capital one credit card cashback bonus credit card protection paypal paypal uk credit card what is credit card apr rate online payday loans no credit check chase visa credit card payment 100 day pay loans best cash rewards credit card canada 2013 best free balance transfer credit cards icici platinum chip credit card army pay advance regulation credit card merchant agreement visa hbc mastercard benefits online cash advance direct lenders chase credit card fraud investigation process 0 cash transfer credit cards tesco bank credit card login starbucks gold card wiki us airways mastercard does commonwealth bank have a visa debit card high limit easy to get credit cards icici bank credit card apply eligibility shell gas credit card application short term loan very bad credit what;s the best first credit card to get the best credit card for me bad credit loan lenders online discover credit card application status what is the best credit card to apply for with no credit best credit card to get free flights chase prepaid visa card if i apply for a walmart credit card online can i use it in the store home trust secured credit card canada credit cards bad credit no annual fee list of credit card issuers in canada secured credit card reviews bank of america best iphone credit card processing what is a cash advance fee wells fargo how do credit card travel points work capital one credit card address cheapest credit card machines for small business petro canada gas credit card can you buy prepaid credit cards at shoppers drug mart best iphone credit card machine credit card payments on android hdfc credit card rewards catalogue platinum chase credit card compare apply for a credit card online with bad credit apply free visa credit card online credit card settlement process in dubai how long does it take to get credit card once approved best credit card processing app for ipad highest credit card limit possible apply for student loans with bad credit us bank credit card payment processing how to get a us credit card for non-residents how many credit cards for good credit apply online icici credit card india can you apply for an ikea credit card in store master credit card india arco gas credit card fee apple your credit card was declined santander 123 credit card cash back list capital one credit cards no foreign transaction fees new york and company credit card payment site top 10 mastercard credit cards canada cash back offer credit cards india best airline rewards credit cards 2013 orchard bank secured credit card visa virtual credit cards free credit card processing charges uk balance transfer credit cards for fair credit ez payday advance olathe ks compare travel rewards credit cards in canada platinum card american express limit best credit card to get for first timers long term loan bad credit no guarantor best buy credit cards contact us best delta skymiles credit card online loan lenders rbc best visa card compare canadian visa credit cards best buy reward zone credit card login best credit card reward offers 2013 cash advance ukiah ca zurich credit card insurance best credit cards for building credit 2012 american express credit card fees for merchants bank of america alaska airlines credit card business best business credit card for travel rewards guaranteed payday loans direct lenders how much money to get a black credit card how to apply secured credit card in bpi secured credit card canada compare secured short term loans online nab low rate credit card interest rate which credit card bad credit car finance what is the best credit card to get for travel rewards bank rakyat credit card application form how to choose a credit card uk best chase business credit card how to get past credit card verification 3 biggest credit card companies best credit card to have in singapore top 10 best secured credit cards visa credit card for bad credit unsecured why do i need a credit card for free apps on itunes intuit gopayment credit card terminal app credit score to apply for sears credit card cash advance fee halifax credit card consolidate credit card and student loan debt bdo credit card application form westpac online loan calculator royal bank of canada credit card fees list unsecured credit cards bad credit student credit card bad credit history using us credit cards in canada best small business credit card 2012 canada equifax credit score best reward credit card canada 2012 can you apply for a credit card online best buy credit card activation payday lenders uk 2012 nurit 8000 wireless credit card machine walmart mastercard review leather credit card holder ebay how to get verified on paypal without a bank account or credit card accept credit cards online australia disney chase credit card rewards rbc visa cards comparison is it possible to get a credit card with bad credit australia delta credit card canada how to change credit card on ebay for buyers corporate credit card policy guidelines citi travel rewards credit cards marriott credit card authorization form fairfield inn discover credit cards compare simmons first visa platinum credit cards capital one zero interest credit card discover cash back rewards credit cards citibank balance transfer credit card secured credit card banks credit card number location discover best buy rewards visa card bank of america secured credit card visa macally secured credit card terminal for iphone and ipod touch standard chartered credit card bank statement worldpay test credit card numbers secured orchard credit card credit card companies with uk call centre types of orchard bank credit cards capital one small business credit card online credit card processing companies abn amro credit card apply online in india sbi credit card helpline number bangalore free credit card advice does best buy accept visa debit cards online paypal merchant credit card fees credit report bad credit car finance essex aspire credit card contact number which credit card has the best rewards system using us credit cards in uk barclays credit card ppi complaints payday loans for bad credit apply for credit card online hsbc smartphone credit card terminal how do i get a credit card if i have a bad credit rating wells fargo debit visa card balance no fee prepaid reloadable credit card secured major credit cards how to get the best credit card rate axis bank credit card apply phone number free prepaid business credit cards phone number for chase business credit cards apply credit card online malaysia payment address for bank of america credit cards hsbc gold credit card minimum payment apply for a credit card with a 5000 dollar limit fnb online loan application prepaid credit cards visa numbers amazon uk credit card security jc penny credit card find pre approved credit cards offers free visa card numbers 2013 canada 21 month no interest credit card where to buy prepaid credit cards uk loans with bad credit no guarantor credit card for students with no income how do i sign up for a credit card with no credit cibc aeroplan credit card travel insurance get a credit card with bad credit score credit card company mastercard uk management services ltd best cashback credit card 2012 singapore credit card services lower interest rate calls walmart discover credit card login page prepaid credit card reviews canada good credit and credit cards best business visa card australia hsbc classic credit card online application chinatrust visa cash card enrollment form hypercom wireless credit card terminal if i apply for a walmart credit card can i use it today barclays us credit card shell gas credit card offers amazon credit card points not showing up quick online payday loans south africa what if i dont pay advance america best free credit card with no foreign transaction fee visa debit gift card commonwealth bank petrol cashback credit card malaysia what to wear with a gold cardigan courtyard marriott credit card authorization form how do i set up a credit card merchant account no fee credit card transfer balances starting a new credit card company us prepaid credit card paypal sample visa credit card number philippines credit card payment protection refund credit card points rewards comparison park hyatt credit card authorization form buy virtual credit cards with paypal marathon gas credit card how to calculate credit card interest per month best credit cards in canada 2012 interest free credit cards halifax td canada trust premium credit cards chase low credit credit cards where to send old navy credit card payments canada credit card promotions interest free balance transfer credit cards canada airline credit card reviews 2013 0 balance transfer credit cards ireland instant cash payday loans south africa how to get easy credit card approval credit card applications online in india should i apply for paypal credit card credit card types in icici amex black card points i want to apply for a maurices credit card prepaid credit cards uk online pay monthly loans unemployed compare air miles credit cards natwest credit card payment protection anz platinum card travel insurance terms and conditions how to load paper in verifone credit card machine credit card processing application wireless credit card terminal malaysia td visa toronto lost card hdfc credit card emi interest calculator apply for discover credit card student free gas reward cards wells fargo credit card approval odds compare low interest credit cards australia southwest credit card free flight offer royalty free credit card logos credit card comparison australia rewards how to pay your credit card bill online cibc zurich credit card insurance reviews best store credit cards to build credit hsbc credit card application pinoyexchange best business credit cards for gas direct payday loan lenders online prepaid credit cards free best place for a college student to get a credit card chase best buy credit card application online payday loans direct lenders no teletrack balance transfer barclaycard free air mile credit cards low interest credit cards balance transfer canada virtual credit card prepaid paypal shell credit card uk citi can online payday lenders sue apply for barclays credit card online how to offer credit card settlement of debt legit cash advances online aqua credit card cash withdrawal limit free real visa credit card numbers best credit cards for bad credit rating discount payday advance loans plus size black cardigan wells fargo virtual credit card number fast payday loans 24/7 visa card application pdf instant response credit cards canada cash back no fee credit cards personal loans with bad credit online free fico score no credit card check the status of a chase credit card application sbi irctc credit card online payment wells fargo credit card payment plan chase credit card minimum payment interest chase credit cards for no credit history credit card comparison chart malaysia compare all credit cards canada sbi credit card interest charges unsecured credit cards for bad credit no credit check high interest credit cards for bad credit canada sbi credit card personal loan western union gold card points uk how do i pay my maurices credit card buy international visa gift card online guaranteed payday loan lenders uk citi aadvantage credit card review payday lenders direct bad credit best visa credit card canada no annual fee when will my capital one credit limit increase apply online credit card hdfc bank how to apply for a credit card if i have no credit business credit card natwest interest free credit cards hsbc payday loan direct lender no credit check uk how do banks work out interest on credit cards best credit card approval rates best buy credit card no interest prepaid credit card uk free credit card machines for small business best rates bank of america credit card fraud protection phone number instant payday loan no credit check what prepaid credit cards work online credit cards bad credit history instant decision uk online payday loan lenders only 0 balance transfer credit cards for average credit compare credit cards uk rewards credit card with no annual fee macy;s credit card cash advances citi american airlines credit card 40000 applying for chase credit cards square iphone credit card processing uk barclays black card credit limit marriott credit card promotions uk i need a credit card today with bad credit credit card uk call centre cara bayar credit card bank mega canadian credit cards rewards comparison no credit loans uk cash back credit card canada best portable credit card machines easy credit card approval bad credit australia capital one small business credit card rewards cash back rewards credit cards 2012 free credit cards weebly pay a walmart credit card payment how to pay off my credit card debt fast sign up for bank of america student credit card credit card companies uk fake visa credit card numbers that work cash loans for bad credit direct lender credit card uk what about prepaid travel credit cards and overseas atms best value credit card rewards australia us bank credit card balance transfer fee 0 balance transfer credit union credit cards icici credit card apply online in india should i close low limit credit cards ulster bank credit card numbers unsecured credit cards instant approval bad credit td canada trust visa debit verified by visa direct auto loan lenders bad credit free credit card reader paypal bank of america visa rewards card login pay off credit card debt or car loan first credit card interest calculator air miles rewards cards applications discover credit card accepted uk average merchant credit card transaction fees where to buy credit card gift cards in canada how to redeem hdfc credit card points for titanium card loans for bad credit without guarantor usaa american express credit card login should you pay off high interest credit cards first capital one small business credit card reviews what are the different types of credit cards available best international travel credit card anz credit card travel insurance claim fake credit card number security code and expiration date loans for bad credit direct lenders make free virtual credit cards apply for barclaycard platinum credit card how does credit card payment processing work starbucks gold card uk cibc credit card balance phone number fast cash loans online credit card no credit check canada how to redeem your icici credit card points credit card scanner for android prepaid reloadable credit cards walmart best buy canada credit card apply citibank credit card types india american express black card alternatives capital one credit cards no international fee gift visa card amazon rewards 660 visa card application capital one balance transfer fee orchard bank credit card for bad credit british airways airmiles credit card uk best credit cards to rebuild credit after bankruptcy chase secured credit card usa rebuild credit cards no annual fee cibc credit card services contact us hdfc credit card application status by reference number secured credit card bad credit canada personal bad credit loans online does colorado dmv accept credit cards hdfc credit cards payment gateway sbi credit card status checking small online loans uk first premier bank credit card login page payday loan online no faxing credit check credit card payment machine rental pay first premier credit card bill credit card apps for windows mobile list of payday lenders uk how can i apply for a orchard bank credit card square iphone credit card service tesco credit card app can you get cash from a walmart visa gift card credit card offer letter sample iphone 5 credit card charger credit card fees explained pnb credit card application form free download african bank credit card limit increase online credit card swipe app for windows phone best place to get online loan easiest credit card to get with bad credit australia credit card number and cvv and expiration date business cash advance uk pay advance tax online pnb how to apply for a credit card in hdfc real free credit card numbers 2012 what can i do about unauthorized credit card charges capital one credit card settlement 2012 online visa card generator how to get a personal loan with bad credit australia fidelity 2 cash back credit card is horizon gold credit card real axis bank credit card payment hsbc costco credit card login do you need a credit card for itunes apps citi corporate credit card customer care free online visa card numbers bank of america secured credit card upgrade credit cards for bad credit no processing fee post office platinum card credit limit prepaid visa credit cards canadian reloadable credit cards is it worth getting a loan to pay off credit cards chase best buy credit card customer service hacked visa credit card numbers 2013 how to improve credit rating chase freedom visa credit card phone number unsecured credit cards for bad credit canada procedure to pay advance tax online interest free credit card transfer balance how to redeem hdfc world credit card reward points hsbc 0 credit card offers pc richard credit card customer service phone number credit card for bad credit instant decision cash loans for bad credit rating apply for personal loan with bad credit how can i track my icici credit card application status hsbc credit cards online payment compare business credit cards take credit card payments online without merchant account marriott rewards signature credit card login rbs black credit card travel insurance lost tesco credit card online tesco finance online credit card sbi credit card helpline chennai unsecured credit cards no credit check credit cards 0 finance offers guarantor loans online uk credit card debt relief canada government program icici credit card settlement letter format best low rate credit card shell master credit card login easy online payday loans how to get a business loan with bad credit and no collateral transfer credit card balance to low interest loan 0 percent interest free credit card how to negotiate with credit card companies to payoff wells fargo visa platinum credit card rewards do you need a credit card for paypal on ebay credit card offers 0 purchases apply for capital 1 credit card best corporate credit card singapore toys r us rewards credit card login call sears credit card services is chase credit card a visa or mastercard usa credit card non resident samsung offers for icici credit cards usaa credit card cash advance limit walmart mastercard credit card best intro apr credit card citibank platinum credit card india us bank chip and pin credit card capital one credit limit increase steps value city credit card
Home Pete Toms LWIB: MLB, MLBPA Continue to Dance Over Collusion

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 474 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: MLB, MLBPA Continue to Dance Over Collusion PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 16
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Sunday, 15 November 2009 20:57

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in LWIB, the longstanding mistrust between MLB and the MLBPA over “collusion” surfaces again.

LWIB, the incoming executive director of the MLBPA Michael Weiner, chose to make some timely and very high profile comments suggesting that the MLB owners are conspiring to “depress” compensation for this off season’s crop of free agents. Is the next battle in the quarter century war over “collusion” in MLB about to waged? Jerry Crasnick reported for ESPN

Although Weiner declined to use the word "collusion," his comments hint at an orchestrated effort by club officials and are the latest salvo in a tug-of-war between players and teams that was heightened during a slow-developing free-agent market last winter.

"I don't think it's an accident that in recent weeks, management officials, without attribution, have been making predictions about what's going to happen in this year's free-agent market," Weiner said. "There have been predictions about the [money] players will get, what players will be offered [salary] arbitration and what players will be non-tendered [contracts].

"If we could prove there was a plan by management to use the press to try to depress free-agent salaries, in our view that would be a violation of our contract," he said.

Those remarks concerning a possible concerted effort amongst the owners to limit the compensation awarded free agents this off season were not the first that Mr. Weiner has made in the press on the subject. During the World Series, Nick Cafardo of The Boston Globe published similar remarks from Mr. Weiner. Mr. Cafardo characterized Mr. Weiner’s stance on the matter;

Incoming Players Association executive director Michael Weiner said the union will closely monitor offseason transactions to see whether collusion among teams to hold down free agent signings is alive, as several established players settled for short-term deals last offseason.

Mr. Weiner will officially succeed outgoing MLBPA executve director Donald Fehr next month. The timing of Mr. Weiner’s public remarks is likely not coincidental. There have been a series of media reports that many player agents have been pressuring the MLBPA since last off season to file a collusion grievance against the owners. The Associated Press reported in July;

As Michael Weiner prepares to take over from Donald Fehr as head of the players' association, several agents said they are pushing the union to file a collusion grievance against teams over their behavior during the free-agent market last winter.


The decision on whether to go ahead with a grievance will be one of the first major decisions for the players' association since Fehr announced his pending retirement last month and its executive board recommended Weiner, the union's general counsel, for the top job.

When the subject of “collusion” in MLB is raised, it is most often associated with the era of the mid 80’s, ending in a 1990 settlement which awarded the players $280 million. The labour peace in MLB of the last 15 years has perhaps left the impression that “collusion” is a relic of that previous era of fractious labour relations. But suspicions and allegations of “collusion” by the MLBPA have been a staple of labour relations throughout this decade. In fact, a collusion settlement was negotiated in the last round of CBA negotiations. Sports Law Professor Marc Edelman published a paper in 2008, “Moving Past Collusion in Major League Baseball: Healing Old Wounds and Preventing New Ones" - PDF.

Coming on the heels of Baseball’s new and promising collective bargaining agreement, the 2002-03 off-season brought the first new allegations of collusion in Baseball since 1988-89. These new allegations claimed that, much like in 1987-88, MLB club-owners again concertedly submitted identical bids for certain free agent players.

Although the MLBPA never made any of its evidence publicly available, independent information compiled from newspaper reports seems to indicate that certain players were receiving identical bids from multiple teams. Although the 2002-03 off-seasons did not seem to produce any “smoking gun” invitation to collude, there were plenty of troublesome statements-such as those made by owners and staff of the Atlanta Braves, Boston Red Sox, Los Angeles Dodgers, and New York Mets about the need to reduce payroll throughout the league. In addition, Commissioner Selig suggested the need for payrolls to fall throughout Baseball.

Ultimately, on October 24, 2006, in conjunction with signing Baseball’s current Basic Agreement, MLB club-owners settled the Collusion IV grievances by paying $12 million in damages to the MLBPA. The parties reached this settlement without an arbitration hearing. Therefore, unlike in Collusion I, II, & III, Collusion IV produced no formal finding of fault.

(Editors note: Also see Collusion I, II, and III (a hard lesson learned) from Rob Neyer's Big Book of Baseball Blunders)

Select Read More to see the rest of the latest Last Week in Bizball

The 2007-08 off season saw the MLBPA accuse the owners of colluding against free agent Barry Bonds, who did not receive a single contract offer after posting an OPS of 1.045 in his last season. The aforementioned Marc Edelman wrote at The Sports Law Blog in July:

With respect to the game's newest collusion allegations, concern of such behavior first surfaced during the 2007-08 off-season when Bonds's agent Jeff Borris announced that he believed the reason why Bonds did not have a single contract offer was collusion. After reviewing the available evidence, the MLBPA announced in October 2008 that it had made a preliminary finding of collusion. However, rather than file a traditional labor grievance against the MLB club-owners, the union instead attempted to resolve the matter through private negotiation.

Last month, Ronald Blum reported for The Associated Press that the allegations over “Bonds” remain unresolved.

….players and owners have had an agreement since last year extending the deadline to file a collusion grievance over the lack of offers to Barry Bonds after the 2007 season. That deal says the union has until after the end of Bonds' criminal trial to file a grievance.

In the aforementioned blog entry from Professor Edelman, he notes that the MLBPA might be motivated to file a collusion grievance over “Bonds” in order to protect themselves from their own (former) union member.

While the MLBPA has broad discretion to determine when, if at all, to file a formal collusion grievance, like any union, it is bound by its duty of fair representation. This means that the MLBPA cannot act in an arbitrary, discriminatory, or bad-faith manner against any of its members. Union membership includes even those who have opted out of joint licensing programs, such as Barry Bonds.

Refusing to file a collusion grievance, even after reaching a informal finding of wrongdoing, might place the MLBPA at some risk of facing a claim from Bonds for breach of the duty of fair representation. This risk, in essence, might eventually pressure the MLBPA to file a collusion grievance, presuming their talks with the MLB club-owners do not reduce union concerns of wrongdoing. For these reasons, I fully expect the MLBPA to begin more aggressively addressing these recent concerns of collusion.

Allegations of “collusion” in last off season’s free agent market also remain unresolved. From the aforementioned report last month from Ronald Blum:

Players and owners have agreed to push back the deadline for a collusion grievance over last winter's free agents until the end of this offseason.

Agents for players have been asking the union for several months to file a grievance.

"It preserves the players' claims, and the commissioner's office hasn't admitted any wrongdoing," union general counsel Michael Weiner said Tuesday. "I would characterize this as a standstill agreement."

The relatively “soft” free agent market of last off season was widely attributed to the clubs’ uncertainty over their projected revenues for 2009 and beyond. However, player agents making accusations of “collusion” argue that this trend is more established, that free agents have met diminished demand since the 2006-07 off season. As for last off season, some player agents are suspicious that not all of what transpired in the free agent market can be explained by owners’ concerns about the economy. Jerry Crasnick wrote in his aforementioned piece of last week, “Numerous agents complained privately about players receiving the exact same offer from several clubs, prompting the union to consider filing a collusion grievance.” And from the aforementioned Associated Press report from July:

"There are too many things that need to be explained," said Seth Levinson, who represented nearly a dozen free agents following the 2008 season. "In my experience, there are no coincidences in a monopoly."

This off season, owners’ concerns about the future financial prospects of their franchises might meet with increased scepticism. Despite legitimate fears over the impact the recession would have on the 2009 season, in the end, industry revenues were flat. (According to MLB COO Bob DuPuy) Recently, Fitch Ratings released a positive report on the state of MLB and The Sports Business Journal reported that MLB will soon renew it’s “credit facility” after failing to do so at the same point last year. If the diminished demand for free agents continues this off season, will the “it’s the economy, stupid” argument be viewed as credibly as it was last off season?

Adam Rubin of the New York Daily News, reported LWIB on comments made by player agent Scott Boras during the General Manager’s meetings in Chicago

Boras chastised owners of some teams for pocketing revenue distributed through MLB that the agent labeled at $80 million per club. He accused the owners of financing the purchases of their teams by pocketing that money rather than investing it in players. He also suggested MLB is rolling in cash, even if teams are crying poverty.

"I would say, based upon their 'bad economy' forecasts from last year, I would not invest in their stock choices," Boras said.

If the owners are, or have been in recent years, colluding to control salaries for free agents, will their conspiracy be more difficult to prove than was the case in the late 1980’s?  David Pinto reacted to Michael Weiner’s recent comments:

It strikes me that MLB has learned to walk the fine line between compliance with the CBA and collusion. Weiner is trying to trying to knock them off the line, but he’s going to have a tough job of doing so. I don’t think anyone is going to leave the smoking gun statement that Peter Ueberroth did in the 1980s.

The “smoking gun statement” that Mr. Pinto refers to is then commissioner Ueberroth’s private address to the owners in October of 1985. In his book “May the Best Team Win, Baseball

Economics and Public Policy”, author Andrew Zimbalist wrote that during that owners meeting, the commissioner “reportedly scolded them for overspending on mediocre free agents.” During that same meeting, Mr. Zimbalist wrote that:

Lee MacPhail, director of the owners’ Players Relations Committee, delivered a speech arguing that players with contracts of three years and more spent nearly 50 percent more time on the disabled list than those with one-year contracts and that the average player with a three-year contract or more experienced a nearly twenty-point decline in his batting average after signing the contract.

The ultimately failed attempts of the owners to “collude” in the mid 1980’s also included, at one point, a very structured and formal approach. In his comprehensive retrospective on the history of MLB labour relations from the formation of the MLBPA in 1965 to the strike of 1994, John Helyar wrote in “Lords of the Realm”;

It was called the Information Bank, and it was simplicity itself. A club making an offer to a free agent reported it to the PRC. That was called an information “deposit”. A club wanting to know what others bid for a free agent could call the PRC and make an information “withdrawal.”

The idea was to stimulate the market enough to blunt charges of collusion, while at the same time keeping a rein on the market. The signal was clear: Okay, guys, you can bid now. But don’t top the other guy’s offer by much.”

As Mr. Pinto alluded to, if there is a collective approach within MLB to controlling free agent compensation, the approach is more subtle than that used in the 1980s. Last November, former Federal Reserve chairman Paul Volker (former “Blue Ribbon” panel member also) addressed a meeting of the MLB owners to discuss the state of the economy. At the time, Barry Bloom reported for, “Selig declined to elaborate on Volcker's remarks, but he said a message had obviously been sent to the owners.” The absence of offers to free agent Barry Bonds was not the only development during the 2007 off season to cause consternation amongst the players side. Again from Marc Edelman’s aforementioned paper, “Moving Past Collusion in Major League Baseball: Healing Old Wounds and Preventing New Ones."

…Selig allowed MLB clubs’ general managers to meet with one another and discuss their 2007 off-season rosters plans by openly stating what players they were making available for trade. This marked a substantial change from the past practice at General Manager Meetings.

The idea of club general managers openly discussing personnel plans was first suggested by General Manager Meetings co-chais Theo Epstein and Larry Bienfest as a way to create more dialogue and stimulate trades. The MLB clubs, however, never informed the MLBPA in advance about these activities, nor was the MLBPA invited to send counsel to police them.

Record industry revenues have resulted in extended labour peace in MLB. If the next CBA (the current one expires in December 2011) can be negotiated without labour interruption, commissioner Selig might rightfully claim that improved labour relations is his greatest legacy.

However, with unresolved allegations of “collusion” the past two off-seasons, and a strong likelihood of another this off season, there is potential for a return to more divisive relations. Mistrust between the two sides arising from the collusion settlements of the 1980s has never subsided. Outgoing MLBPA executive director Donald Fehr (who will remain one of the most important participants in the next CBA negotiations) is believed to still harbour bitter resentment toward commissioner Selig over the collusion wars of the 1980s. Mr. Fehr’s successor, Mr. Weiner, is also a veteran of the collusion era, joining the MLBPA in 1988. Mr. Fehr and Mr. Weiner will never forget that arbitrator George Nicolau (one of two arbitrators to rule in favour of the MLBPA in the 80s collusion cases) identified commissioner Selig (then Milwaukee Brewers owner) as one of the most active owners in their attempts to manipulate the free agent market. Former commissioner Fay Vincent described commissioner Selig as one of the “ringleaders” of collusion. Commissioner Selig has never admitted to playing a role in the “collusion” of the 1980s and many owners and club officials of that era (including Mr. Ueberroth) have never been convinced that their activities were anything other than an attempt to operate MLB in a fiscally responsible manner.

At the same time, heading into his first CBA negotiation as executive director, Mr. Weiner needs to prove to the players and their agents that he will be as formidable a leader as his predecessor. As well, there is a growing constituency of veteran players in the MLBPA who have been openly critical of the diminished opportunities they meet in the free agent market while “rookie compensation” is escalating.

Whether there is or is not collusion in MLB, the issue is once again a point of contention in labour relations. And the history of labour relations in MLB informs us that if there is an issue capable of wrecking labour peace it is collusion.






Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?