diet cefabiot 500mg equals bactroban cream cost tretinoin 05 online buy arimidex 1 mg mestinon 60 mg treatment meclizine over the counter walgreens levamisole side effects cocaine aggrenox medication aspirin liquidex dosage on cycle support buy viagra online in ca usa depakote medication wikipedia cialis super active canada hydrodiuril manufacturer coupon fucidin intertulle 10cm x 10cm xeloda chemo pills side effects how to buy furosemide cytoxan chemotherapy for scleroderma aspirin for dogs with hip pain best viagra pill cialis online with paypal zyvox 600 mg walmart pharmacy cialis 20mg healthy man viagra radio cymbalta and weight gain cymbalta for anxiety altace ramipril coupons buy indomethacin uk erectalis tadalafil cialis buy mil generic cialis from india cockapoo puppies for sale in ohio best price 5mg cialis prevacid side effects rythmol propafenone extended release levitra 40 mg pills neurontin gabapentin for anxiety bystolic 10 mg for sale online can you get high off of etodolac 400 mg unisom and pregnancy category blycolin groepsreizen protonix medication over the counter pharmacy cheapest hydrodiuril drug classification flonase vs nasacort aq nasal spray suprax online without prescription buying viagra and ciallis suhagra india ltd viagra next day shipping edrugstore md promo codes misoprostol en colombia manfaat doxycycline drugstore foundation for dry skin costco travel pheromones perfume for women tesco pharmacy viagra motilium tablets side effects tabletten oynanan oyunlar1 web store viagra lipothin injections to lose weight buy paxil online from usa cialis coupons for walgreens norstan electronics cyclivex 200mg tramadol content analysis research method zithmmax 1gram pharmacy product lisinopril tabs levoxyl recall 2015 corvette clomid dosage for men pravastatin pravachol and grapefruit cipro antibiotics side effects lotrel medication and grapefruit mebendazole vermox side effects problems with generic plavix estradiol blood test for men zyrtec dosage chart by weight zyrtec for children dosage levitra vs cialis comparison prednisone glaucoma cats cheap non generic cialis coumadin blood thinner readings glucotrol xl 10 mg viagra ganstig kaufen octreotide drip treatment canada pharmacy without prescription generic viagra accept paypal 215 acyclovir no script canada seroquel overnight rhinathiol expectorant cough suppressant zyvox side effects what is eprostol used for buy cialis best review viagra canada price pregnant halloween costumes youtube tadacip 20 side effects costco hours of operation gas station rimadyl for dogs medication feldene flash indications saint martin garrigue wine myambutol medicine man bactrim ds online ordering seroxat 20mg prospect doxinyl medication identification zentel prospect jasmine waltz david arquette viagra free pills flexeril generic provigil coupon 2014 folcres finasteride generic nuvigil coupon 2014 proviron side effects in women buying lipitor without a script cealis 5mg doxycycline 100 mg good price pharmacy off brand sildenafil citrate cheap cialis farmacia viagra 100 canada cuepons ezetimibe simvastatin 10 40 requip drug interactions biaxin xl 500mg doxinyl succinate definition buy valtrex online cheap clavamox dogs treatment drops curacne burning rash kamagra without prescription fast delivery of accutane buy uk stratera order online buylowdrugs review canada pharmacy pay with paypal does 10 mg levitra last aldactone side effects medication claritin reditabs side effects how much does a trusted tablets online xatral 10 mg tablet antivert for vertigo clozaril protocols indian pharmacy paypal revatio generic salbutamol nebulizer medication drug study viagra price australia viagra no prescrip canada liposafe ingredients in nyquil india no prescription pharmacy warfarin coumadin and cranberries naproxen sodium side effects alcohol buy amoxil england captopril 50 mg what is it for casodex 50 mg bicalutamide smart rx online acnelyse ingredients in marshmallows pharmacy that accepts american express acyclovir 800mg medication for sale hoodia gordonii plus aleve dosage noroxin 400mg tablets no prescription prednisone fosamax side effects jaw about vigora 100 in hindi prilosec otc dosage enalapril side effects in canines etodolac side effects medications regenon 25mg ephedrine donepezil 10 mg side effects zovirax ointment medication requip medication dosage order robaxin on line dosage for clavamox for humans viagra rezeptfrei aus deutschland macrobid antibiotic toradol im injection side effects reglan lawsuit information bactroban mupirocin ointment for dogs nolvadex cycle for men estrofem effects on men buying 750 mg flagyl er online roxifen gelsons tenormin side effects rash levitra uk online pharmacy viagra diltiazem er 120 mg capsule secure canadian online pharmacy amerimedrx fake id cheapest sildalis 120 mg to g amantidine online paxil cost without insurance viagra cyprus how to use viagra spray aldara medication viagra us distributer paxil side effects antidepressants lipvas tablets sale vermox low cost namibia university canada drugs no perscripition organique acai berry price philippines naprosyn medication over the counter buy metformin online anti biotic drugs without prescriptions probepackung viagra levitra buy amitriptylin with no prescription camelox 15 canadain meds cephalexin 250 mg from canada permethrin spray insecticide for bed bugs diflucan pill clozapine monitoring metformin 500mg side effects alcohol erectalis tadalafil 5mg serta icomfort insight mattress linezolid antibiotics treatment soft tabs vs hard tabs cialis supreme suppliers viagra strengths dosages letrozole 2.5 mg tablet misoprostol vaginally for hysteroscopy zetia coupons free printable zetia coupons sunrise tadarise 20 mg best price buy cheap frumil oxybutynin side effects in children flagyl generic form paxil withdrawal can cause ocd trental medication for stroke furolin medicine cabinet amiloride diuretics definition clavamox for cats from canada cialis viagr canada polar meds cialis shivam arcoxia 90mg em portugues buy novolog insulin online metformin side effects experienced took medication actos warning patients liquidex dosage on cycle reviews arimidex bodybuilding women are there evista coupons side effects of kamagra substitute for albuterol for sale imagenes de futbol femenino con frases doxepin for sleep reviews duvadilan indications vasodilatation billig viagra finpecia free shipping luvox and weight gain side effects clavupen 100mg to g long term effects of gabapentin gold vigra clavupen 100mg clomid fincar 5mg nuvigil treatment 36 hour cialis lamictal side effects medication pay pal pharmacy styplon tablets with windows permethrin cream long term side effects benicar hct side effects lawsuit diovan overnight best life rx doxepin for dogs treatment seroquel for sleeping disorders zoloft and pregnancy studies buy tadalafil 20mg price
Home All Articles The Matsuzaka Dilemma

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 758 guests online

Atom RSS

The Matsuzaka Dilemma PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 0
Articles & Opinion
Written by John Thorn   
Tuesday, 12 December 2006 08:15


John Thorn is a contributing writer for The Biz of Baseball 

From "Play's the Thing," Woodstock Times: 

This whole swirl may be over by the time you read this, but the meaning is the same, no matter how it comes out, and so is the moral. I’m talking about the sequence in which the Boston Red Sox were revealed to have outbid other baseball clubs for the thirty-day negotiating rights to “posted” Seibu Lion pitcher Daisuke Matsuzaka, who wishes to pitch in the United States but is not, under Nippon Professional Baseball (NPB) regulations, eligible for free agency until 2008. This Thursday night at midnight, when December 14 becomes December 15, is the witching hour.

As I write, Boston Red Sox executives have just landed the owner’s plane on the West Coast to plant themselves on agent Scott Boras’s doorstep. His Japanese client is mum on the seeming breakdown in negotiations, but as he has not fired his representative one may deduce that he is in on the game. It is a game designed by Major League Baseball (MLB) and the NPB, but as they seem only dimly to have understood their own rules, D-Mat and his designated hitter have made their own—or rather, as we shall see, correctly fathomed the implicit rule structure of the posting system. Bottom line: no matter how this shakes out, while D-Mat is not exactly the reincarnation of Curt Flood, Scott Boras has taken the mantle of Marvin Miller, and is my new hero. 

Yesterday I had lunch at the local Chinese restaurant where, despite my better judgment, I ate my customary sacramental portion of the stale fortune cookie and read its message. “It is better to have a hen tomorrow than an egg today” was the word from on high. Wait, I thought; this reverses the more commonly expressed wisdom that not only is an egg today better than a hen tomorrow, but also its avian corrolary about birds in hand and those in the bush. I wondered: might Boras have received the same, seemingly counterintuitive message?

Let’s back up for a moment and see how we got here. In the system by which a player is to be posted, both the team and player must agree on the posting. The team then notifies the NPB Commissioner’s Office that the player will be posted, which then notifies MLB, which notifies all of its teams. The MLB teams then have four days to submit a closed bid for the right to negotiate a contract with the player. If the high bid is accepted by the NPB team holding the player’s rights, the winning MLB team has thirty days to reach an agreement with the player. If the bid is rejected, the player is not “posted.” If the player signs a contract with the MLB team by the end of the signing period, then the NPB team receives the bid money. If the player does not sign a contract with the MLB team by the end of the signing period, the player is returned to the NPB team and the NPB team receives nothing.

Whoever designed this may have had in mind that classic scenario of game theory called the “Prisoner’s Dilemma.” It is a mathematical and psychological game illustrating how rational actions by individuals may not always lead to positive outcomes for either the individuals or the group. The Prisoner’s Dilemma is described neatly in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:

“Tanya and Cinque have been arrested for robbing the Hibernia Savings Bank and placed in separate isolation cells. Both care much more about their personal freedom than about the welfare of their accomplice. A clever prosecutor makes the following offer to each. ‘You may choose to confess or remain silent. If you confess and your accomplice remains silent I will drop all charges against you and use your testimony to ensure that your accomplice does serious time. Likewise, if your accomplice confesses while you remain silent, they will go free while you do the time. If you both confess I get two convictions, but I’ll see to it that you both get early parole. If you both remain silent, I’ll have to settle for token sentences on firearms possession charges. If you wish to confess, you must leave a note with the jailer before my return tomorrow morning.’

“The ‘dilemma’ faced by the prisoners here is that, whatever the other does, each is better off confessing than remaining silent. But the outcome obtained when both confess is worse for each than the outcome they would have obtained had both remained silent. A common view is that the puzzle illustrates a conflict between individual and group rationality. A group whose members pursue rational self-interest may all end up worse off than a group whose members act contrary to rational self-interest. More generally, if the payoffs are not assumed to represent self-interest, a group whose members rationally pursue any goals may all meet less success than if they had not rationally pursued their goals individually. Puzzles with this structure were devised and discussed by Merrill Flood and Melvin Dresher in 1950, as part of the Rand Corporation’s investigations into game theory (which Rand pursued because of possible applications to global nuclear strategy).” 

So, the underlying scheme of Prisoner’s Dilemma is to have the two prisoners collaborate wittingly or unwittingly against their own interest, with the outcome weighted to benefit the sate as represented by the police and prosecutor. The dilemma resides in the fact that each prisoner has a choice between only two options, but cannot make a good decision without knowing what the other one will do.

I suggest that the posting system was created along these lines to benefit the “state”—each league and each team involved. Think of MLB and Boston as the police and prosecutor in the above scenario, knowing that the salutary actions of Prisoner A (NPB and Seibu) and Prisoner B (Matsuzaka and Boras) are necessary to prevent the mutually assured destruction (M.A.D.) of MLB. That was the prospect some owners envisioned in 1973-74, at the dawn of free agency: that in an auction scenario, dollars would pursue scarce/unique assets in an irrationally exuberant way that would effectively transfer control of the game into the players’ hands. Marvin Miller cleverly assuaged the owners’ fears while assuring high prices for his players’ union by restricting free agency to those with six years’ service in the major leagues; had he opted for universal free agency, as he might have, the flood of talent onto the market each year would have depressed salaries. 

The design problem in the Prisoner’s Dilemma game above is that Prisoner Seibu has its deal in hand and is (ostensibly) denied the option of contributing some of its $51.1 million posting fee from Boston toward Prisoner Matsuzaka’s new contract. Indeed, without flexibility the fortunes of Seibu/NPB are more closely tied to the Police/Prosecutor than to Matsuzaka despite the pitcher’s total control over Seibu’s posting windfall. Boston, which stands ready to pay the sum and call it a bargain, instead feels aggrieved because its $51.1 million in expense is counted as nothing by Boras, who is looking to obtain $100 million for a six-year contract, pretty much in line with what his client would fetch in an unrestricted market. Boston had intended to pay out $100 million, all right, but had figured that Boras would give the club credit for half of that for “liberating” his client. No such luck, nor should there have been.

The posting system entices Boston (and other bidding clubs) with the lure of paying for a free agent in a tangential way that would not increase its exposure to luxury tax. The Red Sox are further compensated by considering the payment to Seibu as an inexpensive licensing or entry fee to market their brand vigorously in Japan. Additionally, the exclusivity that came with their winning bid permitted them not only to pursue Matsuzaka, but also to defend against the Yankees landing him. 

With its $51.1 million sugarplum, Seibu thought it was being rewarded for having nurtured Matsuzaka’s talent to the point that he was one of the top five pitchers in the world, and for graciously letting him go to America two years before NPB regulations would otherwise allow. In fact Seibu was also being pulled out of a very considerable financial hole, as the posting fee hits up on their bottom line as pure net income ... plus they gain at least $12 million in the amount they would otherwise have had to pay Matsuzaka for 2007 and 2008, the last years of his contract with the Lions.

MLB/Boston is in effect attempting to coerce a “confession” from Prisoner Matsuzaka because he risks embarrassment by returning to pitch for Seibu after 36,000 fans bade him farewell at the Lions’ Stadium, and because Seibu doesn’t want him back at the forfeiture of $63 million it is already counting on. 

What did MLB and the 29 teams not in the running for D-Mat’s services gain by the posting system? A presumptive lid on D-Mat’s demands and their escalating effect on pitcher salaries, already heightened by the ineffectual Adam Eaton and the awful Justin Marquis, each of whom received multiyear contracts at about $8 million per. With Matsuzaka wearing carmine hose, MLB will gain a new hero to promote its brand in Japan as well as the USA, just as Ichiro proved a marketing windfall. In fact this posting system is a nostalgic throwback, recreating for owners a glimpse of the paradise they enjoyed prior to free agency, when they owned the market and could say “take it or leave it” to the players. While the posting system may have been born of a genuine wish to protect Japanese baseball and avoid the appearance of American cultural imperialism, it has played out as an exercise in “Who will rule.”

As Boras has evidently surmised, even though MLB and NPB thought they had boxed in Prisoner Matsuzaka, it turned out that he and his client were not locked in behind iron bars but instead, like Br’er Rabbit, had been thrown into a briar patch from which they could easily escape. Boras has recognized that while the game is structured like Prisoner’s Dilemma, counting upon Seibu and his client to act independently in their perceived self-interest to the benefit of Organized Baseball, there is in fact only one prisoner, and without his yielding, there is no palatable outcome. 

If MLB and NPB had a game theory for how this would play itself out, it was the wrong one ... styled as Prisoner’s Dilemma but quickly revealing itself to be the “Dollar Auction,” another, even more vicious game, in which each of two contestants seeks to overpay for an asset in order to avoid being the second-place bidder whose money will have been utterly wasted.

In the Dollar Auction someone offers to sell a dollar bill to the highest bidder. The highest bidder will get the dollar, but the second-highest must also pay what he bid yet get nothing in return. Think here of “throwing good money after bad,” of “saving face,” of “having too much invested to cut and run,” of “staying the course.” If you can buy a dollar for a dime, this looks like a good deal. Even as the bidding rises in ten-cent increments to the 50-cent level, it still seems a bargain. At the 70-cent level, one may expect that all but two bidders will have fallen off the chase. When the dollar-mark is reached, the underbidder, rather than accepting defeat, will tend to bid ten cents more so as not to lose 90 cents. 

“People escalate their commitment both to justify their earlier bids and to prevent the financial and ego loss of coming in second,” Max H. Bazerman wrote in Psychology Today twenty years ago. “No specific bid is clearly wrong, since it is rational to bid ‘just another 10 cents,’ if the other party is about to quit bidding. But when both parties think this way, an escalatory spiral emerges that is very reminiscent of the Vietnam War and other international and industrial failures in which both competitors get trapped by their previous commitments.”

At first blush the winner in the Matsuzaka Dilemma appeared to be Boston; if the Mets were second, at $13 million less, they felt no ill consequence of their bid. Had the posting system had been a true Dollar Auction, with succesive rounds of bidding,  rather than a veiled Prisoner’s Dilemma with closed bids, the price for D-Mat might have gone much higher, as the underbidder would have been highly motivated to stay in the game. But now Boston’s inadvertent partner has been revealed not to be MLB but Seibu, which unlike Boston—which will retain the defensive benefit of its bid—will lose everything, as if it had been the underbidder in a Dollar Auction. And Br’er Boras and D-Mat, if they do not prevail this year, can play again only with more bargaining clout. 



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?