forum site fiable viagra paxil without food what is ranitidine for babies is allegra d available over the counter medications order accutane online in usa overnight pharmacy order deltasone cod nexium 40 mg 14 tablets crushing cipro tablets generic triamterene-hctz antibiotic azithromycin uses best place to buy levitra professional in uk buy keflex online dapoxetine ordering no prescription detrol price canada shatavari non perscription countries para que se usa crestor cheap seroflo pills diovan 160 25 mg price trazodone 100 mg street price viagra dose for men duphalac syrup price cheapest imitrex to buy pharmacy has best price grifulvin v ampicillin side effects uk contact lenses online uk no prescription serpina for sale philippines what drug category is rhinocort fucidin h cream online zyvox dosage info blue oval pill v15 ditropan online cheap emsam reviews for men cialis soft over the counter canada pharmacy online buy generic serophene nexium prices at walmart order vermox from usa without prescription glyburide metformin for sale safe to buy generic seroquel from canada order nexium 20 mg buy lady era online with mastercard better than hyaluronic acid sinequan brand positioning diflucan compatibility potassium order maxalt-mlt online zoloft vs wellbutrin anxiety carafate pills online in the usa generic benzac no prescription comprar renagel original en madrid side effects of purim finasteride 5mg tablets side effects cheap generic valtrex where do i cialis super active in usa generic geriforte for sale on line fable acheter alliance diovan and water pills effexor xr withdrawal symptoms how long lithium vs depakote bipolar disorder canadian amoxil prescription online is mail order norvasc safe comprar viagra pfizer 50 mg non persciption brand levitra buy benicar 100mg online brand levitra best online non prescription pharmacy sinequan in usa zetia coupon pharmacy para que se usa el medicamento zyrtec lopressor medication order getting finax in australia can i take cold medicine with imitrex buy medication online canada purim music free online is plavix a generic drug xalatan cheapest price sertralina de 50 mg engorda overnight viagra soft tabs is there a generic combivent inhaler cheap carafate us buy generic drugs online metformin 10 mg cost doxycycline shortage substitute floxin online overnight delivery discount code for topamax alphagan india generic canadian online pharmacy for ceftin where to buy kamagra uk kamagra chewable canadian pharmacy how to take nolvadex mg brand advair diskus online cheap lady era order lisinopril complications diabetes all natural fertility drugs for women can you buy canadian pharmacy proventil hfa side effects of zyrtec d hoodia no prescription reviews renova toilet paper coupon ceftin rx buy acyclovir no prescription buy brahmi in australia fast caverta delivery is buying prescription drugs from canada safe uroxatral daily use reviews is lamictal better than depakote buy kamagra oral jelly cheap best generic nolvadex sites is casodex available over the counter cheap uk buy order depakote online what is acai berry good for hair side effects of dipyridamole injection thuoc danazol 100mg buy isoniazid online from usa requip uk buy singulair tablets reviews ciplox cost canadian zestoretic 50mg tablets viagra ohne rezept kaufen erfahrung to buy naprosyn in uk comprar mircette online bactrim over the counter usa best zantac prices order arava cheap methotrexate comprar buy ranitidine online cheap health canada elimite differin shoppers drug mart zithromax dosage too high safe place order deltasone buy kamagra oral jelly mg online lowest price cialis online how much does a bottle of aleve cost loevaquin none prescription canadian drug stores original viagra for sale cafergot tablets for purchase what is lopid tablets rhinocort to buy from europe mail order generic rumalaya forte get viagra sample is there a generic brand for abilify friv 10000 car games valtrex price walgreens oder mg tablets of ampicillin allegra allergy medication lov cost speman premarin discount card what is reglan for dogs discount no prescription pharmacy buy vasotec online usa cephalexin tablets buy brand cialis order midamor online australia what is plendil for cialis pastillas venezuela purchase brand cialis in uk other uses for protonix buy generic augmentin online generic minocycline switzerland accutane sales history how much does singulair cost at cvs how to get ralista in australia famvir and other medications generic hyzaar 2010 low cost overnight minipress get prevacid toronto viagra at walmart pharmacy buy digoxin 0.1 mg buy mircette online pharmacy keflex dose for skin infection can order triamterene canada purchase precose online buy zanaflex paypal accepted paxil generico italiano gasex medication side effects sore nipples after ovulation on clomid liquid altace review reglan shop net citalopram buy online india online cialis soft purchase dulcolax sold over counter liv tablets on line to buy 10 day weather forecast leeds what is estrace used for during ivf purchase luvox cheap aldactone for sale philippines how to use shallaki maxalt 100mg cheap viagra para mujer en ecuador prinivil 10 mg purchase prescription medicine online buy aleve d can you get ranitidine zyprexa 10 mg vial how to get stromectol on line risperdal weight gain prevention valtrex birth control online uk chloroquine ships from india buy bupropion online without a prescription over the counter brahmi bleeding after misoprostol miscarriage western drug phenamax canadian nexium prescription buy oxycontin mexican pharmacies prescription fluoxetine prescriptions purchase bentyl canada without buy cleocin overnight cheap styplon no prescription what is the generic name for entocort can order yasmin online safe combivent no prescription purchase voltaren 1 guy 1 jar official video zovirax ointment vs cream discount canadian pharmacy topamax protonix dr 40 mg tablet pulmicort tablets side effects glucotrol xl order in the us tetracycline over the counter for cats chloroquine (nivaquine ®)100 finasteride no prescription forum albenza by mail order pharmacy reliable rx pills net purchase asacol pills purchase voltaren 75mg how to use triamterene exelon lawsuit propranolol reviews uk para que sirve la crema fucidin no prescription noroxin what is the correct dosage of ranitidine zyrtec otc sales what is the side effects of the drug buspar mentat canada head office best site buy cialis lipitor 40 mg precio mexico how to take prednisone dose pack metronidazole side effects buy percocet online no prescription needed no membership synthroid generic levothyroxine better buy live fish direct online pharmacy uk xeloda codeine promethazine overdose research grade vytorin buy bentyl without rx beat way to order citalopram rosuvastatin prices usa ciprofloxacin and tinidazole dose what is meclizine used to treat tofranil woldwide shipping native canadian medicine wheel citalopram hbr 20 mg and alcohol buy femara online from india how long does it take for flovent to leave the system femara mexico companies only glucophage uk buy the online drugstore voveran sr generic uk paypal colchicine insurance groups explained canadian pharmacy avandamet do you need rx diflucan where to buy premarin in canada safely metronidazole gel naprosyn generic glucophage pills sweat walmart pharmacy refill number flagyl no rx what is alesse tablets serm raloxifene osteoporosis best anti anxiety medication for women aciclovir side effects long term use similar to zoloft pills is it illegal to order generic depakote bystolic 20 mg can you take diflucan daily rhinocort aqua for sale brand levitra ships from india buy online drugs no prescription acquistare keftab in italia buy generic viagra united states compare prices sominex buy prazosin bulk vendita viagra generico online suprax discount card fluoxetine prescription only what is allegra k clothing discount canadian pharmacy kamagra oral jelly buy nymphomax 80 mg online cheapest lamictal sertralina bula anvisa lopressor online from canada order ginseng nexium patent expiration in canada cipro pills online in the usa canadian pharmacy bupron sr purim discount voucher how can you get promethazine prescribed finast where can i buy it fast reglan deleviery how much is propranolol tablets navarro discount pharmacy job application nombre generico del decadron medrol dose pack price walmart safe buy famvir online ceftin fast uk information on cymbalta medication prescription solutions pharmacy help desk buy nitroglycerin without a script zolpidem tartrate 5mg tab buy pyridium 100 mg when is the best time to take my thyroid medication medicamento zestril 10 mg cheapest new liverpool kit comprar suhagra pela internet buy alli at asda chemists que tan efectivo es el omifin walmart flyer alliston ontario where can i buy accutane online yahoo terbutaline dose for asthma trazodone medicine reviews medicine cymbalta australia buy trileptal australia cleocin gel for daily use canada generic versus brand name lexapro singulair lawsuit how to get reglan in australia legal buy albenza online canada acheter kamagra gel all types proscar pills etodolac pills sweat order atacand online in usa zithromax single dose packet side effects side effects of ropinirole requip doxycycline dose for community acquired pneumonia aricept 10 mg side effects tofranil como usar amantadine cheap us pharmacy where can i buy nexium online discount premarin mg order zithromax online no prescription alli coupon november 2012 prescription valtrex cold sores celadrin suppositories buy buy apcalis sx cheap long time side effects arimidex quickest benicar mg prescription motilium on line no script how to take buspar can order shallaki canada female cialis suppositories buy acai order by phone western drug trental protonix generic based teva how to buy flomax in london to buy avalide in uk buy acai visa amoxicillin online no rx taking baby aspirin ranitidine order by phone is viagra safe to use daily dramamine on the internet buy genuine procardia uk finax spain aarp medicare rx preferred mail order pharmacy cefixime no prescription needed buy where to buy kamagra in australia side effects of pain pills in dogs order allegra d online canadian health & care mall how long for allegra to take effect lukol tablets uses without a script aceon online atepros drug what class of drugs is bactrim floxin optic price prednisone dosage for dogs doses buy generic amitriptyline online with prescription lariam reviews diarex drugstore can i order brand advair diskus no prescription in the usa zoloft shopping on line toprol xl weight gain ordering brand viagra pills 100mg deltasone with prescription lamictal weight gain bipolar cialis online canada fast delivery free coupon for serophene astelin dosage too high antabuse direct pharmacy solumedrol dose pack sale how to use erythromycin ophthalmic ointment usp best ed drugs review azithromycin 250 recommended dose of levaquin for pneumonia generic altace paypal snythroid no scrip glucophage available in india buy liposafe usa dapoxetine online price erythromycin tablets what is it used for is crestor better than vytorin alli refill pack 120 capsules benzac online uk ropinirole dose for rls lopressor generico italiano how often should i take 800 mg motrin diovan next day delivery what is cleocin t used for finast online overnight shipping letrozole gyno side effects holiday insurance compare buy rogaine 5 no prescription finasteride buy online canada lasix drug interaction cheap kamagra oral jelly treat l-tryptophan without script ampicillan 500mg no prescription accordo rx reviews flagyl er order canada plendil no prescription purchase doxycycline with mastercard indian pharmacy modafinil finasteride 1 mg without prescription xeloda and alcohol consumption worldpharm4u buy viagra usa 1000 games duck life 4 double strength blue pill review where to get viagra in birmingham buy omifin online augmentin duo side effects children generic beconase aq for sale on line tricor shares suspended low cost ventolin inhaler for uninsured safe buy anafranil online ginseng dose calvin harris we found love lyrics generic periactin cost buy abana in india online what is rumalaya forte pills used for can you buy viagra over the counter in hong kong mycelex-g online cheap does asacol hd cause weight gain protonix no prrescription discount code for alliance francaise quickest prednisolone where to buy cialis soft online canada celebrex drug class can you get serevent buy desyrel xr without prescription suhagra comprare betamethasone cream uk dramamine comprare how long does it take for methotrexate injection to work diltiazem drug class colchicine by mail overnight pharmacy strattera generic estrace is what floxin online usa generic decadron usa buy acticin 20 midamor capsules buy primatene mist canada compare prices emsam obagi tretinoin cream 0.1 20 gm sildenafil citrate usa pharmacies buy allegra offers prevacid 24 costco best place to order zyban in us dostinex visa mebendazole side effects during pregnancy viagrs in usa desyrel women buy buy avodart australia nootropil sold over counter pharmacy has best price probalan us online pharmacy no prescription diarex generic toprol side effects doxycycline hyclate 100mg for dogs vasotec 100mg buy overnight nolvadex mastercard buy voltaren online with mastercard buy claritin hong kong internet prescription alphagan sale brimonidine cheap viagra for sale in australia robaxin uk brand name cipro suppositories buy minocycline canada rayrx online drugstore review lincocin where to buy in canada where to buy abortion pill in hong kong voltaren tab ec 50mg buy nizagara without a script can you buy toradol online proventil inhaler discount coupon buy avandamet visa what is the brand name for methotrexate comprar flovent original rumalaya forte drugs for sale buy lukol online purchase medrol online nizoral with no rx cleocin online australia safe cialis soft no precription lloyds pharmacy jobs edinburgh is it ok to take cipro and flagyl together clomid purchase in canada no prescription generic viagra sales pharmacy evista dosage information how to buy asacol is generic hyzaar effective cialis 20mg preise apotheke order bactroban ointment what does cipro look like generic best site get zebeta viagra without prescriptions yahoo aristocort pills side effects of benicar hct 40/25 mg tri levlen 28 reviews himcolin in croatia cheap glucotrol xl 2.5 mg low cost overnight antivert now thyroid energy synthroid cost viagra 100mg costco xeloda pill shop discount code cipro with no rx buy hytrin discount what exactly does cymbalta do what drugs are similar to lexapro proventil hfa elocon available over counter celexa cheap uk zyvox 500 mg treatment cialis coupon what is amiodarone cordarone how to take actonel monthly buy generic plavix what does prinivil look like super power sale online snovitra maxalt mlt 5 mg side effects buy quibron-t cheap comprar bentyl original en madrid prescription medicine for stress and anxiety can you buy abortion pill online safe myambutol no prescription premarin shop adalat la pregnancy albendazole side effects diclofenac tablets bp buy isoniazid australia como comprar cialis generico en espan~a allegra d generic for sale buy alphagan canada brimonidine chloroquine retinopathy screening buy prevacid have no prescription price increase flovent serpina generic 2013 drugs haldol drug information emsam 100 zofran class action lawsuit buy clomid capsules mirapex shop net neurontin to buy in australia accutane long term side effects liver norvasc delivery renagel from india lotensin for men in usa how to take aleve mg best generic indocin review where to get aristocort augmentin medication used prograf canadian pharmacy risperdal prescription program clomid ovulation predictor calendar buy sarafem from mexico online buy coumadin without a subscription can you get brand levitra can you order kamagra elavil weight gain forum stopping wellbutrin side effects tadapox from usa 100 mg nitroglycerin original glyset online what is the prescription dose of prilosec where can i buy levoxyl fast eulexin generic release date puerto rico pharmacy school periactin store next day evista online cheap tadalafil uk price trazodone no prescription overnight delivery what is ponstel s used for premarin stopping your medicine side effects of lukol how much is generic plan b at cvs is generic bupropion effective buy chloroquine without a prescription from canadian pharmacy ceftin prix en pharmacie en france bulk herbal suppliers viagra super active medication where to buy how long did it take for propecia to work where to buy cheap generic retino-a cream 0,05 cheap danazol 40 mg iron-dragon tadalafil reviews Purchase strattera 10mg viagra rezeptfrei nachnahme how to take skelaxin 800 mg ordering low dose zestoretic yasmin online usa tadalis sx limited india acheter finpecia en ligne florida zenegra generic name for ampicillin no prescription cheap price buy lexapro medicine cordarone buy antabuse 80 mg online vermox without rx best price for wellbutrin sr buy lotrisone 5 nolvadex uk brand name buy floxin online no prescription us prednisolone pills online in the uk price of plavix without insurance brand levitra order in the us what is the dosage for pyridium buy dramamine no prescription fast delivery cheap genuine inderal online where to buy alligator meat in texas indinavir drugstore.com atenolol 50 mg espanol lasix injection guidelines altace cost comparison ajanta pharma products kamagra long no alcohol flagyl florida cytotec generic celexa reviews order finpecia online uk lariam price australia the online drugstore shatavari keftab for dogs buy zyrtec 20mg tab generic viramune switzerland zovirax without a prescription from india stromectol 40 mg pharmacy betapace prices cvs mercury mambo 363 cialis maximum dosage buy serophene no prescription tadacip online, no prescriptions evecare generic reviews paxil canadian source crestor australian patent expiry billig neurontin online kaufen vente de diclofenac gel au quebec brand zofran buy voltaren 100 retard packungsbeilage hydromorphone dosage for dogs how to use diflucan 150 where to purchase moduretic tamoxifen overnight delivery buy styplon hong kong generic for actoplus met 15 800 how much does diclofenac cost is it illegal to order generic micronase haridra rx super kamagra online bestellen where can i buy orlistat tablets cabergoline buy uk low cost overnight baclofen l thyroxine side effects no prescription fml forte sale sildenafil citrate 50mg effects united support services inc charlotte tynidazole without prescription meclizine mg buy coumadin online pay paypal estrace australia price what is zoloft like xanax lamisil uk next day delivery buy luvox no prescription fast delivery german remedies testoviron depot 250 cheap drugs band buy alesse quick cardizem shortage 2012 cheap atrovent free delivery zovirax 100mg buy what is esomeprazole magnesium trihydrate tablet purchase elocon in usa sertraline hcl 50 mg and alcohol get starlix las vegas mircette birth control instructions pet antibiotics online no prescription how to buy avandamet lipitor atorvastatin 10 mg cheap trileptal 40 mg risperdal 4mg tablets how to import risperdal canadian health care for non-citizens buy indocin suppositories order nizagara on line canada low price eulexin uk how often to take allopurinol best place to buy zovirax cialis online pay paypal
Home Pete Toms LWIB: Whither The Amateur Draft? Don Fehr Comments on "Vets vs. Kids", and Minor Leagues See Good Attendance

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1822 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: Whither The Amateur Draft? Don Fehr Comments on "Vets vs. Kids", and Minor Leagues See Good Attendance PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 14
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 15 June 2009 15:04
Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in LWIB, why hasn’t the amateur draft been abolished? Donald Fehr comments on the controversy over escalating signing bonuses in the amateur draft and miscellaneous updates concerning MiLB.

WHITHER THE AMATEUR DRAFT?

LWIB last week reviewed the issues being debated in light of the (then) impending Rule 4 amateur draft. Amongst them, speculation concerning the size of Stephen Strasburg’s soon to be demands, the merits of allowing the trading of draft picks, the ineffectiveness of slot recommendations, why clubs are increasing investments in young talent and the public dissatisfaction expressed by some veteran players over the growing compensation being awarded to new draftees.

This past week saw a continuance of the debate. Ed Price, in a column titled “How to Fix the Draft? Eliminate it” wrote.

Unfortunately, there are still problems with it. And unfortunately, I believe the best way to fix the problems isn't a worldwide draft or a draft with tradable picks.

It's no draft at all.

David Pinto made the case for the abolition of the amateur draft.

International players are free agents, and that seems to work just fine. Let teams sign whomever they like in a fixed period of time. The Yankees can’t sign everybody. Teams like Washington might be able to sign two or three very good players for the price a better team pays for Straburg. That’s what teams like Pittsburgh and Washington need, a way to get many good players onto their roster.

Abolish the draft, and let these amateurs sign for what the market will bear. Then we can stop having these idiotic discussions about what’s wrong with the draft. The draft is just wrong, period.

Rob Neyer responded to Mr. Pinto’s post.

The real problem is that nobody really knows what would happen if the draft were abolished.... Humans are conservative by nature, and baseball men are really conservative. They like the draft, in part, because it's what they know.

But is it only “conservative baseball men” who support the amateur draft?  The draft is often criticized for unfairly limiting the bargaining power of the drafted players. Kevin Goldstein speculated LWIB that if Stephen Strasburg were a free agent he would command at least $100 million instead of the $20 – $30 million Mr. Goldstein believes Strasburg will eventually settle for. So, if the amateur draft (in all of the “big 4” leagues) is anti competitive, a restraint of trade, violates antitrust laws and restricts labour movement, why don’t the PAs challenge the practice in the courts? After all, didn’t MLB lose it’s right to employ the reserve clause over thirty years ago? Andrew Zimbalist explains in May the Best Team Win.

Labor unions by their very nature are combinations in restraint of trade: a union forces an employer to bargain with a group of workers rather than with individual workers. Labor unions thus would violate the Sherman Act of 1890. The Clayton Act of 1914, however, explicitly exempts labor unions from the provisions of the Sherman Act. This is known as the statutory exemption. The so-called non-statutory exemption evolved not from legislation but from court decisions. It holds that trade unions can exchange (in arm’s- length bargaining) free labor market rights for other benefits. Thus, by union shop precepts, a trade union can bargain over general conditions for entering the shop. Player drafts fit this category. Under the non-statutory exemption, a player’s union can bargain away competition among teams over amateurs entering the major leagues directly in exchange for other desiderata in the collective bargaining contract.

Joel Maxcy , at his “Sports Labor Relations” blog, recently reflected on Maurice Clarett’s failed challenge to the NFL’s rule that restricts the draft to players at least three years removed from high school. The NFLPA sided with the league in the case (draft eligibility requirements are set in collaboration with players unions) which was concluded by a ruling that is widely perceived to be strongly pro labour.  

In the instance of sports leagues, players represented by the union, and club owners represented by the management negotiating team, forgo individual antitrust protection for the sake of advancing the collective bargaining process. Conventional features negotiated under current sport league collective bargaining agreements, including restrictions on open labor markets such as rookie drafts and salary caps, are typically decreed anticompetitive and proscribed by antitrust law. Yet these restrictions are legal under labor law, and are exactly the issues around which labor negotiations in sports center. The negotiation process is doubtless better facilitated by their removal from antitrust scrutiny.

President Obama’s nominee to the Supreme Court, Sonia Sotomayor, is one of three judges who ruled on the Clarett case. Judge Sotomayor supported her ruling in favour of the NFL; "That's what unions do every day — protect people in the union from those not in the union," “Why is this case different?”

Professor Victor Matheson argued at The Sports Economist blog that the non-statutory exemption  contributes significantly to the goal of competitive balance in pro sports leagues.

It is certainly the case that the non-statutory labor exemption to the antitrust laws places rookies and draft picks at a huge disadvantage when it comes to salary negotiations. While we are fond of talking about how the reserve clause in the major sports leagues died with the advent of free agency, in fact the reserve clause is alive and well today. It's just that it is only applied to players in the first few years of their career. Of course, given the relatively short careers of most professional athletes, the current reserve clause rules may cover a typical athlete's entire career.

That being said, let's not be too hard on the non-statutory labor exemption. Without this judicial understanding of the labor laws, most of the league rules put in place to promote competitive balance would be under constant threat of antitrust litigation. Without a union's consent, the reverse order draft, salary caps, luxury tax, roster limits, etc., all of which are the result of individual teams coming together and conspiring to limit player compensation, would clearly be, if not per se violations of the antitrust laws, at least subject to significant scrutiny under the rule of reason.

Without the ability to negotiate in good faith without the threat of impending antitrust action, it is unclear how modern sports leagues would be able to function efficiently, at least in terms of promoting competitive balance.

Again from The Sports Economist, Professor Phil Miller blogs about an Eriq Gardner piece in Slate that argues the NFLPA is to blame (or praise?) for preserving the NFL draft.

John Palmer (Eclectecon) sends this fascinating Slate piece by Eriq Gardner about the history of NFL draft along.

In 1968, the Washington Redskins used their first-round pick (12th overall) on Smith, an All-American defensive back from the University of Oregon. The rookie signed with the team for $50,000, and his unremarkable first season culminated in a career-ending neck injury during Week 14. Smith seemed destined for quick obscurity. Then he sued the NFL.

Two years after his retirement, Smith went before a judge and asserted that the draft constituted an unreasonable restraint of trade in violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act. Had it not been for the draft, he argued, he would have been able to negotiate a more lucrative contract for his one year as a professional. And he demanded that the NFL make up the difference.

The case succeeded at the district court, securing $276,000 in treble damages for Smith, and he won again when the league appealed. In 1977, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled the "draft inescapably forces each seller of football services to deal with one, and only one buyer, robbing the seller, as in any monopsonistic market, of any real bargaining power."

Gardner notes that it looked like the Smith had the case won. But the NFL knew that it could effectively get an exemption from the Sherman Act if the players' union would agree to it. How did it get the union to agree to it?

Keep in mind that any collective bargaining relationship is composed of three groups: the employer, the unionized workers, and the union leadership. One of the interesting things about the NFLPA is that the leadership is largely composed of senior union workers, and Gardner argues that it is this arrangement that has led to the draft being kept.

The union's leadership is determined by seniority, with the upper echelon composed of veterans whose financial stakes conflict with those of the rookies. For example, take the way that draftees are paid by their assigned teams. According to the current collective-bargaining agreement, each club is allotted a set amount of "rookie pool money" to sign its draft picks. (Here's last year's breakdown of pool money.) It benefits the veteran players who run the union to keep that pool small: Since the NFL maintains a hard cap on the total amount of money distributed to players throughout the league, less money for rookies means more for the old-timers.

AND

...In other words, those who wish to challenge the NFL draft in the post-Yazoo Smith era should think hard about their target. It's not the league. It's the union.

Finally, should MLB get out of the business of minor league baseball? Is there a more efficient model for recruiting and developing players for MLB? MLB is concerned about rapidly escalating inflation in both the international free agent market and amateur draft. In January, The Biz of Baseball reported that clubs are investing, on average, $20 million a year on player development. Meanwhile, as discussed in the aforementioned Biz of Baseball report, business in minor league baseball (both affiliated and independent) has been booming. The last words to Andrew Zimbalist, again from “May the Best Team Win.”

Further, if minor leaguers did not “belong” to a particular major league club, then it is likely that competitive balance among major league teams would improve. Major league clubs would draft players out of the minors, not out of college or high school. These players would be more developed and their potential talent level more knowable. The reverse-order draft would confer a larger advantage on the low-finishing teams than does the present amateur draft.  

Select Read More to see comments by Donald Fehr on  "Vets vs. Kids", as well as Minor League News including an increase in attendance

DONALD FEHR COMMENTS ON VETS VS. KIDS

LWIB last week reported that some veteran players (Ryan Howard, Jayson Werth, Torii Hunter) had publicly expressed their concerns over the escalating signing bonuses being awarded in the amateur draft. The saturation coverage of Stephen Strasburg bringing much attention to the subject. LWIB saw some baseball pundits siding with the veteran players over these concerns.

Michael Rosenberg:

But having a slotting system should mean more to the owners than not having one means to the players. We're talking about competitive balance and the fate of a dozen or so small-market teams. How much will the major leaguers fight so that unproven amateurs can get big money?

Jeff Fletcher:

One of these days the major league players in the union are going to realize: "Hey, all that money going to amateur kids could be going to us!"

And that would be good for the big-league teams and for the current big-league players.

Liz Mullen reported that NFLPA Executive Director DeMaurice Smith and his MLBPA peer Donald Fehr both recently addressed the increasingly high profile topic of rookie compensation.

While there is growing pressure from the NFL, as well as some in the sports media, for the NFL Players Association to accept a rookie wage scale, new NFLPA Executive Director DeMaurice Smith questioned last week why the players were being asked about the issue when it was one created by the owners.

“The owners sign the checks,” Smith said, in a speech before the Sports Lawyers Association in Chicago last week. “The owners decide how much [players] are going to be paid. …”

AND

MLB Players Association Executive Director Don Fehr, speaking immediately after Smith on the rookie wage scale issue, said, “One of the things you have to be wary of, when you talk about the issues that were just raised, is in collective bargaining generally, and sports is certainly no exception to this, very often people will look, on the other side, will look for wedge issues.”

Fehr said the “classic example of a wedge issue” is one in which one group in a union is told another group is getting too much money “and you should all go and squabble with one another.”

“Now I don’t know if that is involved in this circumstance here, but on this side of the table we are all very conscious of such issues and where the instigation of raising such an issue comes from. If it comes from the players’ side, you don’t have to worry about it, because it will come with a proposed solution.”

MISCELLANEOUS NEWS FROM MiLB

Despite the recession, MiLB reports that attendance in May was very strong, practically on par with last season’s record setting figures. Brian Borawski commented, “I’ve talked about this before, but I thought Minor League Baseball would hold steady despite the rough economic times. People are looking for bargains for the whole family, and you can’t get a better one than a minor league game.” LWIB has not seen 09 attendance figures for the independent minor leagues but a May report in Baseball America speculated that this could be a challenging season.

"I've been around this industry for 30 years and I've not run across people worrying this much," Frontier League commissioner Bill Lee said.

AND

“I think this in many ways could be the toughest year for independent baseball," Can-Am League and American Association commissioner Miles Wolff said.

Longer term, in March Will Lingo wrote about the end of the new ballpark construction boom (120 new baseball stadiums in the past 25 years) and how it might impact on the business of minor league baseball.  

“What will be interesting to watch is how both the economic and construction slowdown will affect attendance. New markets and new ballparks have driven minor league attendance to records year after year, with more than 43 million fans overall last season.”

The owner of the Winston-Salem Dash is asking for more public money to complete construction of a new, unfinished stadium scheduled to open next season. Laura Graff, “Billy Prim, the owner of the single-A Winston-Salem Dash, said yesterday that the collapse of his business partnership with team co-owner Andrew "Flip" Filipowski and the global credit crisis have made it impossible for him to borrow enough money from private sources to finish the stadium.” Josh Levanthal provided some context.

If the Winston-Salem city council approves Billy Prim’s request for $15.7 million to complete construction on a 5,500-seat downtown ballpark, the overall price tag for project will rise to $40.1 million.

That would make it the most expensive Class A facility ever built. The current Class A leader is Great Lakes’ Dow Diamond, which opened in 2007 for $34 million.

AND

Six teams opened new ballparks this season, with only three topping the $40 million mark (all Triple-A facilities):

Triple-A Columbus ($56 million), Triple-A Gwinnett (estimated $40 million, likely total $60 million), Triple-A Reno ($50 million), high Class A Charlotte ($27 million), low Class A Bowling Green ($28 million), low Class A Fort Wayne ($30.6 million).

It’s important to remember that Triple-A ballparks usually seat around 10,000 fans; Double-A facilities 6-7,000; Class A between 4-5,500.

For many years the Buffalo Bisons benefited from being the AAA affiliate of the Cleveland Indians. The Indians consistently fielded very competitive teams in Buffalo and attendance was consistently robust.This off season the Indians were enticed to move their AAA affiliate to Columbus where a brand new stadium awaited. The Mets eagerly moved their AAA affiliate from New Orleans to Buffalo and both affiliate and parent club had high expectations for the 09 season. Mike Harrington reported LWIB that the new partnership has so far yielded disappointing results, with attendance “..down 1,400 tickets per game compared with last year." More from Mr. Harrington’s report.

The Bisons unveiled a new logo, new uniforms, a new name for the ballpark and an expanded statewide television schedule that includes 37 games—highlighted by five that will receive national exposure on SportsNet New York, the Mets' flagship station. The Buffalo franchise once sold a million tickets in six straight seasons, yet an excitement that had not existed in many years followed the franchise all offseason.

But then the season began.

A city that had grown accustomed to winning baseball has endured an utter disaster in the Mets' first year as the parent club. The Bisons lost 11 of their first 12 games, started 2-17 and were fighting to avoid having the worst record in the minor leagues.

They're also trying to avoid losing 100 games—a rare feat in a 144-game schedule—for the first time since 1931.

AND

The top affiliate of the Indians since 1995, Buffalo fans had grown accustomed to winning. Cleveland stocked nine playoff teams in its 14 years as parent organization, and the Bisons won the final American Association championship in 1997, as well as International League titles in 1998 and 2004.

In fact, the only losing season Cleveland had in Buffalo was its 66-77 mark in 2008. Even then, the Indians had one foot out the door as they looked forward to their new partnership with Columbus.

Mets officials are quoted in the piece acknowledging the disappointing performance of their AAA affiliate and have responded by recently signing veterans Wily Mo Pena, Javier Valentin and Mike Lamb to boost the club’s on (and off) field performance.


Pete Toms is an author for The Biz of Baseball and a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He can be contacted at \n This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow the Business of Sports Network on Twitter Twitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?