cymbalta prices in canada topamax where to buy how to get dilantin in australia how long does it take coreg to start working anacin no prescription compare prices donepeil bactrim side effects rash pictures kamagra gel pas cher cardizem in the uk top 10 online sumycin sites buy cytoxan paypal accepted the little blue pill healthpoint what does it do provera canadian online himplasia without insurance remeron tablets 15 mg billig clozaril online kaufen periactin pills used augmentin 100 mg /12 5 buy premarin without prescription what is fenofibrate 160 mg used for how to get promethazine codeine syrup online what is triamterene hctz 37.5 25 mg myl q precio tienen pastillas cytotec ordering voveran here in canada sample of female viagra topamax over counter drugs what does zofran taste like buy aciclovir online in usa grifulvin v cheap uk lowest priced benadryl cost of cialis sublingual what does finasteride taste like is zetia in generic form xbox live price increase activision lexapro for ocd reviews purchase generic female cialis florida alligator hunting license cost where is baclofen metabolized best generic yasmin review what is levaquin 500 used for dapoxetine where to purchase blopress medication order zovirax pills dosage buy cheap aceon pills lisinopril mg canada power pill 100 inderal 10 mg migraine what does femcare buy augmentin online no prescription dose tadacip drugstore buy 1 generic acivir pills mg buy hong kong prescription actonel online cardizem online femara complications infertility cialis coupon discounts buy remeron without a prescription from canadian pharmacy comprare tartaruga alligatore lisinopril hctz 10 12.5 picture low dosage levitra buy generic lotensin nizagara canada finax suppliers overseas where to buy valtrex online canada arimidex 1mg tablets side effects cost of wellbutrin xl at walmart genuine ethionamide best price diclofenac cheapest online overnight buy quibron-t boots viagra and alcohol headache buy neo medrol online mevacor without insurance dipyridamole in the uk now alesse daily use reviews low thyroxine during pregnancy flomax drug oversea buy hydrochlorothiazide 50 cheap viagra generic pills suprax doctors online ebay allis chalmers parts canadian allied forces groningen where to buy alligator meat in orlando generic tinidazole usa tinidazole woldwide shipping buy levitra plus astrailia what is fluoxetine 20 mg used for printable propecia coupons best site get keflex buy astelin 40 zofran orally disintegrating tablets dose little blue pill healthpoint review what is blopress for generic adalat cc 30 mg nifedipine rash from singulair diovan side effects long term use depakote er max dose tadapox for dogs buy famciclovir for sale rogaine 2 cheap where can i buy bentyl in canada diclofenac overnight cheapest generic for zetia buy cipro online discreetly to buy atarax 5 mg brand cleocin for sale allopurinol drugstore acidity treat order premarin 120 mg equivalent du xenical onde posso comprar clomid prandin user reviews buy coloured contact lenses online australia get valtrex prescription online low dose aspirin over counter purchase medrol in australia nizoral tablets 150 mg sumycin online order rhinathiol syrup for children voltaren tablets uk ranitidine liquid price pamelor legal us buy terbinafine pills online no prescription amsa fast 120 mg ic doxycycline 100mg capsule lowest price provera snovitra super power pas cher cheap genuine dilantin online discount coupons voltaren gel oral compazine dose cost of detrol la 4mg unisom generic wikipedia drugs allegra medication class vytorin prescription card order vytorin overnight tadalafil generic australia cheap proventil hfa metoclopramide generic for generic flagyl metronidazole 400mg from uk what is alliteration in english do you need a prescription for valtrex in canada comprar purim original buy generic isoniazid nitrofurantoin for uti reviews buy nolvadex uk bodybuilding where can i buy prednisolone mg premarin recommended dosage propecia reviews forum prescription how long is it safe to take unisom while pregnant slimquick hoodia reviews amazon atorvastatin tablets 40mg mail order rx from canada generic cialis super active buy canada bentyl medication over the counter is diclofenac better than aleve how long do citalopram take to work buy cheap alesse pills pharmacy store design india danazol discount side effects of ciprofloxacin in pregnancy buy risperdal 2mg effexor xr price comparison where are parietal cells located all types kamagra gold pills voltaren mg order benemid prices at costco colchicine prescription assistance buy amoxil mg provera mexico companies only levitra 10 mg 4 film tablet ilac, amoxil dosage calculator zyvox dosage medication xanax bars information how much is diamox tablets how to buy a baby alligator mexican pharmacy no prescription oxytrol ayurslim uk online biaxin discount cheapest levitra plus to buy zithromax chlamydia cabergoline dosage for ohss accutane lawsuit canada 2010 trileptal tablets 150 mg my didronel coupons rumalaya discount medications finasteride (proscar propecia) rxlist valtrex dosage safe buy voveran online allegra 180 mg uses adalat 10 mg sublingual lithium carbonate and alcohol alesse drugstore.com canadian pharmacies that sell viagra amaryl where to purchase 100 mg inderal 24h pharmacy east london isoptin sale generic form of aspirin buy cephalexin without rx betapace side effects uk what are the side effects of the drug doxazosin cost of lamisil at walmart buy viagra without scrip buy tamoxifen citrate online florida lisinopril generic brafix safe there generic arimidex around the world online pharmacy purchase dutas online mexico prescription buy amantadine how to take fincar mg prescription protonix torsemide 40 mg dose birth control pills levitra plus prescription allegra canada without a transcript order desyrel selegiline dosage for social anxiety depression cheap viagra generic paypal best site for bactrim are alli slimming pills safe comprar trental online does watermelon have same effect viagra ndc code for depo medrol 40 mg cialis generico tadacip florida zanaflex prevacid solutab 30 mg generic comprar zebeta pela internet where to buy live lobster in london clozaril cheap mexico pharmacy amantadine hydrochloride suppliers in india original avandamet online order vermox on line india buy orlistat india sale prescription buy cozaar order kamagra on line canada most reliable place to buy lotensin online how to import flovent generic femara available us seroquel discount coupons metformin lactic acidosis diabetes vasodilan dose florida serpina alli cost without insurance stilnox best place to buy vpxl in australia ditropan canadian medications without prescription sleep medicine trazodone side effects which is best cialis levitra or viagra buy brand ventolin where can i buy zanaflex tablets use of chloroquine phosphate tablets probalan without insurance side effects of amitriptyline drugs diclofenac billig kaufen where chloramphenicol cleocin tablets 40mg risperdal reviews ocd abana online pharmacy uk tenormin pharmacy coupons canadian pharmacy online elocon are alligators dangerous for people how to use nizoral shampoo for acne amitriptyline sale side effects of alavert what is the correct dosage of trandate lipitor atorvastatin 80 mg para que sirve diclofenaco sodico inyectable colchicine 100 estrace spain pulmicort user reviews messi stats 2012 13 canadian alliance for community service learning retin-a 0,05 no prescription compare prices coumadin tablets uk canadian alliance church buy grifulvin online safely what is flonase for lasix overnight delivery gauranteed best generic tegretol review risperdal 5mg tablets erythromycin shop net research grade citalopram triamterene tablets buy free cipro company search normal bupropion dose lamictal medication side effects can you buy actoplus met online pyridium pills drugstore can order viagra sublingual canada order robaxin from cheap generic cialis from india is mail order aspirin safe mexican lotrisone german remedies pharma india buy viagra online no prescription usa benicar shop net dapoxetine 50mg tablets what does haldol make you feel like periactin 40mg order cardizem from mexico without prescription pharmacy store for sale in nj coversyl australia looking to purchase reviato from canada cheap lotrel 40 mg pharmacy tech jobs overseas zentel sirop preturi alternative medicine for low back pain acomplia rimonabant wikipedia suprax coupon lupin dosage of prednisone for dogs with cancer buy menosan bulk best place buy lamictal pct where can i buy prednisone for my dog ephedraxin for discount liposafe coupons where to buy alesse in canada safely exelon ordering online pharmacy punar vivah desi tashan june 26 high dose methotrexate order set order norvasc online with visa aciclovir eye ointment side effects canadian pharmacy spam removal can you buy dramamine at walmart levitra professional overnight delivery clonidine hcl price cost comparison buy stromectol online genuine viagra canada 36 hr cialis dosage kmart pharmacy generic price list costco pharmacy buspar price acheter cialis en toute securite abilify no prrescription how to take mobic 7.5mg where can i buy coreg in canada is mail order levitra super active safe blood pressure medication with least amount of side effects legitimate online pharmacies forum chlamydia screening guidelines cafergot availability australia haridra with no rx nexium side effects weight loss cipralex 10 mg buy what is estrace cream avalide usa over the counter substitute for premarin is it safe to order zanaflex cephalexin over the counter australia cheapest arimidex in the uk overnight pharmacy buy alli orlistat cialis usa cvs prices online arjuna with no prescription can i buy diclofenac over the counter anxiety and depression in children celebrex dosage too high can i order drugs from mexico what is citalopram tablets used for can i make zenegra difference between erythromycin and erythromycin gastro resistant retin-a 0,025 online coupon code prescription solutions in overland park ks 66211 order avapro pill buying drugs in berlin prednisolone usa all types prevacid pills indian accutane generic generic zovirax switzerland where can i get cleocin best place buy viagra online generic propecia pris licensed pharmacy protonix cafergot buy lasix boots metformin online from usa what is accutane therapy us online pharmacy no prescription oxytrol vasotec 100 review how to buy nolvadex in australia coumadin toxicity inr lotrisone online usa malegra dxt where to get lasix from europe top 10 online tinidazole sites norvasc dosage 2.5mg cheap celexa 100 mg buy cheap sinequan buy alphagan online canada no prescription 100 mg betnovate cost of isoptin without insurance pharmacie de garde lausanne viagra super active mg order chloramphenicol prescription only saw palmetto rxlist precose 25 mg tablets buy brand brand cialis revia generic name how to use clomid after a steroid cycle buy lipitor tablets medicine cholestoplex online pharmacy retin-a ge express canada the purple pharmacy los algodones mexico max wellbutrin dose order tinidazole no prescription buy aciphex 20 mg where can i purchase beconase aq is it safe to use online pharmacy best site to buy wellbutrin sr protonix 20mg tab lady era shipping overseas taking 2 diflucan pills zovirax cream australia ayurslim drugstore.com elavil 20mg tab synthroid cost cvs levitra us sales drugstore trihexyphenidyl information where can i get some wellbutrin what class of drugs is clonidine order mirapex cheap pictures of digoxin pills finax suppositories buy valtrex dosage recurrent herpes labialis benzac ac 2.5 price in india india buy lotrisone dose purchase kamagra chewable pills buy imuran new zealand online order allopurinol all rights canadian prescription flagyl used alternative medicine to femara cheapest viagra plus in the uk uroxatral tablets 10mg allegra without food mail order accutane erexin-v discount voucher buy food online with paypal order cialis sublingual online no prescription with a amex female cialis pharmacy coupons betamethasone ointment online buy prednisolone online no prescription usa propranolol canada prescription kamagra oral jelly visa what is inderal tablets used for purchasing revatio online shelf life of cephalexin 500mg herpes outbreak treatment valtrex dosage bactrim lawsuit settlements buy amitriptyline usa beta blockers online pharmacy levitra generic do i need a prescription for alesse hong kong buy combivent inhaler online drug market order revia order elocon cream 0.1 eczema can you mix doxycycline and alcohol aricept price increase canada usa mexico alliance buy results rx skincare no rx zebeta online zetia price in canada can you get diflucan otc urispas to buy in england aciclovir creme mylan terramycin drug schedule cefadroxil online in usa flomax generic cost without prescription premarin dosage forms norvasc para que se usa actos combination therapy clozaril buy online ireland plavix generic equivalent buying innopran xl from canada no prescription revia order online buy chloramphenicol usa what is silagra pills used for exelon online legally fucidin sale generic rumalaya us innopran xl overnight pharmacy where do i levaquin in mexico what does synthroid 100 mcg look like albendazole syrup for children lee ann drugs 33139 rogaine 5 shop net chloroquine where can i buy it how to take brahmi powder for memory exelon reviews for men keflex 250 mg capsules drugs online no prescription canada crestor side effects canada what do claritin pills look like research grade bactroban diovan hct generic available long term side effects of atorlip-20 prilosec over the counter dose hyzaar 100 24 for sale clomid men fertility overseas pharmacy no prescription zyrtec dilantin to buy from europe lynoral shopping generic retino-a cream 0,025 us where can i get mentat ds syrup online pharmacy no prescription needed zanaflex acheter requip lamictal 100mg effects biaxin pharmacies in reviews on brahmi amla hair oil obagi tretinoin 05 reviews revatio 20 mg tid tricor 100mg cheep purchase sertraline no prescription ventolin hfa uses buy effexor xr 75 mg pharmacies salbutamol combivent inhaler lipothin to purchase without a prescription buy remeron 20 side effects of brahmi oil zoloft dose buy levaquin 500 mg viagra super active from canadian pharmacy donde conseguir acai berry en costa rica erythromycin base 250 mg nhs cost simvastatin cyproheptadine weight gain adults aleve on line purchase what is parietal lobe function
Home BoB Documents MLBPA v. Steve Garvey

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 972 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA v. Steve Garvey PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 5
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Court Ruling   
Tuesday, 19 June 2001 12:00

MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL PLAYERS ASSOCIATION
v.
Steve GARVEY


532 U.S. 1015 (2001)

PER CURIAM.
The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit here rejected an arbitrator's factual findings and then resolved the merits of the parties' dispute instead of remanding the case for further arbitration proceedings. Because the court's determination conflicts with our cases limiting review of an arbitrator's award entered pursuant to an agreement between an employer and a labor organization and prescribing the appropriate remedy where vacation of the award is warranted, we grant the petition for a writ of certiorari and reverse. . . . .

[In the late 1980s, arbitrators found collusion by the Major League Baseball Clubs (Clubs) in the market for free-agent services and damages to the players represented by the petitioner, Major League Baseball Players Association (Association). The Association and Clubs entered into a Global Settlement Agreement (Agreement), which established a $280 million fund to be distributed to injured players. The Association also designed a "Framework" to evaluate the individual player's claims.]
 
The Framework provided that players could seek an arbitrator's review of the distribution plan. The arbitrator would determine "'only whether the approved Framework and the criteria set forth therein have been properly applied in the proposed Distribution Plan.'" Garvey v. Roberts, 203 F.3d 580, 583 (9th Cir. 2000) (Garvey I). The Framework set forth factors to be considered in evaluating players' claims, as well as specific requirements for lost contract-extension claims. Such claims were cognizable "'only in those cases where evidence exists that a specific offer of an extension was made by a club prior to collusion only to thereafter be withdrawn when the collusion scheme was initiated.'" Id., at 584.
 
Respondent Steve Garvey, a retired, highly regarded first baseman, submitted a claim for damages of approximately $3 million. He alleged that his contract with the San Diego Padres was not extended to the 1988 and 1989 seasons due to collusion. The Association rejected Garvey's claim in February 1996, because he presented no evidence that the Padres actually offered to extend his contract. Garvey objected, and an arbitration hearing was held. He testified that the Padres offered to extend his contract for the 1988 and 1989 seasons and then withdrew the offer after they began colluding with other teams. He presented a June 1996 letter from Ballard Smith, Padres' President and CEO from 1979 to 1987, stating that, before the end of the 1985 season, Smith offered to extend Garvey's contract through the 1989 season, but that the Padres refused to negotiate with Garvey thereafter due to collusion.
 
The arbitrator denied Garvey's claim, after seeking additional documentation from the parties. In his award, he explained that "'[t]here exists ... substantial doubt as to the credibility of the statements in the Smith letter.'" Id. at 586. . . . .
 
Garvey moved in Federal District Court to vacate the arbitrator's award, alleging that the arbitrator violated the Framework by denying his claim. The District Court denied the motion.  [The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed by a divided vote, holding that review of the merits of the arbitrator's award was warranted in this case, because the arbitrator "'dispensed his own brand of industrial justice.'" Id. at 589.] . . . . [I]n the court's view, the arbitrator's refusal to credit Smith's letter was "inexplicable" and "border[ed] on the irrational" . .. Id. at 590. . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed and remanded with directions to vacate the award.

The District Court then remanded the case to the arbitration panel for further hearings, and Garvey appealed. The Court of Appeals, again by a divided vote, explained that Garvey I established that "the conclusion that Smith made Garvey an offer and subsequently withdrew it because of the collusion scheme was the only conclusion that the arbitrator could draw from the record in the proceedings." Garvey II (unpublished). . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed the District Court and directed that it remand the case to the arbitration panel with instructions to enter an award for Garvey in the amount he claimed.

* * *

Judicial review of a labor-arbitration decision pursuant to such an agreement is very limited. Courts are not authorized to review the arbitrator's decision on the merits despite allegations that the decision rests on factual errors or misinterprets the parties' agreement. Paperworkers v. Misco, Inc., 484 U.S. 29, 36 (1987). We recently reiterated that if an "'arbitrator is even arguably construing or applying the contract and acting within the scope of his authority,' the fact that 'a court is convinced he committed serious error does not suffice to overturn his decision.'" It is only when the arbitrator strays from interpretation and application of the agreement and effectively "dispense [s] his own brand of industrial justice" that his decision may be unenforceable. When an arbitrator resolves disputes regarding the application of a contract, and no dishonesty is alleged, the arbitrator's "improvident, even silly, factfinding" does not provide a basis for a reviewing court to refuse to enforce the award. Misco, 484 U.S. at 39.
 
In discussing the courts' limited role in reviewing the merits of arbitration awards, we have stated that "'courts ... have no business weighing the merits of the grievance [or] considering whether there is equity in a particular claim.'" Id. at 37. When the judiciary does so, "it usurps a function which ... is entrusted to the arbitration tribunal." Consistent with this limited role, we said in Misco that "[e]ven in the very rare instances when an arbitrator's procedural aberrations rise to the level of affirmative misconduct, as a rule the court must not foreclose further proceedings by settling the merits according to its own judgment of the appropriate result." 484 U.S. at 40-41, n. 10. That step, we explained, "would improperly substitute a judicial determination for the arbitrator's decision that the parties bargained for" in their agreement. Ibid. Instead, the court should "simply vacate the award, thus leaving open the possibility of further proceedings if they are permitted under the terms of the agreement." Ibid.

To be sure, the Court of Appeals here recited these principles, but its application of them is nothing short of baffling. The substance of the court's discussion reveals that it overturned the arbitrator's decision because it disagreed with the arbitrator's factual findings, particularly those with respect to credibility. The Court of Appeals, it appears, would have credited Smith's 1996 letter, and found the arbitrator's refusal to do so at worst "irrational" and at best "bizarre." Garvey I, 203 F.3d at 590-591. But even "serious error" on the arbitrator's part does not justify overturning his decision, where, as here, he is construing a contract and acting within the scope of his authority. Misco, supra, at 38.

In Garvey II, the court clarified that Garvey I both rejected the arbitrator's findings and went further, resolving the merits of the parties' dispute based on the court's assessment of the record before the arbitrator. For that reason, the court found further arbitration proceedings inappropriate. But again, established law ordinarily precludes a court from resolving the merits of the parties' dispute on the basis of its own factual determinations, no matter how erroneous the arbitrator's decision. Misco, supra, at 40, n. 10. Even when the arbitrator's award may properly be vacated, the appropriate remedy is to remand the case for further arbitration proceedings. Misco, supra, at 40. The dissent suggests that the remedy described in Misco is limited to cases where the arbitrator's errors are procedural. (Opinion of STEVENS, J.). Misco did involve procedural issues, but our discussion regarding the appropriate remedy was not so limited. If a remand is appropriate even when the arbitrator's award has been set aside for "procedural aberrations" that constitute "affirmative misconduct," it follows that a remand ordinarily will be appropriate when the arbitrator simply made factual findings that the reviewing court perceives as "irrational." The Court of Appeals usurped the arbitrator's role by resolving the dispute and barring further proceedings, a result at odds with this governing law.

For the foregoing reasons, the Court of Appeals erred in reversing the order of the District Court denying the motion to vacate the arbitrator's award, and it erred further in directing that judgment be entered in Garvey's favor. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted, the judgment of the Court of Appeals is reversed, and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

It is so ordered.

Justice GINSBURG, concurring in part and concurring in the judgment.

Justice STEVENS, dissenting.

[Separate opinions are omitted]

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?