interest free credit cards bad credit rating secured credit cards pnc bank bank america worldpoints visa signature credit card apply for a credit card for bad credit online air miles credit card no annual fee international credit card fees class action orchard bank gold credit card reviews consolidating credit card debt cibc credit card zero interest offers pay hdfc credit card bill online through billdesk spirit airlines credit card free flights how do i pay my walmart credit card bill online advantages and disadvantages of credit cards and debit cards gap credit card paperless statements pay metrostyle credit card online how to consolidate credit card debt canada circuit city credit card pay get business credit card new business canadian credit cards with lowest interest rates shell gas rebate credit cards how to get a credit card company to reduce your interest rate report lost credit card mastercard how to apply credit cards chase student credit card limit credit card encryption+drupal secured credit cards for bad credit with no deposit card credit debt negotiation settlement accept credit cards paypal mobile credit card machine companies helzberg diamond credit card order a credit card with visa how to dispute a credit card chargeback get chase credit card bad credit credit india plastic card embossing machine credit card interest rate calculation formula goodyear credit cards online list visa credit cards numbers best credit card for medical expenses paying credit card late response letter summons credit card debt nab internet credit card payment can you use an american credit card in europe orchard credit card login what is my credit card number square iphone credit card canada best australian prepaid credit card credit card transfers zero percent credit cards no balance transfer fees best credit card with airline miles surcharge on credit card transactions which is the cheapest credit card to use abroad pay citibank credit card uae low credit card rates good credit best corporate credit card canada credit card issuers airline miles credit card for bad credit figure monthly payment credit card first premier bank credit card processing fee why do people get multiple credit cards no credit credit cards students visa use credit card through paypal can unused credit cards hurt your credit score apply for the children;s place credit card free credit card number and security code credit cards with 0 percent interest on transfers halifax credit card balance transfer to bank account sears solutions credit card application target credit card login page credit card sitex 2011 united airline credit card 50000 case-mate id credit card case for blackberry 9700 credit card air france miles natwest student credit card contact number does wachovia offer secured credit card standard chartered credit card online payment other bank discover student card average credit limit free dating no credit cards bt credit card review credit card manufacturers canada credit card default consequences california $100 free dating site no credit card first national bank credit card login amazon credit card foreign transaction fees amex centurion credit black card bank of america cancel credit card transaction hsbc credit card points redemption uk credit card special offers benefits do credit cards offer merchants best credit cards cash rebate credit card debt relief government help get new credit card sbi fortunoff credit card account charges for using halifax credit card abroad best credit card purchases samuels diamond elite credit card new acm wallet credit card holder & money clip hybrid commonwealth low rate credit card limit wamu credit card agreement can you pay credit cards online credit card with high limits applications credit card payments applied highest interest apple credit card reader uk quickbooks credit card processing reviews singapore airline letter indemnity credit card use prepaid credit card online poker universal 1 credit union card services credit cards with 0 interest for 12 months on purchases wyndham rewards visa credit card login credit cards to build credit score neiman marcus credit card pay by phone visa airline rewards credit cards transfer balance credit card 0 interest ge money credit card uk credit card starting with 4999 government credit card citi exxon mobil credit card pay on line alaska airline credit card canada itunes wont accept my credit card security number credit cards bankruptcy no annual fee free credit cards information wireless credit card terminal first data instant credit card approval canada bad credit visa disposable credit card number can jc penney credit cards used american express credit card pay online india first premier bank credit card activation phone number credit card number generator with cvv and expiration date when do you have to pay off credit card credit card numbers and security codes that work 2013 best credit cards for fair credit credit cards for people with bad credit trying to rebuild credit how much cash can i withdraw from my credit card citi.com credit card login can you pay chase credit card payment chase bank highest rated credit cards rewards activate your rbs credit card apply sears credit card login credit card payments through google stimulus help for credit card debt credit card judgement in pa visa credit card dispute resolution how do i pay federal taxes with credit card magnetic money clip credit card rbs credit card payment uae exchange credit card services rbs phone number hsbc online credit card application philippines can you use sears credit card at sears outlet credit card collection defense free background check no credit card required tractor supply credit card online update credit card information playstation network first premier centennial classic credit card archangel usb 2.0 usb credit card flash drive credit card amazon points where can i get a prepaid visa credit card credit card processors online business mastercard credit cards for people with bad credit credit one card payment make barnes and noble credit card scam how to get a credit card with frequent flyer miles bank america stop sending credit card checks how do you pay off amazon credit card why do we have high interest rates on credit cards airport lounge access credit card paying off credit cards with credit cards secured credit card canada td vending machine credit card acceptance mobile credit card terminal recurring credit card authorization form doc how hard is it to get a walmart credit card best credit card foreign exchange fees credit card cloning machine buy car with credit card points can change my credit card info itunes sears credit card online pay bill iphone terminal credit card credit card interest payment calculators consolidate credit card debt into loan where to apply for a credit card credit cards best rewards consumer reports credit card lawyers ny british airways visa signature card credit score picture of credit card statement credit card deposit to bank account can you pay for my western union money transfer with a credit card how to pay new york and company credit card online hsbc credit card services barclay apple credit card login balance transfer credit cards fair credit hsbc credit card benefits malaysia sears credit card balance canada american express delta platinum credit card best credit card app for ipad answer credit card summons template citibank credit card india online application cell phone can swipe credit card hhonors credit card diamond conoco credit card customer service 76 credit card payment credit card payoff time formula best credit cards no foreign fees air mile reward credit cards prepaid credit card visa usa southwest credit card free flight round trip how do i get a free credit report without using a credit card home pc credit card reader cannot use credit card with paypal when did people first start using credit cards difference between visa debit credit card sbi hero honda credit card number activate chase freedom credit card cell phone credit card debt collection agency dining credit card promotions singapore gm credit card payment address better use credit card debit card online best elite credit card credit card payment processing time who has the best credit card deals claim money back my credit card there any government programs help credit card debt javascript credit card validation jquery there government program credit card debt relief prepaid credit card for business clear choice credit card processing sbi credit card online payment through net banking can you pay your irs bill with a credit card pay capital one credit card bill by phone florida banks that offer secured credit cards bank of america credit card for students safe credit union secured credit card credit card act section 75 stealing credit card information wirelessly apply for a bank of america visa credit card summit credit card log interest free credit card transfers ireland canadian travel reward credit card comparison pay irs credit card check hdfc credit cards reward points gifts 76 gasoline credit card activate bofa credit card aaa credit card gas discount no security deposit credit card accepting credit card payments through iphone best credit cards uk 2011 credit card balance transfer rates slate from chase can college students get credit cards commerce bank credit card customer service number is target credit card easy to get best credit cards flying points credit card processing system problem statement any real credit card generators rbs mint credit card ppi address legacy visa credit card reviews first citizens credit card application prepaid credit cards online use ashley furniture credit card can make payment my walmart credit card store business credit card bmi miles high risk credit card processing companies can you use a credit card at an atm can you cancel capital one credit card online how do i get my credit report without a credit card credit card applications bad credit no application fee gmac mortgage equity rewards credit card using someone else;s credit card with permission best buy master credit card payment can you set up direct debit credit card can you transfer money from credit card to paypal credit card build credit after bankruptcy 0 purchase credit cards government grants credit card debt relief credit one bank credit card agreement first premier bank prepaid credit card credit cards terminals verifone free valid credit card numbers that work 2010 use level up cards facebook credits 5466 credit card number secure online credit card processing aspire credit card reviews fnb gold credit card limit credit card company list hdfc titanium credit card reward points redemption catalogue barclaycard us credit card phone number lowes credit card special offers best credit card get you have bad credit tiffany credit card customer service tesco on line credit card banking do credit card debt too high metal business card credit card holder want apply sears credit card online regions visa credit card world points credit union card online gold delta skymiles credit card phone number why will i need a credit card to download free apps can you buy things online prepaid credit card nordstrom rack credit card pay online mile credit card value calculator make paypal account prepaid credit card use amazon credit card reward make itunes account without gift card credit card best bank get your first credit card credit card debt forgiveness tax consequences card usb flash drive price products credit sears credit cards payment center abercrombie credit card application usaa credit card dispute charge new millenium bank credit card for bad credit pay hsbc credit card by phone check my credit report free without credit card paypal credit card reader for pc can i send money through western union with a credit card get business credit card only ein marriott premier credit card login absa platinum credit card benefits credit card starting with 5 securely store credit card numbers database how to apply a credit card in icici bank buy injectable steroids with credit card what kind of credit cards are good for college students does mean earn cash back credit cards personal loan credit card debt consolidation honda credit card payment pay off credit cards refinance credit card statement cr send money paypal account using credit card does a visa debit card have the same protection as a credit card balance transfer credit cards low fee best bank credit card apply visa debit card same protection as credit card td canada trust debit credit card credit card american express bangladesh mbna credit card america sunoco credit card accountonline visa platinum business credit card capital credit card online banking disposable prepaid credit card uk credit cards for average credit rating citibank credit card payment by cheque in india processing credit cards through google valid mastercard credit card numbers accepting credit cards small business bank america santander credit card login problems citi credit card customer service phone number centon dsc32gb-001 datastick credit card usb flash drive get visa credit card no credit check java code validate credit card number my thomas cook credit card login experian credit card score american airlines frequent flyer program credit card bluetooth credit card reader iphone best credit card processing companies to work for chase disney credit cards rewards wells fargo business credit card icici credit card reward point catalogue valid credit card numbers that work online credit card reform act summary 2009 how to pay credit card bill by another credit card citizens bank credit card login rbs webster credit card login best credit card rewards program in canada current interchange rates credit cards ufcw credit card payment address fidelity 529 american express credit card get cute credit cards amazon credit card uk contact capital secured credit card login common questions about credit cards help with credit card debt.gov ge capital credit card payment online prepaid credit cards no fees international credit card applications for bad credit canada pay with 2 different credit cards amazon credit card forms sample living social credit card stolen members 1st credit card application barclays bank delaware credit card credit card receipt printer mac credit card with high limit and low interest credit card fair fee act 2008 credit cards for fair credit instant approval uk best credit card balance transfer bad credit apply credit cards barclays bank android market account without credit card is citi a good credit card standard chartered hong kong credit card promotion get free cash credit card much do credit card companies sell bad debt does american express offer secured credit card best credit card form design bank hawaii hawaiian airlines visa signature credit card hsbc premier credit card reward mbna europe bank credit card first data credit card processing merchant accounts what do you need to get a secured card credit history credit card type prefix numbers phillips 66 credit card account delta sky rewards credit card check bank of america credit card statement delta credit cards miles bmw credit card application best personal credit cards 2011 say no college credit card offers paypal process credit cards online bloomingdales credit card customer service phone number credit card batch processing pci compliance virgin credit card section 75 cache credit card payment compare bad credit credit cards online credit card payment service hsbc ge money bank credit cards walmart visa united airlines credit card log citi forward credit card customer service number icici bank credit card interest calculation hsbc credit card promotions sri lanka usa credit platinum shopping card what can you do with a stolen credit card number how to pay off your credit card balance american express travel miles credit card credit card debts of deceased spouse capital one credit cards venture rewards card limited credit card login page best free credit cards us hsbc credit card insurance policy walmart credit card help number murphy usa walmart credit card paypal limits unverified credit card easiest place to get accepted for a credit card reasons for disputing credit card charges how to get your first credit card yahoo amex blue credit card offers government credit cards citibank login find unsecured credit card bad credit younkers credit card online payment forever 21 credit card bdo credit card bin numbers australia cannot send money using credit card paypal best credit card processing company in canada credit card rights for consumers citibank credit card contact number bangalore how long does it take to get a navy federal credit card accepting credit cards benefits does credit card company charge off credit cards 0 apr for 15 months ace elite prepaid credit card credit card shape usb flash drive best credit cards to apply for after bankruptcy best credit card software processing credit card low interest rate transfers credit cards 2 percent cash back prepaid visa credit card pet care credit card no interest lowes business credit card does credit build credit cards 4 major credit cards companies pay chase credit card by check credit card gasoline cheap credit card wallets men free credit report scores no credit card required credit card machine my new business sbi credit card credit limit increase form easiest credit card to get approved for bank ireland credit card offers chip and pin credit cards bank of america buy stolen credit cards online close target credit card account understanding the apr rates on credit cards merchant credit card account bad credit best credit card for travelling abroad credit card application approval process issue number on credit card mastercard hsbc bank credit card payment other bank account penn state alumni association credit card should i apply for a credit card online or in person city bank credit cards india where can i pay my discover credit card bill free prepaid online credit card what is the best gas credit card http www bankrate com calculators credit cards mastercard minimum payment aspx top rated merchant credit card processors united chase credit card travel insurance do taxis in paris take credit cards maruti suzuki credit card credit cards help build credit rating can credit card companies garnish wages in florida juniper barclay credit card login union bank india credit card bill design your own credit card chase unsecured credit cards people bad credit canada marshall credit card payment lowes home improvement credit cards starwood credit card referral bonus chevron texaco gas credit card lowes credit card financing offers letter change credit card billing address best travel rewards credit card for average credit network good credit card fees merrill lynch credit card awards pay shell credit card bill online sunoco gas credit card how to pay my wells fargo credit card
Home All Articles Rating the '07 HOF Candidates Based on Win Shares

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 288 guests online

Atom RSS

Rating the '07 HOF Candidates Based on Win Shares PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Bill Gilbert   
Monday, 04 December 2006 17:35
ArticleOne of the first items of business in baseball each year is the announcement of players elected to the Hall of Fame. This leads to lots of speculation and a little analysis prior to the announcement which is scheduled for January 9, 2007.  

Many systems exist for evaluating player performance. One such system, the Win Shares method, developed by Bill James in 2002, is a complex method for evaluating players which includes all aspects of performance—offense, defense and pitching. James has stated that, “Historically, 400 Win Shares means absolute enshrinement in the Hall of Fame and 300 Win Shares makes a player more likely than not to be a Hall of Famer. However, future standards may be different. Players with 300-350 Win Shares in the past have generally gone into the Hall of Fame. In the future, they more often will not."

The 2007 class of Hall of Fame candidates is the strongest in several years. It consists of 15 holdovers and 16 players eligible for the first time. Four holdovers have over 300 Win Shares, Andre Dawson with 340, Bert Blyleven, 339; Dave Parker, 327; and Alan Trammell with 318. Four newcomers on the list have over 300 Win Shares; Cal Ripken, Jr., 427; Tony Gwynn, 398; Mark McGwire, 342; and Harold Baines, 307. One of the newcomers last year, Will Clark, had 331 Win Shares but failed to receive the 5% of votes required to remain on the ballot.  The only 2006 newcomers with enough votes to remain on the ballot were Orel Hershiser (11.2%) and Albert Belle (7.7%).

With the weak incoming class last year, all but one of the 15 holdovers gained votes. The only one that didn’t was Willie McGee who lost 14 votes and dropped below 5%, eliminating him from further consideration by the Baseball Writers. The big gainers were Bert Blyleven (66 votes), Bruce Sutter (56 votes) and Goose Gossage (51 votes).  Sutter’s total of 400 votes (76.9%) was enough for election to the Hall. Jim Rice (64.8%, Gossage (64.6%), Andre Dawson (61.0%) and Blyleven (53.3%) are now within striking range of the 75% required for election but with the incoming  class being so strong, they  will probably not gain enough votes to make it this year.  They will have a much better chance next year with a very weak class becoming eligible.

In the 2007 class, Ripken and Gwynn are certain to be elected on the first ballot. McGwire has the numbers to be elected but is tainted with the steroid cloud and many writers have indicated they will not vote for him. He may make it eventually but not this year. The only other newcomer that is likely to receive significant support is Baines but he is not a serious candidate for election since he was not a dominant player and was primarily a designated hitter for much of his career. Jose Canseco has the numbers that would ordinarily make him at least a marginal candidate but his sordid past may prevent him from getting enough votes (5%) to stay on the ballot.

Following is a list of Win Shares for the 32 players on the ballot. Players on the ballot for the first time are shown in bold.  2005 and 2006 voting is shown for the holdovers.

                    Win     2005      2005       2006     2006
Player            Shares    Votes     Percent    Votes    Percent
-------           --------  -------   --------   -------  -------
Cal Ripken, Jr.     427    
Tony Gwynn          398
Mark McGwire        342
Andre Dawson        340     273       52.3       317      61.0
Bert Blyleven       339     211       40.9       277      53.3
Dave Parker         327      65       12.6        76      14.4
Alan Trammel        318      87       16.9        92      17.7
Harold Baines       307        
Dale Murphy         294      54       10.5        56      10.8
Tommy John          289     123       23.8       154      29.6
Jim Rice            282     307       59.5       337      64.8
Tony Fernandez      280
Steve Garvey        279     106       20.5       135      26.0
Jose Canseco        272
Dave Concepcion     269      55       10.7        65      12.5
Bobby Bonilla       267
Don Mattingly       263      59       11.4        64      12.3
Paul O’Neill        259
Wally Joiner        253
Albert Belle        243                           40       7.7
Ken Caminiti        242
Jack Morris         225     172       33.3       214      41.2
Eric Davis          224
Goose Gossage       223     285       55.2       336      64.6
Orel Hershiser      210                           58      11.2
Devon White         207
Lee Smith           198     200       38.8       234      45.0
Bret Saberhagen     193
Jay Buhner          174
Dante Bichette      168
Scott Brosius       111
Bobby Witt          102

The last 10 players elected by the Baseball Writers have averaged 342 Win Shares, a figure exceeded by only Ripken and Gwynn on the ballot this year.

Player                 Year        Win Shares
---------------        -----      -------------   
Dave Winfield          2001           415
Kirby Puckett          2001           281
Ozzie Smith            2002           325
Gary Carter            2003           337
Eddie Murray           2003           437
Paul Molitor           2004           414
Dennis Eckersley       2004           301
Wade Boggs             2005           394
Ryne Sandberg          2005           346
Bruce Sutter           2006           168
                                     ------
Average                               342

Conclusions: 

1. Cal Ripken, Jr. and Tony Gwynn will easily be elected by the Baseball Writers this year.  Some have speculated that Ripken might set the record for the highest percentage of votes, now held by Tom Seaver with 98.84%. His .340 career on-base percentage could be an obstacle to voters that place special emphasis on first ballot election.

2. Mark McGwire will not come close but will remain on the ballot and could get elected in the future.  If he is not elected, he will be the only eligible player with over 500 home runs not in the Hall.

3. None of the holdovers will receive enough votes for election.

4. Blyleven and Gossage will continue to move up but will fall short.  They could be positioned for election next year when Tim Raines is the only strong new candidate.

5. Rice will continue to fall short because of his relatively short career.

6. Some other newcomers (Baines, Bonilla, O’Neill) could get enough votes to remain on the ballot.  However, a stronger candidate last year, Will Clark, did not get enough votes to remain on the ballot.

7. There will not be a groundswell of support for Scott Brosius and Bobby Witt.

If I had a ballot, I would cast votes for Ripken, Gwynn, Blyleven, Trammell and Gossage.  If I were on the Veterans Committee, I would vote for Gil Hodges, Ron Santo and Minnie Minoso and I would try to figure out some way to get Buck O’Neil in.  

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?