pyridium discount code what is hoodia in green tea clonidine side effects autism cytotec drug schedule buy artane without a prescription from canadian pharmacy is fincar legal in uk buy no prescription fast delivery accutane mg nizagara uk on line what is yagara dog amoxicillin no prescription how much does prandin cost generic zyban no prescription low dose amitriptyline weight cheap accutane acne severe etodolac online coupon code adalat oros costo buy nitroglycerin without prescription getting zanaflex in australia stieva-a side effects giant eagle pharmacy $4 generic where to purchase fluoxetine moduretic tablets for dogs ordering generic cialis online prescription clomid no rx cabgolin 0.5 mg zovirax generic wikipedia drugs buy procardia xl orlistat tablets 120mg buy levitra super active quick allegra d shortage common birth control pills brand names aciclovir echeck buy brand elocon jogos do friv 10000 prednisolone cost in india depo provera reviews 2010 hoodia visa promethazine dosage in children flovent coupons gsk where can i purchase entocort ordering cystone buying glycomet in manchester where can i purchase aciclovir generic for ranitidine roxithromycin suppliers overseas illegal buy rx online biaxin online in us cipla finpecia uk canadian alliance of british pensioners ottawa levitra super active generic for viagra from pfizer in pakistan proventil coupon printable acai max dose over the counter ciprofloxacin hcl purinethol brand positioning buy abilify 20 mg prescription order lamisil from orlistat side effects liver xenical prices at costco why has brafix been discontinued what is the average cost of cymbalta birth control pills phenergan wellbutrin tablets xenical 120 mg dose current price brahmi atomoxetine review cialis daily use formulary canadian donde puedo comprar effexor xr forzest tablets 40mg buy ephedraxin 50 viagra soft cost comparison class action lawsuit zoloft pregnancy indian pharmacy tadapox diabecon canada prescription kamagra dosage recommended generic trazodone sleep can i buy cytotec over the counter in the philippines zovirax cream dosage buy cleocin gel 40 what does meclizine treat can zetia get you high minocycline manufacturer in india what does allegra drug antihistamine canada price buy lamisil top 5 drugstore mascaras atorlip-10 canadian medications without prescription indian pharmacy depakote scadenza brevetto viagra in italia arimidex over the counter australia finax online meds keflex discount voucher doxycycline hyclate side effects Purchase proscar 1 mg levitra plus next day shipping all types valtrex pills can i buy atarax in europe cytotec misoprostol precio venezuela buy vpxl online thru paypals generic elocon us rumalaya for dogs buy desyrel without a script order dostinex 1mg side effects of prednisone on fetus can buy anacin online xalatan price canada buy cheap trandate where artane clomid for women who already ovulate cost of minocycline 100mg low cost myambutol metformin rxp can hyzaar get you high what does benemid do paroxetine price walmart proscar online canadian online pharmacy for aleve can you get zocor where can i buy acai berry supplements in canada cymbalta cod overnight delivery how much is apcalis sx tablets discount procardia reglan next day cheap genuine amoxil online amitriptyline 20 mg ibs what is the meaning of allied health professionals what is cytotec 200 microgram tablets used for purchase torsemide online yasmin dose birth control revatio viagra prevacid pharmacy prices list where can i buy alli diet pills in england purchase xalatan cheap crestor without prescription miami ginette-35 uses medication nitrofurantoin price increase how to pay by check on paypal diclofenac combination paracetamol can you order viagra plus lipitor discount card 2010 stilnox online order viagra jelly overnight suhagra mail order india what does taking baclofen feel like buy celexa 80 mg online buy mevacor online amazon buy amaryllis plants 100mg clomid ovulation mifepristone misoprostol buy uk order inhalers online no prescription order zoloft online without prescription buy betnovate cream uk buy starlix mexican pharmacies plavix for sale uk 450 mg wellbutrin weight loss cost of celexa in ontario flovent inhaler price us ethionamide online canadian zebeta prescribing information buy generic protonix where to buy yasmin in canada safely diclofenaco 50 mg dosis nin~os ezetimibe 10 mg day astrazeneca nexium discount pulmicort daily use reviews buy goldshield eltroxin online walmart actos prices list of tesco stores selling brand amoxil cheap aciphex 20 mg how to buy saw palmetto buy revia prednisone overseas buy zyban without rx buy mentax pills online list of all oral birth control pills order avodart rx uk online pharmacies guide where purchase glyset cheapest actoplus met paypal cheap rx glasses nyc valtrex tablets pregnancy where to buy gasex online usa diltiazem mechanism of action free nexium medicine lioresal canada head office acivir no prescription overnight delivery doryx and drinking alcohol best natural viagra pills worldwide pharmacy citalopram lidocaine infusion side effects prometrium in the uk now domperidone and drinking alcohol coumadin in the uk now snovitra super power refill pack order viagra from india without prescription trental over counter my buspar coupons viamedic ad girl vermox buy without is aldactone available on line in canada has best price cialis does viagra really work erection unisom drugs online purchases mylan a1 pill is xanax online sale of lotrisone comprar exelon online buy nizoral 4 shampoo online renagel drug store online naltrexone hydrochloride information most reliable place to buy lipitor online amoxil for men sale in uk cialis bph package insert tenormin pill canadian starting clomid without period horse ivermectin for pigs arimidex pct forum how much is generic singulair at walmart medicine calan products buy online long time side effects cipro cardura pill shortage cialis reviews 20 mg chloroquine prices usa buy fosamax greece can you order aciclovir rx relief pharmacy discount card necesito comprar cytotec en venezuela elimination half life of levothyroxine habana hospital pharmacy inc furosemide medicine online blood diovan medication pressure combivent lowest price do keflex pills smell order plavix without prescription purchase effexor xr on line in uk keppra 100mg tablet buy dipyridamole without a script divya pharmacy brahmi ivermectin horse wormer for dogs pharmacy that sells cardizem vermox plus contraindicaciones alcohol ivermectin for horses side effects flomax shortage 2012 aciclovir 200-1a pharma 100 buy arimidex paypal side effects of lexapro in men post cycle therapy cleocin augmentin online legally us online pharmacy no prescription brand levitra can i take other medications with claritin cost of viagra in spain levothroid lawsuit medicine minipress xl reviews on celexa is zyrtec a class b drug can you buy dulcolax in ireland pletal australia price can you buy combivent over the counter in germany cost of plavix generic order metoclopramide pills azulfidine roche precio argentina buy diakof pills online how long to take cephalexin for uti buy nitrofurantoin tablets online buspar usa sale clomid success stories-pregnancy info wellbutrin australia florida alliance for renewable energy cheap allegra d 24 hour relief all types celadrin pills avodart side effects in men brand celebrex buy where to buy zithromax drugs online synthroid in the uk now anafranil drugstore cheap viagra super active india can you take 30 mg cialis bactroban canada no prescription malaseb wipes for cats can you get fertility drugs over the counter discount canadian pharmacy finax buy femara letrozole tablets printable alli coupons 2010 original silagra online zebeta lawsuit canada where to buy calandre perfume buy 120 uk alli diet lopid tablets for purchase cheapest place to get accutane side effects of aricept 23 vasotec without prescription miami what is the daily dosage for propecia how to take prometrium to get pregnant buy clozaril overseas zyrtec over the counter seroquel 25mg can you only get retin-a 0,025 on prescription phenergan low cost free birth control online no prescription allopurinol tablets usp monograph united states based online pharmacies paxil usa cvs prices lamisil cream for sale buy glucophage with visa albenza online usa safe place order zithromax best high blood pressure medication cymbalta weight gain the drugstore pharmacy is levitra better than viagra discount phenergan mg kohler med cabinet florida state alligator facts canada drugstore neurontin discount coupons best online pharmacy generic didronel is ditropan available on line in canada where to buy cialis in kl best place to buy alligator clips them mircette no rx suhagra lawsuit diamox online cheap pariet canada no prescription generic viagra review forums online pharmacy to buy florinef endep without rx walmart pharmacy hours peoria il cheap kamagra gold usa how to treat chlamydia and gonorrhea buy asics online usa to australia cheap nizagara free delivery where can i buy levothroid tablets is there a stimulant like viagra for women when will diovan hct become generic nitroglycerin tablet sale actoplus met in the uk safe glucotrol no prescription is mail order zantac safe pharmacy that sells trandate cialis dosage daily use order triamterene online uk levitra professional by mail guaranteed can you get high off omnicef what is purim about non prescription prograf pharmacy purchase abilify cheap dipyridamole suppositories buy online rumalaya liniment purchase how to purchase albendazole top rated over the counter e.d. pills entocort steroid medicine donde puedo comprar las pastillas de cytotec what is better for hair loss avodart or propecia ordering accutane india finax overnight delivery moduretic uses medication cafergot formulation allopurinol suppliers overseas original compazine online buy risperdal from canada tetracycline price canadian asthma inhalers that dont require prescription cheap phenergan india buying paroxetine in manchester what does sarafem treat very cheap trazodone buy amoxil online no prescription uk how to purchase dramamine online hydrochlorothiazide to buy in england prednisone asthma children purchase pariet mg citalopram common side effects renagel usa cvs prices avapro dosage high endep side effects australia flagyl er online pharmacy uk india pharmacies online that sell brand viagra side effects of claritin diarrhea augmentin 625 duo india in order to prove that motrin and ibuprofen are substitutes one should test the brand tulasi buy haridra coupons where to get kamagra oral jelly cialis sublingual discount voucher where to purchase diclofenac how much does avodart cost missed clozaril doses generic clozaril paypal allopurinol generico italiano buy zanaflex online india orlistat in stock generic drugs for flomax where to get live scan in petaluma ca xeloda non perscription countries us online pharmacy no prescription benzac buy stromectol 100mg online exelon shop net can you buy avandamet online safe place order vermox lioresal 40mg advantage of atorvastatin or simvastatin billig lopid online kaufen nexium store interaction drugstore prescription drug celebrex side effects cost of erythromycin ophthalmic ointment unisom express canada nizoral anti dandruff shampoo cvs buy hydrochlorothiazide pills in the uk what drug category is norvasc para que es omifin 50 mg buy cialis super active discount resources for cordarone viagra professional women buy wellbutrin lawsuit 2012 over the counter claritin dosage erythromycin discount no prescription arimidex on line for sale no script order seroquel xr online what is diclofenac gel tablets cheap buy skelaxin online without difference between coumadin generic warfarin cipro online overnight shipping para que sirve el medicamento aciclovir en crema actos drug prices clomiphene citrate pregnancy success imitrex pills cost supreme suppliers sagar avenue amoxil legal in england yeast infection pills over the counter for men meclizine hydrochloride in canada is toradol 10 mg a narcotic pastas para adelgazar xerograx cheap generic viagra professional best place to buy revia generic name for prilosec otc no rx aleve online cheap kamagra sale atorlip-5 in croatia flovent women buy tadalis sx buy canada valtrex coupons 2010 cheap acivir pills buy online how much does cialis daily cost where to buy phenamax revia capsules colchicine dosage fmf bentyl drugstore methotrexate from china cialis 10 mg for sale walgreens mail order pharmacy keflex 250 mg alcohol tofranil without script liquid dramamine review resources for lady era lamisil over counter medicine aleese birth control online without a prescription erythromycin at discount pharmacies buy zerit greece can order revia canada buy dramamine liquid revatio cost comparison generic viagra information on robaxin medication buy abilify generic naprosyn 250 mg tabletta where purchase alesse atarax hydroxyzine hydrochloride buying snovitra super power in manchester lotensin order by phone genuine viagra uk suppliers best place buy omnicef what is the generic name for januvia cheap shallaki buy online claritin online ordering vermox dosage ireland the online drugstore aricept albuterol sulfate inhalation aerosol side effects ponstel side effects uk ovary pain after ovulation on clomid craigslist northern virginia usa how to use lotrisone zoloft echeck buy amantadine perth australia flagyl er cheap uk to buy diltiazem cheap viagra uk only dapoxetine online overnight shipping como comprar florinefe venlor cheap price coreg where can i buy buy venlor online cheap zithromax legal us what is astelin pills used for buy seroquel online no prescription canada sumycin generico online cost of calcium carbonate in india overnight pharmacy cheap bentyl view topic zyprexa with prescription uk cheap alesse online pharmacy mexican flomax accutane dosage mg anti anxiety drugs no side effects what is the medicine carafate used for buying propecia cheap online lasix injection im zentel prospect sirop zebeta medicine buy lanoxin 100mg online best place buy trileptal acticin no prescription needed himcolin pills does cialis 2.5 mg work flagyl er comprar cleocin t topical solution over counter purchase depo provera shot paypal buy now button with options viagra super active over the counter drugs aceon online uk atrovent nasal spray uk maximum dose of wellbutrin xl legal buy prograf online canada generic urispas in usa menosan pas cher much does paroxetine cost without insurance sibutramine 15mg buy slow release metformin canada can zithromax be purchased over the counter planes medicos de swiss medical buying brand viagra online can i get allegra over the counter buy pink viagra for women discount canadian pharmacy blopress dosage azithromycin cure chlamydia ketoconazole hair loss women order vpxl online without rx fluoxetine order online lov cost paroxetine us online pharmacy no prescription valtrex doryx reviews acne.org buy brand levitra 200 where can i get cialis online side effects of amoxicillin and clavulanate potassium 875 mg side effects of baclofen pump therapy antibiotic doxycycline and alcohol non prescription anti nausea medicine cheap pain meds online no prescription where can i buy differin clomid ovulation day 9 worldwide pharmacy flovent zyban visa long time side effects brahmi top 10 online haldol sites stieva a tretinoin cream 0.025 overseas pharmacy no prescription oxytrol non persciption suprax himalaya evecare medicine buy xeloda pills online what is the medicine cymbalta used for can buy ventolin over counter france quantity aspirin most over counter aspirin products lamisil online terbinafine antifungals nymphomax generic reviews what are the common side effects of depo provera plendil limited india doxycycl hyc 100mg tab for acne metronidazole antibiotics for bacterial infection pharmacy diet pills kamagra oral jelly india manufacturer best place to order viagra sublingual in us safe amoxil buy coumadin on the internet buy micronase from canada arjuna no prescription overnight delivery pilex himalaya use hospital pharmacy jobs buy lady era mexican pharmacies roxithromycin tablets 300mg used buy-viagra-through-paypal german remedies goa snovitra super power overnight pharmacy what is meclizine 12.5 mg why is there a shortage of acivir pills abilify 10 mg vidal augmentin es rxlist sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg malegra pro 100 cam you buy diflucan over the counter in canada altace canadian pharmacy can you buy citalopram over the counter best place to buy celexa without a prescription
Home Maury Brown Baseball Writers Cloud Upcoming McGwire Vote

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 474 guests online

Atom RSS

Baseball Writers Cloud Upcoming McGwire Vote PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 27 November 2006 02:30
Maury BrownWell, let the controversy begin. Or, at least let the members of the BBWAA create some controversy. Yes, Hall of Fame ballots are now in most member’s hands, and with that comes the first votes—or non-votes—for those that played during the steroid era.

So, let’s pass right over Cal Ripken, Jr. and Tony Gwynn, since barring some kind of mental breakdown (something not out of the realm of possibility for the BBWAA), both players should scoot in with nary a hiccup.

No, the big talk will be Mark McGwire and his alleged steroid use.

Let’s take a look at some comments by baseball writers around the US…

Pat Borzi (The NY Times):
I'm seriously considering not voting for McGwire this year. He admitted using andro, and if he doesn't use it, he doesn't stay healthy enough to hit 70 or go over 500.
Here’s the problem with Borzi’s thinking: McGwire wasn’t doing anything wrong at the time. Androstenedione wasn’t banned until after McGwire hit the numbers. Can’t blame McGwire for that one. If that’s the case, are we going to go retroactive when some other yet to be discovered supplement is found to have some adverse performance enhancing side effects? Still, Borzi has a point: legal or illegal, would McGwire’s power numbers have been as high as they were? Without the HR numbers, McGwire is not HOF worthy. Now, when Borzi can tell me how much the numbers were skewed due to andro, maybe we’d be getting somewhere.

Ken Davidoff (NY Newsday):
While I reserve the right to change my mind, I don't anticipate ever voting for him. His conduct during the House Government Reform [Committee] hearing, on March 17, 2006, as well as the revelations of his backroom dealings prior to the hearing, are all the evidence I need to believe that he was a steroid user.

Well, this is a slippery slope. What about others that we all may believe used steroids (but have yet to prove it, or there isn’t the willingness to prove it). Do we start to look at any players that have jacked more than 50 HRs in a season during the era and start excluding them from your vote? Maybe Davidoff won’t vote for Luis Gonzalez if he ever approaches the HOF.

Murray Chass (NY Times):

A difficult deliberation. Although the Times does not allow us to vote, I would probably not vote for McGwire... . He never tested positive, and he has never said, "I used steroids," but his congressional refrain - "I'm not here to talk about the past" - made him look guilty as hell.

The home-run achievements in the steroids era by McGwire, [Sammy] Sosa and Bonds were too far out there to think something underhanded didn't have an effect on their numbers. If they were in the Hall of Fame, they would unfairly skew the measurement of players in future years as well as dwarf the accomplishments of Hall of Famers from the past.

Note to Murray Chass: Pitchers have been found to use performance enhancing drugs more than position players. I assume that Chass won’t be voting (if he could) for Roger Clemens either.

Rick Hummel (St. Louis Post-Dispatch):

McGwire has no chance to get into the Hall this year, not just because of his link to the steroids issue, but the appearance of two clearly better candidates in Gwynn and Ripken.

There is nothing McGwire needs to do - at least not now.

He doesn't have a chance anyway this year, although that is not to say I wouldn't vote for him because I probably will. Next year, however, is different with no standout candidate ahead of McGwire, and we'll have a better barometer of how much the steroids thing has hurt him.

Hummel neatly speaks the truth and sidesteps the matter at the same time. It’s true that Gwynn and Ripken will be slam dunks. But, don’t think for a second that there won’t be a mountain of columns talking about how McGwire’s alleged steroid use was the catalyst for not getting the votes, this point by Hummel aside.

Jayson Stark (ESPN):

I'm going to vote for him. I can't say I feel good about voting for him. But here's why: People have oversimplified this issue, to the point where, if you listened to the way most people talk about it, you'd think there were only 10 players taking any kind of performance-enhancing drugs in the '90s. But we know that, in truth, there were hundreds.

So should I only cast votes against players who happened to get mentioned in Jose Canseco's book or subpoenaed by Congress? What about all the other players who I might suspect were doing something but have never come up in this conversation?

Should I vote only against players who hit home runs or broke home run records or challenged home run records? What about all the pitchers we know were taking something?
I don't see how I can start picking and choosing when, in fact, baseball allowed all of this to happen. So that was the culture inside the game at the time, just as amphetamines were part of the culture in the '60s and '70s and '80s (and beyond).

If more evidence emerges, I always reserve the right to change my mind. But for now, I'm going to cast a very uncomfortable vote for McGwire and, for the most part, every great player of an obviously tainted generation.

Stark may have the comments closest to the truth. Where do you draw the line? How does one, as he says, “pick and choose” if you are basing your vote on something alleged, as opposed to proven.

Here’s my take…

When Palmeiro’s name comes up on the ballot, it’s a no-brainer to vote no. He was caught using steroids, and pays the price. If the Mitchell investigation ever releases its findings, or somehow Greg Anderson snaps and decides to provide direct proof that Barry Bonds used steroids, then there’s your second “no-brainer” criteria. After that, it’s basing a vote on speculation, and as mentioned prior, that’s a slippery slope.

For those that are contending that legal PEDs were used by McGwire and therefore his HR numbers would not be nearly as high without them, you have a point. But, how much did his use of andro impact his numbers? 10%? 20%? 30%? What’s the measure? When there is a way to do more than stick your finger in the wind to see which way the wind blows, then we may have something.

The big question for McGwire may be, does he have enough votes to stay on the ballot next year? Since I’ve given up on trying to figure out any good rationale in how the BBWAA votes for anything these days, I’ll go the finger in the wind route and say, yes.

Maury Brown is the editor of The Biz of Baseball and an author for Baseball Prospectus. He can be contacted here.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?