buy malegra fxt plus cheap imuran price cheap levitra plus prescription order alphagan buy quibron t dose cheap quibron-t buy voveran sr wiki buy mircette line buy lasix from uk cheap effexor xr for ocd isoptin discount get cheap elimite instructions buy nitroglycerin houston order actoplus met side effects order apcalis sx side effects viagra sublingual discount brasil cheap elavil reviews cheap retino-a cream 0 05 ha order valtrex.com reviews cheap voveran sr safe in pregnancy order v gel supraglottic airway device cheap cialis super active vs regular cialis buy nitrofurantoin korea order weight loss juicing buy revia you order actoplus met tablets cafergot discount online proscar discount voucher buy mircette a prescription imitrex injection discount order eldepryl female viagra discount best buy alli weight loss pills urispas discount program buy xalatan from uk buy clomid safely online cheap atarax jarabe buy men;s health week cialis super active discount long does order isoptin prescription cheap mentat wiki buy lantus japan buy retin a 0.025 cheap lariam uk buy januvia 100 mg buy aciclovir tablets in the uk diovan discount vouchers buy ortho tri cyclen online cheap apcalis sx review buy rogaine 5 percent order v gel himalaya how to use cialis jelly discount uk order brand cialis generic cheap advair diskus alternatives where to buy pyridium in canada metoclopramide discounts buy cheap ortho tri cyclen lo maxaman discount code order zovirax cheap motrin capitalizacao sa cheap topamax australia buy bupropion sr cut in half order innopran xl cheap rentals in myrtle beach cheap diclofenac gel work buy wahl lithium ion buy zoloft minocycline to buy cheap prevacid buy cheap retin-a 0 025 gel order clindamycin gel online buy cardizem rx order dried mango online buy himalaya shatavari cheap carafate very buy atorlip 10 cipla buy female viagra online cheap buy arthritis bracelet sleep aid discount quality plus order cabgolin o.5 cheap erythromycin india benicar hct discount buy quetiapine online uk buy micronase prescription order toprol xl zantac alavert discount vouchers buy abilify uk cheap cialis super active france buy snovitra super power erfahrungen cheap ortho tri cyclen mood swings cheap cafergot emicrania how to order provigil cheap viagra plus brand cheapest alli tablets uk cheap zyloprim plm cheap wellbutrin sr night sweats buy lithium carbonate uk buy diclofenac cream order zofran qtc get zoloft prescription buy himalaya septilin tablets cheap reglan breastfeeding men;s health discount yahoo buy cholesterol lowering unclog arteries buy bupropion sr for adhd order aciclovir zovirax cheap styplon tablets buy zyrtec in bulk buy innopran xl for tremors order wellbutrin sr benefits cheap flagyl dosage cheap desyrel alternatives buy clomid (clomiphene citrate) buy zovirax cheap lamisil alternatives cheap female cialis buy cheap claritin vs cheap viagra plus nz where to buy penegra in chennai order ginette 35 cipla female viagra discount kaufen cialis super active discount plus cheap apcalis sx mg opinie cheap advair diskus use order zanaflex overnight cheap betoptic generic order viagra super active x 10 pill buspar discount pharmacy cheap ortho tri cyclen uk buy lithium batteries buy reminyl uses cheap isoptin verapamil buy actos angeles buy raglan t shirts kamagra gold discount opis order anti fungal groin buy nitroglycerin way generic zoloft com kamagra gold discount warszawa cheap prandin bula order erythromycin japan buy maxalt rpd buy zyban online australia buy viagra jelly malaysia buy capoten can cheap erythromycin version buy carafate vegas pamelor discount pharmacy cheap viagra jelly express delivery purchase effexor xr online buy capoten vegas buy cytotec canada grifulvin v discount coupon order hyzaar losartan buy phenergan suppositories online buy l tryptophan quitting smoking cheap cholesterol lowering high buy cleocin gel strength buy allopurinol buy tofranil vidal order requip online premarin for cheap buy dutas pills order brand cialis name vs generic effexor xr discount uses buy calendula order dramamine youtube cymbalta get you high motrin discount vouchers order carafate otc cheap diclofenac gel topical buy valtrex from india order neurontin over the counter buy triamterene australia buy elavil you cheap mentat ds syrup price order cialis soft how to take cheap apcalis sx wirkung cheap hair loss yahoo answers cheap floxin gtts hyaluronic acid discount nz buy ethionamide prescription female cialis discount work buy asacol vancouver order cialis super active buy order blopress zuzahlung men;s health discount ebook the six-pack secret buy shatavari isoptin discount coupon viagra professional discount sildigra cheap muscle relaxant minocycline discount vouchers order maxalt side flovent discount cheap hair loss xarelto order benzac gel buy alavert philippines cheap v gel docsinnovent buy motilium in canada order evista best place diamox discount cheap toprol xl zantac buy naprosyn online uk buy casodex vancouver buy januvia africa cheap azulfidine in usa buy cholesterol lowering buy zyvox rx cheap actos zippy buy cialis online buy nolvadex tamoxifen buy xenical yugoslavia cheap toprol xl withdrawal cheap tricor buy buy proscar uk online buy carafate veterinary cheap erexin v mega opinie buy orlistat dubai buy atorlip 10 que sirve buy female cialis vancouver cheap oxytrol coupon buy augmentin hong kong cheap lisinopril xerostomia order rumalaya liniment price order dipyridamole ventolin mail order robaxin discount generic cheap albendazole alternatives isoptin discount card cheap toprol xl long term side effects hyaluronic acid discount lip injections propecia buy now cheap viagra plus germany generic viagra soft tabs reviews buy zoloft cod cheap cefixime wiki cheap diclofenac gel la copii cialis soft discount espan~a buy yasmin tablets cheap kamagra gold flashback cheap albenza buy cheap azulfidine very cheap azulfidine alternatives order levitra professional kaufen cheap cleocin gel strength brand cialis discount name online cheap desyrel prescription order cephalexin for dogs tamoxifen discount buy levitra super active baby buy innopran xl cafepharma buy premarin injection buy anti fungal herbs cheap actos administrativos buy requip line order toprol xl side effects weight gain endep discount voucher buy zyban stop smoking cheap advair diskus assistance program order viagra super active description buy cialis online usa cheap mentat uses cheap viagra sublingual absorption order atorlip 20 de 20 mg buy urispas in thailand azulfidine discount voucher olanzapine discount generic cheap cholesterol lowering recipes buy protonix africa buy xalatan for cheap buy retin-a 0,025 buy seroquel online uk order tetracycline liquid buy avodart in australia order toprol xl your blood order weight loss after birth kamagra gold discount africa cheap inderal la buy female viagra york buy reglan kol order feldene zastrzyki zeroth order reaction mobicalls cheap mango discount code november 2012 order anti fungal dog shampoo buy seroquel australia order aciclovir bula cheap proventil inhaler order propecia xertigny mango bikes discount mango order number cheap cialis super active generico ampicillin discount lipitor discount card program cialis soft discount online pharmacy cefadroxil discounts buy septilin beneficios cheap kamagra gold dejstvo buy orlistat nz buy tulasi plant online in usa buy anafranil line order meclizine cheap viagra generic order clonidine uk order brand cialis prescription online purchase dilantin canada cheap azulfidine buy seroflo inhaler cheap effexor xr jittery cardizem discount get hydrochlorothiazide discount price buy nolvadex usa order terramycin la order flagyl er what does order metformin loss buy antivert generic online cheap viagra plus for sale buy rogaine 5 lotion review hair loss discount from steroids order calcium carbonate kidney stones cheap brand levitra generic buy elocon cream 100g buy brand viagra pfizer online astrazeneca nexium discount order alavert form buy naprosyn vancouver capoten buy online buy innopran xl migraine order weight loss blogs order skelaxin you buy clindamycin acne order motrin dosage order imuran buy brand name topamax order parlodel hamilelik coreg cr discount card buy men;s health twitter buy cytotec quezon city cialis soft discount tabs dosage order cephalexin online buy viagra soft york wellbutrin sr discount reviews adhd cheap v gel atika beauty cheap muscle relaxant kidney stones maxaman discount voucher order mangoes from india cheap cialis soft alcohol buy hydrea powder buy floxin antibiotics order female viagra from canada online buy antabuse in australia cheap viagra ebay buy casodex vidal order arjuna vs order roxithromycin canada buy atorlip 20 efectos secundarios buy clomid to get pregnant cheap viagra soft effects the order vana v pdf cheap viagra sublingual order finax tablet buy casodex pure discount for diovan buy female viagra jelly online uk cheap kamagra oral jelly directions use generic zoloft problems cheap speman price order clonidine a prescription buy innopran xl wiki buy zyrtec australia cheap levitra plus alcohol cheap actoplus met xr generic buy female cialis buy xenical generic cheap rental near me buy female viagra in india order trental buy avalide pills buy aceon can buy ginseng plant buy leukeran solution order cardizem illegal cheap levitra plus pills shuddha guggulu discount cholesterol order remeron xanax aceon discount cards order brands levitra in india can you buy reglan over the counter order viagra super active for sale; cheap maxalt than buy rumalaya online cheap hair loss while pregnant wellbutrin sr discount not working cheap dipyridamole get order trazodone you order rogaine 5 months cialis soft discount online cheap trial erection packs 1 year buy emsam line can you order provigil online hyaluronic acid discount rich foods cheap provigil online cheap nizagara buy ortho tri cyclen estrogen level cheap muscle relaxant jaw female viagra discount work cheap effexor xr zoloft cheap muscle relaxant knots cheap doxazosin buy order v gel amazon buy diclofenac sodium online propranolol discount voucher buy nolvadex canadian pharmacy cheap advair diskus manufacturer coupons where to buy baytril for squirrels buy himalaya shallaki online cheap artane number order cialis professional does celebrex discount buy hydrea from uk buy orlistat generic uk buy lithium element order tadacip cipla buy cheap xalatan cheap rumalaya gel grifulvin v discount gris-peg grisactin order cialis sublingual xanax cheap floxin tablets buy propecia at walmart buy ventolin inhaler online liv 52 discount ds buy propranolol vietnam buy luvox reviews wellbutrin sr discount night sweats cheap etodolac india buy cholesterol lowering ldl buy accutane uk buy zyrtec d generic order tadalis sx wirkung effexor xr cost at walmart buy cardizem from canada order atorlip 20 side effects buy deltasone can u cheapest alli weight loss pills cheap lioresal vidal buy cleocin gel generic order weight loss news order phenergan with codeine syrup can you buy pariet over the counter cheap albenza dosing buy brand viagra legally load order realistic lighting order zofran cheap azulfidine india effexor xr discount forum the order vana v epub buy capoten uk online buy didronel on line buy propecia online usa suhagra discount code cheap cialis sublingual prec,o cheap effexor xr reviews buy zyvox uk online buy terramycin uk buy nitrofurantoin 100mg online buy crestor online australia cheap fml forte information mircette discount program buy revia best place buy lukol tablet cheap emsam forum buy lithium metal online order atorlip 20 medicine discount provigil canada order erectile dysfunction at 20 order aciphex illegal cheap fml forte gotas ojos cheap viagra jelly quick delivery order trazodone rx buy cytotec cavite area order cialis soft brasil cheap advair diskus vs inhaler cheap lady era hornets cialis super active discount vs regular cialis order suhagra force order clonidine generic order alphonso mango buy emsam las vegas order levothroid availability cheap viagra jelly reliable buy casodex the counter cheap metformin a prescription hair loss discount quiz order flagyl er av kroppen buy xenical xanthi buy casodex liquid liv 52 discount year round cheap viagra professional pills cheap ginette 35 breast size
Home BoB Documents PEDs MLBPA Releases Statement Explaining Why "Survey Test" Results Were Not Destroyed

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 516 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA Releases Statement Explaining Why "Survey Test" Results Were Not Destroyed PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 18
PoorBest 
Performance-Enhancing Drugs (PEDs)
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 09 February 2009 21:47

Donald Fehr

MLBPA Executive Director Donald Fehr releases a statement
explaining for the first time why the 2003 "survey test" results
were not destroyed in Nov. of 2003.

As the revelation that Alex Rodriguez was one of 104 players in 2003 that tested positive during what was collectively bargained between MLB and the MLB Players Association as part of a “survey test”, questions have arisen as to the handling of the samples and data associated with them afterwards. The 2003-2006 CBA reads in part:

At the conclusion of any Survey Test, and after the results of all tests have been calculated, all test results, including any identifying characteristics, will be destroyed in a process jointly supervised by the Office of the Commissioner and the Association.

Those records were not destroyed, and eventually were seized as part of the BALCO investigation. (for more details see The Fourth Amendment, the MLBPA and the BALCO Investigation on Baseball Prospectus)

Up until today, no explanation had been given as to why the survey test was not destroyed.

Major League Baseball Players Association Executive Director, Donald M. Fehr, today issued the following statement in response to questions raised concerning recent reports about the 2003 testing program.

“We are issuing this statement today to respond to two questions that have been raised in the last few days in connection with reports about Alex Rodriguez and the 2003 MLB testing program. First, it has been asked why the results from our 2003 survey tests were not destroyed before they were seized by the government in the spring of 2004. The short answer is that in November, 2003, before that could take place, a grand jury subpoena for program records was issued.

“In mid-November 2003, the 2003 survey test results were tabulated and finalized. The MLBPA first received results on Tuesday, November 11.

Those results were finalized on Thursday, November 13, and the players were advised by a memo dated Friday, November 14. Promptly thereafter, the first steps were taken to begin the process of destruction of the testing materials and records, as contemplated by the Basic Agreement. On November 19, however, we learned that the government had issued a subpoena. Upon learning this, we concluded, of course, that it would be improper to proceed with the destruction of the materials. The fact that such a subpoena issued in November 2003 has been part of the public record for more than two years. See, U.S. v. CDT, 473 F3d at 920 (2006), and 513 F3d at 1090 (2008) (both opinions have now been vacated). Other subpoenas followed, including one for all test results.

“Over the next several months we attempted to negotiate a resolution of the matter with the United States Attorneys Office for the Northern District of California. During that time we pledged to the government attorneys that the materials would not be destroyed. When the government attorneys refused to withdraw its subpoena for all 2003 test results, we decided to ask a judge to determine to what the government was entitled. See, 473 F3d at 944, and 513 F3d at 1118. On the same day we were filing our papers with the court, the government attorneys obtained a search warrant and they began seizing materials the following day. Pursuant to that search warrant which named only 10 individuals, the government seized records for every baseball player tested under our program, in addition to many records related to testing in other sports, and even records for other (non-sport) business entities.

“Later in 2004 three federal district judges in three different judicial districts ruled that the government’s seizures were unconstitutional under the Fourth Amendment and ordered the government to return all the materials seized (except for those related to the 10 players listed in the original search warrant). The government appealed and the matter is still pending before the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

On December 18, 2008, the case was reargued before an en banc panel of Ninth Circuit judges.

“The second question that has been raised in recent days is whether Gene Orza or any other MLBPA official was engaged in improper “tipping” of players about 2004 tests. As we have said before, there was no improper tipping of players. Any allegations that Gene Orza or any other MLBPA official acted improperly are wrong. This issue was raised last year by Chairman Waxman of the House Government Reform Committee following the issuance of the Mitchell Report, and last July I sent him a ten-page letter clarifying the record on this subject. The letter is a pubic document (http://oversight.house.gov/documents/20080703114405.pdf). In that letter, I describe certain privileged conversations MLBPA attorneys conducted in September 2004 with members whose names appeared on certain government lists. It should be noted that the Commissioner’s Office was aware that such conversations were taking place, and in fact those conversations were conducted pursuant to an agreement between the MLBPA and the Commissioner.”

Source: MLB Players Association


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Subscribe to The Biz of Baseball

Add to GoogleAdd to My Yahoo!

Subscribe in Bloglines


 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?