how to apply credit card in hsbc philippines rewards credit card wells fargo best 0 credit card balance transfer aqua credit card app best travel points credit card australia zero balance transfer credit cards australia store rewards cards in phone community first credit union barclay credit card online statement age to apply for credit card in canada credit cards non sterling transaction fees best student credit cards 2012 no credit hdfc credit card a magento 3d secure credit card transfer credit card balance to another credit card track icici credit card application status get online loan without bank account ba credit card offers uk hsbc apply for credit card best no foreign transaction fee credit card 2013 does applying for credit cards lower credit score new york and company credit card payment address orange prepaid credit card visa prepaid credit card usa check application status for capital one credit card guaranteed payday loans direct lenders fund virtual credit card paypal credit card apply now online nigerian credit card scams in new jersey free visa credit card numbers that work 2013 ppt on credit card fraud detection methods best unsecured credit card for no credit standard chartered credit card customer care kerala what to know when applying for your first credit card chase freedom credit card deals orchard bank credit card reviews 2012 portable credit card machines for churches capital one secured credit card business college students and credit cards problems best credit card apps for ipad list of payday loan lenders uk do bank of ireland do visa debit cards can i pay my us bank mortgage with a credit card natwest black credit card your points sears master credit card login 0 interest credit card offers uk chase business credit card promotion apply credit cards bad credit best travel credit cards how to lower credit card apr rate zero interest credit cards sbi visa card online registration best capital one student credit card pay chase credit card online should i consolidate my credit card debt into my mortgage what is credit card payment gateway aib visa card exchange rate how to change credit card on iphone 4s guaranteed approval credit cards unsecured list of 12 month payday loans which credit card is best in india best mobile credit card apps bin credit card search disney credit card account login cash advance credit card atm pin best business credit cards 2012 order free prepaid credit card how to prevent credit card fraud on your website student credit card for students with bad credit credit card with best airline rewards compare icici bank credit cards hsbc credit card cash advance malaysia android credit card payment app apply student credit card online instant approval secured credit card low interest blank credit card authorization form template best high limit credit cards to apply for bank of america credit cards for fair credit staples business credit card application status credit card for no credit rating visa card security code number instant payday lenders only can you get cashback on credit card credit card consolidation king;s gta credit cards in canada travel rewards credit cards reviews canada barclays credit card contact interest free credit cards for 18 months on purchases best loans to pay off credit card debt quick cash loans online australia t mobile reach credit limit can i get a credit card online credit card issuers australia instant payday loans online uk best store credit cards to rebuild credit tesco credit card payment methods best visa debit card for students credit card offers for not so good credit ipad credit card app australia rooms to go ge credit card payment best cash advance loans for bad credit credit limit increase littlewoods leaving uk credit card debt find pre approved credit cards visa card number validation can you get cashback with a capital one credit card secured canadian credit cards for bad credit axis bank credit card reward points hdfc credit card customer care phone number bangalore if i apply for a credit card online can i use it immediately what is a visa signature credit card hsbc credit cards application philippines american airlines credit card login page credit card balance transfer offers ireland cash back credit cards taxable black card points login how long does it take paypal to confirm credit card citi credit cards online bill pay online credit card minimum payment interest calculator chase credit card visa freedom instant online loans bad credit credit card machines uk credit card fraud detection project download calculate credit card interest rate calculator bad credit credit card no deposit how do i get approved for a credit card with no credit walmart credit cards for bad credit bank of america world mastercard credit card with worldpoints rewards and paypass best credit card with 0 percent interest visa credit cards no annual fee ultravx visa secured credit card review pay sears credit card with debit card instant loans online no credit check sears orchard credit card login chase business credit card no foreign transaction fee paypal online credit card processing bank of america air canada credit card pnc secured credit card denied low interest unsecured credit cards for bad credit best cashback credit card offers bank of america launches three new travel rewards credit cards php credit card number validator cash advance lenders only td canada trust student credit cards hsbc credit card cash advance promotion do i need a credit card for google play how to get credit card limit increase chase difference between secured and unsecured credit cards best travel reward credit cards 2012 canada cash advances definition how to reduce my credit card debt fast best platinum credit card uk credit card merchant account india delta credit card cash back secured credit card no annual fee canada chase reward cards reviews canada trust credit card login apple handheld credit card scanner sbi credit card agents accept credit cards online no monthly fee credit card debt consolidation chase apply credit card credit cards with 0 interest on balance transfers for 24 months household best buy credit card login alertpay not accepting credit cards what to look for when applying for your first credit card best credit cards in canada for travel best interest free credit card uk chase business credit cards with rewards compare credit card usaa college credit card review best business credit card offer 2013 delta skymiles credit card deal i have bad credit and need a credit card australia icici credit card credit card fraud punishment in alabama top 10 credit cards in india credit card balance transfer calculators how to pay icici credit card bill online from hdfc credit card hdfc credit card payment gateway online yatra offers hdfc credit cards hsbc corporate credit card malaysia best travel rewards credit cards canada 2011 debit visa card canada minimum payment for bank of america credit cards $25 american express prepaid credit card virgin credit card balance transfer offers wells fargo credit card cash advance staples business credit card canada how many first premier credit cards can you have capital one credit card review canada does credit card cash advance affect credit score hdfc credit card payment through gateway chase virtual credit card number ge capital credit card payment phone number first premier bank credit card login air canada credit card promotions guaranteed credit card approval for bad credit how to get a prepaid credit card online us bank secured credit card annual fee mobile credit card processing for small business cibc canada credit card login best buy master credit card payment loans with bad credit direct lenders chevron gas credit card apply best credit cards offers for bad credit bank of america small business credit cards credit card types uk online visa card number generator chase virtual credit card terminal business credit card comparison uk chase visa freedom credit card login pay as you go credit card visa canada visa credit cards instant approval are travel rewards cards worth it short term loans online south africa best rewards cards for average credit easy approval payday loans online balance transfer offers free visa gift card numbers online what is the best credit card for rewards points lloyds tsb business credit card customer services best secured credit card to build credit history payday loans online no credit check no faxing south africa is it good to have 2 credit cards 12 months interest free credit card australia credit card 0 balance transfer explained square credit card business model how to enhance hdfc credit card limit zend framework credit card validator delta credit card offer 2012 all unsecured credit cards for bad credit can i pay for a money order with a credit card at the post office prepaid credit card online purchase visa debit card online registration bdo credit card application form online how to increase credit limit capital one credit card reward program comparison canada credit cards for college students with cosigner using us credit cards in canada best credit cards for bad credit canada best credit card deals uk petro canada credit card login bankamericard platinum plus visa secured credit card car loans with bad credit bpi balance transfer calculator virtual credit card indonesia free credit card insurance coverage rental cars chase credit card visa customer service prepaid credit cards visa chase citibank secured credit card student credit cards with cash back credit card number format compare credit cards in canada petro canada credit card services best credit card machines for small businesses chase student credit card karma points amazon credit card interest free period how to pay hdfc master credit card bill online can you balance transfer barclaycard to barclaycard credit card search engine low interest student credit cards canada hsbc credit card online payment options care credit reviews do i need a credit card canadian credit card fraud statistics how to get a low interest credit card with bad credit jetstar credit card fees best credit card rates nz hdfc credit card toll free number chandigarh when does my credit limit increase capital one gas credit cards rewards how to increase credit card limit icici household credit card login page get a credit card instantly with bad credit credit card payment comparison calculator credit card online barclays sam;s club business discover credit card login instant 12 month loan bad credit what are credit and debit cards used for online payday loans south africa pay standard chartered credit card payment td green visa card interest rate credit card online apply discover credit card score requirements united mileage plus credit card promotions best zero interest credit card is it bad to open new credit cards im 18 should i get a credit card chase credit card online services best credit cards no interest 12 months free valid credit card numbers with cvv2 2012 vanilla visa card declined online how to get a joint credit card best business credit card 2013 easy no credit loans mastercard securecode reset chase toys r us credit card mailing address bank of ireland visa debit card overdraft valid stolen credit card numbers apply visa credit card fair credit hudson bay company credit card payment incipio iphone credit card case payday loans no credit check no employment verification uk bank of america credit card rewards list of payday lenders no credit check no credit credit cards chase ipad apps for credit card processing credit card balance transfer calculator excel huntington bank credit card processing credit card compliance regulations canada credit card minimum repayment calculator uk credit card bad credit instant approval uk lane bryant credit card payment phone number hdfc credit card reward points offer southwest visa business credit card nationwide credit card offers for existing customers natwest credit card online banking no foreign transaction fee credit card singapore bad credit card debt best credit cards comparison india old orchard bank secured credit card td visa credit card canada low interest fee credit card scotiabank value? visa card hdfc virtual credit card charges bad credit loan lenders online lloyds tsb airmiles duo credit card sort code title loans online only apply for a mastercard over the phone cash advance lenders in georgia credit card merchant agreement visa how to get a student credit card with bad credit best credit card deals process of disputing credit card charges citibank credit card loan interest rate tata sbi credit card online payment credit card business process diagram hdfc credit card online payment india hsbc credit card apply online in india is horizon gold credit card good personal online loans sa accept credit cards online with paypal should i transfer my credit card balance to a new card chase credit card visa southwest how many different types of credit cards are there how do air mile credit cards work credit card payment calculator excel template virgin atlantic credit card mbna login international credit card merchant account sbi credit card online application report credit card fraud visa secured credit cards in canada after bankruptcy instant bad credit loans no fees best secured credit cards to build credit 2011 credit card debt help forum iphone credit card reader no monthly fee travel rewards credit cards comparison canada credit card issuers in india credit card transfer deals uk credit cards apply online ireland african bank credit card limit increase online i need an unsecured bad credit loan td bank visa debit card rewards login walmart credit card login app how credit card processing works wiki pc mastercard sign on getting a credit card machine with bad credit can i apply for a visa credit card online new credit card charges set to hit consumers southwest airlines rapid rewards visa credit card visa credit cards with travel rewards should i accept credit card payments on ebay reward credit card comparison uk 0 interest free credit cards on balance transfers credit card authorization form australian embassy vienna complete list of all credit cards marriott premier credit card status real credit card numbers and cvv2 cheap rate credit cards canada virtual credit card number capital one credit card reward offers 2012 instant credit card approval for bad credit credit card consolidation companies prepaid credit cards canada visa bp gas credit card phone number easy approval credit cards unsecured chase visa rewards card benefits barclay credit card contact address small business rewards credit cards can you use walmart prepaid credit card paypal master credit card apply onyx the new black visa credit card city bank credit card customer care number bangalore new payday lenders 2013 0 credit card transfer balance compare marriott rewards credit cards hdfc credit card online payment through other bank petro canada gas credit card fake credit card numbers that work with security code for paypal gold card derbyshire county council gift credit cards walmart lowest apr business credit card net pay advance contact annual credit report uk hdfc credit card bank chennai credit card search by score uk credit card numbers explained next payday advance phone number best credit card for no credit where can i pay sears credit card neiman marcus credit card payment login need a loan with bad credit fast apply online credit card icici bank ace cash loans online credit card fraud for dummies full the best credit card in malaysia 2012 why do i need a credit card for free apps kindle consolidate credit card debt td canada trust credit card machines for iphone 4 credit cards for poor credit history uk best no-fee credit card with rewards program td canada trust visa gold hdfc credit card helpline kerala keyring rewards cards app td secured credit card canada can you get a student loan with bad credit uk mbna credit card canada review barclaycard freedom rewards credit card review joint credit card applications online payday loan no credit check no broker no fees app store uk without credit card best visa credit card to use abroad discover lost credit card phone number circuit city credit card chase bank best 0 credit cards for balance transfers credit card for small business with no credit balance transfer barclaycard to natwest visa black card review 2012 us fast cash loans vanquis credit card balance phone number bank of america credit card login visa consolidating credit card debt with mortgage how to redeem hsbc credit card points philippines debit visa card canada td easiest credit card approval premier credit card phone number best rewards credit card 2013 australia clothing store credit cards with bad credit 0 credit cards transfer ikea usa credit card application barclays platinum credit card review lenders for home loans with bad credit top 5 most popular credit cards credit card frauds statistics will opening new credit cards hurt your credit score credit card debt settlement process credit card fraud detection project source code bank of america credit card settlement letter granite credit card uk payday cash advance loans missouri chase mastercard credit card ebay credit card offers october 2013 credit cards with airmiles rewards what credit score is needed to be approved for a discover card find credit cards for bad credit scores cheapest credit card processing best small business credit card for new business credit cards uk best deals black card points natwest how to get a us credit card living in canada what happens to credit card debt when you die in ontario small business accepting credit cards credit card online services rbs credit card helpline number icici bank credit card apps for windows phone banks offering virtual credit cards in india best credit card for no credit no annual fee credit card benefits comparison malaysia paypal accept credit cards on website credit card 0 balance transfer offers credit card number search tool how long does it take to get a credit card once approved online application for sbi visa card dcu visa platinum secured credit card visa card services online long gold cardigan how to calculate credit card interest payments in excel halifax credit card complaints address does credit card insurance cover car rental bad credit payday loan lender uk what is a cash advance on my credit card how do you apply for a credit card yahoo how long does it take to get credit card approved easier get credit card credit union how to close a circuit city credit card security credit card wallet jobar starwood credit card td canada trust pre approved credit card home loan with bad credit and no down payment low interest balance transfer credit cards for life
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews Interview - Marvin Miller - Former Director - MLBPA

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 451 guests online

Atom RSS

Interview - Marvin Miller - Former Director - MLBPA PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 12
Written by Maury Brown   
Sunday, 18 July 2004 12:00

Marvin MillerStarting in 1965 with his election to the MLB Players Association, Marvin Miller changed the face of MLB forever by turning a loosely knit players association into one of, if not the, strongest Unions in the Nation.

In this interview, Miller talks of issues such as privacy rights and the BALCO case, the player pension plan, the 2002 CBA, and much more.

When the book on SABR is written, it will never be said that its member base doesn’t have its priorities straight. I say this since the topic: “Who would be on baseball’s Mt. Rushmore?” made the rounds via email this year within my regional chapter. George Washington? Thomas Jefferson? Nah, let’s get serious and talk baseball.

It made for light and interesting discussions. Rickey was mentioned by most. Hulbert by some. Landis, by others. But, Marvin Miller was on every list. There was no question about his place in history.

A few days later, I was looking into the Introduction of Miller’s book, “A Whole Different Ballgame” which Bill James had penned. It seems that we were not alone in this assessment:

“If ever baseball buys itself a mountain and starts carving faces in it, one of the first men to go up is sure to be Marvin Miller.”

So there it is.

Marvin Miller may be the biggest lightning rod the game has ever seen. The creation of the Players Union initiated something of a war with MLB that borders on Jihad. MLB management loathes him. To the rank-and-file players at the time, he must have been seen as something just short of God.

At the time of his arrival, and the eventual breaking of the Reserve Clause, he was viewed by many as a harbinger of the “end of baseball as we knew it.” Surely, the maverick Players Union would destroy Major League Baseball. He elevated the pay of players, created the free agency system in place today, and helped provide benefits, such as a solid pension plan, that allows players to do more than simply survive after retirement. The changes, however, altered the public perception. Players no longer were part of a city – part of the family or “one of the guys.” Now, the players were “out of touch with the common man” and “looking out to make a buck.”

Instead of baseball’s demise, baseball grew exponentially, and both sides amassed untold wealth. Distrust flourished. The Players Union, in concert with management, set into motion repeated strikes and lockouts. Fans venomously cursed both sides. “The million dollar players should be happy to be involved in a game children play. And, the multi-million dollar owners should quit crying poverty and be happy they’re as rich as they are,” were constant themes.

For better or worse, baseball has been forever changed since the MLBPA was recognized in 1966. There is no turning back, although I think the owners would like nothing better.

In framing this interview, I knew that a man with the impact of Miller had already been questioned in great detail. So, this interview focuses more on the present than the past. He is still a man of great conviction. The printed word here will fail to convey the nuances and inflections when the topics of Constitutional rights and the BALCO Trail were raised. Or, how he slowly and purposefully reminded me that the Press never has fully understood what the Union can, and cannot, do for the former players not covered by the pension plan.

What’s ironic is that the chance for Miller to be immortalized in stone is probably better than his induction into the Hall of Fame. But all that aside, never let it be said that he isn’t one of, if not the, greatest men that has impacted professional baseball. - Maury Brown

BizBall: When you were elected head of the MLBPA in 1966, the players were portrayed by some as being nothing more than indentured servants of management. You organized and galvanized the loose knit players’ association into the force that it is today. It seems since that time that the pendulum has been moving in the Union’s favor since. Is that still the case, or was the outcome of the 2002 CBA a step back for the MLBPA?

Miller: It is difficult to have a valid opinion when you are not part of the negotiations. You are forced to make a judgment from the outside just looking at the contract itself and the various positions. What you don’t know is--what I don’t know at least is what were the factors that deem themselves important to consider in taking was now perceived to be taking backward steps.

I am not ducking the question, but I really don’t know the answer to it. Let me explain by first saying, looking at the contract itself I would have to conclude along with others that those were backward steps. But then I force myself to look at a little below the picture, and one that is kind of startling when you think about it, that is that I think the present leadership of the players’ Union has had to contend with something that I never did, and that is they have had to contend with a membership consisting of not one single player who ever had any baseball life prior to the Union. Not one player is able to fully evaluate what the Union has meant to players as a group, and that is a very tough problem to contend with. I think it has to temper any judgment about steps backward.

BizBall: Do you feel that the public’s appetite for MLB would have been severely diminished if a lockout or strike would have occurred in 2002?

Miller: I think temporarily, but I am not one of those who ever believed the propaganda of labor disputes would be the cause of a permanent loss of fans. It never has been and I doubt it ever will.

BizBall: Is the public’s concern something that comes to the negotiating table, or is the overriding concern of a representative of his or her labor Union to get as much for their respective constituency as possible?

Miller: I think you have to bring it down to the cases. For example, in all of those years when I was with the Steel Workers Union, there probably was not a single dispute that wasn’t settled in the White House, and the reason, of course, was that a nationwide steel dispute heavily impinged on the nation’s economy.

When steel went down in those days, pretty soon so did automobiles and so did residence and building construction and onward, and you were dealing with widespread increasing unemployment. So, it was both a public issue and a government issue. In that kind of situation, public opinion is
MLBPAextremely important because sooner or later, after it ends up or gets to the White House, pretty soon the Congress is there, and that becomes a serious matter.

I have never had that kind of a feeling in baseball even though, if you were to judge by the amount of ink that the media spent on it, you would assume it was a matter of great public concern. But, when you examined it, it really wasn’t. My concern in those days was not the public relations aspect in the same sense that a steel public relations reaction in steel was. My concern in those days was that if this gets loud enough, the players will be affected and that’s all. Because I never considered it rising to the level of a national emergency dispute like the mega-steel dispute and nor would I consider that the so called public relations damage would be more than fleeting and small.

BizBall: In 2002 there was considerable talk of a Worldwide Amateur draft taking place. Since that time the issue seems to have been swept under the carpet. What is your take on the concept of the worldwide draft?

Miller: You mean to remove the exemptions if there have been?

BizBall: Yes.

Miller: I don’t know. I haven’t thought about it a lot except for the extent that I have never approved of the idea of a private industry having the right to draft anybody. At no time, for no reason. To me a draft has to do with a governmental function in the time of emergency.

BizBall: Also in 2002 the main topic of conversation was the elimination of teams via contraction by the League. There is verbiage within the last CBA that opens the topic back up, at least in principle, for 2006. Was contraction a straw man in the last CBA and do you feel it will be an issue in the next CBA with the current Union?

Miller: I think first that it was a straw man. I think it was a kind of double-barreled power ploy. It was a ploy in a sense that they were trying to scare the Union that it was going to have a loss of  membership and I think it was a ploy and the usual communities who might balk at public financing of baseball stadiums.

In that sense, it was a clever ploy but not really an effective one.

BizBall: The Expos were a part of the contraction scenario in the last CBA. Since then they have become vagabonds of the League with "home" games being played in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Stuck in the middle have been the players. Did you feel the Players Union represented the Expos players properly on this matter?

Miller: No. I am not sure they were treated right at all.

BizBall: Did the League create this monster of a situation by expanding too fast in the early ‘90s?

Miller: I don’t know about that connection, but I do not think that you can view the expansion as being too much or too little, except in relation to the demand for them. In other words, if you look at the economics of it, with each expansion they raised the entry level price and yet had eager buyers literally standing in line, holding their hats in hand, hoping their bids for a new franchise would be rewarded.

Given that kind of economics and given the fact that the demand was always there and at an increasing price, it’s hard to say if expansion was too rapid – too rapid for what? How do you measure these things except the fact that when they offer the opportunity for expansion, eager applicants came forward, even with tremendously rising price of buying a new franchise?

BizBall: Do you think that it’s possible that expansion was done simply to offset the damages incurred when it was ruled that there was collusion within the League to keep player salaries down? Over the past few seasons, there has been a dramatic decline in the rate in which player salaries have risen. Collusion is being discussed by the MLBPA, and to that end, the Union has requested that Agents keep notes on contract negotiations. Management points to the overall national economy, which has been in decline, as the driving factor. What are your views on the matter?

Miller: I think management’s argument that the general economy ought to be looked at as a factor is probably very weak when you consider past recessions and the rise of baseball salaries. The salaries continue to rise--no matter what the factor of the national economy was--for the simple reason that they had been underpriced for so long that a lot of steam had built up and salaries have kept going no mater what the general economy was. And I would expect that, over time, there might be some leveling off, but without being able to demonstrate it if you want my feeling, my feeling is that collusion was playing a part in the last year or two.

BizBall: On the issue of steroids, and more specifically the BALCO case. Recently there was news that the names of some of the players associated with testing samples were seized by the IRS as part of the Grand Jury investigation. Do you feel that steroid testing, as a whole, is an encroachment of privacy rights for the players?

Miller: Well, I do, but I think the more serious issue really is the attempt by the government through the Justice Department through pressure from the President through continuing pressure by Senator McCain; I think this gets beyond the privacy question. This gets to be one which, when you put it together with the fact that the records that they were trying to seize were testing  records made by the parties who had agreed that it would be a confidential, anonymous test as a first step in developing a testing program. I think the government’s attempt to infringe on that is outrageous. I think what you are dealing with, once the government steps in with that, what you’re dealing with is a violation of the constitutional rights of people. By that I mean it’s one thing if an employer makes it a labor-management issue. It’s quite another when the government says, "I now will subpoena records of confidential tests and I will use the material," which, after all is tantamount to saying, "I will require self-incrimination and I may send some of you to jail." I think the sports media, like so much of the other media, is just asleep on this issue.

BizBall: Do you have any regrets over the years that the vested parties of the MLBPA pension plan did not include more of the population of former ballplayers; i.e. Pete Coscarart et al?

Miller: Well, again the media is terribly at fault in this. The fact is that the player’s Union all through the years, starting with when it became a legitimate Union in 1966, in every single pension negotiation has dealt with former players already retired in a far more generous manner than any other employees in the United States. That is, in negotiation after negotiation, the player’s Union treated former players, who as long as they had even one day of service ten years before those negotiations--then later one day of service in any of the 15 years prior to those negotiations--it treated such employees as if they were still active. No other pension plan in the United States has ever done that, ever!

Now when you get to
, that’s different. That’s the group of players who never were part of the benefit plan. They were not members. And, they were not members, many of them,Pete Coscarart because the players of that period when the pension plan first went into existence in 1947, perhaps because they were dealing with an inadequate amount of money to make a decent pension plan, agreed to the owners’ proposal that anybody who was not on a major league roster on the last day of the 1946 season or the first day of the 1947 season, no matter how many years of major league service he had, would not be a member of the plan.

Now think about it. That meant that somebody with say ten or twenty years of service who had been released before the last day of the 1946 season was treated as if he had never been in the major leagues. This was done by the players before there was any organization. This was done by their fellow players. Now, I’m not saying that because that happened nothing should be done--far from it. I am saying that the people who have written about this are mighty careless in blaming the Union, which didn’t even exist then. But more than that, they don’t seem to understand two things. Number one is that players well, what the most important point is that the Union under law, is not the representative of a former employee. I don’t know if you know that. Two Supreme Court decisions state that an employer is not even required to negotiate with the Union with regard to a former employee. That’s true whether it is baseball or steel or anything. A former employee is not a member of the bargaining unit so an employer is free to say, "Not only won’t I do anything I won’t even talk to you about it." And if the Union were to strike on that issue the Union would be liable for all damages occurring to the employee’s business. That’s the first thing.

The second thing is, the writers who write about this, who are careless about this in my opinion, is that it’s not even clear that a Union would have the legal right to now negotiate inclusion into a pension plan of people who it didn’t represent, and who had never been covered; because the assets in that plan belong to the members of the plan under law. They do not belong to people who were never members of the plan and you have a very serious question of law involved. I don’t know the answer to it, but it is no simple matter.

But, I come back to my original point. This notion that people who were never members of the plan that the Union becomes the one obliged to do something, or the players -- the current players -- that just doesn’t hold water. The employer, if anybody, is responsible for the pensionless status of its former employees not the current employees. The employer is responsible.

I once asked a writer of the New York Times who was writing a lot of blather about this, whether he thought that he and his fellow Times’ reporters were liable for the pensionless status of former writers of the Times at a time when there was no pension plan.

BizBall: What was his reaction?

Miller: He said, "Well, no." (laughs) So why are the present players obligated?

BizBall: As a former Union head, what was your take on the MLUA and Ritchie Phillips’ ill-fated strategy of having the Umpires resign en masse?

Miller: (Laughing) I think the foolishness of it has been demonstrated.

BizBall: Are you surprised it took as long as it did for teams to resort to the strategy of non-tendering large numbers of players who wouldn't otherwise be eligible for free agency?

Miller: I’m more surprised that the Union has not stepped in to prevent it.

BizBall: From an MLBPA perspective, would it be good to have big-market teams fund incentives for small-market teams to field more competitive teams, as opposed to current revenue sharing which arguably doesn’t encourage small-market teams?

Miller: It’s hard to say. Revenue sharing may well have a part to play in terms of competitive balance. I’m not convinced that it does; other people disagree. I think, for example, even prior to  this agreement, involving both revenue sharing and so called luxury tax, I think the competitive balance among all the teams in baseball is probably better than it was when I was a young fan. When I was a young fan, I think it’s eminently provable that there’s far more balance now than when the Yankees would win fourteen pennants in sixteen years and when taken together, the Yankees and the St. Louis Cardinals and the New York Giants would win everything almost every year. So, I’m not sure revenue sharing is a constructive thing at all.

BizBall: There has been considerable concern in Wisconsin about how Miller Park was funded, with a considerable portion of that coming from the public. Milwaukee has since then set team payrolls so low it has created poor-quality product on the field. A salary floor might possibly prevent some of these problems. Is a topic of a salary floor a step toward creation of a salary cap?

Miller: Not necessarily. I mean, there’s always been a salary floor ever since the Union negotiated minimum salaries. I don’t think that having a floor necessarily means you have to have a cap. We have a minimum wage in this country, but we don’t have a maximum wage.

BizBall: How do you view your role in the history of the game? Given the history between management and the MLBPA do you think you’ll get the votes to be in the Baseball Hall of Fame?

Miller: (chuckles) No. I think the votes were never there. I found it interesting. But [it was] kind of uninformed when so many people said just because they changed the method of voting for non-players from the old veterans committee to all of the living members of the Hall of Fame that that necessarily meant I would be eligible. (chuckles) I never agreed with that. I think it left out an awful lot of factors.

One of the reasons I didn’t agree with all of this, is that I think anybody who has ever been a Union leader has to have gained some skill at being able to predict votes in advance. I think that what’s disastrous for a labor leader is to not have that skill.

For example, to call for a strike vote and have the membership turn it down. That’s the end of credibility. Or for a Union leader to go into difficult negotiations, reach a settlement, and then submit it to the membership for ratification and have it rejected. That’s almost the end of the Union.

So, you really have to learn how to forecast votes in advance, and one of the things you do is look at the facts.

Fact number one is that an awful lot of players in the Hall of Fame are pre-Union. They never had anything to do with the Union back in that terrible period.

Number two, is that many of those players and many of the players who were playing in the period in which in which I was involved, after they were through playing, became employed by management. A whole different mindset is set up.

Just for example Monte Irvin in the Hall of Fame is a very nice guy, but the last fifteen years in this working life he worked for Bowie Kuhn. You wouldn’t vote for me would you? And it’s not just Monte Irvin. There are people on the Cubs and people on the Red Sox and Hall of Fame who have worked for management and are working for management. There’s this fine great ball player in the Hall of Fame, who’s vice president of a major league team and so on.

And then there are members of the press who vote who are the newspaper reporters wing of the Hall of Fame. While some of those might vote for me many would not. There were a lot of them who were, if not in the owners’ pockets, at least on their laps. There are the radio and TV announcers who interestingly enough in almost every case cannot be announcers in radio and TV unless the clubs that they are telecasting or broadcasting agree. They hold the veto power over them.

And then finally, if all else fails, to make anybody understand how the votes go, if you have to get 75% of the vote and you do what the Hall of Fame people did two years ago or a year ago, put fifteen people on the ballot. You are making it almost statistically improbable that anyone is going to get 75% of the vote and in fact, no one did.

In the history of the United States, this is just to give you a contrast, while occasionally there are three candidates or four candidates, in most cases there are two. And with only two candidates on the ballot, except for George Washington in his first term, who ran unopposed, with only two people on the ballot--in all the rest of the elections no presidential candidate ever got anywhere near 75% of the vote.

BizBall: Do you feel that there will ever be a truly independent commissioner like we saw in Kenesaw Landis?

Miller: I don’t think there’s ever been an independent commissioner, including Landis. If you think about it at all, it was never meant to be that way. Landis had some assets that enabled him to  appear to be independent. That is, there was a fear asset. Baseball was truly shaken by the Black Sox scandal. And they felt grateful to be able to get a federal judge to come off the bench and become commissioner. And what they never wanted to have happen was to have a former federal judge like Landis resign and blast them for something and so that gave him a certain power. But he was never truly independent. Nor can any commissioner be independent when he doesn’t have a dime in the game. Things don’t work that way. If the owners of the game who own franchises disapprove of a commissioner it’s the simplest thing in the world to get rid of him, contract or no contract, it’s simply about paying off the contract, and every commissioner knows that. The result is that every commissioner except Landis, who died in office and Bart Giamatti who died in office after a short term, every commissioner sooner or later is fired. It’s not always reported that way. Sometimes it’s reported as a failure to renew his contract. Sometimes it’s reported as a suggestion that he take a pension and retire. Sometimes it’s more frank than that; he’s fired. But looked at realistically, except for the two who have died in office, everyone has been fired except the present one and eventually he will be too.

BizBall: What do you feel Bud Selig’s legacy will be?

Miller: (chuckles) Well, you know it’s hard to know what Selig’s legacy will be. You know I am absolutely amused at the way media treats people when they’re gone. You know. I think the Reagan fiasco is a case in point. How they will treat Selig after he’s gone, I don’t know. I am concerned that he has just been oblivious to the danger and the damage done by ignoring the conflict of interest that’s involved. I think that is a permanent damage. How historians will treat that, I do not know.

BizBall: What about your legacy? Have you had time to reflect on that? Is that something you care to look upon or comment about?

Miller: (chuckles) Well, you know every once in awhile you are forced to when you get to be my age. I’m referring to the fact that former commissioner Fay Vincent is involved in a project now, in connection with the Hall of Fame, in which he is interviewing various living people, obviously, who have had a part in baseball history. They are doing this project on film for the benefit of future generations of fans and scholars. As Fay said, when you do a project of this type, you interview the older members first, (laughs) to make sure they are still around. Certainly, you are forced to think about this, but in terms of things I would hope for, is that I would be remembered in terms of having playing a major part in building the first legitimate and still remaining the only legitimate trade Union in the team sports movement. A Union that has demonstrated to be one of great solidarity and integrity and unity and accomplishment. And that’s good enough.

The following interview was originally published on the SABR Business of Baseball website, and can be read here: SABR Business of Baseball Interviews Page

Interview conducted by Maury Brown on 7/13/04. Edited by Jeff Sackmann.



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?