fosamax osteoporosis osteoporosis perlutex information system rimonabant weight loss acomplia maxalt side effects medication milnacipran depression anxiety confidex silverline exhaust thc pills for sale pharmacy near menlo parkpharmphenamax very lowest price on sildenafil neurontin side effects neurontin 300mg canadian pharmacy no script needed orderpharma coupon cabin zenska viagra no 1 online pharmacy clozapine dosage for schizophrenia cheap dutasteride online aurochem canada pharmacy online periostat 20mg dosage cialis 5 mg price female erection photo plavix uk aventis clomiphene mexico mesalamine 400mg low cost lavitra ciprodex sterile otic suspension for pink eye voltaren manufacturer ospamox 500mg sandoz flexeril side effects irritability tetracycline for fish tryptizol 10mg side effects tabletten gegen hautpilz staxyn 10mg vs viagra macrodantin 50 mg capsule aciclovir dosis how long before cialis takes effect cialic best price 5mg canada alli medication seroquel lawsuit 2013 erection problems solutions antibiotics mail order lynoral ethinyl estradiol safe triamterene online capoten contraindications for nitroglycerin midamor amiloride and hydrochlorothiazide glucophage 1000mg real viagra sale pramipexole dihydrochloride drugstore does walgreens sell cytotec lipitor memory loss side effects buy vardenafil on line tape worm tabs praziquantel dosage for dogs paypal kamagra uk alendronate fosamax medication side losartan hydrochlorothiazide combinationlostacef allopurinol medication uses flexidol relax efectos de sonidos where to buy cialis in hong kong 169 tadalafil kaufen deutschland valium dosage doses sa online pharmacy cialis chlamydia treatment during pregnancy supradol sublingual doses is vigra the same as liviyra azithromycin price itraconazole secnidazole side effects order allopurinol 300 mg online tretinoin cream .025 extenze pills before and after pictures best depression anxiety medication cortef no prescription diltiazem cd piroxicam for dogs with cancer birth control desogen side effects dikloron tablet reviews plavix from india buy viagra online reputable drug 24h coupon cabergoline drug interaction cialis pay by paypal epratenz doxology ovral g side effects best price generic cialis 20 mg estrotab 2mg klonopin methotrexate price increase baclofen 10 mg tabletsbaclofenebactrim asacol side effects mesalamine periactin weight gain doctor duphalac syrup philippines rx rx4u drugs unisom sleep aid cialis europe pain pills online legally uses of beprogel lotion cialis side effects cialis information buy anafranil 25mg septra ds antibiotic drug propecia rezeptfrei periactin 4mg used for migraine treatment cardinal bird feeder vigora 100 viagra alternatives in india percocet 10 street value nolvadex bodybuilding use evista 60 mg buy promethazine hydrochloride online vgr 100 facts about one direction paxil side effects antidepressants google zepose tablets terbinafine 250mg tablets foot care valium information medication online cialis in canada strattera side effects on children livial tablets quality pill no rx valium half life drug test what is clotrimazole side effects cheap cialis sale online omifin embarazo de gemelos identicos buy medroxyprogesterone 10mg pheromones and attraction humans ativan durae daction cialis cost cvs prescription for cymbalta needed vegetal viagra diane sawyer world news tonight isoptin verapamil dosage for svt venlafaxine er 37.5mg what does it do for you canadian meds online antibiotics for strep throat while pregnant vaginal water spray viagra sale in japan pay for viagra with mastercard clomiphene for sale in us estrace cream side effects estrogen omeprazole 40 mg side effects amerimedrx model purchase viagra c o d cash delivery buy prescription viagra online online pharmacy with no prescription inderal la 80 salbutamol vs albuterol nebulizer buy cialis online in hawaii catafast powder ridge cheap orlistat singapore topiramate 50 mg and phentermine 30 m evista medication for bones viagra sandoz glucotrol side effects glipizide bonadoxina medicamentos plavix 75 mg medication glipizide dosages buy viagra from canadian pharmacies buy antibiotics with paypal need a perscription for cipro buy azithromycin or ceftriaxone now mircette side effects oily skin dexamethasone buy online australia reichlox antibiotic levitra per pay pal zahlen why was lodine discontinued trazodone with no prescription cialis para venta al mayoreo prednisone by mail t3 slimming tablets reviews viagra nebenwirkungen quiero comprar accutane enbrel equivalents starcef capsule wardrobe levothroid for weight losslicodexon buying lipitor in mexico avodart side effects moduretic dosage for benadryl buy amitriptyline without rx vipps certified online pharmacy viagra terramycin ointment eprex 4000 injection eldepryl prescribing information kamagra oral jelly review nolvadex pct instructions nasonex vs nasacort otc getting viagra under the counter buy amoxil online with examination cialis for sale online review pharmacy rx one pfizer viagra 100mg pills fertomid information amlodipine medications buy propecia 1mg online purchase periactin online avana stonebriar apartments the colony texas artane dublin map artane 2 mg dosage tylenol recall 2014 ditropan oxybutynin chloride erectile dysfunction jokes over the counter drugs similar to lasix pfizer news release business wire buying drugs online from india cefixime side effects diarrhea suprax 400mg during pregnancy sildenafil citrate 100mg tablets directions astelin dosage for children atarax dosage for children canadian pharmacy mail order sildenafil buy viagra nz content definition translations buy liquid kamagra online mexitil contraindications for tpa is antivert over the counter drug viagra galaxy 8mg colchicina en canada apcalis complaints of a dutiful daughter diamox 500 mg northwest pharmacy canada bagomicina online pfizer terramicina oxitetraciclina polimixina b raloxifene drug class vermox plus adipex 37.5mg adipex p cefadroxil 500 mg purchase metaxalone 800 mg street value omeprazole side effects and cautions dutasteride avodart dht strattera reviews children florinef medication information lasix medication and gout ecoval cream for sale us cheap finasteride canada geriforte ingredients cialis for daily use cost buying viagra without a prescription trileptal depression nasonex nasal spray dosage metoprolol tartrate side effects dreams lisinopril medication flagyl antibiotic for dogs buy clomid canada temovate cream 0 05 uses of coconut accutane 5mg dose of haldol for nausea metformin online pharmacy fertomid 50 drug store cheaper for celebrex paxil reviews for anxiety and depression levitra vs cialis drugs femara fertility treatment pillule viagra metformina efectos adversos del potassium foods potassium supplements clenbuterol for sale weight loss reviews medicinenet mobile art main script benzaclin alternative recommended viagra doses online doxycycline prednisone 20mg dosage instructions pharmacies in india buy exelon online clindamycin cost walmart tetracycline antibiotics for dogs sildenafil citrate ireland how to use tantra oral jelly pharmacies online lasuna food 4 wieviel kostet viagra in der apotheke is canadian health care mall site real yagara sashimiyasmin elocon cream 0.1 cardinal community credit union cialis discount europe vivelle dot viagra en farmacias dutasteride hair loss dosage buy generic valtrex amoxil side effects amoxicillin cialis paypal only furosemide lasix mechanism of action vagiral ovulos divanon kamagranow forum 8kamagraruskamagrashop valtrex australia price fosamax side effects fosamax lawsuit paracetamol tablets with codeine obestat reductil pastile actosol products overnight delivery of viagra in the usa best place buy levothyroxine 200mcg minoxidil 5 solution atrovent hfa inhaler coupon rmc lahaie cialis 20mg synthroid without scrpt yasminelle birth control reviews albuterol mdi doxycycline for dogs dose insurance cialis daily bhp vasotec dosage dose norlevo effectiveness and efficiency software update iphone mountain west apothecary bountiful ut famvir dosage famciclovir how to take menhood max clavaseptin 500mg tylenol antabuse rite aid augmentin dosage for uti cheapest place to buy synthroid plavix shoping desogestrel ethinyl estradiol levothyroxine sodium buy uk cialis preis etodolac 300 mg side effects deltasone side effects clozaril blood draw protocol cialis romania clonidine hcl 0 1mg overnight delivery tegretol bipolar in children tadalafil best price buy robaxin otc zyban smoking side effects buy meclizine over the counter buy albuterol inhaler no prescription tantalum metal scrap robaxin for sale no cephalexin 500 mg capsule uses buy cialis express shipping 244 discount levitra pharmacy purchase buying diclofenac sodium roaccutane side effects treatment hydrochlorothiazide online us pharmacy around world pharmacy review absoslutly no req rx 2 5 lisinipril order medicine canada no prescription original cialis pills evista drug repexelon mail order celebrex savings buy trazodone medication without prescriptions online ciales puerto rico maps discount pharmacy pills all body generic viagra myambutol toxicity symptoms salibet ointment for ringworm buspirone side effects warfarin coumadin rat poison apcalis sx 20mg jellyfish sting zyrtec allergy medication ingredients requip medication dose how much is synthroid without insurance norvasc amlodipine 10 mg coupons aubrey lynch paroxetine 20mg treatment espanol arthrotec side effects misoprostol hydrea side effects hydroxyurea medication paxil on line cialis brand name pills to buy famvir vs valtrex shingles buy ciprodex online pregnant halloween costumes funny olanzapine 10 mg tab where to buy permethrin cream for scabies malegra tablets sertraline 50 mg and alcohol garlic butter recipe with garlic powder protonix generic names cheap viagra 25mg generic cialis in germany drug store thailand online pharmacy prices euroclinix hasselt kermis ranbaxy pharmaceuticals nj furosemide medication dosage picareta minecraft best cheapest way to get cialis calis cialis cheap viagra without subscription vigrx reviews forum antibiotics for bronchitis infections acyclovir 800mg medication for sale opatrovatelky rakusko does cialis daily work better diltiazem hydrochloride cream price viagra 100mg walmart voltaren 50 testosterone cypionate online pharmacy aceon medication flexidol relax efectos para albenza dosage for tapeworm pfizer champix dosage best price for colchicine pharmacies los algodones laxifen tabletas en bausch and lomb lotemax coupon sildenafil 100 pink pill for women viagra tinidazole dosage for lyme celexa for anxiety disorders florinef side effects drug proscar canada motilium new zealand purchase motillium in new zealand cheap online cails pills micardis side effects medication viagra generic shipped in usa zyrtec d side effects long term albuterol inhaler side effects kids naproxen sodium 550 tramadol 50mg tab xerograx capsulas de colageno generic cialis 100mg orderpharma accutane side 35mg force culminate cialis vipps online pharmacies no perscription reichlox 500mg hydrocodone doxepin 50 and weight gain brand cialis 20mg best price lidoderm patch 5 coupons epogen dosage information onadron simplex zyprexa 10mg nolvadex research usa suprax 200 mg/5ml suspension order phenagan on line lotrel generic medication bevispas medication identification adderall weight loss forum furadonin russia serophene and multiple births without fertility glipizide medication ingredients holy cross cottingham caverta online acyclovir side effects doctor overnight delivery strattera farmacia online italia cialis hardon pills antidepressants amoxicillin and alcohol consumption antibiotics blood pressure medications for sale ampicillin cheap paxil reviews for social anxiety disorder frumil ls cefaclor 250 mg po tid tabletten zum abnehmen mit avana stonebriar the colony texas viagra price in india 2013 clindamicina ovulos indicaciones cialis cheap uk no prescription candian pharmacy indomethacin 50 mg capsule what is it used for octreotide injection depot insurance company ratings florida lloyds pharmacy cialis price instant erection pills over the counter where to buy nizoral remeron for sleep disorder neurocet painkiller cialis 20mg price spiriva patient assistance program application viagra for men for sale www where to buy nizoral in canada global pharmacy canada complaints rx online pharmacy india bisoprolol 2.5mg tablet cefadroxil antibiotic for cats cialis free trial offer lotrisone cream otc marcumar medication dictionary losartan hydrochlorothiazide generic ranbaxy laboratories and nexium rosuvastatin malaysia metformina denk 500mg grathazon obat apa yang donormyl blue india noche stilnox side effects medicines online can i take two 5mg cialis skelaxin muscle relaxer side effects buy antibiotics online canada can u get viagra over the counter viagra pour femme en pharmacie sotalol 80 mg tablets sale of viagra in singapore buspar side effects go away canadarx bahamas buy cialis in uk online cialis e20 acyclovir 800 mg for shingles adipex 37.5 side effects viagra uk ebay clindamycin for dogs antibiotic side effects donde comprar viagra en londres no prescription venlafaxine pantoprazole from canada diroton 10 mg nizoral shampoo website thuoc augmentin amantadina nombres comerciales de la viagra and ejaculation female viagra australia bonadoxina pfizer medication assistance bystolic 10 mg tablet side effects fanegada wikianswers mobic medication for pain alli order vardenafil cheap 5 10 mg medameds complaints against doctors
Home Maury Brown Expanded Thoughts On the Moneyball Philosophy in MLB

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 976 guests online

Atom RSS

Expanded Thoughts On the Moneyball Philosophy in MLB PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 15
Written by Maury Brown   
Thursday, 17 September 2009 00:22


Last week, Michael Hiltzik of the Los Angeles Times ran a story in the Business section entitled “Oakland A's performance shows that 'moneyball' doesn't always pay off”, with the lead-in reading, “The use of statistical analysis to identify underappreciated players may lead to periods of success, but the concept has never been a panacea for the problems of a low-budget team.” Myself and Kevin Goldstein of Baseball Prospectus were interviewed for the article. Here are some added thoughts to go along with my quotes.

It’s been six years since Michael Lewis published Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game. Depending on your point of view, that’s either a long time ago, or just yesterday (after all, a movie is being made about it). But, the “moneyball” philosophy is ever present as the economy places added pressure on small-to-mid revenue making clubs, while the Yankees, and other larger revenue making clubs continue to outpace the majority of league in player payroll spending. The idea that “winning an unfair game” using objective analysis to find undervalued talent continues to be a hot bed of discussion.

So, when Michael Hiltzik of the Los Angeles Times contacted me, asking the question, “Does moneyball still work based upon the A’s losing season?” the answer was, “depends”.

"Moneyball" works, it’s just that when Billy Beane and the A’s engaged in the philosophy, other clubs weren’t – they had a bit of a monopoly. They drafted exceptionally well, garnering three incredible pitchers in Hudson, Zito, and Mulder without having any high picks. From 2000 to 2007, they didn't have a pick in the top 15. Now, large and small revenue making clubs use sabermetrics to one degree or the other; the Athletics no longer corner the market. That, and moneyball is not the be-all-end-all for success. As I was quoted in Hiltzik’s article:

"Moneyball works in giving you another set of tools," says Maury Brown, a veteran baseball analyst and founder of the Biz of Baseball website. "But you still need good scouting, and luck -- you have to draft well and get everyone hitting at the same time."

Expanding on “luck” is to say, that injuries or forecasting or talent spikes or… well, the unpredictability of the game, impedes the road map to success. The moneyball philosophy should no longer be excluded from any major league organization, but, as mentioned, it’s a cog in the wheel.

The other point made in the article surrounds the discussion of the level of player payroll being tied to winning. Whether it’s the Tampa Bay Rays, or the Colorado Rockies, or the Florida Marlins, there have been clubs with small-to-mid level payrolls that have played in, or in the case of the Marlins, won the World Series. Doesn’t this show that moneyball works? Not exactly.

The biggest shift in parity for Major League Baseball hasn’t been revenue sharing, or the use of moneyball, it’s been the introduction of the wild card – the key to getting into the postseason for some clubs without high payrolls. Note that I said some clubs. What about teams like the Rays who won their Division outright? The problem is one of sustainability.

As noted within Hilzik’s article, both Goldstein and I talked about large revenue making clubs with high player payrolls being able to put together a string of winning seasons, as opposed to low-to-mid revenue making clubs only getting the occasional season where they have a shot.

"Without a high-priced payroll, you can't be expected to win year in, year out," baseball analyst Brown says.

Or as Goldstein put it when I asked him what it would take for a small-market team to build a dynasty that would stand for years: "You better be stocked with geniuses."

Of course, there are always exceptions to the “big payroll = winning” model. Look no further than the Mets (ranked 2nd) and Cubs (ranked 3rd) for high payroll clubs that will miss the playoffs. But, in the end, clubs in large markets, ergo, high revenues, have larger margins to work with; a bad contract can be more easily absorbed than a club with low revenues. For those clubs, the margin for error becomes much smaller.

In the end, moneyball works, regardless of the A’s losing season. Just because Billy Beane became its poster child due to a book doesn’t mean that he’s impervious to other trappings over time. Oh, and consider this: The A’s had an opening day payroll of $62,310,000, and increase of 29.90 percent from last season when they had $47,967,126 opening day payroll. So, are the A’s ditching moneyball? Hardly. Their opening day payroll was $79,938,369 in 2007 and $62,243,079 in 2006. The A’s simply had adjusted in prior years to give themselves flexibility this season. Now, if only everything had projected exactly as planned...

In the end, those with low-to-mid level revenues to work from will have to regularly draft and develop players better, work to wrap up their best talent through salary arbitration eligibility years, or early free agency, and yes… use moneyball to find undervalued talent, if they want to make steady runs into the postseason. It works, but as Goldstein mentioned in the LA Times article, "You better be stocked with geniuses."






Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network (select his name in the dropdown provided).

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter




Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?