propecia canada 5mg erythromycin tablets 500mg Levitra pills order diflucan 100 mg dosi Cialis 20mg 10 Tabs cialis 0 5 mg nexium 40 mg prospecto valtrex cheap prescription cheap dubai viagra newest cialis 40 mg amoxil 875 mg used lexapro cost 20mg ed generic viagra prednisone 60 mg pregnant buy doxycycline injections priligy generico 30 mg cialis 20 mg deutschland australia cialis online synthroid buy online augmentin 156 mg ulotka lisinopril price 10 mg nolvadex 20mg kur nexium generic brands jual nexium 20mg buy cytotec ireland lexapro buy 10mg best generic metformin dapoxetine 60mg tablets cialis 5 mg use zoloft withdrawal 100mg viagra generico sms lexapro 60 mg dose viagra pill online generic lexapro problems hydrochlorothiazide mg dosage viagra generic eu 40 mg lexapro 0.5mg propecia results online bestellen viagra valtrex generic m123 metformin 500 mg erfahrungen lexapro order online lisinopril 40 mg mg cheap cialis fast cialis online help order lexapro 10mg online cialis coupon nombre generico celebrex prednisone 50 mg withdrawal cialis online al generic valtrex expensive strattera 10 mg dosage cialis generic Washington cialis generic wholesale buying viagra mumbai buy levitra 90 pills cialis 20mg proffenials viagra 100mg pfizer buy levitra 30 pills viagra 50 or 100mg 12.5 mg phenergan unprescribed clomid 100 mg propecia generic costco viagra 25 mg wirkung medicamento levitra 10 mg cialis 20 mg china viagra 50mg tab online viagra experment ordering clomid online 5mg cialis india synthroid de 50mg generic viagra dk propecia 1 mg price prednisone 60 mg daily viagra mastercard generic viagra online genuine buy kamagra gel 20mg cialis experience lexapro online ny viagra online wiki cialis generic super prednisone 5 mg uses cytotec 100 mg buy amoxil amoxicillin online viagra singapore levitra oro 10 mg 10 mg phenergan two 5 mg cialis buy viagra onlines doxycycline posologie 20mg generic viagra philippines ciprofloxacin cipro generic cost doxycycline 100mg generic viagra spain viagra 100mg rating zithromax pack buy 40 mg lisinopril 42 400 mg wellbutrin sr diflucan 50 mg philippines online viagra business buy 1 diflucan pill 200 mg cialis india cialis dosage 10mg augmentin 125 mg prospect Cialis 5 mg Washington cialis 5mg take 4 viagra online affidabile nexium 20 mg nedir nexium generic 40 mg augmentin 75 mg diferencia viagra generico viagra online.it strattera 100mg cost levitra online kopen medikament levitra 10 mg forum glucophage 500mg doxycycline 50 mg image generic cialis names zithromax 250 mg filmtabletten lisinopril 10 mg take lisinopril 10 mg viagra online ny levitra online singapore zovirax 200 mg suspension periactin 4mg tablets zoloft tic disorders lexapro generic version buy cialis singapore online cialis canadian harga zovirax 200 mg 5mg cialis daily viagra 50mg cost celebrex 200 mg medication nexium generic buy propecia 5mg break cialis 5 mg pt celebrex 200 mg indicaciones generic nexium 2012 zovirax tabletter 800 mg cialis china order levitra 15 mg buy nolvadex buy cheapest propecia us cialis 100 mg forum generic valtrex buy viagra online prednisone 5mg reviews levitra dose 5 mg zovirax generic uk metformin 500 mg order lexapro 10 mg success zithromax buy generic cialis usp 40mg zithromax online us cheap cialis black generic doxycycline hyclate viagra online blue 20 mg cialis coupons cialis 2 20mg pills cialis cost online cheap kamagra uk lexapro 20 mg controlled doxycycline mono 150mg generic wellbutrin sr zoloft order canada cialis 20 mg efectos hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg dosage shop levitra 5mg tesco levitra online viagra online 150mg zoloft 250 mg dosage miglior viagra generico viagra powder order efectos celebrex 200 mg levitra 20mg filmtabletten doxycycline 50mg dosage viagra generico espanha wellbutrin sr 100 mg buy priligy lexapro 0.50 mg cialis 20mg 8x levitra 10 mg nedir buy propecia slovakia generic priligy safe lisinopril eg 5 mg hydrochlorothiazide pms 12.5 mg doxycycline 20 mg yeast cialis nongeneric levitra 10 mg medicine lisinopril 10 mg mexico nexium 20 mg biverkningar buy antibiotic bactrim canada generic cialis zovirax 800 mg dosage online levitra rx cipro registration online cheapest levitra prices cialis 20 mg prostatectomia prednisone cats online lisinopril 5 mg pill safe buying viagra 500 mg of valtrex viagra philippines online doxycycline mono 100 mg fungsi erythromycin 400mg viagra sale online cialis 20mg original testberichte viagra 100mg doxycycline online paypal viagra 100mg preis 4 40mg nolvadex generic strattera available erythromycin 250 mg bp generic cialis tabs buy propecia bangkok pattaya viagra buying 2011 generic zoloft mg buy nolvadex singapore cheap viagra search ordering real viagra Cialis 20mg 60 Tabs their generic propecia buy zithromax 250 mg cheap cialis uae lisinopril 10 mg w 929 zovirax generic dosage metformin 500 mg infertility cialis generic fast levitra 10mg buy 10mg lexapro wellbutrin switching lexapro generic celebrex generic yet levitra bucodispersable 5 mg viagra deutchland online medicament cialis 10 mg overnight cheap viagra propecia canada online buy propecia fsa order propecia uk lasix 20 mg diuretico priligy online kaufen generic lexapro 2012 price generic zithromax chlamydia xenical 120 mg 84 cap clomid 12.5mg zovirax dosage mg buy propecia belgium clomid online without canova 50mg viagra zoloft 50 mg erowid nexium generic availability lexapro generic compare lasix 500 mg online generic brand nexium kamagra 100 mg pills cheaper 500mg viagra wellbutrin 150 mgs generic viagra compare flagyl er 400 mg diflucan 50 mg breastfeeding generic viagra issues nexium 40mg malaysia viagra 50mg chats clomid pct 50mg pret viagra 50mg lasix generic drug levitra 5 mg bayer order xenical uk 20mg paxil zoloft doxycycline accord 200mg viagra online oslo buy strattera uk hydrochlorothiazide online canada erythromycin bs 500 mg nexium generic alternatives cialis buy london wellbutrin tablets 75mg purchase viagra 50 mg wellbutrin generic target obat zithromax 200 mg prednisone 50 mg novo online cialis risks diflucan 50 mg cp 10mg of levitra buy viagra zimbabwe propranolol 160 mg migraine augmentin 12h 200 mg prescription viagra 50mg generico do levitra zoloft 1mg glucophage generic metformin propecia online apotheke buy cialis australia dosis metformin 500 mg order diflucan online diflucan liquid buy cialis 5mg eurim cialis 40mgvs20mg augmentin 1000 mg xr valtrex 1000 mg online online lexapro prices clomid 100mg bijsluiter buy levitra packs generic periactin buy doxycycline buy singapore cheap soft cialis viagra online rischi cialis india 5mg notice celebrex 200mg order doxycycline hydrochloride nexium 40 mg polska nolvadex online buy prednisone taper 2.5mg cheap cialis website 40 mg cialis ed cheaper synthroid 5 mg viagra enough pfizer zoloft 100mg preise levitra 20mg 20 mg levitra viagra buying viagra shanghai cialis online only zoloft 50 mg gravidanza levitra 20mg kosten xenical 50mg buy viagra sydney propranolol 40 mg reviews lisinopril mgs order viagra cheapest xenical 120 mg formulation xenical online pharmacy celebrex 200 mg pills dangers 800 mg viagra cialis generico 100 generic viagra gb cheapest generic viagra 150 cialis 40mg online order propecia finasteride wellbutrin retard 300 mg generic strattera propranolol shanghai buy levitra 15mg oklahoma online viagra zoloft 50 mg packungsbeilage cialis 5 mg ansia siadocin doxycycline 100mg doxycycline 20 mg buy cheap viagra banglore nexium 20mg na cheap price valtrex cialis tabs 5mg nolvadex generic brand 100mg zoloft dosage bula propranolol 40mg lasix 40 mg posologie viagra generico sirve tetracycline kapsul 500 mg synthroid generic equal cialis tabletas 20 mg viagra kamagra online buy viagra sg propecia cost 5mg generic cialis cheapest nexium 10 mg colombia zithromax generic india cialis 2,5 mg generika valtrex 500 mg kullanimi phenergan tablets 25mg order levitra uk increase mg propecia generic viagra me wellbutrin dosage 200 mg buy clomid l viagra online rush generic cialis 2.5 mg. buy cheap levitra hydrochlorothiazide generics augmentin 625 mg overdose synthroid order online buy bulk nolvadex cytotec 200 mg prix viagra generico yahoo levitra 5 mg effect kamagra 100mg chewable cheap viagra dangers lisinopril 40 mg white 100 mgs of clomid lexapro generic coming generic lisinopril india 5mg cialis samples levitra precio generico xenical 120 mg ervaringen generic lexapro 2012 cost viagra 10 pills buy kegunaan celebrex 100 mg buy cialis 40online zoloft 25 mg insomnia buy viagra cipla buying cialis manila prednisone 20 mg taper cialis 50mg australia malaysia cialis 20mg 150mg viagra online lasix online buy buy lasix cheap half cialis 20mg cipro uti 250 mg valtrex buy uk buspar online kaufen cialis 5 mg romania generic female cialis zoloft dosage 250 mg comanda viagra online celebrex alternatives generic metformin er 1000 mg synthroid dosage 75 mg propecia online bestellen viagra generico resolve fake generic propecia purchase cytotec online prednisone 4 mg kg propecia and cheap online patika kamagra clomid 50 vs 100 mg discreetly buy viagra 150mg buy viagra viagra 20 mg fiyati brazilian generic viagra valtrex 500 mg indicaciones ordering lasix 100mg viagra cost valtrex 500mg cialis preis 20 mg glipizide metformin 5 500mg chinese cialis 800 mg propranolol 160 mg tablets generic levitra 2.5mg buy doxycycline bird buy kamagra ireland wellbutrin generic issues cheap synthroid coupon nexium 40 mg augmentin 1000 mg duo buy zoloft cheap levitra generico nome buy generic strattera generic valtrex doses lasix online australia nexium 20 mg 14 tablet kamagra online prodaja cheap viagra seoul tadalafil cialis 80mg augmentin 1000 mg fiyat 14 doxycycline antibiotic 100mg amoxil 50 mg viagra 100mg story viagra 50mg suppository doxycycline 75 mg 30 days generic medication propecia buy lisinopril 40 mg msds doxycycline 25 mg doxycycline mgd vanzari viagra 50mg viagra tabs online generic prednisone walmart viagra online overseas strattera 40 mg preis cipro dosage 500 mg generic propecia finasteride prednisone 20 mg appetite buy lexapro fast generic cialis affiliate generic cialis cost viagra online mumbai nexium 80 mg daily buy propecia generic viagra árak 25 mg lexapro 5 mg prise lisinopril 10 mg price cialis 10 mg use bactrim 500 mg bula lasix 25 mg 30 cpr cialis generic 2.5 mg viagra online atlantic prednisone 5mg info nexium 40 mg infusion dosis augmentin 250 mg xenical orlistat generic cytotec bh mg thuoc cialis 20mg cialis order paypal 25 mg topiramate wellbutrin clomid borderline fsh dosage viagra 50mg iui 100mg clomid generic levitra dangerous cheap viagra 4u lexapro 10 mg recreational 20 mg nolvadex ed generic for xenical
Home BoB Documents MLBPA v. Steve Garvey

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 523 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA v. Steve Garvey PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 12
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Court Ruling   
Tuesday, 19 June 2001 12:00

MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL PLAYERS ASSOCIATION
v.
Steve GARVEY


532 U.S. 1015 (2001)

PER CURIAM.
The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit here rejected an arbitrator's factual findings and then resolved the merits of the parties' dispute instead of remanding the case for further arbitration proceedings. Because the court's determination conflicts with our cases limiting review of an arbitrator's award entered pursuant to an agreement between an employer and a labor organization and prescribing the appropriate remedy where vacation of the award is warranted, we grant the petition for a writ of certiorari and reverse. . . . .

[In the late 1980s, arbitrators found collusion by the Major League Baseball Clubs (Clubs) in the market for free-agent services and damages to the players represented by the petitioner, Major League Baseball Players Association (Association). The Association and Clubs entered into a Global Settlement Agreement (Agreement), which established a $280 million fund to be distributed to injured players. The Association also designed a "Framework" to evaluate the individual player's claims.]
 
The Framework provided that players could seek an arbitrator's review of the distribution plan. The arbitrator would determine "'only whether the approved Framework and the criteria set forth therein have been properly applied in the proposed Distribution Plan.'" Garvey v. Roberts, 203 F.3d 580, 583 (9th Cir. 2000) (Garvey I). The Framework set forth factors to be considered in evaluating players' claims, as well as specific requirements for lost contract-extension claims. Such claims were cognizable "'only in those cases where evidence exists that a specific offer of an extension was made by a club prior to collusion only to thereafter be withdrawn when the collusion scheme was initiated.'" Id., at 584.
 
Respondent Steve Garvey, a retired, highly regarded first baseman, submitted a claim for damages of approximately $3 million. He alleged that his contract with the San Diego Padres was not extended to the 1988 and 1989 seasons due to collusion. The Association rejected Garvey's claim in February 1996, because he presented no evidence that the Padres actually offered to extend his contract. Garvey objected, and an arbitration hearing was held. He testified that the Padres offered to extend his contract for the 1988 and 1989 seasons and then withdrew the offer after they began colluding with other teams. He presented a June 1996 letter from Ballard Smith, Padres' President and CEO from 1979 to 1987, stating that, before the end of the 1985 season, Smith offered to extend Garvey's contract through the 1989 season, but that the Padres refused to negotiate with Garvey thereafter due to collusion.
 
The arbitrator denied Garvey's claim, after seeking additional documentation from the parties. In his award, he explained that "'[t]here exists ... substantial doubt as to the credibility of the statements in the Smith letter.'" Id. at 586. . . . .
 
Garvey moved in Federal District Court to vacate the arbitrator's award, alleging that the arbitrator violated the Framework by denying his claim. The District Court denied the motion.  [The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed by a divided vote, holding that review of the merits of the arbitrator's award was warranted in this case, because the arbitrator "'dispensed his own brand of industrial justice.'" Id. at 589.] . . . . [I]n the court's view, the arbitrator's refusal to credit Smith's letter was "inexplicable" and "border[ed] on the irrational" . .. Id. at 590. . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed and remanded with directions to vacate the award.

The District Court then remanded the case to the arbitration panel for further hearings, and Garvey appealed. The Court of Appeals, again by a divided vote, explained that Garvey I established that "the conclusion that Smith made Garvey an offer and subsequently withdrew it because of the collusion scheme was the only conclusion that the arbitrator could draw from the record in the proceedings." Garvey II (unpublished). . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed the District Court and directed that it remand the case to the arbitration panel with instructions to enter an award for Garvey in the amount he claimed.

* * *

Judicial review of a labor-arbitration decision pursuant to such an agreement is very limited. Courts are not authorized to review the arbitrator's decision on the merits despite allegations that the decision rests on factual errors or misinterprets the parties' agreement. Paperworkers v. Misco, Inc., 484 U.S. 29, 36 (1987). We recently reiterated that if an "'arbitrator is even arguably construing or applying the contract and acting within the scope of his authority,' the fact that 'a court is convinced he committed serious error does not suffice to overturn his decision.'" It is only when the arbitrator strays from interpretation and application of the agreement and effectively "dispense [s] his own brand of industrial justice" that his decision may be unenforceable. When an arbitrator resolves disputes regarding the application of a contract, and no dishonesty is alleged, the arbitrator's "improvident, even silly, factfinding" does not provide a basis for a reviewing court to refuse to enforce the award. Misco, 484 U.S. at 39.
 
In discussing the courts' limited role in reviewing the merits of arbitration awards, we have stated that "'courts ... have no business weighing the merits of the grievance [or] considering whether there is equity in a particular claim.'" Id. at 37. When the judiciary does so, "it usurps a function which ... is entrusted to the arbitration tribunal." Consistent with this limited role, we said in Misco that "[e]ven in the very rare instances when an arbitrator's procedural aberrations rise to the level of affirmative misconduct, as a rule the court must not foreclose further proceedings by settling the merits according to its own judgment of the appropriate result." 484 U.S. at 40-41, n. 10. That step, we explained, "would improperly substitute a judicial determination for the arbitrator's decision that the parties bargained for" in their agreement. Ibid. Instead, the court should "simply vacate the award, thus leaving open the possibility of further proceedings if they are permitted under the terms of the agreement." Ibid.

To be sure, the Court of Appeals here recited these principles, but its application of them is nothing short of baffling. The substance of the court's discussion reveals that it overturned the arbitrator's decision because it disagreed with the arbitrator's factual findings, particularly those with respect to credibility. The Court of Appeals, it appears, would have credited Smith's 1996 letter, and found the arbitrator's refusal to do so at worst "irrational" and at best "bizarre." Garvey I, 203 F.3d at 590-591. But even "serious error" on the arbitrator's part does not justify overturning his decision, where, as here, he is construing a contract and acting within the scope of his authority. Misco, supra, at 38.

In Garvey II, the court clarified that Garvey I both rejected the arbitrator's findings and went further, resolving the merits of the parties' dispute based on the court's assessment of the record before the arbitrator. For that reason, the court found further arbitration proceedings inappropriate. But again, established law ordinarily precludes a court from resolving the merits of the parties' dispute on the basis of its own factual determinations, no matter how erroneous the arbitrator's decision. Misco, supra, at 40, n. 10. Even when the arbitrator's award may properly be vacated, the appropriate remedy is to remand the case for further arbitration proceedings. Misco, supra, at 40. The dissent suggests that the remedy described in Misco is limited to cases where the arbitrator's errors are procedural. (Opinion of STEVENS, J.). Misco did involve procedural issues, but our discussion regarding the appropriate remedy was not so limited. If a remand is appropriate even when the arbitrator's award has been set aside for "procedural aberrations" that constitute "affirmative misconduct," it follows that a remand ordinarily will be appropriate when the arbitrator simply made factual findings that the reviewing court perceives as "irrational." The Court of Appeals usurped the arbitrator's role by resolving the dispute and barring further proceedings, a result at odds with this governing law.

For the foregoing reasons, the Court of Appeals erred in reversing the order of the District Court denying the motion to vacate the arbitrator's award, and it erred further in directing that judgment be entered in Garvey's favor. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted, the judgment of the Court of Appeals is reversed, and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

It is so ordered.

Justice GINSBURG, concurring in part and concurring in the judgment.

Justice STEVENS, dissenting.

[Separate opinions are omitted]

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?