relafen 500 mg buy cheap female viagra where to buy misoprostol over the counter side effects propecia acne sumycin online in usa top generic viagra from india urispas generic 2013 drugs low cost finast xeloda prices at costco buy cafergot new zealand online where to get doxycycline for acne erexin v tablets questions insulin overdose amount get lexapro discount clomid for sale canada alli orlistat price philippines desyrel for sale aricept pharmacy buy moduretic online us no prescription no prescription effexor xr fedex delivery can you order bupron sr what is avalide 300 mexico alligators generic flomax over the counter where purchase cialis super active what is clomid mg used to treat furosemide 40 mg sale lasix buying himplasia order avodart pill phentermine diet pills uk pilex no prescription reviews propecia italiano aciclovir prescription cialis sublingual refills how much will maxaman cost best retin a cream for wrinkles abana himalaya herbal cephalexin over the counter equivalent buy phenergan tablets usa medrol online no prescription methylprednisolone drug clomiphene citrate 100mg take where to buy brand viagra with visa buy women viagra uk diovan cost costco buy generic viagra toronto comprar fosamax en argentina current price strattera aricept donepezil doxycycline over counter drug xenical cheapest rate can buy phenergan over counter abilify online shipping benicar capsules dilantin capsules open lotensin with no rx canada and female cialis himcocid usa cvs prices sex pills houston tx best ed pills where can youtube buy viagra over the counter in uk skelaxin tablets dosage lioresal without prescription herbal ed pills australia will you order atarax canadian buy retin-a 0,05 uk buy citalopram no prescription uk dulcolax cheap price where can i order flomax online pharmacy uk lasuna 2 zyrtec pills zithromax for sale usa buy malegra fxt online at canada pharmacy buy reglan line cheap retino a cream why is there a shortage of avalide viagras effect on women cefixime 5mg tablets can i get bactrim over the counter metformin hcl er 1000 mg side effects flagyl generic canada benicar online shipping glucophage mg buy diclofenaco pensa crema liquid tamoxifen citrate dosage geriforte syrup generic 2013 drugs florida amaryllis nexium costco price minocycline side effects depression sale voveran there generic januvia cost of prednisolone 5mg lithium 300mg for sale over the counter antibiotic pills will gabapentin 600 mg get you high keflex dosage for tooth infection generic order abana cheap pharmaceutical companies uk list lanoxin online without prescription generic substitute for tricor cymbalta online pharmacy shipped to canada buy brand cialis online canada fda lipitor recall 2010 robaxin prescription canada buspar comments cytotec 200mg abortion dosage uk version of dapoxetine cheap buspar usa cheap orlistat india where can i get fertomid pills pictures of glucophage pills depakote medications side effects aciclovir maximum dosage what is chloramphenicol used for in dogs arimidex with no perscription benadryl generic children trusted online drugs aygestin from canada claritin rx-to-otc switch suppliers of extendaquin in us fucidin tablets side effects aygestin usa comprar compazine en argentina what is levitra for women trental 10 mg what does himcolin over the counter pills to help lose weight zyvox discount cheap no prescription generic arimidex how to buy eurax in canada zestril prescription only generic mentax safe strattera where can i buy it emsam side effects uk buy amoxil astrailia benicar on line relafen for sale australia protonix lawsuit settlements thyroxine on line sales mestinon uk buy how to buy propecia in uk buy online australia diflucan no rx sinemet online uk mexican pharmacy no prescription dramamine get chloromycetin toronto buying atorlip-5 using paypal paroxetine fda approved to buy without prescription avapro uk boots cheapest imuran tablets uk lipitor vs zocor dose cabana pharmacies fl comprar brand levitra pela internet purchase brafix cheap buy citalopram bulk buy alli slimming pills uk buy paxil mg cialis sublingual bonus pills cgv online pharmacy hydrochlorothiazide combination meds how to purchase actonel online comprar amaryl original en madrid lotrisone prescription only how can i get clomid over the counter canada pharmacy discount drugs buy lotrisone online overnight mobic online store how to take metformin hcl 500 mg canadian pharmacy 24-hour flagyl 400 mg metronidazole alesse tablets uses decadron woldwide shipping frumil canada no prescription bystolic usa sale combivent generic mexico omnicef cost 300 mg generic revia (naltrexone) overseas pharmacy no prescription wellbutrin sr fast naprosyn deleviery buy stilnox online australia trial erection packs 1 cost comparison cheap allinclusive holidays to turkey marmaris prescription medicines on airplanes can you buy fincar over the counter in germany sumycin pill shortage colchicine discount prescription side effects of taking minocycline long term buy cialis without doctor prescription canada can i make brand cialis a good web page to buy alesse with no script elavil medication side effects is it illegal to order generic famvir proper dosage of cephalexin for dogs side effects of meclizine hcl 25 mg canadian blopress tablet canadian online prescription reviews canada drugs paxil with prescription buy fluconazole online no prescription real viagra canada no prescription best generic flovent sites online cordarone purchase doxycycline hyclate 50 mg capsules allopurinol prescription dosage get levitra super active las vegas at what dose does lamictal start working kytril cheap uk what is inderal for pcm pharmacy non prescription liposafe prescription flomax coupons olanzapine generic manufacturer purchase anafranil pills how much does lipitor cost per month tegretol tablete 200 mg viagra jelly generic reviews difference between wellbutrin and generic bupropion how much does flonase cost with insurance benzac free shipping singulair us sales merck;s fincar mail order india craigslist londonderry uk forum buy zyrtec online celexa 20mg tablets can toradol cause weight gain buy motilium online pharmacy comprar trazodone portugal kamagra soft uk online ordering low dose prazosin uk version of tricor is mail order dapoxetine safe there generic lithium m and s credit card purchase deltasone cheap cheap lotrisone usa rxrelief card reviews compazine get you high forum buy zyrtec online generic online nizagara purchase sarafem shoppers drug mart buy cafergot greece where can i buy retin a gel mavi umut dershanesi donde comprar propecia online danazol uk buy brand advair diskus no rx decadron us companies only us online pharmacy no prescription forzest cheapest lotensin femara without a prescription from india comprar mycelex-g en argentina order prilosec cheap lexapro discontinued regenon retard pret buy diakof mexican pharmacies prednisone 5 mg tablet for dogs cymbalta side effects rxlist tylenol jr. strength acetaminophen rapid tabs buy cheap lipitor pills buy anacin from india zithromax to buy in the usa without a prescription can allopurinol cause weight gain cheapest caverta in the uk effects of mixing prednisone with alcohol skelaxin mg price purchase vpxl cheap voveran pill canadian prednisone india tadapox pills drugstore how to use trimix gel clonidine compatibility side effects of rhinocort aqueous nasal spray clomid cycle 28 days inhouse drugstore co uk buy clomid next day delivery buy plendil without a prescription from canadian pharmacy best generic zofran sites tricor 160 mg tablete buying atarax using paypal types of antibiotics for uti prednisone barato kamagra oral jelly tablets side effects artane user reviews relafen shopping buy generic zestril with bonus tadalis sx pharmacy buy vermox online canada rogaine 2 for sale australia voveran tablets online celadrin no prescription canada sumycin classification canadian pharmacy femcare buy albenza online usa nike air max 1 leopard print black fucidin without a prescription from australia prazosin discontinued prinivil coupons buy cialis online usa prednisone 50 mg price bactrim no prescription where can i get rumalaya forte pills nolvadex pct dosage adderall generic wellbutrin sr weight loss what is cialis oral jelly best place to order metformin in us abilify for bipolar i disorder user reviews buy lozol usa coumadin canada head office buy furosemide pills in the india buy amantadine online no prescription united states green tea with hoodia pills reviews much does generic zoloft cost best viagra prices lowest levitra where can i get zestoretic order viagra professional canada viagra sent from europe where can i purchase nexium dutas bonus pills what is the best antibiotic for gonorrhea nizoral tablets over the counter where to buy erythromycin ointment fluoxetine india pharmacy dutas where to purchase para que e' usado feldene can buy lipitor canada top 10 online oxytrol sites what does tamoxifen citrate look like anafranil order cialis lilly icos prezzo lipitor uk prescribing information cialis south africa price arimidex refills overnight pharmacy 4 u coupon singulair dosage bentyl online legally cheap sarafem free delivery abana overnight prescription kamagra chewable next day can citalopram pills be cut in half pramipexole tablets usp purchase propecia in canada what is coreg generic for how to order brafix online can you get apcalis sx over the counter pharmacy buy drugs maxalt did anybody order viagra online can you crush prednisone pills order viagra online without a prescription echeck free trial viagra sample where is the parietal bones where can i get some diflucan remeron medication where to buy pariet 20 mg used med cab zetia can order zyvox online depakote 100 order etodolac 400 mg buy meclizine 40 acheter beconase aq pas cher pill rx health cordarone products tinidazole without where to buy viagra online review why has zyrtec been discontinued compare prices proscar buying fertomid from canada no prescription can you get over the counter antibiotics will 25mg of seroquel make you gain weight side effects of voltaren eye drops cheap uroxatral sale uk buy lilly brand cialis how long does it take for astelin to work use viagra soft coupon online tadapox on line no script taxidermy for sale alligators propecia supplier in uk prevacid 30 mg over the counter cost levlen ed australia prometrium australia pharmacy fast trileptal delivery where can i buy biaxin online without a prescription cuanto cuesta el roacutan en mexico flomax compression fax generic pill identifier cheap metformin medicine diabetes ramicomp genericon mite when to take a pregnancy test calculator cephalexin echeck how to buy kamagra in uk atenolol 50 mg and alcohol reviews on lexapro canadian online pharmacy for antabuse propecia cheap can take keflex urinary tract infection secure pharmacy plus franklin tn to buy chloroquine in uk voltaren 50mg tablets dosage atrovent tablets 150 mg what is the dosage for zyrtec d buy pravachol with no rx over the counter drugs similar to erection packs 1 buy viagra soft quick erythromycin acne topical shipping lithium ion batteries in canada do gabapentin get you high do you need rx feldene what is cabgolin made of chloromycetin paypal pravachol legal us lipitor online overnight where to purchase furosemide buy malegra fxt in singapore brand ginette-35 buy do you need rx bupropion buy zovirax online no prescription usa antibiotic azithromycin uses rogaine 5 weight gain mexitil online buy lithium polymer batteries genuine finast best price online dostinex purchase amitriptyline comments chloroquine looking for canadian pharmacy generic viagra online buy synthroid in australia lisinopril reviews over the counter medicine that acts as fucidin buy tofranil mg generico del pariet receding hairline treatment finasteride cefixime mail order canada pharmacy meds online canadian synthroid no prescription discount buy finpecia generic norethindrone generic aygestin buy zestoretic online no prescription us buy plavix cheap online where can i get viagra from cheap overnight cialis fedex prednisolone acetate drops prices chloramphenicol shoppers drug mart altace discontinued elocom mas'c' 30 g cena is mail order rumalaya safe best kamagra chewable prices buy terramycin new zealand online valsartan 80 mg donde comprar bentyl provera dosage health canada aristocort lisinopril noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy over counter medicine equal nexium where can i buy celebrex on line nitrofurantoin antibiotic side effects abilify cost canadian bactroban generic release date capoten reviews for men vpxl where to get lowest price haldol fluoxetine 20 mg alcohol cheap suprax usa order clozaril online no prescription with a visa buy proscar online ireland class action lawsuit against allianz brand cialis medication dulcolax no prescription canada generic viagra cheapest synthroid legal us is it illegal to order generic lioresal long time side effects synthroid duphalac side effects procardia how to buy suppliers of cardura in us canadian pharmacy propecia online compazine now co uk fluoxetine generic wikipedia drugs desogen without prescription allie brosh depression do i need a prescription for ponstel best place to buy cytotec diflucan for sale no prescription plavix tablets price suprax drug class celebrex generic reviews yagara pills drugstore toradol pills high what is the side effect of benadryl for allergy kamagra cheap canada pharmacy what is erexin-v tablets benadryl allergy tablets side effects oregon state treasury cio tadapox pills buy tropical fish online australia benemid brands india mylan a1 street value retail cost of advair diskus metoclopramide medicine children naprosyn for sale philippines nexium generic over the counter diclofenac genericon 50 mg 20mg accutane results pariet generico side effects of long time use of prednisone
Home Pete Toms Is Selig to Blame for Franchise Debt Problems in MLB?

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 765 guests online

Atom RSS

Is Selig to Blame for Franchise Debt Problems in MLB? PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 21 February 2011 18:28

Baseball and moneyMLB is prospering. Despite the recession, revenues have grown to almost $7 billion annually. The two most recent franchise sales, the Rangers and Cubs, saw both fetch staggering amounts. Like him or not, the biz of MLB under commissioner Selig has been a spectacular success for both owners and players. (I’ll leave the debate of whether Selig has transformed the role of Commissioner into COO, and the merits of that, to others more philosophical) Much of Selig’s success has resulted from his unification of the owners. While his critics decry MLB ‘s clandestine process of transferring ownership of franchises to FOBs (Friends of Bud), Selig long ago ended the inter-ownership battles that contributed greatly to baseball’s lengthy and harmful labour interruptions. But while the biz of MLB has continued to flourish despite the financial meltdown, some individual franchises have been left in vulnerable positions due to the debt problems of their owners. When Hicks Sports Group, a holding company of former Rangers owner Tom Hicks, defaulted on debt payments it led to the Rangers franchise eventually filing for bankruptcy. More recently, the well documented personal financial problems of the Mets owners Fred Wilpon and Saul Katz, along with those of Dodgers owner Frank McCourt, have led to speculation that both those franchises might also become ensnarled in bankruptcies. LWIB saw commissioner Selig criticized in the media for allowing franchises to become burdened by the broader financial problems of their owners. In fairness to Selig, ownership of an MLB franchise is typically more complicated than it was as recently as the 90’s. Franchises are but one part of a business model that is also dependent on both media and property development rights. The exponential growth in franchise values, which Selig deserves some credit for, also has resulted in clubs comprising an ever greater share of their owners’ overall financial worth. Going forward, some say it is essential and imminent, that MLB will attempt to implement new rules to protect franchises from the debt troubles of their owners. Whether or not the owners will be amenable to these proposals is a potentially sensitive matter. So, lets have a look at what is being said, starting with Josh Kosman’s report LWIB for the NY Post that some wonder if the Mets situation is the Rangers redux.

Banks that provided roughly $400 million in loans to the New York Mets are starting to unload some of that debt at a discount, a sign that creditors are getting nervous about the team's finances, The Post has learned.

Potential buyers are bidding around 90 cents on the dollar for the debt, sources said. At least one creditor has bought a debt slice at a discount with the approval of Major League Baseball, which must sign off on any buyer of the team's loans, said one source.

"This tells me the original lenders are scared," a source close to the situation said.

AND

One source said MLB is holding up trading in the loans because of concerns that vulture investors will snap up the debt and force the team into bankruptcy -- just like they did last year to the Texas Rangers.

"[MLB] is being very difficult," the source added.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE THE REST OF THIS ARTICLE

In light of the rampant speculation surrounding the financial health of the Mets and Dodgers (obviously, two of MLB’s crown jewel franchises), LWIB Ben Klayman of Reuters wrote a piece titled Baseball needs to strike out owners' debt issues. Within the piece, both on and off the record sources directly blamed MLB (Selig) for allowing the Mets and Dodgers to become exposed in their owners’ debt problems.

The off-the-field struggles and heavy debt loads of so many major-market teams' owners have some industry observers questioning the league's stewardship.

"It's either an unfortunate set of circumstances or it demonstrates a consistent failing at Major League Baseball to monitor the ownership of its clubs on an ongoing basis," said Marc Ganis, president of consulting firm Sportscorp Ltd and an adviser to Tribune Co in its 2009 sale of the Cubs.

Baseball, like many sports, saw fans and corporate backers trim spending during the recession, but owners suffered as well. Many are businessmen who used debt to invest and got in over their heads, putting the fates of their profitable teams in question.

"It's not the teams that are distressed, it's the ownership," said a sports banker, who asked not to be identified discussing team finances.

AND

"An issue that will be on the table in 2011 will be upstream holding company debt. There's no doubt about that," said a senior baseball official, who asked not to be identified discussing financial matters usually addressed by Selig.

Klayman’s piece goes on to explain that imposing tighter rules on the non-baseball finances of league owners is easier said than done. Present and potential owners might be offended by MLB’s invasiveness which former commissioner Fay Vincent speculated could lead to more franchise ownership by large corporations. As well, franchise values could be negatively impacted by tighter rules governing owner debt.

While LWIB saw industry insiders take to the media to discredit and criticize MLB for its role, in their opinion, of allowing franchise owner debt to become the problem it is, there is speculation that somebody at 245 Park Ave. already “took the fall” last year. In December, the SportsBusiness Journal reported that the Rangers sale, eventually settled via auction brought about by bankruptcy, was a factor in the departure of the formerly most second powerful executive at MLB, Bob DuPuy. “The contentious transaction, however, sullies the image of MLB in the financial community, and is believed to play a role in the autumn departure of league President & COO Bob DuPuy.”

The SportsBusiness Journal recently published an opinion piece from NYU sports business professor Robert Boland examining what the Mets situation reveals about the more volatile state of present day pro sports ownership. Professor Boland warns that the “big 4” should expect more of the same.

The first lesson about franchise ownership drawn from the Mets situation: The margin for error for any owner has shrunk to the degree that one big mistake — trusting Madoff — combined with other decisions, made with good intention but without great success, can threaten to cost one of the more stable ownership groups in all of sports its franchise. The most unsettling part is that the Wilpons and the Mets are not alone. They have company, whether it is the seemingly impervious Los Angeles Dodgers or the perpetually challenged New Orleans Hornets, and for the strangest reasons.

AND

Perhaps the next lesson of franchise ownership is to recognize that teams can no longer be kept at arm’s length from the rest of an owner’s portfolio. They are simply too valuable now.

This folds into the third lesson: that teams are targets. Given their huge valuations, franchises will be the target of creditors, especially when they overreach trying to jump to a higher foothold. The Wilpons and Mets had seemingly done all the right things in trying to grow their business: starting SportsNet New York, signing expensive free agents and building a stadium. Yet it’s these decisions, coupled with the Madoff thefts, that have left them vulnerable.

AND

…But when Madoff’s embezzlement hit the Wilpons’ cash reserves, compromising the operational liquidity of the Mets — which had already been stretched thin by otherwise “good debt” from the new stadium, RSN and a high payroll — the fragile nature of franchise ownership in 2011 was revealed. The perfect storm may have hit the Mets, but that storm is still off the coast waiting for another team pushing the boundaries of fiscal restraint. So the next lesson may be that these crises may simply not be avoidable.

Ironically, MLB realized in the early part of the last decade that their industry had a problem with club debt. (Not the debt of its franchise owners) The 2002 CBA negotiations included changes which drastically reduced the amount of debt clubs were allowed to carry. Several years later, when the credit crisis arrived, MLB appeared prescient. In March 09, MLB CFO Jonathan Mariner told CFO Magazine:

I like to describe that era leading up to the 2002 Collective Bargaining Agreement as a time when we were financing player compensation and whatever growth we were realizing through debt. There was a lot of available debt, very cheaply priced. We put in place the most critical element of that CBA, a debt-service rule. The debt rule said that what used to be balance sheet, ratio-based debt would become EBITDA-based debt. It also said the debt cannot exceed more than ten times EBITDA.

Most people say, "ten times EBITDA, that's a pretty big leverage factor." But not if you consider that most clubs didn't even have positive EBITDA. We had a lot of work to do. But putting that rule in place basically forced clubs to focus on earnings and, as a result, slowed the pace of payroll growth. Payroll has still gone up every year for the most part, but the pace of growth is more in line with revenue growth.

I don’t know if Selig should have to accept the blame for the messes created by Hicks, Wilpon, Katz and the McCourts. I’m not saying yes or no. But it was evident LWIB that he will likely be forced to at least try to assert some control over the broader financial decisions of his owners. The owners won’t like it but that doesn’t mean it won’t happen. Ultimately they all became members of this private club called MLB because Selig favoured them over others. Over the decades that has fostered a lot of loyalty towards the commissioner and he will certainly need it as he addresses this sensitive, and important, matter.


Pete Toms is senior writer for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?