zyrtec vs claritin d relafen nabumetone 316 primatene mist buying sifrol 0 18 mg of melatonin vigrx plus in the uk unprescribed viagra more effective viagra levitra tantalum metal endo pharmaceuticals lidoderm patch coupons pravachol side effects dizziness abilify no prescription river pharmacy prednisolone eye drops beprogel scalp pfizer connection to care patient assistance program clavaseptin for dogs and kennel cough feldene piroxicam preventing gi upset glucovance generic buy malegra pro 100 glucophage without rx from canada depakote sprinkles for dementia lopressor medication assistance clozaril protocol wbccocainacockapoo pentrexyl 500 mg capsules drug interactions medyka ukraine russia levitra coupons from viamedic tadacip 20 india supreme suppliers pharmacy mumbai cheap cialis 20 mg vermox amazon what is puretone hearing testpurmycin amlodipine side effects amlodipine besylate side effects purchase atomoxetine mobic meloxicam medication side effects std medications online australian generic cialis viagra mississauga 100 mil cialas offshore pharmacy sertraline 100mg tablets why mebendazole discontinued phexin boats bikes non prescription 200mg celebrex meprate 2.5 cialsis lowest price walmart pharmacy cialis pills pfizer free samples effexor dosage for depression nasonex nasal spray coupons misoprostol side effects for miscarriage rx pharmacy viagra mumbai detrol side effects medicines lanoxin drug dose cialis en ligne canada 5mg cialis no rx potassium foods potassium deficiency discount online stores keppra medication levetiracetam propecia from worldwide sale flonase nasal spray side effects levaquin side effects levaquin antibiotic lotrel 5 20 mg benemid dosage of tylenol frumil 5 40 threaded rod viagra usa online pharmacy asthma attacks in children eldepryl package insert compare generic cialis prices digoxin level range cialis mg5cialisacialis estradiol patch estrogen for males medrol dosepak methylprednisolone dosage bevispas 135 mg is how many grams generic voltaren raloxifene hcl 60mg viagra in dubai sildenafil citrate 100mg plus sinequanone clothing store viagra cream for women xerograx pastillas mccoy doxepin reviews for anxiety liposafe baggallini silagra online pharmacy generic viagra pill in usa mexico esomeprazole where can i buy periactin medrol without rx cytotec haw much price in abu dhabi best place to buy generic cialis online dostinex side effects cabergoline and pregnancy buy prednisone online cozaar no prescription advair side effects pink viagra australia viagra substitute gnc olmesartan amlodipine side effects norfloxacin dosage in dogs metformin overnite delievery prednisolone tablets for sale florinef side effects dogs zyban dosage smoking cessation condyline podophyllotoxin side mail order generic meds from india lasaoren removal tool buy stratteraonline buy tadapox erection pills pay with checking costco locations cialis 5 fertilita zocor medication leviteracetam shopping antibiotic minocin side effects walmart cost for viagra online medicine canada ampicilina para que sirve aricept side effects. 5mg nitrazepam prospective definition walgreens employee website employee benefits amantadine 100mg for dogs zopiclone side effects doctor vardenafil hcl side effects maxaman ingredients to die where can i buy prexil nexium coupons nexium 40mg cheapest online pills haloperidol injection 100 mghealthman bph meds online average price of 100 mg viagra acura viagra prozac dosage for children accutane black box canada cialis coupon walgreens cephalexin uk legally buy pain medication online india online pharmacy blopress 8mg is mupirocin ointment over the counter chlamydia pneumoniae treatment antibiotics misoprostol induction stories atosil dropshippers alendronate sodium fosamax in lifting weights atomoxetine pharmacies india pinamox caps alli orlistat philippines magnesium oxide supplement acquistare propecia pharmacy thailand dikloron jello zantac coupons samples cheap genuine cialis uk rabeprazole 20mg dr tab green line pharmacy canada shelf life teva 3109 precio levitra toy dakar trucks faridexon forte lighting aciphex 20 mg price cheap cialis not generic kamagra india online buying antabuse online uk rxlist com brand names fedeltry healthcare viagra antibiotics canada over the counter when will alli be sold again tadalafil singapore chlamydia trachomatis rna eldepryl side effects valtrex pharmacy vardenafil uk prevacid lansoprazole ingredients viagra sample pifier viagra online jasmine villegas justin bieber propecia purchase online canada otibact ear drops 15ml to tablespoon propranolol for anxiety medication rapid tabs cialis candian rx zetia generic equivalent captopril dosage formcarbimazole norapred 5 mg diclofenaco sodico 100mg zocor cholesterol medication side effects doxycline price increase dove posso comprare il kamagra buy cheap online aciclovir seks sri lanka oxybutynin 10 mg er side effects azulfidine sulfasalazine reviews lisinopril hctz side effects gout ramipril fait il grossir elocon lotion cephalexin 500mg capsule antibiotic for dogs ranitidine 150 mg flexeril 10 mg cyclobenzaprine hcl benadryl ingredients diphenhydramine hci optimmune ophthalmic ointment for dogs in genetics the position where to buy cialis in mexico where is the best place to buy viagra fluconazole diflucan treatment apodefil es bueno commande de viagra cialis can i buy viagra in singapore flomaxtra pricegrabber generic viagra pay with paypal priligy buy online usa lasuna planting costco photo center christmas cards atorlip 20 mg crestor price malaseb dog medicated shampoo viagra nz queenstown accutane pill for acne buy online fluconazole tadalafil online pharmacy unisom and pregnancy and nausea vistaril medication dosage duphalac laxative lactulose alzytec tablets suhagraat ki starting kaise se hoti hai tere prilligy tablets in germany buy lisinopril online india viramune xr coupon fervex kaufen tadapox 80mg prozac seroquel side effects in elderly dementia patients thyroxine side effects l thyroxine does zoloft cause weight gain zyban dosage to quit smoking online erection pills doxycycline 100mg tablet combiben in canada 1691 buy cheap tadapox advair coupons $20 advair coupon amphetamine side effects in children neurontin for anxiety side effects quit smoking zyban reviews supradol ketorolaco 60mg viagra price philippines discount clomiphene pharmacy order azitromicina 500 mg online nasonex coupon $15 garlic mashed potato recipe with red potatoes caffeine and breastfeeding quetiapine online how to take prednisone 10mg minocin 100mg uses doxycycline and cold medicine tabletten zum abnehmen am bauch xanax street prices state by state glyprin aspirin dosage cialis brand name usa price ornidazole tablets side effects minocycline uses in canines pravachol and grapefruit interaction bactrim antibiotic side effects with alcohol xenical 60mg from canada canadian pharmacy percocet cipla finpecia vigra for sale in ireland where to buy viagra in toronto proviron tablets side effects asacol side effects doctor obat ciprofloxacin glipizide side effects salzarex tramadol capsules pictures norfloxacin 400mg dose alzytec 10 mg hydrocodone doxycycline malaria bestellen online ketazol tablets on sale seroquel xr side effects cyclidox capsules nespresso leconfield house curzon street cinema vigrx plus results pictures albuterol inhalerin the eu nuvigil vs provigil for narcolepsy cialis generico consegna 24 ore viagra store canada aciclovir tablets en espanol viagra cost per pill 2012 is pharmacy rx one legitimate clozaril patient monitoring service buy viagra in karachi levitra without a rx lidoderm pain patches back pain safe on line pharmacy dermasone scalp trileptal medication jean coutu viagra looking for nolvadex buy sildenafil online mesalamine generic biaxin clarithromycin mechanism of action www nizagara viagra best results indian pharmacy colchicine buy estrace tablets sildenafil citrate 100mg tabs non prescription viagra mexico minoxidil for women walgreens ordering cialis 5mg prescription ambien money pak cefixime 100mg obat apa blue watson 540 canadian buy viarga with a mastercard kamagrafast brighton michigan malegra 100 tablets natija dyal 9wilbat aliviosin dyal gholdoian clotrimazole troche lozenges how to make cialis more effective buy cialis online secure cytotec side effects on baby zocor side effects viocore orlistat reviews medrol side effects burning laxifen medicina natural promethazine codeine dosage atarax medicine for dogs orlistat capsules instructions tadarise 60 rollbox playerauctions nootropil medicine tablets doxycycline for dogs antibiotic treatment trusted online pharmacy reviews cialis price in ksa 356 rogaine side effects rogaine for women buy viagra online canada fast viagra generic release date can meloxicam get you high lumigan generic drug haloperidol injection side effects viagra online fast delivery viagra brand vs generic viagra equivalent in india viagra soft cheap salazopyrin en tablets buy lynoral in uk levitra online prescription azithromycin side effects propecia 100 1 mg pakistani viagra proventil inhaler medication coupon promethazine codeine cough syrup for sale unisom side effects dose roaccutane on line pharmacy clenbuterol weight loss dosage fast best reviews on cialis purchase viagra on sale cheap antibiotics online overnight generic viagra 100mg price nuvigil vs provigil price progesterone cream side effects in men where to buy domperidone online livial 2.5mg side effects fosamax lawsuit bisphosphonates cialis comprar cytotec pills peritol sirop copii imovane 7 5mg information now sotalex tabletta cialis 5 mg daily success albenza treatment stop body odor elomet lotion kaufen buy viagra in calgary zopiclone tablets in india get suprax shipped next day atenolol medication and grapefruit pharmacy online cheap abortion pill ampicillin in canada mobic 7.5 mg for headaches levitra prices go way up reputable online pharmacies cy cialis trimetabol dosage calculator puretone addicted to bass bupropion online eli lilly cialis diclofenac sodium side effects rabeprazole sodium over the counter pilocarpine side effects medication order zanaflex online allegra d coupons printable mobic meloxicam side effects cenveo corporation pension plan buy ketotifen pills online where can i buy nizagra kamatra sumatra coffee anxiety definition webster diovan side effects diovan hct no presacription acivir dt 800 how to find real cialis on the internet alli available in canada is zifi 200mg tablets causes sleep mail order levitra tetracycline back order zyprexa for anxiety buy generic viagra overnight shipping flomax 0.4 mg capsule viramune xr 400 mg buy generic viagra online uk accutane long term side effects depression ospamox 250 mg walmart price for levemir vial duvadilan drug study isoxsuprine pulmicort flexhaler 180 mcg coupons cuckold creek hollywood md post proscar to uk without prescription foreign online pharmacies elimite cream retirides 0.025 metallica enter sandman live viagra en ligne au quabec erythromycin without prescription comprare levitra in slovenia cheap viagra without prescription prednisone 6 day instructions relafen 750 nabumetone canadian pharmacy no prescription pets exelon employment revatio 20 mg for erectile dysfunction generic viagra canada price tretinoin cream usp 0.025 uses generic boner pills actonel without prescription periactin medication information dalacin t lotion for acne duphaston 10mg dydrogesterone film canadian pharmacy in largo florida seroquel withdrawal symptoms last metpamid 10 mg melatonin primox muscle men chest citalopram and ibs d diflucan side effects alcohol synthroid coupons 2014 ranigast skutki uboczne grzybka advair inhaler side effects weight gain cephalexin 500 mg capsule side effects adderall side effects in adults without adhd the purple pharmacy algodones xalatan eye drops generic tinidazole without prescription remeron side effects remeron lawsuit sertraline hydrochloride therapy 2000 ceu disulfiram no prescription phenergan for nausea in pregnancy wlik viagra comprar cialis generico ativan withdrawal symptoms begin birth control pills salbutamol guaifenesin capsule cardinal richelieu magnesium supplements and diarrhea estrace coupons antibiotics without a prescrip abortion pill online nasonex nasal spray over the counter valium vs xanax vs ativan primox portia what works like viagra ramipril capsules images ritalin weight loss us drugstore discount codes pfizer viagra for sale cheap cialis online pharmacy bactroban 2 ativan for anxiety attack anafranil side effects doctor mestinon medication information blood pressure monitor lidocaine cream 5 over the counter imitrex nasal spray 20mg tantra oral jelly side effects estrace cream treatment estrogen 552 free albuterol inhaler samples florinef medication and alcohol tadalafil 20mg tablets cipralex information medication albuterol sulfate inhalation solution 0.5 trazodone sleep medication bactroban cream uses treatment euro pharmacy online samples of cialis best mexican pharmacies how to get viagra discreetly buy flagyl overnight whexenical no prior prescritption how long before feel effects of clomiphene for men atenolol 25 mg side effects novartis clozaril national registry india cialis online non prescription alternative to lasix toprol side effects coughing secure tabs viagra overnight cialis canada ampicillin with out perscription levitra 10 mg prezzo rayrx online drug store milnacipran brand name viagra and delayed ejaculation
Home Jordan Kobritz KOBRITZ: Baseball Hall of Fame Voters Err on PED Issue

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1019 guests online

Atom RSS

KOBRITZ: Baseball Hall of Fame Voters Err on PED Issue PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 6
PoorBest 
Jordan Kobritz Article Archive
Written by Jordan Kobritz   
Tuesday, 11 January 2011 23:45

The concept of “innocent until proven guilty” is a fundamental tenant of the U. S. criminal justice system, but one the voting members of the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA) are apparently unfamiliar with. While a majority of baseball writers aren’t lawyers, and therefore aren’t versed in criminal law, the appalling lack of support for former Houston first baseman Jeff Bagwell in the recent Hall of Fame (HoF) election suggests that BBWAA members could use a crash course on fairness, justice and objectivity.

Bagwell, a Hall of Famer if ever there was one, received only 41.7 percent of the vote. I won’t attempt to overwhelm you with Bagwell’s statistics and how they measure up against his peers, current members of the HoF, and other players who were eligible for election this year. Those stats and supporting arguments are available at the touch of a mouse. Suffice it to say that a number of respected members of the BBWAA were articulate and passionate in arguing for Bagwell’s candidacy.

On the other hand, voters who shunned Bagwell defended their position by referencing the “suspicions” of steroid use that shadowed the slugger during his playing career. Despite the suspicions, these are the facts: Bagwell never tested positive for steroids, was never accused of using PEDs, and has always emphatically denied using. Nevertheless, Bagwell was effectively “convicted” of using steroids without a scintilla of competent evidence to support that verdict. While circumstantial evidence - Bagwell hit only six home runs in 900 Minor League at bats and 449 home runs during 15 years in the big leagues, he “bulked up” during his playing career, slugging records in the “steroid era” are tainted, etc. – was often cited to support the case against Bagwell, such “evidence” is little more than baseless rumor and innuendo.

The argument that players who used steroids – as evidenced by positive tests and/or admissions - violated the “integrity and character” language in the Hall’s admission guidelines may be defensible. But shunning those who are “suspected” of using steroids is a contradiction of all that we hold dear in a free society, something members of the media should understand better than most.

In my view, even confirmed steroid users should be elected to the Hall if their stats warrant it. While the language in the voting guidelines has remained consistent, the interpretation of that language has not. If voters had consistently applied the integrity and character wording in the past, the Hall would be bereft of a majority of its inductees.

Ironically, many voters who shun steroid users are not so inclined with amphetamine users. Yet there isn’t a shred of medical research that suggests, let alone conclusively establishes, that steroids are more of a performance enhancer than amphetamines. On the other hand, substantial research has determined that caffeine, one of the most frequently used and easily available substances, enhances performance by as much as 25%, something most members of the BBWAA can no doubt relate to. Try writing a story on deadline without the requisite java. When big league clubhouses become caffeine-free zones, you can talk to me about keeping steroid users out of the HoF.

How to remedy the current situation that allows individual voters to define “integrity and character” as they see fit? One possibility is for the Hall to eliminate the language in the voting guidelines, although based on recent comments by Hall President Jeff Idelson, such action seems highly unlikely. As an alternative, the Hall could clarify the language, perhaps limiting it to a player’s conduct on the field of play. However, that interpretation may have prevented Roberto Alomar, who was infamously involved in a spitting incident with umpire John Hirschbeck, from gaining election this year.

Another option is to have some combination of the Hall, MLB and the MLBPA conduct an educational seminar with the BBWAA membership regarding what information is or is not appropriate to consider regarding Hall qualifications. Such an approach seems reasonable, given that MLB and the MLBPA were co-conspirators in the steroid era visited upon the sport and the Hall takes its marching orders from MLB.

While convincing all 500+ voting members of the BBWAA to think alike is an unreasonable expectation, something must be done to assure greater consistency in the voting process. Decreeing that suspected steroid users are “guilty until proven innocent” is an unconscionable travesty that must end.


Jordan Kobritz is a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He is a former attorney, CPA, and Minor League Baseball team owner. He is an Assistant Professor of Sport Management at Eastern New Mexico University and teaches the Business of Sports at the University of Wyoming. He looks forward to your comments and can be contracted, here.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?