business credit limit calculator australian average credit card debt can you use ann taylor credit card loft alaska airlines credit card through bank of america consolidating credit card debt with personal loan bmo prepaid credit card review instant cash loans for the unemployed bad credit car leasing no deposit southwest business credit card 50 000 credit card offers $500 cash back credit card debt consolidation wells fargo are credit card rewards taxable rbs credit cards online india can;t pay sallie mae loans compare best small business credit card best low interest credit cards for balance transfers blank automatic credit card billing authorization form applied bank?î secured visa?î gold credit card disputing credit card charges american express how to apply for apple id without credit card rbs student credit card cash withdrawal best credit cards for airline rewards 2013 online credit card validator javascript should i pay off credit card debt or save want to apply for credit cards in india american express platinum credit card wiki verified by visa for axis bank credit cards student credit cards instant approval apply for credit card with no credit visa top 10 uk credit card companies nedbank platinum card requirements how to get a refund from a credit card transaction paypal virtual credit card plugin first premier bank secured credit card reviews new payday lenders 2013 gold plated credit card holder do visa debit cards work in europe prepaid credit card reviews canada store credit cards and bad credit bank of america credit card settlement offer company issued credit cards policy barclay credit card apple login apple update credit card details are cash reward credit cards worth it how do i get credit card logos for my website visa credit card fraud insurance i want to apply for a sears credit card online real credit card numbers generator best credit cards uk sams discover credit card login 2012 best mobile credit card processing compare credit cards india reviews 10 best credit cards to have credit cards for bad credit no credit check canada apply for barclays credit card online india average credit card limit good credit credit card apply now online axis bank easy credit card apply microsoft excel credit card payment calculator unsecured credit cards for rebuilding your credit capital one credit card settlement 2012 what does cashback on credit cards mean sbi credit card online payment options list of online payday lenders next payday advance reviews zero percent interest credit cards for 24 months american express premier rewards gold card credit score chase get cash advance credit card can i increase my absa credit card limit online compare business credit cards chase credit card for college students white hills cash payday loans number international credit card merchant account credit card bank of america lost hdfc credit card interest rate for cash withdrawal fund virtual credit card paypal best visa card rewards pc richards ge credit card payment babies r us credit card number visa card uk customer services ace payday loans lord and taylor credit card contact info where to file credit card company complaints sears mastercard solutions manual credit card machine canada hdfc credit card credit card payment hdfc credit card customer care number surat credit card low interest rates southwest rapid rewards credit card 50000 download ocbc credit card application form mbna canada credit card balance free mobile credit card processing android car loan with bad credit and no cosigner top canadian credit card rewards how does gnc gold card work how do i get a portable credit card machine can i get a capital one credit card with bad credit ge capital toys r us credit card payment address best credit cards to have in usa gap visa credit card services jetstar mastercard credit card login credit card fraud prison sentence uk bank of america credit card 0 interest balance transfer credit card instant approval fair credit how to get credit card details off ps3 what is the best credit card for rewards online loan uk store photos of credit cards on iphone halifax bank student credit card absa credit card limit increase contact number free ways to accept credit cards online does american express gold card improve credit history prepaid credit cards no fees no monthly fees cara bayar credit card bank mega 05 balance transfer credit cards money magazine credit card ratings 2012 halifax credit card contact centre no fee td visa cards hdfc corporate credit cards india sbi credit card customer care number in noida free credit check no credit card required uk where can i apply for a credit card with poor credit credit card online payment system pay as you go credit card visa canada citi corporate credit card customer care best virtual credit card usa as seen on tv credit card protector citibank credit card online application india navy federal credit union credit cards review 0 balance transfer credit cards for bad credit rating virgin credit card balance transfer offers loan with bad credit and no job how do i know which credit card is best for me capital one credit card customer service phone number what is a secured credit card to rebuild credit how to get emi in hdfc credit card credit cards with low apr rates disney credit card payment login personal online loans with installment what are the benefits and disadvantages to the small business of accepting credit cards installment loans online approval new payday lenders not brokers no teletrack payday loans direct lenders 100 approval paypal virtual terminal credit card fees best starwood credit card deal canada credit card rewards best offer hdfc bank credit card flight booking how long does it take to get a refund on your credit card axis bank credit card reward points barclays credit card approval standard chartered credit card india student credit cards no credit history store credit cards that are easy to get approved for apple support change credit card what happens when a credit card company sues you hsbc credit card cash advance fee best td visa card canadian credit card companies that use transunion capital one balance transfer how to get a bad credit loan personal loan best credit cards in canada 2012 online loan lenders uk canada best credit card rewards td green visa card grace period credit card machines for iphone 4 go ge capital credit card payment chase apply credit card tesco credit card bank transfer compare credit card offers 2013 how can i take credit card payments over the phone hdfc bank credit card helpline no kolkata santander 123 credit card instant decision no credit check credit cards for students rfid credit card protector zero percent interest credit cards td canada trust visa infinite credit card finder by score bank of america credit card protection claim miles and more credit card uk review can i get a credit card after bankruptcy do you have to be 21 to get a credit card now top 10 best student credit cards international credit card services abn new payday lenders no credit check capital one credit card 0 apr credit card charge approval form what is the best credit card for me how to get a credit card if you have bad credit in canada how do you calculate interest paid on a credit card all 3 credit scores for free no credit card sbi credit card customer care number in gurgaon top 5 most popular credit cards mbna canada credit card application bank of america prepaid credit card reward credit card review canada reviews capital one credit cards canada credit card interest rate comparison calculator free usa virtual credit card irs credit limit worksheet 2009 best credit card promotions september 2013 bad credit credit cards usa best credit card approval rates hdfc bank credit cards redeem reward points credit cards no annual fee low interest rate credit cards with no annual fee and no apr online application for credit card bpi disney chase credit card application status prepaid credit cards to help rebuild credit accept credit cards online canada are travel rewards cards worth it late on best buy credit card payment american express platinum card travel credit card bank of america payment cash advance rate american express citi vs discover student credit cards close credit card account credit score best credit card jpmorgan chase student credit card apply for lane bryant credit card international credit card services nederland 3d secure credit card validation mastercard citibank credit card singapore payday advance online bad credit sears ca credit cards login teachers federal credit union secured credit cards prepaid visa credit cards india federal law credit card minimum payment can credit card companies garnish your wages in florida credit card with no credit history capital one top 10 zero interest credit cards does applying for credit cards hurt credit score bank of america business credit card limit standard bank british airways credit card mastercard careers london virgin credit cards online banking virtual credit card terminal ireland merchant cash advance loans bank of america credit cards rewards program best no foreign transaction fee credit cards 2013 payday lenders not brokers high acceptance hdfc credit cards customer care number online application for credit card in bank of india bank of america amazon credit card application payday loan online no teletrack direct lender hdfc credit card domestic flight offer 2013 reloadable prepaid canadian credit cards titanium hdfc credit card limit best credit card reward system sbi credit card charges us bank credit card login corporate barclays credit card contact number credit card debt relief reviews natwest black credit card terms and conditions first premier bank credit card login page td canada trust visa gold does chase bank offer a secured credit card easier get credit card credit union payday loans online same day south africa really bad credit credit cards credit card 0 interest no balance transfer fee what credit card is best for me quiz what is the easiest credit card to get intuit iphone credit card app fnb online loan application i need a secured credit card with bad credit bank of america travel credit card how to get free real credit card numbers discover credit card student loan calculate credit card interest rate payment hdfc credit card limit information get easy credit card uk instant use credit card bad credit hdfc international credit card quick online loans today visa cards start with what digits bpi credit card online application requirements 2 cash back credit card no annual fee business credit card offers paying off credit card debt faster credit card for no credit history capital one new payday loan lenders 2012 capital credit card services chelsea al what credit cards can i apply for online are credit card balance transfers bad for your credit orchard bank secured credit card limit chase credit card services payment address secured mastercard credit card canada pay us bank credit card bill compare credit cards travel credit card fraud for dummies watch online best joint credit card offers hsbc visa gold credit card credit cards no credit check unsecured best rate credit cards 2012 credit cards visa mastercard uk payday loans with bad credit best us airways credit card offer 2013 fnb gold credit card design capital one small business credit card best credit cards for college students uk how to use fake credit card information uk credit card association how to calculate total interest paid on credit card i need a credit card today with bad credit top credit card processing standard chartered credit card login india payday lenders online capital one visa card application list of major credit cards companies how to pay hdfc credit card bill payment online from other bank obama credit card debt relief 2010 largest credit card issuers in the us 12 months interest free credit card australia i have bad credit and want to get a credit card cheap interest payday loans online mastercard credit card number example top credit card processing providers corporate credit cards for employees use hdfc reward points platinum credit cards how does walmart credit card cash back work apply credit cards india best online payday advance reviews credit union uk hsbc online credit cards australia best united mileage plus credit card offer online payday loans instant approval uk how do credit card machines work best interest free credit cards uk southwest airlines rapid rewards credit card chase review travel rewards credit cards australia update apple id without credit card credit card debt help government all unsecured credit cards for bad credit citibank credit card travel insurance hong kong best deals credit cards canada top ten credit cards to have walmart store card credit score first credit card company in 1950 small business reduce credit card fees corporate business credit cards without personal guarantee ana mileage credit card usa how long does it take to get credit card refund credit card for no credit rating new credit card apply online india should i use my tesco credit card abroad hsbc credit card online payment from icici bank hdfc credit card toll free number mumbai instant cash loans no upfront fees current average credit card interest rate secured citibank credit cards small business accepting credit cards disadvantages best credit card travel rewards program 2011 apply for a barclay credit card online india hdfc credit card help desk chennai is bank of america secured credit card good air canada credit card offers hdfc credit card toll free number best credit card for bad credit 2013 credit cards for bad credit no deposit instant approval uk credit card reader for android phone reviews i want to apply for a orchard bank credit card chase visa card security code business cash advance loans reviews credit cards for fair credit uk online loan application at african bank standard chartered credit card online payment india sampath credit card promotions sri lanka american express platinum card benefits uk apply for credit card hsbc bank 0 balance transfer credit cards uk applying for credit cards with no credit history storing credit card information law canada free prepaid credit card online standard chartered credit card offers on dining natwest online loans how long merchant credit card fees explained tesco credit card ppi claims national city credit card pnc best credit cards for college students with no income how to best use a credit card to build credit free government credit card debt relief department of education pay loans online php secure credit card storage top 5 credit card issuers uk interest free credit cards bad credit rating united airlines credit card offers 2013 first premier bank credit card login who has the lowest credit card rates can you use a business credit card for personal easy online payday loans no credit check best credit card offer september 2013 master credit card number generator credit card logos for website comparison of reward programs for credit cards hdfc titanium international credit card review average credit card debt uk 2011 chase increase credit limit without hard pull bankamericard platinum plus visa secured credit card chase credit card no interest for a year lufthansa miles and more credit card online-kartenkonto how to redeem hdfc world credit card reward points td canada trust business credit cards balance transfer cards with no fee capital one credit cards visa signature american express credit cards wikipedia platinum cardcaptor sakura download instant credit card approval bad credit no deposit cibc visa credit card balance household credit card login page can i buy costco cash card with visa merchant credit card fees uk icici credit card annual charges maestro credit card number format ge money bank credit card contact information walmart credit cards pay bill pay off credit card debt or car loan first best pay day loans direct lenders mobile credit card processing iphone how long for best buy credit card approval compare best canadian credit cards airline credit card promotions free tickets bank of america credit card offers for students free credit check average credit credit cards instant approval credit card limit increase without permission sbi credit card loan online hdfc credit card offers secured vs unsecured credit card balance transfer 0 interest free credit cards on balance transfers american airlines credit card offers american express apply for visa debit card bank of ireland virtual credit card prepaid total merchant services credit card processing reviews largest credit card banks compare travel credit cards canada best cashback credit cards for gas and groceries amazon uk credit card credit card machines uk same day quick cash loans how to apply for a credit card at target credit score needed for valero gas card how can i get approved for a credit card with no credit how do i apply for a visa credit card online toys r us gold card points credit card interest rate calculator monthly payment best way to accept credit card payments on iphone online cash advance loans magento storing credit card information apply for a sears mastercard online how to get an international prepaid credit card 90 day payday loans no credit check australia best travel reward credit card 2011 capital one balance transfer payee account number no credit credit cards chase aqua credit card limit starting fake credit card information for websites credit card with bad credit rating australia union bank online application for credit card sears gold mastercard credit card login bpi credit card application status online standard chartered credit card malaysia review how to upgrade hdfc credit card limit easy credit card application accept credit cards over the phone free is a prepaid credit card a good idea lowest credit card rates australia splunk credit card search pay ikea credit card usa lane bryant credit card approval rate buy virtual visa card online get a payday loan online direct lender axis bank new credit card apply can i get cash from a walmart visa gift card best visa credit card to use abroad secured vs unsecured credit card credit score credit card a best rewards credit cards 2014 top rated cash reward credit cards best cash back business credit cards 2012 facts about credit and credit cards manchester united credit card review credit cards for college students with fair credit what credit card can i get with bad credit and no bank account credit card terminal application citi government travel credit card best credit card advice sears credit card lower interest rate android credit card app uk chase prepaid business credit card partially secured credit card bank of america free yatra barclaycard platinum credit card bodog credit card verification form firestone credit card balance what credit card to get with bad credit amscot payday advance fees credit cards after chapter 7 bankruptcy same day payday loans online first time credit card no credit history best interest free credit card 2013
Home Pete Toms LWIB: MLB, MLBPA Continue to Dance Over Collusion

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 319 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: MLB, MLBPA Continue to Dance Over Collusion PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 16
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Sunday, 15 November 2009 20:57

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in LWIB, the longstanding mistrust between MLB and the MLBPA over “collusion” surfaces again.

LWIB, the incoming executive director of the MLBPA Michael Weiner, chose to make some timely and very high profile comments suggesting that the MLB owners are conspiring to “depress” compensation for this off season’s crop of free agents. Is the next battle in the quarter century war over “collusion” in MLB about to waged? Jerry Crasnick reported for ESPN

Although Weiner declined to use the word "collusion," his comments hint at an orchestrated effort by club officials and are the latest salvo in a tug-of-war between players and teams that was heightened during a slow-developing free-agent market last winter.

"I don't think it's an accident that in recent weeks, management officials, without attribution, have been making predictions about what's going to happen in this year's free-agent market," Weiner said. "There have been predictions about the [money] players will get, what players will be offered [salary] arbitration and what players will be non-tendered [contracts].

"If we could prove there was a plan by management to use the press to try to depress free-agent salaries, in our view that would be a violation of our contract," he said.

Those remarks concerning a possible concerted effort amongst the owners to limit the compensation awarded free agents this off season were not the first that Mr. Weiner has made in the press on the subject. During the World Series, Nick Cafardo of The Boston Globe published similar remarks from Mr. Weiner. Mr. Cafardo characterized Mr. Weiner’s stance on the matter;

Incoming Players Association executive director Michael Weiner said the union will closely monitor offseason transactions to see whether collusion among teams to hold down free agent signings is alive, as several established players settled for short-term deals last offseason.

Mr. Weiner will officially succeed outgoing MLBPA executve director Donald Fehr next month. The timing of Mr. Weiner’s public remarks is likely not coincidental. There have been a series of media reports that many player agents have been pressuring the MLBPA since last off season to file a collusion grievance against the owners. The Associated Press reported in July;

As Michael Weiner prepares to take over from Donald Fehr as head of the players' association, several agents said they are pushing the union to file a collusion grievance against teams over their behavior during the free-agent market last winter.


The decision on whether to go ahead with a grievance will be one of the first major decisions for the players' association since Fehr announced his pending retirement last month and its executive board recommended Weiner, the union's general counsel, for the top job.

When the subject of “collusion” in MLB is raised, it is most often associated with the era of the mid 80’s, ending in a 1990 settlement which awarded the players $280 million. The labour peace in MLB of the last 15 years has perhaps left the impression that “collusion” is a relic of that previous era of fractious labour relations. But suspicions and allegations of “collusion” by the MLBPA have been a staple of labour relations throughout this decade. In fact, a collusion settlement was negotiated in the last round of CBA negotiations. Sports Law Professor Marc Edelman published a paper in 2008, “Moving Past Collusion in Major League Baseball: Healing Old Wounds and Preventing New Ones" - PDF.

Coming on the heels of Baseball’s new and promising collective bargaining agreement, the 2002-03 off-season brought the first new allegations of collusion in Baseball since 1988-89. These new allegations claimed that, much like in 1987-88, MLB club-owners again concertedly submitted identical bids for certain free agent players.

Although the MLBPA never made any of its evidence publicly available, independent information compiled from newspaper reports seems to indicate that certain players were receiving identical bids from multiple teams. Although the 2002-03 off-seasons did not seem to produce any “smoking gun” invitation to collude, there were plenty of troublesome statements-such as those made by owners and staff of the Atlanta Braves, Boston Red Sox, Los Angeles Dodgers, and New York Mets about the need to reduce payroll throughout the league. In addition, Commissioner Selig suggested the need for payrolls to fall throughout Baseball.

Ultimately, on October 24, 2006, in conjunction with signing Baseball’s current Basic Agreement, MLB club-owners settled the Collusion IV grievances by paying $12 million in damages to the MLBPA. The parties reached this settlement without an arbitration hearing. Therefore, unlike in Collusion I, II, & III, Collusion IV produced no formal finding of fault.

(Editors note: Also see Collusion I, II, and III (a hard lesson learned) from Rob Neyer's Big Book of Baseball Blunders)

Select Read More to see the rest of the latest Last Week in Bizball

The 2007-08 off season saw the MLBPA accuse the owners of colluding against free agent Barry Bonds, who did not receive a single contract offer after posting an OPS of 1.045 in his last season. The aforementioned Marc Edelman wrote at The Sports Law Blog in July:

With respect to the game's newest collusion allegations, concern of such behavior first surfaced during the 2007-08 off-season when Bonds's agent Jeff Borris announced that he believed the reason why Bonds did not have a single contract offer was collusion. After reviewing the available evidence, the MLBPA announced in October 2008 that it had made a preliminary finding of collusion. However, rather than file a traditional labor grievance against the MLB club-owners, the union instead attempted to resolve the matter through private negotiation.

Last month, Ronald Blum reported for The Associated Press that the allegations over “Bonds” remain unresolved.

….players and owners have had an agreement since last year extending the deadline to file a collusion grievance over the lack of offers to Barry Bonds after the 2007 season. That deal says the union has until after the end of Bonds' criminal trial to file a grievance.

In the aforementioned blog entry from Professor Edelman, he notes that the MLBPA might be motivated to file a collusion grievance over “Bonds” in order to protect themselves from their own (former) union member.

While the MLBPA has broad discretion to determine when, if at all, to file a formal collusion grievance, like any union, it is bound by its duty of fair representation. This means that the MLBPA cannot act in an arbitrary, discriminatory, or bad-faith manner against any of its members. Union membership includes even those who have opted out of joint licensing programs, such as Barry Bonds.

Refusing to file a collusion grievance, even after reaching a informal finding of wrongdoing, might place the MLBPA at some risk of facing a claim from Bonds for breach of the duty of fair representation. This risk, in essence, might eventually pressure the MLBPA to file a collusion grievance, presuming their talks with the MLB club-owners do not reduce union concerns of wrongdoing. For these reasons, I fully expect the MLBPA to begin more aggressively addressing these recent concerns of collusion.

Allegations of “collusion” in last off season’s free agent market also remain unresolved. From the aforementioned report last month from Ronald Blum:

Players and owners have agreed to push back the deadline for a collusion grievance over last winter's free agents until the end of this offseason.

Agents for players have been asking the union for several months to file a grievance.

"It preserves the players' claims, and the commissioner's office hasn't admitted any wrongdoing," union general counsel Michael Weiner said Tuesday. "I would characterize this as a standstill agreement."

The relatively “soft” free agent market of last off season was widely attributed to the clubs’ uncertainty over their projected revenues for 2009 and beyond. However, player agents making accusations of “collusion” argue that this trend is more established, that free agents have met diminished demand since the 2006-07 off season. As for last off season, some player agents are suspicious that not all of what transpired in the free agent market can be explained by owners’ concerns about the economy. Jerry Crasnick wrote in his aforementioned piece of last week, “Numerous agents complained privately about players receiving the exact same offer from several clubs, prompting the union to consider filing a collusion grievance.” And from the aforementioned Associated Press report from July:

"There are too many things that need to be explained," said Seth Levinson, who represented nearly a dozen free agents following the 2008 season. "In my experience, there are no coincidences in a monopoly."

This off season, owners’ concerns about the future financial prospects of their franchises might meet with increased scepticism. Despite legitimate fears over the impact the recession would have on the 2009 season, in the end, industry revenues were flat. (According to MLB COO Bob DuPuy) Recently, Fitch Ratings released a positive report on the state of MLB and The Sports Business Journal reported that MLB will soon renew it’s “credit facility” after failing to do so at the same point last year. If the diminished demand for free agents continues this off season, will the “it’s the economy, stupid” argument be viewed as credibly as it was last off season?

Adam Rubin of the New York Daily News, reported LWIB on comments made by player agent Scott Boras during the General Manager’s meetings in Chicago

Boras chastised owners of some teams for pocketing revenue distributed through MLB that the agent labeled at $80 million per club. He accused the owners of financing the purchases of their teams by pocketing that money rather than investing it in players. He also suggested MLB is rolling in cash, even if teams are crying poverty.

"I would say, based upon their 'bad economy' forecasts from last year, I would not invest in their stock choices," Boras said.

If the owners are, or have been in recent years, colluding to control salaries for free agents, will their conspiracy be more difficult to prove than was the case in the late 1980’s?  David Pinto reacted to Michael Weiner’s recent comments:

It strikes me that MLB has learned to walk the fine line between compliance with the CBA and collusion. Weiner is trying to trying to knock them off the line, but he’s going to have a tough job of doing so. I don’t think anyone is going to leave the smoking gun statement that Peter Ueberroth did in the 1980s.

The “smoking gun statement” that Mr. Pinto refers to is then commissioner Ueberroth’s private address to the owners in October of 1985. In his book “May the Best Team Win, Baseball

Economics and Public Policy”, author Andrew Zimbalist wrote that during that owners meeting, the commissioner “reportedly scolded them for overspending on mediocre free agents.” During that same meeting, Mr. Zimbalist wrote that:

Lee MacPhail, director of the owners’ Players Relations Committee, delivered a speech arguing that players with contracts of three years and more spent nearly 50 percent more time on the disabled list than those with one-year contracts and that the average player with a three-year contract or more experienced a nearly twenty-point decline in his batting average after signing the contract.

The ultimately failed attempts of the owners to “collude” in the mid 1980’s also included, at one point, a very structured and formal approach. In his comprehensive retrospective on the history of MLB labour relations from the formation of the MLBPA in 1965 to the strike of 1994, John Helyar wrote in “Lords of the Realm”;

It was called the Information Bank, and it was simplicity itself. A club making an offer to a free agent reported it to the PRC. That was called an information “deposit”. A club wanting to know what others bid for a free agent could call the PRC and make an information “withdrawal.”

The idea was to stimulate the market enough to blunt charges of collusion, while at the same time keeping a rein on the market. The signal was clear: Okay, guys, you can bid now. But don’t top the other guy’s offer by much.”

As Mr. Pinto alluded to, if there is a collective approach within MLB to controlling free agent compensation, the approach is more subtle than that used in the 1980s. Last November, former Federal Reserve chairman Paul Volker (former “Blue Ribbon” panel member also) addressed a meeting of the MLB owners to discuss the state of the economy. At the time, Barry Bloom reported for, “Selig declined to elaborate on Volcker's remarks, but he said a message had obviously been sent to the owners.” The absence of offers to free agent Barry Bonds was not the only development during the 2007 off season to cause consternation amongst the players side. Again from Marc Edelman’s aforementioned paper, “Moving Past Collusion in Major League Baseball: Healing Old Wounds and Preventing New Ones."

…Selig allowed MLB clubs’ general managers to meet with one another and discuss their 2007 off-season rosters plans by openly stating what players they were making available for trade. This marked a substantial change from the past practice at General Manager Meetings.

The idea of club general managers openly discussing personnel plans was first suggested by General Manager Meetings co-chais Theo Epstein and Larry Bienfest as a way to create more dialogue and stimulate trades. The MLB clubs, however, never informed the MLBPA in advance about these activities, nor was the MLBPA invited to send counsel to police them.

Record industry revenues have resulted in extended labour peace in MLB. If the next CBA (the current one expires in December 2011) can be negotiated without labour interruption, commissioner Selig might rightfully claim that improved labour relations is his greatest legacy.

However, with unresolved allegations of “collusion” the past two off-seasons, and a strong likelihood of another this off season, there is potential for a return to more divisive relations. Mistrust between the two sides arising from the collusion settlements of the 1980s has never subsided. Outgoing MLBPA executive director Donald Fehr (who will remain one of the most important participants in the next CBA negotiations) is believed to still harbour bitter resentment toward commissioner Selig over the collusion wars of the 1980s. Mr. Fehr’s successor, Mr. Weiner, is also a veteran of the collusion era, joining the MLBPA in 1988. Mr. Fehr and Mr. Weiner will never forget that arbitrator George Nicolau (one of two arbitrators to rule in favour of the MLBPA in the 80s collusion cases) identified commissioner Selig (then Milwaukee Brewers owner) as one of the most active owners in their attempts to manipulate the free agent market. Former commissioner Fay Vincent described commissioner Selig as one of the “ringleaders” of collusion. Commissioner Selig has never admitted to playing a role in the “collusion” of the 1980s and many owners and club officials of that era (including Mr. Ueberroth) have never been convinced that their activities were anything other than an attempt to operate MLB in a fiscally responsible manner.

At the same time, heading into his first CBA negotiation as executive director, Mr. Weiner needs to prove to the players and their agents that he will be as formidable a leader as his predecessor. As well, there is a growing constituency of veteran players in the MLBPA who have been openly critical of the diminished opportunities they meet in the free agent market while “rookie compensation” is escalating.

Whether there is or is not collusion in MLB, the issue is once again a point of contention in labour relations. And the history of labour relations in MLB informs us that if there is an issue capable of wrecking labour peace it is collusion.






Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?