generic viagra at walmart vicodin addiction symptoms terbutaline side effects on the baby berifen 100 mg tramadol prednisone for pets where can i buy vermox over the counter buy buspirone 15 mg online accutane australia frumil fortegames brand levitra 20mg finpecia cipla online rizatriptan 10 mg reviews premarin 1.25 coupon buy novartis cafergot quanto costa il viagra in farmacia obat meloxicam untuk apa pravastatin medication is for what santissimo porto alegre my super pharmacy can you buy cialis in hong kong buy alli offshore atorlip 10 cipla parcopa discontinued croscill rimadyl side effects panting 689 buy liquid antibiotics online levitra preise pyridium medication over the counter proviron impotence compound evista 60 mg coupon lasuna food channel buy nolvadex pct aciphex side effects treatment nimesulide tablets for propranolol dosage for anxiety omaggio vase gold seal leadmedic online pharmacy sifrol 0 125 company antibiotics without doctor desogen reviews clenbuterol cycle dosage side effects tadalafil 20mg fast shipping celexa reviews for depression vigora 100 how to use in hindi provigil side effects forum venlafaxine er 75mg tablets best indian viagra cialis tennis commercial liquid cialis jelly canadian pharmacy that let you echeck order amoxcillain from mexico cialis 5 mg prix pharmacie levitra 20mg vs viagra 100mg adipex 37.5 mg medication asthma inhalers for children bactroban nasal ointment for mrsa when does viagra go generic safe online viagra levitra 5 mg elomet cream uses soviclor aciclovir cream 5 cockapoo rescue florida arcoxia medicine contraindication flomaxtra xl 400 designs plavix medication lotemax side effects weight gain olanzapine and fluoxetine capsulesolmesartan levitra side effects vardenafil venlafaxine xr 37 5 mg online uk order cialis safely online canada pharmacy no script indian drugstores how to order cialis from canada ciales puerto rico real estate geo trust cailis dermizol gel stain pregnant cat litter lasuna garlic festival 2015 esomeprazole vs omeprazole get viagra without seeing a doctor viagra wholesale price seroquel xr astrazeneca purchase real antabuse pulmicort respules children provera period doctor pharmacy online medications digoxina indicaciones para dutasteride avodart vs propecia cefadroxil 500mg doses terramycin antibiotic ophthalmic ointment with polymyxin b sulfate plendil without prescription online cialis prix en pharmacie belgique ezetimibe 10mg simvastatin 80mg interaction cytotec united states two unisom tablets medrol dose pack natural alternatives buy elocon ointment no prescription furadonin rural king desogen user reviewsdesyrel astelin discount coupon altace ramipril dose viagra vs cialis cost comparison sildegra tablet hotels viagra and cialis samples from pfizer acheter viagra pfizer vera bradley fabric by the yard digoxina 0 075000022 viagra phone orders licodexon obat batuk viagra ordering from india binotal ampicillin throat infection albenza dosage for pinworms canadian substitutes for viagra prozac nation movie epogen information secure medical viagra cheap viagra online overnight indocin dosage for headaches metroconazole for brain abcesses will amoxicillin cure chlamydia danazol drug interactions enalapril maleate medication vasotec nolvadex for sale master card 60 20mg cheapest generic taladifil ic valacyclovir hcl 1 test tren proviron cycle coumadin antidote vitamin k what are pills called o primox port letrozole 2.5 mg tablets dumocycline online accutane lawsuit accutane side effects lexapro generic date buy zolpidem us something better then viagra does daily cialis work fluzol 200mg progesterone doxycycline pills black market nifedipine ointment recipe cenveo layoffs and closings cheap tadalafi super active plus lotrel dosage remedio la prostata grande medications without rx takes amex bupropion hcl 150mg for weight loss progesterone only birth control pills bentyl 10mg dosage zithromax 500mg dosage cardura 8 mg dailycasodex flagyl 500mg increasing and decreasing functions in calculus viagra kaufen paypal buy abilify online cozaar 50 mg tablet peritol dermatitis treatment lamictal and alcohol reaction skelaxin muscle relaxer side effects allopurinol 100 mg tablet prevacid vs nexium medication augmentin 1g represa de cachi atacand on sale progesterone levels during pregnancy twins beconase aq nasal spray cost cordarone prospectors vytorin medication update viagra online ireland maxalt migraine headaches compazine no prescription tylenol pm side effects long term citalopram without a prescription india thailand pharmacy online diflucan evista side effects doctor levothroid recall 2015 nissan neurontin gabapentin lawsuits where to buy cialis in canada body building forum clomid arcoxia medicine side effects westhroid naturethroid tri levlen generics benemid contraindications to tpa himcolin gel bd price lotrel generic medication glucovance online no prescription atarax 25mg information malaseb shampoo dogs antibacterial indian mail order pharmacy provigil depression medication doctor ketorolac 10mg toradol omaggio olive oils vigre in usa without prickription pletal cilostazol medication ketorolac eye drops medication zetia generic ezetimibe subutex side effects drug pharmacy 1010 nexium 40 tabletten zum abnehmen in den duphalac syrup for kids vagiral ovulos para methocarbamol online 120 mg viagra avapro side effects irbesartan 150 cialis srbija prodaja robaxin side effects addictive use of duvadilan in pregnancy magnesium sulfate formula generic cialis with dapoxetine risperdal side effects gynecomastia augmentin and alcohol combination primox movie online pharmacy synthroid chinese herbal viagra tiger zofran side effects buy naproxen buy tidamax real cheap casodex withdrawal cialis for slae cheap viramune copay assistance program furosemide 40 mg side effects sotalol side effects betapace manufacturer flazol medicine wheel como tomar omifin pastillas viapro reviews capsule levofloxacin side effects medication progesterone suppositories side effects in early pregnancy generic name for prednisone lasik furosemide purchase order saroten retard albanese canesoral reviews on vigrxcaptopril vgr 100 facts about me cheap erectile dysfunction pill claritin reditabs xlpharmacy canada revenue buy cheap viagra online uk mh drugs kd 19 sildenafil garlic shrimp recipe pasta fucidin no prescription venlafaxine hcl er 37.5mg medrol steroid packs cialis pills canada cefaclor dispersible tablets formulations echeck canadian online pharmacy cheapest overnight generic viagra 100mg how to get viagra legally moltrin 800 for sale prevacid recall frumil wikileaks uk on line pharmacy garlic butter sauce for fish order no script voltaren tadacip 20 mg reviews over counter viagra in germany beconase aq nasal spray price levoxyl vs levothyroxine synthroid retin a micro gel without prescription glucophage 500mg price periactin used for migraines trileptal depression anxiety online apotheke kanada finestiride5mg pharmacy ketorolac 10mg toradol dose buy plavix on line no prescription sibutramine 15mg weight loss brand cialis viagra trial pack metoprolol succinate er vs metoprolol tartrate progesterone levels early pregnancy do you need a prescription for nolvadex best price 100mg generic viagra on line z pack antibiotic for sale side effects of cataflam tablets levitra generics sotalol 80 mg tab twice a day phenergan without prescription fast tesco viagra price 2012 tegretol medication uses sublingual vitamin b12 ambien addiction side effects zolpidem tartrateamebidalamikacin etodolac 300 mg cap generic allegra at costco australian pharmacies no prescription lovegra reviews arimidex bodybuilding dosage pfizer viagra price in pakistan dalacin t gel 1 water pills no prescription mexico detrol la coupons januvia side effects drugs lasix water pill buy online exelon stock price drop crestor side effects rhabdomyolysis lawsuit buy strattera online usa pharmacy secure drugshop probenecid and penicillin g suprax 400mg capsules bactrim without prescription cheap drugs levitra leconfield wines by wives actos and bladder cancer statistics lawyers in texas can you buy amoxicillin over prednisone 10 mg avodart coupon 2015 cialis viagra canada pyridium 200mg amiloride hydrochloride and hydrochlorothiazide etodolac 400 mg side effects canadian online pharmacy ambien buy clomid 100mg buy tretinoin cream usp omnicef antibiotic cefdinir side effects in babies jasmine waltz lee ryan clopidogrel mechanism of action and ppi domperidone maleate molecular weight lortab 7.5 325 mg betanoid 0 5mg hydrocodone buy propecia usa viagra online prednisone for poison ivy where can i buy elavil best life rx pharmacy ondansetron without prescription caverta 100 ranbaxy where to buy orlistat in canada motrin 800 ibuprofen coupon levitra generic available allopurinol side effects prescription free nitrofurantoin tablet risperdal without prescription ciplafield eas req statusuri zetia medication coupons metpamid nedir vitamix blender costco reviews diprosone ointment cephalexin monohydrate capsules eprex liturgia de las horas de hoy online sale of predisone mupirocin 2 used to treat supradol mexico obat meloxicam 15 mg dispensing viagra zanaflex capsules tizanidine suprax cefixime dose cialis from american companies mobicox 7 5mg percocet arthritis in the knee amitriptyline 100mg buy on line ciales cooperativa 29 cheapest kamagra oral jelly buy robaxin canada salbutamol nebulizer drug study coversyl 5mg viagra ne shqip topiramate 25mg for headaches best online pharmacies canada phentermine information lumigan 0.03 availability risperdal medication lawsuit buy viagra online uk no prescription flazol 500mg trimetabol syrup brands avedox fcebokcom isoniazid pronunciation of medical terms stromectol ivermectin scabies dogs furosemide 40 mg diuretic edex mixed with viagra viagra su ebay antabuse alcohol treatment casodex medication for prostate cancer mode daction flagile paypal motillium buy viagra 10mg online how to make your dick bigger mexican pharmacy with no cipro without prescription in us generic tadalafil side effects order nolvadex canada lidocaine and prilocaine cream 2.5 uses norstan consulting inc sustiva and truvada combosynthroid levitra fast delivery xalatan 0.005 ophth soln 2.5ml tamsulosin 0.4mg cap fosamax osteoporosis side effects ivermectin dosage for dogs heartworms oracef 250mg diphenhydramine what is viagra in hindi lamictal rash picture doxylis acheter doxycycline online pharmacy adderall xr side effects finasteride 5 mg generic tablets hyzaar forte dosage buy methotrexate no prescription clomid for men reviews nonprescription orlistat betacin tablets brand viagra shipped overnight from usa acheter cialis 5mg en pharmacie synthroid and weight gain primitine mist inhalers viagra online uk 1 tadalafil 20mg mastercard cheap online boutiques uk pliva 433 effects pros and cons of evista for osteoporosis allopurinol 300 mg propecia for women over 50 puretone stethoscope parts tamoxifen breast cancer drug cilais gel diclofenaco dosis pediatrica cheap rx generic viagra testimonials canadian pharmacy brand viagra tadalafila manipulada luvox and weight gain drug cheap medicine buy cialis no prescription pharmacie viagra clotrimazole and betamethasone cream medicine online 24 terbutaline injection dose canadian pharmacy online secure imovane 7 5mg information clearing oxybutynin 5mg tab qua elocon cream buy online yasminelle ulotka biedronka decadron dosage www pfitzer for brand pills amoxicillin or zithromax for sinus infection can u buy tetracycline viagra prezzi e confezioni baclofen 20 mg abuse prinivil medication himcolin side effects corlistat in australia viagra online indian pharmacy viagra mexico otc vilches ferreteros mexico vs usa naprosyn medication is a prescription gpchealth reviews for fifty buy proscar online in ireland cialis gel canada womera viagra kenya polarmeds complaints against companies in illinois buy zithromax 100mg online viamax gold price salibet ointment for boils avalide medication recall no prescription allegra d clomid pills for sale clozapine monitoring guideline amitriptyline usa buy nympho max in australia skelaxin abuse doctor que pastilla es mejor viagra o cialis anxiety medication lists tinidazole online viagra price in pakistan karachi rollbox player diclofenaco sodico 50 mg cialis brand 10mg online kaufen pay after dilivered india pharmacies motrin dosage for dogs ciprotab dosage for benadryl calis on line pharmacy ciprodex sterile otic suspension is this for eyes mexico pharmices to order meticorton mexico medicine online sildenafil 25 mg online bestellen detrol la side effects cytotec for abortion subutex treatment in pa misoprostol en costa rica viagra pharmacy online progesterone pills to start period amerimedrx cialis for daily use duloxetine hcl dr caps 60mg silagra by cipla india methotrexate walmart rogaine rebates clindamycin phosphate topical solution usp 1 ovral lo revatio cost best online pill site carbimazole and breastfeeding augmentin 457 doxazosin 8 mg tablets how to use them minocin dosage for mrsa wellbutrin reviews from patients weight loss phenergan dosage chart for children buying citalopram without prescription buy arimidex online canada viagra for women online can i get valtrex over the counter side effects of going off wellbutrin buy viagra 50mg toprol xl 50 viagra chops canadian pharmacies that take paypal
Home Jordan Kobritz Kobritz: What Will it Take for MLB to Ban Maple Bats?

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1126 guests online

Atom RSS

Kobritz: What Will it Take for MLB to Ban Maple Bats? PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 4
PoorBest 
Jordan Kobritz Article Archive
Written by Jordan Kobritz   
Monday, 27 September 2010 23:44

Shattered Bat

The debate concerning the use of maple bats by MLB players has flared anew after Cubs rookie outfielder Tyler Colvin was nearly impaled by the remnant of a shattered maple bat used by teammate Welington Castillo.

The shad hit Colvin under his collarbone causing an injury known as pneumothorax. In layman’s terms, a jagged piece of Castillo’s bat pierced Colvin’s chest wall and air leaked from his lung, becoming trapped inside his chest. If you think Colvin’s injury sounds life-threatening, it was. But fortunately, the outfielder was released from a Miami hospital after a four-day stay, thankful that only his season had ended and not his life.

A number of on-field personnel – umpires, players, and coaches – as well as fans have been the unintended victims of splintered bats. One fan, Susan Rhodes, was sitting in the stands during a game at Dodger Stadium in April 2008 when the flying remnants of a maple bat shattered her jaw. Rhodes’ injuries required multiple surgeries and resulted in permanent disfigurement.

Although not all the injuries can be attributed to maple bats, there’s no doubt that maple bats shatter at a rate that exceeds ash, and the splintering affect of maple makes such incidents exceedingly dangerous.

MLB and the Players’ Association formed a committee in 2008 to review the maple bat controversy. Multiple tests have been run to determine why maple bats shatter more frequently and to a greater degree than ash. Causes have included the wood itself, which is much denser than ash, and the design of maple bats. Because of its extra density, maple bats can be manufactured with larger barrels and thinner handles, which apparently makes them more prone to splintering.

So why not ban maple bats entirely? MLB can’t ban equipment without the consent of the MLBPA. According to Rob Manfred, MLB’s Executive Vice President of Labor Relations, the league has worked with the union on measures that have reduced the incidence of shattered bats by 50 percent in the past two years. While significant, those numbers suggest there is still a long way to go to improve safety for everyone at the ballpark.

Manfred also maintains that a ban on maple bats would imperil the games. Due to beetle infestation that has killed millions of ash trees, there isn’t enough “high-quality” ash available to keep up with the demand for bats.

Most MLB players currently use maple bats and don’t want to see their freedom of choice restricted. Castillo’s comments after his airborne bat injured Colvin are telling. “It wasn’t my fault,” Castillo told ESPN. “I didn’t want to hit him on purpose. That’s baseball. It happens.” The fact it happens more frequently when using maple bats didn’t seem to register with Castillo, who has used maple his entire career.

The union has every intention of supporting its membership on this issue. MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner told the Chicago Tribune, “We wish Tyler a speedy recovery. The bargaining parties have made meaningful progress on bat safety. We look forward to continued discussions with the Commissioner’s Office this offseason on practical solutions to enhancing safety in the ballpark.” Those carefully chosen words don’t suggest that the union is overly concerned about the potential – and perhaps inevitable - catastrophe that awaits one of its members or an unsuspecting fan.

To date, there is only one recorded suit against MLB for injuries suffered as a result of a shattered bat. MLB’s defense in that suit relies on the theory of assumption of the risk, where fans are presumed to understand and accept the risks associated with attending a baseball game, including the risk of being hit by foul balls and flying bats. While that defense has worked well in the past, it rests on the nature of the game, the unpredictability of when and how balls and bats leave the field of play and end up in the stands. In MLB’s own words, when players use maple bats over ash the risk of injury to fans may increase by 50%. That documented information is a plaintiff attorney’s dream.

It is way past time for the union and MLB to agree on measures that would prevent maple bats from shattering at a rate that exceeds ash. The alternative is to ban them entirely.


Jordan Kobritz is a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He is a former attorney, CPA, and Minor League Baseball team owner. He is an Assistant Professor of Sport Management at Eastern New Mexico University and teaches the Business of Sports at the University of Wyoming. He looks forward to your comments and can be contracted, here.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?