compare credit card offers 2013 lloyds tsb platinum credit card travel insurance best credit card deals 0 on purchases ace online payday loans credit card to rebuild credit score hsbc credit card insurance uk www hbc com creditcard student no interest credit cards black cardigan sweater instant online cash advance loan low credit card rate bad credit loans uk tenant airline credit card deals 2013 how to pay advance income tax online in india td canada trust credit card application status halifax credit card complaints address rbs online credit cards standard chartered credit card customer care kerala ebay buyer protection credit card payday lenders list forum hsbc uk credit card market share hsbc mastercard credit card terms and conditions no credit loans in el paso tx 0 credit card transfer balance virgin credit card balance transfer fee lic axis bank credit cards direct rewards discover credit card payment free prepaid credit cards no monthly fee hsbc credit card cash advance fee how much does a mobile credit card machine cost usaa secured credit card after bankruptcy uk direct payday loan lenders only standard chartered credit card payment india online o interest credit cards for bad credit american express starwood credit card login unsecured credit cards for poor credit with no deposit icici credit card reward points mint best first credit card for college students best credit cards for rebuilding credit canada register vanilla mastercard marriott rewards credit card review illegal online payday loan companies sbi international credit card apply cancel anz credit card insurance how to pay icici credit card bill online from sbi credit limit citi student cards visa credit cards with travel rewards can get secured credit card bad credit citibank credit card balance transfer philippines virgin credit card log on click to pay icici bank credit cards blank credit card authorization form doc ppi credit card calculator apply for business credit card bank of america how to get credit card with bad credit rating virgin credit card contact details standard credit card authorization form pdf best disney credit card offer hsbc online credit cards australia compare business credit cards best credit card for college students with no credit history barclays visa debit card online banking 0 apr balance transfer credit cards 12 months uk credit card rate comparison walmart credit card cash back rules click to view icici credit card statement cancel best buy credit card application create credit card calculator excel best low rate credit cards australia best credit card canada 2012 standard chartered credit card status virgin mba credit card payday loans with bad credit does credit card insurance cover car rental best platinum credit cards 2012 home loan with bad credit history bad credit card offers unsecured retail store credit cards for bad credit online visa card balance checker can you get a target credit card with no credit history credit building credit cards with no deposit best cashback credit card 2013 india unsecured bank credit cards for bad credit credit cards no credit history uk 0 percent interest business credit card hdfc bank credit cards payment chase increase credit limit request online capital one platinum card uk halifax credit card minimum monthly payment credit card apply online in india axis bank apply for a credit card online with bad credit settlement figure credit card debt best cashback credit cards 2012 malaysia pc richards credit card review everest cash advance payday loan login chase credit card fees international transactions bank of america credit card fees for paying off balance good unsecured credit cards for bad credit bank of america credit card student platinum plus hdfc credit card loan statement payday loans direct lenders uk no credit check how does a prepaid visa credit card work list of different types of credit cards td visa card benefits credit card processing fees small business hdfc credit card limit titanium platinum credit card lloyds delta credit card miles deal nandos black card how to get credit loans for bad credit credit card business process diagram hdfc bank credit cards status check hudson bay company credit card payment southwest airlines credit card promotions 2013 tesco credit card online statement bad credit credit cards guaranteed approval australia how to get a credit card for your business with bad credit mastercard priceless cities prepaid credit cards business plan bad credit car leasing uk cash loans with bad credit history credit cards 0 interest on balance transfers halifax credit card minimum payment credit card processing online payment voip interface lost virgin credit card uk what is a secured credit card wells fargo easy fast payday loans no faxing apple store credit card swipe chase business credit cards comparison unsecured credit card applications online why do i need a credit card for my apple id online cash advance loans portable credit card machines best travel credit card 2012 india chase mastercard credit card logon what is a secured credit card mean bank of america credit card phone number chinese credit card debt help government visa credit card uk ge capital toys r us credit card payment address compare premium credit cards in india bad credit card debt disney chase rewards cards best travel credit card canada 2012 best way to get approved for a credit card with no credit anz cash advance calculator credit card authorization form pdf reward credit cards travel fake credit card information for paypal compare travel credit cards canada tesco credit card login accounts rbc air miles credit card canada credit card with travel rewards points moneysupermarket credit card search united credit card uk army navy federal credit union citibank credit card reward points catalogue 2013 bp gas credit card review usaa credit card pin setup pay belk credit card where to get prepaid credit cards in canada first time no credit credit card lowest fixed interest credit cards 2012 no interest credit card for 18 months cash back credit card canada hdfc credit card settlement process india american express black card 2012 mobile credit card processing iphone sbi visa card online registration how to use reward points in hdfc credit cards pay barclay credit card payment online hsbc online application for credit card capital one credit card review what is a credit card number sample what credit card should i get for my small business personal online loan bad credit halifax credit card travelling abroad bank of america online credit card processing for small business login into sears credit card td visa infinite lost card chase credit card payment hsbc premier credit card hong kong hdfc gold credit card reward points redemption catalogue citibank credit card offers standard credit card approval form credit card logos paypal credit card payment calculator monthly interest easy credit card application malaysia complaints against capital one credit card company cheapest credit card apr how to apply for a credit card if you have no credit credit card processing apple vanilla mastercard amazon fast cash loans online lenders safe unsecured loans with bad credit credit card reward comparison australia best portable credit card scanner application for credit card sbi sears credit card lower interest rate visa debit cards online shopping perks for disney credit card holders icici bank credit card customer care number in pune best credit card cashback deals how to negotiate a debt settlement with your credit card company hdfc credit card customer care toll free number best prepaid credit cards usa best payday loan no credit check federal program to reduce credit card debt best visa credit cards to have orchard bank secured credit card visa online credit card application south africa online loan lenders credit card approval no credit check how to increase credit card limit halifax credit card annual interest rate explained where can i use my gap visa credit card how do you get pre approved for a credit card visa credit card number format starwood credit card uk goodyear credit card promotion can i get a credit card after bankruptcy discharge uk online loans paid today student visa credit cards canada credit card with bad credit instant approval care credit credit card agreement credit card merchant account india citi corporate credit card payment online payday loans direct lender credit card history check india guaranteed issue unsecured credit cards chase visa gift card balance online how to pay sbi credit card bill online with other bank bad credit loans no fees no guarantor no broker uk temporary credit card machine rental how to enhance hdfc credit card limit 3 free credit reports no credit card buy gold uk credit card credit card allocation of payments new law uk chase visa credit cards good credit cards for travel abroad horizon bank credit card login best buy credit card customer service direct lenders for personal loans with bad credit does td bank have prepaid visa cards credit card history check bank of america credit cards compromised 2013 apply online credit card icici bank icici credit card online payment ifsc code horizon gold credit card reviews credit card air miles what does your credit score have to be to get a sears card what numbers do mastercard credit cards start with 500 fast cash loans best spg credit card deal canadian credit card rate comparison online loan lenders philippines lloyds visa card issue number old navy visa credit card payment what is the best credit card for travel rewards 2011 value city credit card sears credit card services pay bill gift visa cards where to buy best balance transfer credit cards existing customers how do you sign up for netflix without a credit card pay citibank business credit card online best business cash advance loans standard chartered credit card customer care number india free gnc gold card membership nhs cashback black card target visa card balance check discovery credit card partners south africa city bank credit card apply status good first credit card to build credit direct payday lenders bad credit online best canadian cash back credit card 2011 capital one credit card low interest rate very bad credit cards with no deposits chase credit card balance transfer calculator orchard credit card login online how long to wait between applying for credit cards large personal bad credit loans dubai first credit card charges credit card cashback bonus gap visa card payment online best online cash advance airtel balance transfer system best us credit cards for international travel visa card online registration india how to apply for a credit card if i have no credit get free prepaid credit card online apply for a walmart credit card online cash back credit card comparison uk hdfc bank chennai customer care numbers credit cards 1st financial credit card master note trust iii does applying for credit card hurt credit score best buy credit card customer service phone number commonwealth bank low rate credit card payday loans cash advance no credit check how to use black cardamom how to encash icici credit card reward points credit card for bad credit instant approval cape town major credit card logos uk best travel reward credit card offers how to apply for a secured credit card with bad credit best credit card processing rates canada annual credit report lowest merchant credit card processing fees hilton credit card points guy british airways credit card points cash loans to your door no credit check pay lic premium using credit cards are there any fixed rate credit cards anymore no credit check payday loans uk low interest credit cards balance transfer icici credit card helpline hyderabad icici bank credit card application form pdf anz international credit card fees canara bank credit card apply online in india american express black card concierge hsbc credit card settlement department interest charge on cash advances us bank walmart credit cards online account first cash advance midland tx icici credit card apply online hyderabad cancel hbc mastercard credit card pay paypal credit card bill apply online credit card hdfc bank best credit cards for college students with no credit yahoo best cashback credit card in india 2011 post office mastercard prepaid create free virtual credit card track barclay credit card application icici bank credit card apply online india credit cards with fixed low interest rates chase credit card cash advance charges chase credit card for business bank of india online application for credit cards who owns aqua credit card online payday loan lender only do department store credit cards help your credit score credit card reward comparison canada credit card consolidation loans for bad credit best credit card travel rewards program 2012 how do i get a credit card if im 18 credit building credit cards for bad credit how to pay off credit card debt suze orman ryanair credit card booking fees paypal credit card top credit cards for spending abroad go compare balance transfer credit cards reputable credit card consolidation companies capital 1 credit card customer service telephone number paypal credit card processing reviews best credit card philippines review 2012 get credit card bad credit rating household credit card login page best canada credit cards 2012 top credit card payment processors how many major credit cards should i have merchant cash advance loans how to transfer money from hdfc master credit card to bank account penalty for going over credit limit cancel halifax credit card application quick cash loans direct lenders fast cash payday loans does arco gas have a credit card where can i use my bestbuy credit card capital one credit card business rewards easy online payday loans direct lender how to reduce my credit card debt fast apply for credit card with no credit history credit card apr example reloadable credit cards canada united credit card premier status square iphone credit card system applying for a credit card with a bad credit rating hdfc online credit card payment help desk best credit card services for small businesses cnn best credit cards for bad credit best travel reward credit card 2011 real visa credit card numbers 2013 post office credit card payment line costco credit card processing machine prepaid business credit cards visa orange prepaid credit card credit card limit enhancement letter format hdfc bank low interest credit cards canada rbc standard chartered 5 cash back credit card credit card air miles offers can a credit card company sue you after 7 years barclays platinum credit card uae easy cash advance payday loans faxless bad credit payday loans royalty free credit card logos credit card limits illegal 0 fee balance transfer credit cards no fee halifax credit card balance transfer offers existing customers how to buy a house with bad credit and no money direct online payday advance lenders shell citi credit card contact credit card for international students in uk credit cards cash back rewards american express cash back business cards best first credit card for young adults with no credit best reward credit card reviews applying for a secured credit card with bad credit post office platinum card online aqua credit card instant decision best buy rewards master credit card how to get real working credit card numbers visa credit card fraud insurance natwest credit card payment protection claim anz platinum credit card insurance chase increase credit limit without hard pull apply online for credit card pnb reloadable prepaid credit card usa instant credit card approval in canada online hdfc credit card offers citibank credit card activation is there a chase credit card for students free virtual us credit card does applying for credit cards ruin your credit best credit cards for students with no credit history top 10 credit cards in australia emi offers on hdfc bank credit cards how long does it take to get a credit card rbc best visa credit cards 2011 credit card interchange fees explained pay off credit card debt planner does applying for credit cards lower your score credit cards that give cash back for gas best reward credit cards 2014 apply for department store credit cards with bad credit ways to pay off credit card debt paypal canada credit card fees post office credit card contactless mastercard exchange rate app banks that accept american express cash advance chase visa debit card online disney credit card offers 200 things to consider when comparing credit cards halo reach credit limit weekly credit card payment calculator sbi credit card statement online credit cards bad credit instant approval comparing credit cards check credit score for free no credit cards required best capital one student credit card credit card rewards comparison canada 12 month cash loans today how do i check the status of a us bank credit card application getting a chip and pin credit card in the us credit card validator jquery td canada trust credit card renewal credit card instant approval no annual fee pay advance america online 30 000 spg point american express credit card guaranteed credit cards for no credit navy federal credit union student credit cards ann taylor loft credit card sign in credit card minimum payment calculator formula bajaj standard chartered credit card customer care number free credit card numbers for testing credit card expiration date javascript validator us prepaid credit card comparison business credit card with rewards program my rewards best buy credit card online direct payday lenders no teletrack consumer finance college students and credit cards icici credit card interest rate calculator goodyear credit card customer login boi credit card rate increase sams club discover business credit card login household credit card customer service number is there a best buy credit card app credit card history in the philippines td gold elite visa cash back how often to apply for new credit cards canadian secured visa credit card how do i apply for a barclays credit card earn airline miles credit card no annual fee bad credit visa cards australia who accepts visa debit cards what is the first step in choosing a credit card dummy uk credit card number mobile credit card processing canada android credit card canada review can i transfer credit card balance to someone else visa student credit cards no credit secured credit card bad credit no deposit no interest credit cards capitec bank personal loan online application form hyatt credit card offer review what credit cards can i apply for with no credit washington hilton credit card authorization form free virtual credit card usa bad credit credit cards no annual fee banamex usa credit card application bank rate credit card calculator open sky secured visa card contact
Home Jordan Kobritz MLB Contraction is an Illusion

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 697 guests online

Atom RSS

MLB Contraction is an Illusion PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Jordan Kobritz Article Archive
Written by Jordan Kobritz   
Tuesday, 15 March 2011 14:35

The Biz of Baseball“Dreams are my reality…”
Dreams Are My Reality, by Richard Sanderson


No, you aren’t dreaming, but someone obviously is.

The Poobahs of Major League Baseball played the C-card - contraction - once before to no avail. In case you don’t remember, MLB tried to contract two teams – the Minnesota Twins and the Washington Nationals, nee the Montreal Expos – after the 2001 season. The move was based on a report submitted by the commissioner’s hand-picked Blue Ribbon Commission that confirmed what we all knew: That some clubs were generating more revenue than others and the lower revenue clubs were having difficulty competing with the higher revenue clubs; i.e., competitive balance was an issue.

The Commission’s report proved to be the impetus behind revenue sharing which was implemented as part of the 2002 Collective Bargaining Agreement. In the decade since, MLB has arguably had more parity than any of the big four team sports if you look at the number of different teams in the playoffs and the number of league champions. And the obstacles to contraction that kept the Twins and Expos/Nationals alive still exist today – the MLBPA, Congress, and the legal system that protects cities, taxpayers and fans who have invested money in a team’s stadium.

The concept of contraction has surfaced periodically since 2001, mostly in response to two things: The inability of teams to strong-arm the public into paying for a new facility and revenue sharing. High revenue teams, such as the Yankees and the Red Sox, are understandably loath to contribute to revenue sharing. Between the two, they contribute approximately half the MLB revenue sharing kitty (a total of $433 million changed hands in 2009 according to Maury Brown of the Biz of Baseball). A number of recipients pocket the money rather than use it to strengthen their team, either at the Major League or Minor League level. John Henry of the Red Sox and Hank Steinbrenner of the Yankees have been outspoken critics of revenue sharing and Henry recently revealed he was fined $500,000 for his comments in 2009.

Recently, New York Daily News columnist Bill Madden, a notorious mouthpiece for MLB management, wrote an article describing the “growing sentiment…throughout baseball” to contract two teams. To support his statement, Madden cited “three anonymous baseball execs” who targeted the Tampa Bay Rays and Oakland A’s as likely candidates, given their stadium situations.

To further bolster his “growing sentiment” allegation, Madden interviewed Baltimore Orioles manager Buck Showalter who, last I checked, has never made anyone’s list of the 1,000 most powerful people in baseball. Unfazed, Showalter nonetheless told Madden he “stays up nights configuring realignment scenarios that would solve a lot of baseball’s problems.” While Showalter wouldn’t address contraction directly, he made it clear that “in his dreams,” MLB consists of seven divisions with four teams each – for a total of 28 - which of course would necessitate the contraction of two teams. Given that the Orioles haven’t won the World Series since 1983, and haven’t made the playoffs since 1997 - which not so coincidentally is the last season in which the team had a winning record – you’d think Showalter would have other reasons to stay awake at night.

If contraction is in fact on the table, count MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner and MLB Commissioner Bud Selig among the uninformed. Weiner has said on a number of occasions that he “doesn’t see any major obstacles in the way” of a new CBA to take the place of the current one, which is set to expire at the end of the year. Selig told MLB.com that despite speculation to the contrary, “contraction of franchises is not on the table for these negotiations. Nobody ever talks about it to me.” Which must come as a surprise to Madden – and Showalter.

While MLB may have the right to contract clubs under the CBA, what happens to the players on the 40-man rosters of those teams is a matter that must be negotiated with the union. And the quid-pro-quo the union might exact in return for agreeing to a dispersal formula could cost the teams more than continuing to subsidize the existing clubs through revenue sharing.

Contraction may appeal to a number of owners, but like Sanderson’s song suggests, the only reality is in their dreams.


Jordan Kobritz is a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He is a former attorney, CPA, and Minor League Baseball team owner. He is an Assistant Professor of Sport Management at Eastern New Mexico University and teaches the Business of Sports at the University of Wyoming. He looks forward to your comments and can be contracted, here.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?