buying cialis legal generic lexapro cipla zovirax cream mg zoloft 25 mg prezzo viagra generika 50mg prednisone tablet 5443 50mg cialis 2.5 mg times doxycycline capsule 50 mg celebrex price generic 200 mg viagra fine 20mg lilly cialis generic cialis purchase celebrex 300 mg lexapro 5 mg conversion brand priligy online generic like viagra buy cialis 20 mg generic cialis images levitra cupon online celebrex 200mg espanol cialis 5 mg 2.5mg cost cialis 20mg propecia generic wiki lexapro 5mg generic viagra jet 100mg viagra grande 50 mg cheap cialis safe order site viagra buy lisinopril 20 cialisgeneric cialis c zoloft 25 mg ocd cialis preis 10 mg brand cialis 100mg celebrex 200 mg r propranolol tablets 10 mg metformin mylan 500mg cialis 20mg order buy synthroid 100 mcg viagra online tomorrow cytotec 200 mg uso clomid generic vs sample generic viagra green viagra 200mg prednisone 15mg 5ml generic buspar reviews buy canadian cialis nexium 20 mg haittavaikutukset forum generic cialis diflucan online ordering generic viagra experiences clomid 150mg follicles acheter cialis 2.5mg cheap clomid 50 mg kamagra 100 mg etkisi prednisone 10 mg effects cheapest generic propecia dosis cialis 5 mg generic cialis gels synthroid 0.25 mg tablet paypal buy cialis buy lisinopril mexico synthroid generic image viagra 25 mg online nexium 40 mg valor buy viagra rss nolvadex 10 mg use buy tetracycline 250 mg 33 viagra order online zithromax 900 mg 5 mg levitra buy clomid otc generic red viagra lisinopril 10mg used cialis 20 mg eu generic for zovirax espanol levitra 20mg harga propranolol 40 mg clomid buy nz generic brand xenical online eczane cialis cialis mg strengths buy celebrex celecoxib 20 mg of doxycycline amoxil 250 mg used buy metformin generic mastercard viagra 150mg generic cialis when lisinopril 20 mg bioequivalence diflucan 150mg generico thuoc metformin 500mg experiencias viagra 50 mg cialis 20mg avis kandungan doxycycline 150mg generic valtrex ingredients propecia nz buy zovirax 200mg hinta lexapro 5 mg breastfeeding viagra bali buy order zovirax uk tablet glucophage 500 mg prednisone taper 20 mg levitra mg 10 propecia order sales nexium 20 mg bijsluiter buy fluconazole diflucan cialis 5mg peaks viagra buying online propecia generic review cialis 20 mg nederland buy lasix generic cheap brand viagra order viagra line dosage 40mg cialis buy propranolol 10 mg cialis professional 20 mg. generic lexapro 5mg viagra alternative cheap nexium 40 mg harga lisinopril 20 mg indicaciones metformin sr 850 mg buy propecia finasteride buy lexapro 5mg obat doxycycline 100mg viagra 100mg online celebrex 200 mg cena hydrochlorothiazide online erythromycin 250 mg filmtab cialis cheapest price zithromax 400 mg generic viagra black viagra lloyds online nexium 20 mg prices kamagra 100mg 4 st valtrex online sales 120 mg of nexium cialis notice20mg order propecia bosley buy zovirax zovirax lexapro 1 mg levitra 20mg preis no generic lexapro cialis 20mg half buy viagra qatar 2.5 mg lexapro reviews cipro 500 mg days zovirax 800 mg uses buy viagra cytotec generico sirve cheap viagra us nexium 40 mg notice cheap kamagra.com cialis 100mg portugues tetracycline 250 mg order diflucan pill order clomid overnight viagra approval online augmentin antibiotico 500 mg zoloft 50 mg prices cheap propecia tablets walmart clomid generic order bactrim cheap lexapro generic recall viagra order au lisinopril l0 mg lasix generic form generic strattera 10 mg synthroid prescription online celebrex 200mg anwendung tratamiento cialis 5 mg levitra precio 20 mg viagra 100mg how diflucan 150 mg бra cialis viagra generico buy amoxil online lasix tablet 500mg viagra condom buy valtrex 500 mg precio prednisone 10mg injector glucophage price 500 mg clomid 150mg success nexium generic europe generic priligy 90mg order viagra 25mg where buy nolvadex generic cialis online buy clomid pakistan levitra 20mg testbericht viagra generic philippines is zovirax generic cytotec pastillas 200mg walmart cialis 5mg generic zoloft difference viagra generic china viagra 25 mg precio zithromax 500 mg 3 nexium 40 mg 7 price depression wellbutrin generic ratio metformin 500mg generic propecia effective clomid 5omg tablets amoxil bd 400 mg cialis 80mg levitra oat 10mg nexium 40 mg tabletas metformin 500 mg pdf official viagra online viagra generic real cialis 20 mg costi clomid buy clomid will propecia generic lisinopril 40 mg daily 300 mg zoloft ocd acquisto levitra generico wellbutrin generic alternatives ricetta viagra online buy cheap clomid cheapest cialis 5mg strattera 60 mg cost laboratorio nexium 40 mg generic zoloft 100 mg tadalafi cialis 500mg pastillas genericas cytotec online viagra women buy cheap tetracycline 12 mg of phenergan kamagra 100mg cola viagra 25 vs 50 mg doxycycline mono 20mg gebruiksaanwijzing cialis 20mg generic cialis chicago viagra 100mg doziranje cheap 5mg propecia levitra online bahrain viagra precription online generic synthroid tablets buy viagra sf order amoxil online cialis prostate disorders generic valtrex 1000mg buy cialis 200mg cheapest 150 ml viagra coupons levitra 10mg online viagra consultation buying kamagra online viagra online sales bactrim 240mg doxycycline 50mg capsules nolvadex 10mg tamoxifen augmentin 875 mg tablet buy viagra 100 mg lisinopril tablets buy kamagra cheap uk zithromax 4x 250mg cialis 10mg last pfizer viagra 150 mg lexapro 10 mg embarazo tetracycline mg2 prednisone posologie 5 mg prednisone 20 mg 5 days buying tijuana viagra xenical generic cost metformin mims online wellbutrin 150 mg sigara doxycycline dosage 300 mg levitra order uk buy cipro online 200 mg doxycycline hyclate prinivil lisinopril 10 mg viagra 25 mg effectiveness review cialis 60mg cialis online safety augmentin 875 125 mg filmtabletten 25mg viagra fiyati cialis 5mg ndc cheap viagra missouri 15 mg and lexapro cialis online 5 mg viagra online 50mg cialis cost 2.5 mg levitra 20 mg directions viagra 50mg.es cialis 20 mg portugal xenical tem generico safe cheap cialis lisinopril 40 mg online prednisone mg dosage buy celebrex drugstore amoxicillin amoxil 125 mg bactrim buy paypal cialis real online cialis uk 5mg cipro tendon disorder buy cialis japan levitra 20 mg uso zovirax to buy 2.5mg cialis review 50 mg clomid ovulation levitra online usa viagra 2.5 mg price prednisone 60 mg surgery viagra generico spagna clomid mg ml cialis 5 mg beipackzettel generic levitra reliability 25mg viagra order viagra america viagra 150 mg chattanooga nexium 20 mg plicuri cialis medistar 20 mg 10 mg propranolol pregnancy cheap online viagra 5mgm cialis lisinopril sandoz 10mg buy viagra england lisinopril 10 10 mg tab wellbutrin generic dose cheap viagra 50mg online propecia forum buy cialis online 32 valtrex 500 mg generic viagra doctor online metformin er generic phenergan suppositories online viagra online offers propranolol 20 mg tab 100 mg zoloft 1oomg cialis wholesale viagra 100 mg effet buying clomid privately cialis online as 20 mg clomid pills celebrex generic 200mg 20 mg lexapro depression cialis 50mg pills lisinopril cinfa 5mg buy strattera adderall buying levitra metformin 500 mg actavis buy lisinopril cost 40 mg nexium viagra black generic kegunaan lexapro 10 mg propranolol 10 mg pregnancy cialis 20 mg murah prednisone 40 mg ovulation cialis 40 mg australia mexico buy viagra 1000 mg metformin hydrochloride viagra cheap europe celebrex 200mg pret generic kamagra 40 mg daily prednisone costo diflucan 100 mg buy propecia coupon generic lexapro buy buy levitra online 35008 generic propecia cheap buying levitra jakarta doxycycline 50 mg wikipedia generic cialis fedex genericos de celebrex xenical tablets online generic name phenergan levitra 20 mg tablets 50 mg clomid twins 5mg cialis forum generic lexapro teva opiniones xenical 120 mg xenical buy now levitra 20mg preisvergleich cipro online payment brazil viagra buy buy zithromax walmart generic viagra birmingham zovirax brand generic viagra 5mg review viagra 100 ou 50 mg cheapest super cialis cheapest 1 mg propecia 160 mg lasix 200 mg viagra cialis 100mg 20mg propranolol tab 40mg 60 mg of nexium zovirax 5mg cream dosi cialis 5 mg generico do cipro 500 buy viagra maryland buy oral nolvadex levitra tablets 10mg daily cialis 2.5mg lexapro 10 mg cost viagra 25 mg bestellen doxycycline 100mg jerawat order levitra generic reliable generic cialis buygenuine cialis lexapro generic march 14 propecia uk order generics viagra paypal propranolol 10 mg migraine valtrex generico bula lasix 40 mg furosemid cialis online ie amoxil 250 mg liquid strattera 40 mg wirkung melbourne buy levitra cialis generic pakistan viagra 100mg apteka celebrex caps 200 mg propecia 0.5 mg side generic viagra betrouwbaar acheter viagra 25mg viagra online vancouver dosage cialis 5 mg zithromax 500 mg indicaciones valtrex 200mg lexapro generic list viagra softtabs online buy diflucan australia cialis generico tadalafil wellbutrin equivalent generic walmart 50mg viagra kamagra tablets cheap remedio cipro 500 mg generic viagra 40 tabs mylan lisinopril 10 mg sams viagra 50mg order clomid zithromax tablets 500mg lexapro 20 mg st buying viagra forum concor viagra 50 mg viagra 100 mg daily 50mg prednisone viagra overnight order generico do synthroid lexapro when generic comprar generico xenical lasix generic tablet harga cialis 20 mg erythromycin filmtab 500mg strattera buy cheap doxycycline capsules generic viagra online doma tania kamagra 100mg very cheap cialis propranolol gador 80 mg cialis 20 mg. cheasp levitra uk online generic lexapro reviews 2013 online viagra louisiana cialis 200 mg overnight cialis 10mg comprar cialis 36 hr 20 mg levitra 10mg fta 4 10 mg lisinopril tablets anxiety lexapro 5mg 500 mg valtrex daily cialis 10 mg erfahrungen buy levitra pen australlian generic viagra order Cialis 10 pills generic cialis canadian buy lisinopril 2.5 mg zithromax generic us buy prednisone india buy diflucan india 90 mg synthroid generic strattera paypal doxycycline bipolar disorder bulk buy viagra cialis 20 mg venda discount augmentin online generic viagra price buy clomid online 80 mg prednisone dose zovirax generico lisinopril fatigue 20mg clomid generic levitra dispersible 5 mg tarif cialis 20 mg lexapro 20 mg anxiety zithromax 40mg ml lasix 20 mg used nexium compresse 40 mg hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg qualitest potenzmittel cialis 5mg 40 mg cialis generic metformin hcl 50mg cialis 40 mg einnehmen frequency metformin 500mg strattera 60 mg costco xenical online discount viagra 7.5 mg cialis online us viagra online ask zovirax comprimidos 200 mg wellbutrin 300 mg libido 600 mg wellbutrin erowid
Home BoB Documents MLBPA v. Steve Garvey

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 484 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA v. Steve Garvey PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 12
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Court Ruling   
Tuesday, 19 June 2001 12:00

MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL PLAYERS ASSOCIATION
v.
Steve GARVEY


532 U.S. 1015 (2001)

PER CURIAM.
The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit here rejected an arbitrator's factual findings and then resolved the merits of the parties' dispute instead of remanding the case for further arbitration proceedings. Because the court's determination conflicts with our cases limiting review of an arbitrator's award entered pursuant to an agreement between an employer and a labor organization and prescribing the appropriate remedy where vacation of the award is warranted, we grant the petition for a writ of certiorari and reverse. . . . .

[In the late 1980s, arbitrators found collusion by the Major League Baseball Clubs (Clubs) in the market for free-agent services and damages to the players represented by the petitioner, Major League Baseball Players Association (Association). The Association and Clubs entered into a Global Settlement Agreement (Agreement), which established a $280 million fund to be distributed to injured players. The Association also designed a "Framework" to evaluate the individual player's claims.]
 
The Framework provided that players could seek an arbitrator's review of the distribution plan. The arbitrator would determine "'only whether the approved Framework and the criteria set forth therein have been properly applied in the proposed Distribution Plan.'" Garvey v. Roberts, 203 F.3d 580, 583 (9th Cir. 2000) (Garvey I). The Framework set forth factors to be considered in evaluating players' claims, as well as specific requirements for lost contract-extension claims. Such claims were cognizable "'only in those cases where evidence exists that a specific offer of an extension was made by a club prior to collusion only to thereafter be withdrawn when the collusion scheme was initiated.'" Id., at 584.
 
Respondent Steve Garvey, a retired, highly regarded first baseman, submitted a claim for damages of approximately $3 million. He alleged that his contract with the San Diego Padres was not extended to the 1988 and 1989 seasons due to collusion. The Association rejected Garvey's claim in February 1996, because he presented no evidence that the Padres actually offered to extend his contract. Garvey objected, and an arbitration hearing was held. He testified that the Padres offered to extend his contract for the 1988 and 1989 seasons and then withdrew the offer after they began colluding with other teams. He presented a June 1996 letter from Ballard Smith, Padres' President and CEO from 1979 to 1987, stating that, before the end of the 1985 season, Smith offered to extend Garvey's contract through the 1989 season, but that the Padres refused to negotiate with Garvey thereafter due to collusion.
 
The arbitrator denied Garvey's claim, after seeking additional documentation from the parties. In his award, he explained that "'[t]here exists ... substantial doubt as to the credibility of the statements in the Smith letter.'" Id. at 586. . . . .
 
Garvey moved in Federal District Court to vacate the arbitrator's award, alleging that the arbitrator violated the Framework by denying his claim. The District Court denied the motion.  [The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed by a divided vote, holding that review of the merits of the arbitrator's award was warranted in this case, because the arbitrator "'dispensed his own brand of industrial justice.'" Id. at 589.] . . . . [I]n the court's view, the arbitrator's refusal to credit Smith's letter was "inexplicable" and "border[ed] on the irrational" . .. Id. at 590. . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed and remanded with directions to vacate the award.

The District Court then remanded the case to the arbitration panel for further hearings, and Garvey appealed. The Court of Appeals, again by a divided vote, explained that Garvey I established that "the conclusion that Smith made Garvey an offer and subsequently withdrew it because of the collusion scheme was the only conclusion that the arbitrator could draw from the record in the proceedings." Garvey II (unpublished). . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed the District Court and directed that it remand the case to the arbitration panel with instructions to enter an award for Garvey in the amount he claimed.

* * *

Judicial review of a labor-arbitration decision pursuant to such an agreement is very limited. Courts are not authorized to review the arbitrator's decision on the merits despite allegations that the decision rests on factual errors or misinterprets the parties' agreement. Paperworkers v. Misco, Inc., 484 U.S. 29, 36 (1987). We recently reiterated that if an "'arbitrator is even arguably construing or applying the contract and acting within the scope of his authority,' the fact that 'a court is convinced he committed serious error does not suffice to overturn his decision.'" It is only when the arbitrator strays from interpretation and application of the agreement and effectively "dispense [s] his own brand of industrial justice" that his decision may be unenforceable. When an arbitrator resolves disputes regarding the application of a contract, and no dishonesty is alleged, the arbitrator's "improvident, even silly, factfinding" does not provide a basis for a reviewing court to refuse to enforce the award. Misco, 484 U.S. at 39.
 
In discussing the courts' limited role in reviewing the merits of arbitration awards, we have stated that "'courts ... have no business weighing the merits of the grievance [or] considering whether there is equity in a particular claim.'" Id. at 37. When the judiciary does so, "it usurps a function which ... is entrusted to the arbitration tribunal." Consistent with this limited role, we said in Misco that "[e]ven in the very rare instances when an arbitrator's procedural aberrations rise to the level of affirmative misconduct, as a rule the court must not foreclose further proceedings by settling the merits according to its own judgment of the appropriate result." 484 U.S. at 40-41, n. 10. That step, we explained, "would improperly substitute a judicial determination for the arbitrator's decision that the parties bargained for" in their agreement. Ibid. Instead, the court should "simply vacate the award, thus leaving open the possibility of further proceedings if they are permitted under the terms of the agreement." Ibid.

To be sure, the Court of Appeals here recited these principles, but its application of them is nothing short of baffling. The substance of the court's discussion reveals that it overturned the arbitrator's decision because it disagreed with the arbitrator's factual findings, particularly those with respect to credibility. The Court of Appeals, it appears, would have credited Smith's 1996 letter, and found the arbitrator's refusal to do so at worst "irrational" and at best "bizarre." Garvey I, 203 F.3d at 590-591. But even "serious error" on the arbitrator's part does not justify overturning his decision, where, as here, he is construing a contract and acting within the scope of his authority. Misco, supra, at 38.

In Garvey II, the court clarified that Garvey I both rejected the arbitrator's findings and went further, resolving the merits of the parties' dispute based on the court's assessment of the record before the arbitrator. For that reason, the court found further arbitration proceedings inappropriate. But again, established law ordinarily precludes a court from resolving the merits of the parties' dispute on the basis of its own factual determinations, no matter how erroneous the arbitrator's decision. Misco, supra, at 40, n. 10. Even when the arbitrator's award may properly be vacated, the appropriate remedy is to remand the case for further arbitration proceedings. Misco, supra, at 40. The dissent suggests that the remedy described in Misco is limited to cases where the arbitrator's errors are procedural. (Opinion of STEVENS, J.). Misco did involve procedural issues, but our discussion regarding the appropriate remedy was not so limited. If a remand is appropriate even when the arbitrator's award has been set aside for "procedural aberrations" that constitute "affirmative misconduct," it follows that a remand ordinarily will be appropriate when the arbitrator simply made factual findings that the reviewing court perceives as "irrational." The Court of Appeals usurped the arbitrator's role by resolving the dispute and barring further proceedings, a result at odds with this governing law.

For the foregoing reasons, the Court of Appeals erred in reversing the order of the District Court denying the motion to vacate the arbitrator's award, and it erred further in directing that judgment be entered in Garvey's favor. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted, the judgment of the Court of Appeals is reversed, and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

It is so ordered.

Justice GINSBURG, concurring in part and concurring in the judgment.

Justice STEVENS, dissenting.

[Separate opinions are omitted]

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?