how do you dispute information on your credit report where can i get annual free credit report credit reporting laws after bankruptcy free credit report online without credit card canada release state tax lien credit report how can i challenge something on my credit report unlimited 3 bureau reports free credit is free annual credit report legitimate one off credit report check how to cancel credit report membership how to see my credit report credit bureau reporting requirements cheapest away to get your credit report credit report all three bureau big three free credit report free credit reports and scores for all three free letters credit reporting agencies experian free credit report form consumer get credit rating report india how to understand transunion credit report need a free credit report free personal credit report transunion what was the first free credit report commercial do cell phone companies report credit agencies request copy of credit report free annual credit report service phone number equifax 3 1 credit report coupon buy credit report and score one time request credit report transunion mail free credit reports 3 times year how do i get my credit reports for free how to dispute an item on your credit report credit bureau reports singapore important how can i get free credit report without a credit card us gov free credit report annual sample credit reports experian credit report does sears pull privacy under fair credit reporting act financial privacy an international comparison of credit reporting systems monitoring credit report san luis obispo transunion personal credit report dispute online credit reports free credit report cancel number how to remove satisfied judgement from credit report should i dispute items on credit report how long to judgements stay on credit report get credit report free australia how do red get a free copy of your credit report consumer credit reporting company should use correct credit report errors experian how to read a credit report statement credit card companies report all three credit bureaus credit report experian phone number credit report consumerist free company credit reports uk 3 credit report phone numbers long do bad scores stay your credit report navy federal credit union 2010 annual report stolen identity credit report free credit report band completely free credit report canadian business credit reports customers when is chapter 7 bankruptcy removed from credit report credco credit report how to read check your credit report freeware no credit card 100 free credit report no credit card needed get my credit report gov 1) which of the following is true about credit reports transunion commercial credit report free credit report guy eric violette how to obtain my business credit report credit reports transunion 3 free credit report year dispute my credit report trans union free credit report in maryland transunion order credit report by mail how to get my free report in canada credit rating all 3 credit reports monthly see my credit report score free how to remove a late payment from my credit report free credit reports scores online free credit report gove credit score best place to get free credit reports removing negative items off credit report annual credit report site legit how to dispute personal information on credit report what are the three free credit reports global wealth report credit suisse 2011 pdf mni credit report customer service number how to check credit report for free how to check business credit report correcting credit reports free credit report without credit cards experian free report uk credit rating difference between fico credit report navy federal credit union report lost card can access your credit report about credit reports sample letter challenge credit report top credit report collection agency credit reporting rules chase credit card lost card reporting unlock my transunion credit report free credit report equifax denied credit free experian credit report daily credit report monitoring how does debt settlement affect my credit report credit report totally free free credit report dot com commercials how do you read an equifax credit report experian annual credit report free need pull credit report tenant clearing credit report after bankruptcy transunion credit reports canada consumer protection agency free credit report transunion credit report access insurance company does not use credit report fcra definition credit reporting agency long does timeshare foreclosure stay credit report obtain your credit report freeware how does one get your free government credit report free annual credit report massachusetts residents instant credit report online chapter 7 bankruptcy removed from credit report yearly credit report free gov 2008 credit reporting resource guide state ca free credit report credit report remove closed account dismissed chapter 13 bankruptcy credit report credit report rules and regulations charged off accounts on credit report how to get free credit report from transunion fair credit reporting act fair credit billing act fair debt collection practices act bank america credit report lawsuit consumer credit reporting act ontario how do you get your credit report for free annually how do i get a copy of my credit report in canada transunion experian credit report login report number there credit report actually free how to contact the three credit reporting agencies remove collections my credit report dun & bradstreet credit reports can i pay for a credit report what if i dispute everything on my credit report removing paid debt from credit report find my credit reports free annual credit report clark howard what does charge off mean in my credit report long collections stay credit report free credit report government once year transunion business credit report credit report monthly my one time year free credit report how to get a free credit report if denied credit free disputing credit report online free credit report song lyrics bike remove paid public record credit report can you remove charge offs your credit report authorization to run credit report inquiries credit report bad which credit reporting agency does pnc bank use remedies violations fair credit reporting act federal how long does paid collection stay on credit report free credit report authorized federal government how often should i check my credit report canadian company credit reports what happens when you dispute a credit report reports for credit credit information report (cir) how long does it take for your credit report to clear how to delete hard inquiries on credit report what is a charge off on credit reports run a credit report on someone else corporate credit reports fcac understanding your credit report and credit score how to free credit reports online experian does reporting credit card lost affect your credit free credit report if you have been denied credit fcra free credit reports without credit card required happened free credit score report band ftc credit reports gov what is included in your report equifax rating credit get credit report online now request your free should i dispute closed accounts on my credit report capital one reporting to credit bureaus phone number all credit report transunion fast does credit report update free report gov canada personal solutions credit 1 dollar credit report free credit report with credit score how to write a request for free annual credit report state ga free credit report when are negative items removed from your credit report free credit report consumer reviews bank america free credit report credit suisse annual report free annual credit report credit bureau obtaining credit report for free truly free credit report and scores remove authorized user account on credit report dispute my credit report online experian remove collections credit report free free credit card expense report form how to order free credit report canada can i dispute a bankruptcy on my credit report equifax denied credit report freeware good free credit report sites old free credit report band name equifax free credit report fico score trial credit scores reported see what is on my credit report correct error experian credit report florida credit report laws secured credit card reporting all three bureaus annual free credit report government website how to clear a judgment on your credit report credit report and criminal background check write dispute letter credit report my free credit report annual fair credit reporting act background check form official free annual report fcra credit history free credit report actress which credit report is free once a year free credit report legitimate bally total fitness credit report personal information your credit report how to correct error on credit report how to remove paid tax lien from credit report how do i fix an error on my credit report correcting info on credit reports personal credit reporting agencies how to cancel the free credit report membership length of time bankruptcy stays on credit report need free credit report without using credit card federal credit reporting agency cbc innovis credit reporting agencies free credit report band salary credit rating report format does bank of america secured credit card report to credit bureaus disputing a credit report claim credit bureau free credit report south africa credit report 3 scores free how to fix credit report after bankruptcy free credit report.com lyrics all 6 what is on a credit report free credit report california law obtain 3 free credit reports national credit report am i entitled to one free credit report per year e loan credit report get all three credit reports and scores experian credit score credit report experian long does take clear credit report do you get a free credit report every year annual credit report contact us get paid debt off credit report what is the range for credit scores on a credit report how to obtain free annual credit report go how doo i know if i have a security freeze on my credit report transunion credit report request canada how do i report credit card companies federal government free credit reports free chase credit report do credit unions report to chexsystems suze orman credit report kit cancel true credit report com get free credit report texas credit report for employment sample pay off derogatory items credit report request for free credit report form old debt credit report canada experian credit report reference number report my chase credit card stolen free credit report commercial predictions lyrics how do you correct an error on your credit report my credit report for free fair credit reporting act collection agency fcra how to order free credit reports online yearly credit report for free veda advantage credit reporting bureau how to get credit report free in canada dispute credit reporting information how do i get my credit report online for free summary rights under fair credit reporting act where can i get a copy of all 3 credit reports reporting bad tenants to credit bureaus free credit score report uk all the free credit report songs experian 1 dollar credit report 3in1 credit report with scores best site for free credit report how to obtain free credit report and score does collection charge off mean credit report instant free credit report no credit card secured credit cards reports all 3 credit bureaus change employer name credit report wells fargo report lost credit card free credit report and score from all 2 bureaus consumer credit report assistance experian free annual credit report no membership real free credit report government free credit report-no credit cards required myfico fico credit scores get free credit report online how long do derogatory accounts stay on your credit report what is the least often you should check your credit report report bad credit card company credit report score one time only credit reporting bureau addresses free credit report commercials planet x transunion credit report lock how do i remove a freeze on my credit report credit report form free credit report fix chapter 7 bankruptcy removed credit report does checking your credit report lower my score reporting errors your credit report experian mailing address for credit reports clean up your credit report quickly annual credit report federal law commission true credit report customer service online fair credit reporting act consumer disclosure general authorization how to order all 3 credit reports first free credit report commercial remove kd my credit report charge off removed my credit report change my address credit reporting agencies dispute transunion credit report by phone credit reports from all three agencies credit report examples experian how does one get a copy of your free credit report understanding kroll factual data credit report what is the most common credit reporting agency union trans credit report view your free credit report experian credit card company reports irs long free trial free credit report ordering credit report free poor credit report score annual free business credit report how to get a copy of your credit report from cibil does annual credit report include score freeze my credit report fair credit reporting act background checks free credit report letter example free annual credit reports when does amex update credit report free annual credit reports and scores equifax free credit report canada phone number free credit report iif denied credit equifax credit report cost best credit score report company free financial report if have been denied credit the best credit report credit report dispute contact numbers can i get a credit report if i have no credit fair credit reporting act signed into law free credit report.com commercials in order adding consumer statement your credit report free credit report sites reviews unlimited credit reports fico scores company credit check reports reading your credit report equifax credit reporting agencies addresses dispute how doo i get my free credit report from transunion update my address my credit report tips on disputing your credit report equifax credit report promotion code 2011 how to fix negative information on credit report how to lock credit report free clean credit report services inc free credit report scores all three best credit report sites free my free credit report usa what information can cancel free credit report online cards reporting credit score how to write a letter to clear credit report credit report gov free checking your credit report free experian report federal gov free annual credit credit report rules 7 year rule annual credit report free usa project report on credit management in banks what ever happened to the free credit report band obtain credit report and scores free free personal credit rating report free credit report georgia clark howard delete inquiries your credit report experian credit report contact 16 does checking your own credit report affect your credit score how to get a credit report from bank of america credit reporting bureaus wikipedia annual credit report transunion login information violations fair credit reporting act free credit score & free credit reports. no credit card needed errors on credit report how long does it take for credit report to clear up bad credit report sample consumer reports credit repair services call credit online report company has most accurate credit report what is a public record on credit report global sovereign credit risk report equifax canada credit report free form canada get your transunion credit report free royal bank credit report fdc inquiry on my credit report how to free report credit score data online free credit score no credit report get free credit report without trial how do i cancel free credit report membership how to remove information from your credit report credit reports gov free all credit report authorized credit report obtain how to cancel free credit report.com membership three credit bureaus report free instant credit report online credit score vs credit report how to pull a soft credit report reporting bad debt to the credit bureau auto insurance rates credit report ordering free credit report mail report credit card do payday loans appear on credit report all three credit score reports remove credit inquiries credit report often could get free credit report canada credit report checks canada free credit report all bureaus equifax the fair credit reporting act free credit report free credit check report gov annual credit report 3 agencies tenant credit and background check reports free canadian credit score report sarma credit report free annual credit report and scores does bank of america secured credit card report to credit bureau fair credit reporting agency phone number credit report credit score canada how to get free copies of credit reports how to remove a default from credit report free annual credit report experian ce credit report phone number when does negative information fall off your credit report fre credit report ordering a credit report online denied credit free credit report online 3 1 score credit report credit reporting agencies in usa remove capital one charge off credit report credit agricole group annual report 2010 free credit report you entitled under federal law where to get all 3 credit reports and scores best credit report equifax experian transunion how can i get all 3 credit reports for free can you get mortgage charge off your credit report three one credit report equifax how to place an alert on your credit report 3 credit reports gov free credit report uk no sign up free credit report song lyrics golf how to get free credit report online csc credit report dallas tx quizzles credit report loan irs tax lien release credit report can request credit report deceased spouse denied debt free credit report transunion business credit reports experian report lost chase visa credit card free credit report transunion free annual agencies much does equifax credit report cost dispute credit report all 3 bureaus credit union trends report 2012 what is the federal fair credit reporting act copy your credit report freeware what does it mean when a account is charged off on credit report certified credit report fcra cdia equifax credit report guide where to get a copy of my credit report for free get your credit report free government is there a free credit report without credit card information free credit report no credit card information needed once year free credit report information correct errors on credit report how long does a derogatory stay on your credit report clark howard annual credit report find out your credit report free free credit report song 2011 credit report address information what is the meaning of charged off on credit report best way to remove negative items from my credit report reliable free credit report sites how to unfreeze my experian credit report what are inquiries on your credit report three nationwide consumer credit reporting companies free credit report no credit card necessary experian commercial delphi credit report how long do collections stay on your credit report request a credit report form does checking you credit report lower your score
Home Pete Toms LWIB: Ticketing Gets Creative in MLB, Portland Beavers Update, MiLB Might Face Tough Year, Plus Tidbits

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1415 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: Ticketing Gets Creative in MLB, Portland Beavers Update, MiLB Might Face Tough Year, Plus Tidbits PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 26
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 22 February 2010 06:50

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in “Last Week in BizBall”, the Cubs pre-sale of tickets at 20% over face value brings attention to the shifting sands of “ticketing”, an update on the future of the Portland Beavers franchise, difficult times ahead for MiLB owners?, and tidbits.

“TICKETING” UPDATE

LWIB saw much reporting and controversy surrounding the Chicago Cubs pre-sale of tickets at 20% over face value. In August 07, MLB and ticket resale leader StubHub announced they had entered into a 5 year revenue sharing partnership. At the time, many sports business pundits believed that the formal entry of the “big 4“ into the “secondary ticketing” market would bring vast amounts of new revenue to professional sports. More recently, some question if “secondary ticketing” has been the boom to professional sports that many foresaw and if the “big 4” should be in the “secondary market” at all. The last few years have also seen the introduction of sophisticated “ticketing” systems. This new technology is revolutionizing “ticketing”, allowing clubs to introducing the “variable pricing” model long used by the airline industry. MLB revenues have never been more diversified and ticket sales no longer account for a majority of industry revenues. However, MLB remains at its core a “butts in the seats” business, as ticket sales continue to be the single biggest source of revenue in the industry. How franchises adapt to the rapidly changing world of “ticketing” bears watching.

LWIB the Cubs staged their first MasterCard First Chance Presale. From February 15-18 tickets were available via the Cubs at 20% over their face value. (15% if purchased via MasterCard)  Pre-sales of tickets amongst MLB clubs is not new or unique. Many clubs, to varying degrees, offer pre-sales to existing customers (e.g. full and partial season ticket holders) Ken Belson pointed out in the New York Times that, “…the Cubs’ presale stands out because there are no preconditions to participate — just a willingness to pay more.” Mr. Belson also described the conditions that allowed the Cubs to implement such a pre-sale.

In Boston and Chicago in particular, where the Red Sox and the Cubs are intensely popular, the ballparks are famously small and the high proportion of season-ticket holders has reduced the number of individual-game tickets available, fans feel the pressure to immediately get online and buy seats before it is too late.

AND

…..the waiting list to get a season ticket at Wrigley Field has 110,000 people on it.

Media reaction to the Cubs pre-sale was mixed. Tim Joyce was offended by the Cubs new practice and expressed his disdain at RealClearSports:

Yes, the Cubs are now in the business of officially scalping their own tickets. Their cynical and contemptible new policy gives their fans a chance to purchase advance sale tickets for regular season games this week for a limited time, but with a 20% Scalping Tax added on. And the owners of the most storied Chicago franchise haven't neglected their corporate duties - if one pays with a MasterCard, it's only a 15% fee.

Don Walker wrote for the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, “Depending on your point of view, what the Chicago Cubs are doing today is either a naked money grab or marketing genius.” Mark Brown wrote for the Chicago Sun-Times, “This is the conundrum in which the Cubs always find themselves: Their tickets are worth more than they can get away with charging for them from a public relations standpoint, a fact proved out by the prices those tickets fetch on the secondary market.”

The Cubs pre-sale also illustrates the entanglements amongst franchises and ticket resellers/brokers in contemporary professional sports. While MLB, via their official “secondary ticketing” partnership with StubHub is active in this marketplace, the Cubs staged the pre-sale in part to insulate themselves from the secondary market. Along with the pre-sale the Cubs have increased the number of “platinum” games on the Wrigley schedule, again in part due to the secondary market. Petrina Crockford reported for TicketNews.com:

The team increased the number of platinum games for the 2010 season, from 14 to 26.

The Cubs also attribute the increase in ticket prices to the secondary market. Cubs president Crane Kenney told the Chicago Tribune that 25 percent of platinum tickets ended up on StubHub, which is also the official reseller of MLB.

Brian Borawski reacted to the Cubs pre-sale at The Hardball Times, “This is also an obvious attempt by the Cubs to chew into the resale ticket market. I know the ticket resale business was huge a couple of years ago and while I’m sure it’s regional, I know they’re still around. Teams have made attempts to get in on the game with varying results and this is just one more stab.”

The Cubs reasoned that their pre-sale would be popular with fans indifferent over whether they paid a premium on the “secondary market” or directly to the team to ensure their attendance at games they had a strong interest in. While no numbers were released, Cubs CMO Wally Hayward was quoted after the first two days of the pre-sale, "From what we saw yesterday and today, we received tremendous support from the fans, We've had a lot of positive response to this."

Not surprisingly, the pre-sale also brought attention to the long time controversy surrounding whether or not the Cubs have been scalping their own tickets for many years. From the aforementioned Mark Brown column:

At least this 20 percent premium fee for the pre-sale is right out in the open, unlike Wrigley Field Premium Ticket Services, the ticket broker surreptitiously created by former Cubs owners Tribune Co. to enable the team to scalp its own tickets. Because the ticket broker service was owned by Tribune, the team was successfully able to argue that it was separate from the team and therefore legal.

It might interest you to know that this "separate" company was part of the sale of the team to the Ricketts family and that the Cubs will continue to sell tickets to Wrigley Field Premium Ticket Services for resale to the public.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE MORE ON TICKETING, AN UPDATE ON THE POSSIBLE RELOCATION OF THE TRIPLE-A PORTLAND BEAVERS. WHETHER MINOR LEAGUE BASEBALL COULD HAVE A TOUGH YEAR, AND OTHER TIDBITS

While the Cubs strive to see fewer of their tickets sold via the “secondary market”, last season saw reports that the Yankees were doing the opposite. There was speculation that in order to move ticket inventory that had been over priced using a pre recession model, the Yankees turned to the “secondary market”. Last season Alfred Branch Jr. reported for TicketNews.com:

Less than a week after the team slashed prices for many of its premium tickets, hundreds of premium New York Yankees tickets are turning up on StubHub, and speculation is rising that the team or intermediaries may have posted them.

While there is no direct proof that the team is involved – as a policy, StubHub does not disclose seller information – large quantities of premium seats are not turning up on other broker Web sites or exchanges, only on StubHub, which gives the impression that the tickets are not coming from multiple sources.

Many of the Suite seats tickets began turning up on StubHub after the team cut prices for them last week, and began offered extra tickets to previous purchasers and season ticket holders.

Is the “secondary market” the friend or foe of MLB clubs? The answer is likely neither but certainly the hype around “secondary ticketing” has abated. At the end of 07, CNNMoney.com reporter Chris Isidore named StubHub his Sports Business of the Year, “….nothing has been more significant, or will have as long-lasting effect, as the rise of the market for ticket reselling.” Mr. Isidore was far from the only sports business pundit at that time predicting newfound riches for professional sports from “secondary ticketing”. Less than two years later, some sports business reporters are arguing that “secondary ticketing” has been a disappointment to the industry. While there is obvious profit in reselling tickets to high demand games, “secondary ticketing” has also resulted in a glut of ridiculously cheap tickets. In July of last year, Tom Van Riper reported for Forbes:

The resale market for sports tickets has gone the way of the real estate boom--a bonanza driven by ever-increasing prices that came crashing down when the bubble proved unsustainable.

AND

But these days, online prices are dropping along with demand, with many games going for far below face value. At the same time, management's double-dipping into the ticket till turns off some fans who believe teams were already squeezing every last dollar out them. Never mind that StubHub prices move with demand, whether or not the team gets a cut of the sale, perception often trumps reality. And the revenue that clubs are realizing from the practice isn't living up to expectations, some say.

In May of last year, Eric Fisher reported for the SportsBusiness Journal that the ticket resale market has changed dramatically from its origins when it catered to a high-end clientele. Last season saw an overabundance of MLB tickets on the “secondary market” resulting from a flood of individual resellers into the marketplace, spurred in part by the recession.

“There is so much inventory out on the markets right now, particularly for baseball,” said Mike Janes, co-founder and chief executive of FanSnap, a Bay Area-based startup that acts as a metasearch engine for secondary tickets. More than 15 million tickets are accessible through the site, and the majority of those tickets are for sporting events. “I joke now that you’re going to pay more for your beer or your parking to go to a game than your actual ticket. Heck, you could pay more for your large mocha latte. But we’re living in a very, very different world now.

“There was a general thought for a long time in this business that ticket resale was a supplier-driven business, but the supply-demand equation has totally swung the other way now,” Janes said.

“Secondary ticketing” is not the only major change of recent years in “ticketing“. Clubs are adopting “variable pricing” (aka “dynamic pricing”) models. In the “variable pricing” model, ticket prices for the same seat are continually adjusted according to a broad range of factors including (but not limited to) day of the week, weather forecast, opponent, starting pitcher(s), standings, in stadium promotions, etc. Many have pointed out that this strategy is not new, the airline industry has practiced it for many years. However, the introduction of sophisticated ticketing software developed by companies like Qcue and Stratbridge has recently allowed MLB franchises to implement the same approach.

Darren Rovell of CNBC was likely the first sports business pundit to predict the use of “variable pricing” by professional sports franchises. In December 08, Mr. Rovell reported on the Giants decision to use Qcue’s software to manage some of their ticket inventory for the 09 season.

The SF Giants are going to do very well with this program and I think, in the end, will find out that they're going to make more money through airline pricing than static pricing. At this point, many clubs wrongly see this as a risk and that's why it's going to take some time. But in two years, I'm thinking a third of the baseball teams will be doing this with thousands of their seats.

In October, Don Muret reported for the SportsBusiness Journal that the Giants were very satisfied with the results of their limited use of Qcue’s “dynamic pricing” software during the 09 season.

The San Francisco Giants’ dynamic pricing program at AT&T Park proved to be such a success in 2009, the club says, that it is exploring the possibility of expanding the system to the entire ballpark for 2010.

The Giants say they generated $500,000 in incremental ticket revenue after signing a one-year contract with software company Qcue that enables the club to change single-game prices at any time.

The team sold 25,000 single-game tickets for seats in the outfield bleachers and upper deck, in the stadium’s least desirable locations. The Giants wouldn’t reveal a total revenue figure for the seats or how it compared with previous seasons.

Darren Rovell’s aforementioned prediction appears prescient in light of the SportsBusiness Journal’s recent prediction to, “Look for more teams to start testing dynamic pricing to sell tickets in least demand.”

The recent changes in “primary ticketing” (premium games, variable pricing) have met with some media backlash. Earlier this month, Joe Eskenazi of SF Weekly described the Giants “dynamic pricing” as “downright evil”.

….it just seems downright wrong that you should be made to pay more for a baseball game because it's a "great day for baseball." It seems exploitative that you should be made to cough up extra dollars when Tim Lincecum is on the mound: will we be given a deep discount when Zito is pitching or Pablo Sandoval takes a day off? Further following the airline model, will we be charged extra for using the restroom? Do clean seats cost more? Do I have to pay extra to stay out of the all-felon, all-drunk, all-jerks talking loudly about work on their iPhone section?

Mr. Eskenazi’s disdain for “dynamic pricing” comes on the heels of the complaints last month from Kevin Cowherd of The Baltimore Sun regarding the Orioles announcement to charge more for 19 “premium games” (Opening Day plus all Yankees and Red Sox visits) as well as tacking on an additional charge to tickets purchased on game day. Mr. Cowherd reported that, according to the Orioles, 10 other teams charged a premium for game day tickets last season. Sports economist Dennis Coates responded to Mr. Cowherd’s column and wonders if the MLB franchises charging a premium on game day purchasers are ill advised.

…Early purchasers of airline tickets get lower prices than last minute purchasers. The airline bears risks of flying with empty seats, and the higher last minute prices capture the opportunity costs of selling the seats earlier, for example. Of course, virtually no one has to suddenly and unexpectedly rush to a ball game, so holding seats open for these last minute purchasers cannot justify the higher prices for game day purchases.

It isn't clear to me how it is a reward to advance ticket buyers to know that day of game ticket buyers paid a higher ticket price. It is even less clear to me that a "reward" to the buyers least likely to alter their purchasing behavior is a profit-maximizing business move. In other words, it seems to me the Orioles have their pricing with respect to day of game tickets versus advance tickets exactly backwards.

Variable pricing is here to stay if it fulfills its promise of allowing clubs to sell more of their least desirable ticket inventory. As for the philosophical debate over whether it is positive for baseball fans, not all are in agreement with Mr.‘s Eskenazi and Cowherd that the fans are being “played” by the franchises. Aside from the premiums being charged by some clubs on “game day” purchases, some argue that “variable pricing” of MLB tickets is a positive development. Stanford economist Roger Noll remarked to the Biz of Baseball in an interview published November of last year, “Economists have always wondered why pro sports teams do not engage in more price variability than they do. It makes sense economically to have the sticker price be the price that is appropriate for the weekend, and to offer discounts for week days, especially if the opposition is weak.”

J.C. Bradbury reacted to Mr. Eskenazi’s criticisms of “dynamic pricing” at his Sabernomics blog. Mr. Bradbury argues that the introduction of “dynamic pricing” to MLB is a positive for baseball fans.

….The blessing of charging different prices for a product is that it allows more units to be sold at a lower price. In a world were a seller chooses only one price for a product, it must be the one where it maximizes the gains from selling a few units at a high price and selling many units at a low price. Where that price occurs it’s going to result in some people paying prices less than they value the product and some having to pay more than they value the product. The former group will continue to purchase the product, but the latter group is priced out of the market—this is very bad.

AND

But with price discrimination, those marginal fans have the opportunity to go to games when other fans value them less…Fluctuating prices don’t just mean higher prices, they result in lower prices as well. The team now has the freedom to charge lower prices without losing revenue from all the fans willing to pay higher prices when games are in high demand.

If dynamic pricing goes away, so do the cheap seats. If you have to choose one price to maximize profits, it’s going to be one that prevents a lot of fans from going to the games, and that is a bigger tragedy in my mind.

Selling tickets at Wrigley Field and Fenway Park is a much different proposition than selling tickets at Progressive Field and Rogers Centre. For some clubs the concern that the “secondary market” cannibalizes their “primary market” market is a legitimate concern. For other clubs, the challenge is pricing tickets on their “primary market” closer to what the “secondary market” commands. With “variable pricing” in MLB in its infancy, it is too early to know if selling baseball tickets is analogous to selling seats on an airplane. “Ticketing” will be an interesting and important area to both fans and franchises in the present and near future.

PORTLAND BEAVERS UPDATE

Last month, Last Week in BizBall reported on the real possibility that the Portland Beavers franchise will relocate subsequent to this season. LWIB, Josh Leventhal reported for Baseball America:

Triple-A Portland is exploring the possibility of temporarily relocating to Tucson, Ariz., for the start of the 2011 season if it cannot complete construction on a new local ballpark in time for Opening Day, a pair of newspapers recently reported.

The Arizona Star reported that Portland owner Merritt Paulson has been exploring the Tucson market, which hosts a pair of ballparks suitable for Triple-A baseball. Meanwhile, Portland general manager Chris Metz confirmed to the Oregonian that the team has been looking at other markets, but he would not elaborate as to where.

Houston suburb Sugar Land has also been rumoured as a possible future home to the Portland franchise. LWIB, BallparkDigest.com reported that negotiations are moving ahead on the construction of a new ballpark in Sugar Land. But the possibility of the Portland franchise relocating to Sugar Land is suspect because, “…the front office of the Houston Astros has been adamant in its opposition to any affiliated team entering the market.”

DIFFICULT TIMES AHEAD FOR MiLB OWNERS?

MiLB attendance declined approximately 3% last year. By comparison, MLB attendance declined approximately 6.5% last year. Both were very satisfied with the results given the economic recession. Nonetheless this off season has brought reports that some minor league owners are experiencing difficulties not seen in the recent past. LWIB, Will Lingo the Editor in Chief of Baseball America reported on the January annual shareholders meeting of Rochester Community Baseball (aka the owners of the Triple A Rochester Red Wings).

…this year the Red Wings lost money for the first time since moving into Frontier Field in 1997. According to the Democrat and Chronicle, the Wings lost $24,349 last season—driven primarily by investment losses —and while that's a small loss, it shows the tight times minor league teams are facing, even the successful ones.

Shareholders, while approving the issues put before them like officers and bylaws, had the most questions about Rochester's ownership of the Batavia franchise in the New York-Penn League. The Red Wings saved the franchise from ruin by taking it over before the 2008 season and assuming its debts, and the Muckdogs operation has lost a total of $396,920 since Rochester took it over.

The Red Wings hope to recoup their investment by eventually selling the franchise, but some were skeptical that they'll find a buyer in these economic times.

Mr. Lingo’s report was reminiscent of a year end prediction made by BallparkDigest.com.

It will continue to be a buyers' market in the minors. It is a good time to have money, as there are some deals to be made if you're looking to buy a baseball team. Former MiLB President Mike Moore repeatedly warned owners about the escalating valuation of ballclubs, and it looks like he was right: Many teams were overvaluated the last five years, and unfortunately a lot of folks bought into the market at its high point. We continue to hear about affiliated teams on the market for some pretty decent and fair prices. Valuations are even more depressed in the indy ranks. We don't expect this trend to wane in the coming year.

TIDBITS

  • Mike Ozanian of Forbes is very critical of the pending sale of the Rangers from Hicks Sports Group to a consortium led by Chuck Greenberg.  “This deal stinks. It is rotten to the core. And it sets a bad precedent…..It will be a sick joke if 75% of MLB's owners sign on to this deal, as is required for league approval.
  • MLB continues to grow its RBI (Reviving Baseball in Inner Cities) program. This weekend saw MLB’s Urban Youth Academy in Compton host a tournament for 2 HBCU’s and 2 Division I schools. (details here)  A second Urban Youth Academy is set to open in Houston to be followed by a third in Hialeah, Florida. LWIB, Don Walker reported for the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel that MLB executive vice president of baseball operations Jimmie Lee Solomon recently visited Milwaukee and discussed with local business people the possibility of an Urban Youth Academy in that community. In the 09 amateur draft, 21 athletes who either played or trained at the Major League Baseball Urban Youth Academy were selected.
  • Diane M. Grassi is very critical of MLB and the MLBPA for not taking measures to improve the working conditions of Costa Ricans who manufacture (by hand) 2.2 million baseballs annually. “As America’s National Pastime has continued to rake in record high revenues over the past several years – in the billions of dollars each season – MLB continues to remain deaf to its critics concerning the manufacture of its Official Baseball, apparel and other accessories, with regard to unfair labor practices in the Third World.”
  • Sarah Talalay blogged about the Marlins’ FanFest for the South Florida Sun Sentinel. Ms. Talalay quotes Marlins President David Samson on the prospects of the Marlins hosting an All Star Game in their currently under construction new stadium. “It has not been confirmed, but if you thought to yourself we would host the All-Star Game in 2015, you would probably not be misleading yourself,”


Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?