visa credit card insurance on purchases credit building credit cards with no deposit chase credit card rewards center bpi credit card cash advance pin easy credit card to get approved for 2012 best buy credit card customer service ics international credit card services visa credit card application for bad credit guarantor loans online uk which credit card is best for international travel personal loans ireland bad credit hsbc uk lost credit cards hsbc debit visa card issue number balance transfer offers halifax existing customers credit card holder leather best 0 interest balance transfer credit cards credit card debt settlement australia prepaid credit cards with overdraft best uk credit card for airmiles chase bank pre approved credit card icici credit card insurance benefits i want a credit card that has no limit get online loan how to reduce your credit card debt yourself credit card low interest balance transfer chase international travel credit card sears canada credit card contact number unsecured credit cards for bad credit canada average credit card merchant fees what does a black credit card mean compare and contrast the good and bad characteristics of credit cards credit cards with no interest and no balance transfer fees pay shell gas credit cards online virgin credit card uk login anz credit card travel insurance claim national cash advance head office debit visa card canada citibank international credit card india prepaid credit cards no activation fee cash reward credit card comparison military credit card rate reduction united cash loans login page anonymous prepaid credit card australia how to get the best merchant credit card rates online cash loans for bad credit direct payday lenders bad credit ok whats a good first credit card walmart credit cards online application citibank platinum credit card features speedy cash payday loans reviews credit card instant approval india business credit card balance transfer 0 pay as you go credit card processing buy visa gift card online instant apply for gold credit card fnb westpac low rate credit card interest rate how to download free apps for ipad 2 without credit card pay target visa credit card online how do i pay my firestone credit card online get a payday loan online instant payday lenders no brokers compare canadian credit cards cash back who has the best credit card rate home depot credit card promotions hdfc credit card helpline no gurgaon visa debit cards wikipedia how does a cibc visa debit card work online standard chartered credit card payment india sbi online credit card rewards hsbc corporate credit card malaysia using us credit cards in canada bad credit credit cards no annual fee credit card number location student credit cards with no credit instant approval what credit score do you need for a toys r us credit card no interest credit card transfer offers td rebate rewards visa card limit visa credit card with low interest rate can you buy prepaid credit cards at walmart in canada mbna canada credit card payments hsbc balance transfer credit card list of credit card company names is personal credit card interest tax deductible need for speed carbon reward cards ps3 prepaid credit card visa bank of america manchester united credit card review cibc visa cash back credit card what is purchase interest rate in credit card chase business credit card phone number wells fargo credit card services apply online credit card citibank post office credit card balance transfers southwest credit card offers two free flights using credit cards abroad compare sbi and icici credit card best credit card payment app not so good credit cards credit card search engine india horizon gold credit card complaints nationwide online loan quote get credit card information free best bad credit credit cards unsecured swarovski hello kitty credit card holder call chase freedom credit card customer service credit card for new business bad credit city bank credit card application malaysia how to sign up for amazon prime without credit card free prepaid credit cards canada free gnc gold card interest free credit card tesco canada best credit card points best online credit card processing 2012 business card credit analyst salary walmart credit card canada phone number best credit cards for travel perks bad credit loan lenders uk simmons first credit card application status business credit card offers balance transfer icici credit card helpline mumbai best payday loan lender uk chase credit card apr citibank credit card apply compare credit cards for bad credit best student credit cards with no credit nab credit cards travel insurance credit card for no credit score tips on how to get rid of credit card debt college student no credit credit card how can i pay icici credit card bill online apply online credit card icici bank payday loans for bad credit instant cash top ten credit cards 2013 lowest rate mobile credit card processing orchard credit card payments online 0 credit card offers balance transfers which is the best student credit card in canada best travel points credit card canada 2011 visa prepaid credit card online anz rewards platinum credit card travel insurance bank of america power rewards visa card virgin credit card mbna contact number what does a starbucks gold card do best cash back business credit cards 2013 air miles credit card comparison disney chase credit card rewards balance transfers explained major credit cards how do you calculate interest payments on a credit card example nandos black card td canada trust secured visa cards difference between visa and mastercard debit card capital one credit card review canada how do i check the status of my best buy credit card application hsbc premier credit card air miles army pcs pay advance credit card number and security code and expiration date payday loan lender list uk top bad credit loan companies best buy credit card customer service contact get credit card for bad credit rating how to pay bank of america credit card online with another bank account credit cards for new uk residents credit card ratings consumer reports td visa card account login delta miles credit card deals secured credit card 10000 limit bank of america sign up for credit card bank of america credit card login mastercard aadvantage credit card offer 2013 hsbc credit card promotions for hotels pay my bestbuy credit card hdfc credit cards rewards points redemption apply for mastercard credit card with bad credit secured credit cards for business wells fargo check chase freedom credit card application status secured credit card banks online loans in south africa no paperwork what does it mean to get pre approved for a credit card best cash back visa or mastercard low rate credit cards for life of balance transfer delta credit card cash back malaysia credit card review 2013 credit card fraud sentence in florida best credit card transfer rate nz aspire credit card company does applying for credit cards hurt my credit score view hdfc credit card statement online delta skymiles credit card good deal does walmart credit card help build credit accept credit cards with no credit check new bad credit card offers standard chartered credit card promotions singapore credit card terminal application how long can credit card companies sue you how to get past the halo reach credit limit bank of america virtual credit card debit apply for capital one credit card application chase credit card travel protection credit cards that offer cash back rewards credit card uk comparison credit card number and cvv validator download orange prepaid credit card paypal credit card verification code fake bankamericard cash rewards visa secured credit card how to get a bad credit mortgage fnb gold credit card interest rates gift visa card india vacation pay advance form 0 interest credit card balance transfer ireland chase credit card balance transfer calculator citibank indian oil credit card reward points redeem pay off credit card debt or save for college hsbc bank credit card customer care number how can i get a best buy credit card with no credit platinum card post office storing credit card information law uk bank of america prepaid debit visa card calculate credit card interest rate payment fast payday advance loans credit card cash advance atm limit best visa debit card for students find the best credit card for me canada reducing credit card debt online payday advance california cash advance america payday loan scams discover credit card review 2012 credit card comparisons nz hsbc credit card rate of interest best unsecured credit cards with bad credit secured visa credit cards alaska air miles credit card td emerald visa card application how to get a rbc visa debit card chase freedom credit card review 2011 can i get a credit card without a job and bad credit airline credit card with no annual fee credit card offers 0 balance transfer 12 months credit card for small business with no credit credit card application form pdf low rate credit card australia sbi credit card offers on samsung mobiles icici credit card payment using debit card best rate credit cards 2013 is it safe to apply for a chase credit card online alaska air miles credit card reviews how does credit card interest work malaysia best new credit card bonus offers chase credit cards online payment arco gas credit card fee does paypal accept virtual credit cards hdfc credit card toll free number chandigarh ikea usa credit card apply black visa card uk important things to know before getting a credit card streamline credit card machine rolls best credit card for first time users with no credit credit card company list halifax credit card minimum payment amount secured mastercard credit card canada store rewards cards in phone starbucks credit card processor 0 intro apr for 12 months credit cards credit card validator free download secured credit card canada compare virgin credit card balance transfer limit store photos of credit cards on iphone net pay advance wichita get a payday loan online direct lender how can we pay lic premium using credit cards valid credit card numbers that work 2012 where to send old navy credit card payments credit card holder with money clip can i buy a visa gift card with a walmart credit card pnc secured credit card login bank of america international travel credit card how to get a bad credit loan without a bank account can i get a credit increase on a capital one secured card store credit cards after bankruptcy what credit card can i get with a score of 620 disney chase credit card application status how to pay canada student loans legitimate poor credit loans how to receive pre approved credit card offers how to hack a credit card number visa 2011 prepaid reloadable credit cards walmart all credit cards into one public savings open sky secured visa credit card amazon bank of america credit card how old do you have to be to get a prepaid credit card in canada australia;s lowest rate credit card credit card low interest rate small cash loans uk file bankruptcy credit cards only credit card number and security code hack compare credit card rewards australia payday quick cash loans online payday lenders california average credit card apr 2012 chase freedom credit limit increase online iphone credit card case 4s hdfc credit card application status disapproved valid credit card numbers generator with cvv credit cards for bad credit 2013 uk citibank platinum credit cards capital 1 credit card ppi claims best credit cards with rewards consumer report whats the highest credit card limit sears credit card services address reclaim credit card protection insurance charges credit card calculator multiple interest rates navy federal credit union student credit cards best 0 balance transfer credit cards uk applying for credit cards with poor credit first modern credit card introduced 1950s capital one canada credit card agreement no fee td visa cards low limit credit cards for students credit limit definition wikipedia credit card debt settlement agreement best delta credit card deal merchant fees for credit cards comparison canada cibc debit visa cards first premier credit cards pay new york and company credit card online what is the best credit card to have with bad credit easiest way to get a credit card uk one hour cash advance lenders online lowest apr credit card rates 0 interest credit cards no balance transfer credit card prime rate definition continental chase mastercard credit card apply for ikea credit card uk standard chartered online credit card payment pay as you go credit cards canada free credit cards numbers that work 2011 suze orman best secured credit card best travel credit card deals 2011 mastercard credit cards for no credit history best credit card transfer balance no transfer fee car loan with bad credit random credit card number and cvv calculate credit card balance transfer calculator reloadable prepaid credit card with no fees online payday loan lender only best small business credit card 2012 canada low interest credit cards for average credit hdfc credit card apply online in bangalore prepaid credit card to help rebuild credit visa credit card application no credit transfer credit card balance to low interest loan compare visa credit cards australia apply for visa credit card with fair credit accepting credit cards over the phone with paypal bad credit loan lenders credit card address verification phone number pay dillards credit card account online sheer black cardigan women;s bank of america credit card application status phone number orchard bank unsecured credit card reviews platinum card american express limit virtual credit card paypal free jcb credit card number format no interest credit cards bad credit best money back credit cards 2011 cash advance online no credit check legit bad credit loan lenders american express prepaid credit card reviews credit card rewards canada dbs black card travel insurance dbs black card credit limit capital one best buy credit card customer service number compare air miles credit cards canada integrity advance payday loans no credit card business loans speedy cash payday loans online payday cash advance direct lenders only calculate credit card interest rate calculator credit card debt consolidation ontario canada best credit cards for students with no annual fee low interest easy approval credit cards citi corporate credit card payment best credit card reward scheme best buy credit card payments center international credit cards for students major credit cards companies starbucks credit card discount icici credit card application status using application number are orchard bank credit cards good how old do u have to be to get a credit card in the uk does arco gas station accept credit cards rbc visa prepaid credit card hdfc credit cards payment online top credit card issuers in malaysia wells fargo secured credit card business is capital one a good credit card after bankruptcy how does cash converters payday advance work list of bad credit loan lenders new fees for credit cards 2013 top 5 credit card processing companies 100 guaranteed credit card approval uk apply for discovery credit card how long does it take to get a secured credit card bank of america pre approved credit cards canada wells fargo secured credit card cash advance fee square credit card reviews data mining implementation for credit cards application processing system phone number for orchard bank credit cards small cash loans with bad credit how to get credit card numbers hacked black credit card visa limits top 10 college student credit cards nhs discounts black card best corporate credit card canada real usa credit card number compare travel credit cards 2013 capital one platinum credit card reviews merchant credit card fees visa sbi visa classic debit card take credit card payments on android disney rewards credit card phone number high interest credit cards for bad credit canada credit card number checker free download capital one small business credit card agreement tesco credit card protection apply for a mastercard credit card online american express prepaid credit card uk international credit card processing first credit card company in 1950 credit check companies virgin credit card payment what is the best credit card to use in america does kmart accept sears credit cards send money online using your credit card best secured credit card bad credit do prepaid credit cards help rebuild credit title loans online no credit check best low interest credit cards for students how to get credit card limit increase chase easy approval gas credit cards offers on visa cards india cvv number on visa debit card can you use us credit card in uk costco credit card processing rates for small business rbs visa credit card uk bad credit loans no credit check unsecured get credit card numbers download best credit card to get american airline miles sears credit card application status phone number how do i get a cash advance on my capital one credit card compare rewards credit cards orchard bank bad credit credit card low interest credit cards canada visa best secured visa credit cards emirates platinum card discounts credit card reward tricks td canada trust cash back credit card rbc credit card travel notification hsbc credit card application pinoyexchange valid stolen credit card numbers how to open up a locked door with a credit card unsecured credit card for bad credit instant approval best fixed rate credit cards 2011 capitec multi loan online application credit expert best credit card offers for new users lloyds tsb student credit card interest rate is there a starbucks credit card visa card number sample easy credit card approval australia credit card swipe app for windows phone best citibank credit card offer iphone credit card payment hdfc credit card deals on flights credit card debt after death california best credit card for no credit or bad credit how many types of credit cards are there orchard bank secured credit card phone number pentagon federal credit union credit cards apply for first premier credit card sbi credit card customer care number mumbai apply for a walmart credit card online instant cash loans in minutes microsoft excel credit card payment calculator industry average credit card processing fees prepaid credit card help build credit best cashback credit card comparison cash advance credit card chase icici bank international credit card using visa debit cards in india hotel reward credit cards comparison icici bank credit card settlement letter apply for a loan with bad credit and no bank account capital one visa platinum card speedy cash loans oldham allied cash advance westfield in credit cards compare uk british airways credit card offer uk titanium visa prepaid credit card virtual credit card number uk track barclay credit card application
Home Pete Toms LWIB: MLB's Anti-Trust Exemption and Franchise Relocation

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 589 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: MLB's Anti-Trust Exemption and Franchise Relocation PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 7
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 04 January 2010 00:40

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

2010 will probably be the pivotal year in determining whether the Oakland A’s relocate to San Jose. In March of last year, Commissioner Selig announced the formation of a three member committee which has been studying the options available to the A’s in their quest for a new baseball stadiium in northern California. The committee’s recommendations should be made public early this year. The latter part of 2009 saw an escalation in the rhetoric amongst the potentially affected parties in Oakland, San Francisco and San Jose over the fate of the A’s. In November LWIB reported on the stepped up media campaign of A’s owners John Fisher and Lewis Wolff to bring local attention to their courtship of San Jose. Grassroots groups either advocating for, or opposing, a move of the A’s to San Jose ramped up their campaigns as the year progressed (the Giants are the driving force behind one of the groups). Likewise, public officials in all three cities (and at the state level) raised their public profiles on the issue late in 2009 (amongst them, mayors Dellums (Oakland) and Reed (San Jose) plus SF City Attorney Dennis Herrera and CA Senator Barbara Boxer). As is always the case when franchise relocation in MLB is discussed, baseball’s antitrust exemption is an important part of the debate. Can the Giants prevent the A’s from moving into “their” territory (as defined by MLB)? Do the A’s need the “permission” of MLB to relocate? Does anybody know for certain?

LWIB Evan Weiner wrote for examiner.com:

To all those prognosticators, and you know who you are, who are trying to predict the top business sports stories of 2010, you have missed what is going to be the biggest fight. Oakland Athletics owner Lewis Wolff and the city of San Jose against the San Francisco Giants, the San Jose Giants, the city of San Francisco and Major League Baseball and the battle will center on the 1922 United States Supreme Court decision that gave the National League and the American League of baseball an antitrust exemption.

Wolff, whose lease with the Oakland Coliseum ends in 2013, would like to locate his baseball business in San Jose. Because of the 1922 Supreme Court decision that baseball was a game not a business, he has many hurdles to climb in his quest, hurdles that would not be there without the SCOTUS ruling.

AND

The stage is being set right now and a fierce territorial battle may shape the future of baseball and determine whether or not San Jose can become the home of Lewis Wolff’s baseball team. Wolff has to decide whether he really wants to fight this war and the implications may be felt far beyond the Bay Area.

AND

This could be a battle that extends to Congress but would the former San Francisco Mayor, Senator Diane Feinstein along with her colleague Barbara Boxer and the House Speaker, Nancy Pelosi of San Francisco want to get involved in the issue? Congress squawks about antitrust issues in sports but does nothing to correct inequities.

Last month, aforementioned SF City Attorney Dennis Herrera made public his threats to sue MLB should they allow the A’s to move to San Jose. The city of SF argues that the revenues they receive from the Giants would be threatened by the A’s move. The revenues received from the Giants are used to pay down debt on city issued bonds which financed infrastructure improvements around AT&T Park. Most pundits saw Mr. Herrera’s letter to MLB as nothing but sabre rattling given that MLB’s antitrust exemption allows them to control the location of “their” franchises. Last month, Nathaniel Grow wrote about Mr. Herrera’s threats at the Sports Law Blog. Mr. Grow points out that should the city of SF attempt to force MLB to enforce their territorial rights it would be a new twist on previous legal challenges.

On first impression, the threatened suit by the city of San Francisco seems problematic on several fronts. First, the city would have to convince a court that its interest in protecting its tax revenues from the Giants gives it sufficient standing to legally challenge MLB's approval of the relocation of another franchise into the Giants' assigned territory.

However, even if San Francisco is able to establish standing, such a suit would also place the city in the awkward position of effectively asking a court to enforce MLB's anticompetitive territory allocation system. While professional baseball's practice of granting franchises exclusive rights to certain geographic territories has previously been challenged by those seeking to enter a restricted market -- suits which have historically been dismissed pursuant to MLB's antitrust exemption (see, e.g., New Orleans Pelicans Baseball, Inc. v. National Association of Professional Baseball Leagues, Inc., Case No. 93-253, 1994 WL 631144 (E.D.La. March 1, 1994)) -- a suit by San Francisco would mark the first time that MLB has faced a lawsuit seeking to require the league to enforce this restriction. The optics of such a suit, being filed by a municipality no less, would be less than ideal. I suspect most courts would be uncomfortable issuing an order requiring baseball to enforce its territory restriction, especially in a case where MLB had already decided to set aside its long-standing anticompetitive policy.

Eighty seven years after the “federal baseball” decision by The Supreme Court created baseball’s antitrust exemption, do we know conclusively that it allows MLB to dictate franchise location? In November of last year, the aforementioned Nathaniel Grow published, Defining the 'Business of Baseball' - A Proposed Framework for Determining the Scope of Professional Baseball's Antitrust Exemption (read here in PDF).

No doubt due to the peculiarity of the exemption, as well as baseball’s standing as the “national pastime,” baseball’s antitrust exemption has generated substantial consideration over the years from both courts and commentators. Despite this voluminous analysis, no consensus has been reached regarding the extent to which baseball’s operations are protected under the antitrust exemption. The Supreme Court itself has never specifically addressed the scope of the baseball exemption, but instead has only generally held that the “business of baseball” is exempt from antitrust law. Based on this language, some lower courts have broadly interpreted the Supreme Court’s precedent as providing an exemption for the entire “business of baseball.” Meanwhile, other courts have concluded that the exemption is more limited, with some courts and commentators arguing that the exemption should be restricted solely to the facts of the Supreme Court’s most recent affirmance in Flood v. Kuhn.

Mr. Grow is not alone in his opinion that baseball’s ability to control franchise relocation as a result of it’s antitrust exemption is uncertain. Roger Noll, professor of economics emeritus at Stanford University told the Biz of Baseball in November, “The status of franchise location antitrust in MLB is uncertain – there has never been a case that was litigated to completion.” In his 2003 book, May the Best Team Win Baseball Economics and Public Policy, economist Andrew Zimbalist wrote that it is unclear if baseball’s antitrust exemption extends to control of franchise relocation. However, Mr. Zimbalist notes that MLB perhaps can control franchise relocation under a rule-of-reason defense. On Oakland Raiders owner Al Davis’s successful legal battle with the NFL over relocating his franchise to Los Angeles in the 1980’s Mr. Zimbalist wrote;

The courts did not rule that a sporting league could not exercise some controls over a team’s location; rather, they made it clear that such controls, when properly exercised , fall under a rule-of-reason defense. That is, there are good reasons why a league would want its teams to be both geographically stable and geographically dispersed. These reasons must be considered and offset against the negatives connected to prohibiting an owner from moving his or her team. The negatives include a reduction in an owner’s rights of free trade and the possible retention of a team in a city with less interest in the sport than a prospective host city.

AND

…..MLB’s presumed exemption may shield it from owner antitrust challenges and make it more difficult for teams to move. It should be noted, however, that where such moves are not in the public interest, team relocations could be prevented under a rule-of-reason defense even without an exemption.

2010 will tell us much, or all, about the eventual fate of the A’s franchise. Either San Jose or Oakland will make the most enticing offer to the A‘s owners. Should it be the former, the Giants will be “indemnified” for their territorial rights. But eventually, won’t somebody or some city challenge MLB over relocation and clarify exactly what the “exemption” really means?


Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

Follow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?