orlistat roche naruciti atacand discount coupon sanofi lantus solostar coupons sirius radio healthy man orderpharma uk basketball meprate side effects silagra deutschland lortab hydrocodone erection pills walgreens european drugs online zyban smoking weight loss abilify maintena prescribing information order elavil overnight antivert over the counter medication search http arrangerxmusic plant v eltroxin dosage ketorolac tromethamine ophthalmic solution 0.5 trimox 500mg capsule picture buy sildalis online norlevo levonorgestrel tablets tablete ieftine preturi buy moduretic tablets strattera drug claravis side effects changes in eye color the goodrx appgrafazol bactroban ointment uses for nose citalopram hydrobromide 20mg most reliable site to buy clomid lopid generic name cialis 5 mg cost cytoxan side effects treatment primox portable air ramipril 5mg capsule lup antibiotics no prescription overnight walmart cialis suhagraat ki starting kaise se hoti hai vigrande nedir berifen medicina alternativa lamictal rash picture lamictal side effects discount adhd meds hydroxyzine dichlorhydrate viagra levitra cialis a basso costo wellbutrin side effects withdrawal symptoms of mestinon overdose singulair side effects in adults cefamor 250 grams rocket stove mass heater zyvox 600 mg for free cost of cialis daily dose how to get free viagra online diclobru tablets with windows adderall withdrawal help meprate dosage calculations acyclovir philippines zoloft side effects weight gain zyprexa relprevv injection septra suspension presentation cost of 100 mg viagra finasteride online kaufen prescription drug buyer diane keaton movies baby boom dikloron jelena accutane usa bestellen pharcharmy online viagra de los del tercer mundo reminyl drug interactions xatral xl medicine naproxen side effects medication antabuse medication purchase nuvigil medication side effects doxycycline 150 mg sale cafergot suppositories message board irbesartan generic approval tadalafil 20mg uk pharmacy express reviews medication over counter like combivent suhagra 50 advantages of technology lisinopril hctz side effects webmd kemadrin medication identification viagra blogs marcumar medication interaction canadian overnight buy doxycyclene cambodia stromectol ivermectin scabies dose mincorp mn child synthroid dosage chart cialis online pharmacy paypal oxybutynin chloride 5mg price wellbutrin xl vs sr aldactone 50 mg bid antabuse side effects disulfiram like effect laxsum frusemide to buy zyloprim medication allopurinol micardis generic alternative soviclor prescription diflucan side effects buy online cialis without prescription obetrol adhd drugs aciphex medication information dianabol information methandrostenolone lopid medication uses metformin sale no prescription where i can order viagra pills cialis men cheap cialis in california buy promethazine w codeine syrup kamagra 100 mg tablets nederland lotrel dosage form bevispas ibs treatment metformin er 500mg vs metformin 500mg pinamox suspension training what is sildenafil citrate viragratablets with prescripion 5 mg cialis without prescription viagra tablet price zyprexa relprevv reviews ventolin hfa 90 mcg caffeine content of drinks chart alternative medicines for bactrim joint pain birth control pills vardenafil hydrochloride good generic cialis made in india viagra tips lipitor and grapefruit juice reaction generic hydrochloride trihydrate danazol use for men chloroquine malaria pill topamax topiramate 25mg weight loss viagra samples for physicians printable synthroid coupons where can i buy alli weight loss pills tadalafil generic india ebay precio de la ciales no prescription aciphex tadacip cheap zithromax antibiotic amitripyline online pharmacy lexapro weight loss or weight gain pump it global caplet cialis 20mg directions requip starter pack directions tetracycline sale canada viagra online review zofran for children with colitis plendil 5mg tablets uk no prescription lamictal side effects bipolar bestellen cialis generika how does cialis work for bph indocin 25mg priceinsulin periactin 4mg for children frumil fortesta mobicox 15 mg indicaciones geograficas avodart coupon for 2014 commender cialis 60 mg buy proscar online cialis overnite buy accutane online with paypal buy ed pills online elavil for sleep reviews canadian pharmacy takes paypal buy viagra brand on web premarin coupon cialis pills original diltiazem cd capsules canadian pharmacies and tretonin trileptal side effects why does cialis last longer than viagra chloroquine phosphate 250 mg dosage cheap tamsulosin generic viagra fast shipping toradol dosage for migraine imitrex dosage instructions valtrex order in canada omeprazole 20 mg treatment symptoms decadron side effects itching microzide hydrochlorothiazide 25mg tablets viagra online in spain ephedraxin infolanka how to buy levitra on line crestor side effects weight gain toradol 10mg street price low cost viagra without perscription colospa retard uputstvo geriforte ingredients in beer renagel 800 mg genzyme sifrol pramipexole tremor best discounts rx in canada irbesartan 150 mg tablets and grapefruit nifedipine ointment drug uroxatral vs flomax discussion groups online tramadol hcl 50mg treatment vs vicodin augmentin 875 mg buy magnesium deficiency symptoms in humans albuterol inhaler side effects hfa using viagra over counter erectile dysfuntion prandin 2mg side effects cataflam cost viagra price comparisons levitra orosolubile levofloxacin antibiotic alcohol viagra free sample differin adapalene gel side effects alfuzosin hydrochloride er 10mg quality of india made cialis mail order cialis generic purchase sildenafil citrate where can i get clomid in johannesburg valtrex for cold sores treatment cozaar medication and potassium elocon 0.1 lotion is used for cialis online express post does ginseng grow in florida bactrim tablete viagra store in canada propecia from canadian pharmacy purchase synthroid 5 7 day delivery erexin ingredients in splenda acyclovir medication dosage redumas precio baytril antibiotic side effects viasek sildenafil tablets what is flagyl used for in men cheap viagra overnight shipping kamagra paypal cardura 8 mg brand levitra canada genrric sildalis buy flagyl online with paypal metronidazole for mycoplasma flomax for womens urinary retention what is mobic 15 mg used for carprofen 100 mg for dogs spain viagra over the counter actos warning patients pioglitazone yasmin le bon beauty secrets application of elimite for scabies 1 gram azithromycin for sale cytoxan side effects prinivil side effects cough seroquel side effects seroquel lawsuit trazodone 50mg chlamydia treatment antibiotics for eyes doxazosin drug class atepros drug identification viagra in mexico canaian meds celebrex without prescription in canada cephalexin for sinus infection septra antibiotic for acne treatment prednisone without prescription in uk buy finasteride online uk estrogen order on web temovate scalp application ativan half life benzodiazepines etodolac side effects doctor progesterone pills viagra puerto rico acnelyse cream information assurance isoniazid side effects medication cicloferon aciclovir cream bp ospamox 1000mg sandoz warfarin side effects fentanyl patch abuse methods how to trazadone online overnight drug cipla product list yasmin le bon and simonyasmine apertium traductor en paxil withdrawal symptoms brain zaps viagra berlin pentrexyl 500mg ampicilina baclofen medication for alcohol abuse treatment buy cheap actos without prescription cheap drugs india cialis fast shipping how to order viagra cipro from canada flexidol relax accion terapeutica veterinaria mobicool mini fridge zincovit side effects zetia meds for sale is avelox for sinus infection atenolol 25 mg side effects webmd ropinirole hcl 0.5 mg tablet omifin 50mg from mexico furosemide no prescription vipps buy viagra bayer viagra for sale in boston doxycycline hyc 100mg no script order sinemet medication torsemide dosage for adults insulin resistance diet book aspirin dosage for dogs vet prevacid lansoprazole side effects canada pharmacy viagra tablet name lantus cost without insurance bystolic supply shortage vilches radio eprostol misoprostol induction how often can you take viagra olanzapine tablets 10mg buy propecia finasteride australia buy vyvanse 70 mg online famciclovir 250mg for cats trileptal 300mg 5ml baclofen tablets purchase on line donormyl sleeping pills 15mg digoxin and potassium level of 2.9 staxyn 10mg erlamycetin ointment definitionescitalopram peut on maigrir avec dulcolax 2014 can i get elimite over the counter singulair medicine reviewsskelaxin adipex weight loss results fgr 100 viagra antibiotics online trusted sites aldara side effects hair loss terramycin for cats directions probenecid side effects provera medication jasmine mickael jordan boyfriend non prescription 400mg viagra is levitra sold online motrin and robitussin interactions roxifen gelato bystolic nebivolol tablets 5 mg buy accutane cheap flagyl on sale terbutaline dosage for dogsterramicina where i can buy prednisone 20mg viagra bestellen per rechnung diclofenac sodium 75mg ec tablets ketorolac tromethamine injection 15 mg medrol 4mg dosepak 21s side effects tantra oral jelly side effects cheap cialis fast shipping vimax patch scam ranitidine medication pill identification buy viagra 10mg online rhinathiol expectorant cough mixture eutirox 100 contraindicaciones mexican drugstores without prescription over the counter lotrasine sofilex wikifeet tiendas la esquina famosa puerto rico grifulvin 500mg side effects trazodone desyrel side effects disgrasil pastillas colombianas brand name wellbutrin sr insurance marketplace government insurance baytril for dogs ear infections wellbutrin weight loss antidepressants side effects colchicine tablets ip cleocin antibiotic uses pravastatin sodium 80 mg side effects allegra carpenter twitter zyrtec dosage for dogs allergies mirapex side effects mirapex restless leg syndrome tizanidine side effects zanaflex mesterolone bodybuilding tips cialis information propecia cheap online india buy clomid without prescriptions buylowdrugs canada cardura xl reviews plavix coupons astra zeneca natija dyal 9wilbat aliviosin dyal gholdingallopurinol wellbutrin withdrawal symptoms weight gain exelon careers openings websites to purchase abortion pills laxifen tablets at walmart generic cialis paypal payment novolog flexpen dosage chart purchase topamax without a prescription synthyroid no rx free shipping tablete de vanzare ieftine il viagra puo essere mutuabile sotalol 80 mg prices antibiotics buy amoxil uk cheap how to get albuterol little script who sells pheromones and attraction tetracycline powder good for humans furacin nitrofurazone dressing xlpharmacy vip amantadina clorfenamina paracetamol roselyn para que sirve el omifin united states no prescription pharmacy cafergot tablets to buy in australia ketorolac tromethamine injection side effects milk cream roche xeloda obat levofloxacin ventolin side effects wikipedia clomiphene for men dosage extenze side effects lisinopril side effects heart health buying calis use paypal cheap viagra in australia stem cell supplement in chicago can i get provera over the counter sertraline zoloft side effects weight gain buy provera acyclovir medication xeloda 500mg cost vigria pills low dose anastrozole for men genetic viagra using mastercard estrace 1mg price zenegra reviews fiftyzenerexzenerx medicines without a prescriptions garlic clove for yeast infection oral lamisil over the counter the best selling viagra dalacin c 300mg price cipro no rx caffeine withdrawal symptoms duration xanax alprazolam side effects cialis daily for sale cialis spedizione anonima bentyl side effects in dogs generic abilify jasmine rice recipe ingredients prostata sintomas y prevencion de accidentes myambutol adverse reactions to shingles mylan diclofenac order atarax online terbutaline preterm labor risks usa meds online review prevacid solutab cost sertralina efectos a largo plazo silagra 100 mg india hoodia tea bija phexin 750 wsb tesco viagra salbutamol information macrodantin 100mg antabuse australia propecia post delivery avana at the rim calis without prescription betnovate locion capilar omifin tablets ritalin generic brands minocycline online lamisil cream ringworm phentermine side effects danger viagra discount pharmacy cheapest us pharmacy for viagra budesonide nebulizer solution dosage viagra pfizer for sale chigualos ejemplos de sustantivos where to buy viagra in bali cheapest finasteride on the web maxalt migraine dosage where to buy prednisolone 5mg contact eucustomer com xeloda chemo brand cialis sale lidocaine hydrochloride jelly for hemorrhoids didi ki suhagraat vasotec 20 mg tablets euroclinix reviews on vigrx bystolic online pharmacy contact rayhhealthcare cialis by paypal tryptizol 25mg benadryl generics med indian new covenant church trappe life span of 30 pills cialis valium withdrawal diazepam erythromycin dosage for sinus infection cardizem iv drip protocol pariet 20 mg without prescription why does viagra cost so much fempro ob gynfentanyl buy cialis tadacip in netherlands getpharma pakistan international airlines levitra preis pilocarpine hydrochloride ophthalmic solution toprol xl generic name buy cytotec feldene 20mg dose vitamix recipes book keftab antibiotic cefuroxime infertility drugs for sale pilocarpine hcl 5mg tablet buy benzaclin online unisom natural nights pregnancy cafergot medications 365 pillsbury vicodin vs percocet which is stronger cialis 40 mg betneval pommade antifongique misoprostol induction stories doxitab pills and potionsdoxycap diazepam 10mg levitra prezzo alli available in canada viagra swiss
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews Earl Santee - Ballpark Development

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1010 guests online

Atom RSS

Earl Santee - Ballpark Development PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Sunday, 09 April 2006 12:00
Earl SanteeIn this interview, Santee of HOK talks the Twins and Marlins continued efforts for new facilities, and how HOK approaches projects that are not yet funded, how the stadium design process is launched, which designs have been the most challenging, the downsizing of seat capacity in current designs, how upper deck design is approached in the context of lower bowl seating, Busch III, the New Nationals design, how Value Engineering is approached, what options by the client allow for a moving away from the nostalgic, or retro design, and how HOK can approach further work without resting on their laurels.
In the 1960s and ‘70s a series of multi-use stadiums were built starting with RFK Stadium, and moving the through the likes of the Astrodome, Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium, Busch Stadium II, and the Kingdome that has garnered a label within ballpark history as the Cookie-Cutter, or Cement Donut age of ballpark design.

As it sits now, we are in another design era that simply will be called the HOK Era.

Since the development of Oriole Park at Camden Yards in 1992, HOK has been the gold standard by which many clients looking for new facilities start, and nearly always end.

At the heart of many of these designs by HOK Sport, which is a division of Hellmuth, Obata and Kassabaum, is Earl Santee.

Santee has worked on more than 18 Major League Baseball parks and 40 minor league and spring training baseball projects, including the successful completions of PNC Park, Minute Maid Park and Angel Stadium of Anaheim. His responsibilities include design, project direction, interior architecture, cost estimating, feasibility studies and master planning.

As a Senior Principal at HOK, Santee’s influence on a vast array of ballparks developed, or in the works is astounding. A small sampling of his project experience includes:

  • Washington Nationals New Ballpark, Washington
  • New Busch Stadium, St. Louis, Missouri
  • PNC Park, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
  • Angel Stadium of Anaheim, Anaheim, California
  • Minute Maid Park, Houston, Texas
  • Coors Field, Denver, Colorado
  • Wrigley Field Renovation, Chicago, Illinois
  • Portland MLB Site Analysis, Portland, Oregon
  • Northern Virginia MLB Site and Concept Design
  • Kauffman Stadium Improvements, Kansas City,
  • Busch Stadium Master Plan, St. Louis, Missouri
  • Minnesota Twins Site Study, Minneapolis, Minnesota
  • Shea Stadium Redevelopment Study, New York,
  • Florida Marlins New Ballpark, Miami, Florida
  • New Yankee Stadium, New York, New York
  • Las Vegas MLB Study, Las Vegas, Nevada

He recently received the top honor on Sports Business Journal’s list of Most Influential People in Sports Facility Design, Architecture and Development. He currently serves as principal in
charge of the New Yankees Stadium and the New Washington Nationals Ballpark designs.

Given the scope of Santee’s experience, it would have been impossible in one sitting to touch on every ballpark he has had a part in. Topics include the Twins and Marlins continued efforts, and how HOK approaches projects that are not yet funded, how the stadium design process is launched, which designs have been the most challenging, the downsizing of seat capacity in current designs, how upper deck design is approached in the context of lower bowl seating, Busch III, the New Nationals design, how Value Engineering is approached, what options by the client allow for a moving away from the nostalgic, or retro design, and how HOK can approach further work without resting on their laurels.

This extensive interview would have been far longer had Santee been able to talk in detail about both of the upcoming projects in New York in New Yankee Stadium, and the new Mets facility design.

Enjoy.Maury Brown


Selected Ballpark Design Renderings
Courtesy of HOK and the NY Mets

Click on images for Large view

Select links for hi-res versions

Nationals Renderings

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Hi-Res NE View (4.91 megs)

Click to see larger view

Hi-Res NW View (2.02 megs)

Click to see larger view

Hi-Res SE View (1.94 megs)

Click to see larger view

Hi-Res SW View (1.94 megs)

 

Marlins Renderings
Courtesy HOK

Click to see larger view

Hi-Res Aerial (4.87 megs)

Click to see larger view

Yankees Renderings
Coming Soon

Twins Renderings
Courtesy HOK

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

Click to see larger view

BizBall: Your bio mentions that you served as Principal on the first two major league ballpark design-build bridging projects: PNC Park and the New Busch Stadium. Can you explain what a design-build bridging project entails?

Santee: Design build bridging is where we are the design architect and we take the drawings to a certain point in the project. At that point, the contractor hires an architect directly to complete the work and the architect works for the contractor.

We stay with the owner and act as his advocate for design of the project. So the bridging aspect is that we "bridge" the design through the owner and not the contractor—the design build job basically.

In traditional design build jobs, the design architect is the architect of record. In design build bridging all of the cost overruns are born by the design builder, which would include design errors adnomissions and so on. In traditional building that’s not necessarily the case.

BizBall: How big of a role does consensus play in stadium designs that involve public/private partnerships?

Santee: Well, quite a bit.

Obviously, it depends on how strong the team is about their design objectives and then how those design objectives may marry with a community’s objectives for themselves, as far as future planning purposes or master planning purposes…if they want to build more than just one project, and what the influence of the project design might be on that (planning). So building consensus on design is important so everybody has a common direction and common goal, and at the end of the day they feel like there is a broad sense of success that is borne not just by one group.

BizBall: In many cases, you and HOK have been working on some designs that are, for lack of a better word, in limbo. The Twins design and site, along with the Marlins are two of these as the clubs continue to work on funding. How do you approach these projects, and, if you could, explain the adaptability part of that process.

Santee: Those projects are a lot like all of our projects. The most difficult part of any project is getting them funded. That’s as simple as it gets—some projects can be done in a year or two, like in Pittsburgh. Some projects take 15 or 16 years, like San Francisco.

So adapting is not a term I would use; I would probably say that we learn to be patient and let the process take on its own life and let it go its own course.

When the time comes you deal with all the changing environment conditions. Our job at that point— like with both the Twins and Marlins—is to create a sense of excitement and interest in the project that helps support the interest in that project from a funding standpoint and a public acceptance standpoint.

Once funding happens, in most cases, you get into a much more serious design process because you’ve got a schedule, you’ve got money that supports construction and building, and you’ve got risk…risk in the project both from a budget and time standpoint. A lot of it is just being patient and letting the process take its course. It’s different in every State but there is always a process and 9 times out of 10 it’s lengthy and not something that happens in a year or two.

BizBall: Given the number of ballpark projects you are working on, is there a method by which you can take a previous design and use that as a jumping off point, or do you approach each design from scratch?

Santee: They are from scratch. What we do historically is with what we callBaseball 101, because a lot of times when we start a project we have people that don’t understand the design elements and why things are done the way they are, and how those things relate to the building—from a design standpoint, from a functional standpoint, and so on. So we’ll do that at the beginning and then we do a thing which is really just interviewing all the stakeholders and try to get as much input about what they want in the building.

It’s a very traditional kind of architectural process where you’re finding out the needs of the users and you’re finding out facts about the site and about the city. From that you develop a process that creates the building. That kind of gives you the functional side of it (the process).

The form side of it is narrowly driven by, in many cases, one or two people on the owner’s side who have a strong opinion about the form. On the public sector side many, many people have opinions about the form. So you try to take all that into consideration with what the design of the project is moving toward.

In a lot of ways it’s like baking a cake in that you know how many ingredients are there but where and when you put them, and how big the cake is, and how you decorate, is really distinct to each process.

BizBall: Of the 18 MLB ballpark projects that you’ve worked on, which one was the most challenging?

Santee: I think the jobs we have now are the most challenging. The shift from a design perspective is, we’ve done some really great projects and people are happy with them, and now everybody wants to do something different or better.

Understanding that "different" or "better" sometimes makes things more complicated; may take longer or cost more, so this is the challenge within any design process.

The expectations are quite a bit higher now than they had been. They always were high, but now they are higher than they were. I think a lot of times people use the past projects as “okay I know you did this but can you do this?” and they’re changing the paradigm of what these projects are and can be.

They’re challenging…the New York jobs, the DC job, what we had to go through in St. Louis, these are very challenging projects. They challenge us from a design standpoint and they challenge us from a process of how we deal with all the complexities—how many people want to have input into the project. Who we try to satisfy; that’s another key point. Trying to determine who we need to satisfy in the process is very challenging.

BizBall: There seems to be more of a shift now towards revenue generating, such as total seat capacity coming down, there seems to be more emphasis being placed on other revenue streams, mostly in the form of suites. Is that a reasonable comment?

Santee: No. Since the early 1990s revenue was always a mainstay for the purpose of building a new building, along with the functional obsolescence of the buildings there were in. Nowadays suites have really come down.

What I will agree on though, is that looking at revenue in each market is distinct, and that drives the building design to be distinct.

It isn’t all about seats, it’s not all about suites.

In fact, I’d say if anything the baseball suite market has shrunk significantly over the last five years. I mean significantly. It is about providing distinct experiences for the premium seats just like you do with the everyday fan, and that makes the buildings different than what they were before. When we do suites now, there are not many of them and we do them in such a way that they have a position that causes the design to stay uniquely different. Like in Jacobs [Field], where you have three levels of suites along the third base line, but I don’t think you see the suite market driving the design of the projects anymore. In fact, it’s one of those ingredients but we’re definitely in a shrinking suite market and it has been for five years.

I think we’re at the smallest it’s been in a long time. The interesting part about that is that it gives us some more flexibility, because the numbers of suites in these buildings are not an enclosed building form like some football stadiums might be, so that we can put suites in different positions. We know how many suites we can put on one level and it allows us to make a much more intimate seating goal, and more interesting seating goal because we can split the decks up into four or five different organizations that make it interesting for that city or that team.

Revenues have always been there, and think that each team’s leadership really wants to add something to where they know their market really well and they want to work with us to design original and thoughtful forms for their markets. That’s good because it gives the community a much stronger connection to the building and hopefully that strong community connection means more revenue.

BizBall: On the proximity of (especially upper deck) seating to the field ... What's the acceptable distance compared to what it used to be, and where do you see those standards of acceptability going?

Santee: Well, we are designing much smaller upper decks like what you’ll see in St. Louis. There, you have only 9,500 seats in the upper deck, so I think what you’ll see in the future.

From a personal viewpoint, that is my preference: Build as many lower deck seats as I can.

Part of that is usually based on grade or access by the street. The experience of being in the lower deck is much different than being in the upper deck. I’m an advocate of large lower decks, starting with PNC Park and now St. Louis, which both have fairly significant lower deck capacity. So I’m an advocate of large lower decks and small upper decks, for a variety of reasons.

BizBall: Let’s go through a few of the ballparks that you have worked on…

Busch III has been interesting in that it has been developed in phases, and the footprint places it close to an Interstate freeway. How did you approach these aspects?

Santee: The phasing around Busch Stadium—I found out today (3/15/06) that they are finally laying sod. One of the ways to make phase one more function was to move the scoreboard so that it would not be impacted by the demolition of the old Busch Stadium.

I think it was more of a construction feat than a design feat. We put so much emphasis on stuff in the lower deck and things between the baselines, such as left field, which is where the old Busch sat wasn’t as critical for the construction process.

As far as the highway (I-64), we just had to be sensitive about it. We couldn’t push it any farther north because that’s where Busch Stadium was. It’s not unusual to have those kinds of constraints. They were difficult. The highway was something we had to think about from a noise standpoint. The architecture of that side of the building addressed the city and streets and so on, and I think we made reasonably good decisions about it.

We’ve got strong entry and seating points along first and third base and right field, and all of left field and center field are wide open to the city. Our design objective was to connect the building to the city itself and that was strongly related to how we positioned the building on that side, and coincidentally it was adjacent to the highway. But, at the same time it gave it the strongest connection to the city.

BizBall: In the case of some of the current designs you are working on, there is the use of a frieze. Can you go over how HOK decides whether or not to use one?

Santee: Some of our clients want to connect to the history and heritage of the franchise, and that may make for a fairly literal connection that manifests itself in some architecture.

Some of those issues are just logical design solutions to complete the design of the building. That’s one of the things that the Nationals project does, is that it allows a little more freedom for people to think in a broader sense about architecture as it relates to sports.

Historically that’s been (arena design) fairly modernistic in its approach. Football projects, while they started out to be more modernistic, have been both traditional styles and modern styles. Some are transitional, like the Chicago Bears stadium. That makes it interesting.

Baseball fields are baseball fields. It has the same physical dimensions. If you’re doing the job right you’re trying to get the fans to have the most intimate personal experience as you can. The shape of the stadium and its relationship to the field is something you can’t separate. Would we want to? I don’t know if anyone would want to.

I always remember that people said that Oriole Park and Jacobs Field look alike, and I said the only parts where they look alike is the grass field and that they share the same baseball configuration.

The architecture is that one is modern and one is a traditional building form.That’s always been a little bit of a challenge.

The same is true with football; because you’re designing to such a specific sport, and the sport has such a specific size that you try to make the best possible experience for the people who are going to use the building. You would think the seats would conform to the playing field. The only architecture is whatever else you put around the seats, whether it’s more development or inclusive development or exclusive development.

I think in 10 years you really will see a change in how buildings have provoke thought that is connecting the building to more than just the building form. I think you’re going to see more of the St. Louis Cardinals and PETCO analogy where people are trying to do more than just one building at a time, and try to create a district or neighborhood for the community. I think you’re going to see more of that in the future than you do now.

That’s part of the process with DC, is that they are trying to build community and the ballpark is one piece of it. So I think you’ll see more of that. Frankly it’s more fun for us. The more challenging the jobs are the more fun they are. I think that we’ve done quite a few, and having projects that challenge us is a good thing. It’s what motivates us to come to work everyday.

BizBall: On the Nationals design… The use of double decker suites has raised the overall height of the design. I have heard that the new facility will be 21 feet taller than RFK. Can you verify that, and how do you design a facility with this attribute to allow those in the upper deck the best visibility?

Santee: I’ve always stated this on DC, and it too has a large lower deck. Comparatively speaking it probably has half as many upper deck seats as RFK. So what that means is that this is where the whole evaluation analysis comes into play, which doesn’t actually work well, is that we could have added a lot more upper deck seats and gotten some seats a little bit closer. But, I think it’s better that you have a lot more lower deck seats and you have a lot more people closer. That’s really the shift and that is clearly a design shift.

I think they’ve got 23,000 or 24,000 seats in the lower deck, and let me tell you, that’s a great lower deck. If I didn’t do 23,000 or 24,000 seats down there and I put 3,000 or 4,000 more seats in the upper deck—and again this is where I think things are from a design point— I think lower deck seating is a much more valuable play for the fan.

I guess there are people who would rather sit in the upper deck seats than the lower deck seats, and I don’t know why, but I think we’ve had a preference in the last four or five years to create a stronger emphasis on the lower deck seating just because of its accessibility to the fan.

BizBall: There has been talk of trying to get the bouncing stands into the new stands that have become a signature at RFK. Is HOK working on this design aspect for the ballpark?

Santee: It’s been talked about. It’s still part of the design goal, and whether or not it gets executed is another question, but it’s still part of the design goal that was stated early on. That made RFK special to people and whether or not that will make its way to the new building, only time will tell.

BizBall: There has been a considerable amount of attention paid to the funding component of the new Nationals ballpark. The term Value Engineering has been repeated often. Is there a point when the overall aesthetic of the design could be impacted through value engineering, and how have you been so effective in addressing the value engineering component?

Santee: Historically, once we know how much money is being spent purely on construction and that’s been established, we really depend on the construction manager to identify what’s appropriate for that market. Whether that’s structural frame or concrete or steel or mechanical or electrical systems, we really try to work in with the construction manager to make better decisions.

That process went through a lot of VE (Value Engineering), but frankly, a lot of projects go through it because the construction market is as fluid from a pricing standpoint as anything I’ve seen in my career.

Because there is a lot of construction going on, you try to bid the work in a certain marketplace from a competition standpoint, so you get a lot of quality bidders. We just had a hurricane down south that had an impact in construction costs. We’re at kind of a dynamic time as far as how you look at cost. Fortunately for us, a lot of those issues are being dealt with early on. During the VE process you’re basically taking to subcontractors and saying “here’s what we’ve got so what do you think the number is going to be” so you’re actually getting early pricing from them that allows you to make a somewhat informed decision. It’s fairly fluid, so what happens is that after the early information you get some additional information and you have to make some modifications. Every job these days has a fairly extensive VE process.

BizBall: The Nationals design breaks with nostalgic design that has been a large part of ballpark designs by HOK in the recent past. Was there much discussion as to whether to go this route, or was there an effort to have the urban design fit in with some of the other architecture in the Near SE area that is being developed?

Santee: I think the design that was shown yesterday (3/14/06) was really a fairly common design objective that was shown by the city and the sports commission, as well as, the planning commission. It was a fairly common position for what the design should be, and our job was to organize it in a way that gives it a rationale for its purpose and what it looks like.

From what I’ve seen so far the press clippings have been fairly complimentary and people have commented that it took a break, but I’m not certain that if you look at that area there aren’t some changes within four or five or six blocks where there are buildings that have historical value. When you look at DC it has its own history. It’s not like we need to re-create it within a ballpark.

BizBall: Was the placement of the parking structures toward centerfield a design concern in terms of the viewing aesthetics looking out of the ballpark?

Santee: Yes. As architects we thought over everything with those kinds of details. It’s a concern about how big the buildings are and what’s the view to the Capitol—can people see into the ballpark from that side of the city—so those are always concerns.

How they are going to be developed is another question, and those are future questions that I don’t know if they have answers to right now.

BizBall: How important is site selection to the overall astetics of the stadium design? Did that have any impacts to the Nationals design given the unique process that MLB and the District were under?

Santee: The one thing that's different about the DC job is that in most cases is that historically we do the site selection.

Site selection is one of the most crucial aspects of whether or not you create a great building. I think the site we have in Pittsburgh is incredible and immaculate. In DC, that process was an independent process. We were given a program and given a budget and given a site, and asked to design a building and that's where we are today.

BizBall: What type of designs do you feel we’ll see in the next 10 years? Is there the capacity for a radical departure from what we are now seeing?

Santee: I think it depends on the client and the design climate.

Some clients like the Marlins, we had an even more modern looking building than DC and with a roof, and that was because the owner of the team wanted a piece of sculpture.

It just depends on the client and how they see the branding of their franchise and the community and how that’s represented. So I think you’ll see more projects like this one. We’ve embraced the Nationals job and that’s important to us because it does allow us to spread our wings a little bit. We can design modern buildings and we do it all the time. It just happens to be that we have quite a few buildings that have red brick or limestone or something that looks like it has a more traditional feel to it. We can design modern buildings, so I think the Nationals project is an important project for us. It just changes how people perceive how the success of a different design might have on their franchise within their community.

BizBall: Finally, given the number of ballpark designs that HOK has, done as well as those in process, is there ever a worry that HOK might rest on its laurels?

Santee: That’s one of my personality flaws I guess! I want them to be unique and distinctive. Absolutely. It’s part of how you start the process. You have to look at the city first and then you look at the client and then you look at the site possibilities, and all those things kind of drive it. The fresh side of it is that we challenge ourselves to do bigger and better things. Because we’re not a factory; we’re trying to keep this as creative as we can.

Fortunately for us we’re an international company so we go overseas and look at international buildings and study the architecture as an idea to create more interesting things for our clients. I think it’s just the way we’re organized. People call us a corporation but we’re just a group of individuals that love doing what we do and we don’t want to repeat something that we did before. We want every project to be new and fresh because that’s what motivates us to continue.

Let me close on this...one of the things we actually do is listen to peoples' feedback about our facilities. We read the press and we understand that we have a lot of design goals, and we're trying to do all we can do to make every building special to those communities.

In some cases we get opportunities like the Marlins job, which is a very interesting piece of sculpture, and a lot of that depends on how the client is. We have a great enthusiasm to try new and different things.

We have design studio that is full of young architects that we hire from all over the country to come work here and incubate ideas. I think that some of that manifests itself in our buildings as time goes on.


The following interview was originally published on the SABR Business of Baseball website, and can be read here: SABR Business of Baseball Interviews Page

Interview conducted by Maury Brown on 3/15/06
Transcribed by Galen Antle

Edited by Maury Brown
Graphics and layout by Maury Brown

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?