is brahmi available over the counter growing ginseng australia what is celebrex tablets propecia side effects postmenopausal women alesse dosage forms valtrex canada prescription phentermine side effects depression tamoxifen citrate pct dosage herbal extract suppliers in india proscar tablets in pakistan aqua ban water pills uk roxithromycin uk online names of non narcotic pain meds viagra in usa uroxatral no prescription compare prices flovent dose for cats online canadian pharmacy buy cheap zyvox where to purchase nizoral shampoo without a prescription danazol over the couter levitra 40 mg canada deltasone lowest price what is losartan potassium used for methotrexate side effects nausea anafranil direct pharmacy inderal without insurance purchase nizoral a d shampoo retin a cream reviews acne buy levitra professional pills cheap cialis sublingual india brazil viagra generic long term side effects of starlix micardis generic version buy kamagra gold online drug market order remeron canada and naprosyn buy atarax cheap allergy levlen contraceptive pill pregnancy has dilantin been discontinued city discount pharmacy toronto Purchase accutane 2 mg buy lotrisone online at canada pharmacy synthroid 75 mg price sinemet next day delivery diclofenac 100 review all types casodex pills what is anafranil effexor xr without a prescription generic sumycin safe 36 hr cialis best place buy ranitidine sertraline high effects ventolin and flo vent prescriptions order aciphex 6 canadian pharmacy cheap glycomet usa brand levitra tablets price buying ephedraxin using paypal erythromycin mims australia cheapest wellbutrin sr paypal omnicef dose for strep throat online pharmacy information drugs where to buy retin-a in mexico order live lobster canada nitroglycerin pharmacy furosemide 40 mg dose prednisolone to purchase without a prescription stromectol online pharmacy mail order generic diflucan clomid prevent miscarriage viagra requiere receta en mexico cheap clomiphene generic from levlen is robaxin better than vicodin fungsi bactroban salep champix forum prometrium online pay paypal tadacip uk online viagra cape town sale cheap atarax online low coreg high blood pressure heart failure esomeprazole magnesium trihydrate msds delivery cod cheap aldactone western drug advair diskus farmacia order online clomid on line mexico border cafergot buy amaryllis bulbs online paroxetine indian pharmacies quinine sulfate leg cramps lexapro wikipedia pl canadian alliance for community service learning website nitroglycerin online where can i purchase malegra fxt xenical orlistat 120 mg prix viagra portugal elimite buy usa buy inderal online australia where can i get diflucan online prices can you drink alcohol after zithromax cutting wellbutrin pills grifulvin v tablets 40mg buy pravachol 100mg online synthroid india companies only buy kamagra soft online pharmacy best over the counter aspirin order generic tetracycline accutane drugs are cipla drugs safe cialis online buying geriforte syrup from canada no prescription sumycin tablets purchase on line cheapest rumalaya forte buy over the counter benadryl online can you buy protonix in ireland side effects of atenolol 25mg code red 7 seconds erectile triamterene 20 mg healthy diet for male athlete buying betapace using paypal buy calcium carbonate in singapore citalopram coming off effects diamox prix en pharmacie en france biaxin dose for sinusitis actos spc where provera erectile defuntion medicine cost buy avapro australia free coupon for viagra plus side effects of buspar in women methotrexate mechanism of action in cancer accutane medication for acne buy cialis online us pharmacy buy adalat visa tegretol xr uses bystolic side effects ed medicamento tenormin 100 mg national pharmacy association ireland albendazole pills online in the mexico what is the correct dosage of lotrisone effects of mixing prednisone with alcohol long term side effects of acai generic purinethol switzerland buy endep paypal accepted cheap xanax online no rx atorlip-5 online pay paypal get abana toronto western drug detrol buy emsam perth australia acquisto valtrex sicuro online cardizem pct buy where do i buy alliance tabards legal buy blopress online canada can you only get keppra on prescription dilantin pediatric loading dose can you buy lisinopril drugs prescription do you need rx minocycline fluoxetine 20mg tab revatio generic canada generic benadryl inactive ingredients genuine online buy altace prednisone online with no prescription what is chloromycetin ointment side effects of cardura medication claritin online pay paypal pyridium pill shop discount code retin-a cream uk where can i get clomid for pct buy anafranil with visa doxycycline price comparison buy bupron sr 100mg online is generic cleocin gel available in usa sony xperia s sim free canada pharmacy university us online pharmacy no prescription propecia seroquel without a perscription where can i buy toprol xl buy acticin drugs best place buy real viagra online combivent overnight delivery can i buy doxycycline in india metformin pills sweat discount buy finpecia finasteride mestinon no prescription compare prices where to buy xenical in uk acheter du cialis en belgique buy doxycycline 100 mg where can i get fincar pills penegra over counter liv medication order does methotrexate weight gain skelaxin coupons what is cytotec tablet seroquel discontinued recommended prednisone dose for poison ivy abilify online pharmacy uk colchicine spain innopran xl for sale australia ordering augmentin mexico azithromycin long half life buy reminyl online india doxazosin medicinenet good reviews on low dose propranolol for anxiety cheap allinclusive holidays 2016 bentyl tablets dosage nexium 40 mg online buy forzest without rx generic duphalac cost shatavari online legally legal buy trileptal online canada cialis viagra online femara price usa cheapest flovent in the uk cialis professional side effects how to take nexium 20 mg costco zithromax medrol spain can lexapro 20 mg get you high where to buy misoprostol over the counter rimonabant withdrawal from market safe buy topamax online which uk site to buy amantadine can you buy emsam in ireland generic aciphex india comprar zyprexa pela internet female cialis over the counter drugs cipla pharmaceuticals ltd pune viagra seller in malaysia success stories on clomid 2012 proscar order online can you buy water pills at walmart brand pletal buy sinequan 50mg tablets side effects of seroflo 500 ordering silagra mexico sumycin over the counter usa quiero comprar acai sinequan tablets us online dog itching prednisone mexican pharmacy prednisone buy robaxin tablets online avandamet overnight pharmacy fosamax discount levitra professional usa tulasi discount how long does depakote er take to work levothyroxine side effects hair loss acheter viagra au quebec buying avodart online propranolol drugs forum albendazole 400 mg tablet medrol maximum dosage ordering hydrochlorothiazide on line alli diet plan caroline can u buy flagyl online atorlip-20 brands india calan online uk how do i know when to start taking clomid how do i buy cialis in canada 800 mg neurontin high ou acheter le clomid buy omeprazole canada maxalt generic date buy levitra professional without a prescription from canadian pharmacy buy kamagra online review brand levitra dosage instructions what are the side effects of taking propecia lisinopril tablets 10 mg com cheap precose sale uk what is better for fibromyalgia cymbalta or lyrica rsvp zyvox assistance program tetracycline generic brand how to buy coreg in london kamagra oral jelly review forum aristocort tablets without prescription over the counter olanzapine what prescription drug is used to treat gonorrhea where to buy viagra online cvs discount card prescriptions purchase abilify 3 mg glycomet over counter uk us online pharmacy no prescription orlistat can you order pyridium buying lopid from canada no prescription can you order actoplus met order kamagra 100mg motrin 1b high lipitor cost per pill is it legal in the us to buy viagra from canada without a prescription buy imuran cheap buy decadron in usa ramipril 10 mg dosage purchase adalat 15 mg online femcare india donde comprar levitra en peru what happens after the accutane treatment avodart uk pharmacy ordering propecia australia best online sites generic viagra losartan potassium and hydrochlorothiazide tablets buy lexapro pills atacand sales methylprednisolone better than prednisone 1 gbp to eur marks and spencer buy alesse 31 amitriptyline withdrawal where can i purchase serpina can you order flonase sure prescription danazol delivery london cardura generic release date canadian online pharmacy for amoxil prednisone side effects in dogs with lymphoma prevacid online ordering buy voveran with visa domperidone for breastfeeding desyrel without insurance flomax pills online in the india diclofenac online purchase fastest rogaine 2 uk delivery proventil supplier in uk best online pharmacy generic zyvox rosuvastatin with out prescription accutane side effects 7 years later what is the typical dose for lexapro antabuse without prescriptions comprar naprosyn en argentina indian pharmacy ciplox best online pharmacy to buy strattera rxrelief discount card we will rock you nottingham forzest uk online prinivil pas cher purchasing serophene online vermox plus precio en farmacias del ahorro generic effexor xr capsules Purchase prednisone 1 mg lynoral discount atrovent pill shortage which groups were allies at the start of the french and indian war research grade lukol buspar new zealand buy micronase without a prescription from canadian pharmacy what does reglan treat pharmacy support staff responsibilities alli diet pills website prescription drug fincar prescription aciphex doctor buy doxycycline with visa medrol dosepak 4 mg tablet what does metoclopramide mean zocor billig kaufen mexico antibiotics cheap us buy deltasone online alliant international university mexico city zyban australia pbs canine prednisone 20 mg side effects side effects of champix 2010 best generic cardura review buy cheap accutane in usaa online pharmacy tegretol xr how much will clozaril cost tesco pharmacy greenock opening times aciclovir online shipping decadron online shipping order doxycycline mg bestsellers how long does unisom sleep gels take to work generic cefixime in usa prometrium tablets florinef pas cher can you get high off gabapentin 800 mg zyloprim generic cheap costs order cephalexin on line india buy nexium india viagra plus price viagra alternatives nz generic cyklokapron switzerland natural post cycle therapy supplements cialis wiki fr ponstel order online buy triamterene overseas cost of voltaren gel without insurance can you use flonase long term buy dipyridamole pills in the canada acquistare hytrin in italia cicloferon crema funciona prednisone pack dosage 5mg kmart pharmacy generic list buy finpecia for daily use mycelex-g uk brand name doxycycline hyc 100mg tablets clomid success rates over 40 women prevacid tablets generic paxil pharmacy online avalide weight gain sominex medicine online compare prices probalan uses of ventolin tablets cialis sales online australia guaranteed pyridium medicine order cialis online pharmacy buy rhinocort australia prometrium medication order buy kamagra jelly uk generic pravachol limited india antivert components brahmi buy online ireland order prednisolone on line india alesse generic price cozaar brand positioning levitra professional to buy cheapest epivir-hbv rumalaya forte next day pyridium for uti pain improvement free or low cost flovent olmesartan side effects erectile dysfunction buy l-tryptophan online india how long does it take for colchicine to take effect ventolin without prescription in canada buy nolvadex pct online what kind of blood pressure medicine is norvasc vente de plendil au quebec can i send medicine by mail to uk warfarin mechanism of action side effects of proventil inhaler vendita di viagra in italia the chepest medrol can order erexin-v canada delivery next day buy adalat online where to buy clomid in malaysia behavioral side effects of prednisone in dogs side effects of zyprexa 10mg what is the difference between claritin and zyrtec trandate cheap periactin sold over counter pillsbury crescent roll recipes 365 albendazole zentel buy imitrex maximum daily dose exelon with american express viagra in croatia buy alphagan from mexico online generic forzest overnite shipping safe provera buy thyroid medication synthroid dosage purchase tamoxifen uk worldwide pharmacy midamor cafergot prescription coupon how to get viagra on the internet side effects of metoclopramide lopressor reviews 2009 viagra gels uk what class of drug is torsemide why has procardia been discontinued ephedraxin 40 mg dose rosuvastatin legal in england buying bactrim from canada no prescription generic pills for cafergot erythromycin drug in uk pharmacy buying furosemide using paypal buy lexapro 10mg no prescription lamictal xr generic launch atarax online shipping risperdal medication order ajanta pharma limited aurangabad suhagra where to get elavil australia pharmacy comprar fosamax portugal buy unisom in singapore femara generic for hydroxyzine anxiety med what does pravachol look like innopran xl delivery lawsuit against metformin best online pharmacy generic trileptal i pill neurontin website cheapest glucotrol xl in the uk cheap aciphex usa yaz birth control online pharmacy decadron low dose birth control non generic dramamine buy azulfidine online pharmacy trental 400 mg is for what suppliers of liposafe in us effexor drug in canada pharmacy order viagra online us pharmacy alli reviews uk 2012 tofranil sublingual dosage how to take minocin 17. what is the drug reminyl used to treat buy eldepryl 10 how to use clonidine for opiate withdrawal trazodone for sleep 2012 keftab 100 review bupropion tablets identification new drugs treatment erectile dysfunction best online pharmacy generic atacand robaxin without perscription xenical de roche precio argentina levitra precio 5 mg buy finpecia buy metformin xr online flomax complications ordering silagra prescription cialis viagra sales in india do you need prescription generic propecia where to buy cheap generic ephedraxin provigil no prescription online pharmacy medrol dose pack over counter what does doxycycline tablets look like trial erection packs 2 online pharmacy shipped to canada buy genuine digoxin uk where levitra what is relafen 500 mg used for lithium buy on line comprar lincocin en argentina apcalis sx drug class comprar quibron-t en argentina aspirin over the counter strength cheapest way to live food cheapest mircette tablets uk januvia rx purchase atarax on line in uk erythromycin stearate manufacturers india malegra dxt for men sale in uk cozaar blood pressure medicine atacand on line purchase augmentin alternative medicine what is erection packs 2 mg used to treat donde puedo comprar anafranil feldene uk online trandate canada head office pharmacy has best price mycelex-g zyban generic cheap costs plavix 75 mg indication atorlip-10 dose danazol dose endometriosis clomid wanted online review can you buy reglan online where can i get snovitra super power pills non narcotic social anxiety medication pharmacy has best price rhinocort bentyl precio mexico vente de rosuvastatin au quebec best place to buy ophthacare deltasone usa cvs prices rosuvastatin usa diltiazem prescription coupon is propecia generic yet best site to purchase viagra serevent prices at costco cheapest neurontin lotensin cost without insurance what does suhagrath mean comprar benemid original viagra nz price nexium generic form tadalis sx no rx canadian research alliance for community innovation and networking (cracin) zyban cost ireland dosering av kamagra aciphex cost in canada purchase viagra tablets non generic sinequan buy glucophage online overnight council europe drugs order non generic provera brand name zyvox online venta viagra sin receta mexico cialis soft western australia what is alesse 20 mcg-100 mcg nymphomax lawsuit canada generic proventil uk paypal para que serve o cloridrato de sertralina us pharmacies online that sell arimidex actos us sales 2009 reliable mexican pharmacies order nizoral trusted online drug stores in canada clomid medication pregnancy can you get singulair over the counter sinequan ordering online pharmacy one stop pharmacy yuba city xenical reviews for men buy yasmin pill online saw palmetto usa cvs prices brand levitra mg canada tegretol pill shortage buying alli online clomiphene citrate testosterone gel replacement therapy male hypogonadism buy rhinocort in india online buy xenical online cheap canada synthroid online cheap side effects of taking citalopram long term epivir-hbv canada prescription cheap roaccutane 10 mg glycomet 500 mg tablets mail order generic minocin why is there a shortage of brand viagra purchasing cialis jelly online what is the proper dosage when taking viagra prevacid in croatia cephalexin sale viagra reviews for men buy brand advair diskus with visa celexa 20 mg vs lexapro 10mg buy crestor cheap cleocin hcl dosage buying indinavir using paypal mobic 7 5 mg tabletten brand eurax for sale cheapest fertomid in the uk vermox reviews for men glucophage low cost hat happened to orlistat buy vasotec canada lady era shop net trandate medication dosage order jelly from pills viagra online what does grapefruit do to lipitor order discounts generic levitra overseas pharmacy no prescription phexin yasmin buy online uk hydrochlorothiazide coupons viagra professional 100mg pills alli discounts concept benicar for sale buy seroquel without a prescription from canadian pharmacy norco sight 3 se 2013 nizagara online sales to buy viramune national insurance card generic paroxetine cr buy hoodia 20 snovitra super power for sale australia online pharmacy tadacip what is allopurinol 100mg used for cipro shop net levlen order in the us lasix drugs dogs cialis viagra compare worldwide pharmacy toprol xl allegra drugstore canadian leading online purchase florinef 0.1 mg tablets testosterone cream reviews bodybuilding generic alli pills allegra without a script next day duphalac dosage during pregnancy cialis tadalafil 100mg 30 lu tablet azithromycin capsules zithromax 500mg better than naprosyn order clozaril on line usa buy doxycycline 50 mg isoptin medicine purinethol usa sale generic singulair availability date canadian pharmacy cafergot tablets lithium ion battery charging can 10mg citalopram cause weight gain micardis tablets uses can you paypal buy haridra without list of tesco stores selling reglan how to order wellbutrin sr buy generic levitra plus lowest price pariet ortho tri cyclen lo canada no prescription blue mountain pharmacy blanding probalan order fisher price australia buy online cheap pulmicort flexhaler nizoral birth control online mexico bbc 1 radio is it illegal to buy antibiotics online in the us is it illegal to order generic flagyl er what is altace used to treat tretinoin cream .05 reviews acne buy pyridium lowest price serpina not generic buy retin-a 0,05 singapore vigrande 50 mg tablet celebrex coupon code where to buy cytotec in south africa is extendaquin available over the counter malaria medication doxycycline will 800 mg motrin get you high what class of drugs is atarax viagra 100mg cheap uk cialis usa pharmacy decadron tablets dose cost of promethazine-codeine syrup best online pharmacy for cialis reviews viagra recreational use women cipro new company registration forms do you need rx cystone allegra 180 mg tabletas university costa rica pharmacy school american ginseng root extract long term side effects of metformin use western drug glucotrol xl is valtrex a prescription drug prescription drug suhagra generic vs brand birth control pills where is merlin filmed camelot prednisone 5 mg tablet image order clozaril online canada is there a generic for viagra accutane online cheap inderal without script what does generic d look like buy allegra online viagra .99 canada terramycin dosage instructions to buy benicar in uk female viagra in croatia buy uroxatral online no prescription us how to sleep without seroquel ondansetron tablets 4mg where can i buy actoplus met in canada where can i purchase cleocin gel insurance factory birmingham what does wellbutrin sr best generic celebrex review how long does it take for lexapro to start to work get finax las vegas ciprofloxacin milk of magnesia cytotec discount buy claritin mg epivir-hbv for sale uk coversyl plus blood pressure medication celebrex no prescription fedex ups yasminelle buy online uk tadacip refill pack how can you get promethazine codeine prescribed where can i buy live butterflies natural female viagra acai online uk discount code for trandate can claritin d make you gain weight hyzaar generic names buy online rhinocort generic florida confido can you order advair diskus brand name alli pill canadian keppra on line no script ceftin drug in uk pharmacy maximum daily dose of actos blue oval pill with watson 349 on it is tramadol better than diclofenac imitrex coupons print viagra pharmacy coupon septilin online buy atarax new zealand online purchase voltaren in usa what is metoprolol xl feldene generic reviews to buy prograf where to purchase zovirax suppliers of unisom in us zithromax usa sale triamterene and hydrochlorothiazide capsules usp generic female cialis paypal western drug lipothin lamisil for sale manila what does the parietal lobe do for kids zithromax z-pak uses is eurax available over the counter what is the drug paxil used to treat top 10 online retin-a 0,05 sites buy generic valtrex online drugs Purchase viagra 20 mg accutane from canada vardenafil hcl 10 mg propecia 1 mg online kamagra singapore retino order online no prescription can buy nootropil online what does seroquel treat salbutamol inhaler same as ventolin zyprexa withdrawal antabuse dallas original hydrea online tetracycline buy without como preparar la sandia como viagra natural colospa overnight delivery keflex phone orders antabuse injection australia 6 mercaptopurine and pregnancy generic uk paypal roxithromycin crestor cost usa revatio canada head office how to take fertomid buy ponstel perth australia over the counter medicine back pain tetracycline staining mechanism clomid no prescription uk why is alli not available in uk buyers of viagra super active canada generico de viagra can order dramamine canada over the counter actoplus met can i make torsemide trimox new zealand buy us generic diamox cialis super active medicine online discount sustiva can you buy dramamine under 18 i want to pay some aldactone long term side effects of procardia terramycin ointment shelf life what does elocon cream treat buy diclofenac usa rosuvastatin for sale online buy abilify 20 mg licensed doxazosin online legally mexican pharmacy no prescription actoplus met order cephalexin pills zofran tablets dosage antibiotics keflex pregnancy order lopressor canada can i order aciphex no prescription in the usa atrovent on line for sale no script cheapest sustiva purchasing actonel online uk americans getting drugs from canada plendil in croatia buy aspirin 75mg chloramphenicol next day shipping side effects of nitroglycerin transdermal patch can you buy generic diflucan no prescription minocycline capsules side effects paypal buy now button with quantity can you buy adderall in the uk how do i make a healthy mango lassi suhagra cost comparison pharmacy discount is there a shortage of amitriptyline is esomeprazole safe during pregnancy eurax billig kaufen buy nitrofurantoin online canadian family magazine contact how to import hytrin get tadapox toronto nolvadex pas cher italie seroflo tablets online exelon patch order online capoten next day delivery canadianmedicinenow com reviews albendazole with store buy donde puedo comprar ginseng generic isoniazid overnite shipping to buy tegretol in uk purchase finasteride cheap online pharmacy western drug erexin-v what is diclofenac ec tablets 50mg for buy accutane online cheap pariet precio mexico what is the best dosage for viagra cheap caverta free delivery cleocin gel drug oversea msds for nitroglycerin tablets vasotec drug interactions can you buy diskus advair cheap generic ordering viagra soft mexico tulasi prices fastest geriforte syrup uk delivery order tegretol online in usa best over the counter cough syrup to get high celebrex discount no prescription ephedraxin discounts codes amoxil 50mg tablets online pharmacy uk roaccutane buspar generic india celebrex drugs interaction 2 lidocaine gel buy brand advair diskus quick pomegranate juice concentrate organic buy lantus insulin elavil 25mg what is prednisone 10mg for onde comprar o remedio nexium mais barato zithromax online with out prescription med express pharmacy north carolina buy pariet 10 vardenafil generic alternative anacin no prescription reviews canadian silagra overseas pharmacy no prescription kytril discount canadian pharmacy shatavari best place buy prograf pct medrol dose pack buy online nymphomax doctors online zofran 4mg 6 tablet tamoxifen fertility drug nolvadex without a prescription from australia why has alavert been discontinued where torsemide brand viagra discontinued astelin online overnight shipping astelin for men in usa actos online shipping order coversyl online what is trazodone hydrochloride 100mg chlamydia home test kit boots flovent 100 mcg non prescription cialis professional pharmacy buy malegra fxt in australia cheapest drug augmentin informatii despre viagra how to get lipitor cheap yasmin sewell twitter allopurinol for daily use canada keflex uk brand name mary pharmacy algodones mexico zyrtec generic reviews ayurslim cheap price compare prices acai buy v-gel visa can you trust canadian online pharmacies abilify medication assistance uk version of triamterene lotensin best price imuran online cheap maxalt 10 mg wafers reglan tablets for dogs 1500 mg depakote bipolar disorder comprar zovirax original very cheap revatio how to take kamagra jelly cost of entocort purchase diflucan in uk cefixime 100 mg tablets voveran sr reviews for men buyers of silagra canada buy trileptal online usa arimidex dosage buy cream online cheapest nizoral prices viramune tablets penegra perth australia generic liv overnite shipping voveran sr overseas order eurax online with visa top 10 online zanaflex sites legal buy meclizine online canada goldshield eltroxin tablets cialis on line from a us pharmacy where can i get dulcolax indian generics online compazine olanzapine pharmacy cheap and best place to live in india chlamydia in men eyes mentax order in the us ordering cialis online canada prescription allegra generic brand nymphomax western australia zofran extreme constipation skin cream betnovate n glucophage prices usa minocin sold over counter tylenol motrin recall generic tenormin tablets purchase on line all types aciphex pills singulair side effects in women zyrtec 100 tabletek omifin precio 2012 espan~a is there a generic form of flonase health canada ginette-35 flovent hfa online pharmacy ceftin uk companies only nymphomax with no rx buy requip from canada buy kytril in singapore do you need rx risperdal average cost of maxalt take 4 pills chlamydia cheapest online viagra levitra best online pharmacies uk no prescription buy brand advair diskus fluticasone is hoodia legal in the uk where can i buy lanoxin cost of lithium ion batteries in india medicine digoxin side effects original suhagra online buy anafranil online pharmacy effexor xr drug oversea cheapest place to buy biaxin good over the counter erection pills get fertomid las vegas benzac without a prescription diabecon prescription coupon drug market order cozaar wellbutrin xl generic price amaryl drugs prescription diabetes best place to order trazodone in us where to buy ginseng wow dostinex dose stop breastfeeding voveran india order levothroid online uk lotensin uk buy can you get torsemide online pharmacy no prescription needed motilium online rosuvastatin purchase cipro and low blood pressure zyrtec precio mexico does levitra have a shelf life cheap canadian drugs online menosan on line no script avalide by mail order como comprar levitra pela internet albendazole 40 mg dose acivir dosage diabecon ds price barbarian stats hell is there a generic form of effexor xr singulair prescription drug assistance trandate uses medication buying viagra online thuoc doxycycline capsules bp 100mg order elavil canada buy benicar without a prescription from canadian pharmacy what does green tea with hoodia do cialis jelly shelf life what is teva olanzapine used for levlen 100mg cheep sominex without script seroflo lawsuit canada moduretic pharmacy coupons generic viagra soft tabs reviews pharmacy mexico elimite betnovate n cream price zithromax walmart pharmacy canada dispensing fee buy lopressor without rx female viagra drug class buy hong kong fml forte liters what enzyme does allopurinol inhibit fluoxetine generic form lithium reviews for depression generic suhagra paypal lipitor drug discount card zoloft australia price effexor xr next day no prescription ranitidine side effects of celebrex tablets what does lithium do when it reacts with water purchase viagra jelly pills xenical for sale online cialis at costco pharmacy order clonidine hcl how to order rhinocort online vytorin echeck tesco pharmacy jobs search plendil wanted online review what are cephalexin tablets used for buy pulmicort perth australia how to purchase premarin online 10mg amitriptyline weight gain propranolol 20 mg half life actonel once a month dose accutane before and after cystic acne viagra purchase online buspar mg canada trileptal 100mg acute gout allopurinol dilantin from usa best generic lotrisone review eldepryl in canada trazodone drugs tenormin trusted online drug stores in canada buy cephalexin pills i pill sarafem website what is antabuse made of buy female viagra boots gabapentin 300mg tablets cozaar sublingual dosage clomid twins success stories rumalaya liniment to buy from europe how to use penegra 50 mg endep legal us doxycycline for acne scars ordering wellbutrin on line flagyl er where to purchase brand lotensin buy how to use tricorder app buy canada no prescription for phenergan order tinidazole rx buy elavil in usa synthroid pharmacological classification non persciption cardizem lamisil pills for ringworm side effects lopid generic equivalent celexa mg canadian rx where can i order trimox buy revia usa how to buy lioresal in london what is amitriptyline for dogs best generic viagra seller mexico pharmacy no prescription online mixing celebrex and alcohol pariet contraceptive pill medication online order purchase ventolin lowest price where to buy hoodia in ireland asacol to buy in england propranolol inderal adverse effects can you take cymbalta to get high health canada oxytrol viagra coupons buy generic florinef with bonus elavil delivery uk nootropil price research grade zantac cheapest zofran in the uk what class of drugs is cialis what is ranitidine used for in children lamisil tablets 250mg best cheap drugstore lipstick cialis dosage mg lithium satellite radio online legal buy rumalaya forte online canada caverta tablets online betnovate scalp application alternative zetia side effects liver eulexin comprare female viagra uses medication cheap nizagara 100 mg top 10 online lariam sites over the counter carbozyne fincar refill pack dilantin in the uk now viagra legal buy us nimotop online order lopressor without a script atrovent usage buy voltaren online india no prescription forum cod buy periactin online zofran tablets 4mg 8mg where can i buy prilosec in the uk legal status of drugs in canada order clonidine online uk mircette discount card india propecia price norvasc online coupon code metronidazole 500mg dosage for trichomoniasis mycelex-g pas cher donde comprar estrace yasmin pill side effects 2012 cheap vytorin buy online isoptin dosage form diamox pills side effects what does the drug finasteride do serophene online shipping best drugstore makeup can you buy lotensin without beat way to order ranitidine nolvadex buy without cialis viagra online canadian minomycin legal us comprare viagra bologna lopid capsules buy genuine exelon uk atorlip-20 dosage too high purchase risperdal cheap skelaxin pills uses adalat without a script fedex cheap all rights reserved buy allopurinol online buy periactin pills in the india ophthacare discount voucher where to get prinivil pct aciphex 20 mg generic dramamine for kids reviews can buy entocort online diltiazem pills drugstore cialis daily dosage side effects toradol without prescriptions non prescription endep pharmacy minocycline echeck allegra costco pharmacy what is l-tryptophan good for diovan hct vs diovan is viagra cheaper than cialis 123 reg support advair diskus medication can i buy metformin online diovan valsartan dosage buy abilify 40 what is elocon tablets allegra buy on line lotrisone australia pharmacy generic wellbutrin sr in usa malegra dxt generico italiano methotrexate generic reviews medication without prescription where can i buy cymbalta cheap augmentin dosage australia how to get discount lexapro buy fluoxetine online overnight delivery buy nexium 10 buy doxycycline patch which generic wellbutrin works best where does ginseng grow best grows legal buy brahmi online canada without a script buy order allegra online cheap jelly buy kamagra online better than rogaine 2011 vytorin generic wikipedia drugs buy ventolin evohaler online accutane sales online cialis viagra impotence erectile dysfunction is praziquantel safe for humans what is sildenafil citrate made of nymphomax lawsuit side effects of thalidomide on babies buy bystolic in usa www.online canadameds.com cheap strattera mg buying cialis from canada no prescription us online pharmacy no prescription renagel buy water pills over counter cheapest drug terramycin lipitor 4 you participating pharmacies better than suprax cheap abilify 11 pharmacy buy albendazole tablets usa to buy xalatan in uk alliant international university mexico city mexico canada toradol meds lamisil maximum dosage para q sirven las pastillas cialis cheap generic cytoxan buy meclizine discount purchase generic robaxin retin a amazon uk i want to pay some florinef buy himalaya speman online india buy eurax without a script skelaxin pills effects can you order claritin drugs relief buy valtrex without prescription valtrex 500 mg dosage purchase generic arjuna alesse reviews users how long does it take to recover from a liver biopsy sominex shortage 2012 nolvadex uk online buy vermox online at canada pharmacy cheap amaryllis bulbs selection how to purchase synthroid american express usa account login donepezil 5 mg side effects citalopram discount coupon sale online probalance buy live fish online australia hyaluronic acid injections dose olanzapine online legally wellbutrin 100 xeloda dose for colon cancer is it safe to buy pills from canada buy metoclopramide no prescription fast delivery can you take levitra plus daily to buy periactin drug pharmacy olanzapine discount card what are the long term side effects of viagra lady era tablets uses buy kamagra 15mg online strattera medicine online advair diskus shoppers drug mart maxalt max dose per month benicar delivery viagra jelly coupons pharmacy plus jobs bristol cost of ampicillin 500mg generic viagra super active 100 mg donde comprar micronase Purchase orlistat 180 mg cafergot more drug_uses buy generic renagel with bonus long term side effects of doxycycline buy female viagra bulk finpecia online mexico orlistat for sale usa ginseng medicine online extra sex power medicine long term side effects of mirapex hydrochlorothiazide generic side effects buy remeron in australia best deals on viagra "cgv online pharmacy dulcolax suppository dose for kids zyprexa 2.5 mg tablets ashwagandha brands india what types of starlix are there advair diskus for dogs buy viagra generico farmacia italia buy entocort online cheap indian pharmacy zyban ou acheter viagra en suisse viagra trial sample pharmacy no prescription paypal ortho tri-cyclen mg buy allie brosh 2013 zyban australia depression vermox oral suspension dosage risperdal reviews weight gain uk viagra sales online which uk site to buy toradol buy valacyclovir 500 mg what is brand amoxil for comprar levaquin online does taking synthroid cause weight gain generic phenergan overnite shipping where to allopurinol chemist importing lexus rx canada order ventolin 4mg valacyclovir hcl drug interactions buy mexiletine 150 mg can you buy erexor over the counter buy hydrea inhaler canada buy zyloprim without rx levaquin usa sale pill rx health evista products deltasone tablets 150 mg ranitidine otc australia cheap fertility pills online buy trimox tablets us generic cialis tadalafil price comparison where to get glucophage pct legal buy clonidine online canada doxycycline reviews for sinus infection malegra dxt pills mexican pharmacy no prescription topamax tenormin without prescriptions pharmacy that sells aldactone where to buy cheap generic uroxatral rocaltrol pill shortage feldene maximum dose rizatriptan vs maxalt styplon mg buy isoniazid overnight endep dosage and half cheapest generic proscar comprar viagra barato en espan~a buy actoplus met tablets uk can you buy cialis jelly in ireland online pill store levitra cipralex reviews drugs.com buy tadalafil online australia celexa uk next day delivery what does paxil do to your brain toprol xl canada head office what is the generic for effexor xr administration hyzaar plus 100/25 levitra super active best price buy ventolin on line in usa long time side effects mestinon how much is lexapro generic vitamin shoppe locations ny overseas pharmacy no prescription arjuna can you buy female cialis online lesofat orlistat best site to buy brand cialis what is the active ingredient in viagra and cialis order lopressor pill canadian meds item canadian pharmacies to buy cialis levaquin iv compatibility orlistat alli philippines price where can i buy testosterone cypionate powder lopressor 10 mg iv torsemide 50mg tablets decadron from usa is it legal to purchase prescription drugs online cheap cialis 5 difference entre viagra et levitra allegra drugstore com low prices what type of medication is requip blue pill vgr 100 ordering cafergot india original carafate online herbal phentermine reviews albuterol sulfate inhalation solution 0.083 expiration date cytoxan medication online como se usa el dulcolax can you buy benadryl in australia xeloda sales crestor rosuvastatin wikipedia cheap mobicosa pharmacy no presciption canadian viagra ethionamide mg tablet buy viagra boots canadian como comprar livros digitais para ipad prednisone side effects nausea dizziness losartan potassium 25 mg subtenon triamcinolone injection neurontin bonus pills buy periactin in ireland propecia pills india western drug kamagra how much do trazodone cost lansoprazole 30 mg fastab bentyl 20 mg oral tablets order buy deltasone cheap buy no prescription order abilify online mexico buy reglan order most reliable place to buy differin online purchase antabuse pills can you buy atorlip-5 acivir pills from europe lynoral online legally comprar generico do viagra em portugal acticin pct buy glucophage xr usa amantadine hydrochloride wiki do i need a prescription for plendil valtrex valacyclovir same thing buy diclofenac gel hong kong lipothin tablets on line to buy order cialis online no prescription purchase generic cyklokapron does retin a work better than differin why is there a shortage of levothroid how to buy brand viagra kamagra tablets review eldepryl tablets from buy cialis vs viagra en espanol 20mg allegra coupons printable 2012 cheap maxalt online why has suhagra been discontinued can i get cialis over the counter bentyl order amantadine over the counter prescription can i take 2 diflucan pills diclofenac sodium 100 mg sa tab cabgolin on line no script buy generic wellbutrin sr online post cycle therapy seroflo buy tofranil online at canada pharmacy lukol non perscription countries best place buy sominex pct is kamagra legal in the us plendil online order keppra price india wellbutrin 100 mg tablet voltaren rapid 50 mg novartis how can i buy cialis online side effects of seroquel 25 mg rumalaya in the uk using doxycycline acne treatment dilantin toxicity lipitor canada head office online midamor india betamethasone valerate price what is olanzapine nhs direct propecia online coupon code cheapest furosemide to buy over the counter pills for yeast infection how to use renova cream safe to buy generic paroxetine from uk generic trial erection packs 1 canada generic drug for neurontin chloramphenicol mg price generic uk paypal periactin buy cialis in london ralista prix en pharmacie en france what does prometrium do for fertility coreg women buy ciplox comprare ipharmacy rx reference android what are the most common side effects of lasix viagra professional on line in the usa best online pharmacy generic acai med cab zestoretic zovirax canada prescription prescription solutions phone number overland park where purchase acticin pastillas para la ereccion masculina cialis zebeta without a prescription alphagan medication interactions prescription drug buy accutane acai berry detox pills review buy asacol boots weight gain tablets fluoxetine 20 mg how long does it take to work where can i buy propecia uk where to get furosemide can you buy tegretol online can i buy viagra over the counter in costa rica adalat order online cialis soft tabs online generic tadalafil sinemet suppositories buy antivert otc walgreens terramycin usa sale le viagra definition lowest price duphalac online pharmacy cialis overnight delivery indian jelly order viagra online buy nitrofurantoin online at canada pharmacy paxil 10 mg for anxiety strattera dosage forms how much does clomid cost privately nexium 40mg coupons cialis 20 mg price uk joint pain meds for dogs retino-a cream 0,05 for men in usa can you buy drug betapace online ordering generic amaryl pharmacy buy precose boots vente de norvasc au quebec commander viagra en suisse prilosec overnight pharmacy cost of actos in us buy antibiotics uk what does prednisone do to the body vermox tablets mebendazole glycomet legal in england nolvadex prices buy zithromax from mexico online is there a generic form of premarin cost comparison prednisolone mg buy caverta from india comprar plavix pela internet ordering actos drugs generic lasix 100 review levlen canada head office cheap buy amoxil online without rhinocort from usa pharmacy how to import live mail into outlook 2007 azithromycin tablets for acne topamax fda approved to buy without prescription purchasing stromectol online generic bactrim buy canada generic bactrim side effects buy azulfidine in singapore cabgolin online forum what is the difference between biaxin and biaxin xl what does levlen brand cialis purchase in canada no prescription where to snovitra super power buy zocor tablets purchase protonix in us overnight delivery buy floxin ophthacare maximum dosage albendazole tablet formulation where to buy generic viagra atarax cheap buy online no prescription bromocriptine dopamine prolactin voltaren side effects dizziness side effects of sarafem 20 mg missed lexapro dose side effect where to florinef mexican pharmacy no prescription duphalac best male enhancement drugs best price for real propecia what is atrovent used for how to get bactroban drug promethazine dm max dose cabgolin for sale australia endep delivery
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews The Economics of Sports: An Interview with Roger Noll

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1067 guests online

Atom RSS

The Economics of Sports: An Interview with Roger Noll PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 33
PoorBest 
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 23 November 2009 00:00

Roger NollThe biggest story in all of sports (and beyond) over the last year and a half has been the influence of the economy on sports properties. The NFL, NBA, NHL, and Major League Baseball have not been impervious to the lashings that every sector in business has taken, and that has trickled down the fan, who has had to decide whether to attend games, or save their money.

With the recession playing such a key role in professional sports, sports economics has moved from the background to front page news.

Roger Noll, professor of economics emeritus at Stanford University and a Senior Fellow at the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, has been one to have their pulse on economics, including sports.

He’s been the author or co-author of twelve books and over three hundred articles and reviews. His primary research interests include technology policy; antitrust, regulation and privatization policies in both advanced and developing economies; the economic approach to public law (administrative law, the judiciary, and statutory interpretation); and yes, the economics of sports and entertainment.

Staff author Pete Toms caught up with Noll recently for a broad ranging interview that runs from leagues as a single entity; competitive balance in MLB after the Yankees winning the World Series, which includes his takes on salary caps in U.S. pro sports; possible relocation of franchises ranging from the Athletics to the Niners; the debate over public subsidies for stadium development; and much more – Maury Brown

Select Read More for the interview with Roger Noll

Pete Toms for the Business of Sports Network: You are amongst a group of sports economists who recently filed an Amicus Curiae brief with the Supreme Court in American Needle. At stake in this case is the status of professional sports leagues as single entities. This same issue was at the core of Jim Balsille's recently failed attempt to purchase and relocate the Phoenix Coyotes without the permission of the NHL. Why are you and the other sports economists opposed to single entity status for these leagues? Why did the NFL ask the Supreme Court to rule on this matter when the lower courts had already sided with them? Why should sports fans be interested in this case? If the Supreme Court rules that single entity status does not extend into the realm of labor relations (as has been speculated), is the case of less importance? Would you care to handicap the outcome?

Roger Noll: The opposition to single entity status is partly that leagues are not "single entities" (organizations that have a unity of purpose) and partly that leagues should not be exempt from any specific antitrust complaint without having to prove that centralizing decisions in the league is more efficient than decentralizing them with teams, given that the former eliminates competition.

The NFL did not appeal the decision -- American Needle appealed. When they did, the NFL sought to broaden the case. Having been found to be a single entity with respect to licensing caps that bear team logos, they seek to be declared a single entity with respect to everything. Obviously this would be a great result for the NFL as it would reverse fifty years of adverse antitrust decisions.

Sports fans should be interested because the outcome will affect whether players can be free agents or the conditions under which the NFL (or any other league) can control the location of teams.

The narrower the decision of the Supreme Court, the less important is the case. I don't think team logo caps are a very big deal, although even here I do not think that the courts were correct in exempting the NFL from having to prove that their joint licensing arrangement was efficient and did not harm consumers.

I do not handicap the Supreme Court.

Toms: The World Series victory of the New York Yankees has baseball's chattering classes in an uproar over the state of competitive balance in MLB. Ostensibly (according to some), MLB has increased revenue sharing and implemented a competitive balance tax (aka the luxury tax) in their efforts to achieve greater on field parity. Some Sports Economists argue that the real purpose of these initiatives is to suppress player compensation. The same proponents of this argument believe that these same league policies contribute nothing to competitive balance (this argument is presented in the aforementioned brief submitted to The Supreme Court in American Needle). Can you explain this logic to baseball fans in Pittsburgh and Kansas City who believe that the key to fielding competitive teams in their markets is some combination of a salary cap/floor, increased revenue sharing, more punitive payroll taxes etc.?

Noll quoteNoll: The only way to have equally balanced teams is to ban trades and sales of players and to have periodic drafts of managers, coaches and directors of player personnel. The methods that leagues use to create balance have been shown to have little or no effect on the distribution of quality among teams. The logic behind it is that it is not in the interests of owners as well as players to have balanced competition. If all teams were of the same strength, total league revenues would go up if the best player in KC were traded for the worst player in NYC. In a regime of salary caps and no free agency, the KC owner will be richer if he sells his underpaid star to NY.

Check out last year's NHL standings. The NHL has the toughest salary cap in all sports. Was the league more balanced (e.g., the gap between the best and worst teams in W-L records) smaller than before the cap was established? The NHL cap reduced payrolls, but even if the payroll were zero in the poorest drawing markets, those teams would still lose money.

Toms: Is the era of the salary cap in US pro sports nearing its end? There is much conjecture that many NFL owners (both large and small market) would prefer to operate without a salary cap/floor. Increasingly, NFL teams are finding ways to circumvent both the cap and the floor, contributing to greater on field competitive imbalance this season. The NHL forewent an entire season in their successful battle with the NHLPA to implement a salary cap. Many NHL observers argue that the cap in the NHL has caused more problems than it has resolved. Sun Belt franchises have incurred large payroll increases as the salary floor has risen, meanwhile the revenues of these franchises haven' kept pace. The salary cap has historically been favored by owners because it limits player compensation yet the only uncapped league - MLB - is paying out the smallest percentage of league revenues to its players. With the CBAs in all the sick and ball leagues potentially expiring in 2011, are salary caps on the way out?

Noll: You misread the NFL. They are willing to let the current CBA expire and have one uncapped year in return for imposing on the players the old system (no free agency, no agents) -- if the Supreme Court declares them to be a single entity. The players would never agree to a CBA that eliminates free agency, so enduring an uncapped year and imposing it is the only option available to the owners.

The MLB comparison is not quite right because it does not take into account the amounts MLB pays to support minor league teams.

Obviously, if leagues are single entities, they do not need a CBA and can impose restrictions on players that vastly reduce their salaries. A cap is not important in this regime. But I doubt that this will happen.

Toms: If economics is fundamentally the study of how markets allocate resources, what impact will the expansion of the amateur draft internationally have on the player/labour market? Some argue that the introduction of the draft to Puerto Rico has directly resulted in a diminished number of players being recruited from that country. Those same people are concerned that the introduction of a player draft to the Dominican Republic will have the same effect. There is also an argument that a draft in Latin America will not result in lower player acquisition costs for MLB, that in fact, the present buscone system is very efficient. Assuming that MLB successfully negotiates these changes with the MLBPA in the next CBA negotiations, what long term effects do you foresee?

Noll: I do not think that this is terribly important. A few foreign players will be drafted high, but the rest will not, and after the first few rounds draft picks are not paid very much, just as most teenagers signed from the Caribbean are not paid very much. I see no reason to believe that many fewer will be signed -- and even if that happens, it will not matter very much because the vast majority of foreign minor leaguers never make the majors.

Toms: On the subject of revenue-sharing in MLB. In 2007 you told The Biz of Baseball, "Under the old agreement, teams in low-revenue markets were rewarded financially for making their teams weaker." MLB attempted to address that problem by changing the revenue sharing marginal tax rates in the current CBA. Have those changes resulted in greater incentives for small revenue franchises to field competitive teams? On the same subject, Commissioner Selig is sometimes criticized for not disciplining clubs that do not invest all of their revenue sharing proceeds in their on the field product. (I.E. Their revenue sharing receipts exceed their big league payroll). Is that a fair criticism?

Noll quoteNoll: The new revenue sharing formula is much better in giving teams more incentive to win. And as for the "criticism" by the Commissioner, it has no effect. The point is that paying a lot for players is a losing proposition in several markets. As witnessed by salary floors in other sports, forcing people to spend money does not really do very much.

Toms: Are there any US markets without MLB capable of supporting a franchise? Put another way, can Tampa Bay or Oakland make a credible argument that if they don't get public cooperation in constructing a new baseball stadium that they will relocate their franchise? What would have to happen before a third or fourth MLB franchise set up shop in New Jersey or Brooklyn? Does this bring us back to the significance of American Needle?

Noll: Yes, there are markets where teams would succeed if given a free stadium, and the threat to move is credible. Even in the NHL, the threat to move is credible if the league would let Sunbelt teams move to Canada. To get another team in NYC requires bribing the Yankees and the Mets, just as the Mets bribed the Yankees to let them in when the Mets were created. The status of franchise location antitrust in MLB is uncertain – there has never been a case that was litigated to completion. Thus, American Needle may not be important for MLB.

But more generally, the two Raiders cases do say that leagues cannot block relocation just to protect the team that is already there from competition. If the NFL wins its argument before the Supreme Court, the Raiders decision will be reversed.

Toms: At present, the MLBPA does not share in the wealth generated by MLBAM. Maury Brown and Jayson Stark, amongst others, have speculated that at some point the MLBPA will request that this changes. Also, this year saw MLB launch the MLBN, where again the players do not share in the profits. Both media enterprises are considered very successful by the sports business pundits. MLBAM was rumoured to be valued in excess of $2 billion in 2005 by Goldman Sachs when an IPO was reportedly under consideration. MLBN, at inception, launched into 50 million homes. (A record amount for a new cable channel.) How important are these media companies to the overall financial health of MLB and do you foresee the players asking to share in the profits soon?

Noll: The players do share -- if team revenues go up, so do salaries. I do not think that MLBPA should given this much priority. Anything that increases revenues will be good for the players.

I also suspect that league-controlled new media entities are likely to be a bad idea. Leagues do not generally do a good job running them. Remember the Baseball Network? They could make more money licensing it to someone else.

Toms: MLB attendance declined approximately 7% in 2009 from 2008. Twenty-two of 30 franchises reported a decline in attendance. There was also widespread ticket discounting and sponsorship revenues were under pressure due to the recession and the collapse of the banking and auto sectors (traditionally the two most important sponsorship categories). At the same time, MLB COO Bob DuPuy has stated that revenues were flat in 2009. Are the reported flat revenues a sole result of the increased dollars generated by the two new ballparks in NYC or are there other factors?

Noll quoteNoll: I have not seen a breakdown of the revenues, so I do not really know the answer. But in-stadium revenues are less than half of all revenues, and TV audiences are up (which happens in a recession).

I am not sure that "price discounts" are the full story. If the discounts are off of higher prices, the net effect could even be positive. Economists have always wondered why pro sports teams do not engage in more price variability than they do. It makes sense economically to have the sticker price be the price that is appropriate for the weekend, and to offer discounts for week days, especially if the opposition is weak.

Toms: Credible media sources (including Liz Mullen at The SportsBusiness Journal) have reported that the NFL has presented a proposal to the NFLPA which includes expense credits that owners will deduct from revenues that determine the amount of the salary cap. The owners have contended all along that their principal problem with the current CBA is that the players do not share in the risk and costs associated with constructing new stadiums. The same proposal includes a rookie wage scale, as opposed to the current rookie cap. Both sides are refusing to comment on the media reports, fuelling speculation that the proposal is under serious consideration. Do you see this proposal forming the foundation of a new agreement? Why is a rookie compensation a labor issue in both the NFL and MLB? Will the NFL and the NFLPA agree to a CBA before March and avoid the much talked about uncapped 2010?

Noll: I have no idea what is going on in the NFL-NFLPA bargaining. The "expense credit" idea is just another way to cut salaries. I doubt that this makes much sense because of the differences among teams in the expenses that they could deduct. Tighter controls on wages for drafted players are much more likely because that does not hurt existing NFLPA members. And the reason that rookies salaries are on the agenda is that wages are a mandatory issue for bargaining -- if either side wants to discuss them, the other side is required to engage.

Finally, I have no insight about whether a CBA will be agreed by March, but I have strong doubts. If the NFLPA believes that it must settle for a bad deal, it will wait to get one good year out of it.

Toms: I put together a piece for The Biz of Baseball in March entitled Sports Marketing is the Recession's New Whipping Boy. The political and populist backlash against corporate sponsorship of professional sports (particularly against banks that received TARP money) was severe. CitiBank and the Mets were reviled in the NY press for their naming rights deal. At the last minute, BofA backed out of a major sponsorship deal for the new Yankee Stadium. Barney Frank expressed outrage in a series of interviews and TV appearances. The PGA suffered. Jerry Jones opened his new football stadium without a naming rights deal. There are countless other examples. Recently there are reports that sports marketing dollars are rebounding. Do you see that trend in your research? Will the sports marketing dollars return in the same levels previous to the financial meltdown or has there been a more permanent shift?

Noll: I do not know whether sponsorship revenues and other revenues from corporations have started to rebound, but I see no reason to believe that they will not rebound as soon as executives believe that the recession is over.

Toms: Many sports economists (including yourself) have long been vocal in their opposition to investment of public dollars in stadiums/arenas constructed to house professional sports teams. I sense that there has been a shift in public attitudes towards these initiatives, that more and more people agree that the economic benefits promised by proponents of these projects are false. In turn, we have seen a change in the tactics of stadium proponents, where arenas/stadiums are promoted as the key component in urban renewal projects aka entertainment districts. Governments and developers have also become more sophisticated in how they funnel public money into these projects, often now via financing. (I.E. Tax Increment Financing aka TIFs and Payments in Lieu of Taxes aka PILOTS) What does your data reveal, as a percentage, is there less public money being invested in these projects as opposed to 10 or 20 years ago? Do you think the Sports Economists have had an impact in influencing public policy in this area?

Noll quoteNoll: Yes, public subsidies of sports teams are declining. Yes, sports economics research probably has had some effect. But, the bigger effect is that state and local governments are on the verge of bankruptcy. Look for some revival in subsidies in a couple of years.

Toms: A hot topic in the baseball media has been collusion. Michael Weiner has been making some thinly veiled and very public allusions on the matter. Those who argue that there is evidence of collusion claim that the diminished demand for free agent players precedes the recession by a couple of seasons. These same people will point to stable (and historically high) industry revenues. On the other side is the argument that there has been a fundamental change in how the management of the clubs values veteran talent. The rationale being that the now industry wide emphasis on objective analysis has resulted in less demand for veterans and increased demand for young players. As well, there is a belief that veteran players are less productive in the latter stages of their careers in the post steroids era. Do you see any evidence of collusion in the MLB free agent market the past handful of seasons? Whether there is, or isn't, collusion, what are the chances that the MLBPA could successfully argue their position before an arbitrator?

Noll: I would need to see the books of the teams to know whether collusion is plausible. The alternative explanations need to be tested using real data on salary budgets, revenues, and other costs. The speculation that career are shorter due to steroids is clearly not true, but the notion that teams have over-valued older players in the free agent market may be true -- but research has not yet proved it.

Toms: Being a resident of the Golden State, please give us a California sports business update. There is a lot of speculation that Ed Roski will attract an NFL franchise to the City of Industry. (a suburb of Los Angeles) All three California NFL clubs are agitating for new stadiums, with Santa Clara courting the 49ers. Is the NFL coming to the City of Industry and if so, will it be a franchise currently in the state or one from outside? Might the Raiders and 49ers have to agree to share a stadium in order to see a new one constructed? What is the future of the Chargers? Are the Oakland A's moving to San Jose? Why has California been largely absent (SF has AT&T park but it was mostly privately financed) from the nationwide trend of new stadium construction?

Noll: I think it is doubtful that Santa Clara will approve a stadium for the 49ers -- could happen, but probably won't. I also do not think the Raiders are likely to get a new stadium anywhere in the Bay Area because they have become unpopular as an organization. And I doubt that the two teams will share a stadium because they probably would prefer to move.

[City of] Industry is a better chance, although the legal challenges will drag on for a long time.

The A's are more likely to move to San Jose than the 49ers to Santa Clara. But they still must bribe the Giants for the territory. Politically San Jose is more favorable for a stadium subsidy, but it will still be a fight.

California is not "absent" from stadiums -- remember the financial disaster that is San Diego? The important point is that in the Bay Area and LA, voters have been rejecting these things fairly regularly. We will see how long this lasts, but the 2006 votes in Pasadena and Sacramento were before the recession hit.

Toms: At the Baseball Winter Meetings, the fate of Marvin Miller's candidacy for the Hall of Fame is up again, and the media has been discussing it (see Maury Brown’s take). There is agreement that Mr. Miller had a seismic impact on MLB but there is debate about the worthiness of the changes he fought for. From a fan perspective, was Marvin Miller a positive force in MLB?

Noll quoteNoll: First, I am not sure that the appropriate criterion is whether Marvin benefited fans. Once one goes beyond players and managers (where the issue is playing field success), the criteria should include owners, players, and the business side of the sport.

Beyond this, Marvin Miller is a giant in the history of baseball. He is responsible for the existence of a strong union and thereby the existence of free agency. One cannot imagine writing a history of baseball in the second half of the 20th Century in which he would not play a central role. And the argument that he caused damage to the sport is obviously false -- all of the predictions of disaster at the time of the McNally-Messersmith case have been proven by time to be false. Most of the complaints about the way that baseball was affected by transferring more power to the players are based on false premises about how the business side of baseball works. Of course, some owners would be a lot richer if baseball's institutions were the same now as they were in 1965.

Keeping him out of the Hall of Fame for this reason would be a travesty.


  • Interview conducted by Pete Toms
  • Editied by Maury Brown


OTHER NEWS FROM THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)

(SPORTS BASH)


Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?