buy brand viagra zealand order alli online flovent hfa discount card cheap shuddha guggulu capsules order amantadine cheap hyzaar losartan cheap muscle relaxant for tmj cheap brand cialis cialis.com buy glucophage zealand buy cefixime 400 mg orally in a single dose cheap female cialis a prescription buy prandin uk online discount for lipitor buy ventolin evohaler 100 mcg cheap shatavari juice cheap viramune india cheap brand cialis free shipping cheap suprax cw buy alli diet pills buy clomid from boots cheap cardizem in usa order pain relief during labour cheap hair loss gene from mother aldactone discount card cheap speman himalaya order a bank statement order clomid in canada order pain relief real time ventolin discount generic buy aleve online buy brand levitra order zyvox india buy hydrea angeles buy triamterene much cheap relafen version buy desyrel generic buy amantadine hydrochloride order lisinopril kidney buy singulair korea buy alli at boots cheap female cialis kaufen buy ginette 35 cipla pcos order amoxicillin canada buy kamagra oral jelly romania order propecia online cheap buy female cialis japan buy ortho tri cyclen lo pill case buy dostinex much buy elavil online mango discount code europe order citalopram mg online buy topamax cheap cheap makita lithium ion batteries imitrex discount coupons aleve coupon deals propranolol discount vouchers innopran xl discount generic buy lasix cheap online order urispas canada buy accutane singapore order tamoxifen zealand viagra soft discount generic buy dipyridamole kuala lumpur cheap elimite lice buy trazodone online buy levitra plus usa order cialis soft unterschied cheap cialis soft uk order bentyl nausea order starlix bula order diclofenac gel for actinic keratosis buy inderal retard buy propranolol europe buy desyrel uyku buy cleocin uk cheap prevacid solutab buy cholesterol lowering quitting smoking pfizer dilantin discount card buy lamisil hcl benzac ac order pyridium discount vouchers cheap viagra generic uk cheap cialis sublingual comprar order florinef mail cheap isoptin a prescription cymbalta discount card lilly order lipitor in canada order female viagra takes cheap risperdal online order actors by name in reversed alphabetical order viagra jelly discount online buying asacol from canada discount nolvadex cheap rogaine 2 results cheap astelin spray buy viagra cialis online canada buy elavil in canada order evista generic buy carafate at walmart cheap wellbutrin sr bipolar disorder cheap claritin d cheap viagra plus jelly atorlip-5 discount voucher buy lantus online cheap hytrin in usa order toprol xl mechanism of action order ditropan vidal buy casodex online cheap brand viagra name in india buy leukeran online uk buy property canal du midi geriforte syrup discount price pain relief discount quick order hair loss causes buy aldactone in nz buy amitriptyline online buy kytril cheap advair diskus yeast infection order calcium carbonate uses in food buy bupropion sr dosage for smoking cessation buy kamagra oral jelly directions use buy olanzapine side hair loss discount experiences cheap levitra professional effects buy premarin job order zyban online uk buy glucotrol xl online cheap adalat episode cheap vasotec india buy cefixime online requip discount order effexor xr benefits cheap viagra super active ingredients how to buy baytril online lipitor discount voucher order zovirax illegal buy cialis via paypal cheap femcare ob gyn buy dramamine canada order glucotrol xl nedir buy penegra online in india order generic acyclovir where to buy dramamine bracelet cheap rogaine 2 or 5 wellbutrin sr discount jittery order calcium carbonate generic name buy orlistat hexal buy zyban best place generic viagra super active (sildenafil) order antabuse back hyaluronic acid discount holland and barrett cheap femara letrozole ventolin hfa discount coupon propranolol to buy online order levitra professional paypal kamagra gold discount jelly cialis soft discount rezept order mango cheap wellbutrin sr lowest dose buy levitra plus tablets order trazodone safe buy generic femara buy finpecia india rumalaya forte discount zio?a cheap glucotrol xl expiration buy capoten liquid buy cholesterol lowering grocery list buy nitroglycerin zealand diclofenac gel discount wikipedia silagra discount buy levitra plus europe cheap wellbutrin sr long term side effects buy lexapro system buy anti fungal paint b q order benzac uk order paroxetine yawning cheap actoplus met wiki wellbutrin sr discount zyban order pain relief for dogs order wellbutrin sr epocrates cabgolin discount vouchers buy valtrex from canada himcolin discount order cialis soft work cheap baclofen benfotiamine discount code requip discount price buy revatio vancouver order anti fungal wall paint cheap glucotrol xl formulation cheap anti viral free antivirus buy xalatan voltaren copay assistance order mango extract grifulvin v discount insert buy l tryptophan recommended dosage order prandin australia viagra jelly discount card buy parlodel generic order weight loss workouts order diamox legal cheap sinequan uses buy unique hoodia order cialis soft x 40 mg order brand cialis prescription cheap hair loss emedicine order flagyl er price cheap different dinner ideas chloromycetin discount order benzac kruidvat buy dipyridamole in thailand buy pyridium bula buy quibron t sr dose buy cleocin gel dermal cheap effexor xr and pregnancy cheap cleocin gel vs lotion buy anti fungal ketoconazole buy brand name viagra online benicar hct discount card cheap glucotrol xl coupons buy female cialis from canadian pharmacy order chloromycetin information order levitra super active viagra cheap betoptic gotas order erectile dysfunction reasons buy tetracycline canada order gasex yahoo cheap diclofenac gel the counter buy viagra soft uk aricept discount buy prandin legal buy micronase online canada cheap v gel himalaya order premarin script buy xalatan australia cheap actoplus met for weight loss buy arjuna mahabharata order brand levitra pharmacy cheap diclofenac gel grossesse cheap atorlip 20 que sirve buy minipresso uk buy ortho tri cyclen vs trinessa cheap penegra sk cheap actos in usa cheap risperdal australia cheap minocin uk cialis soft discount bestellen alavert discount code 2012 buy arava 20 mg cheap toprol xl kidneys order kamagra chewable gum order levitra knoxville cheap viagra professional information order remeron from canada order amoxil india buy dutas new zealand order furosemide online buy cleocin gel insert buy rogaine 5 does it work erection packs 2 discount dlc buy bystolic in thailand buy valtrex walmart cheap hyzaar lek buy voveran sr tab buy cipro online buy albenza zealand order brand advair diskus blast cheap azulfidine ra cheap accommodation palau micronesia cheap plendil generic buy viagra plus uk tesco order accutane uk buy viagra jelly hong kong maxaman discount order paroxetine withdrawal order hytrin online cheap erexin v megaforum order tetracycline dogs buy mentat ds syrup recipe order glucotrol xl obat order rogaine 5 uk order bactroban cream online cheap v gel nature buy amitriptyline in uk buy lipitor vancouver cheap elimite order zanaflex in canada order pain relief ear infection order tinidazole zealand cheap all inclusive buy cabergoline online buy zyloprim india buy real kamagra buy avodart vidal hair loss discount thyroid discount generic imitrex order accutane xenia buy coumadin zealand tretinoin 0 05 discount rezeptfrei buy ditropan online cheap lady era the fame monster order voveran sr quotes hair loss discount while pregnant buy nexium cheap online order hair loss natural remedies order innopran xl drug how to buy baytril order cialis professional and cialis order hair loss products order hytrin in canada cheap carafate in usa cheap viagra plus mastercard ranitidine discount vouchers cheap citalopram protonix discount buy flagyl at walgreens celebrex cost with insurance buy didronel in singapore cheap ventolin uk cheap finpecia uk cheap cialis jelly apcalis oral buy levitra philippines order calcium carbonate nursing implications buy innopran xl prescribing information cheap diclofenac gel otc leukeran tablets buy buy singulair veterinary cheap viagra super active en france buy bupropion sr dosage for weight loss cheap viagra jelly in uk order reminyl uses buy crestor quickly order pain relief of sciatica buy isoniazid vitamin order calcium carbonate tums buy leukeran vancouver buy snovitra super power jack hydrea discount generic order hair loss questions flagyl er discount mg dosage order cialis jelly ajanta buy elocon buy ventolin evohaler kamagra prix discount buy nizagara information buy januvia real buy generic protonix 40 mg cheap unisom overdose buy voveran sr india buy prandin africa cheap baclofen xl female viagra discount how to use buy aciclovir tablets over the counter buy xalatan liquid buy tadalis sx tadalafil labetalol discount card buy unisom tablets uk buy hydrea singapore mango discount outlet cheap voveran sr mg dosage cialis soft discount review buy asacol cheap buy triamterene in stores cheap cialis viagra online shuddha guggulu discount khasiat levitra discount walmart cheap venlor cheap femara a prescription men;s health discount twitter buy female cialis cialis.com buy saw palmetto oil uk cheap brand viagra pills buy cytotec over the counter buy brand valtrex online cheap kamagra supplier reviews buy zetia uk online buy maxalt dogs cheap v gel jell buy generic seroquel online order pravachol a prescription buy tenormin canada order mircette kariva order ginette 35 you gain weight cholesterol lowering discount and side effects methotrexate clearance graph viagra professional discount does buy revia from canada glucophage discount online buy aldactone best place where to buy zofran in canada cardizem discount generic cheap artane motels cheap anti viral windows 8 antivirus alesse discount vouchers cheap cialis super active mg buy l tryptophan growth hormone order cialis free overnight delivery buy ginette 35 tablet uses order review process buy rogaine 2 at walmart buy alavert place order weight loss after pregnancy rocaltrol discount order myambutol prescription cheap viagra super active wirkung order zenegra xpress buy bupropion sr by mylan buy coumadin africa cheap hair loss and thyroid cheap alli slimming tablets hair loss discount vitamin deficiency buy singulair uk order zovirax by mail buy finast jenta aceon discount coupon cheap fml forte prescribing information provera discount voucher order viagra plus cialis myambutol discount program order voveran sr india buy glucotrol xl label proventil inhaler discount card cheap levitra professional wiki pravachol discount pharmacy buy zanaflex high order venlor antidepressant order levothroid synthroid cheap apcalis sx gu"nstig zyvox discount vouchers order hair loss keratin treatment buy innopran xl gsk pravachol discount voucher buy tretinoin 0 05 prozent zaditor discount prices cheap cozaar reviews cheap cholesterol lowering naturally cheap accutane singapore buy citalopram 10mg online order buspar side order zenegra price order rogaine 5 cheap retino-a cream 0,05 buy retin a 0.05 buy alli express buy diclofenac hcl cheap albenza results order pain relief arthritis cheap kamagra in london order v gel kandicide buy hydrochlorothiazide zealand buy bystolic hcl order levitra professional es order forzest lasik discounts for law enforcement buy kamagra chewable cheap cheap advair diskus klinefelter syndrome buy reviews order cialis super active description order zyprexa cheap rental inflatable water slides cheap elimite lotion buy phenergan qtc buy lantus solostar pen buy confidor online order mango online india cheap clomid rx order actos juridicos order unique hoodia order protonix a prescription buy cheap zyprexa order orlistat buy female cialis toronto order serpina bodrum buy deltasone tablets buy emsam tablets buy tricor braun order viagra sublingual brasil order mycelex g y monistat 3 (miconazol) hyaluronic acid discount knee injections buy zyban melbourne order himcolin review buy haloperidol uk buy prednisone from canada buy urispas legal inderal discount coupon order buspar canada purchase dostinex online buy xenical online cialis discount card cvs buy propecia singapore cheap adalat full cheap malegra dxt reviews asthma discount vouchers buy levitra online canada cheap kamagra gold jelly pamelor discount vouchers mail order synthroid buy dipyridamole for cheap order toprol xl kidney function buy prometrium
Home All Articles Solving Baseball's Financial Inequities

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 459 guests online

Atom RSS

Solving Baseball's Financial Inequities PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Adam Holzman   
Tuesday, 15 April 2008 19:54

A Biz of Baseball OriginalThe following is a guest article by Adam Holzman.

Since the introduction of free agency in the mid-1970s, the salaries of Major League Baseball players have risen without limit. The abolishment of the reserve clause, which bound a player to his original team for the duration of his career (barring a trade), forced MLB owners to compete with each other in attracting premier players to play for their teams, driving up player salaries. As a result, many small market teams find it difficult to compete in a market where large market teams can offer substantially larger sums of money to free agents. While the reserve clause unfairly restricted the salaries of MLB players, free agency has threatened the competitive balance of the game. However, is a salary cap an appropriate solution to create balance in the playing field?

Certainly, small market teams are disadvantaged in the free agency market. In Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game, author Michael Lewis explains how Doug Pappas, the late, great sabermatrician, measures the quality of a team’s front office by determining the team’s “marginal wins” (all wins above the 49th) and “marginal salary” (all payroll dollars spent above $7 million). Dividing marginal wins by marginal salary gives the team’s financial efficiency for a given year. From 2005 through 2007, the median financial efficiency for MLB teams was $2,265,414.99 per marginal win. In 2007, the minimum number of wins needed to make the playoffs in the American League in 2007 was 94, or 45 marginal wins. (see a detailed breakdown of the 2007 Marginal Wins/Marginal Payroll here on The Biz of Baseball). Therefore, a team operating at the average efficiency level would have had to commit to a marginal payroll of $101,943,674.60, or a total payroll of $108,943,674.60. Since most small market teams cannot afford to spend this much on payroll, the general managers of these teams are forced to find ways to operate at higher levels of efficiency in order to compete with large market teams. Clearly, small market teams have an inherent disadvantage in free agency.

Select Read More to see the rest of this orginal article.

However, before we declare that a salary cap is a viable measure to fix the problem of competitive balance, we must consider its feasibility and its consequences. Firstly, the hope that a salary cap will be implemented in the near future is unreasonable. Not only would large market teams be reluctant to concede their financial advantage in the free agency market, but the Major League Baseball Players’ Association (MLBPA), the most powerful union in America, would not accept any measure that would decrease the amount of money being spent on player salaries. If the commissioner’s office were to attempt to install a salary cap, the decision would almost certainly be followed by the most prolonged strike in the history of major league sports.

In addition, the question must be asked: would a salary cap actually provide us with a more entertaining league? In the NFL (which has a salary cap), team quality fluctuates drastically from year to year, and the final standings of each season are almost impossible to predict. I may be in the minority, but I find a league with a greater degree of continuity to be much more entertaining. To me, one of the most appealing aspects of being a fan of a certain team is being able to watch the front office construct a contender or a dynasty from a previously hopeless club. I worry that a strict salary cap, while fixing the problem of competitive balance, would create too much parity throughout the league.

A stronger luxury tax system is most likely the best possible available method for leveling the playing field among large market and small market teams. While large market teams will still have the option to spend higher amounts of revenue on payroll, they will be taxed a certain percentage of their total payroll. This tax revenue will then be distributed amongst teams that do not surpass a predetermined payroll threshold.

However, out of this system of revenue redistribution arises another question: how can MLB administration prevent the owners of small market teams from pocketing the redistributed funds and refusing to spend it on payroll? Contrary to conventional wisdom, an owner’s ultimate goal is not necessarily to construct a winning team, but to make a profit. Because these two goals often go hand in hand (winning teams should increase team popularity and, therefore, team revenues), the distinction is sometimes overlooked.

One must consider the incentives presented to small market team owners in producing winning teams. When a small market team competes with a large market team for a high profile free agent, the small market team would inevitably have to spend a higher percentage of its total revenue in order to win the players’ services. Even if the small market owner decides to make this financial commitment, the financial returns on his investment will be less than what they would have been for the large market team. For argument’s sake, let’s assume that whichever team signs a certain high profile free agent will receive attention from an additional 2% of the team’s metropolitan area. In other words, 2% of the area’s population who previously could’ve cared less about the team now begins to spend money on tickets, jerseys, etc, because of the attraction of the newly-signed player. For a team in New York, this would signal an increase of about 376,370 local fans (2% of 18,818,536 total people in the metropolitan area), while, in Milwaukee, the team would receive increased revenues from only 30,200 additional fans (2% of 1,509,981 total people). If I am the owner of a small market team, why would I invest a greater percentage of my revenues in a player that will produce less increased revenue for my team than he would for a large market team? Small market owners, such as those of the Florida Marlins, are often criticized for a lack of commitment to producing a winning team, but, in reality, there is a lesser amount of financial incentive for the Marlins’ ownership to construct a winner than there is for large market teams.

The solution to the problem produced by the incentive disparity is twofold. Firstly, in addition to the luxury tax threshold described above, a salary “floor” should be implemented. Teams with payrolls below this floor would not be eligible to receive the redistributed luxury tax revenues, creating an incentive for stingy owners to spend more money on payroll. Secondly, the redistributed revenue should act less like a donation and more like an interest free loan. If the owners do not spend the added funds on team payroll by the end of the season, the money will be returned to the commissioner’s office. In other words, if a team receives $8 million in redistributed funds but only spends $5 million on payroll, the owner of the team will not be allowed to retain the extra $3 million. This removes any incentives that small market owners have to restrict team payroll. As a result of this plan, small market teams should become more financially competitive in the free agency market relative to large market teams.

Most importantly, the MLBPA would not be opposed to this plan. While an NFL-style salary cap would reduce the total amount of money spent on player salaries, the luxury tax plan may, in fact, promote increased spending on payroll. Although the ability of large market teams to agree to astronomical contracts would be restricted, small market teams would simultaneously begin to commit more money to team payroll. Because more teams would have a legitimate chance to sign high priced free agents, the competition among owners to sign such free agents would increase. Such competition would increase the negotiating leverage of the players, naturally driving up player salaries. All things considered, this luxury tax system appears to fix the problem of competitive balance between large market and small market teams, preserve the ability of a team to produce a consistent contender, and satisfy the MLBPA’s demands. I doubt that a salary cap would have the same level of success. 


OTHER NEWS ACROSS THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK


Adam Holzman is a senior at Amity Regional High School in Woodbridge, CT., and is a guest contributor to the Business of Sports Network. He will be attending Yale University in the fall.  

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?