revia perth australia suhagra fast usa online pharmacy uk tamoxifen skelaxin discounts codes baclofen on line pharmacy tamoxifen ebewe 20 mg side effects can you buy altace further discount order clonidine medication by mail cheapest metoclopramide in the uk cipro tablets crush cialis vs viagra forum comments daily cialis better than viagra buy generic aleve with bonus valtrex interactions other drugs buy sinemet 275 free viagra sample by mail secure hydrochlorothiazide uk brand name zyrtec uses medication what does sominex contain cheap allinclusive holidays for 2008 bystolic dosage maximum diovan hct manufacturer coupon cafergot india zyrtec australia hydroxyzine dosage best drugstore makeup remover wipes for acne prone skin ordering depakote canada compare prices kamagra oral jelly online sale of revatio pet meds online canada purchase cefixime how to get betapace drug zyrtec generic release date buy cheap dvds online australia bupropion generic cheap costs can you buy cytotec tablets alli wanted online review buying proventil blue oval pill vgr 100 where to buy liv 52 uk cozaar dosage 100mg arimidex vs nolvadex vs clomid lithium dose bipolar 2 anafranil in croatia pfizer zyvox assistance program eligible prevacid 40 mg pharmacy prednisone 1 mg price femara pct buy amazon thunder acai pure reviews best price for real benicar artane for purchase where to buy clomid online safely prescription asacol rx where to buy benzaclin online reviews on lopid buy beconase aq boots pharmacy clomid comprar aldactone prescription effects interactions zyban prices seroquel 100 mg tabletten what does coreg treat safe buy celadrin online jia yi jian ireland discontinued use of depo provera rosuvastatin noprescrition needed usa online pharmacy levoxyl price comparison buy retino a cream 0 05 no prescription planete pharmacie london why has orlistat been discontinued vente de nootropil au quebec inderal la 80 mg generic medrol online no prescription drugs pharmacy buy buy pulmicort hong kong generic flonase side effects high blood pressure low price exelon uk where to buy tetracycline for fish pharmacy what is the generic version of plavix alli capsules for sale acai berry diet now cleansing xenical buy cheap mebendazole side effects in children how to by roxithromycin online common side effects of sublingual nitroglycerin over the counter generic avapro cephalexin canada head office what does ampicillin do for acne star wars grand florida alliance generic detrol usa pharmacy nitrofurantoin mono mac 100mg caps used treat pain pills for back pain how to take orlistat lesofat purchase citalopram 20mg diovan ordering no prescription buy misoprostol online uk precio cymbalta 60 mg mexico safe cialis professional buy levitra pas cher italie florida zofran fastest mentax uk delivery actos with american express is it safe to order indinavir generic brand for zofran geriforte tablets himalaya what is the classification of rocaltrol cyklokapron sale where can i order roxithromycin what is the classification for atarax espn mayne event viagra fast roxithromycin delivery discount canadian pharmacy sominex india finpecia price rogaine 2 order canada mail order generic deltasone tetracycline for dogs uti can i get finax voveran by mail order aqua ban men protonix canadian medications without prescription aciphex pills sweat order cialis soft from india without prescription what happens when you take cialis and viagra together generic female viagra buy canada sildenafilo citrato tabletes billig xenical online kaufen cipralex side effects in men buy ginette-35 pills allegra feltz wedding pictures what is pulmicort nebulizer used for viagra professional online usa liposafe with no rx generic from albenza roxithromycin online pharmacy buy amoxil without a subscription side effects of trazodone weight gain viagra online uk cheapest cialis mail order generic confido glycomet purchase in canada no prescription common side effects of duloxetine buy duphalac hong kong mobic tablets 15mg side effects where can i get compazine pills price increase hoodia diamox with paypal payment buy norvasc astrailia information on plavix tablets evista uk boots alli boots ireland buy aciclovir tablets usa buy premarin online overnight maxalt for daily use canada can you order diakoff buyers of phenergan canada brand amoxil rx generic proscar vs propecia lincocin buy canada detrol without script clozaril doses what does levitra 20 mg do how much does generic seroquel cost at walmart buy zithromax 100mg online seroflo side effects uk amitriptyline hcl generic name buy blopress online at canada pharmacy buy eurax new zealand online is it safe to order cystone jim thorpe stats football norvasc online buying comprar zebeta en argentina tadalafil generic reviews cialis junk mail bentyl 40mg levitra brand for sale where to buy rumalaya forte amaryl women buy us online pharmacy no prescription arjuna what is viagra jelly made of tamsulosin cap 0.4mg side effects nexium mexico no prescription all types menosan pills what is the generic name for diltiazem suhagra uk pharmacy what is zovirax ointment used for 100mg neurontin for anxiety lopressor iv push low dose naltrexone uk nhs buying serpina order abilify 30 mg generic organic pharmacy furosemide canadian source top 10 online toradol sites allegra d dosage children best online pharmacy generic digoxin pavitra rishta desi tashan written update cymbalta 30 mg tablet celebrex dose arthritis acai beeren online bestellen amaryl 1/1000 what is amlodipine besylate 10mg used for cheap cialis viagra tell viagra genuine seroflo price kytril for sale philippines what is aciclovir tablets 200mg buying eldepryl in manchester flovent where to get where can i buy tofranil alli weight control pills www.assessrx.com lamictal sale just nolva for pct nolvadex new zealand is there a generic for zyvox best place buy viagra online uk forum order buy discount advair diskus get elimite toronto over the counter diflucan in the uk where can you buy acai berry juice nor haykakan filmer online low price procardia uk purchase desyrel on line in usa discount buspar otc best deal on cialis canadian pill canadian drug laws penalties v-gel online coupon code prostate pills avodart what is prednisolone pills used for what will lipitor generic cost ceftin generico online online pharmacy rocaltrol where can i buy eltroxin prominent coumadin ridge lamisil without rx buy prazosin bulk cardura tablets for sale amitriptyline dosage insomnia recall on lipitor in canada depakote pills buy rosuvastatin side effects weight gain buy genuine hoodia uk buy terramycin dogs online cheap genuine zyprexa online pantoprazole 20 mg 40 mg how much does korean red ginseng cost do over the counter erectile dysfunction pills work elimite cost without insurance online prescriptions thailand side effects of zantac baby sleeping pills without doctors prescription does promethazine pills get you high buy advair diskus tablets canada strattera 25 mg street price zoloft pharmacy zyban online australia purchase isoptin online nexium coupons and discounts where can i get kamagra oral jelly pills rumalaya where can i buy it air max 1 leopard size 4 delivery plendil without paypal non prescription minomycin buy generic ceftin cheap nexium user reviews is mail order valtrex safe buy voltaren emulgel australia brand aceon for sale spring valley antioxidant support acai reviews how long for singulair to get out of system generic uroxatral medication hyzaar wanted online review there generic bentyl buy diamox in ireland generic snovitra super power us carbozyne sale india online buy lotrisone without buy alesse 21 online canadian pharmacy sex power tablet in india buy propecia hong kong cost of prevacid for infants buy paxil no prescription fast delivery is the uk law on drugs right zanaflex generic for side effects of taking metformin for pcos effexor xr generic release date buy prozac caplets online usa apcalis sx uses medication what drug category is famvir retin a micro 0 1 gel prec,o online cialis reviews buy revatio pills in the canada insulin resistance symptoms in children what does of doxycycline to cure chlamydia is it illegal to order generic benfotiamine buy pain pills online forum viagra without prescriptions in usa where to buy inderal drugs online nexium discount coupons australia what is parietal lobe do the online drugstore propecia buy brand viagra online in usa nike air max 1 black leopard ebay brafix coupon code how to take levlen pills what does seroquel look like where can i get retino-a cream 0,05 cipla india pharmaceutical azulfidine uses medication tenormin prix en pharmacie en france does alli at boots work phone in order for methotrexate medrol prescription information generic nitroglycerin for sale on line erectile dysfunction drugs xm radio ad can calcium carbonate cause weight gain which is best viagra cialis or levitra can buy viagra jelly online discover ireland gb cheapest levitra online uk diflucan 10 mg ml what is ashwagandha used for get adalat toronto buy januvia australia sinemet brands india buy xenical quick where to buy yagara in canada safely buy doxycycline online no prescription usa zanaflex buy mexico minomycin pills sweat buy menosan online overnight buy cheap kamagra online uk purchase hydrochlorothiazide online no prescription celebrex 100 mg pret what is topamax good for haldol tablets dose generic for advair diskus 1000 50 buy ashwagandha no prescription trazodone no prrescription lariam without prescription where can i get claritin where to buy nolvadex forum estrace medication women nymphomax canada overnight delivery i pill estrace website how to by robaxin online kamagra made in india office sales cialis preise vantin online pay paypal speman 40 mg dose side effects of hyzaar medication nootropil ships from india clarithromycin side effects nhs what is the drug precose does aldactone cause weight loss costco pharmacy imuran price discount canadian pharmacy liposafe insulin resistance symptoms dark skin i pill danazol website how to use nitroglycerin transdermal patches calan canadian pharmacy bactrim tablets for children revatio sale cialis prescription glyset online cheap cephalexin keflex side effects cheap septilin uk safe buy trimox online cytotec cheap india pharmacy ordering medications online without prescriptions lynoral coupon code on line drugs online pharmacy uk unisom where coumadin initial voveran results forum how to use fucidin cytotec dose missed abortion order speman cheap prilosec nexium lawsuit where to buy revatio with mastercard florinef without prescription miami prednisone withdrawal in dogs symptoms methotrexate online in usa septilin for sale philippines comprar caverta original en madrid prednisone from mims compare prices hytrin buy brahmi online cheap buy tricor 10 cytoxan tablets purchase on line using cialis and viagra together buy lederle minocin how much is emsam tablets female viagra effects had where to spend honor points alliance cataclysm lithium shortage 2011 what does allegra d twelve hour look like buy retino-a cream 0,05 online pharmacy accutane results how long generic zithromax z pak goes you buy shuddha guggulu canadian buy speman 40 free coupon for glycomet common side effects of cozaar order viagra online with amex where purchase apcalis sx weather vigra norway discount canadian pharmacy serophene wellbutrin buy online uk ordering ralista allegra d canada pharmacy where to buy water pills in toronto generic didronel to buy flovent in uk voltaren retard 75 mg bijsluiter cheap propecia uk can i order cephalexin no prescription in the usa online without buy cheap aricept order alphagan online no prescription with a echeck combivent drugs feldene medication for dogs ginseng pills for energy can buy viagra singapore lista de nombres de pastillas para la ereccion pharmacy 365 kamagra canadian pharmacy cheap amoxil meloxicam tabletas 15 mg dosis how to take eldepryl how to order ginseng wellbutrin canada overnight delivery trazodone online canadian prevacid 30 mg over the counter price carbozyne order canada what color is levitra pill can you buy diclofenac over the counter fluoxetine 40 mg capsules a107 vente cialis montreal exelon medication parkinson;s what does depakote do for migraines order skelaxin pill generic capoten switzerland indocin generic 2013 drugs actonel drug oversea get zithromax no prescription how much is augmentin without insurance bystolic purchase buy fluconazole tablets ordering nizoral mexico viagra sample pack buy betapace with visa nizoral antifungal drug us online pharmacy no prescription lisinopril buy celexa overseas culturismo italiano andrea nuccitelli zyprexa cost omnicef online australia liv 52 cheap uk buy inderal 20 danazol mg tablet pyridium australia pharmacy prozac nation quotes hemingway biaxin in italia advanced recreational trimix course luvox max dose zanaflex side effects weight gain where can i buy hoodia over the counter best generic coumadin review the chepest zithromax kamagra acai sales co uk viagra over counter london cheap genuine erexor online side effects of amitriptyline hcl 50 mg duphalac online how to by tricor online cabergoline effects men walmart prescriptions no insurance how to by baclofen online metoclopramide canada acquistare lipothin in italia generic prograf in usa vpxl online order how much will levothroid cost best pharmacy to order eurax where to transplant amaryllis outdoor how much is generic valtrex med cab valtrex research grade sominex order cytotec overnight how long will it take for pyridium to work zithromax antibiotic without prescription mastercard n antibiotics to buy online canada ginseng visage cytotec overseas get slim acai reviews canadian online pharmacy for cialis soft buy atorlip-5 in singapore tofranil for sale philippines brand coreg buy famvir pharmacy omnicef for men in usa premarin mg buy alli birth control online australia crestor.com minocycline wanted online review
Home BoB Documents MLBPA v. Steve Garvey

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 822 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA v. Steve Garvey PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 12
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Court Ruling   
Tuesday, 19 June 2001 12:00

MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL PLAYERS ASSOCIATION
v.
Steve GARVEY


532 U.S. 1015 (2001)

PER CURIAM.
The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit here rejected an arbitrator's factual findings and then resolved the merits of the parties' dispute instead of remanding the case for further arbitration proceedings. Because the court's determination conflicts with our cases limiting review of an arbitrator's award entered pursuant to an agreement between an employer and a labor organization and prescribing the appropriate remedy where vacation of the award is warranted, we grant the petition for a writ of certiorari and reverse. . . . .

[In the late 1980s, arbitrators found collusion by the Major League Baseball Clubs (Clubs) in the market for free-agent services and damages to the players represented by the petitioner, Major League Baseball Players Association (Association). The Association and Clubs entered into a Global Settlement Agreement (Agreement), which established a $280 million fund to be distributed to injured players. The Association also designed a "Framework" to evaluate the individual player's claims.]
 
The Framework provided that players could seek an arbitrator's review of the distribution plan. The arbitrator would determine "'only whether the approved Framework and the criteria set forth therein have been properly applied in the proposed Distribution Plan.'" Garvey v. Roberts, 203 F.3d 580, 583 (9th Cir. 2000) (Garvey I). The Framework set forth factors to be considered in evaluating players' claims, as well as specific requirements for lost contract-extension claims. Such claims were cognizable "'only in those cases where evidence exists that a specific offer of an extension was made by a club prior to collusion only to thereafter be withdrawn when the collusion scheme was initiated.'" Id., at 584.
 
Respondent Steve Garvey, a retired, highly regarded first baseman, submitted a claim for damages of approximately $3 million. He alleged that his contract with the San Diego Padres was not extended to the 1988 and 1989 seasons due to collusion. The Association rejected Garvey's claim in February 1996, because he presented no evidence that the Padres actually offered to extend his contract. Garvey objected, and an arbitration hearing was held. He testified that the Padres offered to extend his contract for the 1988 and 1989 seasons and then withdrew the offer after they began colluding with other teams. He presented a June 1996 letter from Ballard Smith, Padres' President and CEO from 1979 to 1987, stating that, before the end of the 1985 season, Smith offered to extend Garvey's contract through the 1989 season, but that the Padres refused to negotiate with Garvey thereafter due to collusion.
 
The arbitrator denied Garvey's claim, after seeking additional documentation from the parties. In his award, he explained that "'[t]here exists ... substantial doubt as to the credibility of the statements in the Smith letter.'" Id. at 586. . . . .
 
Garvey moved in Federal District Court to vacate the arbitrator's award, alleging that the arbitrator violated the Framework by denying his claim. The District Court denied the motion.  [The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed by a divided vote, holding that review of the merits of the arbitrator's award was warranted in this case, because the arbitrator "'dispensed his own brand of industrial justice.'" Id. at 589.] . . . . [I]n the court's view, the arbitrator's refusal to credit Smith's letter was "inexplicable" and "border[ed] on the irrational" . .. Id. at 590. . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed and remanded with directions to vacate the award.

The District Court then remanded the case to the arbitration panel for further hearings, and Garvey appealed. The Court of Appeals, again by a divided vote, explained that Garvey I established that "the conclusion that Smith made Garvey an offer and subsequently withdrew it because of the collusion scheme was the only conclusion that the arbitrator could draw from the record in the proceedings." Garvey II (unpublished). . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed the District Court and directed that it remand the case to the arbitration panel with instructions to enter an award for Garvey in the amount he claimed.

* * *

Judicial review of a labor-arbitration decision pursuant to such an agreement is very limited. Courts are not authorized to review the arbitrator's decision on the merits despite allegations that the decision rests on factual errors or misinterprets the parties' agreement. Paperworkers v. Misco, Inc., 484 U.S. 29, 36 (1987). We recently reiterated that if an "'arbitrator is even arguably construing or applying the contract and acting within the scope of his authority,' the fact that 'a court is convinced he committed serious error does not suffice to overturn his decision.'" It is only when the arbitrator strays from interpretation and application of the agreement and effectively "dispense [s] his own brand of industrial justice" that his decision may be unenforceable. When an arbitrator resolves disputes regarding the application of a contract, and no dishonesty is alleged, the arbitrator's "improvident, even silly, factfinding" does not provide a basis for a reviewing court to refuse to enforce the award. Misco, 484 U.S. at 39.
 
In discussing the courts' limited role in reviewing the merits of arbitration awards, we have stated that "'courts ... have no business weighing the merits of the grievance [or] considering whether there is equity in a particular claim.'" Id. at 37. When the judiciary does so, "it usurps a function which ... is entrusted to the arbitration tribunal." Consistent with this limited role, we said in Misco that "[e]ven in the very rare instances when an arbitrator's procedural aberrations rise to the level of affirmative misconduct, as a rule the court must not foreclose further proceedings by settling the merits according to its own judgment of the appropriate result." 484 U.S. at 40-41, n. 10. That step, we explained, "would improperly substitute a judicial determination for the arbitrator's decision that the parties bargained for" in their agreement. Ibid. Instead, the court should "simply vacate the award, thus leaving open the possibility of further proceedings if they are permitted under the terms of the agreement." Ibid.

To be sure, the Court of Appeals here recited these principles, but its application of them is nothing short of baffling. The substance of the court's discussion reveals that it overturned the arbitrator's decision because it disagreed with the arbitrator's factual findings, particularly those with respect to credibility. The Court of Appeals, it appears, would have credited Smith's 1996 letter, and found the arbitrator's refusal to do so at worst "irrational" and at best "bizarre." Garvey I, 203 F.3d at 590-591. But even "serious error" on the arbitrator's part does not justify overturning his decision, where, as here, he is construing a contract and acting within the scope of his authority. Misco, supra, at 38.

In Garvey II, the court clarified that Garvey I both rejected the arbitrator's findings and went further, resolving the merits of the parties' dispute based on the court's assessment of the record before the arbitrator. For that reason, the court found further arbitration proceedings inappropriate. But again, established law ordinarily precludes a court from resolving the merits of the parties' dispute on the basis of its own factual determinations, no matter how erroneous the arbitrator's decision. Misco, supra, at 40, n. 10. Even when the arbitrator's award may properly be vacated, the appropriate remedy is to remand the case for further arbitration proceedings. Misco, supra, at 40. The dissent suggests that the remedy described in Misco is limited to cases where the arbitrator's errors are procedural. (Opinion of STEVENS, J.). Misco did involve procedural issues, but our discussion regarding the appropriate remedy was not so limited. If a remand is appropriate even when the arbitrator's award has been set aside for "procedural aberrations" that constitute "affirmative misconduct," it follows that a remand ordinarily will be appropriate when the arbitrator simply made factual findings that the reviewing court perceives as "irrational." The Court of Appeals usurped the arbitrator's role by resolving the dispute and barring further proceedings, a result at odds with this governing law.

For the foregoing reasons, the Court of Appeals erred in reversing the order of the District Court denying the motion to vacate the arbitrator's award, and it erred further in directing that judgment be entered in Garvey's favor. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted, the judgment of the Court of Appeals is reversed, and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

It is so ordered.

Justice GINSBURG, concurring in part and concurring in the judgment.

Justice STEVENS, dissenting.

[Separate opinions are omitted]

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?