hdfc credit card reward points platinum plus generate credit card numbers for testing best prepaid credit cards usa hotel rewards credit card comparison chase credit card services jobs prepaid gift visa card using chase credit card in canada best credit cards with rewards consumer report gap visa credit card account best exchange rate credit card canada hsbc apply for credit card online buy anonymous prepaid credit card easy way to pay off credit card debt fast chase credit card services nz balance transfer credit card deals best credit cards 2011 for good credit which bank credit card is best in malaysia does bank of ireland have visa debit cards zip code for canadian credit cards best credit card deal 2012 hdfc credit card payment ifsc code how do you apply for a credit card at walmart apply for online payday loan cash advance loans online no credit check does td canada trust have visa debit cards icici instant titanium credit card review credit cards no annual fee indusind bank credit cards apply online average household credit card debt in usa best way to get a credit card in canada malaysia credit card cash rebate comparison best way to accept credit card payments on iphone citibank credit card settlement offer do you need a credit card to build credit types of delta american express credit cards dept store credit cards for fair credit united cash loans scams icici instant credit card activation union bank of india credit card application form download hbc zellers credit card login business analyst in credit card domain credit card bank mega fnb apply online for credit card credit card machine for taxi cabs student visa credit card usa easiest credit card approval 2012 wells fargo unsecured credit card payday loan companies online no credit check legitimate poor credit loans canadian tire credit card minimum limit ifsc code hdfc bank credit cards chennai partially secured bank of america credit card platinum nab credit card travel insurance disney chase visa credit card login online payday advance loans no credit check top 20 credit cards in uk how to apply maybank supplementary credit card credit card bin number search zero percent balance transfer credit cards 2012 pay my first premier credit card bill online apply for walmart credit card login citibank credit card offers unsecured credit card definition how long does it take to get credit card from chase travel credit cards review do aib do visa debit cards national city credit card pnc sample credit card billing authorization form best credit cards with low interest rates business cash advance loans reviews credit card bank identification number easiest way to accept credit card payments target visa credit card discontinued mastercard business rewards credit cards college student credit cards no credit pay value city credit card which department store credit card is easy to get for bad credit capital one credit card settlement offer prepaid us credit card in canada online credit card numbers for sale hsbc credit card rewards points how to get a credit card in canada cibc best visa card rewards canada title loans online fast guaranteed approval credit cards with $10000 limits for bad credit score get a credit card with bad credit unsecured capital one orchard bank credit card application citibank business credit card online payment bank of america student credit card requirements department of education pay loans online balance transfer calculator savings chase visa card phone number hsbc credit card online application status 12 month loans online decision black card nandos ebay cash advance credit card 0 interest gas rewards credit card offers southwest chase credit card no credit check payday loans lenders uk platinum credit cards pay banana republic visa credit card best reward credit card with no foreign transaction fee aspire credit card apply best credit card reader for ipad mini easiest way to get a credit card with no credit paying off student credit card lloyds tsb black card visa requirements credit card account number citibank home loan with bad credit and no money down uk credit card market analysis quickbooks credit card processing reviews payday loan lenders online no credit check what is the credit score range for american express card what;s the best small business credit card low interest credit cards canada rbc how much does it cost for a business to use credit cards chase freedom credit card 5 cash back marriott rewards premier credit card from chase review hsbc platinum credit card cash advance apply for student credit cards with no credit american express credit card no annual fee india easy payday loans uk no credit check student credit card hsbc alaska airlines credit card through bank of america aspire credit card payment online tesco credit card lost what credit cards are made of metal how to negotiate with credit card companies 2010 credit card with no annual fee philippines 2013 apply credit card online instant approval nz top cash back business credit cards visa debit card rewards program bad credit bank accounts apply online shell gas credit card apply amazon visa rewards card interest rate options for accepting credit cards online standard chartered credit card offers on mobiles same day cash loans uk what are reward points on credit cards new small business credit cards bad credit free visa credit card numbers westpac black credit card review petro canada gas credit card can i apply for a walmart credit card over the phone buy prepaid visa card online canada pc credit card limit increase credit card for students in india best credit card student credit card payment protection insurance compensation discount tire ge credit card easiest bad credit credit card get do you pay interest on cash advances credit card number validation javascript philippine credit cards online applications credit card information stolen 2013 lost gnc gold card major credit card company list bad credit loans no guarantor review hsbc credit card application online long term loans with bad credit score credit card consolidation loans aqua card initial credit limit amazon credit card uk login taking credit card payments over the phone cibc prepaid credit card canada barclay credit card customer care number bangalore instant approval credit cards poor credit td canada credit card fees 3d pin icici bank credit cards secured vs unsecured credit cards credit score capital one bad credit credit card credit card debt consolidation wells fargo fast installment loans online axis bank credit cards benefits dubai first credit card charges new credit cards canada 2013 post office 0 credit card balance transfer royal bank of canada prepaid visa credit card visa credit card bank of ireland sbi credit card logins travel rewards cards for students toys r us credit card promotions credit card with bad credit no deposit how do you transfer credit card balance to another credit card american express credit card offer opt out ge capital walmart credit card customer service nab low rate credit card credit cards compare philippines balance on credit card credit score bank of america credit card merchant account citibank cash back credit card accept credit cards free does making the minimum payment on a credit card hurt your credit score valero comcreditcard login natwest credit card protection plan low rate credit cards nz 3d secure credit card validation citibank dept store credit cards after bankruptcy payday loan online decision westpac credit card travel insurance credit card comparisons nz how to get a credit card as a student with no job new business credit cards for bad credit chase international travel credit card best pay as you go credit card standard chartered credit card promotions malaysia post office credit card online banking login credit card payoff calculator chart chase credit card with disney rewards facebook credit gift cards uk payday loans cash advance for bad credit delta credit card reward miles credit card protection act wiki chase credit card for students with no credit credit card online application form $10000 unsecured bad credit loan sears credit card application phone mastercard credit card number hack aadvantage credit card review how long does it take to get credit card after applying i need a payday loan from a direct lender credit card after bankruptcy discharge uk best credit card to use on holiday in usa spider credit card search tool chase credit card application status best credit card to have with no annual fee walmart pay as you go credit cards give me a fake visa credit card number citibank credit card cash advance singapore standard chartered master credit card payment best secured credit cards with rewards apply for shell credit card uk visa card security code invalid what is the minimum payment on my virgin credit card chase credit card balance transfer no fee online credit card fraud statistics cancelling credit card affect credit score canada what are the best credit cards in canada virtual credit card paypal indonesia virgin credit cards login uk black card uk visa jcpenney credit card payment online citi american airlines credit card credit card insurance mis-selling instant payday loan online canada small business credit cards chase gold reward card tfl credit card number location discover sears citi mastercard credit card login how can i get approved for a credit card with no credit commonwealth bank credit card travel insurance review credit cards for small business with fair credit how to apply for hsbc credit card online in india cheap rate credit cards uk chase credit card fraud prevention number delta rewards credit card login how to pay sbi credit card bill online from hdfc ge money bank credit card list bank of america small business credit card offers get a credit card with no credit now list of credit card company in usa valero gas credit card login how do i pay my halifax credit card online chase credit card settlement sears credit cards rewards dining offers on icici bank credit cards leaders merchant services mobile credit card processing how to consolidate credit card debt yourself online credit card merchant services reviews company credit card policy template uk virtual credit card us billing address i need to get a credit card to rebuild my credit best frequent flyer credit cards no annual fee starbucks credit card processing visa cards with travel rewards chase cash advance credit card limit getting a chip and pin credit card in the us pnc visa card services pc mastercard contact ann taylor loft credit card sign in guaranteed credit cards for bad credit uk sbi gold credit card offers disney credit card canada how to apply for apple id without credit card black card visa american express rewards gift cards online payday loans no credit check instant approval payday loans online same day no credit check amazon uk credit card annual fee apply for department store credit cards with bad credit super balance transfer virgin credit card credit cards deals india apply for barclays platinum credit card gap visa credit card account login american express gold card compare all credit cards canada best online payday loan sites credit card for no credit history canada how to get a payday loan with bad credit uk delta credit card offer visa hsbc credit card debt settlement philippines what credit card company accepts bad credit best credit card to get american airline miles verizon visa rewards card balance credit cards with low apr for students bank of america credit card 200 cash back post office credit card payment credit card company liable faulty goods payday loans no credit check no brokers rbc bank visa debit card hdfc credit card payment options neft best prepaid gift credit cards amazon visa credit card application status walmart credit card payment calculator portable credit card machine hire household bank credit cards for bad credit apply for staples business credit card does rbc offer visa debit card apply for a credit card online instant approval philippines costco credit card uk best way to get a student credit card nandos black card how to get credit card debt relief company reviews student credit cards halifax business credit cards for new businesses with no credit what is credit card apr rate citibank australia credit card travel insurance 0 apr purchase credit cards bad credit loans no credit check nz bank of america student credit card denied how do credit cards work apply for a gas card with no credit hong leong bank hello kitty credit card how does chase apply credit card payments credit card comparison 0 transfer fee fake credit card number information that works instant cash loans for unemployed uk top credit cards for students canada credit cards with low interest for students buy virtual credit cards with paypal hsbc credit cards uk contact best deal on credit card gift cards low interest fee credit card scotiabank value?î visa card td canada trust visa travel card online payday loan 100 approval consolidate rewards cards app visa card number uk student credit cards with no credit instant approval capital 1 credit card customer service telephone number credit card prepaid canada 0 balance transfer no balance transfer fee credit cards black hello kitty credit card halifax balance transfer to current account best credit cards for poor credit 2012 check status of cibc credit card application idbi credit card apply online india chase credit card bad credit disney credit card reviews 2012 use paypal to buy virtual credit card preloaded credit cards ireland capital one prepaid credit cards no fees axis bank easy credit card form unsecured credit cards to rebuild your credit free reward credit cards canada student credit card reviews canada natwest platinum credit card minimum payment commonwealth bank international credit card fees how to get credit limit increase capital one credit card processing for small business reviews fake visa card number and security code list of free valid credit card numbers hdfc credit card application status disapproved goodyear credit card customer service best unsecured bad credit cards all types of credit cards in india best travel credit card singapore hyatt credit card authorization form axis bank credit card apply online in hyderabad first credit card company ever marriott reward credit card icici instant credit card eligibility best credit card for travel rewards us bank joint credit card application best buy credit card apply kotak bank aqua credit card chase british airways credit card offer credit card deals money transfer student credit card bad credit uk credit card app for phone american airlines 50000 mile credit card black and gold card provident apply citibank credit card online india buy mobile credit card machines applied bank visa business card credit limit canara bank credit card application form wells fargo credit card use in canada best credit card to get to build credit sears credit cards online services phone number to apply for visa credit card bad credit loans no fees online decision best rewards credit card usa compare charity credit cards uk 10 best online payday loans first premier credit card limit increase how to apply for a credit card in axis bank citibank american airlines credit card offers goodyear credit card promotion ge money pc richards credit card login apply for credit card 0 interest rate buy gift credit cards online going over credit card limit hsbc free reloadable visa debit cards freedom credit card review get credit card instantly with bad credit hdfc bank credit card 5 cash back instant credit card application approval best credit card students no credit how to get reward points in hdfc platinum credit card does wells fargo secured credit card report to credit bureaus get online loan without bank account ryanair credit card charges capital one credit card contact phone number hdfc virtual credit card charges how to redeem my icici bank credit card points best airmiles credit card canada payday lenders online only hsbc gold credit card business lowest balance transfer fee hsbc credit card ppi calculator credit card protection insurance compare best gas credit cards for bad credit best uk credit cards 2012 barclay credit card online application i want a credit card to build my credit citibank credit card online payment login credit card merchant services ireland pc mastercard app credit card travel points best bpi family savings bank credit card online application citibank credit card limit calculator payday advance loan uk best credit card to have in india commonwealth bank credit card insurance abn amro credit card online payment india halifax credit card online help report lost chase credit card online online loan companies with monthly payments betus credit card verification form how to pay off my credit card debt faster 0 interest credit card balance transfer free virgin credit card 0 for existing customers halifax student credit card benefits ebay change payment from credit card to paypal reward credit cards 2013 cash advance america ( priority payday ) icici bank credit card limit calculator capital one small business credit card reviews square iphone credit card system credit cards for students with bad credit scores us bank credit card processing charges credit card reader for pc laptop verifone wireless credit card machines business gas cards for bad credit payment address for bank of america credit cards best reward credit cards 2012 best way to raise credit card limits iphone credit card payment system new horizon credit union credit card delta airlines credit card no annual fee citibank gold credit card travel insurance pay citifinancial credit card bill online prepaid credit cards freedom capital one credit card login bad credit loan company no broker sbi corporate credit card customer care best online cash advance reviews need help consolidating credit card debt chase joint credit card account small business credit card machines wireless should i get credit card with annual fee fast cash advance online reviews best buy credit cards online bill pay american express student credit card uk fast cash advance online loans navy federal credit card prime rate best credit cards for low income earners 0 percent credit cards 18 months hdfc titanium credit card travel offers international credit card charges best premium credit cards in india no credit check payday loans online uk clark howard how to choose a credit card stop american airlines credit card offer getting a credit card with a 600 score american express student credit cards apply how do i sign up for a walmart credit card new credit card offers 2011 no fee credit card abroad best delta credit card mqm citibank instant approval credit card
Home Maury Brown Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 602 guests online

Atom RSS

Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 63
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 06 November 2009 15:30
Yankees
Should talk of a salary cap  be
about the Yankees, or a far
broader topic?

As soon as the Yankees won the World Series, the conversation broke into a chorus. There had been discussions about it before, but once the moniker “27th World Series Champion” was attached to the Bronx Bombers, the conversation kicked into high gear… and it hasn’t stopped.

Whether it was Baseball Daily Digest (and Baseball Prospectus’) Joe Hamrahi, or the New York Post’s Bart Hubbuch, calls for a salary cap in Major League Baseball sang out, and that’s just on Twitter.

First of all, I’m not one to say that baseball’s system is perfect; far from it. It’s that a salary cap is (mostly) a reaction to the Yankees, and doesn’t move much beyond that (Hamrahi offers up great conversation on the overall salary cap topic via Twitter, if you look through his posts)

There is lots of talk of a cap, but then, there's little about how to implement it. What there really is a lot of talk about the Yankees being the problem, but a salary floor is needed, as well (keep the Marlins, Royals, and Pirates from living off welfare).

Give me a number for the cap. Or, give me a system for a cap. It’s one thing to complain, it’s another to say the system stinks, and here’s a possible solution.

I’ve written about why a cap is, at best, difficult and create a host of issues, to understanding that perfect parity is a far off notion (some statistical details are within Ranking Who in MLB Got the Biggest Bang For the Buck in 2009). Here’s what I mean.

As mentioned, a floor is need, I believe, more than a ceiling. The Marlins expose the revenue-sharing flaw each and every year and that’s that they take in more in revenue-sharing than they spend on MLB player payroll. That’s certainly not the spirit of the provision within the CBA that says revenue-sharing should be used to improve the on-the-field product (the MLB roster).

But, if you create a floor to address the Marlins, it can create issues for others that really seem to be making a go of it with very little (i.e. the Athletics). So, if you set the floor, to say, $70 million, or around $18 million below the league average for Open Day player payroll for 2009 (actual average, $88,513,173), you’d currently have eight teams below the threshold (Texas, Baltimore, Minnesota, Tampa Bay, Oakland, Washington, Pittsburgh, San Diego, and Florida). So, let’s throw out Florida and Pittsburgh, clubs that have historically collected large amounts in player payroll, but not used it to the best effort with MLB player payroll. I can’t speak for the six other clubs that would be forced to increase player payroll, but they would most assuredly say that it would place them under duress. Possible solution? A system by which club revenues are tied to player payroll, but even that is a flawed model. After all, you do have to invest in prospects… drafting and developing players, just not to the extent that the Marlins use that as a cover for taking in boat loads of revenue-sharing dollars.

On developing and scouting players, one way of “capping” expenditures is to allow for a hard slotting system for the amateur draft, and create an international draft. This keeps costs down for bonuses in the amateur draft and gives clubs that have limited resources to scout internationally a leg up with an international draft.

As for a cap, well… Nine clubs had player payroll over $100 million. The Yankees spent over $200 million and the Mets were just under $150 million. Five of the nine made the playoffs, while four did not (Mets, Cubs, Tigers, Astros). So, what’s the proper level? $110 million? More? Less? Could it be that all a cap would do is undervalue talent? It may prevent the Yankees from gobbling up all the talent by offering more than others could offer, or… Would it?

Ask yourself if the cap has prevented conversation about players such as Labron James leaving Cleveland and going to the Lakers or the Knicks (large media markets). Or, if NFL players would prefer playing in New York due to the media market size there.

MLB is no different. A player that would look to choose between Kansas City or New York, given the same salary offering, where do you think they will look to play? New York where they can garner the most in sponsorship activity.

So, if this is about grossly overspending for free agent talent (cornering them), why not simply do this...

Make the Luxury Tax have teeth. Set the penalty so that it's a dollar for dollar figure (for every dollar over the threshold, the club pays in), or make the tax escalate the higher a club goes over.

In the history of the Luxury Tax (or, as it is more properly called, the [ahem] Competitive Balance Tax), the Yankees have busted through the threshold each year. The Red Sox were the same, until recently, the Angels have done so once, as the Tigers did so this last year. As those that follow this stuff will tell you, the Luxury Tax was designed to go directly after the Yankees. So, if the problem is the Yankees, the Yankees don't seem to care; they simply keep breaking through the soft cap and pay the penalties. So, apparently (at least for the Yankees) the thresholds don’t work (while it does seem to work for the other 29 clubs to one extent or another).

But, the notion of a salary cap is unneeded. MLB has the least amout of revenues going to player payroll ithan any other sport (52% compared to 56.7% for the NHL, 57% for the NBA, and 59% for the NFL), a sign that the uncapped league functions in a "cap-like fashion" better than capped leagues; a cap does not stop high revenue making clubs from having advantage, it is politically challenging (see '94 work stoppage), and if you have a ceiling you need a floor (which could have consequences for clubs that run into economic head winds).

So, the talk of a salary cap should remain that: talk. The system is not perfect, but taking a wrecking ball to it is not the solution. Put in a hard-slotting system for the amateur draft. Create an international draft. Make breaking through the Luxury Tax threshold painful – very financially painful – for those clubs that dare to flirt with it.

And finally, there’s this: Remember that no matter what system you put in place, you are not going to get parity nirvana. You can create an ability to retain talent, but in the end remember… The smartest team will win given the right circumstances. Money or no, there will always be inadequacies due to market size, which attracts talent looking for the most coverage. So, even if every red cent were centralized – shared between each club evenly – players would gravitate to the New Yorks, Bostons, Chicagos, and Los Angeleses of the sports world. Sorry, Kansas City, Pittsburgh, and Cleveland, no salary cap will fix that.

ADDED COMMENTARY:

SPORTS BASH: Yankees Make Some Want to Eat the Rich


OTHER NEWS FROM THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)

(SPORTS BASH)


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?