prednisone 100 mg day valtrex in croatia what is the classification of avalide how to get plavix what is cymbalta mg used to treat buy augmentin no prescription infections cheap generic sustiva apo-minocycline 100mg capsule prescription pain medicine without codeine nimotop maximum dosage does viagra work for young men ethionamide india diabecon pills +buy brand viagra in us get morning after pill over the counter periactin pills used realo discount drugs kinston nc norvasc tablets cost what is micardis pills used for coumadin cost walmart where to buy actos online generic does wellbutrin cause weight gain or loss accutane online mexico pharmacy that sells tadapox buy geriforte syrup hong kong most reputable canadian pharmacy online viagra mail order prescriptions what is clomid steroids buy evecare mexican pharmacies overseas pharmacy no prescription vytorin indian pharmacy capoten flagyl medicines cheap oral jelly australia buy kamagra ciplox in croatia what does cialis cost at walmart sinemet medication order free alavert coupons periactin without prescription miami buy generic viagra from canada what kind of medicine is diovan blopress medication order buy flagyl er 200 what types of zovirax are there 100mg seroquel xr orlistat brands india keflex price australia effexor xr side effects memory ordering suprax here in canada to buy dulcolax in uk pharmaceutical drug salesman viagra official site virus buy buspar quick overseas pharmacy no prescription revatio amoxil online usa no prescription buy generic lotensin cheapest snovitra super power in the uk why is there a shortage of female cialis buy cephalexin pills in the australia amaryl medicine for diabetes norvasc discount code no prescription viagra order buy levaquin online canada no prescription long term side effects of taking mobic where cane i buy alligator clips hair purchase risperdal 2 mg cheap on line viagrpills atarax drug schedule do i need a prescription for vermox certificated anti anxiety pills for cats cialis soft non perscription countries buying ciplox in manchester compazine from india med cab levitra super active xenical spain cialis india generic elavil no prescription where purchase retin-a ge buy cheap viagra using pay pal carafate suspension available generic order glucophage online no presctiption plendil generic release date what aspirin is good for your heart nolvadex express canada tadapox for dogs buy how to get levaquin on line canadian pharmacy differin gel levitra tablet sale stats hell website aleve online coupon code zoloft online order non generic mircette levitra super active non perscription countries i pill mevacor website pharmacy amaryl discounts codes best place to buy ceftin what is clomid bodybuilding can buy keppra online best online pharmacy generic rhinocort buy atorlip-5 in singapore artane castle shopping centre dublin rumalaya gel brands india abilify buy cheap how to get prescriptions online legally generic furosemide safe aceon overnight shipping buy cheap extendaquin online ordering chlamydia treatment azithromycin how long what is terramycin used for in animals can take water pills lose weight crestor woldwide shipping hyzaar 100mg order accutane from canada without prescription order accutane non prescription voltaren maxifort seeds in the uk no prescription cialis soft sale generic furosemide cost what types of pulmicort are there cheap genuine cardizem online buy permethrin spray online river pharmacy canada ldn mexican pharmacy no prescription flagyl er ezetimibe max dose purchase sinemet pills toradol injection how long does it last buy erection packs 3 online thru paypals synthroid us companies only como comprar hyzaar where to buy clonidine drugs online mylan-fluconazole and alcohol voveran sr perth australia levitra brand usa buy cialis sublingual uk antivert australia price fml forte india where to buy penicillin vk 500 mg buy chloromycetin drugs how to use neurontin buy nolvadex uk bodybuilding generic zithromax for sale what is flagyl er 750 mg benzac ac gel india emsam usa cvs prices hyzaar medication used buy reglan from mexico online when will plavix be available in generic form no prescription cheap buy innopran xl online Purchase adalat 50 mg all types benadryl pills shot called liquid viagra buy clonidine hcl certified is acai berry better than blackberry plavix prescription help does micardis hct cause weight gain zofran coupons brand amoxil online order levaquin prix en pharmacie en france provera mexico companies only online forum order cheap zyrtec suggested retail price viagra can you take plendil daily motilium domperidone no prescription flovent hfa price alesse low dose ethinyl estradiol how long after taking viagra does it start to work buy capoten inhaler canada lamictal dose pack green nitroglycerin ointment in india order entocort online uk which uk site to buy pletal accutane lawsuit canada 2010 how much does a 30 day supply of nexium cost
Home Maury Brown Baseball Writers Cloud Upcoming McGwire Vote

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 899 guests online

Atom RSS

Baseball Writers Cloud Upcoming McGwire Vote PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 27 November 2006 02:30
Maury BrownWell, let the controversy begin. Or, at least let the members of the BBWAA create some controversy. Yes, Hall of Fame ballots are now in most member’s hands, and with that comes the first votes—or non-votes—for those that played during the steroid era.

So, let’s pass right over Cal Ripken, Jr. and Tony Gwynn, since barring some kind of mental breakdown (something not out of the realm of possibility for the BBWAA), both players should scoot in with nary a hiccup.

No, the big talk will be Mark McGwire and his alleged steroid use.

Let’s take a look at some comments by baseball writers around the US…

Pat Borzi (The NY Times):
I'm seriously considering not voting for McGwire this year. He admitted using andro, and if he doesn't use it, he doesn't stay healthy enough to hit 70 or go over 500.
Here’s the problem with Borzi’s thinking: McGwire wasn’t doing anything wrong at the time. Androstenedione wasn’t banned until after McGwire hit the numbers. Can’t blame McGwire for that one. If that’s the case, are we going to go retroactive when some other yet to be discovered supplement is found to have some adverse performance enhancing side effects? Still, Borzi has a point: legal or illegal, would McGwire’s power numbers have been as high as they were? Without the HR numbers, McGwire is not HOF worthy. Now, when Borzi can tell me how much the numbers were skewed due to andro, maybe we’d be getting somewhere.

Ken Davidoff (NY Newsday):
While I reserve the right to change my mind, I don't anticipate ever voting for him. His conduct during the House Government Reform [Committee] hearing, on March 17, 2006, as well as the revelations of his backroom dealings prior to the hearing, are all the evidence I need to believe that he was a steroid user.

Well, this is a slippery slope. What about others that we all may believe used steroids (but have yet to prove it, or there isn’t the willingness to prove it). Do we start to look at any players that have jacked more than 50 HRs in a season during the era and start excluding them from your vote? Maybe Davidoff won’t vote for Luis Gonzalez if he ever approaches the HOF.

Murray Chass (NY Times):

A difficult deliberation. Although the Times does not allow us to vote, I would probably not vote for McGwire... . He never tested positive, and he has never said, "I used steroids," but his congressional refrain - "I'm not here to talk about the past" - made him look guilty as hell.

The home-run achievements in the steroids era by McGwire, [Sammy] Sosa and Bonds were too far out there to think something underhanded didn't have an effect on their numbers. If they were in the Hall of Fame, they would unfairly skew the measurement of players in future years as well as dwarf the accomplishments of Hall of Famers from the past.

Note to Murray Chass: Pitchers have been found to use performance enhancing drugs more than position players. I assume that Chass won’t be voting (if he could) for Roger Clemens either.

Rick Hummel (St. Louis Post-Dispatch):

McGwire has no chance to get into the Hall this year, not just because of his link to the steroids issue, but the appearance of two clearly better candidates in Gwynn and Ripken.

There is nothing McGwire needs to do - at least not now.

He doesn't have a chance anyway this year, although that is not to say I wouldn't vote for him because I probably will. Next year, however, is different with no standout candidate ahead of McGwire, and we'll have a better barometer of how much the steroids thing has hurt him.

Hummel neatly speaks the truth and sidesteps the matter at the same time. It’s true that Gwynn and Ripken will be slam dunks. But, don’t think for a second that there won’t be a mountain of columns talking about how McGwire’s alleged steroid use was the catalyst for not getting the votes, this point by Hummel aside.

Jayson Stark (ESPN):

I'm going to vote for him. I can't say I feel good about voting for him. But here's why: People have oversimplified this issue, to the point where, if you listened to the way most people talk about it, you'd think there were only 10 players taking any kind of performance-enhancing drugs in the '90s. But we know that, in truth, there were hundreds.

So should I only cast votes against players who happened to get mentioned in Jose Canseco's book or subpoenaed by Congress? What about all the other players who I might suspect were doing something but have never come up in this conversation?

Should I vote only against players who hit home runs or broke home run records or challenged home run records? What about all the pitchers we know were taking something?
I don't see how I can start picking and choosing when, in fact, baseball allowed all of this to happen. So that was the culture inside the game at the time, just as amphetamines were part of the culture in the '60s and '70s and '80s (and beyond).

If more evidence emerges, I always reserve the right to change my mind. But for now, I'm going to cast a very uncomfortable vote for McGwire and, for the most part, every great player of an obviously tainted generation.

Stark may have the comments closest to the truth. Where do you draw the line? How does one, as he says, “pick and choose” if you are basing your vote on something alleged, as opposed to proven.

Here’s my take…

When Palmeiro’s name comes up on the ballot, it’s a no-brainer to vote no. He was caught using steroids, and pays the price. If the Mitchell investigation ever releases its findings, or somehow Greg Anderson snaps and decides to provide direct proof that Barry Bonds used steroids, then there’s your second “no-brainer” criteria. After that, it’s basing a vote on speculation, and as mentioned prior, that’s a slippery slope.

For those that are contending that legal PEDs were used by McGwire and therefore his HR numbers would not be nearly as high without them, you have a point. But, how much did his use of andro impact his numbers? 10%? 20%? 30%? What’s the measure? When there is a way to do more than stick your finger in the wind to see which way the wind blows, then we may have something.

The big question for McGwire may be, does he have enough votes to stay on the ballot next year? Since I’ve given up on trying to figure out any good rationale in how the BBWAA votes for anything these days, I’ll go the finger in the wind route and say, yes.

Maury Brown is the editor of The Biz of Baseball and an author for Baseball Prospectus. He can be contacted here.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?