smart credit cards chips ge ultra diamonds credit card sony credit card mbna google tv top credit card affiliate programs standard chartered credit card offers on movie tickets orchard credit card credit card offers most cash back retail credit cards credit card compliance act 2009 credit card definition balance transfer chase credit card phone customer service care credit cards payment how to accept credit cards for your home business can i get a credit card with a bad credit rating bank of america new credit card activation chase business credit card rewards uk credit cards with 0 interest on balance transfers zero interest credit cards for beginners visa credit card offers low apr money best prestige credit cards how long for credit card refund to post credit card section 75 claim hdfc credit cards my rewards bank of america small business credit card application status no credit credit cards uk tribute credit card customer service number how many americans are in credit card debt today can pay walmart credit card bill store credit card with the best rewards no annual fee airline credit cards without annual fees cash back business credit card offers natwest student credit card contact know all about credit cards tesco credit card points value apply cimb petronas credit card how do i get a pin number for my bank of america credit card do i need a merchant account to accept credit cards united airlines mileage plus credit card benefits chase visa credit card southwest centon 32gb datastick credit card usb flash drive credit card processing iphone canada redeem your facebook credits gift card m&i credit card payment mailing address instant approval credit cards for no credit history best alaska airlines credit card deal credit card from post office sears mastercard credit cards capital one credit card pay online bill can i pay mortgage with credit card credit card swiper for kindle fire statistics college students debt credit cards how to change your credit card info on steam credit card cash back offer india jcpenney credit card account access typical credit card minimum payment hsbc credit cards online bill payment pay visa credit card gift card best buy credit card log in credit cards earn alaska air miles good credit cards high school students having difficulty paying credit card hdfc customer care credit card mumbai aspire visa credit card application travel rewards credit card offers the best cash back credit card citi american airlines credit card 75000 miles can make hsbc credit card payment online pay my goodys credit card online delta gold credit card review valid security credit card number credit one bank - sign in to access your credit card account.url much will paying down credit cards raise your credit score transfer credit card debt student loan best high risk credit cards online credit card processing cost icici bank credit card apply best corporate credit card for small business american express credit card reviews american express credit card application phone number credit cards with bad credit score credit card best rewards travel how do i get my free credit report without a credit card no foreign transaction fee credit card credit card 3 digit code back victoria secret credit card number customer service credit cards with low apr and interest rates wireless credit card processing machines credit card reform act 2010 text alaska airlines rewards credit card credit card id number mastercard do department store credit cards help your credit score first citizens bank credit card login credit card gas pump skimmers credit cards airline miles bonus pay hsbc credit card bill online citibank chevron credit card payment cherry credits card code generator icici bank credit card apply form lloyds air miles credit card review iberiabank credit card online jp chase corporate credit card natwest credit cards online banking best zero rate credit cards southwest airline credit cards reviews best business credit cards for small business uk how much is a credit card processing fee credit card usage for good credit score can i use my credit card to get a cashiers check lowest rate credit card usa credit card terminal app for iphone uk a credit card number that works best unsecured credit cards to build credit if i dont pay my credit cards what will happen no annual fees credit card india dillard credit card capital one cashback credit card review accepting credit card information online prepaid credit card paypal account bank journey student rewards credit card capital one amazon visa card credit limit hack credit card & cvv# for free city bank credit card application form halifax online credit card services credit card repayment cover claim google checkout sandbox valid credit card von maur credit card payment chart get good credit card offers credit card machine paper roll wholesale jet 2 credit card charges card log in bad credit first premier bank calculate credit card payoff which credit cards are not issued by mbna best ways to pay off credit card debt the credit card information you entered was invalid. please try again how to get credit cards paid off quick best business reward credit cards 2011 credit card transaction date vs posting date american express secured credit card number get approved credit card student amnesty international credit card how can i improve my credit score if i can;t get a credit card capital one credit card customer services number do you need a us credit card for amazon chase credit card access my account credit card with 0 percent interest hilton hhonors credit card log in credit card reviews consumer reports 2010 credit card declined for no reason how to use paypal without linking credit card credit card for ipad lost my credit card bill apply credit card online instant approval ireland new york taxi credit card hdfc titanium credit card rewards points redemption store department credit cards hdfc credit card payment visa money transfer minimum credit score to get a credit card us airways dividend miles credit cards what is the best credit card for gas purchases redeem world points bank america credit card business credit cards poor personal credit charge off on credit card what does that mean sear credit card ing credit cards canada card only checks transunion free credit report cancel boa credit card ms word credit card authorization template credit card processing applications for iphone rei credit card $100 gift card credit card comparison site au best credit cards online decision quick response credit cards australia visa credit card rewards no annual fee credit card processing rate review why do i need a credit card for free kindle apps frys credit card approval best credit card terminal rates tesco bank personal finance servicing credit card online index lexus credit card key credit card lightbulb uk american credit card japanese psn choice credit card review hsbc credit card pay by phone number jc penney credit card customer service number credit cards zero interest 12 months credit card scores required for credit cards may 2009 credit card act abn amro credit card statement online harlem the room place credit card get your money back credit card company credit card companies use experian credit check can you pay your federal income tax with a credit card hsbc bank credit card application status india foreign credit card cash advance big lots credit card apply online chase visa credit card activation phone number best airtran credit card offer ashley furniture credit card payment wells fargo credit card terminal for iphone paypal intuit credit card swipe droid hdfc bank silver credit card reward points citibank credit card dining promotion 2012 singapore credit card comparison chart usa get credit card 500 credit score free reloadable credit cards aaa worldpoints credit card review is interest on business credit cards tax deductible balance transfer credit cards australia offer citi government credit card phone number best marriott rewards credit card offer halifax credit card application status ally bank credit card online office max credit card application officemax visa signature credit card cvv2# generator online apple store itouch credit card reader compound credit card interest formula disputing credit card charges visa credit card debt consolidation loan hsbc credit card activation sms plains commerce bank credit card application hsbc credit card pantip credit card limit increase without permission best credit card rewards 2 cash back red mango credit card no credit credit cards canada td credit cards comparison credit card numbers and cvv hack card consolidation credit debt loan unsecured how to pay bills with chase credit card can merchants charge credit card processing fee best canadian student credit card check orchard credit card application status sbi credit card apply form chase amazon business visa credit card apple square credit card swiper credit card organizer wallet women ways to build credit without credit cards ocbc titanium credit card rewards bank of america credit card features best chase credit card college student pbs frontline secret history of the credit card transcript no credit student credit cards phillips 66 conoco 76 credit card payment can you use american credit cards in europe what is a pre approved credit card shell gas station credit cards horizon credit card complaints against credit card company best credit card reward reviews standard chartered bank india credit card application status 0 transfer credit card no fee chase credit card payment calculator card credit raiffeisen documente necesare sears mastercard credit card login canada 1st credit card issued lic premium online payment through hdfc credit card calculate credit card payment payoff change credit card on ipad data plan accept credit cards by phone for free how to close out old credit card accounts lowes ge money bank credit card credit cards rewards vs cash back most accepted credit cards in australia my friedmans credit card pay hsbc bank credit card bills online any bank account new credit card incentives texaco chevron credit card payment online spirit airlines credit card promotion best rewards credit card 2011 no annual fee best business credit card airline miles 3 benefits of using a credit card heartland credit card 101 how do you cancel a credit card charge capital one credit card credit limit easiest department store credit card to get with bad credit hdfc platinum chip credit card paypal accept credit card phone buy 1 get 1 free citi cash rewards credit card merchant account credit card service singapore airlines letter of indemnity credit card download mbna virgin atlantic credit card uk best credit card apps for ipad best credit cards for college grads barclay platinum credit card online banking credit cards no credit guaranteed approval how many numbers in a credit card security code orchard bank secured credit card for bad credit national debt relief credit card united mileage club credit card credit cards people bankruptcy discharge best credit cards for low credit score united states credit card usage statistics goodys credit card payment center where can you get a prepaid credit card in canada free credit card reader for cell phone getting cash from a credit card bank of america credit cards and loans before 2007 company credit card agreement template credit building credit cards for college students fair credit credit cards get valid credit card numbers cvv best credit card foreign exchange grace period credit card definition credit and debit cards in india american airlines credit card promotion code pay bloomingdale credit card best low interest credit cards for students hsbc credit card customer care email india want apply barclays credit card best disney rewards credit card credit card encoder machine reward points credit cards hdfc bank merchant credit card fees refund citibank credit card customer care number lucknow name of 3 digit code on back of credit card reestablish credit card rci credit card points redemption discount credit card processing for non profits make your own credit card wallet what is the credit card machine called state farm bank credit card login best credit card balance transfers existing customers get credit card credit score 640 union national bank credit cards how do i find out how many credit cards i have open best buy credit cards hsbc horrible can you stop credit card transaction standard chartered bank manhattan credit card online payment formula to calculate credit card payoff how to pay hdfc credit card bill online southwest airlines credit card deal fair credit credit card offers continental finance matrix discover credit card free credit card swipe iphone valid credit card information 2011 ocbc credit card customer service hotline best credit card company to work for best credit card with high limit credit card debt reduction software buy facebook credits card lloyds advance credit card minimum payment milage credit cards lowes commercial credit card account department store cards for bad credit centennial credit card unsecured business credit cards with low interest rates buy a credit card machine instantly approved credit cards online samsclub credit card can you get a credit card if you;re under 18 asiana credit card juniper credit card barclay debit card credit card does work credit card number generator download free advantages disadvantages paying cash debit card credit card cheque instalments ge care credit card how to hack a rfid credit card for $8 how do i pay off my american eagle credit card what is the most popular credit card in usa credit cards low apr no credit hdfc credit card login online payment does military star card build credit wireless merchant credit card machine student credit card visa choice rewards visa credit card true credit card horror stories startup business credit cards bad credit master credit card number example get real credit card number credit cards miles american airlines credit card debts of deceased spouse davids bridal credit card hsbc payment best bank credit card apply salute credit card credit card promotion hong kong hotel best no fee credit cards credit card information storage laws where to send kohls credit card payment credit cards points best credit card offers credit score 640 sears credit card sign on page apply amex credit card uk do i need to use my credit card to how to build credit fast bank of america secured credit card customer service number get wawa credit card morgan stanley credit card customer services best business credit card with no annual fee wachovia rewards credit card review bank of america cash rewards platinum plus visa secured credit card do need pin number credit card usa capital one? no hassle cashsm rewards credit card online credit card payment apply us credit card without ssn frontline secret history of the credit card how to get a us credit card in canada reduce credit card debt law air canada aeroplan credit card from bank of america 0 small business credit card how much cash back can i get with my walmart credit card sapphire credit card chase householdbank credit card payment online how to calculate credit card payment with apr pay credit card through paypal names of major credit cards online poker accepts prepaid credit cards credit card research india bank of america credit card dispute process hdfc bank platinum credit card reward points nfcu credit card offer what is a security code on your credit card typically send my walmart credit card payment sears visa credit card phone number best credit card students canada payment address for jc penny credit cards how to become a credit card processing company quickbooks credit cards us bank credit card processing rates credit card rewards miles vs cash back how to get free netflix without credit card monopoly credit card game pay paypal credit card fee do i need credit card for itunes store hsbc premier credit card rewards program pay bowflex credit card online m and t bank credit card login does us bank offer a secured credit card does applying for a new credit card hurt your credit score union bank credit cards gap credit card payment online login safe enter credit card info android market hdfc platinum credit cards offers southwest credit card worth annual fee visa credit card charges uk capital one best credit cards free no credit card required dating sites credit card credit score needed do credit cards increase interest rates best credit cards balance transfer student no credit credit cards best o purchase credit cards will walmart credit card help build credit hsbc credit card business news new york secretary of state credit card authorization form best credit card for balance transfers 2010 do debit cards build credit best credit card photos credit card bad credit no deposit required credit card designs for capital one hdfc credit card online payment ifsc code buxton fan out credit card holder hdfc credit card cancellation letter sheraton credit card visa new york and company credit card services icici sapphire credit card review ent federal credit union credit card ways to pay chase credit card bill prepaid credit building credit cards gander credit card payment apply british airways chase credit card mile jc penny credit card login page aspen credit card payment address how hard is it to qualify for a best buy credit card avs credit card check view walmart credit card balance kirklands credit card log best merchant credit card processor do retail credit cards affect credit score stop chase sending me credit card applications credit card processing equipment rental credit cards help build up credit home improvement credit card 2010 financial consumer agency canada credit cards how to pay target credit card online can transfer balance one credit card another online credit card payment sbi bank does cost pay credit card paypal hbc credit card account login hsbc credit card offers hk accept credit cards on website paypal credit card accept cell phone carte blanche credit card wikipedia credit card expiration date end month credit card offer comparison calculator can you use credit card casinos hsbc credit card account online access paypal accept credit cards fees best ecommerce credit card processing credit cards for people with poor credit with no deposit business credit card advantages disadvantages us credit card emv chip exxon mobil credit card account line paypal plus credit card ge money bank apply business credit card without ssn hsbc online credit cards australia capital one credit card online banking canada citi shell credit card login credit card authorization agreement sample what are the fees for prepaid credit cards free powerpoint templates credit card default credit card debt michigan
Home Maury Brown Analysis: Fantasy Stats Case Appeal Heard

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 382 guests online

Atom RSS

Analysis: Fantasy Stats Case Appeal Heard PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 15 June 2007 07:02

The Biz of Baseball

The following is analysis from Maury Brown, a sports business analyst for the Business of Sports Network  

Yesterday, oral arguments in the appeal of CBC Marketing and Distribution v. MLB Advanced Media took place before three judges for the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in St. Louis. The landmark case revolves around CDM Fantasy Sports’ (who was then owned by CBC Marketing) use of player statistics without a license from MLB Advanced Media. MLBAM and the MLBPA reached a $50 million agreement which, “provides MLBAM the exclusive rights to use, and to sublicense to others, Major League baseball player group rights for the development and creation of on-line games, all other online content, including fantasy baseball and interactive games, as well as all wireless applications including cell-phone enabled games.”

CBC sued MLBAM and the MLBPA arguing that they should be able to conduct the business of fantasy baseball games for-profit without a license and use player names and their associated statistics.

A judgment in US District Court in 2006 agreed.

Attorneys representing the MLB Players Association (MLBPA) and MLB Advanced Media (MLBAM) are urging the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to reverse the lower court judgment from US District Court Judge Mary Ann Medler from August of last year (see the opinion handed down by the court as well as the conclusion here on The Biz of Sports).

The appellant brief filed by the MLBPA and MLBAM reads in part (read the entire brief, along with its associated addendum here):

CBC’s conduct violates Missouri’s publicity rights law, and enforcement of those rights does not affect expressive activity or violate the First Amendment. At the very least, disputed issues of material fact precluded summary judgment for CBC. Alternatively, no federal statute addresses publicity rights and thus federal law does not preempt enforcement of CBC’s state-law contract obligations.

(To listen to the court proceedings, as well as read a partial transcript, select Read More)

Virginia Seitz, representing the MLBPA in oral arguments (listen to the oral arguments from yesterday here), urged the court to reverse the ruling based on right of publicity, stating that while statistics themselves could be used, once an MLB player is associated to those statistics, it breaks with the right of publicity and therefore is not protected by the First Amendment as outlined in the lower court’s judgment.

The judges seemed to be skeptical of that argument when addressing counsel for the MLBPA.

In a sharp exchange between Chief Judge James Luken and Seitz, Judge Luken said:

“So, now we have a limitation (referring to the use of associating a player to their statistics), and now I come around to, ‘This isn’t about statistics’ -- the basic war of the brief .

‘This is about names,' you say. ‘This is about statistics,’ they say.

And I understand the practicality of the war because the statistics are in the public domain.  And it seems to me, it’s clearly a use of public information to figure out that if you’re going to have an ongoing fantasy sports league over the life of a real professional sports league – clearly a collateral market – you have to have an opening set of statistics and evolving statistics that will allow competition and trades and so forth.

And so where do you get those statistics?

Well you can’t take the 1923 Philadelphia Athletics because that doesn’t evolve over a season. So you take these statistics that are in the public domain.

And as I translate the argument in this case.... ‘Well, we won’t argue with that (referring to the use of statistics without player association), but don’t you dare put a name next to those statistics.’

Well, of course that’s ridiculous.

So you are saying that this collateral market can be monopolized by your clients. The statistics – the public statistics – cannot be marshaled and be used for another kind of game without your clients getting a share of the action.”

Seitz then replied:

“Those statistics can appear in newspapers. Those statistics can be published on websites. But what cannot be done is have a player identity – a name – be used as a game piece for identification.”

Judge Luken shot back:

“The only identification is identifying the statistics so that this group of evolving statistics for the second baseman can be followed.”

The name is only to identify the statistics. It’s not to steal the identity of the second baseman.”

Seitz responded:

“The only reason these game are valuable and marketable is precisely because these are major league baseball player names attached to those statistics. If you used ‘Player A’, ‘Player B’, no one would be interested in playing the game. The game is interesting precisely because people feel they are owning and managing real major league players.

In summarizing his points later, Judge Luken said, “Since this is completely tangential to Major League Baseball, and the success of Major League Baseball, I don’t understand where that success and that identity, gives the players – at least I’m having trouble seeing – how it gives the players the right to monopolize an entirely separate entertainment industry.”

Rudy Telscher, lead counsel for CBC said during his 20 minutes that, “There’s not any affidavit from players who say they feel like they have been damaged,” referring to the fantasy baseball gaming industry. He then went on to say that the Phillies front office participated in playing fantasy baseball actively.

Telscher argued that fantasy baseball – in its various forms – have been played for years prior to the dispute between MLBAM and CBC.

“The only thing that my clients did was to create software to automate it.”

Reached for comment on Friday, Charlie Weigert, Vice-President of CDM Marketing said that there was extra pressure knowing that if the case remains in CDM's favor that it will create case law, and leave a lasting legacy.

As to how long he might be willing to pursue the case, Weigert stood behind his convictions.

"I’ll pursue the case as far as it goes," Weigert said. "Hopefully this decision will produce a final opinion and the decision will be as strong as the lower court decision, so if they try to appeal this higher, they are rejected."

A ruling on the appeal is expected from the three-judge panel in three to six months. 

Maury Brown is the founder and president of The Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball and The Biz of Football (full launch coming in July). He is a contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and can be contacted here. 

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?