paroxetine online usa no prescription canadian health care mall virus generic drug prices canada vs us imiquimod cream 5 buy buy calcium carbonate powder uk is it is itlegal to buy prescription drugs from india are ed drugs covered by insurance accutane name in mexico where to get propecia in uk over the counter prevacid vs prescription prevacid walmart pharmacy hours in canada viagara falls band nj problemas diabetes y disfuncion erectil benadryl online australia coreg tablets from buy azithromycin 250 mg pak tab sandoz intralesional triamcinolone alopecia areata can order pulmicort canada where to buy renagel online canada paroxetine by mail periactin drug in usa pharmacy fucidin h cream acne reviews what is wellbutrin sr 100mg mirapex sale what is crestor 20mg purchase ethionamide cheap periactin sale uk is renagel legal in uk can you get high off paroxetine hcl differin gel 0.1 buy all types coumadin pills american phenergan nexium 40 mg tablet price what is a pill called mobic prednisone prices at costco cleocin medication where to buy world football stats what are the side effects of zyprexa altace coupons augmentin 100mg cheep buy abana with pharmacy safe reglan buy cymbalta approved in uk trazodone cost walmart bentyl lawsuit purchasing lisinopril online prazosin 1 mg tablet what does hoodia do alli over counter diet pill lamisil tablets for jock itch best place to buy acticin in canada artane credit union opening times z pack antibiotics during pregnancy where do i bactrim in usa arimidex lawsuit there generic advair diskus tesco pharmacy slough opening times what is clomid drugs used for hoodia legal in england cialis soft where can i buy erexor for men in usa seroquel tablets can you buy promethazine over the counter in the uk meclizine over the counter walmart chloroquine where to get best place to buy nizoral in mexico frumil tablets dosage brand levitra over the couter buy actos online without a prescription l-tryptophan generic reviews med cab atarax blopress generic cheap costs gyne-lotrimin online uk get anabuse topamax over the counter india legal sell kamagra online buy viagra paypal account how to buy fml forte in london what type of infections does cipro treat is it legal to bring viagra into the uk buy antabuse online amazon amoxicillin trihydrate 500mg uses walmart generic prices prescriptions prograf online uk buy generic levitra plus online motrin in the uk now glucophage medicine children tricor 48 mg price claritin d price walmart erectile dysfunction drugs with the least side effects cialis 40 mg safe common side effects of lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide order finpecia without prescription buy keflex 200 didronel delivery uk acheter cytotec avortement best site get atarax what is clonidine hcl .1 mg used for what are the side effects of norvasc how to get premarin in australia where can i buy cardizem mg forzest brand positioning buy amoxil online no prescription generic inderal next day shipping information on zyprexa medication where is alligator alley restaurant xenical back order fluconazole for thrush dose levitra medicine order coreg online uk global stats counter elavil dosage cats cytotec comprar femara letrozole buy no prescription cialis side effects cialis vs viagra online medicine store in chennai vardenafil review revia order by phone cheap cost antibiotics online without www indiatvnews com aap ki adalat long term effects of accutane on women viagra canadian online raclet allegra for sale aspirin with no rx content marketing uk propecia side effects cure allies web canadian forces links voltaren retard 75mg tablets periactin shoppers drug mart zyban pharmacy how to take provera 5mg artane medication yasmin online purchase bupropion tablets 100 desyrel sublingual dosage what is nolvadex for men female cialis 100mg cheap is generic viagra soft effective my zenegra coupons buy levitra online overnight nice 1000 games play handless millionaire can order dulcolax canada topamax prices pharmacy buying aricept retin-a 0,025 non perscription countries sominex sold over counter mircette 40mg can you take flovent daily aygestin perth australia buyers of actoplus met canada is patanase better than astelin cost of paxil at walmart buy tetracycline mexican pharmacies tretinoin cream 0.025 uk order ortho tri cyclen cheap buy evecare new zealand online what quantity of aspirin is contained in most over the counter apirin products etodolac mrp generic lipitor ranbaxy amoxil overnight delivery non persciption propranolol buy tamoxifen canada estrogen prescription robaxin-750 pariet uses medication original methotrexate online pet allies show low az directions what does amitriptyline feel like buy exelon fast shipping 500 mg cheap zyvox combivent pharmacy can you snort gabapentin capsules asacol enema package insert best site to buy lanoxin cost of avapro 300 mg buy flonase hong kong nasal spray lady era pill shop discount code clozaril by mail order suhagra brands india brand brand viagra buy alli refill tablets uk ayurslim uk brand name ordering nimotop sildenafil citrate 100mg and dapoxetine 60mg elocon side effects ointment lowest price amitriptyline prevacid for infants does it work trazodone for sleep weight loss prescription medicine keftab from europe generic zestril 20 mg ponstel pills florida duetact ciplox oz tablets cialis soft online in canada mail order prazosin zovirax pill shop discount code acquistare cafergot in italia walgreens canada rd hwy 64 pliva 433 pill white buy over the counter chloramphenicol online buy dapoxetine online at canada pharmacy benicar on line no script effexor xr for purchase without a prescription buspar for anxiety attacks cost of zofran iv do i need a prescription for zovirax cream ranitidine hydrochloride tablets side effects comprar pyridium pela internet generic robaxin overnite shipping ampicillin tr 500 mg cap cytoxan overseas nizagara shipping overseas where to buy aspirin gum what is prednisone for dogs used for pfizer diflucan fluconazole wellbutrin sr order canada genuine viagra cheapest erexin-v tablets from buy top drugstore makeup products 2012 rumalaya online sales eli lilly cymbalta lawsuit all types clonidine pills purchase finpecia coumadin overnight pharmacy what is suhagra used for actonel once a month australia how to buy aricept glipizide for sale augmentin costco price glycomet medication kamagra soft over the couter amiloride hcl dose delivery buy generic abilify can you buy stromectol over counter valtrex without a prescription from us hong kong buy haldol online drugs compazine comprar buy online menosan generic viagra sublingual australia price ciprofloxacin side effects bnf cheap nolvadex uk coming off premarin side effects tinidazole dosage 250 mg buy micardis line minomycin to buy in england best price for real speman atorlip-20 discount celexa website pill identifier tool celebrex from usa pharmacy low price clozaril uk where can i purchase proventil zyban online kaufen viagra discount canada side effects of himcocid cyklokapron shelf life how much is my prescription without insurance elavil antidepressant side effects can you get rogaine 5 cardura canada head office chloromycetin overnight pharmacy mail order baby alligators premarin price in india 2 claritin pills buy dutasteride hair loss purchase lorazepam online no prescription can you order promethazine with codeine online augmentin 100mg best price for real female cialis cheap prescription buy zyprexa chloromycetin generic 2013 drugs comprar skelaxin portugal what is methocarbamol 400 mg printable coupons for voltaren gel prilosec online usa buy mobic online in usa what is sarafem used for cheap didronel pills buy minocin 80 mg online diclofenac potassium retail price buy synthroid online without rx where accutane canada gabapentin withdrawal symptoms pictures discount coupon for cymbalta i want to pay some strattera where to buy dilantin can you buy moduretic in ireland cialis import singapore how much will tamoxifen cost order erection packs 1 package bonus where to buy alli weight loss orlistat how long to use differin gel suhagra over the counter drugs cheap yasmin birth control australia can you buy lamisil online drugstore terbinafine sominex online pay paypal cheap xenical usa pilex dosage sarafem 10 mg reviews search engine optimisation tips voveran online meds what is mentat can you order aldactone ordering prescription medicines online paxil perth australia prednisone deltasone adverse effects buy lexapro 50 drugs like paxil how to get abana in australia buy nizagara from india tenormin online overnight shipping cheap generic venlor mg cabgolin order in the us best weight loss supplement for women over the counter diclofenaco sodico 50 mg dosis nin~os where can i order toradol anacin shortage canada tinidazole 1000mg arimidex tablets alcohol indian steel alliance advertisement max dose celebrex per day minomycin non perscription countries advair diskus on line in the uk buy uk kamagra oral jelly nitroglycerin drug class canadian online pharmacy using paypal what is cozaar que es lincocin con eucalipto ortho tri-cyclen generic name unisom generico online cheap vermox usa buy confido himalaya albendazole treatment how to order desyrel online trandate online overnight etodolac 300 mg tablet clozaril generic drug obtaining a viagra prescibtion cialis 5 mg daily effectiveness phone in order for amitriptyline purchase generic zyban amitriptyline without food cardura generic wikipedia drugs what states sell phenergan without a ptescription? what is the dosage for motrin for infants buy cytotec no prescription fast delivery buying augmentin ziter pharmacy windsor canada hours where do i arimidex in india can buy antibiotics online uk azithromycin buy zofran no prescription fast delivery where viagra professional revista palermo blanca online robaxin fast canada where can i get viagra today buy shatavari australia depakote phone orders casodex drug class acivir online canada hoodia over counter cipla pharmaceuticals products generic chloramphenicol safe zanaflex drugstore.com otc similar to flagyl nitroglycerin discounts codes what is hyzaar for how to get cheap prescriptions without insurance top 100 otc meds what does the drug phenergan do treatment tadapox uk next day delivery generic sarafem pmdd health canada rogaine 5 ordering silagra levitra discount im toradol shortage fda approved pharmacies aldactone noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy keppra xr generic reviews can bentyl be abused where to get bupron sr pct methotrexate mail order safe apcalis sx buy retin a micro gel 04 reviews glucophage no script buy nimotop in ireland overnight generic viagras nizoral online in usa acquistare lady era in italia radio ad viagara $5 viagra jelly 40mg cymbalta without food shuddha guggulu side effects uk celexa next day lotensin medicine online viagra from india forum tamoxifen overnight generic from fucidin generic for lipitor availability purchasing acai online tab fertomid 100mg what is aspirin yahoo internal medicine alliance tucker ga kikisu tribulus terrestris taking meclizine during pregnancy can you buy revatio men s sildenafil lisinopril discount card nizoral pharmacy order best place buy accutane online buying cleocin gel abilify shopping fincar medication hcg pharmacies in broward county order erection packs 11 online without baclofen drug store online danazol pharmacy order provera pills online in the usa cheap generic viagra 100mg generic benadryl safe names of pills that can get you high zovirax mist canada augmentin spain over counter how to buy yasmin diclofenac sodium importer online pharmacy kamagra chewable best prices buy prandin order prandin cheap cialis trial packs cheap amoxil usa pharmacy cozaar 100 review cytotec philippines order is colchicine available in india ponstel pharmacy order what is asthma attack buy ginseng in bulk suppliers of atacand in us strattera daily use reviews is canadian pharmacy for viagra a ripoff sarafem 5mg tablets generic wellbutrin problems npr how fast can you get pregnant while taking metformin free coupon for clonidine aspirin price increase citalopram hbr 20 mg generic prescription ranitidine order generic chloroquine cheap tofranil sale uk side effects of saw palmetto capsules buy erexin online thru paypals buy cardura 8 mg online grifulvin v purchase how to import baclofen where can i buy alligator meat in ohio abilify commercial narrator motilium from usa pharmacy united support systems western drug aceon chloromycetin to buy in england voveran sr online bestellen buying eldepryl using paypal kamagra gold generic name purchase levaquin 750 mg generic elavil pills purchase vermox in mexico keftab women buy health canada actos bladder cancer canadian atrovent tablet xeloda next day shipping buy frumil tablets ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablets information no rx pharmacy online med express pharmacy salisbury nc bystolic company lioresal echeck viagra pfizer wiki what is cialis tadalafil 20 mg used for purchase tetracycline viagra originally heart medication how to order femara online flomax pharmacy differin online meds where to buy cytotec pills generic glucophage manufacturers ethionamide buy online us buy famvir 15mg online isoptin tablets uk non persciption tetracycline how long does it take for proscar to work for bph best generic cialis prices what is cardizem cd flovent australia ciprofloxacino normon 500 mg efg prospecto amantadine no prescription lisinopril bonus pills coltivare il ginseng in italia order diovan tablets lasuna legal us what are the negative side effects of cialis buy chloramphenicol no prescription prescription drug atrovent pharmacies that have isoniazid over the counter substitute for keflex differin online without rx artane tablets uses what is keftab pills used for comprar myambutol portugal cheap keppra 100 mg what is ampicillin for no generic premarin levaquin discount price cheapest price xalatan buy antabuse online thru paypals how long does it take differin gel to work does generic propecia work as well farmacias venden alli mexico cost generic paxil without insurance canadian viagra online fedex carbozyne over counter uk xenical online bestellen schweiz fluoxetine 100mg cheep cleocin medication uses rhinocort results forum kamagra coupon code order trandate online uk how long does it take for proscar to leave the body how to take lotensin mg rhinocort aqua discount coupon where can i buy viagra in toronto what is cialis for women used for cialis professional sale online discount blood pressure medicine zestril can i buy viagra over the counter in thailand pills buy vermox us fallout wiki mentat albuterol sulfate inhalation solution buy online brand cialis birth control online australia nice guidelines donepezil pharmacy that sells artane buy genuine minipress uk buy synthroid online no perscription cheap isotretinoin online sinemet 40 mg pharmacy buy atacand from canada get best results using cialis feldene tablets side effects free viagra order online overnight buy ampicillin pills online can you buy mg betapace without buy cialis jelly from india lipitor 80 mg price philippines flomax results forum buy levitra professional 80 mg online para que se usa el zyprexa plavix 75mg indication biggest indian pharmaceutical companies where to buy remeron with amex how much is accutane in canada coming off zoloft crying cialis sale uk discount european pharmacy students association what does prevacid contain how can i get viagra today order wellbutrin from canada retin online order rumalaya without prescription canada elocon ointment during pregnancy flovent direct pharmacy differin generic available indian pharmacy minipress estrofem 2mg tablet cheap roxithromycin india where to buy promethazine and codeine cough syrup order albendazole on line usa how to order forzest online buy viagra sublingual 50 levitra plus to buy from europe brand viagra online canadian pharmacy approved coumadin generic cheap costs como comprar lamisil epivir-hbv cheap price doxazosin mg buy aspirin for chest pain dose antabuse generic wikipedia drugs india triamterene price acheter finpecia buy evista discount reglan cheap uk can take 2 unisom tablets effexor xr cheap uk pharmacy cheap cozaar 25mg
Home

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1216 guests online

Atom RSS

The Battle Over Content Fair Use Places "Aggregators" in the Crosshairs PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 18
PoorBest 
Maury Brown Article Archive
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 04 August 2009 03:27

The Biz of Baseball - ExclusiveCORRECTION: Within the article, Bart Hubbuch of the New York Post referenced ESPN's Buster Olney as someone that he believes links "properly." The article then went on to reference an article/video piece with Olney that has references to the Washington Post without linking back.

Olney contacted me to say that he only was involved in the video piece, and the cooresponding article is an ESPN news service piece, based largely on what Pedro Gomez reported and augmented by the info from the Washington Post.

The article has been corrected to reflect this.


If you follow sports on the web, you most likely read ESPN, or SI, or The New York Times. And just as likely as you are to read those traditional media outlets, you might be just as likely to make Baseball Think Factory, MLB Trade Rumors, or MetsBlog your daily stop.

 

Both types of sites are exceptionally popular.

Both, for the most part, are very different.

The new media sites mentioned have been called by some as "aggregators", sites that sweep the web, find the best stories for their given audience, and either copy and paste a paragraph or two of article with a link back, or describe the gist of the article in total and link back.

The value of these sites is that they make it easy to go to a single location and get information from a broad range of sites and then engage in commentary with others in a blog format.

For some that write for the larger traditional sites that get linked to – at least for some of the writers – aggregators are stealing content.

What is Fair Use?

At the heart of the debate is what is deemed as fair use of content. At its extreme, if you copy>paste an entire article in a blog, and don’t link back, it’s a clear sign of copyright infringement. But, from there, it becomes a case of interpretation.

For example, if an article is three paragraphs long, and a blog lifts two paragraphs, you can make a solid case that it does not fall within the “fair use” boundaries. But, what if the article is 5 or 6 paragraphs, the blogger lifts two paragraphs, and then writes a lengthy commentary around what was pulled and links back? What then? At that point, you have what has been considered traditional blogging since, well… blogging pretty much began.

But, there are a writers that see that method as over-stepping the boundaries. The argument goes, if the entire gist of the article is republished, why would anyone feel the need to actually click to the originating content?

This past Sunday, Ian Shapira of the Washington Post bemoaned the aggregating of content in an article entitled, The Death of Journalism (Gawker Edition). That caught the eye of Bart Hubbuch, the Mets beat writer of the New York Post, who said on Twitter that if you replaced “Gawker” with “metsblog.com” you’ll know exactly how Mets beat writers feel. As Hubbuch continued, “Beat writers object when aggregators cut and paste large sections and quotes from stories.”

Aggregators as Bloggers and Traditional Media Outlets

Hubbuch made a clear point that he views aggregators as different from bloggers, saying, “I have no objections whatsoever to bloggers who do their own work.”

The problem is, the lines can get particularly gray in this regard.

A good example is the SportsBusiness Daily, an extension of the SportsBusiness Journal, who is owned by American City Business Journals. The site is considered an electronic trade magazine, and is rarely, if ever, called a blog or aggregator. The SBD, is a subscription based site, that not only reports on news from other outlets, it provides an extensive amount of information researched and reported from the SportsBusiness Journal staff. They are considered the premiere sports business media outlet. As mentioned, they are a subscription based outlet. As an example, a single user, six month (26 weeks) rate is $700. (see an example of a page from the SportsBusiness Daily – PDF).

Yet, when I asked Hubbuch if he sees the SportsBusiness Daily as being guilty of aggregating content, he said, “Yes it is, in my opinion. Especially with how much the [SportsBusiness Journal] charges for that. I wonder how many publications are aware of SBD…” adding, “…and how freely they cut and paste. I see SBD, and there isn't even that many links in there.”

What About Referencing Without Linking In Mainstream Articles?

Pressed for what Hubbuch sees as the proper method for linking back to content, he cited Buster Olney’s blogging technique of a “one-sentence tease” with a link as being “spot on” – fair use.

However, a search of ESPN brought up this video/article on the Nationals and efforts to sign Stephen Strasburg.

Olney is only within the video, and did not contribute to the corresponding article. It is published as an ESPN News Service piece by Pedro Gomez. The total length of the article is six paragraphs tied to a video clip. Of the six paragraphs, three contain details with the reference, “according to the Washington Post.” There is no link to the Washington Post, simply the citation. Is this fair use? It is unknown whether ESPN has any agreements with the Washington Post, but if not, it points to another instance of how content is republished across media outlets.

That aside, referencing other news sources does occur in mainstream media, through lucrative content agreements. An example of this can be seen in this The Associated Press article from Monday in regards to The Boston Globe story on two security staffers with the Red Sox being fired after being linked to steroid use. The AP agreements allow not only licensed outlets to publish AP stories, but The AP has the right to reference the content of those that license content of The AP.

Fair Use Will Move Beyond Just Opinion

The issue of fair use of content is moving out of the sphere of personal opinion between those that provide original content, and those that aggregate that news. In June of 2008, a blogger was sued by The AP over six disputed blog entries, one of which had “18 words from the story and a 32-word quote by Hillary Clinton.”

The Associated Press Board of Directors voted this past March that “it would launch an industry initiative to protect news content from misappropriation online.”

In a statement at the time, AP Chairman Dean Singleton said the news cooperative would work with portals and other partners who properly license content – and would pursue legal and legislative actions against those who don‘t.
“We can no longer stand by and watch others walk off with our work under misguided legal theories,“ Singleton said at the AP annual meeting, in San Diego. As part of the initiative, AP will develop a system to track content distributed online to determine if it is being legally used.

Standards For Fair Use Sets Up a Likely Court Challenge

While The AP seems to be drawing a clear line in the sand, other media outlets have yet to follow suit, although it may be simply a matter of time. Legal challenges seem a near certainty as the statements give way to practice.

As mentioned, one of the aggregators Hubbuch takes issue with is Matthew Cerrone’s MetsBlog.com, one of, if not the most popular Mets outlets on the web. As Cerrone was pulled into the Twitter conversation on fair use, he said in one Tweet, “WFAN just cited a newspaper report on air. I tried to click the link, but it was radio, so I guess I can't read the original report.”

While comedic, it begs the question: What news can be re-reported without crossing the “copyright infringement line?” It’s an extreme example but will Re-Tweets on Twitter become simply aggregating? If content is going to be policed, then there will need to be standards by which all will be held, a difficult legal matter that is bound to touch on copyright use.

Finally, One Might Consider the Following...

The newspaper industry has seen collapse after collapse due to waning revenues as news becomes readily available across multiple platforms. With newspaper website ad revenues becoming critical to their bottom line, playing hardball with aggregators could present a case of the aggregators finding less stringent sources to follow, which in turn lowers page views to stories once linked to, which, in turn lowers critical revenues, which, in the end, could lead to more layoffs and shutdowns in the print industry. While aggregating content may rub some writers raw, they are, in many ways, supplementing their paychecks. There needs to be a proper line between fair use, and cutting the flow of revenues off at the spigot by cutting aggregators off entirely. I'm reminded of the old saying... Don’t bite the hand that feeds.

Normal 0 false false false MicrosoftInternetExplorer4

If you follow sports on the web, you most likely read ESPN, or SI, or The New York Times. And just as likely as you read those traditional media outlets, you might be just as likely to make Baseball Think Factory, MLB Trade Rumors, or MetsBlog your daily stop.

Both types of sites are exceptionally. Both, for the most part, are very different.

The new media sites mentioned have been called by some as aggregators, sites that sweep the web, find the best stories for their given audience, and either copy and paste a paragraph or two of article with a link back, or describe the gist of the article in total and link back.

The value of these sites, is that they make it easy to go to a single location and get information from a broad range of sites and then engage in commentary with others in a blog format.

For some that write for the larger traditional sites that get linked to – at least for some of the writers – is that they view aggregators as stealing content.

What is Fair Use?

At the heart of the debate is what is deemed as fair use of content. At its extreme, if you copy>paste an entire article in a blog, and don’t link back, it’s a clear sign of copyright infringement. But, from there, it becomes a case of interpretation.

For example, if an article is three paragraphs long, and a blog lifts two paragraphs, you can make a solid case that it does not fall within the “fair use” boundaries. But, what if the article is 5 or 6 paragraphs, the blogger lifts two paragraphs, and then writes a lengthy commentary around what was pulled? What then? At that point, you have what has been considered traditional blogging since, well… blogging pretty much began.

But, there are a writers that see that method as over-stepping the boundaries. If the entire gist of the article is republished, why would anyone feel the need to actually click to the originating content?

This past Sunday, Ian Shapira of the Washington Post bemoaned the aggregating of content in an article entitled, The Death of Journalism (Gawker Edition). That caught the eye of Bart Hubbuch, the Mets beat writer of the New York Post, who said on Twitter that if you replaced “Gawker” with “metsblog.com” you’ll know exactly how Mets beat writers feel. As Hubbuch continued,Beat writers object when aggregators cut and paste large sections and quotes from stories.”

Aggregators as Bloggers and Traditional Media Outlets

Hubbuch made a clear point that he views aggregators as different from bloggers, saying, “I have no objections whatsoever to bloggers who do their own work.”

The problem is, the lines can get particularly gray in this regard.

A good example is the SportsBusiness Daily, an extension of the SportsBusiness Journal, who is owned by American City Business Journals. The site is considered an electronic trade magazine, and is rarely, if ever, called a blog or aggregator. The SBD, is a subscription based site. As an example, a single user, six month (26 weeks) rate is $700. (see an example of a page from the SportsBusiness Daily – PDF).

Yet, when I asked Hubbuch if he sees the SportsBusiness Daily as being guilty of aggregator of content, he said, “Yes it is, in my opinion. Especially with how much the [SportsBusiness Journal] charges for that. I wonder how many publications are aware of SBD…” adding, “…and how freely they cut and paste. I see SBD, and there isn't even that many links in there.”

What About Referencing Without Linking In Mainstream Articles?

Pressed for what Hubbuch sees as the proper method for linking back to content, he cited Buster Olney’s blogging technique of a “one-sentence tease” with a link as being “spot on.” – fair use.

However, a search of ESPN brought up this article by Olney on the Nationals and efforts to sign Stephen Strasburg.

The total length of the article is six paragraphs tied to a video clip. Of the six paragraphs, three contain details with the reference, “according to the Washington Post.” There is no link to the Washington Post, simply the citation. Is this fair use? Without placing words in Hubbuch’s mouth, the difference may be that Olney’s referencing of the Washington Post story is a rare exception, not the rule. Olney is considered one of the best in the baseball business for breaking news. He’s hardly an “aggregator”.

But, the point being made here is it’s difficult to say that it’s unacceptable for a new media outlet to aggregate news, when traditional news sources do it almost daily. A quick search finds that gold standard news organizations such as The Associated Press did so on Monday in regards to The Boston Globe story on two security staffers with the Red Sox being fired after being linked to steroid use.

Fair Use Will Move Beyond Just Opinion

The issue of fair use of content is moving out of the sphere of personal opinion between those that provide original content, and those that aggregate that news. In June of 2008, a blogger was sued by The AP over six disputed blog entries, one of which had “18 words from the story and a 32-word quote by Hillary Clinton.”

The Associated Press Board of Directors voted this past March that “it would launch an industry initiative to protect news content from misappropriation online.”

In a statement at the time, AP Chairman Dean Singleton said the news cooperative would work with portals and other partners who properly license content – and would pursue legal and legislative actions against those who don‘t.
“We can no longer stand by and watch others walk off with our work under misguided legal theories,“ Singleton said at the AP annual meeting, in San Diego.
As part of the initiative, AP will develop a system to track content distributed online to determine if it is being legally used.

Standards For Fair Use Make a Likely Court Challenge

While The AP seems to be drawing a clear line in the sand, other media outlets have yet to follow suit, although it may be simply a matter of time. Legal challenges seem a near certainty.

As mentioned, one of the aggregators mentioned Hubbuch takes issue with is Matthew Cerrone’s MetsBlog.com, one of, if not the most popular Mets outlets on the web. As Cerrone was pulled into the Twitter conversation on fair use, he said in one Tweet, “WFAN just cited a newspaper report on air. I tried to click the link, but it was radio, so I guess I can't read the original report.”

While comedic, it begs the question: What news can be re-reported without crossing the “copyright infringement line?” It’s an extreme example but will Re-Tweets on Twitter become simply aggregating? If content is going to be policed, then there will need to be standards by which all will be held, a difficult legal matter that is bound to touch on copyright use.

Finally, One Might Consider the Following…

The newspaper industry has seen collapse after collapse due to waning revenues as news becomes readily available across multiple platforms. With newspaper website ad revenues becoming critical to their bottom line, playing hardball with aggregators could present a case of the aggregators finding less stringent sources to follow, which in turn lowers page views to stories once linked to, which, in turn lowers critical revenues, which, in the end, could lead to more layoffs and shutdowns in the print industry. While aggregating content may rub some writers raw, they are, in many ways, supplementing their paychecks. There needs to be a proper line between fair use, and cutting the flow of revenues off at the spigot. As they say, don’t bite the hand that feeds.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network (select his name in the dropdown provided).

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown and the Business of Sports Network on Twitter Twitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?