duloxetine hcl dr buying clomid online uk albuterol nebulizer treatment for children maxifort zimax reviews fucidin cream antibiotic uses orlistat side effects in children epanutin injection site levitra 20mg there shortage alli rx online tetracyline no presp flazol 500 tablets best canadian pharcharmy online reviews wellbutrin withdrawal how long marijuana and cialis where to buy albendazole over the counter mobic side effects 15mg metoprolol tartrate 25mg tab skelaxin 800 mg drug levitra prezzi in farmacia glipizide side effects medication what is flagyl 500mg used for metronidazole 500mg tablets amazon esomeprazole sodium iv retirides reviews adalat serial viagra pills cost viagra in the united states canadian companies selling viagra arthritis gloves thermoskin reviews ephedraxin inforum paypal to purchase viagra lynoral tablets under $100 leconfield house curzon street apartments viagra naturale prezzo rabeprazole sodium 20mg zithromax antibiotic price metoprolol succ er beprogel lotion lotrel 10 20 mg side effects where to buy lasix order zestril lisinopril lipvas 20 hydroxyzine for dogs order generic viagra bupropion hcl xl 300 mg costs cuvarlix reviews robaxin without a script tricilest composition notebooks cefaclor 250mg cap antabuse alcohol drugs risperdal long term side effects in children cabaser vs dostinex best drugstore makeup remover effect of paracetamol in pregnancy proviron cycle cialis online express post levitra discount salazopyrin sulfasalazine ec comprar accutane in usa duroval sildenafil generic kino onlain cuvarlix review of 50 phenergan dm cough syrup norlevo torrinomedica indiceschede terbinafine hydrochloride cream 1 clomid without a rx sunsuria berhad meaning when will alli be back for sale atacand without prescription therapy management corporation email pentrexyl 500mg furacin ointment ingredients cheap plan b pill cuckold creek hollywood md 1742 buy tinidazole 500mg jasmine villegas india pharmacy paypal female viagra in london accutane lawsuit settlements floxin otic solution 0 3 month swimsuits precose dosage of aspirin buy tetracycline in the uk how much are viagra pills januvia merck patients metformin avodart hair loss fda ocgs zanzibar amoxil australia abilify bipolar aripiprazole name brand cialis online viagra cheap euro antibiotics online uk cheap ivermectin buy clomid cheap genuine clomid online what is the difference between sotalol and sotalol af where to buy viagra in calgary duroval sildenafil 100mg faridexon fortessafasigyn percocet vs vicodin cialis black pills tadalafil rezeptfrei cefaclor suspension storage voltaren 50 mg buy online prednisone paypal chewable visgra accutane online best price 40 mg medsindia reviews rizatriptan 10 mg tablet starcef capsulectomy lisinopril side effects heart health antibiotics and birth control nuva ring very cheap no prescription viagra amikacin injection over the counter inhaler 2013 cephalexin and alcohol side effects sublingual sildenafil citrate dermasone betamethasone valerate ointment content marketing strategy pharmacy express corp vardenafil hcl 20mg dosage xenical mail order india metallica black album zyvox side effects medications clavamox without a prescription paracetamol drug study scribd naprosyn medication side effects prometrium 200 mg during pregnancy amoxicillin no script meds myambutol medicine shoppe buy provera and clomid online viagra en chile tenormin atenolol lopressor metoprolol inderal propranolol corgard nadolol super silagra brand viagra pfizer sale anastrozole for sale indocin 25mg gout cheap online meds no prescription prednisolone eye drops side effects in dogs avelox for sinus infection myambutol manufacturer abbreviation asacol hd cialis 5 mg best prices sunsuria berhad toprol xl 25 mg metoprolol succinate buy flunitrazepam zestoretic 20 12.5mg cialis canada paypal fasigyn 500mg information cymbalta antidepressant dosage newhealthyman complaints canadian drugs no prescription oracea 40 mg coupons online pharmacy that accept paypal elavil for sleep aid clomid paypal apcalis sx 20mg jellyfish mupirocin 2 ointment 22gm sibutramin sildenafil tadalafil nedir viagra without side effects acyclovir side effects hair loss best on line pharmacy generic pills for exenical diane kruger measurements buy viagra cod fluoxetine prozac flovent coupons glaxosmithkline medical web prescriptions viagra famvir dosage yasminelle ulotka is mebendazole over the counter lergigan company generika apotheke deutschland vibramycin medication side effects erythromisin where to buy viagra price in south africa firide finasteride canada drug levitra no prescription tadalafil lowest price tryptizol 25mg viagra antabuse natural alternatives lisinopril medication liposafe ingredients to die albenza couponsuzy goodrx comparison magnesium rich foods for dogs combivent at reasonable prices cytotec malaysia pharmacy dilantin pain killers trileptal dosage oxcarbazepine carafate for dogs need refrigerated buying levitra tablets buy orlistat online without script cheap prednisone without prescription omeprazole 40 mg capsule otc metronidazole for dogs no rx remeron dosage strengths costco locations in washington state cabaser dosage cycle sublingual nitroglycerin spray colospan tablet for kids captopril renal scan hypertension zanaflex tizanidine erowid metoprolol succinate er 100 mg tabs zyvox coupon card octreotide scan images paxil online buying overnight delivery erection pills walmart buy lexapro without prescription aricept generic name and drug classifications viagra indian market lady era tadalafil powder bulk synthroid no prescription needed in usa avelox antibiotic law suits over night delivery anti biotics nexium side effects symptoms forum esomeprazole is there a generic form of optimmune eye ointment for dogs onadron simple interest arimidex vs tamoxifen for pct can i order viagra online metrogel cream rosacea aciphex medication side effects viagra next day delivery calgary digoxin toxicity and potassium naproxen sodium 500 mg iv drugs without prescription ranbaxy lipitor recall list buy alli cheap online rx hotline oracea side effects rosacea estradiol side effects risk reglan 10mg uses sildenafil citrate ripoffs rimadyl dosage for dogs after surgery the canadian pharmacy no prescription antibiotics online vitamin k2 benefits esquina carlos gardel cena show cheap adhd medication from canada pinamox caps 500mg amoxicillin dosage no script lasix hyzaar side effects lupus vigrande 50 mg fluoxetine prozac side effects memory loss caffeine pills and alcohol clomiphene citrate shop advantage real estate sumter sc ranigast lektire no presciption doxycycline 651 filagra super active ortho tri cyclen lo purchase online buy 1 mg propecia losartan potassium hydrochlorothiazide hyzaar trazodone sleep aid side effects androgel side effects androgel bodybuilding real viagra pills valium dosages online cialis scams software engineering projects min ovral 28oxazepam uk suppliers of amoxicillin avana apartment north hollywood free viagra no script needed licodexon obat sakit buy lasix from mexico tesco chemist online diltiazem cd capsule terramicina oftalmologica pfizer erectalis cipla share buy claravis online buy generic propecia 1mg puppies for sale in wisconsin myambutol medication identification ecco contact center sertraline zoloft ingredients approved canadian pharmacies online generic cialis tadalafil 20mg canadian pharmacy support net estrogen without a prescription cheap viagra overnight delivery medrol canadian no prescription proviron steroidology pilocarpine ocular system pic extenze free sample pack ht flagyl pills produit 62 spiriva side effects drug want to buy levitra evista medication side effects doxycycline over the counter antivert vertigo symptoms estrace cream reviews cycline antibiotics family order fluoxetine online himalaya himcolin gel use in hindi amoxicillin without a script billig viagra online bestellen content definition translations folcres panalab laboratorios how to buy virga 50mg viagra plus ciales puerto rico pictures of cultures zyban smoking cessation reviews norlevo pill emergency contraception buy brand pfizer viagra nimesulide extended release tablets prednisone 20mg side effects taper mometasone furoate cream usp .1 prescriptions without a script latisse price compare remeron side effects in elderly lamotrigine medication for depression comprar viagra en valencia cialis orlando for sale levamisole hydrochloride for sheep wellbutrin for anxiety disorders free viagra sample no perscription phentermine diet pills for sale roxifen capsules nespresso hoodia cvs pharmacy metformin weight loss diet hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg for sale z pack dosing schedule vigora 100 how to use esquina nyc review chemistry surf famvir 500mg vs valtrex moduretic drugstore cicloferon tabletas omifin embarazo de gemelos mes aggrenox medication and plavix prednisone purchase cialis montreal antabuse drug test mometasone furoate cream usp 0.1 uses fluoxetine 10mg for cats pravastatin sodium 20mg zentel liquid benicar medication generic drugs obestat meridiano zenegra reviews on 50 generic cialis 40 mg doxycap capsulectomy premarin tablets 1.25 viagra omeopatico ovral emergency contraception pravastatin sodium 80 mg side effects evista side effects long term translate google http trustedstoreon cheap pfizer viagra online comment du kamagra generic cialis for sale online cheapest price for vardenafil 10mg canada wellbutrin sr no rx doxitab side effects levaquin vs zithromax for sinus infection cialis for performance anxiety yasminelle pillola order doxycycline without prescription cytotec in ireland sinequanone dresses orange buy zofran canada lesofat vs xenical reviews cipro 500mg generic sildenafil citrate cheap viagra without a script paypal pharmacy viagra generique inde sample free herbal viagra metformin group meds order propecia online mastercard where do i buy diflucan alli refill clonidine medication for children aricept side effects treatment erectile dysfunction drugs best online buy cheap viagra from india suhagra 50 enalapril maleate 10 mg farmacies in tijuana phone nunmbers accutane after 20 years cipro mail order noroxin antibiotic for uti harga nizoral tablet london drugs canada electronics rx canada 365 arthrotec 75 mg prospect anastrozole 1 mg treatment for men priligy taiwan buy avodart online canada losartan hydrochlorothiazide generic spiriva handihaler medication valium 5mg dosage medicinenet com doctorsmedicpillsmedicstar mobic 7.5 mg meloxicam chlamydia symptoms men untreated acivir tablets cozaar generic brand onlaintv ntv7 adderall xr dosage side effects purchase antabuse canada no prescripton zantac england misoprostol for miscarriage side effects generic pharmacy belize domperidone maleate used prednisone and pregnancy risks cheap orlistat 120mg cardizem cd generic equivalent benzaclin alternative ebay cheap kamagra uk prednisone 40mg amerimedrx discount tire benadryl for dogs for anxiety buy propranolol without a prescription overnite pharmacy 4 u when will viagra prices go down 365 pills netabana viprogra review order tretinoin 0 1 cream online terramycin ophthalmic ointment naproxen 500mg uses images danazol treatment for gynecomastia dapoxetine india online what cialis vendor can i trust 100 mg tadalafil clonazepam buy online free world pharmacy himcolin cream puffs generic daily use cialis arcoxia tablets information milnacipran hcl cost salbutamol information side effects minoxidil 2 topical treatment fosamax lawsuit otc equivalent to singular pharmaceutical companies selling viagra milnacipran hydrochloride msds extenze male enhancement liquid shot amoxicillin and alcohol interactions protonix side effects symptoms rayh health care pvt ltd viagra allopurinol dosage for chronic gout vigora 100 citrate of magnesia how long does it take to work xenical side effects pharmacy propecia generic prednisone withdrawal symptoms for dogs aprovel acheter wikipedia zyprexa withdrawal symptoms viagra generic india where to buy erythromycin rapharmacy reviews on vigrx clindamycin phosphate gel 1 side effects ketorolaco trometamina en espanol colchicine 175 no script doxepin for dogs omnicef for strep throat anxiety attacks in children indian cochcine doxepin side effects weight gain what is the generic for carvedilol buy finasteride australia debit card elomet ointment 0.1 ciprobay 500 antibiotics cialis pills tricilest uk yahoo how to buy flagyl 500 mg tadalafil online reliable reglan lawsuits tardive dyskinesia picareta de diamante minecraft wiki celecoxib drug side effects cipla mumbai india how much viagra should i take diamox dosage rogaine side effects omaggio hadley 1993 cefalexina para que serve article 56 viagra erectile disfunction cialis medication approved by fda contrave diet pill available anxiety disorder symptoms and treatment mincorp plcb tretinoin gel with no prescription amerimedrx online pharmacy levothroid dosage forms ciprodex otic suspension 7.5 ml pharmacy technician certification texas yasmin deliz gallery cymbalta and weight gain drugs medameds viagra commercial actress order pills online voltaren gel side effects medication canada pharmacy viagra without script tabletten gegen hautpilz bilder ovral generic name z pak no prescription cefalexina bula rapidtabs reviews on apidexin online pharmacy no prescription canada
Home Maury Brown Baseball Writers Cloud Upcoming McGwire Vote

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 674 guests online

Atom RSS

Baseball Writers Cloud Upcoming McGwire Vote PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 27 November 2006 02:30
Maury BrownWell, let the controversy begin. Or, at least let the members of the BBWAA create some controversy. Yes, Hall of Fame ballots are now in most member’s hands, and with that comes the first votes—or non-votes—for those that played during the steroid era.

So, let’s pass right over Cal Ripken, Jr. and Tony Gwynn, since barring some kind of mental breakdown (something not out of the realm of possibility for the BBWAA), both players should scoot in with nary a hiccup.

No, the big talk will be Mark McGwire and his alleged steroid use.

Let’s take a look at some comments by baseball writers around the US…

Pat Borzi (The NY Times):
I'm seriously considering not voting for McGwire this year. He admitted using andro, and if he doesn't use it, he doesn't stay healthy enough to hit 70 or go over 500.
Here’s the problem with Borzi’s thinking: McGwire wasn’t doing anything wrong at the time. Androstenedione wasn’t banned until after McGwire hit the numbers. Can’t blame McGwire for that one. If that’s the case, are we going to go retroactive when some other yet to be discovered supplement is found to have some adverse performance enhancing side effects? Still, Borzi has a point: legal or illegal, would McGwire’s power numbers have been as high as they were? Without the HR numbers, McGwire is not HOF worthy. Now, when Borzi can tell me how much the numbers were skewed due to andro, maybe we’d be getting somewhere.

Ken Davidoff (NY Newsday):
While I reserve the right to change my mind, I don't anticipate ever voting for him. His conduct during the House Government Reform [Committee] hearing, on March 17, 2006, as well as the revelations of his backroom dealings prior to the hearing, are all the evidence I need to believe that he was a steroid user.

Well, this is a slippery slope. What about others that we all may believe used steroids (but have yet to prove it, or there isn’t the willingness to prove it). Do we start to look at any players that have jacked more than 50 HRs in a season during the era and start excluding them from your vote? Maybe Davidoff won’t vote for Luis Gonzalez if he ever approaches the HOF.

Murray Chass (NY Times):

A difficult deliberation. Although the Times does not allow us to vote, I would probably not vote for McGwire... . He never tested positive, and he has never said, "I used steroids," but his congressional refrain - "I'm not here to talk about the past" - made him look guilty as hell.

The home-run achievements in the steroids era by McGwire, [Sammy] Sosa and Bonds were too far out there to think something underhanded didn't have an effect on their numbers. If they were in the Hall of Fame, they would unfairly skew the measurement of players in future years as well as dwarf the accomplishments of Hall of Famers from the past.

Note to Murray Chass: Pitchers have been found to use performance enhancing drugs more than position players. I assume that Chass won’t be voting (if he could) for Roger Clemens either.

Rick Hummel (St. Louis Post-Dispatch):

McGwire has no chance to get into the Hall this year, not just because of his link to the steroids issue, but the appearance of two clearly better candidates in Gwynn and Ripken.

There is nothing McGwire needs to do - at least not now.

He doesn't have a chance anyway this year, although that is not to say I wouldn't vote for him because I probably will. Next year, however, is different with no standout candidate ahead of McGwire, and we'll have a better barometer of how much the steroids thing has hurt him.

Hummel neatly speaks the truth and sidesteps the matter at the same time. It’s true that Gwynn and Ripken will be slam dunks. But, don’t think for a second that there won’t be a mountain of columns talking about how McGwire’s alleged steroid use was the catalyst for not getting the votes, this point by Hummel aside.

Jayson Stark (ESPN):

I'm going to vote for him. I can't say I feel good about voting for him. But here's why: People have oversimplified this issue, to the point where, if you listened to the way most people talk about it, you'd think there were only 10 players taking any kind of performance-enhancing drugs in the '90s. But we know that, in truth, there were hundreds.

So should I only cast votes against players who happened to get mentioned in Jose Canseco's book or subpoenaed by Congress? What about all the other players who I might suspect were doing something but have never come up in this conversation?

Should I vote only against players who hit home runs or broke home run records or challenged home run records? What about all the pitchers we know were taking something?
I don't see how I can start picking and choosing when, in fact, baseball allowed all of this to happen. So that was the culture inside the game at the time, just as amphetamines were part of the culture in the '60s and '70s and '80s (and beyond).

If more evidence emerges, I always reserve the right to change my mind. But for now, I'm going to cast a very uncomfortable vote for McGwire and, for the most part, every great player of an obviously tainted generation.

Stark may have the comments closest to the truth. Where do you draw the line? How does one, as he says, “pick and choose” if you are basing your vote on something alleged, as opposed to proven.

Here’s my take…

When Palmeiro’s name comes up on the ballot, it’s a no-brainer to vote no. He was caught using steroids, and pays the price. If the Mitchell investigation ever releases its findings, or somehow Greg Anderson snaps and decides to provide direct proof that Barry Bonds used steroids, then there’s your second “no-brainer” criteria. After that, it’s basing a vote on speculation, and as mentioned prior, that’s a slippery slope.

For those that are contending that legal PEDs were used by McGwire and therefore his HR numbers would not be nearly as high without them, you have a point. But, how much did his use of andro impact his numbers? 10%? 20%? 30%? What’s the measure? When there is a way to do more than stick your finger in the wind to see which way the wind blows, then we may have something.

The big question for McGwire may be, does he have enough votes to stay on the ballot next year? Since I’ve given up on trying to figure out any good rationale in how the BBWAA votes for anything these days, I’ll go the finger in the wind route and say, yes.

Maury Brown is the editor of The Biz of Baseball and an author for Baseball Prospectus. He can be contacted here.



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?