how to get away with online credit card fraud hdfc credit card reward points redeem applying for credit card with bad credit rating apply online for hdfc silver credit card virgin credit cards uk compare credit cards with low interest rates credit card with no credit check australia hdfc credit card interest rate details business credit cards gas rewards halifax credit card reward points approved cash advance dothan al hdfc credit card verification process starwood credit card points guy capital one credit card droid app credit card credit union or bank how do i get a portable credit card machine where are visa prepaid debit cards accepted new payday loan lender 2011 free credit card reader app android small cash loans uk lost paypal credit card uk sbi irctc credit card reward points canadian visa credit card numbers walmart visa gift card cash back credit card rewards blog tesco credit card deals for existing customers visa credit card services ireland advance america can;t pay what is the best credit card to use in australia best credit card deals balance transfers can you transfer a personal loan to a credit card chase visa freedom credit card login hsbc loan against credit card hdfc credit card payment online from hdfc canadian tire credit card online login what is a cash advance on my credit card credit card travel miles blog icici platinum credit card review bad credit small business loans pay belk credit card with debit card credit card uk bad credit history sams club discover credit card payment things to consider when comparing credit cards capital one credit card activation phone number citi credit cards usa visa credit card 5000 limit bank of america credit cards review balance transfer personal loan to credit card prepaid reloadable credit cards australia apply for store credit cards online hdfc credit card settlement process in india best credit card reward programs 2012 how to negotiate with credit card companies 2010 myer visa card cancel hdfc credit card payment online from sbi credit card credit card fraud for dummies full top 10 cash back credit cards uk credit cards cash back offers how to lower credit card apr rate gold plated credit card holder icici credit card helpline number delhi business cash advance uk generic credit card authorization form word credit card fraud punishment uk instant payday loans no credit check south africa track sbi credit card status credit card information stolen what to do should you pay off high interest credit cards first online credit card payment system singapore pay off credit card debt or save manchester united credit card maybank stats canada credit card debt canadian credit cards with travel insurance apply for personal loan with bad credit getting my first credit card uk visa canada credit card does chase have credit cards for college students credit card balance transfer offers no fee business credit card natwest online how to apply for credit card with bad credit in india post office credit card balance transfers pay jcpenney credit card in store best credit cards for students with no annual fee apple iphone credit card processing what is the best credit card in canada for rewards prepaid credit card to help rebuild credit where can i buy visa cash cards online credit card apr calculator balance transfer calculator australia how do i register my visa gift card for online purchases citibank reward credit card new credit card charges set to hit consumers can i apply for sears credit card online loans for bad credit without guarantor amex credit card promotions philippines pnc secured credit card denied easy to get credit cards australia capital one credit cards for bad credit bank of america credit card balance transfer offers what credit card to get with bad credit pc mastercard interest rate payday loan lender only credit card low interest balance transfer australia krungsri ge credit card online orchard bank credit cards pay online credit card with 0 interest on balance transfers for 12 months lord and taylor credit card services phone number pay my orchard bank credit card bill online axis bank credit card helpline no citibank balance transfer offer set credit limit virgin mobile citibank international platinum rewards credit card cancel home depot credit card canada free credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date 2013 compare low interest rate credit cards hsbc online credit card payment india cash register with scanner and credit card reader bad credit loan companies list rbc cash back visa redeem chase disney credit card login credit card applications for poor credit canada best credit card business canada virgin low rate credit card review alaska airlines bank of america credit card customer service who inherits credit card debt after death best rewards credit card usa credit card minimum payment law 2011 starbucks platinum card sold out amazon chase credit card deal receiving credit card payments on iphone hsbc credit card review australia credit card magnetic strip protector sleeve halifax student credit card online best credit card for students canada student with bad credit need credit card online credit card applications for bad credit in south africa best credit cards for gas rewards discover credit card ratings apply for gas credit card for bad credit m&s money credit card limit icici bank credit card apply online car loan with bad credit and repossession sample credit card application form for students visa business credit card no personal guarantee spread the cost catalogues for bad credit private student loans with bad credit and no cosigner natwest credit card fraud centre cash advance lenders direct online easy credit cards for business new law about credit cards 2013 samsung offers for icici credit cards different types of credit cards in south africa pnb credit card application form download low income credit cards philippines us bank credit cards phone number are cash advances on credit cards bad documents required for sbi credit card application best student credit cards no credit paypal mastercard uk pay monthly catalogues for bad credit credit card processing app for kindle fire visa credit cards numbers that work barclays credit card eligibility in india visa credit cards no credit what credit cards are made of metal best credit card offer april 2013 how to get free apps on kindle fire without a credit card where can i pay sears credit card pay a chase credit card bill best canadian business travel credit card aadvantage credit card signup bonus is a secured credit card a good idea ics international credit card services does applying for credit card affect credit rating best credit card for rewards points chase visa credit card protection change iphone credit card detail cash advance usa payday loan best credit card limits vanilla prepaid visa card canada balance rbs credit card services telephone number how to obtain a secured credit card with bad credit can a credit card company sue you in florida visa credit card bad credit no annual fee ikea store credit card usa fast loans with bad credit and no job payday loans like speedy cash citibank credit card application form sample cancel anz credit card insurance no annual fee credit cards rbc visa prepaid credit card instant 3 month payday loans how to get a payday loan online ehow black card points natwest net pay advance inc wichita ks compare credit card interest rates australia usaa credit card rewards merchandise starwood preferred guest(r) credit card from american express easy cash advance payday loans how to reduce my credit card debt fast best place to get a credit card for the first time reclaim credit card charges 2013 citi aadvantage credit card review can you apply for credit cards online home loans for bad credit citibank corporate credit card login india best buy credit card credit card login where to send my us bank credit card payment best buy rewards credit card mastercard annual gold card partner card babies r us credit card number 90 day payday loans no credit check australia federal law credit card minimum payment apply for credit card online 0 interest citibank credit card activation hsbc credit cards uk contact how to get a credit card if you have bad credit in canada chase credit card 12 months no interest how to get a prepaid credit card in usa credit card rewards canada 2011 guaranteed cash loans for bad credit bank of ireland credit card apply online which credit card is best in india 2011 store reward cards app for iphone buy prepaid virtual credit cards credit card online shopping cash back comparison virgin pay as you go credit card how to get a personal loan with bad credit in india bankamericard cash rewards platinum plus visa secured credit card cheap payday loans uk cheapest credit card balance transfer td canada trust visa debit age online credit card payment system new sbi credit card apply online mortgage calculator credit card payments national average credit card limit prepaid credit cards with overdraft walmart canada credit card customer service compare fixed rate credit cards bmo us dollar credit card air miles pnc credit card services telephone number using lloyds tsb platinum credit card abroad citibank indian oil credit card apply online virtual credit card paypal indonesia is there an app for walmart credit card natwest credit card payment protection claim tesco credit card ppi refund credit card balance transfers best deals is discover card good for building credit credit card application declined affect credit score business charge for credit card use international credit cards in india best credit cards uk black card visa gas station credit cards for fair credit how to pay sbi credit card online payment vanquis credit card balance phone number getting a chip and pin credit card in the us free payday loans online uk payday loan with bad credit uk ocbc great eastern credit card application form if interest rates are so low why are credit card rates so high citibank credit cards uae low interest rate credit card for bad credit credit card settlement dubai how do i get a business credit card if i have bad credit verifone credit card machine ink black cardigan women;s sweater chase generate virtual credit card lloyds tsb student credit card apply online chase credit card payment history discover credit card application phone tesco credit card bank transfer credit card helpline number hdfc secured short term loans online reporting unauthorized credit card charges low interest student credit cards canada best credit cards for travel benefits compare credit card interest rates ireland statute of limitations on credit card debt in wv icici credit cards online apply lowest credit card processing fees online credit card logos psd small personal online loans vanquis instant cash advance verify paypal prepaid credit card secured credit card canada compare target visa credit card payment address ba credit card payment charges kohls credit card number apply for a halifax clarity credit card absa credit card fraud insurance applying for credit card online safe discover walmart credit card payment mastercard credit card application for bad credit apply for ge money bank credit cards citibank credit cards contact no foreign transaction fee credit card american express rbs credit card offers for existing customers i need a personal loan with bad credit credit card for small business with no credit canada do you have to be 21 to get a credit card now what banks offer visa debit cards canada how to apply for a credit card in hdfc no credit credit cards to build credit apply for visa credit card with no annual fee freedom credit card pay as you go free credit card bin number search quick bad credit loans reviews lowest credit card rate in usa discover credit card credit score list of top credit card companies who is liable to pay advance tax instant online payday loan canada rewards cards for bad credit canada best credit card points pokemon black cardboard boxes vanquis credit card payment details get small business credit card bad credit how credit card processing works pdf unsecured credit cards after bankruptcy 2012 unsecured loans to consolidate credit cards hsbc secured credit card usa bank of america credit card usage abroad apply for a sunoco gas credit card secured credit card capital one bank capital one credit cards bad credit instant approval best cash back credit card offers in india is there a charge for using credit cards in canada bp gas rebate credit cards cash advance fee best travel credit card deals 2011 valid fake credit card numbers with security code american express credit card customer service number uk firestone auto care credit card login new payday lenders not brokers no credit check best credit card canada for bad credit ace online cash advance pro score credit card scale unsecured bad credit loan uk easiest way to get a credit card uk canadian prepaid visa credit cards hostelworld gold card review free travel credit card offers mobile credit card processing canada android td canada trust visa card login temporary credit card machine rental best credit cards for building new credit new bad credit credit card offers us bank cash back credit card review types of rbc visa cards american express platinum cashback credit card travel insurance best credit card deal uk marriott rewards premier credit card from chase review mastercard securecode enrolment quick and easy online loans in south africa bank of america visa rewards card login interest free balance transfer credit card australia credit card settlement letter format credit card reviews canada interest free credit card offers no fee balance transfers prepaid visa cards with no fees canada gift visa card difference between hbc credit card and hbc mastercard can you get a joint secured credit card liquid advance payday loans review credit card compliance regulations canada transfer credit card balance to someone else charge free credit cards abroad walmart credit card ipad app online payday loans direct lenders uk cerulean discover credit card reviews amscot payday advance fees everyday rewards cards au credit card application hsbc philippines home depot credit card services address barclays uk student credit card bank of america instant credit card approval sears sears mastercard credit card reviews best buy reward zone credit card usa cash back credit cards no annual fee uk getting a credit card machine for a business no fee prepaid reloadable credit card rate credit card reward programs hdfc virtual credit card statute of limitations on credit card debt in india compare business credit cards offers visa and mastercard virtual prepaid credit cards h&r block emerald secured mastercard credit card starbucks gold card perks credit card comparison site india best travel credit cards 2011 new credit card offers 2012 hsbc credit card application form easy gas credit cards to get approved for how to use apps store without credit card cash advance online lenders uk best credit card merchant account service what;s the best credit card to use in the usa cute free prepaid credit cards pay dillards credit card eligibility for sbi advantage credit card canadian travel credit card comparison anz low rate platinum credit card citibank visa credit cards australia hotel reward credit cards canada royal bank of canada visa card services credit score required for credit card canada usaa credit card score requirements cash advance online no credit check credit card balance transfer calculator best credit card for bad credit rating uk credit card debt 2012 hdfc credit card payment status check canadian tire mastercard cash advance how to apply for credit card online what credit cards can i apply for online marriott chase business credit card best fixed rate credit cards 2012 first direct credit card uk best way to refinance auto loan with bad credit pc credit card processing current credit card interest rates in south africa best buy rewards zone credit card payment easy payday loans hdfc credit cards customer care number best mastercard prepaid credit cards cibc credit card lost apply for credit card with bad credit and no processing fee can you sign up for amazon without a credit card coast capital business credit card chevron credit card review teachers platinum credit card hdfc visa credit card fraud protection pay advance america credit card offers $500 cash back i need a bad credit loan asap uk best rewards credit cards canada 2012 do i get credit checked for a company credit card santander 123 credit card cash back stores online application for credit card citibank virtual credit card terminal ireland credit card number and cvv number annual percentage rate calculator credit card credit card logos intuit salary pay advance form guaranteed unsecured credit cards for poor credit get a credit card with no credit check cash back credit card calculator new list of payday lenders apply for visa student credit card best business credit card offer 2013 best credit cards and why chase bank first credit card credit card visa mastercard american express new credit card rules for stay at home parents pay jcpenney credit card bill best travel points credit card 2011 how do manual credit card machines work kotak credit cards application status american express rewards credit card uk lowest fixed interest credit cards 2012 best buy credit card payment plan credit cards compare philippines what is cash back offer in credit cards visa debit cards india best credit cards canada 2011 can you get a credit card with bad credit canada paypal ebay credit card payment rewards cards app android us bank credit card application under review credit card reviews secured credit cards for bad credit uk how to get a credit card with no credit history yahoo answers payday cash advance loans florida chase credit card no international fees continental chase credit card application status paypal credit card reader walmart store credit card reviews credit card cash advance charge calculator how many different credit card types are there easiest bad credit credit card get bad credit loans online no brokers how do credit card rewards programs work what is the best online cash advance website does chase offer virtual credit cards best travel credit card usa radley credit card holder best credit card rewards programs 2011 best credit card reward offers 2013 cash same day payday loans how to negotiate credit card settlement canada credit card interest free on purchases for 12 months visa credit card app iphone best buy credit card login canada top credit cards for spending abroad best small business credit cards canada visa credit card numbers that work 2011 what is a good credit card apr 2012 easiest gas credit card for bad credit
Home Kyle Lamb Tax the Poor: An NBA Solution to Baseball’s Financial Disparity

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 566 guests online

Atom RSS

Tax the Poor: An NBA Solution to Baseball’s Financial Disparity PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 21
Kyle Lamb Article Archive
Written by Kyle Lamb   
Wednesday, 15 September 2010 23:44

A Biz of Baseball Original ArticlePlease welcome this first article by Kyle Lamb, the latest author for the Business of Sports Network. -- Maury Brown

A few weeks ago, several financial statements were leaked, causing shock and awe reverberations through the baseball community. Though the home front is all quiet in preparation for that National Pastime’s postseason, the winds of change are soon to pick up steam.

After the season, the MLB Player’s Association and Major League Baseball are due for earnest preliminary discussions for the next collective bargaining agreement. The Deadspin Scrolls, as I’ll call them, left some ownership seething over the (self) reported lack of spending by their colleagues. I can only imagine how the Player’s Association will respond.

As a refresher course, Deadspin leaked financial statements and balance sheets for six different Major League clubs. The gist of the documents suggested that some of these clubs were gratuitous recipients of Major League Baseball revenue sharing, but not necessarily aggressive spenders of those funds. Since Major League ownership is not privy to other clubs’ financials, owners were left staring at these documents in disbelief with the rest of us.

The affects of these leaks are not completely known and won’t be for some time. But rest assured hopeless romantics of a Major League salary cap were dealt yet another blow in the name of fruitless passion. Love hath no fury like revenue payors scorned.

The shock has worn temporarily. But it’s likely we’re merely inside the eye wall of “Hurricane Labor”, and the retribution for these documents will unleash the fury of a much stronger storm on the other side of the wall. The basic agreement expires following the 2011 season meaning the next 6-8 months are vital in the bargaining process.

I used to be in the camp that firmly believed a salary cap was key to the long term success of baseball. I’ve gradually come off those concerns. Instead, I actually support the implementation of a minimum salary tax. Make no mistake, I believe a tax threshold needs to be implemented on violators of both the high end (looking right at you, Yankees) and low end. However, the cries for a salary cap are likely to dwindle in the coming years, so it’s time to concentrate on the issues that are easier to get corrected.


A plan laid out in March by the Federal Communications Commission (“FCC”) might hold the key to baseball’s salary disparity. From the Washington Post on April 22:

“The FCC voted Wednesday to begin studying ways to achieve that goal, which was part of the agency's national broadband plan. One proposal would require paid television service providers to deliver their signals to a small adapter that could serve as a standard interface for broadband and paid television content. That adapter would connect to a television, computer or other device.”

As part of that plan, reported in March that the FCC has also delegated unused frequencies from over-the-air (“OTA”) television providers to be used in conjunction with the national broadband plan. The intent here is very clear—the FCC believes strongly in the future of delivering broadcast content over the internet.

David Colarusso, columnist for the Huffington Post, had an interesting column on this subject this past spring. He wondered how long it would be until a la carte programming was delivered, possibly free, over the internet.

Colarusso writes, “This week, the FCC laid out its vision for a future where everything is carried over the Internet, and Comedy Central cut the commercials back down to one per break for all but the first ad block. The future is clearly up for grabs. So I couldn't help but wonder, how long will I be able to avoid paying for cable, and more importantly, if everyone adopted my viewing strategy, would it be sustainable? Would someone still make Mad Men?”

The future is already here; sort of.

The cable provider Verizon FIOS already offers some a la carte programming through their television service. Fancast, owned by NBC parent company Comcast and Hulu, a joint General Electric, ABC and Fox venture, both stream many of the most popular shows over the internet with short advertisements in lieu of standard 3-minute commercials. Though this model has yet to fully vest a full evacuation of cable television, the media research site ComScore reported nearly 40 million unique visitors to Hulu in March 2009, which is significant considering there are an estimated 120 million television-ready homes in the United States.

By now, you’re reading this information and might be reminded of Annie’s famous Field of Dreams line to her husband Ray Kinsella, “look, he’s my favorite writer too, but what’s Terence Mann got to do with baseball?”

This seismic, fundamental shift to internet television, possibly pick-your- programming, will allow Major League Baseball a more concentrated portion of revenue from content. Wisely, Commissioner Selig had the foresight to set up MLB Advanced Media L.P., which is a subsidiary of Major League Baseball’s Central Fund (the centralalized revenue sharing account), the controlling entity of and the growing services MLB TV and’s At-Bat mobile device application.

These services, which stream Major League Baseball games over the internet by video and audio respectively (i.e. television and radio feeds of your chosen favorites), play an important role in the future of Major League Baseball revenue sharing. All 30 clubs have an equal interest in MLB Advanced Media, meaning as the transition from over-the-air television to online a la carte happens, MLB is in position to control most of the revenue and divide it equally among clubs.

This also means that as the revenue becomes largely centrally distributed, local revenue disparity from broadcast rights will dwindle. In fact, it’s conceivable that the majority of any disparity in revenue 10 or 15 years from now might be from attendance and concessions.

There will undoubtedly be some obstacles along the way. The Yankees’ and Red Sox began a trend pioneering their own cable networks, profiting billions along the way. With ownership in YES and NESN respectively, these cable networks pay the club annual fees for rights to broadcast games for just pennies on the dollar. The networks benefit by keeping the costs low, but making a fortune on advertising meanwhile the clubs have the advantage of reporting lesser revenue but still be able to pump back capital investments into the club. It’s been a win-win situation. It’s certain these investments, ones in which the Baltimore Orioles, Washington Nationals and other clubs have already joined suit, will complicate the transition to a mostly-internet revenue stream.

But assuming, then, the need for a cap is diminishing, and the efforts to get concessions to implement one from the Players’ Association is futile, perhaps the key to the immediate health of Major League Baseball lies within the NBA’s own cap structure.

To some people, the thought of using anything related to the NBA salary cap is more frightening than what Mark Cuban might say next. After all, the system is convoluted enough that general managers often hire a “capologist,” to explain if two plus two really does equal four within the cap guidelines. However, nested within the finer details of a complex cap system is a simple, equitable solution that players, owners and the commissioner could (and should) rally behind: designated income levels for players.

In the NBA, the league pools together what it terms all “basketball related income” or BRI, to create a functioning salary cap. The BRI is a league sum of revenue relating to attendance, marketing, television and radio, etc. Of course what we’re after is not a salary cap, and any system relating too closely to the NBA would be seen as a de Facto salary cap by the MLBPA—or at least another step towards it.

But we can draw the line before that.

The NBA currently defines its cap at 51 percent of the BRI. In addition to this, the league sets a mark (currently at an estimated 61 percent) to apply a luxury tax. The tax is set at a higher level than the cap because the NBA uses exceptions to function over the cap. A team cannot go over without using a limited number of exceptions. These exceptions range from signing your own free agents to signing a player at the mid-level average salary. Since teams are limited in their flexibility once over the cap, the league offers some leeway before assessing a tax.

In addition to this payroll, however, the league also has an escrow system that designates a certain percent of salaries paid to players. In this escrow system, a certain percentage of money is taken from each player’s pay and held in escrow. After the season, the league assesses the entire amount of money paid to players, and redistributes the amount necessary to guarantee the players their guaranteed share. Currently, players are guaranteed between 57 and 58 percent of overall BRI. Anything under this amount is paid back to the players. Anything over is redistributed back to the owners.

The Players’ Association would never allow any system that essentially garnishes wages of its earners. However, this concept could be strategically applied to the revenue sharing system to better guarantee compliance from payees within the system.

Let’s start with the basics of revenue sharing. The straight-pool plan transfers 31 percent of a team’s local net revenue into a pool, and distributes it evenly among 30 teams. Biz of Baseball reported in February that an estimated $433 million was transferred between local and central revenue. That amount derives from the local portion and an amount necessary from the Central Fund to achieve 48 percent of the revenue being transferred.

Local revenue is essentially the sum of a team’s revenue from local broadcasting rights, gate receipts, concessions or parking, advertising and marketing. If a team brings in $100 million, then $31 million would be paid into the revenue sharing pool. Let’s say a team earns $100 million in local revenue, pays out $31 million and then receives back $15 million from the equal pool sharing. We would say, then, a team has earned $84 million in net local revenue.

Major League baseball could potentially solve several problems by applying a stiff (i.e. twice the dollar amount) threshold to baseball income above and below the set parameters.

Using our $84 million example in net revenue, let’s say a team earns an additional $50 million in central fund sharing. We could apply a minimum threshold of 60 percent, meaning teams must spend at least 60 percent of their revenues in salaries (defined by signing bonuses and 40-man roster costs) and a maximum threshold of 80 percent. In our example of $84 and $50 million ($134 mil total), a team would have to commit at least $80.4 million to payroll obligations to avoid tax assessment, but less than $107.2 mil. If teams are under the threshold, the amount is withheld from the central revenue sharing and paid out to the players on the roster in proportion to their salaries, and the a fine is assessed and added to a large pool. If a team goes over the amount, twice the dollar amount is withheld from the central fund payment, and added to the escrow pool.

Essentially then, every dollar below or above these thresholds are taxed and applied to an escrow account. A percentage of the account shall go toward the industry growth fund (as tax payments do currently) and the rest shall be divided up and split evenly among non-violators of the tax threshold. This system would promote teams to spend on the low end, but spend conservatively on the high end.

The risk here is the union calling this a de Facto salary cap. But in reality, there’s nothing stopping teams from going over the threshold, merely a financial penalty for doing so. But the positives would have to outweigh the negatives if you’re the Players’ Association. This guarantees the players a set revenue as baseball grows in popularity and industry revenue.

If the future of television unfolds as industry experts are predicting, the need for a salary cap may vanish entirely. A tax penalty, or some sort of soft cap could be implemented later down the road, but baseball would conceivably be much healthier financially than it has ever been. Competitive balance might close to being achieved.

There’s still that hurricane-a-coming in the near future. But if the two parties want to avoid the storm surge, it should look to the NBA for guidance. A guaranteed percentage of revenue might seem like a short-term fix, but it could actually be the step toward a happier working relationship.

Kyle Lamb is staff writer for the Business of Sports Network. He looks forward to your comments.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?