how do i redeem my amazon credit card points orchard bank credit card payment phone number barclays credit card application what is a good balance transfer credit card apply for a credit card santander mastercard credit card number hack bank of america credit card cashback bonus credit cards online instant decision what does pdq credit card machine stand for 21 month no interest credit card citibank no annual fee credit card india what credit card should i get apple credit card swipe device best travel reward credit card 2011 how do i check my amazon credit card points first time credit cards no credit history guaranteed cash loans now check my credit card score free how to get hdfc credit card statement online halifax credit card application bank credit card comparison malaysia pay advance america credit card apply sbi visa card online registration delta credit card promotion 2011 how to get a bad credit mortgage rbc royal bank credit card low rate balance transfer compare business credit cards canada can i get a credit card for my business if i have bad credit apply for a visa credit card with no credit history top credit cards for bad credit 2013 credit card instant decision canada credit card approval with no credit history low interest balance transfer credit cards australia best air miles credit card wells fargo credit card approval odds bad credit car leasing companies pay off credit card debt calculator is there a grace period for chase credit card payments chase credit card rewards quarter credit card for bad credit instant approval uk hsbc credit card apply for credit card get a credit card with bad credit with no annual fee barclays premier credit card login bad credit installment loans direct lender uk best credit card deal how to buy apps from google play store without credit card list of secured credit card issuers quick bad credit loans south africa payday loans cash advance no credit check how to reduce my credit card debt fast capital one credit cards banking auto loans checking wells fargo business credit card review top 10 credit card issuers uk american express gold card money saving expert westpac credit card rates australia new payday loan direct lender uk best credit card cashback deals prepaid credit cards freedom bad credit loans online canada best air miles credit card 2013 canada what happens to credit card debt when you die canada ipad credit card app australia visa credit cards applications list of all citibank credit cards online payday loans direct lender pay belk credit card payment online reward points hdfc credit card offers credit card low interest rates icici credit card settlement payday lenders online no credit check how do i redeem icici credit card reward points credit card report example visa credit card instant approval chase freedom credit card cash back categories sears canada credit card services check my visa gift card balance online cibc credit card lost or stolen compare student credit cards uk prepaid visa cards wiki nilson report credit card fraud applying for a credit card natwest chase virtual credit card getting a capital one credit card after bankruptcy best hotel rewards credit card 2013 chase freedom credit card for bad credit how to download free apps from app store without credit card anz platinum card travel insurance policy number best travel credit card usa credit card debt settlement canada visa debit cards work in europe wireless credit card machine hire capital one credit card for college students how much does a credit card machine cost key ring reward cards uk hsbc credit card no annual fee india top 5 credit cards in india pay dillards credit card payment online i need a bad credit loan not a payday loan i need to get a credit card to rebuild my credit new credit card fees law getting store credit cards after bankruptcy guaranteed credit card uk how do credit cards work bank of ireland visa debit card locked best credit cards in canada for travel sears hsbc mastercard credit card credit card debt on death visa credit card numbers that work 2011 credit card logos vector files calculate monthly credit card interest calculator credit card rate reduction letter i need a personal loan with bad credit forbes top credit cards 2013 paypal credit card processing canada anz cash back visa gold zero balance transfer credit cards no fee hdfc emi credit card calculator what does cashback on credit cards mean how to know sbi credit card status 3 month payday loans no brokers long term bad credit loans online how to get a bad credit loan fast best credit cards for bad credit canada capital one balance transfer card best secured credit card to build credit fast 2013 test credit card numbers with cvv2 0 apr credit card offers balance transfers difference between secured and unsecured credit cards credit card fraud bust in queens ny credit card verification code java lifehacker best credit card rewards payday advance no credit check no faxing belk credit card minimum payment best airline rewards credit card 2011 canada online credit card security can u get a credit card with bad credit how to apply for hsbc credit card online visa debit cards how do they work capital 1 credit card payment online when does discover credit card report to credit bureau am i liable for my company credit card no fax no credit check payday loans online secured business credit card canada how to get an american express platinum card starbucks platinum card sold out canada travel rewards credit card compare secured credit card to rebuild credit score best travel visa cards canada wells fargo visa platinum credit card rewards best secured credit cards to rebuild credit free online credit card payment processing best way to consolidate high interest credit cards best payday lenders bad credit business credit limit calculator buy instant virtual credit card how do cash advances on credit cards work real credit card numbers that work online 2013 credit card settlement letter example apply for uk credit cards online square credit card reader android uk capital one credit cards login what is credit card apr mean credit cards with fixed low interest rates wells fargo international credit card fees cibc student credit card limit types of td visa cards what us credit card has chip and pin instant virtual credit cards travel rewards credit cards comparison canada payday loans online direct lenders no credit checks go compare credit card balance transfers no fee american airlines credit card 90 day payday loans no credit check australia bank of america credit card travel miles bank of america prepaid credit card to build credit what credit card is best for me goodyear tire credit card sign in mastercard careers mba is there a halo reach credit limit paying off credit card debt vs saving reputable credit card debt settlement companies how to get hdfc new credit card standard chartered credit card application status with reference number best rewards cards app wells fargo secured credit card cash advance hsbc sears credit card customer service hdfc credit card charges for foreign currency transactions marriott premier credit card uk bank of america credit card activation phone number what are good interest rates for credit cards how to create apps store without credit card barclays credit card application online how credit card processing works wiki free gnc gold card best credit cards to have with fair credit chase pre approved credit cards joint credit card account chase secured credit card guaranteed approval canada college student mastercard credit cards average credit score us airways credit card points guy best payday loan online lenders update apple id credit card on ipad neiman marcus credit card payment phone sears master credit card login prepaid visa credit card canada best capital one business credit card canada best credit card points apply for credit limit increase capital one credit card terminal till rolls zero percent balance transfer credit cards 2012 department store credit cards usa types of orchard bank credit cards goodyear credit card promotion what credit card can i apply for without a job swiss air miles and more credit card cancel hsbc credit card insurance premium online apply for credit card hsbc bank credit card holder with money clip current limitation of online credit card payment system new small business credit cards with bad credit how long is a mastercard credit card number hbc credit card points apply for credit cards with no credit check sears orchard credit card login prepaid canadian credit cards payday loan lenders no credit check no brokers student visa credit card login fha mortgage loans with bad credit 2 cash back credit cards fidelity credit card interest free balance transfers credit card promotions november 2013 anz platinum credit card insurance axis bank credit card cash back offer cpp credit card protection review credit card machine for taxi visa card generator with security code best merchant cash advance companies low rate for life of balance credit cards how to get guaranteed credit card approval best cashback credit card calculator online prepaid credit card barclays platinum card benefits guaranteed instant approval credit cards travel rewards cards comparison canada credit one bank credit card agreement credit card application for bad credit with no application fee capital one secured credit card consumer reviews best credit card for living abroad virgin business credit card uk prepaid credit card canada reloadable bank of america business credit card login american airlines credit card points guy best credit card interest rates balance transfer white hills cash payday loans number visa credit cards numbers that work fake valid credit card numbers with security code stolen credit card numbers hacked visa credit card numbers 2013 does it hurt your credit to apply for several credit cards get online loan without bank account best place to get a student credit card low interest rate credit cards no annual fee pay monthly payday loans td canada trust cash back credit card pay bank of america credit card cash back visa cards canada low interest credit card balance transfer nz bad credit american express corporate cards mastercard black card uk change mastercard securecode citibank transfer credit card balance sears credit card application phone accept credit cards on iphone travel rewards credit cards australia credit cards with bad credit or no credit kotak credit card online payment applying for a credit card in canada with bad credit best rewards credit cards 2014 visa credit card number hack discover student credit card bad credit best credit cards for college students 2013 how to redeem hdfc world credit card reward points amazon credit card visa login chase reward cards bank of america corporate credit card standard chartered new credit card apply account services credit card rate reduction how to pay barclays credit card payment black cardigan uk credit card charges abroad nationwide top credit card processing companies in the us visa credit card number generator with cvv credit card apr calculator download credit cards for low income good credit apply for credit cards for bad credit business credit card offers balance transfer list of credit cards company in uk best rewards credit card no annual fee 2013 negotiating with credit card companies to reduce debt uk new fees for credit cards 2013 what is a cvv cvc in a credit card vanilla prepaid visa card canada balance starwood preferred guest credit card 30000 online credit card generator fast payday loans no credit check prepaid visa card euros tesco credit card login ireland ge money walmart credit card contact number top 10 credit cards to have buy virtual credit cards with paypal visa gift card online registration best rewards credit cards no annual fee iphone credit card processing paypal bridgestone firestone credit card guaranteed payday loans get a credit card with no credit history lord and taylor credit card services number bank of canada credit card debt ba master credit card trust icici instant credit card charges bank of america small business secured credit card how can a small business accept credit cards online apply for a visa credit card scotiabank top 20 payday lenders no brokers value city credit card payment is it bad to consolidate credit cards instant credit cards transfer balance credit cards australia martin lewis best credit card balance transfer do i need a credit card for paypal to receive money travel rewards cards for students us fast cash loans credit card payment calculator uk uob credit card rewards catalogue malaysia icici virtual credit card emi ebay credit card payment processing business credit card air miles compare credit cards online australia what is my american express credit limit virgin credit cards ppi claims what is the best credit card to have with bad credit who has the best credit card rate myer visa card review best interest free credit cards uk best reward points credit card 2013 best visa credit cards 2011 canada easiest unsecured credit card for bad credit best travel visa credit card canada cash rewards credit cards comparison how do you cancel a maurices credit card american express rewards cards compare free virtual credit card usa major bank secured credit cards top credit card deals 2012 where else can i use my lane bryant credit card best tips for paying off credit card debt aqua credit card payment protection best place to get credit card with no credit register canada post visa gift card credit card minimum payment calculator uk easy credit card application no requirements philippines hdfc credit card offers emi how to lower your credit card interest rate sbi credit card statement sample list of online stores that accept international credit cards free virtual credit card for paypal verification best first credit cards for young adults apply for lifetime free credit card best canadian credit cards 2013 hsbc credit card application online india credit card offers for bad credit instant approval ann taylor mastercard credit card login icici credit card international transaction fee citibank credit card approval code what is credit card issue number mastercard rbs credit card offers for existing customers credit cards with rewards bad credit credit card protection insurance australia best starwood credit card axis bank instant credit card review best gas credit card ontario icici credit card apply online in chennai apply for credit card online canada credit card offers $500 cash back southwest credit card free flight after first purchase free credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date credit card application has been referred walmart credit card cash advance limitations hsbc credit card application online singapore bpi credit card cash advance charges online credit card application philippines ofw applying for credit card with bad credit score apply for chase british airways credit card super balance transfer to current account should i accept credit card payments on ebay chase business credit card customer service starbucks credit card discount what credit score do i need for a best buy card secured visa credit card no annual fee apply for a new credit card with first premier bank costco credit card application union bank of india credit card application form visa credit card movie offers india discover credit card stolen phone number pay bank of america credit card with paypal should i consolidate my credit cards how many credits cards is too many pentagon credit card credit union texaco chevron gas credit card low or no interest credit cards icici credit card credit card no credit check canada hdfc credit card reward points redeem instant online loans uk falcon credit card fraud detection system citibank business credit card application sbi irctc credit card registration credit cards 0 interest for 12 months no balance transfer fee can i get cash from a walmart visa gift card citi credit card balance transfer to bank account credit cards for poor credit instant approval bank of america student credit card credit score best credit cards for online purchases list of online payday loan lenders no credit credit card application fnb online loan calculator online application for visa electron card how to consolidate credit card debt yourself chase credit cards no credit history payday loan bad credit lender only instant cash advance loans online best citibank credit card offer best buy credit card payment o2 prepaid credit card uk usaa credit card cash advance limit citi aadvantage credit card review bdo online application for credit cards apply student credit card online instant approval buy prepaid credit card paypal apply for chase credit card for students how can i sign up for a credit card with bad credit best credit card to get with bad credit hdfc credit cards reward points titanium capital one credit card 0 balance transfer barclays credit card ppi insurance prepaid gift credit cards with no fees best visa credit cards with rewards should i consolidate my credit card debt hdfc credit card online apply best credit card offer travel rewards credit cards canada 2012 malaysia credit card cash rebate comparison can applying for credit cards hurt my credit score credit card terminal for iphone australia manchester united credit card maybank anz credit card balance transfer 0 ge money bank credit card contact number watch credit card fraud for dummies best credit card points guy goodyear credit card login account mobile credit card processing iphone paypal pay hdfc credit card bill online neft mastercard careers sydney what credit card should i get for my first one tesco credit card payment methods paypal credit card finance charges credit card loans in singapore cash loans now moline free credit report canada no credit card post office credit card travel money horizon credit card number neiman marcus credit card login small business credit card processing mobile best corporate credit cards canada amscot cash advance no checkbook what is the lowest credit card rate available application form for visa credit card apply for bad credit loan by phone reporting unauthorized credit card charges lowest interest credit card australia new payday lenders online jcpenney credit card login page halifax credit card online bank apply for marriott credit card uk small business cash advance loans corporate credit cards for small business credit card fraud penalties texas pay bank of america credit card online google credit card search credit card payments on iphone apps sbi online credit card payment login independent payday loan lenders icici bank credit card application form pdf old orchard credit card online should i pay off my high interest credit cards first free valid visa credit card numbers 2012 payday loan direct lenders only no teletrack barclays credit card apply online in india
Home All Articles Inside the Numbers: Ranking the 30 Clubs by Marginal Payroll/Marginal Wins

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 599 guests online

Atom RSS

Inside the Numbers: Ranking the 30 Clubs by Marginal Payroll/Marginal Wins PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 52
Articles & Opinion
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 24 October 2008 12:28


Efficiency and effectivity; two words that are the hallmarks of any well run organization. In Major League Baseball, often times, you can win the World Series, and have one but not the other.

In a league where there is a soft salary cap in the form of the competitive balance tax, or as it is more commonly known, the Luxury Tax, clubs that have deep pockets to work from can spend far more on player payroll than the majority of the other 30 clubs in the league. As an example, the New York Yankees had an Opening Day payroll that was almost as much as the player payroll for the bottom six teams by player payroll combined (Nationals, Pirates, Athletics, Rays, and Marlins).

But, as we saw this year, all that money could not get the Yankees’ foot in the door of the playoffs. As the old adage goes, it’s not how much money you spend, it’s how well you spend it.

With that, we can look at how much a team spends per win – a bang-for-the-buck metric called Marginal Payroll/Marginal Wins.

The formula works like this.

As a baseline, we’ll create a fictitious marginal team. Even the worst teams made up of near minor league players would not lose every game. So, we’ll say that a truly mediocre team would win only 30 percent of their games. For salary, we’ll set every players at the league minimum, which for 2008 was $390,000 . And finally, we’ll make the roster 25, plus 3 replacement players to allow for the DL..

By having this baseline team, we can use the winning percentage for each team in MLB for 2008 at the end of the season, along with their Opening Day payroll to determine what their marginal payroll would be and how much it costs a club per marginal win. We'll use Opening Day payroll instead of end of year payroll as a measurement of the intent of the club's spending as the season started. The formula, created by the late Doug Pappas, looks as follows:

(club payroll - (28 x major league minimum) / ((winning percentage - .300) x 162)

So, the lower the figures derived out of this formula, the better. In other words, if your cost per marginal win is lower, you are spending less per win – you’re efficient.

But remember, being efficient isn’t always being effective. As an example, Oakland spent $1,387,533 per marginal win this season based upon the third lowest Opening Day payroll of $47,967,126. The problem is, the A’s were second to last in the AL West with a 75-86 record. It didn’t cost the A’s much per win, but then again, they didn’t win enough games to make the playoffs.

On the other hand, you can be effective but inefficient. The Dodgers spent $3,040,001 per MW and won the NL West, but they spent nearly twice as much per win as the Diamondbacks ($1,655,171 per MW), who just missed the playoffs.

And, then there is the ultimate yin and yang of this formula: those teams that spent little per marginal win, but still won enough games to reach the playoffs, and those that spent a truckload of cash on player payroll only to sit at the bottom the standings.

Select Read More to see the rest of this article

Select to view PDF

As we present analysis around the figures for this past season, we encourage you to view the PDF file we have provided breaking down all 30 clubs by this “bang for the buck” metric (select the image to view).

Spending by the Truckload, and Losing Anyway

Of the four categories your team could land in, this is the one you’d least like to be in. It’s never easy having a large player payroll, but it’s beyond painful to spend money, only to flush it down the drain.

The unfortunate leader in this category for 2008 was the Seattle Mariners who had Opening Day player payroll of $117,993,982 but wound up losing 101 games or 39 games out of first place. For every one of the scant 61 wins the Mariners had, it cost them a staggering $8,634,999 per marginal win. It will be interesting to see how much salary the M’s shed in the off-season under new general manager Jack Zduriencik.

The other clubs that spent wildly but finished poorly include the Detroit Tigers (74-88, ODP of $138,685,197, cost per MW $5,030,126) and the San Diego Padres (63-99, ODP of $73,677,617, cost per MW $4,358,168) And while they didn’t finish in the cellar, we’d be remiss if didn’t mention the Yankees. With MLB’s largest player payroll at $209,081,579 and spent $4,904,990 per marginal win. The Bronx Bombers went 89-73 and missed the playoffs for the first time since 1995.

We should mention the New York Mets, who for the second season in a row, missed the playoffs on the last day of the season while posting an Opening Day payroll of $138,293,378, went 89-73 and posted $3,152,806 per marginal win, and the Washington Nationals, who had a reasonable Opening Day payroll of $54,961,000 but posted the worst record in the league at 59-102. Put them together, and the Nationals had a cost per marginal win of $4,115,981.

Spending, but Getting to the Playoffs

Call this the “burning money but we don’t care because we made the playoffs” category. These teams may not be efficient, but at least when they spent they can say that it garnered results.

At the top of this list sits the Los Angeles Dodgers who went 84-78 and won the NL West. The club posted $118,536,038 on Opening Day player payroll or $3,040,001 per marginal win. To place this in perspective, the Dodgers spent almost twice as much per win as the second place Diamondbacks who had a skinny $1,655,171 per MW.

Other notables in this category include the Chicago White Sox (89-74, ODP $121,152,667, cost per MW $2,748,944), Chicago Cubs (97-70, ODP $118,595,833, cost per MW $2,211,003) Boston Red Sox (95-67, $133,440,037 ODP, cost per MW $2,640,518), and the Angels (100-62, ODP $119,216,333, cost per MW $2,106,933).

Being Efficient, but Not Making the Grade

These were the teams that knew well enough not to spend every cent they had, but had to have done so knowing they had little to no chance making the playoffs when the season began, or in some cases, overachieved and wound up on the edge of making the playoffs.

The Florida Marlins are the best example, and with this year's figures, maybe ever. Owner Jeffery Loria snubbed his nose at the revenue sharing system, and rolled out a team with by far the lowest payroll in MLB at $21,836,500. To place this in perspective, the Rays had the second lowest Opening Day player payroll in the league at $43,820,598, over twice what the Marlins opened the year with. Still, in a weak NL East, the Marlins very nearly made the playoffs posting an 84-77 record, or a staggering $305,784 cost per marginal win. Just imagine if Loria had spent at a remotely respectable level of player payroll. Would there have been both South Florida teams in the playoffs?

Other examples include the Pirates (67-59, ODP $49,365,283, cost per MW $2,089,418), Kansas City (75-87, ODP $58,245,500, cost per MW $1,792,633, and Cincinnati (74-88, ODP $74,277,695, cost per MW $2,494,397).

Your Efficiency and Effectivity Winner

Here’s where you want to be. You spent wisely and went deep into the playoffs. And while everyone may look at the Tampa Bay Rays’ figures (they are hands down the winner in this category), we need to add a bit of a footnote.

Yes, the Rays had the second lowest Opening Day payroll in the league at the aforementioned $43,820,598, won the AL East with a 97-65 record, which comes to an incredible $679,764 per marginal win. The footnote? The roster is almost entirely the creation of draft picks meaning the club has offered this incredible collection of talent a fraction of what they will be worth when they hit arbitration eligibility and free agency. None the less, it is an incredible feat that the Rays have pulled off this year. To place this in perspective, with the exception of the Brewers at $1,692,854 per marginal win, no team that made the playoffs spent less than $2 million per marginal win. The only team that came close to matching Rays and Brewers were the Twins who just missed winning the AL Central with an 88-75 record, $62,182,767 ODP, which translates to $1,311,068 per marginal win.


This season wound up being a wonderment on a number of levels. Who would have thought that predictive contenders in the Tigers and Mariners would end the season so horribly? Who in their wildest dreams would have expected to see the Rays in the World Series, or the Twins and the Marlins post respectable records?

It seems that there is a new world order in MLB these days. Some have contended, and it's looking more truthful by the day, that the drug testing policy has changed how GMs build their teams. Veteran free agents, that at one point were viewed as effective well past their prime, have been passed over in favor of developing talent internally.

With that change, young talent is in again. That bodes well for those clubs that have stunk up the standings in the past (that would be you, Tampa Bay) and are now parlaying good draft picks into the core of their teams. Low revenue-making clubs are also seeing the value of wrapping up this young talent by way of long-term contracts. Players such as Evan Longoria and Troy Tulowitzki have signed contracts that will keep them with their respective teams through their arbitration eligibility years and early free agency.

As the numbers show, it is now possible for teams with low payrolls to have a successful regular- and post-season. As reported earlier this week, the challenge is for these teams once deemed to be nothing more than doormats of the league to contend over multiple seasons. That is the challenge of the low- to mid-revenue making clubs going forward.

Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and is available as a freelance writer.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?