buy lexapro colombia lasix 120 mg iv buy viagra poland 37 mg zoloft generic cialis houston mylan generic wellbutrin generic nexium mexico generic viagra sub diflucan dosage 200 mg 6generic levitra cheap viagra buy edmonton lexapro 20mg zoloft 250 mg of phenergan phenergan 25 mg cmi doxycycline generic names buy cipro 2250 mg metformin doxycycline 100mg 3142 viagra suppositories buy nexium 20mg buy prednisone 10 mg uses propranolol online uk cialis online apotheke lexapro 20 mg headaches prednisone 1mg clomid de 100 mg fungsi nexium 20 mg buy viagra caverta viagra online sites doxycycline online buy original lexapro cialis cheap taking 2 500mg metformin 3mg cialis cialis 20mg reviews synthroid dosage .05 mg lisinopril 10 mg eon erythromycin ethylsuccinate 800 mg doxycycline buying online cialis commercial online sales cheap viagra nexium canada buy cialis tadalafil 100 mg nebenwirkungen lisinopril 10 mg nolvadex 10 mg dejstvo cheap kamagra 50mg cipro 500 mg online nexium 20 mg capsule dogs prednisone 60 mg cialis 100 mg overnight viagra buy singapore cytotec misoprostol online buying clomid nolvadex health online viagra generic india levitra cialis 10mg 48 zovirax 50 mg creme kamagra 100mg women online zovirax sale viagra generic cheap prednisone 20mg pregnant doxycycline 100 mg palu 100mg viagra dosage prednisone 10 mg espanol nexium 20mg tabletten order some viagra boots buy viagra clomid pcos 50mg diflucan da 100 mg nexium mups 10mg paris buy viagra 100mg strattera diflucan mgs cialis de 0,5 mg generic viagra uae dubai buy viagra buy overseas viagra 100 viagra 100mg cheap levitra 10mg works buy viagra georgia generico do cialis levitra 10mg price cialis 50mg india 10mg levitra reviews cheap real viagra 2 mg cialis xenical 120mg reviews lisinopril tabs 40mg propecia online kupovina buy buspar online 2.5 cialis cheap nexium capsules 40 mg cialis 5 mg works cheapest online cipro cialis 2,5mg paypal nexium 40mg tablets allergic generic wellbutrin glucophage generico cheap blue kamagra cialis 20mg spanje cialis 2mg propranolol 40mg lch viagra generic medications cialis 5mg deals wellbutrin generic effective levitra 10 mg fiyatlari doxycycline 20mg tab lexapro 5mg alcohol ubat clomid 50mg generic cialis overnigh xenical 125mg medicamento levitra 5 mg clomid 100 mg statistics metformin 500 mg identification cialis online prescriptions blue lisinopril generic viagra buy ireland nolvadex uk buy generico de bactrim cipro xr 750mg strattera hoeveel mg buy viagra spain cipro 5oo mg cialis tadalafila 20mg tablet metformin 850 mg female dapoxetine 30mg purchase Levitra 20 mg nolvadex o generico cialis generic equivalent viagra mg sizes synthroid .5mg clomid online nz strattera 10 mg generic generic for glucophage 10 100 mg clomid pills clomid cheap 100 prospecto viagra 25 mg generics24 cialis zoloft online consultation active viagra cheap ordering doxycycline antibiotics order cialis 5 mg cialis 20mg marseille lexapro buy generic cialis manipulado 10 mg cheap 5m cialis acquisto cialis 20 mg 2.5 mgs lexapro cost lexapro 20 mg 10 mg ml tetracycline buy priligy paypal prednisone 60 mg 5 days cialis 5 or 10mg propecia cena 1mg buy cipro france dog cipro online generic propecia 2013 buy doxycycline generic 10 mg prednisone high doxycycline 100mg skin prednisone 500 mg uses wellbutrin xl 150 mg cipro 500mg treats werking cialis 20mg online cialis genuine buying cialis forums viagra online ontario clomid 100mg round 2 buy metformin usa 20mg of lexapro cheap viagra 150 mgs buy wellbutrin sr lexapro generic whirte cialis medistar. 25mg. viagra online leagle levitra 120 pills online take 2 20 mg levitra cialis 20mg opinie generic zithromax 500mg ubat metformin 500 mg tadafil cialis 50mg generic valtrex cheap viagra online cz order lexapro uk 10mg lexapro elderly price levitra 20 mg 100mg clomid ovulation celebrex 200 mg francais viagra c5 generic thuoc augmentin 875 mg cialis liquid buy prednisone 5mg 5ml priligy 30mg doxycycline 100 mg bijwerkingen generic levitra otc zovirax 200mg dose viagra online tesco valtrex 500mg preis viagra 10mg online cialis order online comprar cialis online viagra online stockists dapoxetine 20 mg cialis 20mg doseage cialis 20 mg buy cialis 100mg. online buy 150mg viagra everyday generic cialis buy celebrex overnight celebrex 200 mg anwendungsgebiete viagra online 25 mg conditionnement cialis 10mg clomid 50mg 2012 lisinopril online canadian viagra 30 pills 100 mg glucophage hcl 500mg generic levitra effective zoloft sertraline 50 mg 120mg viagra cialis dosage mg buy viagra shipping viagra 25mg polska propecia .5mg 2013 teva prednisone 50 mg generico de cipro clomid 300 mg la viagra generica wellbutrin generic budeprion lisinopril 20 mg prescription acheter levitra 20 mg mylan nolvadex buy prednisone 5mg constipation amoxil 500 mg posologie kamagra viagra 100mg buy nolvadex 2013 bulk cheap viagra clomid 50mg days canadian generic viagra viagra anavar online zithromax sirop300mg wellbutrin 300 mg tablets locate generic cialis 150 mg zoloft pregnant viagra generico 25 50mg clomid pcos buy viagra newcastle gebruiksaanwijzing viagra 100mg viagra stood online diflucan 100 mg cost metformin backorder priligy 60 mg fiyati viagra wholesale buy cost cialis 5 mg generico di zovirax celebrex 5 mg valtrex generic walmart incredibly cheap viagra order wellbutrin sr lisinopril 20mg price took levitra 10mg viagra 100 mg 100 pills lexapro 5mg week 3 celebrex 250 mg dosage buying brand viagra synthroid generic cost nexium 40mg yanetkileri generic lexapro order buying cialis overseas prednisone 5mg sales nexium 20 mg dosierung celebrex 100mg wiki zithromax 500mg preis valtrex mgs precio viagra 100mg nexium 40mg indicacoes nexium coupons online viagra condoms online 50 mg prednisone asthma cialis prise 200mg buy legit viagra propecia online recommendations online cialis forum propranolol inderal 40mg metformin 500 mg uses zithromax 1200 mg daily valtrex online prednisone 20 mg walmart fast online viagra viagra 150 mg prices lexapro generico confiavel cialis 20mg 12 st buy viagra 25 mg viagra very cheap viagra 100mg box strattera 100mg costo 10 mg prednisone dogs cheap viagra generica buy synthroid generic viagra strips 25 mg viagra generic .net zovirax 200 mg cena generic cialis trial nexium mups 40 mgs cialis tablets buy cheapest cialis super lisinopril 40 mg espanol lexapro 10 mg directions kuwait buying viagra glucophage 500 mg tabletas diflucan cpr 100 mg 50 mg viagra instructions 5mg lexapro affair generic valtrex 2011 clomid 3000mg order diflucan overnight online viagra free cialis online paysafe erythromycin goi 250mg online cialis soft buy kamagra 50 to buy cialis valtrex 800 mg authentic generic cialis generic viagra yet controindicazioni cialis generico bijsluiter glucophage 850 mg buy strattera 100 mg fungsi augmentin 625mg cialis online walgreens kamagra 100mg online medicament zoloft 50mg zovirax 800 mg uk metformin atid 850 mg diflucan 150 mg prospect buy cialis cyprus metformin 500 mg sandoz buy viagra philippines generico viagra funziona canadian dapoxetine online metformin 800mg viagra 0.25 mg forum golden viagra 3800 mg nexium 20 mg cp medicamento propranolol 40 mg cheap lisinopril 40 mg propecia 4mg cialis 20 mg work augmentin suspension 125 mg wellbutrin 200 mg cytotec 200mg online celebrex tablets 100mg generic online viagra generic zithromax 1g pastilla nexium 40 mg nexium pills online nexium generic 2011 generic viagra usps comprare propecia online metformin 500 mg works buy bactrim pharmacy levitra 20 mg posologie viagra 50mg pills drug lasix 40 mg lisinopril 20 mg 12.5 mg valtrex online cheap prednisone 120 mg order cheap kamagra clomid online prescriptions propranolol to buy generic levitra problems generic cialis 40 cheap levitra 5 mg cost generic lexapro appetite augmentin 1000 mg etkisi cialis 20 mg nasil best online propecia super kamagra 160mg zoloft 5 omg buy 2.5 mg cialis cialis 5 mg recensioni cialis 20 mg faq lexapro 20 mg 90 day obat zithromax 500 mg cytotec de 500 mg viagra 50 mg packungsbeilage cialis black mg glucophage xp 750mg online recept viagra celebrex 400mg dosage durata cialis 20 mg glucophage online prescription cialis 100mg30 tablets viagra 100mg cut buy viagra montreal levitra uk cheap doxycycline my 100mg viagra 50 mg efectos buy propecia pills posologie clomid 100 mg cheap pill viagra generic tetracycline 500mg cialis 200mg review Cialis 10mg 20 Tabs strattera 40 mg adults posologia cialis 10 mg prednisone 20mg mylan kamagra 100mg wikipedia cialis onlinepaypal cheapest cialis edrugstore buy metformin 1000mg levitra forum 10 mg kjope viagra online cialis sublingual buy generic viagra calgary cialis buy coventry generic levitra manufacture administrare augmentin 500mg cialis 36 hour generic lisinopril tablet 5mg 100mg clomid zwanger lisinopril cost 10mg viagra online discreet usa 800 mg viagra overnight cheap levitra cialis 5mg sales 800mg generic cialis dapoxetine online pharmacy buy levitra sale zoloft 75 mg daily cheapest dapoxetine levitra 2.5mg online online amsterdam viagra diflucan compresse 50 mg wirkung levitra 20mg vademecum cialis 5 mg coupons viagra online cialis cheap cost lisinopril 40 mg tabs zithromax buy atl packungsbeilage cialis 20mg costo levitra 5 mg prezzo zoloft 50 mg generico para nexium nexium tablets 20mg confezione cialis 20 mg tetracycline 50 mg nexium 75mg generic cialis 2,5 nexium liver disorders lexapro generic safe levitra 20mg pricing strattera 40 mg sleepy lexapro prescription online cialis 800mg overdose buy viagra indonesia viagra 100mg results generic lexapro name order cialis singapore viagra cream buy cheap nexium tablets generic viagra mylan cialis online sydney super viagra generic nolvadex pct buy buy viagra lebanon zithromax for cheap 100mg zoloft review mexican viagra online viagra generic sample doxycycline hyclate 80mgs prednisone 20 mg pak nexium 40 mg n3 kamagra gel 20 mg propranolol 40 mg grossesse clomid ohss 50mg buy cialis cina zovirax 400 mg cena cialis online Washington order propecia cod levitra vademecum 10 mg cheap nexium 40 mg cheap sale viagra nexium become generic cialis jelly 20 mg 30 mg levitra safe viagra strengths mg generic lexapro recreational generic lisinopril identification valor nexium 40 mg order viagra cvs buy zovirax budapest cheapest zovirax online lexapro generic timing zithromax oral online lexapro generic when amoxil suspension buy viagra generic british levitra 10 mg forum 5mg propecia viagra buy oonline
Home All Articles RULE IV DRAFT -- What is the Future of MLB Player Development?

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 773 guests online

Atom RSS

RULE IV DRAFT -- What is the Future of MLB Player Development? PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 46
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Pete Toms   
Sunday, 16 November 2008 22:22

A Biz of Baseball OriginalMLB implemented changes to the Rule IV draft in the most recent round of CBA negotiations, with the intent that the changes would result in a lowering of signing bonuses doled out to drafted amateurs. Two drafts have since been conducted and the changes have not lowered signing bonuses, leading to speculation that MLB will attempt to negotiate mandated slotting of draft picks in the next CBA. (The CBA expires in December, 2011). Paradoxically, while dissatisfied with the inflationary impact the Rule IV draft has had on acquiring labor in North America, it appears MLB will attempt to expand the draft to Latin America, and beyond in an attempt to control the spiraling costs of signing amateur players not subject to the draft.

The concept of a worldwide draft was first proposed as part of the 2002 CBA, but negotiations between management and the MLBPA withered on the vine.

The current CBA – which took effect in December 2006 – included an earlier signing deadline of August 15 for players chosen in the Rule IV / aka June draft. Combined with another change that awards compensation in the following year’s draft for teams failing to sign their pick, management was to be better positioned in negotiations with drafted amateurs. In addition, prior to the 2007 draft, Commissioner Selig exerted pressure on clubs to adhere to recommended "draft slot" bonuses that were set 10% lower than the previous year. Some clubs complied, but the overall impact of the rule changes and “slot recommendations” was negligible.

Baseball America reported, "There were 184 picks in the first five rounds in 2007, and 171 of them signed, receiving an average bonus of $685,328. Last year, 179 of the first 184 picks agreed to terms, getting an average bonus of $662,531. So despite the 10 percent reduction in slots, the bonuses rose 3 percent.” Sports Business Journal reported, "Overall average signing bonuses for 2007 first-round draft picks hit their highest mark in five years, at nearly $2.1 million…"

Commissioner Selig relaxed his efforts to control spending in the 08 draft and an increased amount of dollars were awarded to drafted players. In August, Forbes reporter Tom Van Riper wrote, “The league made a concerted effort to change things this year, encouraging small-market teams picking near the top to draft the best talent and pay out expensive bonuses.” In October, Baseball America reported, “Teams combined to spend $186.5 million on draft bonuses in 2008, an amount believed to be a record and up 23 percent from the $151.8 million they shelled out in 2007.”

The past two drafts have seen a trend of small and mid market franchises outspending many larger market franchises. The Rays and Nationals ranked #2 and #5 in dollars spent on signing bonuses in the 07 draft with the Royals and Rangers also in the top 10. The 08 draft saw an increase in this behaviour with the Royals, Rays and Pirates all in the top 4 along with the Giants, Brewers, Rangers, Twins and Indians all in the top 10. The shift amongst small and mid market teams to compete more aggressively in the Rule IV draft is perhaps a reaction to the diminishing number of quality free agents available in recent years. According to Maury Brown, “...clubs are wrapping up contracts more often now – signing players to extensions, which in turn lowers the number of players in the free agency pool.....” And, “What has happened over the years is a case of viewing free agency as an inefficient avenue in which to build contenders." Increasing investments in the Rule IV draft might also be attributed to the better results that clubs are garnering in the draft, perhaps due to the increased emphasis on “objective analysis” in evaluating amateur talent. In June of this year, Rob Neyer wrote on his ESPN blog;

Anyway, it seems to me that teams are doing a lot better in the draft than they used to.....In the 1970s, an entire first round might produce four or five good major leaguers. Probably an average of six or seven per draft (first round only).

In 2002, the first round produced B.J. Upton, Zack Greinke, Prince Fielder, Jeff Francis, Jeremy Hermida, Joe Saunders, Khalil Greene, Scott Kazmir, Nick Swisher, Cole Hamels, James Loney, Jeremy Guthrie, Jeff Francoeur, Joe Blanton and Matt Cain. That's 15 guys who already have done good things in the majors. I suppose two or three of them will fall by the wayside soon, but they might be replaced by first-rounders who haven't made it yet.

In 2003, the first round produced Delmon Young, Rickie Weeks, Nick Markakis, John Danks, Lastings Milledge, Aaron Hill, David Murphy, Conor Jackson, Chad Cordero, Chad Billingsley, Eric Duncan and Carlos Quentin. That's 12 guys, and does not include Ian Stewart, Michael Aubrey, Brandon Wood or Daric Barton, all of whom are highly regarded young hitters.

What does it mean?...I think it also means teams have become more systematic -- and thus more effective -- in their evaluation of amateur players. ...

Some observers believe that allowing the trading of draft picks would be beneficial to clubs, contributing to more competitive balance by providing clubs more flexibility in maximizing the value of their pick(s). Keith Law of ESPN wrote prior to this years’ Rule IV draft, “Small-market or just plain cheap teams selecting near the top of the draft are hostages of their situations. If the best player on the board wants a bonus well above slot for that teams' position, and they are unwilling or unable to pay, they must select the best player on the board whom they can afford, but in the process they have no way to recover the value they lost from having to bypass the best player. Allowing these teams to trade picks would mean that, for example, the Pirates, picking fourth last year, could have received value in excess of what they actually got (selecting Daniel Moskos, who wasn't one of the 10 best players in the draft) by trading their pick to a team that coveted Rick Porcello or Matt Wieters, two high-slot players still available for the Pirates' pick.”

At the same time MLB is spending record amounts of money on drafted players it is spending record amounts of money on free agent amateur players in Latin America, principally in the Dominican Republic. In a Baseball America piece, Ben Badler quoted an unnamed scouting director, “I didn't think that I would say this three years ago, but Latin America is becoming more expensive than the draft." Five of the Top 10 International Signing Bonuses, including the top 3, were awarded in 2008. The A’s awarded Dominican Michel Inoa a $4.25 million signing bonus. Prior to 2008 the previous high was $2.44 million. In September, ESPN published figures provided by MLB claiming that “..the average signing bonus given to prospects in the Dominican Republic has more than tripled.” MLB claims the average signing bonus has ballooned to approximately $108,000 in 08, up from an average of approximately $29,000 in 04. An unnamed AL executive was quoted in Baseball America in July, “We're going to crash and burn because these numbers are ridiculous. Ultimately something needs to change."

Both Commissioner Selig and MLB President and COO Bob DuPuy have been very public this season in their support for expanding the draft to Latin American countries. During an All Star Game Q&A with baseball media, Selig was quoted, “I don't think it's any secret that support for a worldwide draft is growing amongst all baseball people," Selig said. "I've had a lot of people, including a significant number of general managers, say to me in the last couple of months that they wish we had a worldwide draft. I think that's something we will discuss in the future." DuPuy was quoted in an ESPN article published in September, "There's almost total unanimity from the clubs' standpoint that a worldwide draft would be a good thing."

MLB’s public desire to implement an amateur draft in Latin America has been accompanied by a season’s worth of reports in high profile baseball publications – USA Today, ESPN, Baseball America – detailing abuses suffered by young Latin baseball players, particularly in the Dominican Republic. The reporting is in reaction to investigations launched by both the FBI and MLB into “bonus skimming / kickback schemes” involving scouts employed by MLB clubs and local buscons/player agents. The White Sox, Yankees and Red Sox all dismissed employees in their international scouting operations this season over alleged improprieties. At the same time, much attention has been brought to steroid use amongst Dominican amateur players. USA Today reported that the Dominican Summer League, “....made up 15% of all players under contract to major league teams at the start of the season, yet they accounted for nearly 60% (40 of 68) of positive drug tests this year.” Again, the media reports affix much of the blame to the buscon culture. From Baseball America, “Dodgers scout Ralph Avila, who helped open the floodgates to Dominican talent when he established the first training academy there 22 years ago, fears things have gotten so out of hand that the only way to bring order would be to make Dominican players subject to the draft, an idea that has been discussed before.”

If the Rule IV draft is expanded to include Latin American countries, what impacts will it have on the baseball labor market? The introduction of the draft in 1965 is often linked to a corresponding decline in the percentage of big league players recruited from the US and the increase in big league players recruited from Latin America. A 2002 Emory University Law School analysis on the impacts of the draft “U.S. Labor Market Regulation and the Export of Employment: Major League Baseball Replaces U.S. Players with Foreigners”, concluded, “Our analysis of the market for professional baseball players shows that domestic labor-market restrictions have reduced domestic employment, especially of African-Americans, with employers instead shifting employment overseas. Our theoretical model suggests that, in 1965, the imposition of both the player draft and stricter age minimums for hiring U.S. players reduced the benefits of signing and developing U.S. players, especially players from disadvantaged groups such as African-Americans. Our empirical analysis, using a new data set, then shows that, in response, teams have shifted to developing and hiring players from other countries where the regulations do not apply, such as Latin America.” Jimmie Lee Solomon, MLB executive vice president for baseball operations, was quoted last year in a CNNMoney.com article. "Clubs do leverage their dollars much better if they develop a kid in a country not subject to the draft. Those decisions are purely business decisions, very pragmatic business decisions."

The discussion in the baseball media this season concerning expansion of the draft to Latin America has led to reflections on the affects of the introduction of the draft to Puerto Rico in 1989. Again from Baseball America;

It has happened before, in 1989, when baseball, in an effort to rein in bonuses, expanded its amateur draft to include Puerto Rico. Almost 20 years later, many in Puerto Rico blame that decision for the demise of baseball on the island, where the once-prestigious winter league wasn't even able to play last season.

"Between the baseball academies and the Dominican Summer League, we built la gallina de oro, the golden hen," Avila said. "Now it's a real mess. The market is crazy.

"A worldwide draft would kill la gallina de oro."

And from the aforementioned Emory University Law School analysis; “In the 1990s, Puerto Rico has been the one exception to the increasing number of Latin-born players in MLB, providing declining numbers of players.....The draft again explains this....Teams quickly cut back their scouting and development efforts in Puerto Rico....In less than a decade after 1989, the number of Puerto Rican players signed per year had dropped more than 40%.”

The competition to acquire talent in Latin countries has led to multi million dollar investments by MLB clubs in training facilities/baseball academies, again mostly in the Dominican Republic. The SportsBusiness Journal reported that the Padres recently opened their training academy, investing $8 million in the project. “This does quite a number of things for us,” said Padres Chief Executive Sandy Alderson. “There are not many foreign players on our roster, and it immediately makes us more competitive and visible in that space, and fully reflects the fast growing amount of international talent in our game. It will also enhance our brand up and down our organization and gives us a better opportunity to overcome some market advantages teams like the [New York] Mets have.” Will a draft in the Dominican Republic result in a decrease in these investments? From a 2002 Alan Schwarz piece in ESPN, “Warming to Idea of Global Draft”, “Some executives worry that should MLB fold such players into the draft, teams wouldn’t invest the millions of dollars they currently do on academies because there’s no sense in developing a player to get drafted by another club.”

Regardless of the real or proposed changes, no draft, inclusion of Latin America in the draft, earlier signing deadline, compensatory picks, trading of picks, mandatory slotting....the cost of developing players is a primary concern amongst all clubs. Across MLB, player development costs are in excess of $600 million per year. In March, Andrew Zimbalist wrote in SportsBusiness Journal;

In 2007, the average MLB team spent more than $20 million on its player development system. Of this, over $11.5 million went to pay the salaries of the minor league players.

Generally, each MLB team has six minor league affiliates. Teams also run fall and winter development camps and leagues. Together, an average of 6.2 percent of MLB revenue went toward these minor league salaries.

Also important to business of MLB player development is the impact that the signing of Japanese amateur Junichi Tazawa to a major league contract this off-season will have on future negotiations with Japanese baseball. From a recent MLB.com piece;

As far as MLB is concerned, there are no restrictions on signing Asian amateurs; those players are not included in the annual First-Year Player Draft. Instead, they are handled as free agents, just like youngsters from Latin American countries outside the U.S. commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

But Japanese baseball officials have long worried about losing amateurs to MLB and the ripple effect that might have on professional baseball in their country. Thus far, Kazuhito Tadano and Mac Suzuki are the only Japanese players to have played in the big leagues without playing Japanese pro baseball first.

To that end, Japanese officials have instituted a strict return policy on youngsters who opt to sign with MLB teams first: a three-year waiting period after they leave the U.S. for high school players and two years for college or industrial league players before they can join any of the 12 Nippon professional teams.

Should Tazawa perform well in ‘09 other Japanese amateurs could follow his example which would no doubt strain relations between MLB and Japanese baseball.

The Rule IV draft and escalating player development costs are an issue that all owners and Commissioner Selig will continue to monitor closely.


Pete Toms is a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He can be contacted at \n \n This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?