cipro generico italiano cialis 5 mg the best price interaction between celexa and birth control pills non prescription retin a 0 025 pharmacy better than xalatan veterinary prednisone side effects prometrium side effects ivf generic mentat uk paypal dulcolax over the counter dose long term side effects of low dose methotrexate noroxin comprare cheap augmentin 875 buy effexor xr in india online canadian aprovel buy silagra online from uk can order xalatan canada tetracycline use in rabbits cheapest duphalac viagra plus drugs for sale cialis cost comparison viagra brand advair diskus discontinued avodart buy india colchicina prescription only order elocon overnight brand advair diskus drug oversea eulexin purchase in canada no prescription discount mirapex from canada nizoral online from canada lopid uk next day delivery purchase abilify on line in india buy lipothin singapore very cheap duprost buy leukeran with a mastercard estrofem for sale philippines levoxyl shop net where to buy wigraine online usa best generic viagra prices florinef 0.1mg tablets for dogs levlen overseas generic alesse online discount non prescription v gel where can i buy tetracycline online price discounts where to buy lexapro online coversyl without a prescription from mexico canadian pharmacy abilify cheap genuine lansoprazol online side effects of enalapril maleate buy trental uk taking levaquin alcohol side effects of levitra 20 mg pill identifier blue round v 2531 aleve pharmacy order advair online coupon code endep for headaches forum evista australia pharmacy can i buy metoclopramide purchase lipothin in australia generic form of elavil amoxil birth control online uk fluconazole 200 mg daily micronase no rx can you only get tricor on prescription albendazole noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy problems with generic plavix non generic coreg serevent on line no script viagra professional pas cher very early ovulation on clomid what percentage of people taking celexa gain weight where can i buy atarax cephalexin brands in india viagra professional on line in the uk seasonique without a script best price for real ovral l acheter levitra generique 10mg inhaler buy generic advair diskus elimite shop net aleve australia price habeeb alli canadian council imams serophene tablets online ventolin brand positioning decadron in costa rica buy cefixime 20 how to purchase imovane online purchase proscar in australia exelon patch generic brand xanax wiki dosage buy tadapox mexican pharmacies remeron soltab side effects buy roxithromycin mg online tretinoin 0,025 mexico pharmacy ayurslim without a prescription from canada sominex from canada where to buy amitriptyline 10mg 25mg buy blopress 8 azithromycin chlamydia dose is generic trileptal effective generic valtrex effectiveness cold sore meloxicam overdose cats sertraline shop can we trust malegra fxt online innopran xl over counter uk valtrex prices cvs cheap generic propecia online sertraline dosage bnf liposafe for sale uk buy qsymia online no prescription order tamsulozin online no presctiption best generic menosan review info ventolin hfa bentyl online from usa serpina precio mexico yasmin saleem tetracycline side effects on teeth is advair available on line in canada hytrin side effects in women trimox to buy in the canada without a prescription buy unisom sleepmelts can you buy clomid over the counter in spain cheap rx drugs online maxalt pas cher italie cefixime spain over counter safe to buy generic liposafe from canada ampicillin generic and brand name cost of caverta in india cialis sublingual without insurance cheap lisinopril 5mg online bupron sr online overnight shipping buy thyroxin canada retino a cream 0,05 with no rx buying altace in manchester clomid coupons buy prednisolone online no prescription allegra class action lawsuit order evista on line canada buy diarex uk best place to buy roaccutan in canada how to order fertomid online order amoxicilina on line canada cordarone pharmacy coupons generic deltasone uk colospa on line in the canada how to order hydrea online what types of fluoxetina are there 36 hour cialis dosage best site for motrin where do i glucotrol xl in uk norvasc from uk lamisil tablets buy safe buy oristal online xalatan price in india meclizine medication class is tegretol xr generic available can you order femcare diflucan delivery pharmaceutical machinery suppliers in india quickest pyridium how much is anastrozolo tablets methotrexate toxicity emedicine buy alli weight loss pill suppliers of stieva a in us best place to buy esperal without a prescription lukol shoppers drug mart trandate shop net does lipothin work discount yagara of canada mycelex g over counter uk is adam from man vs food healthy my blopress coupons birth control mircette side effects price of viagra in england can you buy fertomid norvasc supplier in uk himplasia mg tablet american lotrisone fast calan deleviery cheap calan buy online avodart dutasteride forum consumer reviews aleve pain reliever cheap albendazole no prescription safe buy sepibest online parlodel over counter uk keftab for sale online astrazeneca nolvadex rx azitromicina medicine online hydrodiuril uses medication over the counter nizagara lisinopril shoppers drug mart noroxin medication where to buy viagra paypal payment order minocycline uk pharmacy pyridium delivery london avalide online pharmacy uk i pill rocaltrol website cost of venlafaxina aceon on line no script purchase amoxil cheap penicillin 250mg low cost actos synthroid generic levothyroxine sodium zyvox cost 2009 buy tenormin astrailia tegretol cheap mexico pharmacy buy hytrin pills online reglan on line in the india acheter xenical en suisse canadian pharmacy isoniazid canadian pharmacy key pred naprosyn where to get buy singulair online at canada pharmacy order actoplus met online with visa can buy cipro over counter ordering nootropil uk modafinil india pharmacy buy himcocid online india no prescription viagra sublingual mg canadian rx side effects of flovent in cats zithromax online meds how to buy prilosec in canada ashwagandha mg tablet amitriptyline discounts codes how to get doxycycline for malaria mometasona uk next day delivery augmentin bid 1000 mg yan etkileri dulcolax next day drug market order aristocort indian generics online emsam flovent diskus generic online buy ampicillin pharmacy cytotec on line in the uk buy augmentin 875 mg salbutamol online purchase oder mg tablets of brand viagra what kind of medicine is seroquel where to get accutane online accutane pharmacies generic isotretinoin female cialis with paypal payment periactin medication overnight delivery how long to take olanzapine buy generic viagra online in india bactrim generic usa order periactin forum generic doxycycline price uk pharmacies online that sell cialis buy roxithromycin cheap histoire de la pharmacie buy voveran sr pills online how to buy prometrium online sepibest us companies only retino a cream 0,025 where to get can you buy paxil over the counter where to buy januvia with echeck danazol how to buy 5 day z pack dose buy nitroglycerin patches elimite noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy duprost pills online in the mexico do you need rx clincin low price disulfiramum uk albuterol inhaler instructions spanish generic levitra real ampicilina no prescription compare prices cheap erythromycin 500mg non generic citalopram zithromax 1 g packet online dyazide with no prescription viagra no prescription canadian pharmacy buy bupron sr boots lasix generic brand novolog mix flexpen carbozyne buy online india orlistar australia companies only best site for sumycin side effects of lortab 10 original leukeran online buy retino a cream 0 05 pills online suppliers of levothyroid in us order amaryl online no prescription with a mastercard buy brand quetiapinum betnovate without a script lov cost zocor discount paxil of canada cialis jelly by mail salvent for sale australia diclofenac cholestyramine capsules is it illegal to order generic doxycycline true generic viagra propecia reviews 2013 over the counter substitutes for cialis is aleve better than ibuprofen for muscle pain tadalafil salzarex vytorin australia companies only recommended viagra sites how to take cipralex mg trental order on web ginette 35 dose elocom pas cher primatene mist mexico viagra professional online mexico order procardia on line usa purchase solu medrol how much will danazol cost metronidazole uk buy buy prograf 80 mg online how to get viagra in australia reglan mg mexico vpxl tablets us online can i use betnovate cream on my face viagra plus generic cialis canadian what does phenergan contain nausea cheap tofranil india buy betnovate with no script metocarbamol on line in the uk order clavamox no rx canadian pharmacy buy finast bulk buy medicines online serophene uk online canadian pharmacies propecia lotensin overnight shipping cheap cardizem in emergency medicine we bought a zoo book finpecia from cipla lab tests online estrogen where can i get topamax viagra reviews forums prescription atorlip 10 refills piracetam review forum allegra owen mostyn trandate where to get cefadroxil where to buy in canada naprosyn generic 2013 drugs buy generic accutane online keflex tabletas 500 mg precio antara fda approved to buy without prescription what is unisom dosage isoptin online from canada procardia xl dose order erection packs 12 from order claravis on line mexico where to buy erection packs 3 online usa vasotec mg india tetracycline uk sale olmesartan side effects boots pharmacy opening hours london where can i get acai berry diet pills rogaine 2 from china where to buy fasigyn ointment health benefits network discount pharmacy card amantadine on line in the usa risperdal online sales voveran sr without a prescription from canada noroxin lawsuit order rumalaya gel tablets order ortho tri cyclen cozaar 50 mg losartan medrol 16 mg italiano generic drug name flomax can keppra tablets be crushed dapoxetine shipping overseas purchase anafranil on line in australia bristol myers squibb foundation scholarship vistaril online pay paypal lipothin buy usa best generic depakote sites buy ephedraxin canada can you take meclizine daily cheapest place to buy kamagra oral jelly cefixime best online non prescription pharmacy canadian medicines online zone tegaserod maleate 6 mg torsemide now actoplus shelf life isotretin cheap uk pharmacy proscar prescription assistance nitroglycerin uk online us pharmacy online trazodone minocycline hydrochloride capsules usp side effects buy prozac online canada buy differin online from australia meclizine hydrochloride uk pulmicort cost in canada retino a cream 0 05 uk online retin a generic wikipedia drugs valium generico india buy ponstel online in the united states without a prescription nootropil no prrescription ordering sepibest mexico order innopran xl online colchicine tablets 150 mg norvasc drugstore com blood arzomicin dose buy brand cialis mg uk buy roxithromycin without prescription cheap generic flovent astelin to buy from europe order zantac on line mexico tofranil pharmacy prices list toradol shortage buying allegra online how to buy cipralex online eldepryl online without prescription geriforte syrup overnight pharmacy thyrox maximum dosage meclizine suppositories buy aloprim online usa no prescription finpecia canada online no prescription what does ranitidine do for infants online abortion meds the online drugstore orlistat very cheap retin a 0 05 atomoxetine price walmart shallaki cheap us pharmacy where can i buy provera spironolactone acne before and after pictures why has antabuse been discontinued prinivil online usa valtrex naman pharma drugs quantas gotas de atrovent devo usar cheapest sumycin skelaxin 100 review frumil usa tadalafil review forum buy over the counter imitrex online methotrexate mg buy urispas tablets 200 mg estrofem online from canada meteo live in italia dapoxetine online pharmacy shipped to canada celebrex without prescrip buy genuine cialis professional uk is there a shortage of retin a 0,05 comprar midamor pela internet viagra plus pas cher order clonidine online no prescription with a echeck medazole pct buy suprax medication where to buy paroxetine pharmacies olistat delivery uk buy prograf online with out prescription buy metrogel in singapore midamor online overnight mentax birth control online mexico bentyl on line in the india serpina pill shortage buy obelit tablets uk what is tegretol made of viagra 40 mg chlamydia test scotland omnicef costco aciphex dosage 20 mg biaxin paypal order levitra from mexico without prescription advair diskus generic canadian prinivil where can i buy raciper online canada olanzapine nhs clarina sale from canadian company no prescription apo furosemida cheapest xenical prices ventolin lawsuit do i need a prescription for micronase levlen buy online uk pharmacy that sells aldactone fastest tindamax uk delivery chloromycetin australia cialis reviews 5mg allegra coupons december 2012 vardenafilum pharmacy mail order seroquel dose for bipolar disorder buy propranolol no prescription cialis generico al miglior prezzo prescription drug erythromycin styplon free shipping celexa costco cost of strattera 10 mg mail order generic aciclovir elavil 20 mg india apcalis sx price carafate cheap mexico pharmacy how to get evista in australia when will generic nexium be available buy hydrodiuril tablets mexico aprovel buy uk dietary supplement loc:br best place to buy metoclopramide in uk cialis online pharmacy does cialis work compared viagra how to by anacin online generic omnicef switzerland tinidazolum without script having sex pill free week buy v gel with e check buy tretinoin 0,025 tablets uk fast chloromycetin deleviery flovent over counter ventolin inhaler dosage for infants buy dulcolax online usa clincin without prescription medication zestoretic online purchase zantac next day delivery viagra professional discontinued rocaltrol no prescription order sumycin on line uk comprar gyne lotrimin original en madrid what does allegra hives caused para que se usa el antibiotico cipro where to buy silagra ointment cheap sumycin pills lasix from canada buy generic yaz online no prescription purchase caverta pills cialis sublingual drug oversea lipitor prices costco toprol xl online from canada avandamet rxlist prilosec drug in usa pharmacy mexico pharmacies online that sell flucazole buying alesse order himcocid tablets wellbutrin canada companies only vitamin shoppe nyc 8th avenue cheap prinivil pills buy cleocin gel with a mastercard triamterene overseas where can i get ponstel pills valtrex generic pictures relafen to purchase without a prescription tadalafil generico paypal hcg pharmacies in broward county without purchase abilify online cheap blopress uk canadian pharmacy online maxaman is coversyl a prescription drug viagra super active canada drug store what is allopurinol medication best place to buy fluoxetine in usa can you get neurontin over the counter erythromycin best price what types of cipro are there what is the correct dosage for synthroid ordering levitra professional uk buy orlistat online from india where to buy midamor online mexico where can i buy letrozole in the uk estradiol valerate online usa purchase motrin on line in uk what is glucovance diclofenac gel discount code drug market order mircette wellbutrin sr canada online no prescription online pharmacy uk zentel lov cost hyaluronic acid cialis jelly overnight no rx atacand tablets on line to buy can i buy mevacor in canada my metformin coupons prednisone 5mg dose pack nitrofurantoin canadian medications without prescription over the counter erythromycin topical purchase avalide in canada find clarina in florida sublingual sale generic viagra online is flonase legal in uk janumet canada no prescription celebrex 200 mg capsulas duras can i order hytrin online zithromax over the counter generic pills for exenical antara billig kaufen what is tinidazolum made of sale salvent flagyl er from mexico ayurslim no script nizagara online sales zyprexa generic wikipedia drugs dulcolax generic 2013 drugs shuddha guggulu canada head office order benicar from canada clavamox trusted online drug stores in canada levothyroid on line in the uk brand amoxil prescription only l thyroxine sold over counter purchase avodart lowest price health canada lozol cheapest topamax in the uk pharmaceutical news uk to buy septilin in uk buy digoxin online from usa vytorin 20 mg the online drugstore benzac generic almetec us mexican pharmacies without prescriptions drugs buy nexium 40 mg tablets best doxazosin prices buy ephedraxin tablets australia kmart pharmacy generic drug list 2011 salbumol from usa mexico diclofenac online pharmacy crestor usa anti seizure medicine lamictal can we trust voveran sr online buy movalis online in the united states without a prescription decadron medication no script bupron mg getting zestoretic in australia estrace generic form where to get finasteride uk can you buy levaquin fluoxetina over the counter drugs alesse birth control prices buy isoptin pills where can i buy yasmin online buy biaxin online mexico no prescription buy generic levitra professional online no prescription getting elimite in australia florida inderal best shatavari prices avapro from europe small round pill mylan a1 what is cleocin prescribed for mevacor uk no prescription no prescription roaccutane online allopurinol online with no perscription to buy hytrin domperidone for mares diarex to buy in the uk without a prescription cephalexin for dogs hot spots rocaltrol for men in usa decadron side effects uk buy claravis online buy actos pioglitazone hcl what does ashwagandha mean in english como comprar rumalaya bactroban price australia can you open prograf capsules retino a cream 0 05 for sale canada zebeta birth control online australia starting topamax at 100 mg advair fast canada buy plendil pills ordering allegra usa to buy revatio in uk fasigyne lowest price nitrofurantoin without a script can you buy mg generic diflucan generic warafin usa pharmacy aripiprazola medication is it illegal to order generic levothyroid can you take neurontin to get high where to buy cheap generic cialis soft long term side effects of taking tegretol purim lawsuit best universities europe pharmacy shatavari for sale philippines ciplox 40mg trial erection packs 3 from uk trileptal for dogs buy online order grifulvin v lamictal unipolar depression reviews order clavamox from usa without prescription online pharmacy azurette online no prescription uk for singulair express shipping flexisyn cheap does alli work weight loss pills rocaltrol mg buy flomax canada no prescription best place to buy acticin online canadian pharmacy online dostinex buy azitromicina with paypal canada buy baridium without prescription best place to buy micardis online ou acheter le meilleur ginseng buy allopurinol uk lithium drug in mexico pharmacy online generic evista where do i plavix in mexico nebulized albuterol sulfate side effects pharmacy mexico cleocin no prescription needed levaquin non prescription drugs for anxiety meloxicam 15 mg overdose omnipod insulin pump can i make vpxl grifulvin v generic cheap costs is propranolol legal in uk buy remeron with no rx prograf pas cher italie levitra no prescription online pharmacy bit ssl blood thinner coumadin generic brand name ortho cyclen online buy brand pulmicort western drug tadapox mycelex g online legally ventolin buy online mexico prednisone pfizer cheap amantadine us provera how to buy obelit medication differin topical gel reviews what is celebrex 200mg flagyl uk companies only buy atorlip 5 boots pharmacy can buy renagel online order zitromax online uk where to buy metronidazole gel in philippines danazol on line in the canada breaking lipitor tablets over counter equivalent augmentin zetia over the counter usa tablet prescription meds drug store purchase prozac on line in uk apo pantoprazole 20 mg valtrex 1000 mg price abilify 5 mg scored buy orlistat online australia no prescription buy tindamax pills online zentel buy online canada generic atrovent no prescription cheapest without buy tenormin online imitrex nasal spray directions how to use clomifene from usa pharmacy detrol over the counter flovent buy mexico tretinoin 0 05 spain over counter aripiprazola to buy in the canada without a prescription long time side effects allegra how to buy aripiprazola online eritromicina 500 mg usos can advair diskus cause weight gain buy zithromax online in usa what are the most common side effects of wellbutrin what is the alternative to prednisone medication septilin shopping buy desyrel with mastercard buy accutane online no prescription uk cheap ortho tri cyclen lo missed 2 light blue pills zofran drug in uk pharmacy canadian pharmacy caprysin yasmin buy uk lipothin drug class buy valtrex astrailia ordering prednisolone uk aceon generic 2013 drugs buy desyrel online from india ovral l cost in canada can i order furosemide online what is periactin olistat billig kaufen pharmaceutical press oral erythromycin acne during pregnancy how much will retin a 0,025 cost lioresal free shipping where to purchase nitroglycerin where can i order risperdal best site to buy crestor order levitra online no prescription with a echeck toradol on line in the india effects of benadryl the next day aricept donepezil hydrochloride side effects what does brand advair diskus fluss 40 canada prescription how to use penegra 25 buy paxil online no prescription canada assistance with valtrex prazosin canada prescription disulphiram where can i buy mentat over the counter drugs ranitidine order in the us viagra cialis sales purchase voltaren on line in australia herbal viagra alternatives uk alti doxycycline tablets from buy ponstel cheap india pharmacy 5mg cialis not enough trial erection packs 1 buy canada astelin wanted online review comprar viagra original what is the maximum dosage for levitra levitra plus mg canadian rx generic colospa safe imodium recommended dosage danazol online australia salbutamol ventolin 2mg tablet purchase neurontin in australia dilantin medicine children cost of abilify in canada neurontin with no perscription buy erection packs 3 without rx vermox online coupon code flagyl er online pharmacies with out prescription nexium without subscription buyers of sildenafila canada discount nizoral shampoo site de confiance achat viagra pletal tablets fincar order by phone dutas pharmacy coupons olmesartan medoxomil and amlodipine tablets robitussin and clomid fertility clomid drug in canada pharmacy ordering sildenafil citrate on line elimite online without prescription roxithromycin delivery buy zanaflex with a mastercard best levothyroxin prices indian pharmacy remeron tegretol to buy erexor generic 2013 drugs buy calcium carbonate without rx elocom birth control online australia where can i buy flagyl for dogs endep online sales feldene pills buy nizoral online coupon code colchicina generic australia buy azitromicina online us no prescription can i order baridium online cheap cleocin free delivery flexeril high snort elimite reviews lamisil cheap australia pharmacy amoxicilina spain kamagra online germany can you only get kytril on prescription buy seroquel australia ortho cyclen drug in fr pharmacy tretinoin 0,05 for sale philippines the chepest mobic grifulvin v canada companies only purchase zestril lowest price buy zestril boots pharmacy buy indocin tablets us buy aciphex inhaler canada where to get zetia mexico pharmacies online that sell levothroid albuterol over the counter india oder mg tablets of inderal delta cortef limited india buy promethazine codeine cough syrup no prescription vytorin drug in mexico pharmacy css content box kamagra soft dosage instructions alesse medication side effects where to buy seroflo mg levothroid generic online relafen overnight pharmacy albuterol inhaler for cough mylan bupropion xl reviews flagyl canada cost which uk site to buy amaryl coreg pills online in the mexico how to get clozaril on line generic aceon safe lioresal online overnight xenical usage instructions vytorin generic uk novo digoxin online india contraceptive pill yasmin australia doxycycline legal in england prednisone tablets online what does topamax do for weight loss med cab levitra super active cheap viagra australia paypal roxithromycin birth control online uk beta val pills online in the india is there a generic lipitor available can you buy blopress generic danazol by mail order buy online meclizine generic carafate reviews for men actonel in canada stromectol 12mg online betnovate scalp application purchase over the counter lamictal order movalis online without rx saw palmetto no better than placebo clomid 100 twins can we trust lozol online accutane low dosage side effects buy viagra plus tablets lexapro medicine depression suhagra express canada benadryl visa order maxaman without rx decadron discounted how much does allegra cost at costco buy digoxin online canada buy alphagan online uk purchasing flucazole online inderal tablets tamsulozin canada head office terbinafine lamisil price order quibron t overnight disulphiram with no subscription canada and rogaine 5 clavamox fast canada acquisto glycomet sicuro online ciprofloxacino altera cor urina where do i obelit in india ordering viagra plus on line ampicilina buy australia padi tec trimix instructor cheapest zofran in the uk where to buy cheap generic hydrea safe to buy generic hyzaar from usa progesterone deficiency can we trust zyprexa online zestril tablets 10mg furosemide without prescription generic drug names for zoloft viagra to buy nz buy sominex boots lasix side effects in infants order lamictal xr canada robaxin mexico no prescription do you need rx carafate buy elocom capsules can you get zyban order prozac online no prescription with a mastercard bonnispaz online price low cost carbozyne erection packs 1 drug in fr pharmacy buy eurax online from usa raciper where can i buy can i get high off of amitriptyline adjusting to new synthroid dose lioresal tablets side effects buy saw palmetto online reviews buy altace 20 v gel cost in canada lov cost parlodel caverta 100 side effects lisinopril 10mg tablets price cialis pastilla estrace discount coupon buy toprol new zealand online precision peptides tamoxifen citrate reviews cheap genuine eldepryl online ortho tri cyclen uk next day delivery warafin canada head office ranitidine no prescription needed phenegren no prescription generic name calan sr lanoxin drugs online purchases buy trial erection packs 1 xr without prescription buy dapoxetine online amazon buy aleve in australia can you take citalopram daily atacand online sales valaciclovir uk sale gabapentine buy online australia the chepest remeron benicar discount card seven second red pill usa buy tegretol without prescription purchasing zovirax online buy elocom pills online buy colchicine from india amlodipine dosage forms rabeprazole dose children where can i buy ampicilina mg buy cheap dapoxetine uk best price for anacin billig furosemide online kaufen indocin canada companies only common side effects of antibiotics glucovance online pharmacy uk what is disulfiramum drugs quiero comprar evecare propranolol drug class comprar renova portugal benefits of pilex tablets shuddha guggulu online forum where to buy methotrexate online canada european rx pharmacy reviews where to buy grifulvin v online without rx buy salbutamol singapore bactroban nasal purchase buy tofranil in uk where to buy hytrin with echeck buy cheap aldactone online overnight medazole online without prescription order zanaflex from india without prescription generic bactrim us where to buy zanaflex online usa buy cytoxan in ireland viagras available in india how to take allopurinol mail order pharmacy technician jobs in colorado where to buy antara online mexico rythmol sr generic reviews prednisolone for dogs dose topical erythromycin online side effects of minoxidil topical solution tofranil fast uk suprax coupon 2012 metrogel no prescription compare prices hoodia order cheap zoloft online no script silagra purchase stieva a shop net order cialis super active without rx feldene piroxicam side effects orlistato from india how much will flovent cost xeloda mg tablet half price amaryl kelnor online usa no prescription where to buy pravachol online uk buy zanaflex 80 mg online celebrex over the counter india buy aceon online overnight delivery order cleocin gel online no prescription with a visa elimite online pharmacy uk dipyridamole dose can order tenormin canada cheap generic precose buy parlodel pills in the india alfa flucon online uk erexin spray ingredients best prices for cialis 20mg tadalafil claritin and other medication buy ranitidine pills aciphex cheapest rate comprar zestril online how long does it take for nitrofurantoin macro to work where to buy abilify online uk cheapest vardenafil uk novo digoxin canada prescription costco pharmacy tenormin price oestrogel india flovent without a prescription from mexico citalopram buy canada stopping tegretol side effects acivir birth control online us cipro buy uk buy serophene canada sildenafil citrate with prescription diovan cost 320 mg para que sirve la dicicloverina what is zithromax azithromycin used for generic phexin cost cleocin gel pharmacy prices list order priligy from australia without prescription decadron medication on line actonel positive reviews original tinidazolum online discount pharmacy macquarie and gowrie dostinex uses men abilify uk sale what is detrol for canada buy moduretic without prescription rhinocort aqua generic adalat sony tv reviews cephalexin indian drugs cheap indocin india mail order generic desyrel buy ceftin generic health canada avalide recall how much is celexa tablets buy generic cialis sublingual online with prescription cheapest viagra overnight delivery where to buy flomax with echeck order zedd online uk dilantin medicine uses lotrisone purchase flonase pills online in the india viagra 100 mg walgreens price isotretinoin cheap online online accuran india ovral l dosage instructions order quibron t without prescription where do i buy actonel can you get high on wellbutrin xl tadalis sx birth control online mexico lexapro weight loss then gain diclofenac medicine online lincocin medication no prescription medrol dosepak diclofenaco sodico 25 mg vademecum brand levitra generic name buy alesse 21 prescription fast lamictal delivery best steroid post cycle therapy yasmin birth control online key pred drug class morpheus matrix red pill blue pill singulair pharmacies novo digoxin online ventolin price acquisto on line cialis originale calan online no prescription prednisone sale online over the counter drugs similar to risperdal buy retin a 0,05 tablets us order viagra online overnight shipping order levitra professional pills prandin online legally buy stediril australia buy viagra from canada buy accutane us buy propecia patch dutas pills online in the usa rythmol purchase buy cheap cordarone using pay pal buy prilosec online canada cheap paxil sale uk order generic zyloprim western drug minomycin permethrin 5 percent elimite can order novo digoxin canada is generic shuddha guggulu available in usa luvox generico italiano is toprol xl generic liv 52 mg canada generic fosamax cost buy brand keflex cabaser no prescription overseas pharmacy no prescription medazole buy avana 50 cheap femara uk buy bentyl online canada side effects of diovan generic non prescription erection packs 2 pharmacy sarafem discount pulmicort for sale australia cleocin gel without a prescription from mexico comprar key pred original finpecia canada drug store buy lisinopril online non prescription synthroid doses pill color propecia ireland available estradiol valerate discount voucher buy brand cialis pills in the mexico where do i venlafaxina in india cialis soft cheap uk what is metronidazole taken for how to order priligy online lasix pas cher sibustat tablets for sale danazol drug doxycycline 50mg dosage for acne kamagra with american express best site get ivenox aspirin dose canada pharmacies online that sell lotensin naltrexone to treat ms buy apo clopidogrel tablets india hoodia gordonii onde comprar em portugal professional viagra ceep anacin purchase in canada no prescription atacand hct 32 12.5 price drug market order shatavari buy meloxicam enolat online no prescription canada penegra 100 side effects onlain filmi hd paxil cr side effects weight gain how to make powerful viagra at home using fruits original probalan online is wellbutrin an over the counter drug long time side effects yasmin levaquin prescription help what is augmentin duo forte side effects venlafaxina without a prescription from australia minocin where can i buy it cost of mail oestrogel generic micronase paypal levofloxacin alcohol cheap genuine serophene online buy generic zydis online metoclopramide generic release date can you buy lotrisone over the counter phone in order for albenza ordering toradol canada best online pharmacy generic altace buy purinethol inhaler canada buy online fluoxetina generic health canada amoxiline order allopurinol online no prescription with a visa order generic voveran sr antibiotics and the pill how long buy norvasc pills in the australia lexapro over the couter online sale of minipress lopid no prescription compare prices lipitor overnight shipping cheap lotrisone over the counter discount chloramphenicol otc buy brahmi for daily use hoodia gordonii seeds for sale tofranil buy online us cialis soft tabs how to take cheap levaquin 40 mg avalide prices usa prazosin online price a good web page to buy levitra professional with no script can i buy baridium in canada cephalexin for discount branded viagra online betapace generic 2013 drugs order diflucan pills wigraine roche precio argentina cheap viagra super active 100 mg comprar flomax online viagra sublingual delivery strattera with paypal payment does flonase nasal spray make you gain weight non prescription indinavir pharmacy thyroxin from india revia online pharmacy shipped to canada curacne shortage can keppra tablets be cut in half purchase benadryl in usa can i make geriforte online generic geriforte syrup what drug category is voltaren why is there a zofran shortage torsemide medicine children phone in order for hyaluronic acid ranitidine birth control online australia erythromycin buy online where can i buy pilex online without a prescription generic lynoral purchase brand viagra on line in the uk moduretic online overnight safe aygestin no precription cost of flonase beta val medication overnight delivery cytotec for men sale in uk cardura 2mg tablet how long does it take for dutasteride to work rosuvastatin 30 day free trial keppra online australia levitra vardenafil bestellen fast abilify deleviery aldactone pills buy augmentin rxlist how much is retino a cream tablets xenical uk support predalone online in us what type of drug is carafate azithromycin 500mg tablets best site to buy diclofenac gel minocycline india manufacturer oder mg tablets of nizoral pill rx health order erection packs 3 products buy alphagan us eye drops buy nootropil new zealand online how to get lynoral drug signs of ovulation after clomid all types salbutamol pills para que se usa prilosec terbinafine dosage for nail fungus humana walmart mail order pharmacy bupron online with out prescription buy promethazine codeine syrup no prescription online list of tesco stores selling haridra medrol 100mg buy yaz india pharmacy buy bactroban pills in the uk buy orlistat 120mg online uk is it illegal to order prescription drugs from india generic purchase orlistato on line in uk synthroid tablets purchase on line riomont new zealand capoten free shipping midamor for men sale in uk ordering colchicina on line is mail order hydrodiuril safe can you order erythromycin nizoral 2 percent sale zestoretic from usa pharmacy ortho tri cyclen lo reviews birth control what is allegra dosage buy brand evecare tretinoin 0 025 maximum dosage buy clonidine with paypal comprar unisom en argentina i want to pay some brand viagra accutane lawsuit statute limitations texas generic simvastatina india probalan from usa obelit online from usa diamox 500 mg capsules sinemet tablets side effects buy risperdal online with no prescription fluoxetine on line no script us pharmacies online that sell lamisil viagra ersatz rezeptfrei lantus china a good web page to buy zocor with no script tadacip supplier in uk generic nizoral 2 shampoo no script lexapro mg online maxalt india generic deltasone switzerland stopping paroxetine side effects finasteride for sale online pharmacy that sells premarin uk pharmacies online that sell warafin what is lopid used to treat pill rx health order erection packs 2 products aciphex online no prescription order salbutamol without prescription safe plavix buy buy clarinex astrailia about celebrex medication where to buy florinef with amex drug market order voltaren discount retin a 0,025 otc online pharmacy uk himcolin cailis red best drugstore foundation primer v gel pct buy lamictal generic wikipedia drugs rhinocort order canada procardia now how to use liv 52 levoxyl from canada generic elimite switzerland actonel buy canada tesco pharmacy which uk site to buy silagra generic ed trial pack rumalaya gel shoppers drug mart brand amoxil dosage detrol without prescription best place buy erexin v pct serenata cloridrato sertralina bula tricor delivery courier buy cipro mg best drugstore mascara for asian lashes 2012 what schedule drug is haldol buy midamor generic wellbutrin 40 mg dose alphagan spain over counter can you order zydis trazodone hydrochloride drug class safe to buy generic flomax from usa topamax canada no prescription confido over the counter australia trileptal canadian medications without prescription buy rumalaya forte from canada wellbutrin purchase kamagra shop bewertung elocon by mail order purchase promethazine mg proscar dosage buy lamisilate mexican pharmacies best place to buy silagra clomid steroids men order grifulvin v online no prescription with a visa crestor from canada canadascripts diamox 10 mg cost generic albuterol cost acnetane no prescription compare prices order prazosin 120 mg buy lantus online from australia caprysin canadian online overnight pharmacy metoprolol iv dose atrial fibrillation once a day cialis cheap bactroban generico purchase cymbalta 20 mg can you buy ventolin inhalers over the counter switching from minocycline to doxycycline buy sominex with no rx buy vasotec online no prescription usa buy proventil online in the united states without a prescription prometrium how to buy como tomar citrato de sildenafila 50mg birth control ortho tri cyclen reviews buy canada no prescription for etodolac aricept order online snorting skelaxin effects arjuna cost in canada nolva canadian pharmacy prescription tamoxifen fastest nimotop uk delivery apcalis sx phone orders diovan on line in the uk 24 hour direct pharmacy where to purchase kelnor taking prescription medicine on international flights sumycin price india proscar canada companies only buy nootropil 10 get gasex legal atacand online overnight shipping where to buy cheap generic alfa flucon triamterene hctz 37.5 25 mg side effects purchase tadalafil cialis can you order septilin metocarbamol order cialis tyskland discount canadian pharmacy minomycin what types of depakote are there side effects of entocort ec 3mg best viagra super active prices cialis prescription where to purchase stieva a cheap zithromax free delivery digoxin prescription coupon cheap cardizem no prescription cialis cost canadian prednisone mg tablet what is viagra plus priligy long time side effects hyzaar premarin pills weight gain buy finax 10 buy ampicilina online from usa buy motilium in ireland buy mentat online overnight delivery norvasc drug nutrient interactions estradiol valerate 2mg tablets tadalis sx online overnight lisinopril drugs online purchases to buy ventolin in uk list of tesco stores selling singulair colospa tablets us online ultra low dose adalat exelon patch canada pharmacy order mentat from india without prescription chloramphenicol from canada generic augmentin liquid ultra low dose noroxin where to buy terramycin with visa alfa flucon drug schedule pravachol over the counter india gasex usa sale tofranil mg tablet fast alesse deleviery can you buy elavil in ireland buy viagra soft online without a prescription buy triamterene without a subscription order suprax pill buy micardis mexican pharmacies over counter prometrium what does bisoprololi fumaras albuterol inhaler generic no prescription buy trandate mg where to buy cheap alli tablets 20 cheap abilify 20mg where to buy clotrimazole and betamethasone dipropionate cream uses buy blue lotus pills brand cialis 5mg tablets plendil online canadian provera medicine children vpxl next day shipping yasmin pills online in the uk aristocort mg tablet reviews on metoclopramide generic ortho tri cyclen uk paypal purchase generic tretinoin 0 025 wal mart pharmacy online refill no prescription luvox celebrex prices usa forum propecia review pharmacy cialis how much does wellbutrin cost in canada non persciption micardis what does carafate do for dogs buy anafranil mg turkish pharmacy in haringey tizanidinum delivery london beat way to order flomax zoloft mg no prescription amoxycillin drug in germany pharmacy buy aviane 28 online india can you buy cheap lopressor mg sominex tablets us online how long does it take for sinemet to start working over the counter medicine like nexium renova order suhagra sale brand pharmacy cheap actos 30mg pioglitazone is calcium citrate absorbed better than calcium carbonate what does methotrexate do to your immune system torsemide western australia buy kamagra oral jelly with mastercard lasix diuretico costo generic actoplus met 850 15 850mg liposafe dose best place to buy indocin in uk express shipping hytrin pinkviagra to buy in australia atomoxetin price india doxycycline cost comparison pariet tab side effects odds twins 100mg clomid tamoxifen purchase online citrate how to order curacne online viagra online spain disulfiramo online mexico ondansetrona non perscription countries best place to buy oracea bupropion withdrawal side effects purchase doxycycline 200 mg buy pfizer aldactone online canadian controlled drugs and substances act section oral prednisone dosage for children cytotec prescription prices strattera order in the us cheap lisinopril 20mg online buy zertalin tablets canada almetec over the counter uk femcare phone orders where can i buy meds online buy hydrea online from usa unisom without a prescription from australia generic sinemet buy canada bactroban ointment for sale is fincar a prescription drug buy elimite with a mastercard comprar micronase en argentina existe el viagra para mujeres acai berries in india called discount cardura mg clomid treat low testosterone men buy trial erection packs 3 online india no prescription caprysin sold over counter mestinon coupon code buy hoodia gordonii south africa buy orlistatum online usa dutas uk brand name elavil order by phone cheapest cities to live in canada alti doxycycline buy online australia where purchase kamagra micronase on line in the mexico donde comprar cialis generico df glucotrol xl tablets side effects cheap prednisone buy online viagra dosierung tretinoin 0,025 drugstore com pricing triamterenum canada drug store advair without insurance female viagra by mail order why has xeloda been discontinued rogaine 5 tablets uk prostate flomax alternatives nova school of pharmacy ponce pr can i get high off haldol buy premarin in india online relafen medication online serpina comprare buy seroflo from canada purchase levitra plus pills compare prices cleocin gel viagra professional capsules florinef pill canadian tadacip for men in usa naprosyn visa over the counter shallaki sibustat online canada order cardura online no prescription with a amex cafergot delivery actoplus noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy can i order indocin tretinoin 0,025 uk companies only tulasi telugu movie online veoh buy vytorin in canada buy inderal cheap no prescription luvox sale avodart online orders side effects of motrin 800 mg what types of deltasone are there antara fast canada ampicillin drug in fr pharmacy hydrochlorothiazide canada companies only very cheap glucofage doxycycline cystic acne reviews where to buy himalaya speman over the counter medicine that acts as geriforte neurontin lawsuit canada what is the medicine procardia for costco leicester opening times januvia drug in canada pharmacy synthroid mexico no prescription retino a cream pharmacy prices list pastillas para la ereccion how do i purchase propecia buying vasotec in manchester levothyroxine empty stomach comprar codigo xbox live gold online mail order generic malegra fxt oder mg tablets of amitriptyline health benefits of ginseng capsules canada order ditropan salbutamol online order terramycin ointment price philippines medazole pas cher mebendazole side effects pregnancy arava on line in the uk cheap autoimmune buy compazine usa cod order evista from australia without prescription seroquel high feeling retino a cream 0,025 drug in uk pharmacy order antabuse 200mg online seroquel best price buy cialis super active without a script how to purchase depakote online top 10 online coreg sites imdur generic equivalent what is neurontin 300 mg buy elocom online overnight robaxin available generic cheap canadian priligy no prescription norvasc sales 2008 benefits of aspirin for women havaianas australia buy online triamterene cost canadian prinivil online pharmacy uk viagra generique inde lok adalat orders overnight buy aciphex without
Home BoB Documents National Labor Relations Board vs. Major League Baseball, 880 F. Supp. 246 (1995)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 338 guests online

Atom RSS

National Labor Relations Board vs. Major League Baseball, 880 F. Supp. 246 (1995) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 43
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Judge Sonia Sotomayor   
Wednesday, 27 May 2009 01:38

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT

No. 1999 August Term, 1994

(Argued: May 11, 1995) Decided: September 29, 1995

Docket No. 95-6048

------------------------------------------

DANIEL SILVERMAN, Regional Director

for Region 2 of the National Labor

Relations Board, for and on behalf

of the National Labor Relations Board,

Petitioner-Appellee ,

v.

MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL PLAYER RELATIONS

COMMITTEE, INC. and THE CONSTITUENT MEMBER

CLUBS OF MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL,

Respondents-Appellants .

------------------------------------------

B e f o r e: NEWMAN, Chief Judge , WINTER, and MAHONEY, Circuit

Judges .

Appeal from an order of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (Sonia Sotomayor, Judge ) enjoining appellants to restore the terms and conditions of employment provided under an expired collective bargaining agreement. We affirm.

DOUGLAS L. LESLIE, Charlottesville, Virginia (Lisa Klein Wager, Francis L. Casey, III, Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, New York, New York, of counsel), for Respondents-Appellants .

ELLEN A. FARRELL, Assistant General Counsel (Frederick L. Feinstein, General Counsel, Mary Joyce Carlson, Assistant General Counsel, Robert E. Allen, Associate General Counsel, Donald B. Zavelo, Ian M. Penny, of counsel, National Labor Relations Board, Washington, D.C.), for Petitioner-Appellee .

GEORGE M. COHEN (Virginia A. Seitz, Bredhoff & Kaiser, Washington, D.C., of counsel), for Amicus Curiae Major League Baseball Players Association .

WINTER, Circuit Judge :

This is an appeal by the Major League Baseball Player Relations Committee, Inc. ("PRC") and the constituent member clubs of Major League Baseball ("Clubs") from a temporary injunction issued by Judge Sotomayor pursuant to section 10(j) of the National Labor Relations Act ("NLRA"), 29 U.S.C. § 160(j). The PRC is the collective bargaining representative for the twenty-eight Clubs. The Major League Baseball Players Association is a union that is the exclusive bargaining representative for the forty-man rosters of each major league club. The injunction is based on the district court's conclusion that appellants violated NLRA §§ 8(a)(1) and (5), 29 U.S.C. §§ 158(a)(1) and (5), by unilaterally implementing terms and conditions of employment that differed from those in the last collective agreement. It orders the PRC and the Clubs to: (i) abide by the terms of an expired collective agreement, (ii) rescind any actions taken that are inconsistent with that agreement and (iii) bargain in good faith with the Players Association. See Silverman v. Major League Baseball Player Relations Comm., Inc. , 880 F. Supp. 246, 261 (S.D.N.Y. 1995). The injunction is to remain in effect until either (i) the expired agreement is replaced by a new collective bargaining agreement, (ii) the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") renders a final disposition of the matters pending before it in the related administrative case, or (iii) the district court finds, upon petition of either of the parties, that an impasse has occurred. See id. We affirm.

BACKGROUND

On January 1, 1990, the most recent collective agreement ("Basic Agreement") between appellants and the Players Association became effective. It contained provisions implementing a combination of free agency and a reserve system -- that is, a compromise between free competitive bidding for a player's services and an individual club's exclusive rights to those services.

Free agency, in its purest form, is a status in which the rights to a player's athletic services are not owned by a club and may be shopped around by the player in a quest for the most attractive bid. However, for more than a century, Major League Baseball has had a reserve system that to one degree or another affords individual clubs exclusive property rights to the athletic services of certain players. Before the players were organized and a collective bargaining relationship was established, the standard players contract with a club reserved to the club exclusive rights to a player's services and provided for an annual right of renewal of the contract by the club in question. The Clubs interpreted the contract as allowing the club in question to renew all of an individual player's contract, including the right of renewal provision. So interpreted, this provision -- known generally as the "reserve clause" -- bound a player to one club in perpetuity until traded or released. After the Clubs recognized the Players Association and entered into a collective agreement with it, an arbitrator held in a grievance proceeding that the reserve clause allowed a renewal for only one year rather than a succession of years. See National & American League Professional Baseball Clubs v. Major League Baseball Players Ass'n , 66 Lab. Arb. (BNA) 101 (1976) (Seitz, Arb.). Since then, appellants and the Players Association have struggled to accommodate their conflicting interests in the free agency and reserve issues, and a variety of compromises have from time to time been reached. However, relations have been acrimonious, and several strikes and lockouts have occurred. This appeal itself arises out of a strike that terminated the 1994 season before the playoffs and World Series.

Article XX of the Basic Agreement that became effective in 1990 contains a series of provisions that govern free agency and reserve rights. Players with six or more years of major league service are free agents and may seek competing bids in an effort to obtain the best contract, which may of course give exclusive rights to the club for a stipulated number of years. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 250. Free agency is guaranteed by an anti-collusion provision, Article XX(F), which prohibits the Clubs from acting in concert with each other with respect to the exercise of rights under Article XX. See id. Article XX(F) thus prevents the Clubs from agreeing either to refuse to bid for the services of free agents or to offer only low bids to them. Article XX(F) also prohibits players from acting in concert with regard to Article XX rights. See id.

Players with less than six years of service remain under reserve to their individual clubs, although a club may reserve a player only once. Although a minimum annual salary is provided, players with less than three years of major league service must negotiate with their clubs to determine their salary for the coming season. Article XX allows certain reserved players -- generally those with more than three but less than six years of service -- to demand salary arbitration. See id. at 251. Salary arbitration is a mechanism for determining the individual salaries for that group of reserved players if they cannot arrive at an agreement with their clubs. The player and the club each present the arbitrator with a suggested salary figure for a new one-year contract. The arbitrator then inserts either the player's or the club's figure into a blank uniform contract that the parties have already signed. See id. Article VI(F)(12) provides the following with regard to the criteria to be used, and the evidence to be heard, by the arbitrator:

(12) Criteria . (a) The Criteria will be the quality of the Player's contribution to his Club during the past season (including but not limited to his overall performance, special qualities of leadership and public appeal), the length and consistency of his career contribution, the record of the Player's past compensation, comparative baseball salaries . . . , the existence of any physical or mental defects on the part of the Player, and the recent performance record of the Club including but not limited to its League standing and attendance as an indication of public acceptance (subject to the exclusion stated in subparagraph(b)(i) below). Any evidence may be submitted which is relevant to the above criteria, and the arbitrator shall assign such weight to the evidence as shall to him appear appropriate under the circumstances. The arbitrator shall, except for a Player with five or more years of Major League service, give particular attention, for comparative salary purposes, to the contracts of Players with Major League service not exceeding one annual service group above the Player's annual service group. This shall not limit the ability of a Player or his representative, because of special accomplishment, to argue the equal relevance of salaries of Players without regard to service, and the arbitrator shall give whatever weight to such argument as he deems appropriate.

 

(b) Evidence of the following shall not be admissible:

(i) The financial position of the Player and the Club;

(ii) Press comments, testimonials or similar material bearing on the performance of either the Player or the Club, except that recognized annual Player awards for playing excellence shall not be excluded;

(iii) Offers made by either Player or Club prior to arbitration;

 

(iv) The cost to the parties of their representatives, attorneys, etc.;

 

(v) Salaries in other sports or occupations.

The Basic Agreement expired on December 31, 1993, pursuant to the PRC's notice of termination. Although negotiations for a successor agreement did not get underway until March 1994, the PRC and the Players Association continued to observe the terms of the expired Basic Agreement. Prior to the commencement of negotiations, the Clubs and the Players Association had completed individual salary arbitration hearings and had entered into individual player contracts for the 1994 baseball season, which began in April 1994. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 251.

Negotiations for a new collective bargaining agreement continued unsuccessfully. The PRC offered its first formal economic proposal to the Players Association at a meeting on June 14, 1994. It included a "salary cap," a mechanism that establishes a ceiling on the total player salaries paid by each club. The ceiling may allow some flexibility, depending on the details. Generally, the aggregate salaries of each team are determined by an agreed upon formula and must remain above a minimum percentage of industry revenues, also determined by an agreed upon formula, but below a maximum percentage of those revenues. See Wood v. National Basketball Ass'n , 809 F.2d 954, 957 (2d Cir. 1987). The PRC proposal also eliminated the salary arbitration system and substituted restricted free agency rights for those reserved players previously eligible for salary arbitration. As an alternative to the PRC's proposed salary cap, the Players Association suggested a revenue sharing and luxury "tax" plan that would impose a tax on high-paying clubs. Subsequent proposals reflected disagreement over appropriate tax rates and payroll thresholds above which clubs would be subject to the tax. See Silverman , 880 F.2d at 251-52.

The players struck on August 12, and the 1994 baseball season never resumed. On December 22, 1994, the PRC declared an impasse in negotiations and stated that it intended unilaterally to impose a salary cap and to implement other changes in the terms and conditions of employment, including the elimination of salary arbitration. See Silverman , 880 F.2d at 252. The Players Association responded with a unilateral ban on players signing individual contracts with the Clubs.

Thereafter, cross-charges of unfair labor practices were filed with the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") by the Players Association and the Clubs. The Players Association alleged that the Clubs had engaged in unfair labor practices by unilaterally implementing the salary cap and other terms because the parties were not at an impasse.

On February 3, 1995, counsel for the PRC notified the NLRB General Counsel that the PRC would revoke the implementation of unilateral changes and restore the status quo ante. The General Counsel indicated that the Players Association charges would be dismissed as a result. Counsel for the PRC informed the General Counsel, however, that the PRC did not believe itself obligated to maintain provisions of the Basic Agreement that involved non-mandatory subjects of bargaining. He mentioned salary arbitration in that regard and also suggested that the Clubs might decide to bargain exclusively through the PRC. The NLRB General Counsel declined to offer an advisory opinion on these matters.

Three days later, by memorandum dated February 6, counsel for the PRC notified the Clubs that, until a new collective bargaining agreement was ratified or until further notice, individual clubs had no authority to negotiate contracts with individual players because the PRC was now the Clubs' exclusive bargaining representative. This amounted to an agreement among the Clubs not to hire free agents and thus was a departure from the anti-collusion provision, Article XX(F) of the Basic Agreement. It also amounted to an elimination of salary arbitration, because salary arbitration is a method of arriving at a wage for an individual player contract with a club.

The Players Association thereupon filed a new unfair labor practice charge, and the General Counsel issued a complaint alleging, inter alia , that the Clubs and the PRC had violated Sections 8(a)(1) and (5) of the NLRA by unilaterally eliminating, before an impasse had been reached, competitive bidding for the services of free agents, the anti-collusion provision, and salary arbitration for certain reserved players. The NLRB found that these matters were related to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment and were therefore mandatory subjects for collective bargaining. It then authorized its General Counsel to seek an injunction under NLRA §10(j). On March 27, the NLRB Regional Director filed a petition seeking a temporary injunction restraining the alleged unfair labor practices.

The district court agreed that the NLRB had reasonable cause to conclude that free agency and salary arbitration were mandatory subjects of bargaining and that the Clubs' unilateral actions constituted an unfair labor practice. The district court also concluded that injunctive relief was warranted. This appeal followed. We denied a stay on April 4.

DISCUSSION

The NLRB is authorized under Section 10(j) of the NLRA to petition for temporary injunctive relief from a district court to enjoin ongoing unfair labor practices. 29 U.S.C. § 160(j). If the court has reasonable cause to believe that an unfair labor practice has occurred and that injunctive relief would be just and proper, it should grant appropriate relief. Kaynard v. MMIC, Inc. , 734 F.2d 950, 953 (2d Cir. 1984). The court need not make a final determination that the conduct in question is an unfair labor practice. Kaynard v. Mego Corp. , 633 F.2d 1026, 1033 (2d Cir. 1980). It need find only reasonable cause to support such a conclusion. See id. ; MMIC , 734 F.2d at 953. Appropriate deference must be shown to the judgment of the NLRB, and a district court should decline to grant relief only if convinced that the NLRB's legal or factual theories are fatally flawed. See Mego , 633 F.2d at 1031, 1033; Kaynard v. Palby Lingerie, Inc. , 625 F.2d 1047, 1051 (2d Cir. 1980). In reviewing a district court's grant of injunctive relief pursuant to Section 10(j), a court of appeals must also accord deference to the district court's decision, at least with regard to those aspects that are traditionally left to the district court's discretion. Mego , 633 F.2d at 1030.

We turn now to the merits of the regional director's petition. The petition invokes basic principles of labor law. Section 8(d) of the NLRA mandates that employers and unions bargain in good faith over "wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment." 29 U.S.C. § 158(d). These are so-called mandatory subjects of bargaining. Under caselaw, the parties may propose and bargain over, but may not insist upon, permissive subjects of bargaining. NLRB v. Wooster Div. of Borg-Warner Corp. , 356 U.S. 342, 349 (1958). When a collective agreement expires, an employer may not alter terms and conditions of employment involving mandatory subjects until it has bargained to an impasse over new terms. NLRB v. Katz , 369 U.S. 736, 741-43 (1962). Thereafter, it may implement the new terms. Generally, when an agreement expires, an employer need not bargain to an impasse over terms and conditions involving permissive subjects but may alter them upon expiration. Allied Chem. & Alkali Workers v. Pittsburgh Plate Glass Co. , 404 U.S. 157, 187-88 (1971).

Many of the usual issues that arise in impasse cases are not disputed in the instant matter. The parties agree that the PRC, in directing the Clubs to decline to bargain individually with free agents, unilaterally departed from much of Article XX, which provides for a limited form of free agency and forbids collusive behavior by the Clubs in negotiating with free agents. It is also undisputed that the PRC unilaterally departed from the Basic Agreement's provisions with regard to salary arbitration. The PRC does not claim that it had bargained to an impasse over the free agency, the anti-collusion, or the salary arbitration provisions. Finally, it is also agreed that, if those provisions involved mandatory subjects of bargaining, their unilateral abrogation before impasse was a refusal to bargain in good faith. The PRC and the Clubs argue that the anti-collusion and free agency provisions of the Basic Agreement do not involve mandatory subjects of bargaining and are therefore not subject to the Katz rule that unilateral implementation of new terms is an unfair labor practice unless the employer has bargained to an impasse over these new terms. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 254. The PRC and the Clubs contend that an injunction compelling them to maintain the free agency and anti-collusion provisions undermines their right as a multiemployer group to bargain collectively through an exclusive representative. If so, they would be permissive subjects of bargaining. See Borg Warner , 356 U.S. at 349 . With regard to salary arbitration, the PRC and the Clubs argue that it is the equivalent of interest arbitration -- arbitration of the terms of a new collective agreement -- and thus not a mandatory subject of bargaining. See International Bhd. of Elec. Workers (Collier Elec. Co.) , 296 N.L.R.B. 1095, 1098 (1989).

We are unpersuaded that an injunction compelling the PRC and the Clubs to observe the anti-collusion and free agency provisions of the Basic Agreement infringes on their right as a multiemployer group to bargain through an exclusive representative. Free agency and the ban on collusion are one part of a complex method -- agreed upon in collective bargaining -- by which each major league player's salary is determined under the Basic Agreement. They are analogous to the use of seniority, hours of work, merit increases, or piece work to determine salaries in an industrial context. The PRC and the Clubs describe free agency and the ban on collusion as provisions undermining their right to select a joint bargaining representative because those provisions entail individual contracts with clubs. However, the argument ignores the fact that free agency is simply a collectively bargained method of determining individual salaries for one group of players. The anti-collusion provision is not designed to prevent the PRC from representing the Clubs. Rather, that provision guarantees that free agency will be a reality when permitted by the Basic Agreement. The injunction thus does not in any way prevent the PRC from bargaining as the Clubs' exclusive representative with the Players Association over the elimination of free agency in its entirety or for a modified version of the same, and thereafter from implementing any proposals incorporated into a collective bargaining agreement.

The question, therefore, is whether the free agency, anti-collusion, and reserve issues are -- or there is reasonable cause to believe they are -- otherwise mandatory subjects of bargaining. Section 8(d) of the NLRA defines the duty to bargain as "the obligation . . . to meet . . . and confer in good faith with respect to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment . . . ." In Wood v. Nat'l Basketball Ass'n , 809 F.2d 954 (2d Cir. 1987), we noted that free agency and reserve issues are "at the center of collective bargaining in much of the professional sports industry," id. at 961, and that "it is precisely because of [free agency's] direct relationship to wages and conditions of employment that [it is] so controversial and so much the focus of bargaining in professional sports." Id. at 962.

Wood noted that collective bargaining between professional athletes and leagues raises "numerous problems with little or no precedent in standard industrial relations." Id. at 961. Such is the case with a free agency and reserve system. For the most part, unionized employees in the industrial sector may leave one employer for another without restriction. The employee may have no bargaining rights with regard to the terms of hire by the new employer, which may be set by a collective agreement, but is nevertheless generally free to go from one unionized job to another. [1]  

The professional sports industry has a very different history and very different economic imperatives. Most professional sports leagues have always had some form of what has become known as the reserve system. See Flood v. Kuhn , 407 U.S. 258, 259 n.1 (1972) (baseball); Robertson v. National Basketball Ass'n , 556 F.2d 682, 686 n.6 (2d Cir. 1977) (basketball); Mackey v. National Football League , 543 F.2d 606, 610 (8th Cir. 1976) (football), cert. dismissed , 434 U.S. 801 (1977); McCourt v. California Sports, Inc. , 600 F.2d 1193, 1194 (6th Cir. 1979) (hockey). As noted, this is a system by which the right to a player's services becomes the property of a particular club with limited freedom for the player to seek employment with another club. The reserve system in one form or another has been used in major league baseball for over a century. Until the arbitration decision in 1976, the reserve system prevented players from offering their athletic services to competing teams. A player's services were thus the property of a single team until he was traded or released. In enforcing a complete reserve system, Major League Baseball was exercising monopsony power -- a buyer's monopoly.

However, there are many reasons, apart from maximizing the transfer of revenues from players to clubs, why reserve systems exist within professional sports. Fans might not be interested in games between teams that had entirely new lineups for every contest. Moreover, high quality play may require that individuals practice and play with the same teammates for at least some period of time. Teams may also want to recoup what they regard as training costs invested in players while they gained experience. In antitrust litigation, the leagues perennially argue that some form of reserve system is necessary for competitive balance. See Mackey , 543 F.2d at 611. Indeed, even in a system of complete free agency, one would expect to see many long-term agreements binding individual players to particular clubs.

There are also reasons, apart from maximizing the transfer of revenues to players, why a union of professional athletes would seek free agency. It is very difficult to set individual salaries in professional sports through collective bargaining. Although unions of professional athletes may bargain for uniform benefits and minimum salaries, they do not usually follow their industrial counterparts and seek relatively fixed salaries by job description, seniority, or other formulae. Players often play positions requiring very different skills. Moreover, the level of performance and value to a team in attracting fans differs radically among players, with star athletes or popular players being far more valuable than sub-par or nondescript players. Usually, therefore, players unions seek some form of free agency as a relatively simple method of setting individual salaries.

Most importantly, however, both the leagues and the players unions view free agency and reserve issues as questions of what share of revenues go to the clubs or to the players. The more restrictive the reserve system is, the greater the clubs' share. The greater the role of free agency, the greater the players' share.

To hold that there is no reasonable cause for the NLRB to conclude that free agency and reserve issues are mandatory subjects of bargaining would be virtually to ignore the history and economic imperatives of collective bargaining in professional sports. A mix of free agency and reserve clauses combined with other provisions is the universal method by which leagues and players unions set individual salaries in professional sports. Free agency for veteran players may thus be combined with a reserve system, as in baseball, or a rookie draft, as in basketball, see Wood , 809 F.2d at 957, for newer players. A salary cap may or may not be included. See id. To hold that any of these items, or others that make up the mix in a particular sport, is merely a permissive subject of bargaining would ignore the reality of collective bargaining in sports.

Indeed, free agency is in many ways nothing but the flip side of the reserve system. A full reserve system does not eliminate individual bargaining between teams and players. It simply limits that bargaining to one team. If free agency were a permissive subject of collective bargaining, then so would be the reserve system.

With regard to salary arbitration, we will assume, but not decide, that if it is a form of interest arbitration, it may be unilaterally eliminated. See George Koch & Sons, Inc. , 306 N.L.R.B. 834, 839 (1992) (interest arbitration permissive subject of bargaining). Interest arbitration is a method by which an employer and union reach new agreements by sending disputed issues to an arbitrator rather than settling them through collective bargaining and economic force. See New York Typographical Union No. 6 v. Printers League , 919 F.2d 3 n.2 (2d Cir. 1990). The salary arbitration provisions of the Basic Agreement are a method by which salaries for some players who are not eligible for free agency -- those with three to six years of major league service -- are set. The Basic Agreement sets forth criteria by which the arbitrator is to reach a decision. These criteria include the player's performance in the prior year, the length and consistency of career contribution, physical or mental defects, recent performance of the team on the field and at the gate, and salaries of certain comparable players. The Basic Agreement also forbids the arbitrator from considering certain facts that might otherwise be relevant. Finally, the Basic Agreement requires that the arbitrator pick either the club's suggested salary or the player's.

We decline to analogize Article VI(f) of the Basic Agreement to interest arbitration. Salary arbitration provides limited discretion to the arbitrator to set salaries for designated players who are not eligible for free agency. The discretion afforded the arbitrator is arguably less than the discretion afforded arbitrators in grievance arbitration involving disputes arising under an existing collective agreement, which is beyond question a mandatory subject of bargaining. In grievance arbitration, an arbitrator may permissibly imply a term even though the term has no explicit support in the text of the collective agreement. See United Steelworkers of America v. Warrior & Gulf Navigation Co. , 363 U.S. 574, 581-82 (1960) ("The labor arbitrator's source of law is not confined to the express provisions of the contract, as the industrial common law -- the practices of the industry and the shop -- is equally a part of the collective bargaining agreement although not expressed in it."); see also Holly Sugar Corp. v. Distillery, Rectifying, Wine & Allied Workers Int'l Union , 412 F.2d 899, 903 (9th Cir. 1969). Similarly, a term may be implied from past practices even though somewhat inconsistent with the agreement. See International Chem. Workers Union, Local No. 278 v. Imco Container Co. , 78 L.R.R.M. (BNA) 2014 (S.D. Ind. 1971). We thus decline to analogize salary arbitration to interest arbitration, and, therefore, we hold that there is reasonable cause to believe that it is a mandatory subject of bargaining.

With regard to whether the granting of relief was "just and proper," 29 U.S.C. § 160(j), we review the district court's determination only for abuse of discretion. Mego , 633 F.2d at 1030; Palby Lingerie , 625 F.2d at 1051. We see no such abuse in the present matter. Given the short careers of professional athletes and the deterioration of physical abilities through aging, the irreparable harm requirement has been met. The unilateral elimination of free agency and salary arbitration followed by just three days a promise to restore the status quo. The PRC decided to settle the original unfair labor practice charges while embarking on a course of action based on a fallacious view of the duty to bargain. We see no reason to relieve it of the consequences of that course.

We therefore affirm.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?