new primatene mist replacement rocket lawyer interview secure aricept drug info pfizer stock to buy rocaltrol 0.25 mcg capsule suhagraat tips mixing marijuana and cialis purchase biaxin is there a generic for viagra arthritis gloves hands walmart paypal pharmacy mobicox 7 5mg hydrocodone buspar dosage for dogsbystolic aldactone 50 mg bid where to buy viagra tablets elocon 0.1 lotion is used for aldactone spironolactone side effects liposafe reviews on vigrx prilosec non prescription drug coupons tantalum price per gram proventil without rx viagra online spain remeron withdrawal symptoms diarrhea olanzapine tablets nexium otc equivalent cialis ebay diovan blood pressure medicine valsartan zenegra reviews fiftyzenerexzenerx mestinon medication wikipedia amoxil 500 mg dosage chart avapro dosage levels premarin tablets 0.625 coupon lumigan for eyelash growth how to apply levitra coupons walmart rollbox 46307 cialis vs viagra vs levitra generic viagra 100mg uk amantadine 100mg images whoesale levitra pills canadian overnight use of viagra for men minocycline online daly cialis canada diclofenac potassium brand name cheap canadian pharmacy pyridium 200mg dose zoloft mexico pharmacy cholesterol lowering foods diet india drugs generic cialis 200 erection photos clozaril national registry wbc count reporting form phenergan and pregnancy risks avana at the rim san antonio tx promethazine 12.5mg suppositories dafalgan sciroppo bambini 30 mg canada pharmacies top best viagra online europe indocin 50 mg cap euroclinix uk finpecia kaufen get viagra prescription online costco online shopping prednisone for dogs dosage for allergies liposafe bag raymeds pharmacy tech garlic clove for yeast infection where to buy prednisolone 5mg nizoral 2 shampoo walgreens azithromycin 1 gram oral packet bisoprolol fumarate 10 mg side effects buy viagra online in ca usa flomax medication for kidney stones diabecon prospect mortgage buy cefixime online no prescription can you get levitra cheap trazadone without prescription progesterone side effects in women buying cialis online safe lantus solostar tablete za mrsavljenje tomato albuterol sulfate side effects doctor celebrex coupons walgreens plendil medication viapro ingredients in cigarettes order neurontine overnight bystolic generic nebivolol viagra online in ireland famvir 500mg for cold sores zocor generic price zithromax versus levaquin for sinus infection lotemax side effects fatigue vip rx sales cheapest clomid in 24 hrs online cefixime 400 mg uses trileptal oxcarbazepine 600 mg rimonabant weight loss drug zocor generic name terramicina oftalmica pfizer zoloft and breastfeeding viagra at shoppers drug mart garrigue wines adalat desi tashan viagra force for sale elomet cream mometasone furoate ointment propecia dosage form coumadin and alcohol dose subutex vs suboxone during pregnancy vera bradley fabric by the yard sibutramine hydrochloride monohydrate capsules 10mg package cialis viagra soloxine without prescription viagra online greece ciprofloxacin 500 mg side effects fast delivery antibiotics cipro tinidazole 500mg levamisole dewormer for goats clotrimazole solution for pets kemadrin injection sites software stores online viagra girl commercial anafranil drugs proscar side effects doctor cost of valproic acid in uk cialis rezeptfrei mit mastercard tamsulosin side effects mayo clinic donde comprar pastillas cytotec omnicef antibiotic for ear infection methocarbamol online tylenol dosage for infants lopressor generic medmacrodantin buy elavil with overnight shipping capoten side effects dose cipralex side effects depression walmart discount drug list best online pharmacy cialis dermasone 0.1 vitamix coupon code bed bath and beyond dalacin 300 mg capsule samonas prime moving & storage metformin er 500mg vs metformin 500mg prevacid vs nexium which is better amoxicillin 500 mg canadian pharmacy list of illegal drugs india drug pharmacy cialis to buy in usa viagra uk online viagra tablet canadian prices tamsulosin side effects men low cost vardenafil cong dung renapril 5mg hydrocodone order cialis greece zetia coupons free printable zetia coupons merck plavix clopidogrel 75 mg side effects meclizine 12.5mg tablets 5 cialis tofranil dosage for children comprar viagra tarjeta debito champix side effects quit smoking marcumar medication interaction bystolic supply shortage tadalnafil aurochem blog plavix manufacturers generic viagra 25mg free shipping cialis extra dosage walmart pharmacy viagra pricing pharmacy technician salary cvs isoniazid and alcohol use cheapest prices for viagra 100mg cialis dosierung cefixime 400 mg brand names and prices antibiotics no prescription overnight viagra generico in svizzera pharmacie de garde bruxelles map prazosin hcl 1mg indomethacin 50 mg capsule and male potency algondones pharmacies metformina 850 ayuda a la ovulacion buy cipmox flonase otc availability tadalafil 5 mg tablets vpxl american pharmacy hydrochlorothiazide how to get where to buy cialis online safely 164 vermox plus side effects phizer viagra for sale buy generic propecia uk adhd meds online zestoretic without script erectalis 20mg cialis praziquantel for dogs and cats canadian prescription viagra helthy man viagra for women in india astelin nasal spray antihistamine zolpidem medication en espanol isoniazid 300mg side effects acnotin acheter google searchviagra subutex side effects on liver yasminelle pill drospirenone side effects of citalopram hydrobromide side effects buying clomid online australia cytotec 200 mcg orlistat capsules generic evista and breast cancer risk claritin dosage chart cialis original de la india purchasing flagyl over the counter xalatan coupon pfizer beconase aq nasal spray cost picareta de diamante minecraft texture canadian online drug site reviews exelon myhr chlamydia pneumoniae causes eulexin flutamide pcos weight eutirox 50mg laxadin tablets for sale meprate dosage of tylenol vigorex sildenafil tramadol hcl 50 mg info viagra prezzi e confezioni levitra generic available where to buy clomid online bodybuilding antabuse drug info atarax no rx neurontin gabapentin side effects weight gain baclofen side effects in elderly propecia inde ebay precio de la ciales promethazine codeine cough syrup benazepril side effects epratenz doxorubicin can i take two cialis alli diet voltaren emulgel hydroxyzine hcl 25 mg tablet for anxiety reviews cialis generika paypal lasik furosemide purchase order benicar side effects benicar 20mg magnesium deficiency symptoms children flazol 500mg tylenol levoxyl recall 2013 fda yasmin birth control for acne clopidogrel 75mg tablets r 196 keppra 500mg for dogs with seizures prevacid 30 mg over the counter costco black friday 2015 deals cymbalta side effects cymbalta and weight gain how to make your dick bigger propecia on the phone order cuckold definition slang fastest viagra uk delivery levitra generico orosolubile prezzo rimadyl rewards program 2012 atepros 50 mg zoloft bactrim over the counter walgreens generic viagra that takes mastercard trusted cialis website clomid pregnancy symptoms zenerx reviews prescription permethrin spray insecticide for clothes gpchealth reviews on fifty cefixime 200mg vs 400mg fluconazole side effects in infants cipro no rx list pills get you high tretinoin cream 0.1 coupon camping noord holland crestor 10mg metallica tour 2015 opening acts vitamin k2 side effects erlamycetin tetes mata madu generic cialis uk next day delivery pregnant cat pictures cefovex 500 dollar ubat provera valium withdrawal diazepam buy liquor online with echeck atrovent hfa inhaler coupons apertium uoc ambien withdrawal symptoms nightmares viagra uk suppliers generic plavix usa protonix side effects doctor what is betagesic tabletsbetaprofen buy mifeprex online buspirone hcl 7.5mg trimix gel buy zenagra uk application form format in word tinidazole topical cream for bacterial vaginosis alli in stock uk samonas therapeutic listening therapy bayer binotal 1000 doxycycline hyclate uses for boils pletal cilostazol medication side is omnicef for sinus infections metallica nothing else matters lyrics hydroxyzine hcl 25mg side effects duloxetine hcl dr side effects eprostol misoprostol induction metrotab facebook contempt cialis how long to take effect vidalta 10mg methadone torsemide 20 mg diuretic side where can i buy cheap cialis buy scripts from canada evista for osteoporosis prevention furolin medication for depression generic viagra india 100mg viagra de los del tercer mundo levaquin for sinus infections sky pharmacy cialis sunsuria berhadiah billigaste viagra pfizer non prescription colchinine phexin 7500 zoloft online salzarex manufacturer definition avodart coupon for 2014 bactroban unguento torsemide equals how much lasix zyvox antibiotic price nootropil tablets 800 mg viagra pfizer for sale donepezil 5 mg tablets cost medrol dosepak side effects best rx life androgel side effects medication floxin otic drops ofloxacin stromectol doses viagra online legitimate resources augmentin 625 price comprar cytotec en usa cheap keflex where can i buy cymbalta 20mg flomist ciplactin alesse side effects drugs buy brand lilly cialis glucophage weight loss reviews atosil tabletten oynanan canadian rx located in blaine wa cialis generico prezzo piu basso tretinoin cream usp 0.05 reviews canadian pharmacy 24 hour cialis in 3 days milnacipran hcl buy clomid using paypal prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension generic brand mifepristona costo en mexico macrobid and pregnancy side effects birth defects with ondanstron nimesulide and paracetamol tabletsnisoprostolnitrazepam online parmacy pilocarpine hydrochloride ophthalmic solution prednisone dog genetic viagra using mastercard cialis for daily use free trial levitra by phone warfarin and vitamin k interaction womens viagra purchase propecia kaufen order elavil overnight tamoxifen side effects breast cancer vrdrug scampi primox muscle men tank xylocaine jelly sildenafil citrate in natural form astelin nasal spray azelastine hci canadian pharmacy that takes paypal allegra carpenter twitter donormyl 15mg what is betnesol tablets clomiphene for men dosage sunsuria bukit jelutong sime sublingual nitroglycerin administration pharmacy in costa rica buy levothyroxine 75 mg cuckold definition slang huckleberry over the counter testosterone cream pillshouse review motrin and robitussin interactions ramipril side effects drug viagra tablate how use in odia fuenllana centro educativo cocoyoc cheap generic viagra online omnicef side effects cefdinir costco catalog advair inhaler generic prinivil 20 mg does generic viagra work the same esomeprazole magnesium over the counter best viagra online duphaston et depo provera starlix nateglinide cialis spedizione anonima sureway transportation company viagra 25mg vs 50mg zyprexa 0 dollars 63 centimeters budesonide side effects medication and alcohol caffeine side effects heart racing generic daily cialis cytoxan side effects treatment prescription medication mexico buy viagra online legally internet pharmacy quick delivery tablete za mrsavljenje 5mg propecia trusted pharmecies citrate magnesium cleanse pilexil capsulas atacand coupon order lisinopril no prescription herbal viagra australia abilify medication side effects ranigast 150mg viagra kaufen paypal bezahlen online canadian pharmacy viagra echeck propranolol online pharm levitra 20 mg information buy citalopram online no prescription polarmeds comcast customer romanian pharmacy online viagra tablet in saudi arabia non precription viagra from canada desogen generic reviews buy reductil philippines buy amitriptyline online uk kamagra reviews diane von furstenberg shoes digoxina 0 075000051 zyrtec d side effects taking getpharma pakistan international airlines cialis erfahrungen bentyl medication for diverticulitis yasmin online aus diovan blood pressure medicine manufacturer asacol hd savings card viagra 100 mg for sale viagra south africa for sale sertraline hcl 50 mg tablets sri lanka pharmacy online clopidogrel 75mg tablets pics online pharmacy australia cialis metrotab 400 bad melovax 15mg adderall fanegada wikifeet estradiol pills online zyrtec for children dosage chart metallica black album cytotec misoprostol for abortion doxycycline for dogs medication sertralina efectos a largo plazo amerimedrx pharmacy effexor and weight loss side effects xanax side effects and withdrawal symptoms online viagra sales viagra south africa fast viagra shipping usa trim active plus reviews viagra tablets available in chen cyproheptadine ed cialis without ed pilocarpine drug generic dormidina information system orderpharma reviews on vigrx staxyn 10mg vrdrug complaints against companies cheap cialis for sale mtabs reviews for 50 pfizer coupons brand cialis nl mirtazapine medication for sedation januvia 100 mg price viagra levitra cialis a basso costo avelox side effects medicines celebrex side effects celebrex recall online inhalers no prescription usa cialis patent expiration buy metformin without rx trazodone without a prescription viagra types zolpidem 10mg overdose luvox cr dosage healthy man viagara no prescription goldshield order viagra overnight duphaston 10mg indication omeprazole side effects long term isoniazid drug dose acquisto viagra femminile sialis mealworms cong dung renapril 5mg oxycontin zoloft withdrawal symptoms in children malegra 50 mg cipro from canada latisse side effects blog pfizer animal health sales jobs code red 7 seconds pill reviews letrozole australia benazepril 10 mg prices
Home Lance Gurewitz GUREWITZ: Rafael Soriano Revisited

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 936 guests online

Atom RSS

GUREWITZ: Rafael Soriano Revisited PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 5
PoorBest 
Lance Gurewitz Article Archive
Written by Lance Gurewitz   
Thursday, 20 January 2011 08:37

Clearly, some people in the Yankees front office did not listen to my advice. There are so many angles from which to approach the fallacy of the signing of Rafael Soriano that I can hardly decide where to begin. The New York Yankees just agreed to pay an average of over $16 million per year (including competitive balance tax) for a reliever not named Mariano Rivera, allow said reliever the option of opting out of the deal after either of its first two seasons, and give up a first-round pick in a deep draft in the process. Most business-minded baseball analysts would argue that giving up that kind of money, leverage, or future value for a reliever is a bad idea. The combined loss of all three is simply staggering.

It seems as if this s not the timeliest of signing reactions, so I have already overheard pieces of others’ reactions. Some sabermetric analysts, not entirely unlike me, are inclined to look at this contract in a vacuum and conclude rather uniformly that there is no rational justification. More casual or intuitive observers who support the deal have a more varied set of arguments, most of which, frankly, are a bit too casual or intuitive and mostly serve to distract from this analysis.

To those who claim that the Yankees added 2010’s best closer as a bridge to the best of all time, you might be looking at the wrong numbers. Soriano’s performance last season is amazing to those who value his 1.73 ERA and 45 saves. His more predictive FIP and xFIP combo of 2.81 and 3.81—ERA-scaled numbers based on pitchers’ most consistent outcomes, strikeouts, walks, and home runs—is a bit underwhelming. That inflated xFIP number is symptomatic of a large number of fly balls that were not home runs in 2010—but very well could be in 2011, especially in Yankee Stadium. (Joba Chamberlain’s numbers, you ask? 2.98 FIP, 3.34 xFIP. Watch for the convergence.)

To those who claim that the Yankees have found the heir to Mariano Rivera, you need to analyze the contract and its incentive scheme. For one thing, Soriano is only under contract for one year longer than Rivera; a 33-year-old Soriano with one year left on his deal sounds very little like an heir. That assumes, of course, that he even remains under contract that long. Assuming Soriano does not opt out of his contract after the first year, and pitches well in 2012, he will have a choice to make. Option A is to assume the Yankees’ closer role at a salary of $13.5 million for just one year. Option B is to opt out of the last year of the contract and fish for a new multi-year deal, either from the closer-less Yankees or elsewhere. Either way, though Option B seems much more likely—think like Scott Boras for a second—the Mariano Rivera replacement attempt is far from finished.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE THE REST OF THIS ARTICLE

The one argument that seems to actually stand up in my mind, as strange as it may seem, is that the Yankees have so much money that they can afford a contract that would be insane for any other team. The WAR valuation method I previously used to recommend a maximum bid of three years and $16 million uses a “market value” for wins in the free agent market. However, the Yankees clearly have the financial resources, available revenue streams, and place on the marginal win curve that make wins worth more than the going market rate. Due to the market in which they play, wins are simply worth more money to the Yankees than they are to other teams, which is why the Yankees can get away with paying more than other teams for those wins. Even though I expressed my opposition to the contract earlier, I just have not been able to shake the intuitive sense that the Yankees—as astronomical as the financial cost may seem—will not be severely inhibited from pursuing other players, so the situation is worth another look.

Economist J.C. Bradbury, author of The Baseball Economist and Hot Stove Economics, developed a method of determining a player’s value (as a marginal revenue product, for you economists) that does a better job of considering the Yankees’ unique situation. Bradbury’s work involves multiple regression analysis and other calculations that are unnecessary to show here, but the concept is that an average team produces a fixed amount of revenue, and an average player who plays X% of the time (by plate appearances or total batters faced) produces X% of that revenue. Then, any runs scored or prevented beyond the contribution of that average level of play continue to add (or reduce) revenue, and the amount of revenue increases as the quality of the team, represented by run differential, increases. This is the concept of the marginal win curve.

Using Bradbury’s findings about leverage and the percentage contribution of pitchers in Hot Stove Economics (and skipping several steps here), I determined that Soriano saved the Rays 18 runs in 2010 while pitching to only 3.8% of their total batters faced—about 11 runs above average for that percentage of TBF. Bradbury’s book also explains that the 9th inning is 2.5 times as influential as innings 1 to 6, and the 7th and 8th innings are twice as influential as the first six. Thus, we need to adjust Soriano’s runs prevented value by the appropriate factor. Using Bradbury’s runs-to-revenue formula and the assumption that Soriano will pitch almost exclusively in the 7th and 8th innings, we can see what that same performance (an optimistic assumption) would be worth for the 2011 Yankees, conservatively assuming a 130-run differential before the addition of Soriano and assuming that Soriano himself is replacing an average performer (likely David Robertson).

R(d)=.0641d+.00979d^2+.00000312d^3

R(152)-R(130)=11.6

In other words, Soriano’s 2010 performance, if repeated in 2011, would be estimated to be worth $11.6 million for the Yankees. Even if the Yankees started off as better than a 130-run differential team—say, a 160-run differential team, as they were last year—that performance would only be worth $14.8 million. By similar calculations, a duplication of Soriano’s 2009 performance with the Braves, when he pitched better innings and more of them, would be worth $19 million or $24 million for each of those respective run differentials, 130 and 160, respectively.

So what have we learned? When the leverage of the innings Soriano will pitch and the Yankees’ place on the marginal win curve are taken into account, Soriano has a chance to be worth the $16 million the Yankees will pay for him in each of the next three years. However, that possibility assumes that he stays healthy and replicates the best seasons of his career. Given the obvious risk that this will not be the case, the opt-out clauses the Yankees put in the contract, the fact that Robertson is likely to be better than an average pitcher, and the loss of the 31st overall draft pick in a deep draft class, this is still an overpay by the Yankees. At least now, though, maybe we can see where they were coming from. Maybe.

The author extends a special thanks to J.C. Bradbury himself for his clarification of certain processes outlined in his book, Hot Stove Economics.


Lance Gurewitz is currently a freshman at the Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania. He also serves as the MLB Trade Rumors Florida Marlins Team Coordinator. You can read and discuss his baseball analysis and other sports musings in 140 characters or less by following @LanceWG42 on Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?