best rx online pharmacy india prometh with codeine for sale uk metformin 500mg medicine buy toprol xl usa can i buy phenergan over the counter in australia propranolol online overnight buy strattera inhaler canada can you buy phenergan tablets over counter online generic biaxin buy tadalis sx online in usa dosis para abortar con cytotec blue pill red pill list of tesco stores selling mycelex-g ordering lipitor from canada canada and brand levitra buy champix online no prescription starlix pharmacy order finasteride tablets usp 1 mg side effects starlix film tablet 120 mg 84 tb what is calcium carbonate formula elavil 25 mg weight gain best place to buy lioresal acticin buy online onde comprar cialis buy lozol uk order erexor cheap water pills to lose weight yahoo answers singulair women buy get differin cheap where purchase elavil dilantin online purchase himcolin uses medication roche stops selling acne drug accutane get buspar toronto brand advair diskus coupons what does alliance mean in the game can you order zyrtec safe place sale neurontin brand positioning evista compared to tamoxifen cheap rx 8 r3 tinidazole for sale australia what does bystolic medication do florinef sale injection voveran dose buy evista paypal prednisolone tablets asthma super kamagra kopen pulmicort respules generic name seroflo 100 formoterol mometasone inhaler cialis vs which is better viagra or levitra generic differin treat acne sublingual drugs i took 4 pills for chlamydia donde comprar cleocin gel arava next day delivery alavert italiano how to use styplon dulcolax mail order does low dose prednisone cause weight gain doxycycline hyclate make you gain weight etodolac generic drug treatment of coumadin toxicity fluoxetine 20mg capsules information can you order zyrtec online abilify online cheap consecuencias de tomar pastillas cytotec pramipexole depression drugstore coupon code 10 buy cleocin gel no prescription fast delivery generic from yasmin isoniazid for sale australia zetia delivery uk shallaki tablets online discount drugs of canada florida cardura xl spc online pharmacy innopran xl cialis generico italia what all is topamax used for cheap motilium pills drugs online without prescription buy generic zyban buy generic ditropan greenstone azithromycin 250 mg what is zofran tablets buying levitra from cipa in canada what is cleocin used for can you order vicodin online nexium drugs use cheap ginseng pills salep elocon untuk bayi orlistat without prescriptions can i make liv 52 benadryl tablets purchase on line canadian pharmacy online aricept lopressor dosage iv lowest cost canadian online pharmacy voltaren purchase can i buy viagra in canada over the counter prograf tablets on line to buy online pharmacy schools in georgia earth medicine alliance conference differin canada pharmacy does coreg cause weight gain cheap online order alesse us pharmacies online that sell cymbalta over counter zebeta buy over the counter tadacip online canadian prescription drugs pill identifier too much levothyroxine weight loss doxycycline malaria tablets review buy unisom pills online zoloft and anafranil for ocd buy himplasia in india online chloramphenicol pas cher italie xenical de laboratorio roche cholestoplex prices usa what does zanaflex feel like liv 100mg tablet cheap vermox 500mg where to buy levothyroxine tablets synthroid sale overnight buy hyzaar buy cleocin 100 korean ginseng in canada best place to buy amitriptyline in canada cefadroxil side effects billig florinef online kaufen how quickly does viagra work acheter voltaren pas cher order femara pill order lipitor online no presctiption ventolin nebules rxlist differin without prescription miami where can i get some benzac ordering propecia australia levaquin tablets appearance erythromycin pharmacy mail order proscar hair buy abana with drugs zyprexa zydis uk lisinopril hctz overdose cheap advair diskus generic canadian is mail order metformin safe buspar tablets for children canadian viagra reviews where could i buy abana without prescription zetia generic available in usa names asthma medications inhalers silagra on line in the usa how to use prometrium 200 mg generic viagra gel prescription dulcie brand pillsbury winthrop yagara to purchase without a prescription free trial cialis online stromectol cost comparison cod ibuprofen pregnancy side effects tetracycline pills drugstore altace order on web cephalexin australia vital erexin spray liquid imitrex review purchase aldactone online no prescription staxyn discount coupons buy oxytrol hong kong what does a rash from bactrim look like acai costco drink fastest flovent uk delivery voltaren discount voucher buy voltaren online no prescription united states where can i buy caffeine pills canada buy allegra d from canada order dostinex from acheter pas cher zenegra buy levothroid next day what are the different types of drugs called asacol where can i buy it cialis coupons for pharmacy drugstore canada free shipping effexor banned uk endep 25 mg tablets erection pills that really work cheap viagra 150 mg cardizem new zealand actoplus met pas cher italie what is baclofen medicine used for differin 3 gel reviews buy cialis professional no prescription fast delivery buy phexin with paypal imitrex from europe cheap lozol no prescription fluoxetine over the counter india how to use pulmicort turbuhaler video amantadina 100 mg viagra patent expiration extension are alligators dangerous to humans how to take brahmi churna augmentin price at walmart biaxin without prescription pills bactrim generic drug cipro generic reviews pariet brand positioning acticin shipping overseas ephedraxin billig kaufen cheap amantadine approved que es cicloferon crema buy clonidine pills online myorderstatus aol com alesse generic non generic aldactone zestoretic next day shipping viagra super active from usa canadian pharmacy luvox what does generic d look like canada allegra is anafranil legal in uk buy leukeran bulk cheap allopurinol 100mg tablets comprar glucotrol xl original where to buy zetia noroxin 400mg uses yasmin without prescription order actos 1 diabetes pharmacy is it safe to buy viagra? bactrim ds tablet and alcohol low cost benicar finasteride medications generic sinemet uk paypal cialis price greece celebrex order in the us xalatan from usa generic metformin hcl 500 canadian healthcare manager rogers buy prevacid 30 mg online buy cefadroxil in singapore nootropil australia pharmacy sumycin shortage 2012 side effects of clindamycin iv prilosec with no rx costco reading times what does mobic make you feel bupropion hydrochloride reviews crestor rosuvastatin australia cardura lowest price augmentin price australia what are the best pills to gain weight pariet looking for cheapest hytrin to buy will abilify become generic como comprar crestor mais barato buying viagra oline frome mexico generic pills for keflex cheap genuine renagel online hydrochlorothiazide on line for sale no script mail-order actos xenical pills sweat risperdal shortage salzarex ultram side effects of zestril 5mg buying isotretinoin canada generic brand for valtrex can buy aleve uk where to buy micardis ointment online prescriptions canadian pharmacy suppliers of flagyl er in us cabgolin prices generic zocor switzerland order reminyl canada generic claritin for kids is strattera available over the counter order abana 2 tablets where to buy cytotec online usa erectivin vi non prescription sildenafil review how much would valtrex cost without insurance famvir tablets dose glycomet 40mg generic medication for flovent para que se usa el prilosec janssen cilag usa canadian pharmacy viagra generic canada post shoppers drug mart winnipeg clozaril online from canada buy cialis super active without a script where to buy singulair in canada safely generic uk paypal amantadine morning after pill effectiveness non persciption pletalstrattera 25 mg kullananlar canada generic drugs online india chloramphenicol price hydrochlorothiazide medications alli generic reviews how to get lozol in australia yasmin medication buy isoniazid in ireland overnight pharmacy cialis super active health canada v-gel buspar online coupon code cheap propranolol usa order doxazosin buy discount where to buy alligators care order prednisolone on line india digoxin 5mg tablets minocycline discount medications best over the counter antibiotics for uti over the counter antibiotics to cure chlamydia canadian healthcare technology news birth control pills minipress generic allegra sam;s club what is risperdal for kids cheap trileptal india i pill casodex website does generic propecia work the same mexican pharmacy no prescription minocycline carafate refills can you buy premarin in ireland asacol to buy in england buying stromectol for dogs is mail order ephedraxin safe chloroquine online legally where can i get diclofenac gel buying allopurinol cialis overnight shipping no prescription cheap mazda rx8 for sale in ohio viagra on line purchase amitriptyline western australia what is isoniazid 300 mg used for side effects of robaxin 750 mg proscar 5 mg canada anti anxiety medication list canada sodium diclofenac 50mg dose accutane india amoxicillin 875 mg tablet par malegra fxt tablets price common side effects of asthma inhalers buy zithromax® azithromycin hydrochlorothiazide where to get what does biaxin look like avodart 0.5mg soft capsules buy bupron sr 40 xalatan for dogs buy what is the dosage of zyrtec for dogs birth control pills luvox femara cost for infertility best site to buy lasuna clonidine over the counter research grade liv 52 fast endep delivery can you buy benicar fast worldwide shipping pharmacy ampicillin fast india mexican synthroid propranolol for sale online topical hydrocortisone side effects celebrex costco price buy liv 52 online clomid paypal prevacid solutabs for sale bentyl pas cher can we trust septilin online cheap generic ralista purchase effexor xr elavil side effects hair loss carafate liquid price generic from minocycline alphagan 5mg tablets what does cialis do for women can you buy ranitidine over the counter in germany trental direct pharmacy order cymbalta on line uk can i get high on prednisone buy online lotensin generic levoxyl doses buying promethazine codeine syrup online uk pharmacies online that sell prednisone order ditropan on line uk Purchase 1 pharmacy abilify generic blood pressure medication hydrochlorothiazide dosage norvasc low cost best price for imitrex thuo^'c coversyl plus arginine viagra in kuwait side effects of avapro hct cephalexin online coupon code imitrex tablets for purchase trazodone refill pack how to get off doxycycline cheap 1 accutane mg isotretinoin where to get prilosec pct estimated cost of generic lipitor free coupon for lanoxin where to buy asian ginseng ordering vermox canada reviews on erexor buying authentic cialis viagra en ligne suisse propecia safe take long term desyrel prices at costco beconase aq medicine online amoxil online what does bactrim do to bacteria how to use viagra delay spray duphalac tablets uses buy myambutol generic amoxil side effects in dogs what is silagra 100 paxil from sildenafil tablets for sale indian pharmacy fertomid hay tratamiento para la disfuncion erectil elavil for migraines headache canadian online pharmacy for nizoral board of pharmacy in canada what is valacyclovir hcl 500mg used for flagyl er online bestellen lisinopril 100 mg tamoxifen shortage 2012 where to buy indomethacin online buy hydrocortisone no prescription discount betnovate lasix 40 mg tabletas buy cephalexin hong kong imiquimod cream over the counter uk canesten hc clotrimazole hydrocortisone para que se usa el antibiotico cephalexin is generic viramune effective is minocycline available over the counter robaxin high feeling order anafranil online with visa lantus glargine insulin pen aldactone no prescription needed drugstore where to get free sample of cialis buying prescriptions online reviews buy finasteride cheap dose of isoniazid in tb how to get aricept on line snovitra super power limited india best homeopathic medicine back pain synthroid available uk erexor to buy in england canadianmedicinenow what does trileptal look like what is promethazine 25mg used for diflucan single dose for yeast infection buy minocycline online india finpecia discount medications comprar nootropil en argentina generic cialis canada shipping como se usa sildenafil spray nitroglycerin from canadian pharmacy cuales son los efectos secundarios de la prednisona where do i buy voveran sr vasotec online coupon code prograf mail order how to buy zyrtec in london cheap lady era glyset no prescription compare prices doxycycline hyclate side effects tingling what does trileptal feel like buy viagra professional pills dangers of pain pills and alcohol get canadia drugs with no prescription ditropan canada sale uk buy neurontin without prescription where to buy alli from online free shipping purchase carafate cheap tetracycline buy no prescription cephalexin mexico pharmacy singulair medicine side effects children where cleocin i pill gyne-lotrimin website canadian pharmacy no prescription cialis super active buy baby converse online australia rosuvastatin comprar cialis soft online no prescription buy levaquin 750 mometasone furoate cream uses discount canadian pharmacy seroflo buy topical spironolactone uk losec mups dosage for babies atarax 100 mg iv malegra fxt mail order abilify mg usa side effects of indocin indomethacin betamethasone ointment uses sinemet max dose viagra online fastest shipping buy cheap brand cialis online order erythromycin topical solution aravaipa az land for sale pictures of abilify pills viagra shop online com astelin usa cvs prices bactroban 20mg bula himalaya shatavari price indian pharmacy elimite worldwide pharmacy brahmi diflucan daily use reviews low cost overnight luvox buy lisinopril 30 no prescription buy esomeprazole online roxithromycin delivery london bystolic from india zyvox cost walmart order levitra online in usa
Home Maury Brown Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 380 guests online

Atom RSS

Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 63
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 06 November 2009 15:30
Yankees
Should talk of a salary cap  be
about the Yankees, or a far
broader topic?

As soon as the Yankees won the World Series, the conversation broke into a chorus. There had been discussions about it before, but once the moniker “27th World Series Champion” was attached to the Bronx Bombers, the conversation kicked into high gear… and it hasn’t stopped.

Whether it was Baseball Daily Digest (and Baseball Prospectus’) Joe Hamrahi, or the New York Post’s Bart Hubbuch, calls for a salary cap in Major League Baseball sang out, and that’s just on Twitter.

First of all, I’m not one to say that baseball’s system is perfect; far from it. It’s that a salary cap is (mostly) a reaction to the Yankees, and doesn’t move much beyond that (Hamrahi offers up great conversation on the overall salary cap topic via Twitter, if you look through his posts)

There is lots of talk of a cap, but then, there's little about how to implement it. What there really is a lot of talk about the Yankees being the problem, but a salary floor is needed, as well (keep the Marlins, Royals, and Pirates from living off welfare).

Give me a number for the cap. Or, give me a system for a cap. It’s one thing to complain, it’s another to say the system stinks, and here’s a possible solution.

I’ve written about why a cap is, at best, difficult and create a host of issues, to understanding that perfect parity is a far off notion (some statistical details are within Ranking Who in MLB Got the Biggest Bang For the Buck in 2009). Here’s what I mean.

As mentioned, a floor is need, I believe, more than a ceiling. The Marlins expose the revenue-sharing flaw each and every year and that’s that they take in more in revenue-sharing than they spend on MLB player payroll. That’s certainly not the spirit of the provision within the CBA that says revenue-sharing should be used to improve the on-the-field product (the MLB roster).

But, if you create a floor to address the Marlins, it can create issues for others that really seem to be making a go of it with very little (i.e. the Athletics). So, if you set the floor, to say, $70 million, or around $18 million below the league average for Open Day player payroll for 2009 (actual average, $88,513,173), you’d currently have eight teams below the threshold (Texas, Baltimore, Minnesota, Tampa Bay, Oakland, Washington, Pittsburgh, San Diego, and Florida). So, let’s throw out Florida and Pittsburgh, clubs that have historically collected large amounts in player payroll, but not used it to the best effort with MLB player payroll. I can’t speak for the six other clubs that would be forced to increase player payroll, but they would most assuredly say that it would place them under duress. Possible solution? A system by which club revenues are tied to player payroll, but even that is a flawed model. After all, you do have to invest in prospects… drafting and developing players, just not to the extent that the Marlins use that as a cover for taking in boat loads of revenue-sharing dollars.

On developing and scouting players, one way of “capping” expenditures is to allow for a hard slotting system for the amateur draft, and create an international draft. This keeps costs down for bonuses in the amateur draft and gives clubs that have limited resources to scout internationally a leg up with an international draft.

As for a cap, well… Nine clubs had player payroll over $100 million. The Yankees spent over $200 million and the Mets were just under $150 million. Five of the nine made the playoffs, while four did not (Mets, Cubs, Tigers, Astros). So, what’s the proper level? $110 million? More? Less? Could it be that all a cap would do is undervalue talent? It may prevent the Yankees from gobbling up all the talent by offering more than others could offer, or… Would it?

Ask yourself if the cap has prevented conversation about players such as Labron James leaving Cleveland and going to the Lakers or the Knicks (large media markets). Or, if NFL players would prefer playing in New York due to the media market size there.

MLB is no different. A player that would look to choose between Kansas City or New York, given the same salary offering, where do you think they will look to play? New York where they can garner the most in sponsorship activity.

So, if this is about grossly overspending for free agent talent (cornering them), why not simply do this...

Make the Luxury Tax have teeth. Set the penalty so that it's a dollar for dollar figure (for every dollar over the threshold, the club pays in), or make the tax escalate the higher a club goes over.

In the history of the Luxury Tax (or, as it is more properly called, the [ahem] Competitive Balance Tax), the Yankees have busted through the threshold each year. The Red Sox were the same, until recently, the Angels have done so once, as the Tigers did so this last year. As those that follow this stuff will tell you, the Luxury Tax was designed to go directly after the Yankees. So, if the problem is the Yankees, the Yankees don't seem to care; they simply keep breaking through the soft cap and pay the penalties. So, apparently (at least for the Yankees) the thresholds don’t work (while it does seem to work for the other 29 clubs to one extent or another).

But, the notion of a salary cap is unneeded. MLB has the least amout of revenues going to player payroll ithan any other sport (52% compared to 56.7% for the NHL, 57% for the NBA, and 59% for the NFL), a sign that the uncapped league functions in a "cap-like fashion" better than capped leagues; a cap does not stop high revenue making clubs from having advantage, it is politically challenging (see '94 work stoppage), and if you have a ceiling you need a floor (which could have consequences for clubs that run into economic head winds).

So, the talk of a salary cap should remain that: talk. The system is not perfect, but taking a wrecking ball to it is not the solution. Put in a hard-slotting system for the amateur draft. Create an international draft. Make breaking through the Luxury Tax threshold painful – very financially painful – for those clubs that dare to flirt with it.

And finally, there’s this: Remember that no matter what system you put in place, you are not going to get parity nirvana. You can create an ability to retain talent, but in the end remember… The smartest team will win given the right circumstances. Money or no, there will always be inadequacies due to market size, which attracts talent looking for the most coverage. So, even if every red cent were centralized – shared between each club evenly – players would gravitate to the New Yorks, Bostons, Chicagos, and Los Angeleses of the sports world. Sorry, Kansas City, Pittsburgh, and Cleveland, no salary cap will fix that.

ADDED COMMENTARY:

SPORTS BASH: Yankees Make Some Want to Eat the Rich


OTHER NEWS FROM THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)

(SPORTS BASH)


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?