reloadable prepaid canadian credit cards prepaid credit card post office australia apply for credit cards online visa direct payday lenders uk disney visa rewards card code what factors should you consider when choosing a credit card best airmiles credit card canada credit card merchant agreement id american airlines credit card offer 2013 i need a secured credit card to build my credit canadian visa credit card apply for a orchard bank credit card online capital one credit card credit limit increase easiest unsecured credit card to get in canada best credit cards no annual fee low interest online standard chartered credit card payment india hdfc bank credit card 5 cash back credit card validator online free best new credit card 2012 credit cards visa signature bmo us mastercard exchange rate key ring reward cards app review sears kmart credit card new credit card for bad credit mbna credit card reviews uk united airlines credit card offer 50000 lord and taylor credit card make a payment capital one credit card app iphone payday loans online no credit check south africa walmart credit card approval time moneysavingexpert soft search credit card bmo mastercard travel insurance hsbc 2 cash back credit card payday cash advance forum black card visa requirements best credit card to get with bad credit starwood credit card australia icici credit card settlement cibil credit card credit score 700 apply for a credit card online and get instant approval my first premier credit card pay online allahabad bank india card master international credit card vanilla prepaid visa card canada balance apply for credit card with bad credit hdfc corporate credit card status business credit cards visa black sample visa credit card number philippines business credit card natwest online marriott credit card promotions uk how long to pay off credit card with minimum payment formula southwest credit card offer phone number gas cards for not so good credit random credit card number generator with security code online how fast does a secured credit card help your credit nab credit card insurance payday lenders only no credit check random visa card security code gas rewards credit card offers can you get cashback on a prepaid credit card pnc everyday rewards credit card chase marriott rewards credit card benefits cash advance rate meaning master credit card number generator is a walmart credit card a good idea walmart canada credit card apply getting store credit cards after bankruptcy credit card interest rates comparison south africa standard chartered credit card review philippines guaranteed credit card approval australia company credit cards with rewards vcc virtual credit card indonesia credit building credit cards bank of america horizon gold credit card catalog credit card data protection policy discover credit card usa british airways american express credit card benefits capital one online banking credit cards canada credit card apr rates average sbi online credit card application status visa card issue number hsbc credit card amortization calculator extra payment difference between titanium and platinum credit card hdfc credit card credit limit meaning hdfc credit card reward points catalogue india freedom credit card categories online application for sbi visa card best buy credit card canada apply business loans on credit card sales fifth third bank credit card processing credit card for bad credit no annual fee no deposit top ten best credit cards 2013 same day guaranteed payday loans compare travel points credit cards credit card information free 2013 net pay advance wichita same day cash advance online report credit card fraud to police american express premier rewards gold card credit score capital one credit card app status apply for staples business credit card online how to claim natwest credit card points are orchard bank credit cards good merchant credit card rate comparison credit card with bad credit or no credit icici credit card payment using debit card nab visa debit card review compare credit cards cash back american express credit card verification code pnc national city credit card login air miles credit card comparison credit card with rewards no fee gas saving credit card canada credit cards with rewards for gas federal government credit card debt relief standard credit card fees for businesses best credit cards usaa credit card for student with no credit history disney visa card application status japanese credit card number format halifax credit card online security 4 types of credit cards credit card processing for small business reviews secured credit card bad credit uk payday loans no credit check paypal credit card numbers generator how to allow credit card payments on ebay apply for capital one secured credit card canada can i use a non us credit card for itunes best online loans uk fake credit card number and cvv prepaid visa credit cards india eliminate credit card debt fast tesco credit card balance transfer deals best international credit card 2011 free virtual credit card generator capital one apply for credit card direct lender payday loans online no credit check online merchandise credit cards for bad credit how to get a credit card when you have no credit citibank credit card payment due date sears citi credit card customer service phone number ryanair credit card charges dbs credit card promotions singapore credit cards after bankruptcy discharge australia i need a loan to consolidate my credit cards credit card numbers generator online best cashback credit card singapore student credit cards no income requirements ifsc code for hdfc credit card payment bangalore hdfc bank international credit card charges discover credit card reviews 2013 get credit card now pay monthly payday loans prepaid visa cards apply student credit card online instant approval best canada credit cards good credit cards for first timers application for credit cards online discover credit cards payment hdfc bank credit card helpline number bangalore does getting a new credit card hurt your credit score capital one credit cards uk apply for a credit card free credit card numbers and security code and expiration date that work 2012 bad credit car leasing companies credit card approval formula rbs black credit card travel insurance ics credit card online abn amro fake credit card numbers that work canadian tire cash back credit cards can you apply for a lowes credit card online free balance transfer credit cards ireland student credit cards no interest credit card comparison australia balance transfer credit card low interest rates no annual fee what is credit card issue number what is one disadvantage of using a credit card to get a cash advance how to get a joint credit card best new credit card chase 0 balance transfer no fee easy credit cards to get approved for with bad credit canada discuss the cost of accepting credit cards sears credit card application puerto rico new credit card rules 2012 in malaysia best business credit card cash back citibank credit cards emi offers hdfc gold credit card eligibility criteria credit card payment app ireland wells fargo credit card rewards site standard chartered credit card online payment india citibank balance transfer balance transfer credit cards martin lewis no annual fee credit cards india standard chartered bank credit card promotions sri lanka national city credit card services online good credit cards in canada for students how do credit card vending machines work tesco credit card minimum payment bank of america secured credit card instant approval best value credit card australia 2013 track lloyds tsb credit card application black cardigan coat what is the best credit card to have yahoo answers how does applying for a credit card affect credit rating hdfc credit card payment through credit card hsbc starbucks credit card promo student credit card credit union online cash advance direct lenders only interest free on balance transfer credit cards credit card rewards comparison calculator instant decision payday loans online rbs credit cards apply online credit card helpline icici cashback on credit cards taxable united credit card hotel deals premier credit card rewards small business start up credit cards for bad credit goodyear credit card sign in cash back credit cards no foreign transaction fees facts about credit and credit cards requirements for getting approved for a credit card consumer reports best low interest credit cards cash back credit cards for business compare travel credit cards 2013 barclays platinum card online dillards credit card application visa black card stainless steel hdfc credit card payment from other credit card how to get a bad credit loan without a bank account travel rewards credit card for average credit standard chartered credit card points redemption philippines army navy federal credit union barclays credit card application status india credit cards for newly discharged bankruptcy best secured credit cards after bankruptcy apply cibc credit card online military pcs pay advance best unsecured credit cards for building credit natwest credit card online points visa black card requirements ez payday advance olathe ks is capital one a good credit card after bankruptcy list of all credit card companies in india bad credit credit cards guaranteed approval no deposit interest free credit card loans beli virtual credit card indonesia payday loan lender guaranteed approval bad credit loans no credit check no brokers icici credit card limit calculator nationwide visa credit card exchange rate get instant payday loan online td canada trust business travel visa wells fargo credit card services reviews how does apr work on a secured credit card santander credit card deals for existing customers does applying for store credit cards affect your credit spg credit card bonus points visa credit cards applications citibank credit card offer malaysia guaranteed credit card canada bp gas credit cards with cash back how to calculate interest charges on credit card balance opus credit card bank of scotland discover card credit score tracker free credit card numbers and cvv codes that work 2013 platinum card emirates easiest cheapest way to accept credit cards chase credit card cashback calendar best small business rewards credit card 2012 citibank credit card online capital one platinum credit card limits visa credit cards with no international fees payday lenders no credit check uk template letter to claim credit card charges walmart gift visa card bad credit personal loans not payday loans online neiman marcus credit card payment center ge capital walmart credit card customer service credit card points guy ebay paypal no credit card citibank credit card pre approved loan virgin 0 credit card balance transfers air canada credit card us lowest fixed rate credit card offers how to get us credit card for foreigners hdfc credit card interest rate 2012 easy credit card checker 2010 online cash advance lenders reviews heritage first usa credit card paypal credit card charges malaysia credit card fraud detection using hidden markov model ppt download credit union credit cards australia chase bank credit card limits best secured credit card in india how to use stolen credit card numbers kwik fill / red apple credit card application bank of america credit card cash advance online apply for a loan online instant decision bad credit how to apply for bdo mastercard debit card coast capital credit card application bank of america corporate credit card payment tesco credit card protection on purchases non 3d secure credit card legitimate poor credit loans list of credit card processing companies canada hdfc credit card due payment options new bad credit card offers get credit card for bad credit rating average credit card fees for merchants best no fee transfer balance credit cards best student credit cards 2012 uk delta skymiles credit card foreign transaction fee personal online loan lenders square credit card fees review do american express prepaid cards build credit pay advance tax online pnb vanilla gift visa card check balance shell credit card ppi claim best citi credit cards capital one credit card services login apply for uk credit cards online credit card payoff calculator comparison rbc bank visa platinum credit cards best airline credit card offer register credit card online barclays barclay apple credit card review valid visa card security code credit score needed for a best buy credit card icici credit card offers on jewellery credit card terminal for iphone australia ebay buyer protection credit card how to get a credit card merchant account online apply for hdfc platinum credit card how to apply for a mastercard in kenya bank rakyat credit card application form citibank credit card fraud alert icici bank online apply credit cards accept credit cards free paypal prepaid reloadable visa cards canada credit card banks usa best credit cards with rewards programs getting a home loan with bad credit history cash back visa credit card canada three types of credit card fraud african bank online loan application check application status hdfc credit cards citibank credit card application form sample american airline credit card promotions visa credit card for small business firestone credit card login money magazine best travel rewards credit cards wall street journal prime credit card rate compare canadian visa credit cards cheapest credit card balance transfer post office credit card ppi reclaim no credit loans uk personal loans online uk home loan with bad credit score credit card reward schemes compared credit card uk comparison credit cards for bad credit instant approval no deposit mbna credit card canada phone number guaranteed secured credit cards for bad credit compare best small business credit card e application for sbi credit card online credit cards canada can i claim ppi on my halifax credit card tesco credit card online payment td prepaid credit cards canada myer visa card annual fee city bank credit card login singapore transfer balance credit cards canada reward points hdfc credit card offers new horizon credit card reviews exxon mobil gas credit cards best banks for credit card debt consolidation 0 balance transfer apr credit cards lowest apr credit card 2013 free credit report no card details required what are the numbers on the back of credit cards walmart discover credit card cash advance jetstar international credit card fees credit card uk no credit history pay barclay credit card online credit card with no joining fee in india online loan lenders for the unemployed chase slate card credit limits how to use canadian credit cards at us gas stations paypal non-profit credit card processing fees no foreign transaction fee credit card usa can you apply for a maurices credit card online best secured credit card guaranteed approval best credit card to rebuild credit quickly best credit card for travel rewards no annual fee credit card protection paypal calculate credit card payment with no interest lloyds tsb airmiles duo premier credit card merchant visa credit card fees bank of america credit card settlement forum tesco credit card payment methods is there any way to get a credit card under 18 pay advance loans uk how to lower credit card apr long black cardigan sweater travel reward credit cards for bad credit air miles rewards cards applications best money back credit cards 2012 canada all unsecured credit cards for bad credit southwest airlines credit card promotions 2013 credit card application hsbc requirements city bank credit card movie offers kroger us bank credit card login cash advance uk chase credit card protection program how to redeem hdfc credit card points for titanium card chase credit card rewards redemption swiss miles and more credit card hdfc credit card apply free credit card machine for iphone amazon storing credit card information how to get a credit card with bad credit and no job hsbc credit card rewards uk credit card fees explained cheap cash advances payday loans marriott credit card authorization form fairfield inn contacting capital one credit card uk credit card payments for small business hdfc credit card statement bbb accredited bad credit loan companies best cashback credit card virtual credit card indonesia gratis best buy canada credit card phone number costco merchant credit card services uk best payday lenders bad credit instant cash loans online in south africa black cardigan topshop hdfc credit card settlement india all of these are types of credit except credit cards.installment loans.mortgages.bonds interest free credit card transfer offers citibank australia credit card travel insurance best free android credit card reader major credit cards accepted logo how do you get a nandos black card credit card number samples for testing icici credit card online application credit union loans ireland short term cash loans online pay orchard credit card by phone check status of costco credit card application ann taylor credit card review should i take a personal loan to pay off credit card debt spider credit card search tool credit card credit limit decrease cash advance rate united mileage plus credit card review walmart visa gift card cash back uk credit rating citifinancial credit card customer service number bdo credit cards application form gas credit cards consumer finance college students and credit cards hdfc bank credit cards eligibility best air mile rewards credit cards mastercard exchange rate app best website for comparing credit cards credit card report date hsbc direct rewards discover credit card apply for business credit card bad credit credit card with no international service fee cheapest way to get a credit card machine black visa card login how to build your credit rating with a credit card visa credit card comparison australia halifax platinum credit card cash back aqua credit card contact email how to avoid credit card frauds online loan companies with monthly payments mbna credit card charges abroad orchard bank secured mastercard credit card woolworth everyday rewards credit card login credit score for discover card approval amex credit card number format how to you get a nandos black card apply for credit cards with bad credit compare all credit cards canada standard chartered credit card online payment billdesk compare visa credit card australia free black card nandos online payday loans direct lenders ohio unsecured credit card canada bad credit what;s the easiest credit card to get easy fast online payday loans no credit check credit cards for students ann taylor credit card free shipping marriott reward credit card credit cards in canada south west trains gold card discount how do you consolidate your credit card debt paypal take credit card payments over the phone best store cards to build credit uk free reloadable virtual credit cards
Home Maury Brown Maury Brown and Will Carroll Discuss HGH Testing in Baseball and Football

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 591 guests online

Atom RSS

Maury Brown and Will Carroll Discuss HGH Testing in Baseball and Football PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 9
Written by Maury Brown and Will Carroll   
Wednesday, 24 February 2010 12:45

Maury Brown and Will CarrollThe New York Times is reporting today that MLB plans to introduce testing for human-growth hormone (HGH) at the minor league level later this year. The story comes on the heels of a two-year ban Monday for British rugby player Terry Newton testing positive for HGH.

In a statement this morning, the league addressed the story.

“We are well aware of the important news with respect to the HGH blood test in England . We are consulting with our experts concerning immediate steps for our Minor League Drug Program and next steps for our Major League Drug Program. The Commissioner remains committed to the position that we must act aggressively to deal with the issue of HGH.”

It should be noted that in January of 2008, Commissioner Selig addressed the topic of HGH testing by saying, “When a valid, commercially available and practical test for HGH becomes reality – regardless of whether the test is based on blood or urine – Baseball will support the utilization of that test.”

The news that a North American professional sports league is considering introduction of a test for human-growth hormone is a significant story with more of its fair share of questions. To address some of those questions, Will Carroll, Baseball Prospectus staff member, and author of The Juice: The Real Story of Baseball’s Drug Problem (Ivan R. Dee Publishing), and I had the following email conversation today.

Maury Brown: For the uninitiated, how does HGH work in the body, and what, if any, advantages does it give as a performance-enhancing drug?

Will Carroll: HGH, like any hormone, is a protein created by the body. In HGH's case, it's from the pituitary and stimulates growth, cell reproduction, and has some other secondary functions, such as insulin control. It pretty much is self-explanatory. Once recombinant technology made it possible to supplement the natural production, its push as an anabolic agent (growing muscle) was predictable, but the scientific studies have some major questions about it's efficacy. It's also very expensive, easy to track, and hard to store/transport, which makes it far from ideal for doping.

Brown: The league is going to put the testing in place later this year… in the minors, where there is no union protection. The New York Times article implies that that the test might be blood-based. But, even if it isn’t, and it’s urine-based, by MLB’s own admission, the current tests have proven unreliable. That seems to set up a case where the MLBPA would fight it, and there’s the possibility that a minor league player could sue for lost wages, if suspended. For me, the intent is in the right place, but the timing of implementation is off.


Carroll: It's definitely blood-based. There is no urine based test, though Don Catlin is working on both of these. He said early last year that we were still "years away" from an accurate urine test and since we're just now getting to a stage where the WADA blood test is accepted, I think he's optimistic.

The MLBPA has nothing to do with this. This is the minor leagues. There's also no chance that a minor leaguer could sue and win. What I'm curious about are this:

1) Timing is coincident with the first positive HGH test, done in Rugby League of England. That they've never caught someone at Olympics or other WADA-conducted testing tells me it's not that big an issue, not that the test is problematic.

2) What's the test they are using and by extension, what lab? My guess is that it's the WADA test and therefore a WADA lab, like the one MLB uses in Montreal. I don't know that the minor league program is handled the same as MLB.

3) What's the detectable period for the test they're using?

4) Why are they not clearly saying this is blood testing? They can't possibly be using the Ceres test. How will they collect, store, how often, etc?

Brown: Well, to be clear, the commentary on “MLBPA fighting this” is to say that this will be a test in the minors and moving beyond it will be problematic. But, you and I have both seen the most recent Minor League Drug and Treatment Program, and it has been historically used as a jumping-off point for bargaining more stringent testing at the Major League level.

As for whether a minor league player would not be able to sue and win, I’m not so sure. Why wouldn’t there be a case to be made that the current tests out there unreliable?

Back to trying to get an HGH test at the Major League level… I see privacy concerns, based upon blood testing. That, and look how sideways the 2003 Survey Test went. It’s still outstanding in the courts, and could redefine search and seizure. Imagine if blood tests were seized by the Feds. I don’t see HGH testing in the majors for some time… and with that I mean, not until there’s a reliable test out there.

Carroll: I think they see it creeping up, but I also think that it's going to be difficult to fight public opinion. Facts don't work - look, HGH studies have shown conclusively that it's not effective and can actually REDUCE performance. Ok, it makes bones stronger - not a benefit! The detectable period is laughably short. Still, Bud will wave something at Michael Schmidt and ESPN and they'll jump.

First, the public opinion will be massive against the player. Second, most minor leaguers aren't going to have the resources and to go against WADA, you have to go against their system, which will end up at the Court of Sport, not some judge.

WADA's making the argument - strongly - that their blood test is reliable. Those are good, strong scientists who believe strongly in their cause. Rabin and Vernec are not people I'd want to be trying to beat if I was on the other side. If the PA were to make the "unreliable" argument, public opinion would whack them senseless. Again. I'm more curious what the NFL will do, since HGH was a bigger issue for them a decade ago (but is unlikely to be used now.)

Brown: I think there’s a good case to be made that the court of public opinion might raise a ruckus if the PA were to fight it, but by the same token, the fact that blood testing is in play, and is currently unreliable, brings up very real privacy concerns, which many in America can relate to and support. What is going to happen to the samples once tested? You can’t destroy them immediately in case there is a positive test and a retest of the sample were needed to see if it were a false positive. Given how

As for the NFL, they’re already watching closely, and have been trying to get the NFLPA to relent on HGH testing (ESPN is reporting today that the NFL is trying so, again). You have to think each league is communicating over the issue, as are the respective unions for the players.

I just keep coming back to what happened with the 2003 Survey Test samples for steroids. Fighting over privacy concerns seems reasonable based on Constitutionality.

Carroll: You're not going to win on "unreliable." I've sat across a table from the WADA guys and you're just not going to win. Michael Weiner doesn't need my advice, but if I were him, I'd come out and say "We'll be glad to accept an addition of an HGH urine test to the standard panel. We'd also accept for-cause testing for a blood test." You win the public battle and force MLB to be the ones looking to put needles in people. It's a much different situation for the NFL - HGH has already been a major problem for them and size matters in the NFL. Problem is, the league and PA aren't on the best of terms there.

I don't understand your point on samples. Blood testing has an A and B, just like urine. Let's get past the "false positive" thing - red herring. Same with the seizure of samples - the legal issue there is not seizing the samples, but seizing the computers. Today's testing is not anonymous and the G, if they wanted, could grab a sample out of the hand of the collector and see the name right on the tube. This isn't the survey testing and will never be. Athletes initial the sample, for cripe's sake.

Brown: On the “advice” to Michael Weiner: I can see the former but not the latter. There are privacy concerns, and they’ve already voiced that issue. What I’m interested in is if there is a commercially viable test in the works for urine. I keep thinking of what Don Fehr said last March.

"You see periodic reports that there are [HGH] tests out there, and then you never hear about them," Fehr said. "There's certainly no indication that I know of that there's a commercially available test, much less a commercially available urine test, which would solve a lot of problems. It would have to be something that was accurate, that can be vetted and validated by scientific institutions other than the ones trying to sell it to you."

If they get a commercially viable test nailed down for urine, then I think the MLBPA signs off on it.

As for the NFL, I agree that this is where the real battle seems set to go down. As you mentioned, the sides aren’t on the best terms, and let’s face it, the NFLPA has historically not been as strong as the union for MLB’s players – I could see the NFL pushing hard to get the testing in place based upon how the substance weighs more in favor of NFL players, rather than those in baseball.

It sounds like minor league testing is on the way… To what level do you think there is HGH use in sports?

Carroll: Ignore "commercially viable." Don Catlin is working on something and just like Fehr said, it has to be something thats valid. I think a lot of WADA on an integrity basis, even when I don't agree with their methods or focus sometimes, so while I agree with what Fehr said on one level, I don't think WADA is trying to make money here. They ARE pushing their agenda and they're very, very good at that. I actually think Fehr might have been looking more at the ballyhooed Ceres test last year, which I've heard nothing about since.

HGH use? Almost none. I only say almost because there's always someone so far behind the curve. Schaefer got nailed for it, but that was a very unique case in a lot of ways. We saw with Signature that there's been use in baseball inside the last five years, but it was all big name guys coming off injuries. Minor league players are worried more about meal money than they are spending thousands of dollars on a drug. That's why we see minor leaguers getting busted for the cheap stuff they can get in Tijuana.

Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?