annual us credit report long does take credit card payoff reach credit reporting agencies add consumer statement your credit report credit report collections 7 years tenant credit reporting free credit report legit getting a loan with bad credit history requesting free credit report affect score much do free credit report guys make free credit report number to cancel canada credit report fix what is a factoring company account on credit report bank of america credit report dispute address judgement credit report paid credit report how to check error on credit report purchase all three credit reports scores credit report protection data facts credit report fair credit reporting act definition consumer reporting agency assembling annual report credit score order your credit report experian does american express report authorized users to credit bureaus what does a credit card report contain credit alert interactive verification reporting system free credit reports annual my free credit report transunion pay for a credit report credit union 5300 call report data annual report credit suisse 2006 how to dispute bad credit reports credit report federal reserve 3 credit bureaus report equifax canada credit report business how do i dispute a debt on my transunion credit report capital one reports credit bureaus credit report scores what do they mean job asking credit report before interview definition consumer under fair credit reporting act how do i get a free how to get credit report by mail checking my credit report free are credit repair are travel agencies worth it how do i get an experian credit report how to report to credit bureau prepaid debit card reports credit bureau how to find out credit score rbc wealth all 3 credit reports what are the credit reporting agencies all three credit reports same there really free credit report free company credit ratings uk credit report all 3 bureaus one time fee how to remove an error on my credit report do any credit repair companies work vote new credit report band true credit ftc free credit report annual law free credit score credit report best credit report loan denied report personal solutions credit how to get a credit report in canada what are the three credit reporting agencies and why are they important experian free credit report credit denied phone number call get free credit report new jersey free annual credit report one free credit report per year entitled get copy experian credit report experian free credit report access understanding credit reports uk federal reporting period credit report free credit report without credit card uk clear credit report uk credit report and scores free trial georgia credit report free csc credit services my credit report free 3 bureau credit report no credit card debit card reports credit bureau credit report dot com baby lyrics credit card scanner theft credit report authorization form for renters get credit report from equifax free how to report a lost credit card chase how to challenge something on credit report check credit rating online australia equifax canada request obtain my free credit report when are monthly credit reports updated my free credit after being denied credit report online 3 bureau credit report with 4 plus scores free annual credit report online consumers chase report lost credit card number how to get experian credit report by post get something off your credit report after 7 years secured credit best credit cards for credit repair experian phone number order credit report two most common errors appear credit report how do youtube get a free credit report from the government free credit report all three major credit bureaus how often should you check your credit report how long does it take to fix an error on your credit report credit report renters free free credit reports for military personnel get late payment removed from credit report best credit repair real estate companies in dallas tx how long can a paid collection stay on your credit report ftc credit report disclosure free annual order credit report mail free credit report best place california consumer credit reporting act can a lender provide a copy of a credit report address all 3 credit reporting agencies your credit report how to establish using us credit history in canada how to cancel free credit report free credit report active duty military remove inaccurate items credit report what is the best credit reporting company victim of identity theft free credit report free yearly credit report 908 free credit report commercial pirate hat roller coaster free capital report due denied credit equifax cheap credit report monitoring how do you get a real free credit report section 615(b) of the federal fair credit reporting act experian understanding credit report 3 bureau online credit report free report ads check credit history experian member login in federal government website for free credit report tri merge credit reports wholesale how do u clean up your credit report for free 123 credit report free how do you get a free credit report from transunion summary your rights under fair credit reporting act 2009 there any true free credit reports paying debt not on credit report how do you fix how to repair your credit after bankruptcy how often should you view your credit report consumer credit reporting agencies act charge off paid credit report credit report challenge form average credit score in america 2011 the purpose of the fair credit reporting act (fcra) is to report discrepancies my credit report removing debt collection from credit report credit report employment illinois bank of america free annual credit report cash advance credit card deals free annual credit report governors website removing items from credit report after 7 years pay loan direct lenders navy federal free credit report understanding your transunion credit report how long do negative items stay on your credit report how can i get a free credit report without a credit card in the uk credit repair carlson law firm texas free annual credit report irs gov request how to request a copy of your credit report big 3 credit report agencies can i get a free credit report for my business get my credit report from equifax check all three credit reports credit score temp agencies in indianapolis free credit report identity theft victim free credit report commercial 2012 change personal information credit report experian free credit report how to report possible identity theft to credit bureaus credit score for free from government annual credit report and fico score national recovery agency credit report free credit report roller coaster commercial lyrics experian credit report how to cancel transunion credit report free annual free credit report equifax phone number disputing information credit report canada how to get free credit report by phone what are the names of the three major credit reporting agencies experian consumer credit report address free copy credit report annual understanding your credit report canada dispute credit report letter uk 3 fico scores and 3 credit reports charge off on credit report removal what is cash advance google charges on my credit card remove collections credit report free credit report rap commercial 2014 check your credit report free online access report debt bureau canada credit scores free annual credit report for a business see your credit report free entitled derogatory terms in credit report dispute federal tax lien on credit report long does irs tax lien stay your credit report block all credit reports definition consumer report fair credit reporting act title credit report error letter best 3 bureau credit report free credit report commercial set it off what does a credit reporting agency such as equifax do how to request your credit report my the credit repair group inc top 3 credit rating report companies easy payday loan cash advances you cash advance america my credit report card does experian update credit reports free credit report request letter credit report credit card authorized user discover card authorized user credit report the free credit report phone number to order all three credit reports order transunion credit report only order free copy credit report consent to obtain credit report form 3 major credit report agencies experian credit report online dispute how to remove credit report freeze credit report websites reliable information your credit report used credit report free on line credit reporting services compare get annual free credit report online how to get free credit report annualcreditreport can you really get a free credit report online phone number all three credit reports ftc dispute credit report errors credit report landlords check how do i dispute a judgment on my credit report will disputing items on credit report lower my score how long will a charged off account stay on my credit report how to get a free annual report in canada credit scores how to read equifax consumer report canada appliances free credit report federal scores add employer my credit report update credit reporting information free credit reports uk how often are credit card balances updated on credit report address to dispute experian credit report example letter dispute credit report how to get copy of credit report federal credit report act suze orman credit report experian free credit report for credit denial remove charge off accounts your credit report where do you get the real free credit report annual credit report form pdf transunion credit report questions denied credit free report transunion toyota credit revenue canada contact information reporting bad credit agencies free annual report filing a police report for identity theft online ways to fix your credit report for free where can i get a free detailed credit report clark howard free credit report annual sample letter to remove items from credit report get time barred debt off credit report does chase report authorized users credit bureaus letter disputing item credit report getting free credit report annual get equifax visa report denied credit day does capital one report credit bureaus obtaining your free annual credit report how do i get my free annual credit report from transunion how do i request my annual free credit report how to get debt collection off credit report one time credit report score credit report scores wiki credit repair guide by kyle wither 101 tips phone number for free credit report .com free credit score and report from 2 bureaus place active duty alert credit report credit rating reports can you dispute a hard inquiry on your credit report remove derogatory marks credit report credit report official government get your free credit report from the government who can pull credit reports equifax credit report sign in triple alert experian credit monitoring how do i change my employer on my credit report credit card reporting to credit bureaus federal government annual credit report credit report business now free scores often do you get free credit report quizzle credit repair oil security companies in houston tx update personal information credit report free credit report commercial songs three major credit reporting agencies canada canadian online credit report free consumer reports best small business credit cards uk credit report laws does getting credit report hurt score free tri merge complete credit report with scores is the original free credit report band back list of all credit reporting agencies experian understanding your credit report how to clear your credit report yourself request a copy of my credit report my free credit report.gov best three bureau credit report get my free credit report transunion free credit check report government credit reporting act 3 bureau credit report and fico scores legal credit report free how to get the credit report obtaining my credit report canada where can i get a one time free credit report free credit report experian usaa opt out credit report agencies credit repair credit report credit bureau reporting software trans long hard inquiry your credit report how long can a bad debt stay on your credit report how to contest a charge on credit report free credit reports without credit card needed dun bradstreet credit reports free equifax review free credit report experian creditreport infoexd.com ca company credit report us credit reports free law free credit report after denied credit transunion government annual credit report free how doo i freeze my experian credit report annual credit report online managing credit report business uk download credit report songs how do myspace get your free credit report yearly credit search on someone else getting a credit report all 3 credit report addresses dispute credit report error transunion equifax credit report for companies small business credit reports free company free score and report without credit card required how to fix derogatory credit report does checking my credit report hurt my credit score fico how much do the free credit report guys make does credit report system work pay off debt my credit report best place get your credit report free score free credit report and score without using a credit card trial free credit reports from gov free credit score and report from 3 bureaus dispute instant credit report canada does credit repair seasonal work australia what are the codes on credit report how to remove old things from credit report how does one get a copy of your credit report every months cibil credit report form long does chapter 13 bankruptcy stay your credit report long do bad scores stay your credit report how to fix medical bills on credit report best place to get all three credit reports credit report with score free how to monitor credit report for identity theft get a credit report for free why do employers pull credit reports help clearing up credit report safe request free credit report often credit card balances updated credit report credit report dispute online transunion getting items removed from credit report credit report letter of goodwill how do i get a free credit report from experian can you get charge offs removed from your credit report consumer credit report assistance dispute credit report letter suze orman do get free credit report credit card purchases exempt 1099 reporting credit repair letter of deletion free credit report with score remove satisfied judgment credit report access credit report again consumer credit report free pays 31-60 days credit report download credit report application how to remove charge offs on my credit report debt collection credit report experian total credit report how do you really get your free credit report i need help with repairing my credit top credit report monitoring service how can i get my annual credit report free what is a security freeze on a credit report us federal government credit report cheap transunion credit report canada report credit card theft credit bureaus what is the best way to get a credit report how to file a credit report dispute who won the free credit report band contest fix credit report errors transunion free report settlement personal solutions credit scores credit repair kelly services in memphis tn what is the most reliable credit reporting agency fix credit reports fast get midland credit management off your credit report dismissed bankruptcy on credit report what band does the free credit report.com commercials where can i get free credit reports once a year can debt collectors run your credit report how do i fix my credit score myself major business credit reporting agencies free credit score reporting data online how to clear credit report fast wells fargo credit card lost reporting what is the best site for free credit report how to contest information on credit report credit report from government free credit report check third party do credit reporting agencies sell information ny times free credit report credit bureau of canada report word of mouth credit repair san antonio tx credit report active duty how to find out what;s on your credit report request credit report sample letter free credit report from the goverment fair credit reporting act complaint form free credit score and report from three bureaus what is hard inquiry on credit report get better credit report score how to get charge offs removed from my credit report how do i request my free credit report how to make corrections to a credit report best credit report service youtube personal credit report south africa contact all three credit reporting agencies request credit report deceased person free credit report federal trade commision charged how long does chapter 13 bankruptcy remain on credit report will checking your credit report hurt your credit northwestern mutual credit rating am best free complete credit report and scores right to free how to get a copy of credit report my free credit report fico score myfico credit ac repair school miami cbc innovis credit reporting agency hard inquiry credit report long what is the best site to check credit report real singer free credit report commercials free credit report charged me 14.95 debt past statute of limitations on credit report free credit report commercial pirate hat dot safe free credit report website get credit report after being denied loan letter experian postal credit report free credit rating report where can i get free credit score online best way to dispute credit report errors fair credit reporting act amendments 2010 view credit reports and scores sample letter remove hard inquiry credit report what does it mean to credit account what is a tax lien on your credit report how to view your annual credit report does sprint report credit agencies all credit report and score experian equifax credit reports free experian credit report free yearly credit report best place to pull credit report credit union australia annual report 2010 request my credit report free fast credit elevator repair companies in texas how long does credit inquiries stay on your credit report unsecured credit cards reporting credit bureaus how to check your credit report online for free credit report landlord california credit reporting bureau canada request credit report from transunion info free credit report how to read a trans union credit report run credit reports companies visa signature card not reporting credit limit annual annual credit check experian long does take get your credit report mail government website obtain free credit report what is the most common credit reporting agency how do i get a current credit report single bureau transunion? credit report with vantage score where can i get free credit report and score will a collection agency remove credit report erase credit report canada my credit report online free credit report bureaus credit report sites actually free equifax credit report how to read often cane you check your credit report free what are the three main credit report companies sample letter to have items removed from credit report maine free annual credit report phone numbers major credit reporting agencies judgement credit report points address for three credit reporting agencies consumer pay advance loans party supplies in 90065 canadian credit report affiliate program where can i go to get my free credit report how long does a paid charge off stay on your credit report review credit report equifax how to obtain a free credit report after being denied credit equifax freeze my credit report new york
Home BoB Documents PEDs Mitchell Report LIVE BLOG: Congressional Hearing on Mitchell Report

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 827 guests online

Atom RSS

LIVE BLOG: Congressional Hearing on Mitchell Report PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 5
PoorBest 
Mitchell Report
Written by Maury Brown and Dave Rouleau   
Tuesday, 12 February 2008 22:43

 

Mitchell Report Hearing

Today's hearing before the House Committee on Oversight and Reform will mark a key moment in the ongoing implications from the release of the Mitchell Report. With Kirk Radomski, Andy Pettitte, and Chuck Knoblauch providing sworn depositions, but not testifying before the committee, the day will largely be about Roger Clemens and Brian McNamee.

While the report commissioned by Major League Baseball has become a raging debate in the court of public opinion, questions remain as to whether the method by which the report's focus on player names is really on trial. At stake is the integrity of a man deemed to be a first ballot Hall of Fame pitcher in Roger Clemens, against the word of his former personal trainer, Brian McNamee. The integrity of former Senator George Mitchell's report hinges largely on whether the word of McNamee is truthful, and if not, how the process of the report was handled. With both sides fighting so vehemently to say they are telling the truth—yet knowing that one is lying—raises the stakes for McNamee and Clemens, while calling into question the way in which the report was released. The fact that Charlie Scheeler, a key investigator of the Mitchell Commission, is the only other member to testify today, outlines that not only is Clemens and McNamee under scrutiny, but the Mitchell investigation, as well.

Today's hearing is entitled:

"The Mitchell Report: The Illegal Use of Steroids in Major League Baseball, Day 2"

With the importance of today's hearing, Maury Brown and Dave Rouleau of the Business of Sports Network will be blogging the proceedings live starting at 7am ET

Updates are being displayed below.

Select Read More to View this Live Event

Supporting Information for Today's Proceedings 


9:40am ET - Maury Brown - Pre-Hearing News

The NY Times is reporting that not only will Clemens be faced with the damaging testimony of Andy Pettitte that was collected during deposition, but also information that the committee itself has collected, according to two lawyers familiar with the situation:

“The committee is not messing around and has other damaging evidence against Roger,” one of the lawyers said.

The other lawyer said, “Andy said enough to really hurt Roger.”

Clemens continued to insist on Tuesday that he never received injections. He made those denials while visiting privately with six more members of the committee, bringing his three-day lobbying total to 25 of the 40 committee members. But in many respects, it was the calm before a momentous clash for Clemens, the most decorated pitcher in baseball history.


10:03am ET - Dave Rouleau - Clemens Arrives

Roger Clemens is getting in the building.  CNN reports that they have seen his opening statement, where he says, again, that he denies McNamee's allegations against him.

 

10:08am ET - Dave Rouleau - Moment of Silence for Tom Lantos

 There is a moment of silence for Tom Lantos who passed away recently.

 

10:12am ET - Dave Rouleau - Chairman Statement

The Chairman says "we had no intention of making baseball a part of our agenda, however given the nature of the Mitchell Report..." 

He then proceeds to talk about the statements by Knoblauch and McNamee in the deposition and says Knoblauch acknowledged his use of PEDs.

Then, he talks about Pettitte, but doesn't reveal anything yet, keeping for later in the hearing. 

It is very strange to see both McNamee and Clemens seated at the same table.

The Chairman states "someone isn't telling the truth", because the statements received describe very different stories. 

He says that Pettitte and Knoblauch backed McNamee's statement in their deposition, but that McNamee also neglected to tell the full truth "because I was trying to protect the guy....not hurt him"

 

10:26am ET - Dave Rouleau - Pettitte acknowledges Clemens' use

Pettitte and Clemens talked about the use of PED in 1999 and 2005.  They also talked about his wife's use and how it helped a body recover.

 

10:34am ET - Dave Rouleau - Tom Davis opening statement

He is sorry to be there, but felt like he needed to shed light on the allegations in the Mitchell Report.

Want my take, folks?  Clemens is toast.  He clearly spoke about HGH with Pettitte and McNamee and said later, when asked again later by Pettitte what he would say to reporters if asked about HGH, he said "No, you misunderstood, my wife received them, not me".  Pettitte clearly did not want to go further in the discussion, according to his deposition, but had no doubt Clemens was the one who had received them, along with his wife.

 

10:36am ET - Dave Rouleau - Taking the Oath

Two opening statements are coming up.  All three participants took the oath.  Clemens goes first with the statement.

 

10:41am ET - Dave Rouleau - Clemens statement

Condensed... 

"never took any shortcuts...I always want to help everyone...I may be too trusting...how do you prove a negative...my name will never be restored...McNamee's statement about me are wrong"

Brief statement by the pitcher.  McNamee is beginning.

 

10:47am ET -Dave Rouleau - McNamee statement

"apologize to American people for tainting out national pastime....injected Clemens, Pettitte and Knoblauch many times with HGH...I told the truth all along...I hope that the American people, in some small way, can pardon me for my actions...never injected anyone with B12, despite statement by Clemens...my father, who was a policeman in NYC, instilled honest principles in me...Pettitte and Knoblauch have backed my statements...never really trusted Clemens, despite respect for him, that's why I kept the physical evidence...everything changed on January 7th when the call between me and Clemens was made public, that was despicable...I lied to police officers to protect friends and co-workers...painful that my name will forever be linked to this scandal."

 

10:54am ET - Dave Rouleau - Questioning begins

Questions to Clemens about Pettitte and Clemens conversation.  Clemens denies that ever happening and states that he thinks Pettitte is an honest 'fellow'.  Pettitte injected himself again in 2004, something the investigators did not know. 

Clemens again states that Pettitte misunderstood and was talking about a TV show where he heard about HGH.  He was shocked to know Andy used PED.  Clemens sighs, loudly.

All evidence so far is CLEARLY against Clemens and the first questioner made sure he knew what 'under oath' means.

 

11:01am ET - Dave Rouleau - Pettitte wife's deposition

Pettitte wife, Laura, told investigators that his husband told him about a conversation he had with Clemens about HGH in 1999 or 2000.

Clemens loves the word 'mis-remembers' (about Pettitte) and has used it about five times so far.

Laura also said that Andy told her Clemens' wife had used it in 2005.  

 

11:07am ET - Dave Rouleau - Davis questions McNamee and Clemens

The regimen for growth hormones was four times a week, according to McNamee. Clemens bled through his designer pants and a player (Mike Stanton) asked about it, according to McNamee's deposition.  Clemens denies it ever happened.

McNamee says they then bought Band-Aids so it doesn't bleed through the clothes.  Clemens said to Stanton "I'll do anything to get an edge".

 

11:20am ET - Dave Rouleau - Barbecue and B12

Everyone remembers Clemens not being there, from Jose Canseco to the Blue Jays travel secretary, except McNamee.  Clemens played golf that day and showed a receipt.  McNamee says he saw his nanny grab his kid near the pool and turned around only to see Roger Clemens and Debbie.

Tom Davis is handling this matter really well, just looking if McNamee's memory is good when he wants it to be good.

Clemens says his kids could have been there and believes Debbie was with him at the golf course.

The pitcher now talks about B12 and vitamins and how his mother always taught him to take them.  McNamee says he first heard of Clemens taking B12 on 60 Minutes.

 

11:25am ET - Dave Rouleau - Debbie's use of HGH

Clemens is caught in a lie with regards to his wife's use with HGH, giving different accounts of what he said.

 

11:41am ET - Dave Rouleau - Grilling

McNamee just got grilled by  .  He said that he thinks Clemens is innocent, because he has not been proven guilty and it is disgusting all the lies McNamee has told in the past. 

Very agitated gentleman.

 

11:46am ET - Maury Brown - McNamee Admits to Lying to Federal Investigators

Clemens may be lying, but McNamee admits that he did. Brian McNamee was grilled repeatedly about his possible lying to Federal investigators. McNamee admits lying repeatedly to investigators.

 

12:03am ET - Dave Rouleau - Famous buttocks

Clemens had an injury to his buttocks and McNamee says Blue Jays head trainer told him it was an abscess, which would more than likely reveal the injection of Winstrol.  

Davis asks McNamee why he would provide steroids as a former policeman.  He says he is ashamed. 

McNamee is coming under fire and I'm surprised how much he lied and how much Clemens is getting a free ride for the time being, although Lynch threw him some curves.  Davis, however, is falling all over himself to back Clemens

(Maury Brown comment) 

Conversation is about Winstrol injection was too fast regarding abscess. McNamee says Clemens developed an abscess. McNamee says Clemens threw the Winstrol into his locker and says, “Get rid of this stuff.” McNamee is now unaware whether he did a botched injection. Davis says that under oath, he said he injected Clemens in Tampa Bay. Tommy Craig, and Scott Shan (sp?), Ron Taylor, Alan Gross doesn’t remember an abcess with Clemens buttocks. Davis asks why they don’t recollect the abscess. "Are you certain Tommy Craig said it was a abscess?" McNamee says, "Yes." Davis asks why they are saying their recollection and McNamee’s don’t jive. McNamee says he is unaware of the dates. Davis why did he inject illegal substances into professional athletes. McNamee says he was ashamed, but he did it and that is why he is hear today. Since 2002, he says he did not inject athletes, but in 2003, he injected Debbie Clemens

 

12:23am ET - Dave Rouleau - Mitchell report

McNamee says he gave Clemens steroids, Winstrol and HGH.  Clemens is then questioned about the six times he said he had no idea Mitchell wanted to talk to him, but says in the 60 minutes interview he decided not to go.  His agent reportedly kept the request from Clemens and he hasn't fired his agent or representatives for this mistake.

 

12:27am ET - Dave Rouleau - Cover-up?

McNamee says a union rep. told him in 2000 that the owners wanted to cover up the allegations.  McNamee provided the physical evidence AFTER the taped call was played to the public on January 7th and his sure the DNA will belong to Clemens, but could potentially not reveal PED use.

 

12:41am ET - Dave Rouleau -Nanny says Clemens was at the party

Clemens talks about his upbringing, not having a car in school, so he was running home.  He says McNamee, contrary to his alleagations, did not 'make him into what he is'.

Again, the heat is on McNamee so far.  There is no deal on the table for McNamee, according to him. 

The chairman of the committee says they were denied access to the nanny for a while.  She said to the committee that she was at Canseco's home and Clemens was there, too.  She says that Clemens asked her to go to his home, the first time he'd talked to her since 2001.

 (Maury Comments)

McNamee is asked if there is a deal with the Feds in exchange for his testimony today. McNamee says, “No.”

Waxman gets back to Clemens at Canceco’s party. Waxman asks if Clemens was at Canceco’s June 8-10 time period. Clemens had testified that he did not. Committee reports that they investigated the party, and ask for the name of Clemen’s nanny. The committee was unable to contact her till Monday, and spoke to her yesterday. Nanny says she was at Conceco;s and spent the night. Does not remember a party. Remembers that Clemens was there during the time period, and that it conflicts. On Sunday Clemens calls her and asked to get her to his house.

Clemens met with her, and then lawyers for Clemens spoke to her. Clemens tells her to tell the truth. Waxman: “Was it your idea” to contact her? Rusty Hardin leaps up and defends himself. Waxman says he doesn’t believe that there is anything improper.That there was  Impropriety. Attorneys should not have interviewed. Should have provided that the committee would call her. “Innuendo!!,” by Clemen's lawyer, Lanny Brewer. Clemens says, “I’m hurt by statements…”

 

(HEARING BREAK)

 

1:15pm ET - Maury Brown - Comments on the Hearing, so far

 

Today has been something… No one looks good. With Andy and Laura Pettitte’s testimony in which they both state that Clemens used performance-enhancing drugs, the day looked to be an attack on Clemens. Instead, it has become, as one committee said, “Frustrating.” Someone is lying, but do not yet definitively know who it is.

McNamee has become more of a focus as his repeated admission of lying to investigators has placed his credibility further into question.

Clemens has been dealing with conflicting recollections regarding his wife’s use of hGH.

A huge comment by McNamee about a conversation with David Cone, then a player rep, regarding management’s efforts to stall testing has brought up talk of possibly more hearings with owners being made to testify.

We have lengthy conversation about an abscess on Clemens’ rear.

We have comments regarding the handling of physical evidence that McNamee has turned over.

We have Clemens’ nanny involved, regarding Canseco’s party and whether there was impropriety in some way in contacting her -- witness tampering after the committee was unable to reach her.

We have Clemens’ attorneys jumping up and speaking out of turn, which has added to the drama… grandstanding by several members of the committee (one went so far as to ask what jersey Clemens would wear into the Hall of Fame).

It’s been seedy. It’s been unseemly. It’s been, on so many levels, appalling that we have congress involved in this matter

Such is the place we are in in the wake of the Mitchell Report.

What will be interesting is reading the depositions that the committee has said they will release to the public. As one committee member said, “This (the hearing) has been about interaction” between McNamee and Clemens. Today barely scratches the surface when we get to the testimony collected under oath by the likes of Pettitte, Knoblauch, and Radomski. They must be sitting back watching all of this saying, "Thank God, I'm not there right now."

And think… we are most likely only half way through today's hearing. What else will we see?

 

1:28pm ET - Dave Rouleau - Davis continues questioning 

Davis establishes that the nanny could only be contacted through Clemens and that her English is not that good.  Clemens goes through the discussion with her last Sunday, saying they were all trying to remember what happened concerning the Canseco party.

What's Davis problem?  Big fan of Clemens I guess...

McNamee presented himself on the Ramdomski's checks as a doctor, even though his University had no-campus and was through mail only, something he says he didn't know before.

I'm tired of the pleasantries between the members of the committee and Clemens. Is there an autograph session after? 

 

1:34pm ET - Dave Rouleau - McNamee recording with Clemens investigators

Part of the recording was not made public and Clemens is asked why they asked the trainer whether he had physical evidence.  Clemens pleads he's not aware of all that was asked in the recording and that he was not involved.

 

1:40pm ET - Dave Rouleau/Maury Brown -  Duncan speaks to Clemens

Duncan, a former criminal judge, says the evidence against Clemens is very weak and that the physical evidence McNamee gave the committee would probably never be admitted in any other court of the land.

Duncan, “The Mitchell Report is based on statements from someone that has admitted to lying to Federal investigators and someone that has recently plead guilty to charges.”

Clemens plays the patriot and "I worked very hard for so long" cards very well, I must say. He says he is very easy to find and if the Mitchell people wanted to talk to him, it would have been easy to do so.

Clemens is asked if he’s ever been a Vegan. Clemens states that he doesn’t even know what that is, which gives some levity to the hearings, at least for the moment.

Isom to McNamee regarding the lies that have called the Mitchell Report into doubt. Asks McNamee if he believes it has altered the perception of the Report, and  McNamee says, "No." Isom replies, "Shame on you"

 

1:58pm ET - Dave Rouleau - Taped call

They are trying to get McNamee to say why he didn't say on the publicized recording that he was telling the truth when asked by Clemens "Why did you do that?".

The trainer says he wanted him to speak to his son, not him.If he knew it would air on national television, he would have said it clearly.  He previously said that he knew halfway through the call that he was being taped or that at least other person were listening.

 

2:16pm ET - Dave/Maury - Body size

Pictures of Clemens are shown before and after the alleged use of hGH. The Congresswoman mentions the Clemens' workouts. She mentions, "Body change." As a sidebar, the use the PEDs is not all about "size", but rather, the ability to rebound from injury and fatigue.

The chairman stops Clemens in mid-sentence after he makes allegations about McNamee's past involvement with young players and asks him to clearly answer the question about his work regimen.  Clemens says he takes a lot of pride in his workouts and conditioning.

 

2:25pm ET - Maury/Dave - Cummings on Pettitte's Testimony. Clemens is Hard to Believe

 

Cummings sides with Pettitte given the fact that both his response and Knoblauch’s response jives with McNamee’s version of the story. Clemens claims that he never heard about Pettitte’s use of hGH.

 He also brings up Laura Pettitte's testimony. Ends by saying, "Mr. Clemen's you were one of my heroes, but I find your testimony hard to believe."

 

2:45pm ET - Maury/Dave - End of Hearing. Comments by Davis and Waxman

 

Davis: Report by Mitchell is still in tact. The day does not dispute the underlying aspects of it. Hopes that baseball still works to the recommendations of the report.

Waxman: Knoblach and Pettitte corroborate McNamee’s testimony.  Clemens interrupted, saying, “It doesn’t mean he was not mistaken, sir.”  Waxman: “It doesn’t mean that.”  Clemens: “It doesn't mean that he was not mistaken.”  Waxman very upset bangs gavel and says, “Excuse me, but this is not your time to argue with me.” Waxman apologizes to McNamee for some of the comments about his credibility. Clearly, a man that has no love for Clemens.

 

Dave Rouleau - Closing Statement

I find it hard to believe that McNamee got roughed around like he did today.  While his lying in the past should not be excused, Roger Clemens' former teammates corroborated the trainer's statements and all that was debated was whether we could NOW believe McNamee?  Sure...

When McNamee denied being a drug dealer, he was clearly wrong.  He is.  However, he was right on at least one point: he is dealing with adults that have, in some cases, a large ego and many financial reasons to put up impressive statistics, so that future contracts will reflect their level of performance.

That Clemens was praised at one point as a hero and greeted with all the pleasantries was a disturbing spectacle.  He may be guilty or innocent, but someone in there lied through their teeth all day long and we are not that much more advanced in the process.

- Do you call Pettitte a liar, Mr Clemens?

- Do you call his wife, Laura, a liar, Mr. Clemens?

- Why would he do that to you?  Would he sacrifice your friendship for a comment you possibly made about a TV show you saw in the past? 

- Your nanny tells our investigators you were present at one point of the party, is she lying?

- You played golf the day of the party, a location that's 20 minutes by car to Canseco's home, according to you.  Does that make you not present at his home during the whole day?

I really feel cheated by the hearing today, because I feel like not enough emphasis was put on the info that was revealed through the other depositions.  The chairman of the committee made a point of apologizing to McNamee for the unceremonious attacks he suffered.  While I think that's going a bit far (he did lie often in the past), he certainly expressed the view of a part of the audience today and that includes me.

I wonder if the autograph session with Clemens and member of Congress will last long?  Was their an official diner with the President and Clemens where the pitcher will give a speech about the B12 vitamins by his mother in 1988?

 

Maury Brown - Closing Statement

If there is anything to be learned today, it is that we are no further along than we were yesterday. Strike that: I'm more nauseated than I was yesterday. The committee members either pandered to Clemens and shot softball questions, made comments that were pure grandstanding ("You're going to heaven."), or slammed McNamee with being a drug dealer. In the case of the two testifying, they both look guilty. 

Clemens spent the day saying that while hGH surrounded him -- either Andy Pettitte, his wife Laura, or Clemens' own wife Debbie -- he was never aware of them and is only now coming to understand them. Pettitte's damning testimony? "He misheard."

As for McNamee, he was portrayed as greasy, and his comments didn't help. Arguing that it was the "opinion" of a committee member that he was a drug dealer didn't help his case. "It is what it is," may fly in New York (at one point it was mentioned that the record should reflect what that means to a native New Yorker), but come on... 

I think the comment by Rep. Sounder had everyone twitching at MLB Headquarters when he said at one point, "The Mitchell Report was not targeted towards the ownership and it’s one thing we haven’t investigated. … This comes at the core question of the legislation that ... (was) introduced, whether we can trust baseball to, in fact, do testing on themselves." With McNamee throwing David Cone under the bus, and Scheeler doing likewise to the MLBPA regarding letters sent to them where it is said that players would have the right to see information and evidence against them before the Mitchell Report was published, baseball comes off as a circus with not three rings, but more than one can count.

Furthermore, Bud Selig has said that he is proud of what Senator Mitchell did in his report. That may be the public persona, but it's hard not to believe that late at night when Bud's head hits the pillow he curses under his breath. After all, it is the method of the report -- it's focus on names of players, rather than detailed look at the overall, which has created this monster.

Finally, Rep. Virginia Foxx (R-NC) said at one point, “I am not a fan of holding these hearings on issues we have no business dealing with.” She, and others, mentioned that the name they fall under is "Government Oversight Committee." While my eyes are red from watching, I can't help but think of my blood pressure. With the ills of a declining economy and wars on two fronts, we have our elected officials grandstanding over a "buttocks abscess" and a party at Jose Canseco's. Where is the "government oversight"? I was more embarrassed for our political leaders, with Waxman leading the charge, than I was for Roger Clemens and Brian McNamee, and that's saying a lot. Let me ask... What's sexier, Roger Clemens or some owner like Peter Magowan? This is about face time at yours and mine expense. That's what happens when MLB (not the players) gets a pass on the Mitchell Report.


The Biz of Baseball is part of the Business of Sports Network. For details on our interviews, latest new on MLB, the NFL, the NBA,and the NHL from outside the lines, check www.businessofsportsnetwork.com for information and links to the Network's sites.
 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?