doxycycline hyclate malaria instructions side effects of glyset how to get dilantin in australia us online pharmacy no prescription famvir what is brahmi tea antabuse discounts codes dostinex on line canada drugs online no prescription accutane 10 mg per week coupon codes buy zyvox citalopram order online accutane pharmacy coupons malegra dxt from usa dune mentat eyebrows actonel drugs online purchases sale actos online sale of triamterene does propecia work on receding hairlines buy cholestoplex singapore how to import dramamine periactin pills used what drug category is diarex pill identifier white oval m367 q precio tienen pastillas cytotec how much is lamisil pills order arimidex online with visa finasteride propecia 1 mg or proscar 5 mg menosan usa sale how to purchase tricor online chloromycetin reviews for men where can i buy generic levitra how to order medicine from canada can i get meclizine how much is leukeran tablets betoptic over the couter order abortion pill cytotec online what types of nizagara are there blopress medication order florida atacand viagra free sample canada keflex price australia xenical drugs orlistat lipase astelin overseas can paroxetine cause weight gain uk buy vpxl without prescription nexium generics in europe elimite online ordering voveran over counter cabergoline sex drive pharmaceutical drug salesman comprare alli orlistat viagra on sale online viagra alternatives that work billig capoten online kaufen low cost retin-a 0,05 liposafe canadian pharmacy buy ampicillin without rx insulin passport nhs finax by mail order como comprar elocon buy lariam perth australia finax 100 review premarin dosage recommended cheap on line viagrpills do i need a prescription for vermox certificated mevacor without insurance buy minocycline online overnight pilex side effects long term use dipyridamole in the uk now billig nitroglycerin online kaufen advair diskus from china cephalexin for dogs side effects peeing benzaclin back order where to buy alligator meat in orlando generic cialis professional nasal atrovent dosage online pharmacy usa no prescription cialis seroquel for bipolar reviews online pharmacy uk ciplox can you buy flagyl er where can i get acai berry in stores lopid discount zenegra tablets for sale how to order voveran sr online protonix ships from india effexor xr 40mg no prescription nimotop tadapox for dogs buy confido where can i buy it max dose of benadryl for dogs purchase generic skelaxin what is prednisolone made of equivalent du xenical benicar mg order renagel drug study duetact 30-4 mg mebendazole uk pharmacy reviews on acai berry cleanse gabapentin dosage bnf purchase medrol in australia side effects of propranolol in babies ropinirole side effects parkinson;s does levitra work better than viagra minipress in canada viagra slovenia rumalaya gel online forum order plavix online in usa where can i buy prednisone online can you buy adalat pharmacy prescription zyvox annual sales cheap pills buy florinef actonel generic form maxifort seeds in the uk discount coupons voltaren gel do acai tablets really work cheap genuine cardizem online comprar finpecia en pharmacy2home prednisone 1 mg price mirapex discount card augmentin discount glass in generic lipitor ezetimibe max dose requip medication information tretinoin generic canada no prescription celadrin australia pharmacy levaquin next day delivery safe to buy generic doxycycline from canada bupropion smoking cessation dosage culturismo sin tonterias pdf what doses does wellbutrin come in alphagan medication side effects can you buy levitra professional in ireland pharmacy canadian comprar purim original best price for viagra sublingual pharmaceutical machinery manufacturers in india where can i buy bupron sr in canada how long is it safe to take unisom while pregnant buy desyrel overseas cuanto sale orlistat argentina $9 relion ventolin hfa inhaler propecia forum review pharmacy abilify overnight delivery cod zyban online in usa synthroid over the counter buy albuterol sulfate inhalation solution 0.083 advair diskus limited india baytril dose for snakes how long does it take for benicar hct to work azulfidine cost in canada i want to pay some indocin buy amoxil mg safe place order alavert buy brand septilin flovent hfa price canadian pharmacy cordarone voltaren gel usa best price for omnicef zyvox dosage medication rx pharmacy generic viagra lamictal dose pack green nitroglycerin ointment in india order how long does levitra last viagra seroquel tablets 40mg biaxin discount ciplox limited india plavix clopidogrel 75mg tablets zithromax chlamydia trileptal tablets 150 mg buy decadron boots pharmacy apcalis sx online overnight keppra discount card long time side effects lotrisone exelon employment chicago water pills safety 100mg topamax and birth control canadian pharmacy erection packs 11 pills antabuse 20 mg buy cheap motilium taiwan stromectol buy price increase zanaflex kamagra oral jelly 100mg sale indocin dosage for gout is it illegal to order generic silagra over the counter canada lamisil cream one guy one jar video what does cialis 20 mg look like buy cephalexin without rx evecare buy on line elocon tablet sale minocycline dosage for perioral dermatitis buy alphagan brimonidine tartrate buy benadryl cheap finax free delivery gabapentin 300mg capsules pain cialis side effects for young men where can i buy mevacor wellbutrin xr 150 side effects cost of maxalt melt buying prograf from canada no prescription what is the generic drug for cipro where purchase starlix norvasc drugs for sale malegra fxt online pay paypal ventolin drugs com buy levaquin 20 lipothin wanted online review brand cipro buy buy cleocin gel 15mg online buy nizoral online usa prograf 5 mg price does watermelon have same effect viagra buy flonase online no prescription united states speman suppliers overseas order bentyl tablets generic name for lady era sale prescription buy cozaar onde comprar pariet mais barato voltaren cheap uk horse racing first time lasix mail-order acivir pills promethazine overdose antidote when does viagra patent expires tegretol 400 mg tablets 2009 nike air max men dipyridamole australia nexium with no rx florida serpina entocort ec coupon atenolol 25 mg side effects to buy penegra in uk clomiphene early menopause what are xenical tablets for salep elocon untuk ibu hamil hoodia without prescription purchase etodolac 300 mg best website to buy viagra probalan without insurance generic voveran switzerland us online pharmacy no prescription micardis cephalexin for dogs how many days viagra no prescrip canada buy lincocin online amazon costco pharmacy proscar price xeloda rx prednisone online sale chloroquine comprare low amitriptyline back pain buy wellbutrin sr online from usa use amaryl coupon online genuine entocort best price cheapest malegra fxt to buy zoloft insomnia does it go away buy tamoxifen citrate research nolvadex glucotrol contraindications long time side effects suhagra buy viagra professional 50 plavix shop net what is cialis pills used for cialis soft tab review pamelor next day vermox prescription medication 100mg cialis 72 hour buy haridra in singapore furosemide side effects in cats female viagra buy uk ordering birth control pills online pharmacies in windsor ontario prednisolone mg tablets genuine generic acticin lamictal medication side effects ordering avandamet canadian pharmacy lipitor generic costco metronidazole over the counter cream periactin cost canadian coreg dose for congestive heart failure carafate from usa maxalt dosage for children viagra generika billig kaufen clorfenamina dosis toxica pharmacy store for sale in nj olanzapine teva 20 mg cheap prilosec buy online buy yasmin canada zithromax dose pack singulair generic picture betapace no prescription reviews zyrtec ulotka krople viagra on ebay uk sarafem uk buy buy carafate 5 qsymia in the uk cvs rx pharmacy order maxalt antibiotics products etodolac uk next day delivery genuine bentyl medication spastic colon what is valacyclovir hcl tabs can you buy inderal over the counter in germany alavert d-12 reviews atarax price us india paxil price reglan prices usa cheap phentermine online without rx what is the medication trazodone used for can i buy chloramphenicol eye drops indian generics online inderal trental lawsuit settlements discount drugstore coupons para que se usa el lopid where to buy orlistat in singapore all types rumalaya forte pills diflucan mg uk buy viagra online australia no prescription zyprexa side effects forum to buy lamisil what dose of clomid should i take for pct donde puedo comprar el orlistat generic brand amoxil legitimate online pharmacies forum what is levothroid prescribed for medicine decadron proventil uk companies only cheapest procardia to buy wellbutrin usa cvs prices 1 pound fish remix citalopram combination therapy liquid rhinocort review aciphex billig kaufen zoloft without a prescription from canada order indocin online in usa buy toradol online crestor rosuvastatin tablets side effects cheapest arimidex in the uk purchase asacol cheap etodolac canine dose allegra d cvs price best sex enhancing drugs venlor cost in canada buy zetia online without prescription mexico buy floxin online singulair low dose birth control prilosec otc in india overnight delivery online pharmacies voltaren gel 100 gm erythromycin ointment no prescription sex power tablets bangladesh what is tamoxifen for men order liv medication by mail purchase pravachol cheap can you buy cialis sublingual in ireland actos cost at walmart thyroid medication free nhs where to buy allison cabinet pulls pills phenergan shortage 2012 licensed pharmacy protonix isoniazid tablets online stay erect with herbal erection pills indocin pregnancy class i want to pay some cozaar where to get aciphex pct prednisolone daily use reviews how much does anastrozole cost in the uk liposafe online purchase cheap reminyl pills cozaar mg usa buy cheap zithromax online costco pharmacy zaditor price rogaine 5 australia pharmacy purchase silagra on line in australia shortage of alli weight loss pills norvasc dosage 2.5mg buy sinequan next day buy brand amoxil usa price of nexium 40 mg in canada comprar synthroid original en madrid gabapentin weight gain mechanism get kytril las vegas how long does it take for estrace to start working keppra negative reviews losartan potassium side effects cough what does celexa do for depression brand cialis from canadian pharmacy online diclofenac gel purchase lipitor in the uk now buying prevacid for dogs zithromax antibiotics and alcohol cipro pills online in the india buy aciphex 20 mg online pharmacy no prescription needed aldactone where can i purchase beconase aq viagra sublingual prescription cheap robaxin free delivery generic propecia paypal buy pravachol paypal accepted motrin supplier in uk how long does it take for ranitidine to start working medrol tablets used for buy over the counter artane online femara pharmacies methotrexate monitoring blood tests original celadrin online best diet to lose weight fast without pills zebeta tablets uk purinethol canada prescription abortion pill cytotec side effects canadian online pharmacy for nexium pramipexole dihydrochloride tablets online sale of allopurinol price increase diamox what family of drugs is wellbutrin asthma inhalers over the counter nike 95 air max black deltasone free shipping can you buy olanzapine in ireland buy prednisolone online no prescription usa what is inderal tablets used for purchasing revatio online cvs pharmacy online application form ranitidine medication used for leo messi stats why is there a shortage of minocin buy lisinopril bulk aciclovir pharmacy online do i need a prescription for alesse morning after pill boots order online meds clonidine is quibron-t a prescription drug what is lithium carbonate prescribed for doescialas work maxalt discount code no rx zebeta online danazol on line no script fastest cholestoplex uk delivery cheap pravachol 80 mg where is allianz stadium saracens generic arjuna no prescription buy augmentin without a script can you cheap buy benicar hct aciclovir creme mylan pharmacy has best price zofran confido brand positioning buy seroflo capsules order elimite cream online buy propranolol in singapore wellbutrin side effects anger hostility venda alli internet drug generic differin gel instructions is generic atorlip-20 effective colospa costco generic metformin pictures ponstel generic name isoniazid canadian source what does cyklokapron treat does doxycycline make you gain weight minocycline medicine for by tenormin canada no prescription buy nizagara canadian acivir pills generic reviews where can i buy alligator tail meat ordering confido cefixime 5mg tablets buy accutane online overnight delivery all types avandamet pills ranitidine hcl oral tablet 300 mg ditropan over the counter canada decadron 4 mg price best place to buy strattera in mexico zenegra uk next day delivery buy promethazine codeine syrup no prescription online order amantadine online uk buy cymbalta without a perscription long time side effects aldactone original innopran xl online prilosec over the counter dose quiero comprar glucophage can you get celebrex generic retino-a cream 0,025 us is it safe to order silagra is it safe to order tamoxifen buy plavix in ireland anthem rx online pharmacy accredited pharmacy technician online training buy cheap valtrex no prescription himplasia mg buy amaryl uk brand name cheap glucophage uk generic for voltaren generic clonidine photos purchase propranolol mg does walgreens have elimite cream allergy medicine for dogs benadryl number 1 online canadian pharmacy wellbutrin generic release date ventolin hfa uses cheap generic zetia avodart discount program cardizem cd patient reviews ordering finasteride online finasteride 5mg vs. propecia 1mg xenical for sale usa buying pamelor using paypal over the counter prednisone cyproheptadine weight gain adults clomid direct pharmacy amoxil antibiotics prescription buy cheap Purchase abilify 2 pharmacy what is levothroid used for what is parietal lobe function
Home Maury Brown Breaking Down How Salary Arbitration Functions in MLB

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 988 guests online

Atom RSS

Breaking Down How Salary Arbitration Functions in MLB PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 25
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 30 January 2009 17:09

A Biz of Baseball Original ArticleEach year, hundreds of millions of dollars are doled out to players that are part of the salary arbitration process in Major League Baseball. This year, 111 eligible players filed for salary arbitration, and by mid-February all of them will have reached new contracts either through negotiations with their respective clubs, or through rulings by an arbitration panel.

While many have heard of the process, the details aren’t widely published. With arbitration season in MLB in full swing, here’s a breakdown of the process.

History

Many have said that the breaking of the Reserve Clause is the greatest advancement for the players, but Marvin Miller, the former executive director for the MLB Players Association, has said that salary arbitration did more for advancing the salaries and rights of the players.

Before 1973, players were offered a contract by the clubs they played for, and it was a matter of “take it, or leave it.” In an attempt to challenge the Reserve Clause, as well as leverage higher salaries in this system, players began conducting holdouts on contract renewals. The owners, and then commissioner Bowie Kuhn, realizing the wolves were at the door, opted to allow salary arbitration as a way of stopping the holdouts, and rationalized that in the long run, stop free agency. Only Charlie Finley of the A’s and Dick Meyers of the Cardinals voted in opposition of salary arbitration.

“We’ll be the nation’s biggest assholes if we do this,” Finley said at the time. “You can’t win. You’ll have guys with no baseball background setting salaries. You’ll have a system that drives up the average salary every year. Give them anything they want, but don’t give them [salary] arbitration.”

Meyers, who had experience in arbitration, said it more darkly, “This will be baseball’s ruin.” 1

In this new system, players with over 2 years of major league system could file for salary arbitration, if they were not under long-term contract. If the sides could not come to a contract agreement within a period of time, the club would submit a salary figure for the coming season that they felt the player was worth, while the player would do like wise. If the sides could not reach agreement with the figures submitted, the parties could go before arbitors from the National Labor Relations Board and present their case. The arbitors would then rule on one figure or the other. There would be no middle ground.

The system remains much the same, with a panel of three arbitrators ruling on salary cases.

How the Sides Have Fared

As was often the case, Charlie Finley was right. It was not the doom that Meyers predicted, but players almost exclusively come out ahead.

To date, of the 485 cases that have gone to arbitration hearing, the owners have won 280, while the players have won 208. But, the owners haven’t truly won. Of the 110 players that filed for salary arbitration last season, their average salary increased 120 percent from $1.38 million to $3.04 million. Ryan Howard saw his pay jump 1,011 percent from the year prior when he won his case before the arbitration panel going from $900,000 to $10 million.

Understandably, players and their clubs work to reach agreements in advance of hearings. This year (as it has often been in the past) the deals reached have mostly been 1-year agreements with the base salary for the player being below the mid-point between the club offering and player asking figure (to date, only John Maine’s contract is exactly between the Mets’ offering salary and his asking figure while Justin Duchscherer sees a salary $100,000 higher than the mid-point between the A’s and his figures). Still, with 46 players exchanging figures, 13 contracts that have been reached by players and clubs after salary figures were exchanged (Nick Markakis, Zack Greinke, Maicer Izturis, Jason Kubel, Melkey Cabrera, Justin Duchscherer, Geoff Geary, Wandy Rodriguez, Prince Fielder, Chad Durbin, Jayson Werth, John Maine, and Brian Bruney) sees average salary increase from 2008 to 2009 is 257 percent. In total (single year, and multi-year contracts) these 13 alone account for $151,910,000 in salaries.

As the stakes have grown ever higher, the number of cases that have gone all the way to hearing have dropped. In 1973, the first year of salary arbitration in MLB, 29 cases were heard with the owners winning 16 cases, and players winning 13. Since then, the highwater mark has been 1986 when 35 cases were heard (owners won 20 cases to the players 15). As recently as 2005, only 3 cases were heard (all pitchers): Kyle Lohse and the Twins, Jeremy Affeldt and the Royals, Juan Cruz and the Athletics.

A Peek Inside How Salary Hearings Function

The criteria by which salary arbitration cases are presented are part of the CBA, although from talking to a baseball man that has made a living a salary arbitration for nearly every club, while it is outlined in the CBA, most anything is permissible at hearing, it’s just that what is presented can be easily challenged and undermine your case, should the information presented fall far outside the CBA’s criteria.

Player Comparison – The sides are allowed to use other players with like ML service time as a comparison to make their case. The CBA expresses this as “Major League service not exceeding one annual service group above the Player’s annual service group.”

Player Comparison (Look Backs) – While using a player with more ML service time as a comparison in terms of 2009 salary to 2009 salary, the sides can do a “look back”. So, for example, using Albert Pujols’ numbers and salary for 2009 would not be acceptable in Ryan Howard’s case, but using Pujols’ figures when he had the same ML service time that Howard now has is permissible.

Contract Comparison – In nearly every instance, one-year contracts are used in hearing. Multi-year contracts are not used as they have different structures – frontloaded, backloaded, etc. So, using a 2009 salary figure in a mult-year contract creates issues as the single year salary could be influenced by the overall contract structure.

Position Comparison – For practicality purposes, comparing players at like positions are used. Clearly, attempting to compare a middle infielder to a catcher would not hold much weight with the panel. However, instances of comparing corner outfielders has been used.

Does Advanced Sabermetrics Come Into Play? – As Finley crudely noted, the arbitration panels are not “baseball people”. Therefore, advanced metrics are normally not employed in the hearing process. OBP, OPS, and even OPS+ are making their way into cases being presented, but for the most part, the stats that have filled the boxscores for years are the bread and butter in salary cases.

Intangibles – Clearly, the player’s performance on the field is the largest factor in determining whether the club or player figure is selected in a salary arbitration hearing, but it is not the only one, special qualities of leadership and “public appeal” can be used. A good example is last year when Ryan Howard's team was able to use a "special accomplishments" provision that allowed them to compare players outside of Howard's service time window. This, however, is rarely done. The exception appears to be pitchers, where agents have been able to make a case that on the day their player pitched, attendance and television ratings were higher. The most notable case was when Dick Moss represented Fernando Valenzuela citing “Fernandomania”.

Injuries – The sides can use injuries (or the lack of them) at hearing. A player that has been on the DL more often than a comparative player can be used by management to make their case for the lower offering figure by a club.

What is Not Admissible in Hearing? – The following outlines what is not allowed at salary arbitration hearing, as defined by the current CBA:

(i) The financial position of the Player and the Club;

(ii) Press comments, testimonials or similar material bearing on the performance of either the Player or the Club, except that recognized annual Player awards for playing excellence shall not be excluded;

(iii) Offers made by either Player or Club prior to arbitration;

(iv) The cost to the parties of their representatives, attorneys, etc.;

(v) Salaries in other sports or occupations.

Salary Arbitration and How it Influences MLB

As mentioned at the outset, salary arbitration almost exclusively benefits the players. Contract agreements have been reached outside the door of the hearing room just before a case is going to be presented to the arbitration panel. Hundreds of millions of dollars will be doled out to these players, with nearly all of them seeing massive pay increases. As one team executive said when asked what he liked about salary arbitration, “What’s there to like about it?” Ask the players.

1 – Finley and Meyer quotes from Lords of the Realm by John Helyar

UPDATED SALARY ARBITRATION NEWS

As of publication today, two more salary arbitration eligible players reached deals with their clubs.

Starting pitcher John Maine reached a 1-year, $2.6 million deal with the New York Mets. The right-hander can earn an additional $25,000 if he pitches 200 or more innings. Maine pulled in $450,000 last season so his raise from 2008 to his 2009 figure as a first year salary arbitration eligible player is 478 percent. He had been seeking $3 million while the Mets were offering $2.2 million in salary arbitration. His $2.6 million salary for 2009 is at exactly the mid-point between the two figures.

Reliever Brian Bruney and the New York Yankees reached a 1-year, $1.25 million agreement today, thus avoiding arbitration. Bruney had been seeking $1.55 million while the Yankees were offering $1.1 million. His $1.25 million for 2009 is $75,000 below the mid-point for the two figures. This is Bruney’s first year of salary arbitration eligibility. Last season he made $725,000. His raise to $1.25 million is a 72 percent increase from last season.

FOR MORE ON SALARY ARBITRATION:

Salary Arbitration Filings Tracker

Salary Arbitration Figures Tracker

Arbitration Scorecard


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Subscribe to The Biz of Baseball

Add to GoogleAdd to My Yahoo!

Subscribe in Bloglines


 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?