generic viagra review forums pfizer cipro antibiotic dosage buy lamictal hong kong prescription best generic dutasteride motilium tablets 10mg dosage ginseng pharmacy cheap generic acivir pills side effects of alli weight loss aid nepal generic viagra generic valtrex from canada do i need a prescription for chloroquine zestoretic generic release date medrol dose pack side effects anxiety where to viagra in singapore acticin for sale philippines cheap genuine colospa online liv 52 italiano generic prograf usa pharmacy diclofenac results forum buy zantac online amazon alli orlistat precio mexico donde comprar florinef casodex 150 mg tablets antibiotics for sinusitis chronic liposafe generic 2013 drugs discount viagra will you buy adalat canadian online penegra purchase where to buy duetact without a prescription medication ranitidine 150 mg prednisone 20 mg pill levothroid new zealand isoniazid no rx florida alligator attacks 2011 pharmacies amoxil accept visa cialis 10 mg cost is cozaar better than benicar online pharmacy levothroid buy decadron online no prescription united states buy cialis au where does lamictal rash appear canadian drugs buy glucotrol xl isoniazid order generic levitra plus for sale on line augmentin with food or without food life pharmacy dubai online what is the highest dosage for cymbalta crestor 10 mg 28 film tablet cost of proventil hfa inhaler western drug moduretic altace purchase doxycycline 500mg capsules cordarone medication side effects interactions zestoretic 40mg safe buy advair diskus online generic viagra price list generic tricor 145 can buy ventolin over counter uk how to take lipitor purchase compazine 10 mg where do alligators live map generic propecia from india safe revatio medication assistance can you buy trazodone buy benzac patch buy amlodipine online uk minocycline tablets used alesse order nolvadex research buy fast florinef delivery buy extendaquin mexican pharmacies price of abilify in canada seroquel dosage for bipolar ambien cr reviews cialis sublingual lawsuit canada amantadine western australia lioresal in canada can i get antivert drugstore princess pinterest why is there a shortage of fucidin cheap generic viagra online canada ranitidine no prescription needed order estrace estradiol discount brand viagra online us pharmacy phenergan sleep kids celebrex online order canada drugs lasix buy generic feldene online no prescription cheap snovitra super power can you buy levitra professional in ireland online drug cialis is there a drug comparative to cialis jelly advair diskus 1 buy discount pharmacy ordering online forum generic cialis low cost overnight lisinopril abana on line no script inderal next day delivery prednisone dosepak is generic zocor effective cleocin 150 mg price how to get high on clonidine augmentin bid 875 125 mg pravachol express canada asthma inhalers brown buy benemid in ireland to buy voveran sr in uk illegal buy viagra uk viagra order online mail buspar medication cost cheap geriforte syrup sale uk northstar rx propranolol viagra prezzo generico buy chloroquine without a script lexapro 100mg cheap order cialis sublingual online floxin without script atrovent hfa what does hfa stand for generic of cipro adalat watch online apni tv leukeran cats generic femcare cost xenical 120mg capsules 42 (s3) glucophage price walmart himalaya pilex usa tretinoin 0,025 usa cvs prices dramamine without insurance american probalan meloxicam for cats dose what infections is cipro used for buying atrovent for dogs cefixime 400 mg no prescription cheapest drug singulair does wellbutrin affect birth control pills best online pharmacy generic silagra sale ephedraxin generic zanaflex pictures side effects of diovan hct 160 12.5 calan shoppers drug mart cephalexin pills sweat express ordering cialis meloxicam overdose cats liquid viagra thailand paroxetine 100mg cheap pharmacy on line levitra bayer doxycycline for dogs drug treatment robaxin 750 price pastillas levitra 10 mg buy clomid in mexico proscar for sale philippines slimming tablets t500 generic propecia order small round blue pill 2531 v precose mg buy how much does flonase nasal spray cost taking trazodone without food cost comparison buy silagra sildenafil citrate post cycle therapy products biaxin drugstore com pharmacy technician online program georgia cvc cialis 5mg 5mg lexapro where to get nolvadex online dapoxetine online order uroxatral phone orders lioresal online pharmacy uk betnovate comprare billig isoniazid online kaufen non prescription buspar pharmacy buy cozaar cheap nolvadex dosage pct where to buy spironolactone where to buy baby zantac dcheap 5 mg cialis cheap tricor no prescription nitrofurantoin macro 100mg capsules uses cardura side effects long term use how much does zetia cost at walmart low cost mycelex-g cost of depo medrol injection diclofenac tablet sale propecia 1mg results cipla pharma india ltd acticin online uk where could i buy phenergan without prescription discount designer rx glasses clonidine on line for sale no script bupropion prix en pharmacie en france lamisil canada cream itch average topamax dosage legal buy ventolin online canada can you order zaditor save alliteration resources for ks1 buy confido boots cefadroxil 500 mg uses canadian pharmacy with generic viagra ebay allisport nexium spc best compazine prices pramipexole gyno how to use i pill cipla aleve tablets wiki nymphomax over counter uk daily cialis not working cheap synthroid sale uk over the counter biaxin ranitidine drugs online purchases how much bactrim to take for uti betnovate cream francais bupron sr discounted warfarin alternatives 2011 buy alli cheap loss cost of zoloft with insurance zoloft generic color 500/50 advair coupon floxin over counter uk where to get acai berries chloroquine and proguanil generic paxil coupons online drug stores mexico tetracycline price fixing alli simpson wikipedia the free encyclopedia erection packs 13 drugs is it safe to order atacand herbal viagra no side effects buy kamagra oral jelly overseas levitra 40 mg mastercard nolvadex sale australia anti-anxiety medication buspar side effects is there a drug comparative to tetracycline acheter lioresal pas cher buying cleocin gel using paypal purchase tadacip 20mg online buy canada no prescription for pravachol buy 100 mg lasix safe place order tadalis sx bupron sr 150 mg india generic vpxl femara over the counter buy generic metformin online no prescription seroxat withdrawal plan lipitor tablets buy best over the counter face highlighter generic levitra online canada medication for anxiety and depression nhs atepros dosage order epivir-hbv canada levitra 5 mg posologia what does a seroquel high feel like what is plendil drugs ampicillin order in the us remedio tolrest cloridrato de sertralina ampicillin pediatric dosage buy aleve on line motrin price compare cialis soft doctors online cheapest finpecia in the uk how to get lisinopril tenormin buy on line what is in imitrex medication buy doxycycline 10 where to get cialis prescription cefixime usa generic for allegra 180 discount canadian pharmacy premarin increase insulin sensitivity generic depakote vs brand name depakote benicar uk zyrtec canadian pharmacy arimidex by mail what is the generic name for metformin where to buy voltaren drugs online claritin allergy medicine for children keflex from europe allopurinol pharmacy uric acid levels orlistat uk supply list of medications that contain aspirin order retino a cream 0,05 lowest price rimadyl for dogs where finast serophene sold over counter augmentin prospect 1000 mg sumycin for men in usa increasing strattera dosage periactin generic usa acivir pills women buy discount lopid mg can you order diabecon depo provera spain buy no prescriptionsalbutamol inhalation free viagra voveran sr supplier in uk buy zoloft mexican pharmacies discount canadian pharmacy keftab como se dice alli en italiano zithromax canada head office buying cipro online how can i get my amaryllis to bloom where to buy alli in the uk zyloprim prices cvs india atacand price use viagra plus coupon online anafranil sr 75 mg 20 tablet generic viagra plus no prescription viagra ohne rezept kaufen erfahrungen depression medication citalopram minomycin online order viagra prescription only uk cheap viagra website amantadine fast usa free abilify process order comprar diclofenac gel original en madrid med cab propecia can you buy liposafe over the counter lasix 25mg compresse speman overseas dapoxetine uk price isoniazid woldwide shipping bactrim generic brand where to buy advair diskus with amex where to get adalat is generic zoloft safe acivir pills 20mg tab missed paxil dose symptoms apakah prednisone 5mg anafranil 25 mg novartis medicine called flagyl tadalis sx overnight shipping cheap cheap vasotec buy online information on coversyl medication prednisone 5mg dose pack 48 instructions is mail order zithromax safe wellbutrin 100mg kamagra pills what are they what does risperdal feel like buy hoodia no prescription fast delivery albuterol inhaler price compare acheter telephone mobicarte sfr drugstore foundation for oily skin 2013 crestor cost canadian adalat hindi serial download where do i levitra super active in canada what is zantac 150 prescribed for erythromycin uses sinus infection zithromax alcohol comprehensive view car salesman drug test when will a generic for cialis be available side effects of switching from synthroid to levothyroxine salep elocon untuk bayi generic uk paypal avapro betapace buy canada online pharmacy no prescription needed zoloft over the counter silagra lowest price kamagra gold tricor singapore address buy aricept from india what drug category is imitrex can you buy ventolin inhalers over counter uk prescription elavil drug in canada pharmacy elimite barato exelon max dose watermelon juice natural viagra zoloft 200 mg reviews buy antabuse cheap disulfiram prescription accutane pills drugstore simvastatin dose nhs skelaxin erowid vault my canadian pharmacy scams extendaquin over counter uk canada drugs floxin with prescription cialis 20 mg bivirkninger paypal excepted generic cialis amoxicillin 875 mg side effects glyset over counter uk what is cleocin ovules used to treat terbutaline sulfate for dogs albendazole discount online drugstore generic entocort cheap retin-a 0,025 sale uk where to buy alligator clips for hair bows supplies cheap lady era 100 mg descargar libro culturismo sin tonterias pdf buy beconase aq paypal prescription strattera no prescription cipro xl 1000mg which uk site to buy paroxetine where to buy original cytotec in manila side effects of minipress viagra de 100 mg singulair online canada viagra price uk where can i get pamelor pills diovan dose equivalent safe nitrofurantoin no precription celebrex available generic buy cheap revia pills zoloft capsules vs tablets cipro tab 500 mg can you open amoxil capsules buy viagra 100 kaiser generic viagra ordering zofran canada suprax price india viagra insurance online quickest roxithromycin clozaril without a prescription from us drugs similar to neurontin what does trileptal pill look like long time side effects levaquin bactrim sublingual dosage minocycline 100mg capsule side effects zoloft medication anxiety buy alesse bulk buy flagyl over the counter liquid clomid dosage pct do you need rx clozaril what is brahmi tablets how to take care of amaryllis after bloom zithromax 500mg pills how much does levitra cost per pill pharmacy mexico robaxin buy coversyl tablets us celebrex order online acquisto lotensin sicuro online buy cialis 200mg viagra prescription cheapest tegretol retard weight gain bystolic performance anxiety energizer advanced lithium coupons how to use terramycin ointment viagra jelly on line no script side effects of nizoral shampoo prednisolone pharmacy order should i buy accutane online levitra super active by mail comprar finasteride generico provera buy online canada 1xtra mistajam buy cheap nitroglycerin using pay pal best generic keftab sites actos medicine blum minipress pro for sale what is glycomet used for zovirax order malegra fxt on line no script diclofenac sodium enteric coated tablets 25mg buy effexor xr tablets online are albuterol and ventolin the same acheter cialis online what is the correct dosage of paroxetine buy brand viagra tablets india malaysia cialis 20mg buy tramadol online from usa pharmacy premarin cod saturday delivery testosterone therapy dosage and administration class action lawsuit against accutane in canada vendita viagra italia apple customer support number united states cytotec mg canadian rx xenical without script side effects buspar medication vardenafil dosage 20mg order voltaren ophthalmic solution is artane available over the counter viagra und mehr schnell und billig kaufen silagra now co uk cialis 20 mg everyday western drug micardis new ed drugs on horizon synthroid generic synthroid ditropan discount voucher zerit without insurance cheap atacand 40 mg purchase live ladybugs viagra online sales pfizer pictures of synthroid pills emsam where to purchase buy flonase 5 buy snovitra super power online no prescription united states generic requip problems where is arava border keftab canada prescription remeron without insurance levitra cheap deal prescription xenical orlistat how to take ginette-35 mg buy atorlip-10 bulk what is fate hollow ataraxia buying fluoxetine online uk best generic keftab review what is prednisolone sodium phosphate for children cymbalta 60 mg to 30 mg ed medicine online canadian pharmacy reviews forum propecia generic vytorin in usa clomid 100mg online non persciption vasotec purchase motrin 400 mg propecia to buy amantadina mecanismo de accion aricept pictures of pills where to give depo provera injection
Home Jordan Kobritz Kobritz: What Will it Take for MLB to Ban Maple Bats?

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 901 guests online

Atom RSS

Kobritz: What Will it Take for MLB to Ban Maple Bats? PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 4
Jordan Kobritz Article Archive
Written by Jordan Kobritz   
Monday, 27 September 2010 23:44

Shattered Bat

The debate concerning the use of maple bats by MLB players has flared anew after Cubs rookie outfielder Tyler Colvin was nearly impaled by the remnant of a shattered maple bat used by teammate Welington Castillo.

The shad hit Colvin under his collarbone causing an injury known as pneumothorax. In layman’s terms, a jagged piece of Castillo’s bat pierced Colvin’s chest wall and air leaked from his lung, becoming trapped inside his chest. If you think Colvin’s injury sounds life-threatening, it was. But fortunately, the outfielder was released from a Miami hospital after a four-day stay, thankful that only his season had ended and not his life.

A number of on-field personnel – umpires, players, and coaches – as well as fans have been the unintended victims of splintered bats. One fan, Susan Rhodes, was sitting in the stands during a game at Dodger Stadium in April 2008 when the flying remnants of a maple bat shattered her jaw. Rhodes’ injuries required multiple surgeries and resulted in permanent disfigurement.

Although not all the injuries can be attributed to maple bats, there’s no doubt that maple bats shatter at a rate that exceeds ash, and the splintering affect of maple makes such incidents exceedingly dangerous.

MLB and the Players’ Association formed a committee in 2008 to review the maple bat controversy. Multiple tests have been run to determine why maple bats shatter more frequently and to a greater degree than ash. Causes have included the wood itself, which is much denser than ash, and the design of maple bats. Because of its extra density, maple bats can be manufactured with larger barrels and thinner handles, which apparently makes them more prone to splintering.

So why not ban maple bats entirely? MLB can’t ban equipment without the consent of the MLBPA. According to Rob Manfred, MLB’s Executive Vice President of Labor Relations, the league has worked with the union on measures that have reduced the incidence of shattered bats by 50 percent in the past two years. While significant, those numbers suggest there is still a long way to go to improve safety for everyone at the ballpark.

Manfred also maintains that a ban on maple bats would imperil the games. Due to beetle infestation that has killed millions of ash trees, there isn’t enough “high-quality” ash available to keep up with the demand for bats.

Most MLB players currently use maple bats and don’t want to see their freedom of choice restricted. Castillo’s comments after his airborne bat injured Colvin are telling. “It wasn’t my fault,” Castillo told ESPN. “I didn’t want to hit him on purpose. That’s baseball. It happens.” The fact it happens more frequently when using maple bats didn’t seem to register with Castillo, who has used maple his entire career.

The union has every intention of supporting its membership on this issue. MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner told the Chicago Tribune, “We wish Tyler a speedy recovery. The bargaining parties have made meaningful progress on bat safety. We look forward to continued discussions with the Commissioner’s Office this offseason on practical solutions to enhancing safety in the ballpark.” Those carefully chosen words don’t suggest that the union is overly concerned about the potential – and perhaps inevitable - catastrophe that awaits one of its members or an unsuspecting fan.

To date, there is only one recorded suit against MLB for injuries suffered as a result of a shattered bat. MLB’s defense in that suit relies on the theory of assumption of the risk, where fans are presumed to understand and accept the risks associated with attending a baseball game, including the risk of being hit by foul balls and flying bats. While that defense has worked well in the past, it rests on the nature of the game, the unpredictability of when and how balls and bats leave the field of play and end up in the stands. In MLB’s own words, when players use maple bats over ash the risk of injury to fans may increase by 50%. That documented information is a plaintiff attorney’s dream.

It is way past time for the union and MLB to agree on measures that would prevent maple bats from shattering at a rate that exceeds ash. The alternative is to ban them entirely.

Jordan Kobritz is a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He is a former attorney, CPA, and Minor League Baseball team owner. He is an Assistant Professor of Sport Management at Eastern New Mexico University and teaches the Business of Sports at the University of Wyoming. He looks forward to your comments and can be contracted, here.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?