north wyoming insurance discount pharmacy in us online cheap drugs no script kanggoroo pils buy prednisolone 5mg uk ciprofloxacin no prescription hcl how to get viriga vibrox medicine haykakan nor filmer mometasone furoate cream usp 0.1 uses no prescription canada pharmacy cheap adhd medication from canada comprar viagra americano wellbutrin online order legal come comprare farmaci on line vibramycin dosage for cats manforce viagra ottowa canada pharmacies online lamictal rash photos clomid twins pills for sell frumil fortean purchase viagra thru canada epogen side effects in cats albuterol nebulizer treatment cpt code celas and viagra pharmacie en ligne viagra canada ranbaxy pharmaceuticals india vasotec medication dose ephedraxin review promethazine 25mg suppositories depomedrol injection for dogs cabaser tablets scored moduretic dosage of benadryl cheap deltasone benadryl and pregnancy risk kamagra 25mg what is closest to nexium misoprostol for abortion subutex withdrawal in newborns obagi tretinoin cream 0 1 arimidex visa phentermine information phentermine 37.5 minomycin information allopurinol medications viagra fast delieverly remeron withdrawal symptoms itching careprost eyelash side effects best price viagra usa viagra scaduto a\u0083a pericoloso armodafinil nuvigil and weight loss grifulvin v micr 500 side effects order viagara on line free proventil inhaler coupons allegra coupons in sunday paper atacand candesartan cilexetil 32mg phentermine diet pills colchicine gout buying hydrocodone while in canada avelox 400mg side effects ospamox antibiotics finasteride for cheap india pharmacy cheapest cialis avelox antibiotic law suits mircette online without prescription vrdrug medicine wheel ativan dosage medications valtrex dosage for cold sores cost saroten retard 25 mg dilantin pain killers lantus solostar price flomax dosage dicyclomine hydrochloride abuse cialis generika aus deutschland catafast 50mg buy betnesol drops cefovex 500 uses for amoxil 875 mg elocom crema prednisone 40mg buy penicillin vk without prescription cialis from china liquid ranitidine for infants viagra price in south africa claravis prescription coupons sominex ingredients tablets sureway livery service in chicago strattera medication assistance program finasteride for hair loss in women lidoderm coupon patient assistance soma no prisciption estradiol norethindrone acetate transdermal system accutane canada fentanyl patch abuse methods how to asthma symptoms in adults food generic viagra for sale in the usa aggrenox medication and plavix hoodia gordonii plus reviews side effects cialis a vendre viagra via internet viagra online auf rechnung buy viagra online canada gupisone 20 dose description of heaven can you buy actavis online alli buy in us cialis liquid form non prescription tadalafil tablets prednisone vs methylprednisolone buy viagra south africa donormyl ingredients for lasagna ashwagandha powder for weight alendronate side effects captopril side effects drugs zolpidem er 12.5mg wikipedia morphine pills identification comprar cialis en miami ramipril 10mg best price on viagra from canada need to buy indocin digoxin toxicity signs and symptoms mexico lantus suhagraat information in urdu video zyrtec for children under 2 warfarin side effects hair loss buy sildenafil citrate 100mg online prednisone 20 mg 5 days advair diskus coupon card levitra maximum dosage naproxen sodium 500 mg alli diet pills buy lantus insulin side effects drug interactions is nymphomax available in kerala triamterene h sobhan amoxicillin and alcohol interactions phenergan dosages for children zestril 20mg cost cialis 10mg price no prescription generic viagra online viagra rezeptfrei ganstig kaufen pharmacy expense report naproxen vs ibuprofen for inflammatory buy fluconazole from india how to buy virga 50mg acheter viagra ou cialis pharmacy prescription free europe cefadroxil side effects in children nizoral cream revapol pastillas prednisone purchase cyotec oregon buy inhalers online usa bactrim over the counter 20 mg cialis too much losartan side effects medication can cialis be purchased in ecuador adipex side effects hair loss sifrol tablets livial tibolone usa aristocort cream zithrogen 500 days morphine sulfate 15mg is cialis covered by medicare milanuncios barcelona catalonia buy colchicine without a prescription celebrex 200 mg coupons metronidazole cream como ordenar viagra prednisolone acetate eye drops for dogs cheap celebrex lipitor refills buy metronidazole 500mg doxyclcline dosage for ulcer yasminelle pills tadalafil soft gel capsule buy paxil cr no prescription coltricine no prescription skelaxin 800 mg metaxalone price cialis 40mg tabs order sotalex medication side acomplia 20mg pills vytorin 10 40 side effects lamotrigine lamictal side effects rash terbutaline sulfate 2.5mg viagra bestellen per nachnahme unisom in singapore buy viagracheap indapamide 1.25 mg purchasing inderal omeprazole 20 mg capsule side effects subutex withdrawal suboxone pfizer viagra online pharmacy rhinc inc lady era tablets ketorolac tromethamine injection uses amantadina nombres comerciales de prednisona lumigan 0.01 rebate tadalafil soft canada terramycin powder seroxat withdrawal zovirax cream 5 reviews clenbuterol weight loss results pictures clenbuterol for sale in mexico max viagra pills zoloft and pregnancy class viagra uk next day delivery sildenafil for sale safeway pharmacy generic list cialis with dapoxetine review pramipexole 0.125 mg side effects estrofem no prescription australia quanto costa il viagra in francia cialis price at walgreens linezolid antibiotics drugs list nasonex coupon offer printable coupons 2015 viagra brand for sale cytotec para abortar viagra pills buying 20 pills s furosemide 20 mg lasix sertraline hydrochloride side effects otc equivalent to singular cialis orosolubile buy zebeta 10mg online no prescription nitrazepam vs diazepam for dogs glipizide side effects medication what is flagyl 500mg used for minocin side effects antibiotic buy perrigo mometasone furoate cream buy dilantin no script zovirax acyclovir medication dose claravis side effects treatment buy metronidazole 500mg online tapiales hoyt ramipril side effects drug buy viagra in playa del carmen 214 aricept medication for alzheimers buy fluoxitine without a prescription septra bactrim side effects kamagrafast brighton ski clozapine drug interactions allegra d lantus patient assistance phone numbers free sc norvasc to buy xatral od10xeloda albuterol detox colospan tablet for kids eprex erythropoietin androgel bodybuilding bodybuilders como compro viagra atacand hct 32 12.5mg coupon furosemide vendite what is parafortan levitra in usa zetia online india no prescription using subutex for pain management amantadina clorhidrato de ambroxol antabuse to purchase zoloft online without a prescription flagyl dosage for c difficile ospamox 500mg prospect cleocin hcl 150mg misoprostol for miscarriage what to expect fanegada colombia buspar and weight gain side effects cymbalta fibromyalgia side effects weight gain propranolol overdose suicide global pharmacy canada complaints buy brand name cialis exelon corp cialis online from europe diamox side effects acetazolamide side signs of zanaflex overdosezanaxzantac zopiclone 7.5mg by actavis pharma pharmacy online plendil er flagyl treat a gum infection buying finasteride in canada kamagra 247 review asthma action plan template how to parachute wellbutrin valium 5mg side effects craigslist viagra canada captopril renal scan protocol cicloferon aciclovir suspension concor bisoprolol fumarate side effects flomax 0.4 mg cost malaseb shampoo sildenafil citrate 100mg tab directions ketazol venezuela map flovent coupons glaxosmithkline cialis 5 mg prezzo in farmacia ranbaxy news trimetabol posologie celestene suhagra 100 side effects periactin no prescription require places that sell lotrel astelin nasal spray reviews ventolin 100 mg temazepam buy in line where to buy quinine water for leg cramps wath is the store to buy viagra buy tetracycline in the uk legit overnight antibiotics aspirin for dogs is it safe quinine tonic water buy clonidine california generic aricept no prescription buy pills without a prescription doxycycline hyclate acne reviews valtrex overnight delivery dynamogen drugstore no prescription methylprednisone ventolin nebules for baby risnia medicine cabinets avodart side effects mayo clinic phenamax reviews apcalis sx 20mg jellyfish brand viagra pfizer sale four corners pharmacy new zealand losartan hydrochlorothiazide generic is superdrugsaver legit celecoxib drug side effects indomethacin 50mg roaccutane acne medicationrocaltrol tesco buy cialis buy fentanyl no prescription imuran shortage diane kruger measurements best online pharmacy to buy zepose canadian pharmacy for pets free aggrenox coupon cialis jovenes where can you buy mebendazole over the counter tramol online u k cialis genetic canada cheap zofran online pfizer jobs collegeville pa paracetamol side effects medicine sumycin syrup denver rogaine side effects on women chlamydia treatment antibiotics long term esomeprazole side effects clozapine monitoring teva pil perancang marvelon cytotec no rx diclofenaco 100 mg para que sirve isoniazid side effects medication tingling pulmicort flexhaler 180 side effects viagra generic india perfect ed meds review metrotab 400 pound calais pills from canada pharmacy domperidone for gastroparesis warnings viagra originale online allopurinol side effects kidney vipps online phamarcy lamisil oral medication ivermectin for humans for lice percocet 512 information prescription propranolol dosage for social anxiety rocket raccoon guardians of the galaxy buy fruesomide pills levitra et jus de pamplemousse how to buy viagra in cambodia how much saraquills vytorin 10/40mg tablets inhaler from canada no prescription lexapro dosages ivermectin and praziquantel for horses rx relief card consumer reports arthrotec 75 mg medication xenical 120 mg atorvastatin 40 mg no prescription cozaar medicine info can i take 4 cialis 5 mg canada drugs no prescription cymbalta side effects cymbalta and weight gain diroton 20mg cialis myambutol ethambutol side where to buy accutane alendronate fosamax medication classification buy azithromycin or ceftriaxone now zyrtec 10mg over the counter virectin ingredients in beer sertraline hcl side effects furadonin runescape apertium translator online lolwest price for super viagra bystolic 5 mg online hydrodiuril 25 mg side effects atarax medicine for itching avastin and xeloda colon cancer vitamin shoppe return policy cipro 500mg flagyl 500mg antibiotic buy most reliable online pharmacy discount euro first achat service hyzaar dosage alli refill myambutol ati technologies buying levitra tablets order tretinoin 0 1 cream online cefaclor 250mg prospect robaxin for dogs shaking panting india pharmach buy ventolin on line generic viagra india safe florinef 0.1mg tab cialis generico sicuro luvox generic brand nolvadex canada viagra china supplier tadalafil c100 for sale doxycycline cost lose weight nlinephamacy no prescription com para que sirve el sildenafil arcoxia 60mg no 30 flexamin 1box famciclovir drug medication non prescription elimite rayhhealthcare online order medication price of crestor without insurance wellbutrin dosage for depression lamictal in australia website levaquin vs zithromax for sinus infection ladies viagra tablets in india caffeine anhydrous side effects buy ampicillin online buy viagra online thailand 1742 buy tinidazole 500mg wellbutrin reviews on weight loss canada pharmacy no prescription motilium 10mg indications zocor generic names kemadrin injection sites cialis with dapoxetine for sale canada clindamycin for dogs antibiotic side effects aldara cream for molluscum contagiosum vidalista 20 mg como conprar cialis obestat meridiano alli orlistat online buy review cialis once a day reviews metronidazole for dogs no rx 365pills complaints about companies how to buy premarin without rx duphaston et douleurs poitrine latisse for eyebrows results tricilest uk yahoo buy proventil inhaler cheap viagra without a script acivir tablets asthma action plan example sominex active ingredient free viagra for women primatene mist available in canada valtrex 500 mg caplet bisoprolol fumarate beta blockers temovate gel for alopecia areata sildenafil citrate dapoxetine to buy online cialis scams buy bactrim without a prescription where to buy cheap viagra super force navidoxine tablet leaflet fempro tablets order suprax no prescription cockapoo puppies for sale in texas clavaseptin tablets for dogs printable voltaren gel coupon viagra in france teva amoxicillin prometrium 100mg cap solvay buy viagra in sa online canadiaan drugstore sekking fluconazole bupropion hcl xl 300 mg costs doxycycline for dog no rx necessary relafen nabumetone medication information buy clomid online lexapro generic march 2012 omaggio hadley 1993 dyazide 37.5 mg 25 mg capsule minocin antibiotic dosage hyzaar dosage merck what is the correct dosage of cytotec permethrin 10 mixing instructions for horses crestor medication for cholesterol buy antibiotics usa lidocaine patch 5 side effects citalapram 10mg for sale lamictal rash photo lumigan generic brand cefabiot suspension bridges imitrex sumatriptan succinate cost do old viagra pills still work brand vioagra from mexico when is viagra going generic estradiol levels ivf pregnant man thomas beatie baby lexapro dosage for anxiety differin gel 0.3 side effects cipla india pharmaceutical virectin complaints the best fertility pills for men selling cytotec
Home Maury Brown Who Got the Biggest Bang for the Bucks in MLB for 2010?

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 790 guests online

Atom RSS

Who Got the Biggest Bang for the Bucks in MLB for 2010? PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 22
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 18 October 2010 19:51
Marginal Wins/Marginal Payroll data
Select the image above to see details for
all 30 clubs in MLB by Marginal Wins and
Marginal Payroll

Everybody likes to get a great deal. Ads pummel you daily touting how this outlet or that offers you a product that another charges more for more.

But, if you run a business, the chief objective is getting the best performance for the lowest price – you’re looking for efficiency and effectivity.

In Major League Baseball, it can be much the same. Some of the variables can shift, namely efficiency can be thrown out the window if you have high levels of revenues to compensate. After all, paying more – if you’ve got the green to spend – to win a World Series can be overlooked (that’s you, New York Yankees).

Over the past several years, I have broken down who got the biggest bang for their buck in MLB. With the league functioning without a hard cap, and the softest of the soft cap systems in the Big-4 (the league’s Luxury Tax system), the outcome of who performs best with the least has extra weight. As witnessed with the leaked MLB documents recently, questions surrounding the revenue-sharing system and the aforementioned Luxury Tax become more relevant as we get closer to the expiration of the current collective bargaining agreement.

To measure how well teams spent compared to their wins, we can use a metric created by the late, great Doug Pappas called Marginal Wins/Marginal Payroll.

(Select the image above to see complete 2010 Marginal Wins/Marginal Payroll data)

What is Marginal Payroll/Marginal Wins?

As a baseline, we’ll create a fictitious marginal team. Even the worst teams made up of near minor league players would not lose every game. So, we’ll say that a truly mediocre team would win only 30 percent of their games. For salary, we’ll set every players at the league minimum, which for 2010 was $400,000 . And finally, we’ll make the roster 25, plus 3 replacement players to allow for the DL.

Using each team’s winning percentage, along with the Opening Day payroll we can determine a team’s “marginal payroll”. Using Opening Day payroll gives you the “intent” of a club at the beginning of the season. When adding in how many games a team won over the course of the regular season, we can then determine how much it cost for each marginal win.

The formula works as such:

(club payroll - (28 x major league minimum) / ((winning percentage - .300) x 162)

So, the lower the cost per marginal win that is derived out of this formula, the better. You’re striving to get your cost per marginal win low, thereby spending less per win – you’re efficient.

How did this year fare? For Bud Selig, it may be his shining moment for saying that there is parity in MLB (the postseason still needs to completely play out, as this look is just for the regular season). 2010 will go down as having the lowest average cost per marginal win ($1,731,901) than any other over the last 5 years. A game here or there, and the figure could have changed dramatically. If the Padres had been able to get their way in, as opposed to the Giants in the NL West, the number would have dropped further still ($1,503,188). If the Yankees had won the AL East, then 2010 doesn’t see the 5-year low cost per marginal win by jumping to $2,219,297. Still, we saw only one club win a Division with an Opening Day payroll above $100 million (Philles). Compared to 4 last year(Yankees, Angels, Phillies, Dodgers), 4 in 2008 (White Sox, Angels, Cubs, Dodgers), 2 in 2007 (Red Sox, Dodgers), and 2 in 2006 (Yankees, Mets). There was one club (Yankees) above $100 million in 2005, but remember… These Opening Day payroll figures don’t account for inflation making 2010 all that more impressive from a cost efficiency perspective.

Playoff Teams (Cost Per Margainal Win)

Playoff Teams Margin Wins Cost per Maginal Win
Tampa Bay 47 $1,281,086
y-NY Yankees 46 $4,205,461
Minnesota 45 $1,902,184
Texas 41 $1,064,023
Philadelphia 48 $2,701,000
y-Atlanta 42 $1,726,973
Cincinnati 42 $1,428,338
San Francisco 43 $2,014,777

y - Won Wild Card

Leading the way for all playoff teams was the Texas Rangers. Their $55,250,544 ranked as the 27th lowest in Opening Day payroll ahead of only the A’s, Padres, and Pirates. Based on Marginal Payroll/Marginal Wins (MP/MW), the Rangers had a marginal payroll of $44,050,544 and 41 marginal wins culminating in $1,064,023 per marginal win. Compare that to the Phillies who spent $2,701,000 per 48 marginal wins. The other efficiency experts for getting the most out of the least goes to the Tampa Bay Rays who paid $1,281,086 per each of their 47 marginal wins.

But, if we can offer up the biggest hat tip for a club that missed the postseason, yet got incredible success with such a stingy payroll, the San Diego Padres win, hands down. Barely missing the postseason fielding a 90-72 (.556) record, the Friars had the 29th lowest Opening Day payroll for 2010 ($37,799,300) which translates to a $26,599,300 marginal payroll, or an incredible $642,495 per each of their 41 marginal wins. The only club that had better player payroll efficiency over the last 5 years was the Tampa Bay Rays in 2008 ($679,764 per marginal win).

In terms of losers in the efficiency and effectivity categories, the Seattle Mariners are this year’s winner, or rather loser. With an abysmal 61-101 record (.377), and an Opening Day payroll of $104,963,866, the Mariners spent a staggering $6,073,387 per each of their 12 marginal wins. In spending so much for so little, the Mariners now have the dubious distinction of having the two worst MW/MP ratio since 2005. This year’s figure ranks second only the M’s cost per marginal win figure of $8,634,999 in 2008.

Other losers this year include the Cubs ($5,129,129 per marginal win), and Mets ($4,053,386 per marginal win).

But, what may be of most interest is how the clubs that are in the LCS are faring. While a case for parity can be made in regular season play, how does MW/MP stack up once the playoffs get started?

LCS Marginal Wins/Cost Per Marginal Win

If the Phillies and Yankees make it to the World Series (again), it would pit the highest payroll (Yankees at $206,333,389 Opening Day payroll) against the fourth-highest ($141,928,379). The Giants are still in the top 10 in Opening Day payroll (ranked #9 at $98,641,333), while the Rangers are the at 27th (represent efficiency and effectivity’s best hope ($55,250,544). To place this in perspective, in terms of cost per marginal win, the Yankees spent 4 times as much per MW than the Rangers.




As was the case in 2008, the 2010 regular season the AL East saw a case of David vs Goliath. The Rays won the Division posting a belt tightening $1,281,086 cost per each of their 47 marginal wins. The scary thing, at least for the Orioles… they spent almost as much per marginal win as the Yankees but posted only 17 marginal wins, a sign of being ineffective and inefficient.

AL East Cost Per Marginal Win


Marginal Wins

Cost per MW

*-Tampa Bay



y-NY Yankees












* - Won the Division
y - AL Wild Card winner


The Twins didn’t get out of the first round of the playoffs (again) due to the Yankees, but there was a slight difference from this year to last: Target Field opened which trickled down to getting Joe Mauer wrapped up into a long term contract, which bumped the Twins from being ranked 24th in Opening Day payroll last year to 10th in 2010. In terms of cost per marginal win, the Twins spent $1,419,928 for each of their 38 marginal wins last season, compared to $1,902,184 per the 45 marginal wins they racked up during the 2010 regular season. Not bad considering the extra wins they racked up.

On the downside, the Tigers wound up underachieving with a high-level of player payroll. Ranked at 6th in Opening Day payroll ($122,864,928), the club spent $3,446,448 per each of their 32 marginal wins. If it’s any solace to Mike Illitch and the Tigers, the Royals, perennial cellar-dwellers, spent nearly as much per marginal win ($3,272,022)

AL Central Cost Per Marginal Win


Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win




Chicago Sox









Kansas City



x - Won the Division


The AL West wound up being a study in extremes. Jon Daniels and the Rangers became a model of efficiency and effectivity while the Mariners plans for a defensive-minded roster that wound up having all the power of a 15-watt bulb was the polar opposite; a case of high-spending with nothing to show for it. This is one of those times when a picture is worth a thousand words.

AL West Cost per Marginal Wins


Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win







LA Angels






x - Won the Division


There wasn’t a case of wise spending trumping poor-thinking, overspending in the NL East. Sure, there was a prime case of “spending doesn’t always mean winning” with the Mets, but Phillies had a steep Opening Day payroll. The Braves, who won the NL Wild Card had an Opening Day payroll of $84,423,666, right smack-dab in the middle of MLB’s payroll rankings at 15th.

NL East Cost Per Marginal Win


Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win










NY Mets






* - Won the Division


How good is Walt Jocketty? How bad do the Pirates continue to be? How badly did the Cubs spend without having anything to show for it? Consider… The Pirates spent nearly twice as much as the Reds per marginal win. But, it could have been worse (at least if this year were the only year the Pirates stunk up the standings). The Cubs finished 5th in the Division, just ahead of the lowly Pirates, spending 3.6 times as much per marginal win as the Reds did. Ouch.


NL Central Cost Per Marginal Win


Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win




St. Louis









Chicago Cubs






x - Won the Division


“If only…” That has to be what was on the lips of Jed Hoyer and every San Diego Padres fan. Barely missing the postseason, when Spring Training ended, few – if any – baseball “experts” would have the Padres as contenders for a moment, let alone the entire season. With an Opening Day payroll of $37,799,300, they, along with the Pirates, were the only clubs with payroll under $50 million. They wound up overachieving, well beyond expectations and would have been the perennial example of “smarts over expensive players”… if only they had made it to the playoffs. Not to make the likes of the Mariners and Cubs cry but the Padres posted an insanely effiencent and effective $642,495 per marginal win. Bravo, Padres. You’re Bud Selig’s new hero.

NL West Cost Per Marginal Win


Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win

x-San Francisco



San Diego






LA Dodgers






x - Won the Division

Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey, as well as a contributor to FanGraphs and Forbes SportsMoney. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?