praziquantel for fish viagra pills had a bottom line prilosec otc coupons printable vistaril for anxiety dosage potassium chloride side effects periactin in canada pinamox caps 500mg amoxicillin for dogs prednisone 10 pack instructions norvasc 10mg and zocor 10 free ed pills sample no pre flagyl dosage for bacterial vaginosis comprare propecia senza ricetta where to buy cilias professional pills sumycin syrupy digoxina in english what is hyperbole increasing metabolism to lose weight premarin coupons discounts what is shelf life of viagra pills ampicillin to buy levitra generic vardenafil cheap medrol dose pack instructions medrol dosepak raymeds login livereductil buy generic accutane fast delivery buy silagra 50 mg imitrex migraine medication side effects 777tablets erfahrungen cialis 2 day delivery metrotab 400 watt offshore pharmacy no prescription red viagra price in pakistan estrace cream treatment for cancer romney medicare pharm net tadalafil viagra levitra grathazon kaplet roh tabletten zum abnehmen nach aciphex 20mg amermycin 100mg nicotine olanzapine withdrawal meclizine 25 mg tablet overdose diflucan cheap cialis daily use 5 mg cipla tadacip 20 reviews cialis 100 mg jasmine tridevil hoax obagi tretinoin 0 1 omeprazole 20 mg side effects bloating norvasc and pregnancy complicationsnosipren torsemide 2.5 mg metrotab facebook law protonix generic side effects aleve pain medication warnings 5mg cialis canada flazol 500 tablet latisse before and after strattera 40 mg street price canada primatene inhaler cafergot discontinued viagra bay in ireland benazepril 10 mg side effects nootropil 800 mg prospect how much is amitriptyline canadian pharmacy in dubai increasing and decreasing functions worksheets macrodantin dosage for uti treatment tadalafil 20 mg best price sildenafil citrate 100mg irbesartan hydrochlorothiazide tablets viramune xr savings card provera online nonposcription wellbutrin and alcohol withdrawal viagra without perception viagra store in canada cafergot suppositories vardenafil 20mg finasteride 5 mg canada order viagra clindamycin phosphate topical solution vitamin world joint soother ibuprofen 800mg side effects for men what is the target market for viagra unisom natural nights 10mg predisone pill no script required where can i buy cytotec to induce labor vipps pharmacy canada aspirin and pregnancy for blood clots increasing testosterone levels in males obestat meridiana antabuse greece buy prednisone 20 mg tablets lumigan 0.01 cost sildenafil generic quanto costa augmentin canadian men pills allegra side effects and weight gain cephalexin lawsuit blue pill lorinol 10 mg hydrocodone amazon metformin cymbalta medication side effects weight gain fluconazole 150 mg buy finasteride online lowest price antibiotics for uti treatment over the counter are primatene tablets discontinued buy advair online without prescription hydrodiuril contraindications for nitroglycerin condyline podophyllotoxin derivatives benoquin vitiligo buy nexium esomeprazole side effects pletal cilostazol medication pletal arava side effects patients oxybutynin side effects reviews generic viagra online australia provigil medication assistance viagra online canada paypal donato cialis mtabs complaints board over the counter prednisone substitute is cialis cheaper at costco venlafaxine hcl er 37.5mg withdrawal symptoms homeopathic viagra buy neurontin without perscription catafast 50 mg zoloft vardenafil hcl 20mg tab side effects robaxin 500mg methocarbamol side effects abreva vs zovirax for cold sores ampicilina 500 mg capsulas buy cialis us viagra men one day delivery viagra purchase codeine online the little blue pill healthpoint review chlamydia symptoms in women espanol lisinopril no prescription canada maxifort zimax mexico proventil hfa inhaler price generic viagra 150 mg atenolol drug information onlain tamashebi mario xenical philippines advertisement haldol decanoate injection where to get allopurinol pharmacy 24 online meds from india buy liquid cialis online nootropil 800 information phone where to buy viagra in kuala lumpur clobex shampoo coupon generico de ciprovit prozac and weight gain mountainmwest apothecary sertralina generic zoloft 100mg dosage yasmine galenorn website viagra online canada mastercard betnovate n cream for sale prometrium 200 mg crestor in shanghai viagra gold 800 mg deutschland dicyclomine bentyl medication side effects polarmeds comcast xfinity mexican cialis spier tadalafil clavulanic acid combivent inhalers without an rx tiotropium pronunciation of biblical names apcalis sx 20mg jelly belly trileptal depression treatment mercury drug price list of medicine buspirone 5mg withdrawal non prescription tretinoin cream generic cytotec woman in cialis commercial paroxetine hcl 40 mg side effects spiriva patient assistance boehringer ingelheim keppra 500mg coupons plavix lawsuit settlement in california lidoderm patch for back pain alli orlistat buy cialis delayed ejaculation 356 pills coupon motilium to buy 48 hours percocet vs vicodin drug doxycycline without a script buying prednisone without precision trazodone side effects trazodone 50mg order retin a no prescription overnight toradol abana insurance in houston texas 1drugstore online warning signs fentanyl side effects overdose my superbpharmacy nootropil tablets sumatriptan no prescription maxalt migraine medicine cafergot shortage klonopin without script vipro lifescience review desyrel medication 100mg nasonex generic equivalent availability factor content marketing levitra pills price rapidtabs legal drinkingrealvigrareliablerx generic cialis online united states bactrim and alcohol drug interactions risperdal risperidone can i smoke weed while taking cialis buy sarafem online vigra soft avodart 0.5 mg cost nosipren medication avana mckinney ranch review zovirax tablets no prescription fastest known shipping generic viagra synthroid thyroid medication dosage desogen weight gain prostata inflamada doxylamine succinate 25 mg sleep aid cialis best price fast delivery prescription drug buyer pastillas cialis de canada order cialis in usa lipitor and grapefruit side effects proscar uk pletal cilostazol treatment is there a over the counter viagra soviclor prescription levitra online bestellen adderall withdrawal symptoms amphetamine buy cheap lantus insulin adderall side effects where to inject gabapentin bupropion side effects medication extenze side effects chambers www canadian pharmacy 24h finasteride side effects finasteride 5mg phramacy rx1 cialis le moins cher immigrer au canada potassium rich foods for diabetics buy ventolin in uk does levitra make you bigger buy cialis canada how do i remove lasaoren search engine duvadilan isoxsuprine drugs kamagra reviews users how much cialis can i take at one time thalidomide babies where are they now minocycline acne treatment duration doxycycline shortage average cost of viagra 100mg order doxycycline fast delivery online antibotics for dogs on line pharmacy technician letter ce was topamax recalltoprol rimadyl dosage for dogs ambien cr coupon purchase viagra with paypal indomethacin 50 mg viagra gel uk online levitra probepackung cozaar 50 mg what is it used for suhagraat tips in hindi font women viagra pfizer prize in india leukeran tablets gupisone tablets side effects therapy dogs in schools viagra price walmart onlin pharmacy india no prescription contrave weight loss drugs eulexin schering plough corporation vibrox medicine dictionary suboxone on line pharmacy levlen ed online no prescription 5mg cialis from india can any doctor prescribe subutex for pain strongest vigra zithromax 250 mg zyrtec d astelin pediatric dosage parcopa 25 100 rocket powered bicycle viagra generic forzest tadalafil for sale ranitidine 300 mg tablets medrol dosepak lialda coupon for 2012 meds delivered overnight meclizine medication usemedicinenet letrozole bodybuilding side effects ibuprofen 600mg tablets side effects ranigast ulotka pepco isoniazid and alcohol use order cialis online usa viasek 50mg trazodone khawaja naveed ki adalat 2011 prevacid vs nexium aciphex potassium levels too high rogaine for eyebrows side effects januvia 100 mg generic types of viagra pills lasixs medicine side effect ceallis low cost metformin 500mg side effects constipation metformin weight loss pcos polycystic ovary syndrome buspar and weight gain sildenafil citrate tablets india vigra for sale where to buy diclofenac sodium drinking alcohol after azithromycin 1drugstore online complaints presciptions mexico buy cytotec online cheap adderall weight loss before and after amlodipine besylate side effects swelling naproxen sodium side effects effexor withdrawal symptoms last no precription cialis cheap cialis 5 mg vistaril overdose ivermectin for dogs for sale viapro ingredients in beer amlodipine 5 mg side effects viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung manfaat livial menopause captopril drug propecia finasteride for women tetracycline acne gumigem usa hockey cialis with dapoxetine canadapharmacy canadian pharmasuticals viagra buy deroxat clomid pregnancy rates imitrex nasal spray side effects flovent diskus side effects in children rythmol is there a generic buy lopressor online no prescription clindamycin 300mg capsules price non perscription valtrex where to buy cephalosporins diovan hct side effects cough phexin 750 wsb fast delivery online pharmacy clotrimazole troche side effects medrol dose pack on line no pres eldepryl medication for anxiety drug online no prescription needed lotrel medication cost generic sildenafil citrate dapoxetine glyprin 100mg to g plendil 10mg escitalopram 10 mg side effects indocin 25mg tid over the counter viagra walmart how to buy voltaren emulgel 50gm mavidol tr ketorolaco tramadol 10 mg 25 mgccc levitra india omifin 50mg side effects best price for lavitra 20mg but zithromax no rx is diflucan over the counter viamax sensitive gel evista for osteoporosis side effects cheap viagra online india cheap viagra canada overnight strattera vs adderall drug desogestrel in birth controldiclofenac morphine sulfate 30mg side effects hydrochlorothiazide thru canada buy indomethacin 50mg on line metrogel vaginal gel .75 furosemide no prescription columbia abilify patient assistance program application form clozapine withdrawal symptoms webmd sublingual gland swelling pictures macrodantin side effects dose metformina clorhidrato 850mgmetformin canadian mens healt is it safe to take prometrium during pregnancy vasotec contraindications to breastfeeding buy sumycin how much cialis to take tadapox canada little blue pill canada hyzaar side effects doctor lotrisone cream 45g singulair for children with asthma reglan medication metoclopramide tegretol medication flagyl canada antabuse pharmacy betneval lotion bottles pilexil capsulas de cafe robaxin 500mg methocarbamol addiction paroxetine medication side effects cheap universities in canada clomid online usa buy tadalofil disease definition medical aprovel irbesartan dosage estrace cream treatment dosage viagra 150 milligrams buy cialis online usa oklahoma zovirax medication for children ezonline pharmacy clindamycin 150mg cap ranbaxy suhagrat in hindi font getpharma ukc beprogel lotion crafters tabletten pressen zithrogen 500 internal server orlistat diet pills comune di piombino tamsulosin flomax dosage proviron dosage during cycle viagra canada cheapest orderpharma topix jonesboro valtrex for cold sores outbreak does viagera help women buy viagra malaysia online amoxicillin to buy in honkong china pfizer vgr 100 pill thalidomide babies today claravis 40 mg before and after bio metronidazole 400 equivalent for cialis mupirocin cream 2 used for sifrol medication listsilagra effexor reviews for hot flashes canada rx online flomist wikipedia indonesia ritalin weight loss reviews pentrexyl 500 mg capsules drug addiction letrozole 2.5mg tablets canada online pastilla clamidia discount doxycycline no prescription euroclinix reviews of 50 low cost propecia metformin sale online combivent purchase no perscription cheap keflex buy viagra 50mg online mtabs reviews of 50 obetrol adderall side tamoxifen weight gain omeprazole dr 20 mg capsule myl usa albuterol inhaler usa overnight amoxil online worldwide shipping canadian pharmacy accutane albuterol sulfate inhalation solution dosage no priscription generic viagra ventolin salbutamol lotrel 5 20 drug venlafaxine side effects 37.5 comprare cialis generico in italia advair coupons $50.00 off 2014 vardenafil 20 mg lumigan eye drops 0.03 polarmeds reviews for fifty medication without prescription drugs coumadin diet restrictions warfarin foods online pharmacy no rx required xatral xl fluzol 200mg tramadol metformin hcl er 500 mg tablet ativan dosage for anxiety cymbalta withdrawal hell online levitra no prescription lynoral ingredients in benadryl glucophage 500mg images overnight cypro https prednisone levitra bayer en ligne amerimedrx cialis free clomid from canada rhinocort nasal spray in pregnancy zyvoxid spc credit alli tablets vermox no perscription online pharmacy debit card singulair 10mg montelukast side effects baytril injection side effects in dogs side effects of pramipexole di hcl tabspravachol viagra costa rica olanzapine 5mg tablets side effects prednisolone eye drops 1 isoptin verapamil dosage sunsuria bukit jelutong house health benefits of quinine tonic water side effects free viagra sample pack online cabergoline dostinex weight loss watermelon viagra recipe buy cheap nitro glycerenepills aspirin 81mg fempro software programs magnesium supplements for children canada vigra for sale vendita di viagra nebivolol 10 mg price nasonex nasal spray dosage best genetic viagra ropinirole drug test
Home Jordan Kobritz Kobritz: Instant Replay Won't Solve Umpire Incompetence

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 594 guests online

Atom RSS

Kobritz: Instant Replay Won't Solve Umpire Incompetence PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
Jordan Kobritz Article Archive
Written by Jordan Kobritz   
Tuesday, 12 October 2010 07:33

UmpireTwo days into the MLB playoffs and the drum beat for more instant replay had reached a crescendo. While instant replay may have reversed several calls, it’s not a magic elixir for umpire incompetence.

There are a number of issues in play here, not the least of which is that umpires are human, which guarantees they aren’t perfect. No one should expect umpires to get every call correct. Umpiring, especially at the Major League level, isn’t an easy job, despite what those sitting in the press box or at home with the benefit of instant replay might believe. Fortunately, MLB has many excellent umpires, but they’re overshadowed by a few incompetents.

If instant replay had been available for more than the boundary calls it is currently being used for, the umps would have gotten two of several missed calls correct. One was a safe call on an attempted steal of second when the runner was clearly out, and another on a catch in right field that was ruled a trap. But those weren’t the only controversial calls during the first two days of the playoffs. There were two checked swings that were called balls when instant replay confirmed that both should have been strike three. Given a second life, one batter knocked in a run with a double and the other hit a three-run homer.

A checked swing is one of the most difficult calls for an umpire to make, whether it’s the home plate umpire or one of the base umps who is asked to make the decision. The managers on the losing end of those calls, Joe Maddon of Tampa Bay and Ron Gardenhire of Minnesota, were visibly upset. When they left the dugout to voice their displeasure, both were ejected. In Gardenhire’s case, the home plate umpire was Hunter Wendelstedt, who, according to the website, missed 31 ball-and-strike calls during the game.

That comes as no surprise to anyone in the game. If players, managers and coaches could speak on the record, Wendelstedt would be their pick for the worst umpire in MLB. Beyond his incompetence, Wendelstedt also possesses a volatile and surly nature. He has a history of instigating arguments with players and managers, including several with Gardenhire. Hunter would never have made it out of A-ball if his father Harry, a veteran of 35 years as a Major League umpire, hadn’t been born before him. As the person responsible for providing Hunter with game balls and post-game towels at one of his stops in A-ball, I experienced his wrath first hand.

Wendelstedt shouldn’t be on a baseball diamond, never mind receive a post-season assignment. MLB claims playoff umpires are selected based on evaluations and recommendations. That’s only partially true. Although umpires are evaluated, they are evaluated by their peers. They are also recommended for post-season assignments by their peers. Few umpires want to offend Wendelstedt, who inherited his father’s umpiring school in Ormond Beach, FL where the instructors are invited MLB umpires. Professional baseball also selects its umpires from the Wendelstedt School, and it behooves the powers that be to remain on Wendelstedt’s good side.

In truth, umpires are selected for post-season assignments on a rotating basis. The umpiring fraternity would be very upset if those plum assignments only went to the best umpires, which would result in the same individuals being selected every year.

For reasons unknown, MLB has avoided a confrontation with the umpires’ union since the league fired 22 umpires in 1999 after they went on strike. Although three of seven umpire supervisors were axed in the wake of last year’s playoff miscues, working umpires have the equivalent of a lifetime appointment, similar to Supreme Court Justices. The result is more competent umpires rot in Triple-A until they are told to go home or they get fed up with the wait and quit on their own.

The players have decided to take matters into their own hands. The MLBPA requested a sit- down with the umpires, which has been scheduled for December. MLB will have a representative present during the meeting, but Commissioner Bud Selig is apparently allowing the players to do his dirty work for him. If Selig took a more aggressive stance with the umpires, and was more concerned with their competence, he might quiet the call for more instant replay.

Jordan Kobritz is a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He is a former attorney, CPA, and Minor League Baseball team owner. He is an Assistant Professor of Sport Management at Eastern New Mexico University and teaches the Business of Sports at the University of Wyoming. He looks forward to your comments and can be contracted, here.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?