sustiva online usa no prescription purchase motilium in australia maxalt discount coupon is there a generic for cymbalta in canada where to purchase buspar where to buy antabuse from buying pharmacy drugs in mexico lisinopril no prescription needed fluoxetine fast canada premarin billig kaufen buy viagra professional mg 40 mg prozac 300 mg wellbutrin digoxin sales where cholestoplex genuine trandate best price cipla medpro india elocon cream over the counter original artane online low price duphalac uk how to import voltaren rhinocort over the counter order floxin canadian pharmacy best price for real meclizine canadian protonix gonorrhea treatment dosage can women take cialis or viagra buy oxytrol perth australia buy synthroid cheap buy lasix bulk buy eulexin cheap buy accutane online uk pills 100 mg motrin infant where to buy cefixime drugs online what is dispersible doxycycline tablets bp skelaxin from india prednisolone 5mg for dogs side effects viagra canada pharmacy com get prograf las vegas antivert prices cvs generic rx for plavix what does lamictal feel like exelon generic release date viagra without pre generic allopurinol usa pharmacy donde puedo comprar prazosin best online pharmacy generic rumalaya liniment purinethol 50 mg tablet hydrochlorothiazide mims lamisil side effects rash what does atrovent do for copd diflucan 200 mg tablet hyzaar without food ampicillin online no prescription cheap drugstore makeup uk revista palermo rosa online buy keflex from mexico online buy venlor greece clomiphene citrate tablets australia celexa generico online buy tetracycline online pharmacy prescription buy accutane online where levitra coupon bayer bula no rx alesse online safe to buy generic zovirax from usa disgrasil 120 mg cyproheptadine 4 mg appetite can you get high from snorting lamictal zoloft pill canadian order actonel cheap erexin uk levitra or cialis or viagra buy amantadine fast shipping dye free benadryl generic v-gel legal in england mirtazapine reviews 2012 procardia online store where to buy elimite in canada safely ethionamide prices usa cost of lamictal in canada how much will generic singulair cost i pill sumycin website ireland online pharmacy seroquel xr dosage is there a generic drug for effexor xr what does vc mean in phenergan dm trimox cost in canada reglan for men sale in uk is orlistat available over the counter can i get neurontin costo de dostinex en mexico prescriptions without a script buy differin 0.3 gel where can i buy trental in canada cozaar cost without insurance rules for buying claritin d xalatan reviews for men buy cheap finpecia using pay pal how to by glucophage online fast rumalaya delivery birth control pills asacol what are the side effects of diltiazem hydrochloride buy naprosyn online at canada pharmacy donde comprar viagra online espan~a lamictal reviews and dosage hypothyroidism synthroid weight loss cozaar discount card florinef perth australia femara letrozole fertility issues canada drugs vpxl with prescription mircette phone orders diclofenac sodium and alcohol consumption maxaman usa cvs prices buy tamoxifen uk pharmacy generic toprol xl switzerland alphagan brand order terramycin for cats uk brand furosemide buy minocin more drug_side_effects asian veterinary medications no prescription cheap zyloprim mg where can i get serpina pills codeine cough syrup dosage ditropan 20 mg sumycin noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy advair copd side effects lozol online australia fincar looking for oxytrol from canada what is nitrofurantoin mono listaflex carisoprodol posologia buying cialis in singapore can you buy ventolin over the counter in spain prescription buy actos pioglitazone hcl what is micardis plus medication soft cialis us companies only how to use chloroquine online sominex purchase what are the side effects of long term aspirin use what date is lexapro going generic viagra generic canada discount furosemid rezeptfrei apotheke alphagan pharmacies brimonidine generic depakote er side effects exelon starting dose what is celadrin tablets eurax overnight order strattera from india without prescription oral erythromycin for acne in pregnancy what is brand viagra where can i buy viagra tablets how long does it take for promethazine pills to kick in bentyl brand viagra cheap mexico pharmacy how long does it take to get lisinopril out of your system do i need a prescription for prevacid propecia delivery buy lasix greece antabuse for daily use canada promethazine codeine syrup price street fast noroxin delivery flonase in the uk current price snovitra super power amitriptyline generic usa aygestin online pharmacy uk zofran injection prescribing information online erythromycin purchase is there a generic for zanaflex buy effexor xr without capsule 75mg generic antabuse india online pharmacy reviews modafinil what types of female cialis are there how long does it take for bentyl to start working baclofen perth australia how to buy viagra in india bupron sr 150 india differin cream sale can you buy alphagan eye drops call lithium pill shop discount code nitrofurantoin wanted online review estrace delivery london use uroxatral coupon online what drug category is innopran xl quickest female cialis order lariam tablets prednisone for dogs to treat cancer buy aricept mgb no prescription metformin online online pharmacy no prescription needed zestril glaxo wellbutrin lawsuit why has v-gel been discontinued buy provera in uk should women use propecia discount oakley rx sunglasses where can i buy hoodia in south africa where to buy cheap generic amoxil low dose aspirin prices azithromycin generic cost common side effects of levothyroxine finpecia legal in england legal buy pamelor online canada naltrexone implant side effects can i buy zoloft over the counter aygestin brand positioning side effects of venlor xr 75 metformin 1000 mg spc worldwide pharmacy inderal metoclopramide annual sales retin-a ge prix en pharmacie en france how much does valtrex cost do i need a prescription for lasix cheap per pill buy antabuse amaryl 2mg side effects cheapest flagyl er in the uk is atarax over the counter antihistamines uk pharmacies online that sell abilify buy zyvox with cheap crestor 20mg online cost of baclofen at walgreens i missed my dose of wellbutrin buy cheap clomid from uk buy prednisolone online thru paypals list of tesco stores selling probalan compare prices albenza cheapest place to buy imitrex lowest priced altace erection pills that work where to get urispas pct buy nimotop viagra jelly online overnight shipping prednisone generic manufacturer is propecia better than generic finasteride order desyrel cleocin pediatric rxlist generic viagra online canada no prescription pharmacy saw palmetto shortage friv 1000 juegos aleve without a prescription codeine cough syrup dosage recreational acai berry slimming pills reviews where to buy kamagra in pattaya slimming tablets uk alli ketoconazole without prescription what is kamagra chewable drugs lisinopril 20 mg 12.5 paroxetine 20 mg reviews craigslist football tickets manchester alli weight loss pills success stories buy starlix online cheap can you buy permethrin cream over the counter uk cyklokapron from usa cheap diclofenac sodium 50mg uk non prescription diabecon pharmacy cheap kamagra uk com viagra canadian alliance of physiotherapy regulators trained maxalt compare olanzapine 20 mg side effects buy furosemide online from mexico can you take risperdal daily cialis sublingual visa purchase phenergan online roxithromycin 150mg arrow 100mg zoloft not working buy abana in ireland plavix generic release date 2012 levothroid online sales sildenafil citrate 100mg review do i need a prescription for clomid in canada buy forzest generic cialis vs brand name cialis sominex ships from india minocin online meds inderal without prescription canada taking 20mg of prednisone shallaki in the uk onde comprar luvox mais barato best non prescription erection pills femcare delivery london best deal cialis online canadian extremely painful ovulation on clomid acai berry malaysia pharmacy floxin canada overnight delivery legal requirements emergency sale ventolin prescription buy benfotiamine bulk ordering viagra drugstore original acivir pills online benadryl cream rxlist arimidex costco cyklokapron prix en pharmacie en france decadron medication where to buy levitra sale canada 10mg drug market order dostinex plavix lawsuit update 2013 there generic cipro hc otic side effects of seroquel 25mg nexium for purchase without a prescription where to buy anacin drugs online precose cheap where to purchase atacand coumadin necrosis treatment get meclizine las vegas how to get viagra jelly on line cozaar sale prescription reviews on inderal ordering alesse acivir pills uk brand name fertility drugs for menopause provera online from uk tamoxifen usage indian pharmacy association ca donde comprar viagra femenino en buenos aires protonix shop viagra soft tabs dosage saroten retard buy daily dose cialis clomid medicine online alli precios online prevacid dose for infants cheap procardia xl amaryl diabetes med ketoconazole 2 shampoo uk cheapest emsam tablets uk side effects of avapro irbesartan tablets cozaar medication dosage dutas drug class can i take more than 20 mg of levitra cephalexin online shipping cardizem mg buy what is orlistat 60 furosemide 20 mg oral tablet betoptic rxlist valtrex online legally eurax prescription only proscar order in the us remeron australia price what does cytotec mean order lexapro from viagra otc india hyaluronic acid suppositories buy wellbutrin vs bupropion generic cialis 20 mg price walgreens avalide tablets uses elocon no prescription reviews on amaryllis beach resort barbados forum baclofene et alcool syntheroid uk levitra coupon youtube clomid for sale no prescription uk pastillas para ereccion cialis buy indinavir online from usa what is flonase pills used for cheap nolvadex buy acheter kytril abilify in canada pharmacies silagra online store buy diflucan hong kong risperdal for anxiety reviews generic viagra website reviews viagra for sale online approved sale zoloft buy haldol generic benadryl tablets 150 mg acquisto malegra fxt sicuro online sominex online cheap lioresal online usa no prescription anafranil with american express cefixime 400mg genuine acticin 100mg tegretol retard 200 mg tablets canadian pharmacy vermox buy clomid fast delivery artane overseas cialis trial pack generic levitra purchase plavix drug rogaine 5 non perscription countries what is antivert meclizine over counter cipro can you have alcohol with keflex cheap prednisone arjuna pills buy pyridium medication discontinued atorvastatin and amlodipine tablets medicine buy cholestoplex mg generic generic singulair medication buy viagra professional online with mastercard does meclizine make you gain weight what;s in aleve medication where is the drama broadchurch filmed buyers of reglan canada the new order alliance daoc drugstore cialis commercial 2013 how to buy viagra in usa is mail order tinidazole safe vermox 100 mg tabletta adagola'sa non prescription dipyridamole pharmacy tadacip buy online india side effects of sildenafil in children promethazine online order finasteride propecia reviews muscletech 100 premium acai hydroxycut reviews ayurslim delivery london buy inderal with paypal over the counter drugs similar to cephalexin acheter provera best over the counter treatment for erectile dysfunction can you buy xenical online abana herbal medicine himalaya acai trim pills side effects buy diflucan usa celebrex mail order generic suprax kesan pil perancang mercilon how to use pulmicort respules video what is fosamax plus d aldactone prescription blood drugs pariet tablet 10mg how long does it take for zyrtec to work where can i buy diazepam no prescription haridra medicine children depakote without script acheter alli en suisse best place buy benadryl pct herbal medicine for depression anxiety and insomnia a review of psychopharmacology and clinical evidence buy aldara imiquimod cream 5 compazine lowest price best generic lamictal review levitra vardenafil side effects paxil online purchase sito italiano cialis what is augmentin duo forte tablets cialis comprar andorra much does valtrex prescription cost cialis jelly where can i buy it nexium tablets buy cheap genuine lasix online buy online lioresal generic buy finast bulk over counter hyaluronic acid welbutrin without prescription buyers of arimidex canada antabuse alcohol free products how much is dilantin tablets costco pharmacy finpecia price asacol now where can i get liposafe tenormin medication used cleocin gel refills fincar without script is topamax available over the counter viagra sublingual canada otc drugs similar to prednisone viagra online billig kaufen mirapex side effects long term use where can i buy alligator meat in tennessee no prescription celadrin sale elavil medication information zantac medication for babies vasodilan uk brand name lozol australia price i pill paxil website prescription viagra how to take diamox mg side effects of estrace during ivf zoloft no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy cheapest nexium to buy atarax on line nizagara uses medication order tinidazole on line canada why was alesse discontinued high altitude pulmonary edema cialis buying keppra online levlen online prescription buying altace using paypal finpecia pharmacy2home.com buy cheap voveran sr using pay pal where to inject methotrexate injection for ectopic viagra tablets side effects how to buy strattera online worldwide pharmacy plendil desyrel phone orders are diclofenac tablets prescription only albendazole mexico pharmacy fertomid online uk buy chloroquine mg januvia medication cost script purchase albendazole without can you buy pain pills online insulin-international-pharmacy brand name atarax online septilin delivery london naprosyn lowest price tadalafil 10mg vs 20mg what class of drug is flagyl atomoxetine price walmart benzac tablets uk pastillas cytotec precio venezuela unisom overdose symptoms depakote er australia best site get speman danazol pill canadian orlistat tablets purchase on line i pill cytotec website healthy male diet example
Home Jordan Kobritz Andy Oliver Case Highlights Inflexibility Within NCAA Rules

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1071 guests online

Atom RSS

Andy Oliver Case Highlights Inflexibility Within NCAA Rules PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 13
PoorBest 
Jordan Kobritz Article Archive
Written by Jordan Kobritz   
Tuesday, 13 October 2009 12:35

Andy Oliver's case was settled with the
NCAA, but the implications seem far
from over.

The NCAA has been accused of being many things – arrogant, intimidating, oppressive – but stupid isn’t one of them. And they proved it last week when a settlement was announced in the suit brought by Andy Oliver, the former Oklahoma State University pitcher who was punished for violating an NCAA bylaw against having an attorney.

Oliver was drafted out of high school by the Minnesota Twins in the 17th round of the 2006 free agent draft, but opted to play college ball instead of signing a professional contract. Two years later, the NCAA suspended Oliver on the eve of the 2008 NCAA baseball tournament after he admitted that his attorney was present during discussions he had with the Twins in 2006.

His attorney’s presence violated NCAA Bylaw 12.3.2.1, which states that “a lawyer may not be present during discussions between a student-athlete and a professional team or have any direct contact (in person, by telephone or by mail) with a professional sports organization on behalf of” a student-athlete.

In addition to the tournament suspension, the NCAA declared that Oliver should sit out 70% of the Cowboys’ 2009 schedule. Oliver sued, and in a modern day version of David and Goliath, his attorney, Richard Johnson of Cleveland, Ohio, obtained an injunction against the NCAA. The injunction was quickly followed by a trial on the legal issues. In a landmark decision widely hailed for its common sense, the presiding judge lambasted the NCAA for depriving student-athletes of rights that are taken for granted by the rest of us, namely, the right to counsel.

Judge Tygh Tone shot down Bylaw 12.3.2.1, saying the NCAA couldn’t tell student-athletes that they could consult with legal counsel, and then tell counsel how to represent their clients.

The damage portion of the case, which was separated from the trial on the merits, was scheduled to be heard on October 19, but the NCAA wisely settled the case for $750,000 before the matter was presented to a jury. The NCAA has to be declared the winner in this case, regardless of the amount they paid Oliver. And yet, one can certainly understand Oliver’s motivation to put the matter in his rear view mirror. He signed with the Detroit Tigers after being selected in the second round of last June’s draft and his priority needs to be his professional career.

The NCAA had vowed to appeal the case, a process that could have taken 3-5 years and cost millions of dollars. By settling the case, the NCAA merely transferred some portion of its projected legal fees to Oliver in exchange for a dismissal of the lawsuit. In effect, the case disappears, which allows the NCAA to act as if there never was a judicial finding against its Bylaws and actions.

In fact, that’s the position the NCAA took even after Tone’s decision on February 12. The governing body maintained that Bylaw 12.3.2.1 was still in existence, issuing press releases to that effect and threatening student-athletes with loss of eligibility if they ignored the long-standing rules against engaging legal counsel. Those actions almost led to a contempt of court finding against the NCAA.

Even if the decision had not been reversed on appeal, the NCAA could still have argued that it only applied in Ohio. The NCAA’s position would have been that student-athletes in the other 49 states were still subject to Bylaw 12.3.2.1. But that’s not how Judge Tone and other legal experts saw its application. The dismissal of Oliver’s case renders that argument, along with the pitcher’s victory over the NCAA, moot.

The settlement was somewhat surprising, given the NCAA’s avowed objection to settling cases for fear of encouraging future lawsuits. But the NCAA could see the handwriting on the wall, and it didn’t spell “Victory.” For the NCAA, a loss would have constituted a major chip in its heretofore virtually impregnable armor at a time when it is under fire on several fronts for using student-athletes for financial gain. The governing body obviously determined that the potential reward wasn’t worth the risk.

There’s no reason to believe the NCAA won’t continue its unconscionable, heavy-handed, and virtually unregulated abuse of student-athletes. But stupid they aren’t. The Oliver settlement left no doubt about that.


OTHER NEWS FROM THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)


Jordan Kobritz is a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He is a former attorney, CPA, and Minor League Baseball team owner. He is an Assistant Professor of Sport Management at Eastern New Mexico University and teaches the Business of Sports at the University of Wyoming.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?