moduretic generika liste serpina durchschnittliche kosten levitra generika zoll keppra retail price yasmin rezeptfrei deutschland robaxin online bestellen vergleich clarina online bestellen wien coreg online apotheke xilero shatavari root price rumalaya forte price in india amoxicillin 1000 online bestellen rogaine 5 preisvergleich lotion kaufen billig celadrin keflex online apotheke order kosten arava nebenwirkungen billig baclofen hersteller styplon online apotheke günstig kosten maxalt nebenwirkungen kosten liv 52 side effects lozol rabatt online shop ashwagandha wo kaufen aspirin bayer kaufen allegra online apotheke k dresses beconase aq medikamente reviews strattera kopen online silvitra rezeptfrei schweiz liv 52 bestellen quest preis von allopurinol suprax rabatt online purchase billig silagra bestellen ashwagandha generika erfahrungen diabecon online apotheke ds kosten levitra cialis lipothin online bestellen nederland plendil rezeptfrei online entocort retail price zanaflex generika hersteller lipothin online bestellen berlin kosten isoptin wirkstoff bactrim online bestellen overnight shipping ciplox rezeptfrei niederlande kaufen bupropion keflex online apotheke buy emsam rezeptfrei niederlande renagel kosten voltaren rabatt online apotheke zebeta online bestellen günstig clomid rezeptfrei wo lithium tabletten bestellen coumadin rabatt online pharmacy actos generika indien youtube estrace medikamente liste kosten lithium akku prednisone online apotheke canada benicar online bestellen hct keflex online apotheke deutschland preisvergleich aspirin complex bupropion sr preis overdose trial erection packs medikamente aciphex generika rezeptfrei dutas t price rogaine 2 pille vs 5 plavix oder generika kemadrin preisvergleich orlistat online bestellen vendita calcium carbonate verkauf limestone rabatt terramycin yanık furosemide online bestellen xxl kosten actonel cytotec generika deutschland augmentin online apotheke cheap cialis rezeptfrei auf rechnung erexin-v online apotheke deutschland coreg generika erfahrungen prilosec generic and brand name kaufen nicotinell mint mestinon durchschnittliche kosten qm kaufen bupropion sr energy flexisyn generika suche proscar online apotheke kopen citalopram medikamente liste nizoral online apotheke farmacia rogaine 5 medikamente years endep rabatt online prozentrechner vermox bestellen rabatt plaquenil eye flomax online bestellen prescription torsemide rabatt online allegra preis usa avodart rabatt online uk styplon rezeptfrei bestellen lynoral generika apotheke antabuse rezeptfrei schweiz zyvox generika liste furosemide online bestellen to buy emsam rezeptfrei deutschland avalide rezeptfrei viagra rabatt nootropil clonidine durchschnittliche kosten implantat billig slim tea tvm kaufen abana kosten lasix im bupropion sr verkauf sandoz menosan online bestellen test kaufen avodart erfahrungen aristocort generika günstig combivent rezeptfrei apotheke medikamente depressionen citalopram rabatt fucidin dapoxetine online kopen dulcolax generika indien china kytril bestellen online renagel online apotheke testsieger preisvergleich nicotinell 52 yasmin generika günstig kaufen billig ashwagandha seroquel rezeptfrei kaufen kosten v gel lyte v volcano bestina generika apotheke kaufen billig proscar ohne rezept furosemide online bestellen nederland flagyl er verkauf uses nizagara pille online liponexol online bestellen clonidine online bestellen patch ashwagandha online apotheke shopping brahmi online bestellen free watch viagra rote pille kytril generika indien ranitidine generika hersteller uroxatral online apotheke xanten clomid online bestellen from usa plendil online apotheke günstig moduretic online bestellen online triamcinolone preis mg bupropion sr preis sandoz pletal generika türkei levitra generika kaufen schweiz arimidex generika suche xalatan rabatt online order neurontin generika motilium online apotheke deutschland seroquel durchschnittliche kosten xr bupropion sr price walgreens aciclovir preisvergleich alesse generika indien indocin preis rabatt avodart nebenwirkungen imdur rezeptfrei niederlande wellbutrin online apotheke prescription zyrtec rabatt online cheap kaufen billig dostinex ohne rezept aricept rabatt online h&m tenormin bestellen flonase price walgreens fosamax preis tablets rabatt trileptal wirkung calcium carbonate verkauf uses calcium carbonate preis natural sources adalat online apotheke july 2012 kosten saw palmetto oil for hair loss bystolic rezeptfrei viagra cialis bestellen per nachnahme antabuse online apotheke deutschland rabatt etodolac fibromyalgia caverta online apotheke order kaufen billig amitriptylin neuraxpharm clonidine online bestellen purchase clonidine generika tabelle allegra pille preis antivert verkauf baclofen price philippines renagel generika apotheke kaufen bupropion sr withdrawal symptoms naltrexone rezeptfrei viagra dulcolax online apotheke easyapotheke olanzapine rabatt online prescription lady era preis oscar arava rabatt online zebeta online bestellen deutschland periactin rezeptfrei online cialis rezeptfrei in tschechien kaufen amaryl rezeptfrei holland topamax online bestellen buy generic nizoral online apotheke buy india kosten avodart preis glucovance online apotheke deutschland zoloft durchschnittliche kosten grifulvin v bestellen side effects kaufen entocort zyprexa generika malegra rezeptfrei frankreich lamisil price without insurance alesse generika schweiz rabatt pilex tablet apcalis rezeptfrei italien lasix online apotheke delivery rogaine 2 rabatt online youtube diovan online apotheke pharmacies preis von keppra billig slim tea wirkung medikament ciprofloxacin aristo beconase aq medikamente pregnancy montelukast und pille billig ranitidine nexium generika indien youtube aciclovir bestellen bupropion sr pille you high fincar rezeptfrei online levitra preise türkei seroquel rezeptfrei deutschland singulair rabatt online order myambutol rezeptfrei insektenstich chloramphenicol rezeptfrei test desyrel pillen rogaine 5 preisvergleich bestellen malegra online bestellen günstig alavert generika indien lioresal pillen zanaflex generika liste protonix generika kaufen xenical price us trileptal 600 preis imitrex online apotheke xanten kaufen billig viagra günstige atorlip-5 generika cafergot generika hersteller allegra online apotheke kaufen orlistat online apotheke pharmacy flonase bestellen kaufen billig avodart nebenwirkungen remeron rezeptfrei mg endep online apotheke spanien kaufen billig biaxin charboleps bestellen kaufen benadryl kaufen alli tabletten kaufen celebrex rezeptfrei online vasodilan generika türkei kaufen bupropion sr generic reviews procardia online apotheke deutschland kaufen billig norvasc coreg generika rezeptfrei anacin online apotheke rizact generika rezeptfrei petra deppe kosten clomid generika rezeptfrei endep generika kaufen stromectol online apotheke commande ginseng pille siberische clindamycin online bestellen xenos chloramphenicol durchschnittliche kosten implantat vasodilan generika apotheke kaufen advair levitra generika bestellen elavil bestellen estrace generika zoll tamoxifen bestellen sarafem medikamente liste cialis rezeptfrei lastschrift kaufen flomax kleidung kosten rogaine 5 bestellen crestor rabatt online bestellen flonase price target lotrisone rezeptfrei schweiz amoxicillin online apotheke europe nexium online apotheke to buy rabatt nexium bestellen billig rogaine 5 works eldepryl online apotheke holland benzac online apotheke ac buy aricept rabatt online cheap kamagra preis in indien clomid rezeptfrei länder strattera preis qm zyvox rezeptfrei wien kaufen maxalt alkohol geriforte rezeptfrei online liponexol generika indien china zyprexa rezeptfrei frankreich kosten arcoxia rezept beconase aq verkauf price peni large online apotheke juvalis entocort online bestellen apotheke tulsi samen bestellen zoloft rabatt online h&m yasmin online apotheke levy listen minomycin generika tabelle billig saw palmetto gegen haarausfall suprax rabatt online youtube clomid rezeptfrei bestellen rabatt cialis menge rabatt fml forte ointment kaufen billig meclizine finasterid online bestellen billig atorlip 20 preis atorlip atorvastatina 20 mg prednisone online apotheke in uk proscar online apotheke consultation benzac generika viagra betnovate online apotheke uk citalopram pille online kosten saw palmetto gnc toprol rabatt online xl top avana generika indien china kaufen bactrim hund kaufen ranitidine kamagra durchschnittliche kosten lebensmittel top avana rabatt online shop trimox rezeptfrei online beconase aqueous verkauf ear rabatt nizagara online sominex verkauf claritin generika rezeptfrei isoptin online bestellen deutschland doxazosin pille danach kaufen bupropion sr ingredients effexor online bestellen vergleich viagra kosten in der apotheke viagra rezeptfrei rumänien top avana pille danach beconase aq rezeptfrei kaufen amoxicillin antibiotika preis nizoral creme 30 g preisvergleich glycomet generika tabelle precose generika preisvergleich adalat rabatt online narendra modi flomax rezeptfrei online zyban tablet price in india purim online bestellen xenos slim tea rabatt online purchase endep online apotheke schnelle lieferung femara online bestellen estrace generika rezeptfrei kaufen serpina rabatt fml forte for pink eye premarin online apotheke holland zoloft rezeptfrei viagra lynoral generika deutschland furosemide online bestellen zonder recept ginseng kapseln erfahrungsberichte top avana generika indien reisen allopurinol online apotheke sale prazosin online bestellen order erexin-v rezeptfrei bestellen xalatan rezeptfrei apotheke zetia preisvergleich artane preis usa femara pille online beconase aqueous preisvergleich blocked ears accutane pille qlaira kaufen billig dapoxetin apotheke medikamente trental billig hoodia kaufen adalat rabatt online all episodes styplon online bestellen test calcium carbonate preis zinc oxide bactrim online bestellen generic lotensin rabatt online chloramphenicol rabatt online pumpspray calan online bestellen vergleich coreg rezeptfrei viagra bupropion sr bestellen to take amitriptylin pille triamcinolone rezeptfrei viagra yasmin online apotheke berlin zyvox rezeptfrei holland naltrexone rezeptfrei wo kemadrin online apotheke schweiz mobilheim billig kaufen pletal rabatt online buy shatavari preis malaysia astelin online apotheke buy diclofenac price uk provera rabatt online radnog staza zoloft rabatt online buy grifulvin v medikamente susp ditropan pille qlaira tamoxifen generika suche kaufen billig bupropion kaufen billig celebrex rezeptfrei coreg rezeptfrei niederlande flomax online bestellen orlistat online apotheke sandoz brahmi rezeptfrei günstig uroxatral rezeptfrei holland maxalt generika billig liv 52 ebi pharm periactin rabatt online free sildalis rabatt online buy diltiazem online bestellen günstig generika für arcoxia slim tea online bestellen jeans lanoxin verkauf hydrochlorothiazide online apotheke purchase slim tea generika erfahrungen bupropion sr medikamente to quit smoking clonidine generika rezeptfrei plavix generika liste exelon generika rezeptfrei sinemet generika kaufen zocor generika liste kaufen propranolol alkohol lasix online apotheke prescription canada prevacid verkauf zyloprim preis endep rabatt online im vodafone shop kaufen billig zyban rezept kaufen nexium nebenwirkungen arava 20mg preis anafranil online bestellen deutschland mentat rabatt online himalaya topamax online apotheke uk liponexol generika indien kosten feldene gel bentyl medikamente interaction zofran bestellen online osteoporose medikamente actonel lasix rezeptfrei kaufen glycomet rabatt online shop lioresal online bestellen buy robaxin online bestellen pharmacy billig liv 52 cena kaufen copegus kosten ciplox lipitor rezeptfrei yasmin online apotheke travels singulair online apotheke baby msd aldara creme preis mit rezept ginseng generika suche olanzapine rabatt online apotheke proscar online apotheke bestellen billig saw palmetto shampoo kaufen apcalis cardizem pille cd liv 52 bestellen tabletten kosten antabus voltaren dolo liquid preis clomid generika kaufen claritin durchschnittliche kosten lebensmittel urispas rabatt online shop fosamax medikament wirkung prednisolon online apotheke calcium carbonate verkauf zähne cardizem bestellen saw palmetto generika erfahrungen kosten lioresal alkohol shatavari kaufen anafranil online bestellen canada vasodilan preis usa billig finax billig rogaine 5 walgreens xeloda preisvergleich calcium carbonate verkauf manufacturers amoxicillin online bestellen buy bupropion sr verkauf generic kaufen billig xalatan kosten ginseng generika liste urispas online apotheke xanten rabatt cabgolin o.5 kaufen billig zyprexa rezeptfrei tetracyclin generika kamagra oral jelly preis in thailand medikament citalopram al 20mg minocin akne pille medikament citalopram dura arcoxia 90 mg bestellen fluoxetine price per pill benadryl generika pristiq pille online robaxin price walmart shuddha pille preis myambutol online bestellen schweiz depakote rezeptfrei test alessi preiswert menosan online bestellen aceon online apotheke wien tricor bestellen prednisone online apotheke i buy arava online bestellen xenos nasonex rabatt online vendita bupropion bestellen erexor online apotheke test stromectol online bestellen in u.k procardia online apotheke buy antabuse online apotheke comprar dramamine rezeptfrei niederlande clonidine online bestellen xxl doxycycline rezeptfrei mg casodex online bestellen günstig unisom online apotheke uk xalatan online bestellen eye drops mycelex-g generika schweiz himcolin generika hersteller slim tea preisvergleich ultra beconase a preisvergleich q beconase aq preisvergleich coupon kosten v gel eug v metoclopramide generika zoll lamictal rabatt online for sale sinemet rezeptfrei länder
Home Pete Toms LWIB: MLB at Crossroads in the Dominican Republic

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1035 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: MLB at Crossroads in the Dominican Republic PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 10
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Tuesday, 19 October 2010 06:46

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in “Last Week in BizBall”, MLB at a crossroads with player recruitment in the Dominican Republic, plus tidbits.

MLB AT CROSSROADS IN DOMINICAN REPUBLIC

In May, LWIB brought attention to MLB’s efforts to combat age and identity fraud amongst amateur prospects in the Dominican Republic. I wrote:

With both MLB’s Scouting Bureau and Department of Investigations both active on the ground, the buscone culture in the Dominican Republic as it has existed appears over. Going forward, whether MLB works in conjunction with the buscones or renders them irrelevant by establishing a system of leagues and instructional programs remains to be seen.

LWIB, Michael S. Schmidt of the New York Times (HT Rob Neyer) provided an update on the results of MLB’s intervention in the recruitment of Dominican players.

New rules aimed at curtailing steroid use and age fraud among baseball prospects in the Dominican Republic have reduced the number of elite Dominican teenage players being signed to contracts by Major League Baseball teams and the size of their signing bonuses.

Of the top 40 Dominican prospects identified by Major League Baseball this year, only five have signed since July 2, a date set by baseball when many 16-year-olds become eligible to sign contracts.

AND

…..Beyond the reduced number of signings of top prospects, the average bonus was about $180,000 this year, down $20,000 from 2009 and $40,000 from 2008.

This past Opening Day saw 231 players, or 27.7%, of MLB rosters (includes players on DL) born outside of the US. Approximately 80% of these players are from Latin American countries. The Dominican Republic produced more of those players than any other country (86). Venezuela produced the second most (58). In 1990, the percentage of foreign-born players (again, de facto Latin American players) in MLB was 13%. The number of foreign-born players in the minor leagues at the beginning of this season was 48% (most from Latin America) according to this report. According to this report, in 09, the combined number of foreign-born major and minor leaguers was approx 3,500 of a total of 8,532 players “under contract”, or approx 41%. According to the same report, three seasons prior the number of foreign-born players was 2,964. However you slice and dice the numbers the trend is unmistakable, MLB has never been more reliant on Latin America, and particularly the Dominican Republic, for players.

MLB long tolerated the “buscone system” in the Dominican Republic, but as signing bonuses skyrocketed the past several years they concluded that reforms were essential to stop the rampant age and identity fraud. In 1985 MLB attempted a draft of amateur Dominican players but abandoned it after several players were drafted by more than one club due to confusion over player identities. Today, MLB appears at a crossroads with player recruitment in the Dominican Republic. At a minimum, MLB will continue to monitor the “buscone system” of player development via the aforementioned “on the ground” efforts of both their Scouting Bureau and Department of Investigations. A more drastic change, the imposition of a draft in the DR, could be negotiated with the MLBPA in the next CBA. (The current CBA expires in December 2011).

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE THE REST OF THIS ARTCLE, PLUS "TIDBITS", INCLUDING MARK CUBAN LOOKING FOR A REBATE

So, as MLB changes the rules and structure of player recruitment in a country which has produced greater and greater numers of their players these past 20-30 years, what will happen? Does a draft of amateur talent suppress or inflate the cost of recruiting players? Does a draft of amateur talent increase or decrease the output of players subject to it? Depends upon who you ask. LWIB, the Sports Agent Blog posted a recently published paper in the LOYOLA L.A. ENTERTAINMENT LAW REVIEW, authored by Daniel Hauptman, titled The need for a worldwide draft to level the playing field and strike out the national origin discrimination in Major League Baseball. Mr. Hauptman argues that amateur players currently subject to the draft (those in U.S., Canada and Puerto Rico) are underpaid in comparison to their peers in countries not subject to the draft. In a nutshell, a drafted player can negotiate with one club, an international free agent can negotiate with 30. In other words, Stephen Strasburg vs. Aroldis Chapman. Mr. Hauptman argues that without a worldwide draft of amateur talent, MLB is inviting a lawsuit. From the “abstract”:

 

When applying federal (Title VII) and state national origin discrimination laws to the baseball drafting system, it is evident that all draft-eligible U.S. baseball players (as well as residents of Canada and U.S. territories) could successfully state a claim of “reverse” national origin discrimination inherent in the draft. Furthermore, the national origin discrimination claim would not be preempted by national labor law that encourages collective bargaining in sports and other industries. There have been forty-five years of baseball entry drafts in which U.S. amateurs have been treated worse than foreign players, and there would be no need for discrimination litigation if Major League Baseball were to institute a worldwide draft with uniform drafting rules around the globe.

Yes, Aroldis Chapman was in a superior negotiating position to Stephen Strasburg. But does that mean that a worldwide draft will result in an overall lowering of player recruitment costs in Latin America for MLB? Some have argued that the imposition of the amateur draft in 1965 made recruiting talent “domestically” more expensive than recruiting it internationally. (In other words, in Latin America) A 2003 Emory University School of Law Paper, U.S. Labor Market Regulation and the Export of Employment: Major League Baseball Replaces U.S. Players with Foreigners, concluded that the introduction of the amateur draft (since renamed the First-Year player draft) resulted in the drastic increase of Latin American players in MLB.

…in 1965, the imposition of both the player draft and stricter age minimums for hiring U.S. players reduced the benefits of signing and developing players from the U.S. Our empirical analysis, using an extensive new data set of every MLB player from 1947 on, then shows that, in response, teams have shifted to hiring and training players from other countries where the regulations do not apply, especially in Latin America. That is, the regulations have caused teams to replace U.S. players with foreign ones.

In 2007, Chris Isidore of CNNMoney.com quoted Jimmie Lee Solomon, MLB’s Executive Vice President, Baseball Development, "Clubs do leverage their dollars much better if they develop a kid in a country not subject to the draft,"…"Those decisions are purely business decisions, very pragmatic business decisions." In August of last year, Joel Millman wrote in the WSJ, “…Instead of signing hundreds of U.S. amateurs out of high school -- the traditional business model for stocking minor-league rosters -- teams are drafting fewer U.S. kids and signing more so-called nondraft free agents, the vast majority of them teenagers from Latin America.”

It is obviously overly simplistic to conclude that the draft alone makes it more expensive to recruit a player from the US than the Dominican Republic. A $10,000 signing bonus is worth incalculably more to a Dominican boy than a middle class American boy. And the Dominican prospects do not have the alternatives outside of baseball that their U.S. peers do. Should players in the DR be subject to the amateur draft that will not change. Drafted Dominican players will not have the option that drafted American high school players have of not signing in favour of playing at a Junior College or University and being drafted again. Nonetheless, the impact of an amateur draft on the Dominican labour market for baseball players is unknown. Some, including the Puerto Rican government, (see Mr. Hauptman’s paper) argue that the introduction of the draft in that country led directly to a steep decline in the number of prospects recruited there. And those that argue that the amateur draft “killed” baseball in Puerto Rico caution that an amateur draft in the DR will do the same. The “buscone system” will be dismantled, resulting in vastly fewer players being produced there. Warts and all, steroids, age and identity fraud, kickbacks, bonus skimming…the “buscone system” has produced a staggering amount of baseball players considering the DR’s population of approx. 10 million.

One of the biggest changes in MLB during the recent past is the huge influx of Latin American players. Will that remain the status quo or will MLB’s interventions eventually result in fewer big leaguers from the DR? In the short term, clubs will be happy that they are less frequently defrauded by crooked buscones. But longer term, will they miss the critical mass of cheap talent - particularly for their minor league teams - that those same buscones have been producing for decades. Or can MLB replace the buscones with their own infrastructure of academies and leagues which will produce the same number of players, but in a healthier environment for the players and a more ethical business culture for the clubs? Who knows?

TIDBITS

  • The SportsBusiness Journal reported that Mark Cuban and Jim Crane are asking for a combined $2.65 million in legal fees and other expenses stemming from their failed bankruptcy bid for the Texas Rangers in August. They argue that had they not bid for the club, the creditors would have received $98 million less than they did.
  • Big changes in independent baseball. The Winnipeg Goldeyes, Fargo RedHawks, Kansas City T-Bones and Gary SouthShore Railcats have all left the Northern League to join the American Association. The Northern League is the seminal league in the history of independent baseball. It debuted in 1993 and it’s success spawned many other independent leagues across North America. The departure of the four aforementioned clubs leaves the Northern League with four franchises and many questions surround it’s future. See Baseball America and Ballpark Digest for more.
  • Padres owner Jeff Moorad has purchased the Portland Beavers Triple A franchise. The franchise will be based in Tucson for at least the 2011 season. The plan is for the franchise to eventually be permanently located in the San Diego suburb of Escondido. Before that happens, the customary wrangling between the franchise and the local government has to be concluded. Again, see Baseball America and Ballpark Digest for more.


Pete Toms is senior writer for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?