best site to buy betapace generic advair diskus inhaler fluticasone can you take lisinopril daily buy colospa online with mastercard cheapest zantac tablets uk vpxl sublingual dosage keppra side effects rxlist voltaren gel dosage for back pain belize pharmacy license can we trust kytril online comprar viagra generico online espan~a minocycline dose for sinus infection biaxin legal in england where can you buy alligator jerky purchase neurontin gabapentin zentel tablets 400mg side effects of tegretol buy robaxin online us no prescription 100mg ml ampicillin stock can depakote cause weight gain buy provera neurontin 100mg uses altace order on web where to buy menosan does zyrtec come in generic form prilosec paypal what is aldactone prescribed for the new order alliance best place to buy zenegra without a prescription how to get cialis jelly drug tetracycline best price generic combivent malaysia discount proventil mg metronidazole side effects nhs purchase nitroglycerin in canada is there an over the counter equivalent to bactroban long term side effects of azulfidine is emsam legal in uk cialis tabletas propranolol smoking percocet effects my glyset coupons post cycle therapy brand advair diskus mentat ds syrup drug class billig vantin online kaufen doxycycline recent price increase generic lasix online online pharmacy uk ditropan generic periactin weight gain metformin glucophage weight loss how long do i have to take lipitor cytoxan online canadian pharmacy zantac plendil cost comparison purchasing actos online uk best price prilosec 42 count cheap dostinex pills generic aspirin safe purchase pure acai berry pills actonel on the internet flovent pharmacy coupon acheter ginseng rouge paris withdrawal from luvox side effects where to get acai berries in stores where purchase nymphomax what is prilosec otc good for viagra professional without a script flomax mail order india vytorin medication generic furosemide india where do i buy finax brand viagra birth control online australia ordering levitra professional samples cheap forzest tablet sale revatio generic available what is lisinopril for best reminyl prices cialis al miglior prezzo is there a drug comparative to pyridium flovent for sale usa banned drugs from india act over the counter fertility pills canada diclofenac generic cheap costs buy requip 20 best price for real luvox januvia u.s. sales 2010 himalaya purim price in india purchase cialis on line in the uk ambien walrus toothpaste for dinner cheap minocycline Purchase crestor 5mg tablets avalide canada head office where to buy alligator meat in dallas zanaflex comprar free printable lexapro coupons how to buy alesse can i buy a visa gift card with paypal where can i buy lamisil cream himplasia mg tablet is finasteride available over the counter mexican flagyl brand levitra on line buy doxycycline no rx flagyl australia companies only viagra150 sildenafilo cinfa voltaren spain over counter mens health natural viagra how to take metformin tablets bactroban medication where to buy brand levitra pill shortage how much does prednisone cost at rite aid yasmin generic zarah prescription drug florinef how many benadryl can i take to get high what drug category is mevacor seroquel pills online in the usa remeron spain low cost bentyl is there a viagra equivalent for women motilium generico bula buy nizoral without a prescription from canadian pharmacy canadian nizagara tablet where do i buy zenegra how to by betapace online emsam from india diflucan coupons swanson water pills review buy lipothin 10 what type of medication is aldactone low price clonidine uk no prescription lioresal sale nolvadex on line no script celebrex mexico no prescription buy cheap generic avodart without generic motrin infant perrigo tretinoin cream 0.1 reviews where can i get maxaman comprar extendaquin en argentina amitriptyline where to buy finpecia sold over counter will reglan make you gain weight keppra online in usa maxalt generic canada comprar biaxin en argentina claritin ingredients antihistamine tegretol no prrescription buy medical pill buy lipitor what is cefadroxil drugs alesse birth control cause weight gain remeron 40 mg rx lotrisone cream discount code for betnovate cytotec for abortion side effects the online drugstore kamagra soft where can i purchase albendazole without a prescription with secure checkout? purchase generic lasix lopressor dosage tachycardia kaiser prescriptions by mail what is ciplox 500mg for chloramphenicol to buy in england thuoc medrol la thuoc gi rosuvastatin suppositories buy vantin order canada quiero comprar allopurinol diclofenac gel prescribing information order prinivil cheap overseas pharmacy no prescription kamagra how to take ciplox does accutane help acne scars reliable kamagra supplier uk buy lisinopril without prescription from a canadian pharmacy med cab tricor mometasone furoate monohydrate nasal spray side effects fastest reglan uk delivery fluoxetine hydrochloride 40 mg side effects amoxil generic amoxicillin can women use viagra asacol pills are coming out whole comprar hyaluronic acid original en madrid cheap doxycyllin no prescription where to buy mirapex in canada safely zithromax from pharmacy where to get lopid pct linezolid zyvox antibiotic diclofenaco sodico 50 mg laboratorio chile albendazole over the counter usa effects buy amitriptyline inhaler canada online buy lotrisone order zanaflex barato floxin online overnight delivery view topic what is the generic drug for lamictal buy synthroid from india ibuprofen alcohol stomach pain i pill phenergan website best price retin-a ge buy cystone in ireland promethazine over counter substitute ditropan canada online no prescription generic yagara overnite shipping inderal 10 mg acyclovir no prescription needed keftab not generic buy zyban no prescription mail order drugs from canada legal revatio generic cheap costs cymbalta online no prescription overseas pharmacy no prescription eurax herbal viagra suppliers what is minomycin 50mg for can i buy acai berry in boots how come newhealthyman address doesnt work doxycycl hyc 50 mg for acne what types of premarin are there ranitidine syrup india walmart alliance ne top 10 online eldepryl sites cipla field call luvox cr for anxiety procardia pharmacy order can you buy zovirax over counter australia robaxin dosage oral buy isoptin mg depo provera trimestral onde comprar purchase suhagra speman cost is generic avodart available in usa shatavari from usa pharmacy avandamet mg buy tadacip cost canadian azithromycin tablets 500mg ip zithromax pills for sale proventil hfa 90 mcg inhaler coupon zentel tablets for deworming express care pharmacy in arizona danazol buy online ireland Purchase lexapro 10 mg online furosemide canada cost manufacturer aurochem axon zofran cost at walmart venlor for men in usa xenical stock update colchicine uk next day delivery buy exelon online safely how much will haldol cost digoxin over counter medication brand viagra pharmacy coupons is it safe to take metronidazole 500 mg while pregnant generic name for allopurinol aloprim blopress pas cher italie buy anafranil without a prescription tetracycline 10 mg cost why not allopurinol in acute gout alli coupons printable 2010 can i order provera no prescription in the usa purchase pulmicort respules do you need rx clonidine pharmacies american fork ut what does danazol treat order cialis 20 mg buy seroflo 100mg online what is ranitidine bismuth citrate cialis super active sale generic tadalafil silagra express canada canadian alliance for development initiatives and projects (cadip) cheapest entocort biaxin no prescription reviews rumalaya order by phone prescription drug doxycycline hyclate buy generic cialis fast shipping is plavix available over the counter canadian alliance of physiotherapy regulators address what does cozaar treat slow release metformin dosage generic sustiva no prescription purchase zithromax cheap antibiotic prescription tenormin without prescription miami qsymia fda label cardizem discount code dramamine drug classification order retino a cream 0 025 atarax tablets used for order rumalaya forte online uk generic plavix in usa accutane second course results buying zithromax minocycline overseas how does the drug xenical orlistat facilitate weight loss in humans online pharmacy compare accutane prescription macrodantin nitrofurantoin 50mg lithium side effects female viagra low dose birth control actoplus met from india diclofenac sr 100mg tablets genuine doxazosin 100mg buy malegra dxt boots pharmacy long term side effects of cialis professional medicine cephalexin treatment amoxil with no prescription mexico list of drugs that have sulfa generic actos canada pioglitazone can you order allegra products hours diclofenac gel cost without insurance buy bactroban nasal ointment mupirocin over the counter alternative to cymbalta lisinopril without a prescription buy vasodilan online amazon solu medrol 1000 mg side effects nizagara mexico leukeran doctors online best concetraption permethrin cats side effects where can i find dulcolax online sale of rosuvastatin ashwagandha to buy from europe valtrex generic online what are ciplox tablets used for zovirax lawsuit settlements zithromax online legally topamax sprinkle capsules dosage comprar tadacip pela internet feldene side effects weight gain arthritis treatment breakthrough buy citalopram tablets uk promethazine overdose how much malegra dxt online pharmacy uk where can i order levitra professional zyban for sale in the philippines diflucan dosage candida esophagitis tenormin next day what does hydrea do buy cheap generic cialis metformin 500mg er tab information is estrace better than premarin suhagra mg uk hoodia dose thyroxine levels low evecare 40mg how to use pravachol can i buy alphagan in canada ringworm medication for children pharmacy technician jobs in ireland la jolla discount pharmacy ximed buy brahmi online with mastercard generic liv 52 no prescription pharmacie de garde bruxelles uccle common side effects of benadryl metformin prices walmart motilium side effects weight gain lowest price lasix seroquel cheap prices order 10 erection packs viagra lasix tablets for weight loss prilosec otc shortage premarin buy on line tadacip shortage 2012 what does minocin do avalide ships from india purchase metoclopramide pills brand cialis tablets on line to buy yasmin boland libra where can i buy serophene cheap celebrex 40 mg allopurinol prescription uric acid drugs mirtazapine weight gain amaryllis belladonna bulbs for sale side effects of atrovent nasal spray how long does it take to get off pain pills orderpharma accutane reviews pills that get you high yahoo answers generic cymbalta usa pharmacy where to buy mentax zoot z-pack training bag 2010 ortho tri cyclen pharmacy mail order prescription medication without rx elimite pills how to by nymphomax online generic elocon overnite shipping cialis medications picture 80 mg of nexium online forum pharmacy purchase claritin brand amoxil legal in england aricept mg price zithromax dosage for uti over the counter starlix where can i order compazine buy serevent capsules generic for doxycycline hyclate sales 2012 cialis online pyridium ordering no prescription diamox rx liv overseas caverta tablets price how to order reglan buy forzest tablets online cipro side effects discount celebrex of canada buy procardia overseas best viagra alternatives over counter what can i do to make clomid more effective buy lady era in singapore otc lansoprazole dose brand digoxin for sale 1000 games for kids free ventolin 20mg tab what is hydrochlorothiazide side effects order terramycin online actos price japan drinking on metronidazole purchase aciclovir in australia phone in order for allegra where to buy viagra professional online without rx prometrium pills sweat proventil hfa price us lowest priced voltaren shatavari online forum zenegra overnight pharmacy paxil total sales antibiotic keflex cost over the counter drug sales data benzac direct pharmacy cat medication prednisolone keftab generic equivalent cheap metoclopramide no prescription medicine cleocin bayer crystal aspirin in canada aricept medication dose para que sirve el medicamento sertralina 50 mg buy cordarone 40 colospa 5mg tablets resources for flovent how to get finast drug zyprexa canada head office purchase viagra jelly in usa drugstore makeup brush cleanser canadian alliance terminals richmond bc directions viagra professional lowest price messi stats 2013 canada zoloft minocycline hcl 100mg reviews glucophage no prescription needed remeron not generic buy digoxin online overnight buy micronase from mexico online how long to get synthroid out of system is permethrin 5 available over the counter price of cefixime 400 mg para que sirve el prednisone 20 mg how to get vpxl order cialis super active 120 mg extra sex chromosome syndrome cardizem cd side effects weight gain walmart pharmacy synthroid what can you buy over the counter that works like viagra actoplus met online usa periactin pharmacies buy rogaine 2 mg online malegra fxt legal in england side effects of coming off lexapro 10 mg india augmentin price matrix blue pill red pill speech levitra super active online overnight shipping buy liv with no rx nova southeastern university pharmacy puerto rico lipitor 40 mg tablet picture zovirax cold sore cream prescription brahmi for sale usa shallaki sublingual dosage purchase cialis online cheap side effects of generic atacand dosage norvasc schedule drug side effects of prednisone for small dogs list of tesco stores selling anafranil vpxl overnight pharmacy diakof dosage instructions order paroxetine lowest price cafergot tablets 150 mg buy lisinopril 40 mg no prescription pharmacy mexico nitrofurantoin order aripiprazole (abilify) online buy apcalis sx uk viagra men vs. women uk version of keflex bentyl without insurance is mail order micronase safe diclofenac next day delivery no rx cephalexin online tofranil drug classification valtrex ordering no prescription buying synthroid how to order vytorin online ampicillin sulbactam viagra for women survey how to get high off citalopram how long does it take for singulair to work generic purim in usa trental 400 mg bula zetia cholesterol medicine side effects apcalis sx jelly cialis verified by visa uk depakote without a script rx saturday delivery levaquin medication interactions escrow refills hcg review prescriptions ceftin tablets buy generic assistance with cost of plavix what does strattera do to the brain can you buy remeron over the counter in germany how to use flonase for etd can buy betnovate over counter hoodia order online best tricor price citalopram online no prescription uk canadian tamsulosin dose for kidney stones generic version yasmin australia epivir-hbv for sale philippines over the counter pills to delay your period allopurinol medication class orlistat on the internet metformin pharmacy order can you get aristocort over the counter prometrium 100 review synthroid cost target geriforte syrup online uk haldol wikipedia espan~ol leading pharmacies in sri lanka prescription medicine for dog diarrhea buy seizure medication without prescription buy narcotics online no prescription cheap generic benicar can you buy antabuse over the counter online actonel cost comparison petzl myo rxp lithium vermox dosage recommended order birth control pills online uk buy confidom women condom proterium without prescription ventolin on the internet lamictal dose for seizures valtrex canada prices buy mebendazole overnight shipping antivert dosage motion sickness mark richman properties inc buy snovitra super power with paypal rumalaya liniment usa sale buy lioresal inhaler canada floxin on line for sale no script mexico diclofenac pharmacy overnight side effects taking viagra alcohol levitra professional without prescriptions to buy flovent in uk cialis sublingual online coupon code serious side effects of cymbalta tamoxifen buy usa pharmacie de garde bruxelles zaventem lamictal order online no prescription buy pain pills without script toprol xl online order paxil annual sales female cialis review seroquel xr dose for sleep buy prozac no prescription uk top 10 online venlor sites where is exelon patch metabolized cozaar phone orders average cost of prevacid vasotec tablets try viagra free sample actos comunicativos ejemplos where to purchase mentax where can i buy acai berry pills in the philippines buy acivir pills bulk buy tetracycline 100mg online minocycline online overnight buy arimidex cheaply prescription order lincocin online astelin over the counter cialis medicine lipitor prescription information order synthroid pills otc inhaler for asthma generic ciprofloxacin hydrochloride anxiety symptoms lump in throat cheap genuine prednisone online genuine cipro viagra price off egypt online drugs store viagra online kaufen paypal abana non perscription countries buy atorlip 5 no prescription what are the side effects of ashwagandha generic actos drugs dosage anavar pct hcg Purchase strattera 18 mg buy amaryllis bulbs bulk amoxil online lexapro generic available 2011 detrol rxlist rogaine 2 no prescription compare prices bupron sr buy uk why is there a shortage of bentyl side effects of tamoxifen 20 mg tamoxifen citrate tablets 20 mg sale retino-a cream 0,05 beat way to order dipyridamole what is fucidin drugs side effects of topamax tingling proventil generic albuterol generic periatin apcalis sx roche precio argentina topical triamcinolone side effects viagra professional on line no script diclofenac gel 1000 ml skelaxin discount card zestril dosage instructions dapoxetine tablets online purchase celebrex on line in india what is fluconazole used for lexapro vs citalopram weight gain buy amantadine 80 mg online buy accutane online canada free shipping female viagra free sample clomiphene citrate on the menstrual cycle purchase brand viagra in mexico order cialis super active on line uk finpecia medicine used hair loss isoniazid dosage forms buy tinidazole mg online non prescription prilosec where to get clothes like alli simpson where to astelin where to find alli in canada renova toilet paper case study analysis how to take nexium hp7 can your buy levitra super active in ireland canadian walmart pharmacy refill online generic from viagra soft cialis soft precio mexico normal results for clomiphene citrate challenge test cytotec limited india is it safe to order zaditor canadian drug ed buy lanoxin tablets online stromectol over the couter without a script buy albendazole fedex arimidex generic usa how much does decadron cost florida prometrium zenegra sale cheap online pharmacy buy minocycline no prescription
Home All Articles The Clemens Defamation Lawsuit: Litigation Marches On

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 780 guests online

Atom RSS

The Clemens Defamation Lawsuit: Litigation Marches On PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 9
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Patrick K. Thornton   
Tuesday, 13 May 2008 23:46
Clemens v McNamee

The following is a detailed analysis of the Clemens defamation lawsuit by Patrick K. Thornton. Thornton is a regular contributor to the Business of Sports Network. -- Maury Brown, Founder and President, Business of Sports Network

Baseball season has started heating up and as the national pastime heads for the all star break the Roger Clemens defamation lawsuit keeps plodding right along. Although there has been speculation that Clemens would drop his lawsuit against his former trainer Brian McNamee, no dismissal has been forthcoming. The lawsuit was filed in January and McNamee has not yet filed an answer to the petition filed by Clemens but instead chose to file a motion for summary judgment to have the case dismissed in its entirety and additionally a motion to disqualify Clemens lawyer, Rusty Hardin from the case.  The motion to disqualify Hardin was based on the premise that he also represented Clemens’ former teammate, Andy Pettitte.  The motion to disqualify was recently denied by the court so Hardin remains as counsel for Clemens.  The motion for summary judgment is still pending.  The defamation lawsuit is just beginning and could go on for as long as 2-3 years at the pace it is proceeding.

There has some who have called upon Clemens to drop the lawsuit against McNamee but there has been no indication he will do so.  Clemens lawyer, Rusty Hardin, has said, “Absolutely, there’s been no action to dismiss the lawsuit.”  In response, attorney Richard Emery, has stated: "First of all, I'm highly skeptical that Rusty and Roger will be smart enough to drop the suit, because they have not been smart enough to realize that was the best course,” "So I don't know why all of a sudden they would do what's best for themselves” Lawyers: Clemens not Dropping Defamation Suit, Houston Chronicle, May 2, 2008. Emery has given no indication he will back down from his continuous assault on Clemens character:

“We're preparing for a trial,"… "We will follow every lead concerning Roger's rather questionable reputation, including deposing all the women who claimed they have slept with him and members of his family and his wife as to their knowledge of his use of steroids…

"There have been a number of reports that Debbie knew about Roger's dalliances. And we certainly have to inquire whether that was the case.” id.

Hardin admitted his client was going through some rough times but noted the decision whether to drop the case rests with Clemens and not his lawyer.

Select Read More to see the rest of the analysis on the Clemens defamation lawsuit

Defendant McNamee’s Motion for Summary Judgment

McNamee has asked that the court dismiss the lawsuit filed by Clemens based on the following:

1. The court lacks personal jurisdiction over the defendant, (McNamee);

2. The present court is not the proper venue for Mr. Clemens’ lawsuit; and

3. The complaint fails to state a claim for defamation under the law.

The first two reasons are procedural in nature while the third is substantive and goes directly to the defamation lawsuit itself.  The motion for summary judgment filed by McNamee is twenty-five pages in length and can be viewed in its entirety (Defendant Motion to Dismiss (PDF)).

McNamee first asserts the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas has no jurisdiction over him personally because he is from the State of New York and does not have “sufficient contacts” with the State of Texas to allow the court to exercise personal jurisdiction over him.  If the court did grant McNamee’s motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction, Clemens would then be forced to re-file the action in a New York Court if he wanted to continue the lawsuit. 

Secondly, McNamee argued that even if the court does not dismiss the action for lack of jurisdiction, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas is the wrong venue for the lawsuit.  McNamee argues the case should be moved to New York because he does not reside in Texas and the facts which give rise to the lawsuit occurred in New York.  If the court fails to dismiss the action based on lack of personal jurisdiction, McNamee argues the case should be transferred to a New York court to continue the litigation. 

Finally, McNamee’s lawyers argued the case should be dismissed in its entirety based on several factors:

1.  The complaint fails to state a claim because the allegedly defamatory statements are absolutely privileged;

2.  The complaint fails to state a claim because it does not provide Defendant (McNamee) with sufficient notice of the allegedly defamatory statements, nor does it allege special damages; and  

3.  The complaint fails to state a claim because it asserts that McNamee was coerced to defame Clemens.

The court has several options when contemplating the motions.  It could dismiss the case on the basis of lack of personal jurisdiction.  This would again force Clemens to have to re-file the case.  The court could merely pass the case to a New York court and allow the case to be tried in Federal Court in New York.  Finally, the court could decide that Clemens does not have a case and dismiss all or a part of his complaint against McNamee.  This would be a major decision by the court and if the court dismissed the case on substantive grounds, Clemens could still appeal the court’s decision.  

The Admissibility of the Clemens Alleged Extramarital Affairs

Several interesting issues had popped up in the last few weeks and none more public than Clemens alleged affairs with several women.  What do these alleged affairs have to do with the defamation lawsuit he has brought against his former trainer?  Plenty, asserts Richard Emery, McNamee’s lawyer.  As the motion for summary judgment hangs in the balance, McNamee’s lawyers have made it clear they are going to pay “hardball” with Clemens. The recent allegations concerning Clemens’s alleged multiple affairs have been brought to light by McNamee’s lawyer Richard Emery.  (See Emery’s biography).  Emery has clearly indicated that he believes that the alleged affairs are “fair game” in the defamation lawsuit because Clemens has placed his reputation in controversy when he filed the lawsuit.

In a civil lawsuit, unlike a criminal case, an individual cannot assert their constitutionally protected Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination.  The plaintiff must give testimony in the form of a deposition prior to trial if requested by the defendant and it will most certainly be requested by McNamee’s lawyers in this case.  Clemens will be subject to questioning by McNamee’s lawyers in a deposition prior to trial and during the discovery phase of the lawsuit.

The recent allegations that Clemens had an affair with country star Mindy McCready beginning when she was fifteen years old, certainly did not help the Clemens lawsuit or his public persona.  McCready did not acknowledge the allegations as true but merely stated she could not deny the allegations.  After the McCready allegations, next came the allegations concerning an affair with Paulette Daley, the ex-wife of PGA Golfer John Daly, and finally an alleged affair with a former stripper from Detroit.  The Clemens camp was relatively silent on most of the allegations, only issuing a statement saying Clemens had known McCready for a long time but there was no sex.  Clemens lawyer, Rusty Hardin has stated:

"At no time did Roger engage in any kind of inappropriate or improper relationship with her. It is unfortunate that the Daily News has chosen to report anonymous allegations that are completely unfounded, have no basis in fact, and have nothing to do with Roger's baseball career or the issue of steroid use in baseball” Clemens involved with Daly's ex-wife, NBC Sports, May 1, 2008.

Paulette Daly has stated: "I know Roger, I consider him a good friend. That's all I'm comfortable saying” id.

Can all these allegations be admitted into evidence at the trial of the defamation case?  McNamee attorney, Richard Emery stated in an email to the Associated Press with regard to the alleged affairs, "If the case heads to trial and is not dismissed, as we feel it should be, we will be calling (McCready) as a witness”. id. Clemens did apologize without any specific references to the affairs stating:

"I believe my personal life has nothing to do with the accusations of steroid and HIGH use,"…"I have already made clear that I did not use them. Now, I have been accused of having an improper relationship with a 15-year old girl. Nothing could be further from the truth. This relationship has been twisted and distorted far beyond reality. It is just one of many, many accusations that are utterly false.

"I realize that many people want me to simply confess and apologize for the conduct that I have been accused of, but I cannot confess to, nor apologize for, things I did not do. I have apologized to my family for my mistakes, and having offered this apology to the public, I would ask that you let me and my family deal with these matters in private”. Clemens 'Sorry' For Mistakes In Personal Life, 13 WJZ-TV Baltimore, May 5, 2008.

Even if proven to be true, does cheating on your wife translate to a person lying about whether they took performance enhancing drugs?  If the case resulted in a trial would evidence of Clemens alleged multiple affairs be admitted into evidence at a trial?  Not necessarily, but McNamee’s lawyers has show every intention of connecting the two in the court of public opinion and in the courtroom as well. 

Before the case proceeds to trial Clemens’ lawyers would most likely file motions in limine to attempt to have the evidence excluded and deemed not relevant to the defamation claim brought by Clemens against McNamee.  The judge would be guided by the Federal Rules of Evidence which define relevant evidence as follows:

Rule 401. Definition of "Relevant Evidence"

"Relevant evidence" means evidence having any tendency to make the existence of any fact that is of consequence to the determination of the action more probable or less probable than it would be without the evidence” .

If the danger of unfair prejudice from the affairs would outweigh the probative value in examining Clemens defamation claims against McNamee then the evidence would most likely be deemed inadmissible. 

It would be within the discretion of the trial judge whether to allow the admission of such evidence into the trial. 

According to most public opinions polls, the reputation of Clemens has been tarnished.  It was recently reported that Clemens was not welcome on the U.S. Olympic team for the 2008 Olympics in Beijing.  U.S. general manager, Bob Watson has stated: “From my viewpoint, we didn’t need that type of distraction” Clemens Not Welcome on US Olympic team, NBC Sports, May 7, 2008.

This lawsuit is barely underway.  If Clemens continues to move forward there will be numerous depositions taken of individuals involved in the lawsuit including, Roger Clemens, Debbie Clemens, Mindy McCready, Paulette Daly, Brian McNamee, Jose Conseco, Andy Pettite, and most likely many more high profile individuals.  The lawsuit could take 2-3 years to resolve.  The overwhelming majority of lawsuits settle, so what are the prospects for some type of settlement of this lawsuit?  If the judge dismisses the lawsuit Clemens would then have to appeal the court’s decision.  Whether he would do so or not is still a mystery.  The pre-trial discovery phase of the litigation could take 1-2 years to complete.  Of course, settlement discussions can occur at any time and federal courts are known to coerce parties to the settlement table.  The question now is, what does Clemens have to gain by pursuing the case further?  His prospects for winning seem rather dim considering the “public figure” requirement under defamation law which he would have to overcome.  See New York Times v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254 (1964).  If a plaintiff in a defamation case is considered a “public figure” as defined by the law then the plaintiff would have to meet a higher burden of proof, that of “actual malice” to prevail in a civil lawsuit. It is a virtual certainty that Clemens would meet the test for public figure status under defamation law.  

McNamee does seem to be collectable for any damages Clemens might be awarded and Clemens is certainly in need of money.  With his reputation tarnished and a long tough road ahead for the civil lawsuit it seems unlikely Clemens would continue the case against McNamee for an extended period of time.  However, if Clemens never took performance enhancing drugs as he asserts, then just maybe, he wants to prove that in a court of law. 

Clemens approached his baseball career with an aggressive style and was known to throw a “brush back” pitch or two, just ask Mike Piazza.  Maybe he has a piece of evidence that would show his innocence and he is just waiting to deliver the “smoking gun” at the right time.  However, considering the beating he has taken in the press he most likely would have come forward with that evidence by now. 

It is rudimentary to state that the reputation of Roger Clemens is hanging in the balance and his reputation has always been something he has treasured and monitored.  If he voluntarily dismisses the case then he will certainly look “guilty” and giving up is something Roger Clemens has never been very good at.  Pressure is something he is always thrived upon.  Never before has he been in a pressure cooker such as this one.  One of his closest friends swearing under oath that Clemens discussed performing evidence drugs with him, a pending federal investigation into whether Clemens lied to Congress, allegations of marital infidelity and a very public lawsuit which has been the main focus of the media in the last few months.  All those factors together are troubling for Clemens.    

Clemens has never wilted under pressure on the diamond but he has never faced such long odds either.  It is difficult to believe he will sit idly by and do nothing.  That seems against his very nature.  McNamee’s attorney seems bent on embarrassing Clemens into dropping the lawsuit.  McNamee has not filed a counter-claim against Clemens for defamation but there are court deadlines that parties must follow and a counter-claim by McNamee could raise the level of the intensity of litigation by the parties. Maybe Clemens is hoping fans have had enough and will shift their focus to the Boys of Summer and as the season goes on, forget all about the Mitchell Report, Roger Clemens and the cast of characters which have been on display for the last few months.  In the meantime, the litigants weigh their next move.


Patrick K. Thornton is a regular contributor to the Business of Sports Network . He is a Professor at Houston Baptist University where he is the faculty advisor for the MBA in Sports Management.  He also teaches “Baseball and the Law” at the University of Houston Law School and Sports Law at Rice University and South Texas College of Law. He may be contacted at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .


REFERENCES

  • Accusation of Affair Erodes Clemens’ Credibility. Yahoo Sports. April 28, 2008.
  • Clemens’ Alleged Affairs Could be Part of Suit. Houston Chronicle. May 9, 2008.
  • Clemens Apologizes for ‘Mistakes,’ Continues to Deny Steroid Use. ESPN.com. May 4, 2008.
  • Clemens involved with Daly's ex-wife, NBC Sports, May 1, 2008. http://nbcsports.msnbc.com/id/24350727/
  • Clemens 'Sorry' For Mistakes In Personal Life, 13 WJZ-TV Baltimore, May 5, 2008. http://wjz.com/sports/Roger.Clemens.apology.2.716168.html.
  • Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss the Complaint in its Entirety . United States District Court Southern District of Texas, Houston Division. 4:08-cv-000471.
  • Defendant’s Opposed Motion to Disqualify Rusty Hardin , ESQ. and Rusty Hardin & Associates, P.C. United States District Court Southern District of Texas, Houston Division. 4:08-cv-000471.
  • Federal Judge Says Clemens Can Keep Hardin as Lawyer.Sl.com. May 6, 2008.
  • Hardin Files to Remain Clemens’ Lawyer.  Silver City Sun-News. March 25, 2008.
  • Hardin Stays as Clemens’ Attorney. Houston Chronicle. May 7, 2008.
  • Judge Allows Clemens to Keep Lawyer in Defamation Suit. Houston Chronicle. May 6, 2008.
  • Lawyers: Clemens not dropping defamation suit, Houston Chronicle, May 2, 2008. http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/sports/5750706.html.
  • Lawyer Says McNamee Defamation Suit Stands. Chron.com. May 2, 2008.
  • McNamee Asks Lawsuit be Tossed. Chron.com. March 5, 2008.
  • McNamee’s Lawyers Seek Ouster of Hardin. The New York Times. March 5, 2008.
  • McNamee Wants Clemens Lawsuit Dismissed. ABC News. March 5, 2008.
  • McCready Unlikely to be Tipping Point in Clemens’ Defamation Suit. SI.com. April 29, 2008.
  • Memo to Roger and Rusty: Show Us the Lawsuit. ESPN.com. May 1, 2008.
  • More Roger Clemens Affairs Alleged, KHOU.com. May 3, 2008
  • Motion Would Take Aim at Clemens’s Top Lawyer. The New York Times. February 26, 2008.
 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?