viagra 25mg reviews 2013 prednisone 0.5 mg tab nexium cpr 40 mg buy cialis bangalore safe generic viagra mylan generic viagra buy prednisone cod clomid 150 mg ervaringen cialis 20 generico lexapro 10 mg wiki dosis diflucan 150 mg nolvadex online order buy diflucan 150 mg strattera 40mg capsules order Cialis Jelly 10 lisinopril ratiopharm 10 mg generic med synthroid viagra generico efeitos metformin 500 mg nebenwirkungen wellbutrin retard 300 mg antidepressants citalopram 20mg levitra comprar online buy prednisone 5mg 75 mg viagra generic viagra comprar generico order bactrim antibiotic viagra generico efeito generic daily cialis cialis 10 mg tabs nexium 160 mg propranolol bijsluiter 80mg kamagra beograd online viagra tesco buy generic levitra dangerous cipro forms online buy levitra 30 pills nexium 20 mg kaufen prednisone online cheap cialis tabletas 20 mg levitra brand online bijsluiter lexapro 10 mg viagra generic cheapest levitra generic dose viagra 100mg bericht lexapro online ny buy levitra ups 100mg clomid worked propecia generic walgreens wellbutrin 150 mg effective generic wellbutrin anchen 3 generic meltabs viagra xenical meridia online clomid twins 150mg levitra buy toronto buying dapoxetine celebrex online pharmacy viagra generico resolve levitra 10 mg 8 comprimidos 20mg cialis directions nu doxycycline 100mg bactrim fast cheap wellbutrin generic target kamagra online cheapest levitra 30 mgs dinamarca online lexapro zoloft 25 mg insomnia prednisone online dog buy clomid dallas increase lexapro 10mg generic finasteride propecia zithromax liquid buy zovirax iv 250mg buy viagra brazil diflucan tablet 200 mg korea generic viagra erythromycin dosage 500 mg cialis 20mg doctissimo augmentin 1000 mg xr highest mg buspar buy 50mg clomid levitra 20mg achat alli orlistat 60 mg 150 cialis dapoxetine buy walmart generic synthroid viagra 100mg pills strattera generic when clomid 50mg bula comprar kamagra online zithromax 250mg tabs clomid 125 mg kamagra manchester buy lexapro 10 mg price cialis 20mg teilen buy viagra gta 36 hour cialis online cialis split 20mg zithromax 1000mg iv levitra 20 mg orodispersible generic viagra reputable propecia cheap buy mg of bactrim viagra gel online buy viagra hcmc viagra 100mg nl bula zovirax 50 mg doxycycline canada 20 mg generic viagra sydney viagra mastercard generic buy periactin lisinopril 10 mg take valtrex generic pregnancy buy bactrim overnight is generic viagra buspar 15 mg tablets viagra online ny sibutramina 15mg xenical shop levitra 5mg cialis penang buy cipla cialis 5mg medicamento lasix 40 mg vendita cialis generico prednisone china cheap zoloft 250 mg dosage buy levitra mg cialis medicine 5mg buy uk kamagra bayer 20 mg cialis 200 cialis 20mg viagra uk 500mg kamagra 100mg malay two 5 mg cialis existe xenical generico india viagra 100mg cheap dubai viagra buy cialis denmark order bactrim cheap buy cialis venezuela cialis 20 mg interactions zithromax azithromycin 500 mg purchase bactrim online viagra buy tesco cialis 20mg philippines notice viagra 100mg order celebrex canada buy doxycycline dubai drinking 20mg lexapro clomid 100mg daily cialis singapore online wellbutrin overdose 900 mg cipro 500 mg pill cialis online info buy nolvadex generic 25 mg topiramate wellbutrin bactrim 480mg 5 mg viagra enough 30 mg strattera online nexium 40 mg vademecum ic propranolol 40mg prednisone 5 mg alcohol oklahoma online viagra 60 mg propranolol anxiety levitra 10 mg indicaciones cialis 20 mg prostatectomia kamagra pills 50 mg cialis 40 mg bulk synthroid online cheapest 150 viagra medicine lisinopril 10 mg pfizer viagra online buying cialis vietnam generic valtrex buy viagra produce sordera lexapro 20 mg weight generic cialis colombia generic lexapro problems viagra 50mg information buy levitra walmart tratamiento lexapro 10 mg bisoprolol 5mg viagra 0.5mg propecia results cialis daily 5mg lexapro 40 mg cipro online purchase viagra 50 100mg 900 mg wellbutrin xl fda generic cialis levitra tablets buy lexapro cheap xenical online review prednisone buy online about zoloft 50mg xenical 120 mg priser brand cialis generic generic medication propecia clomid 50mg men viagra price online durata viagra 100mg liquid clomid online viagra cheap fedex taking 2 2.5mg cialis cialis 20 mg discoun generic line viagra lasix dosage mg viagra consultation online viagra 100mg tabs cialis 0 5 mg cheap viagra substitutes zoloft 100 mg erowid amoxil manufacturers generic bactrim f generico cialis paypal buy lisinopril eg 5 mg prednisone 5mg info generic lexapro side fungsi doxycycline 50 mg lisinopril 40 mg walmart augmentin 375mg tablets 8000 mg viagra cipro mg 20mg levitra erection cheap cialis wordpress dosage cialis 20 mg clomid order canada kamagra 25 mg cialis 20 mg halbieren buy doxycycline injections metformin 850mg augmentin 625mg frequency zovirax 200 mg dosage viagra 100 mg 8 tabletten existe viagra generico buy zithromax 250 mg propecia 1mg 84 xenical generic available cialis generic fast generic cialis authenticity viagra no.1 200mg levitra 20 mg 3 free cialis tadalafil buy iene viagra online cipro 750 mg 14 tablet order sertraline zoloft augmentin 500 mg cost buy nolvadex safely 80 mg prednisone dogs cialis 10mg forum cialis generic 60 mil metformin 500 mg 48 93 bactrim 400 80 mg roche viagra dosage 50 mg generic doxycycline hyclate buy 4 dose zithromax tablet clomid 50mg viagra da 100 mg buy zithromax brand inexpensive generic cialis buy viagra pretoria 100mg viagra taking 2 white viagra online zovirax generic brand viagra 100mg buying kamagra online europe tratamiento diflucan 150 mg order viagra 100mg online cialis tadalafil using 200 mg viagra acquisto cialis generico 600 mg celebrex viagra strength mg nolvadex tamoxifeno 10 mg generic valtrex india bactrim mg info cialis online reputable online cialis risks generic levitra quality celebrex generic 100mg cheap zithromax uk 100mg fake cialis buy clomid quick augmentin 875 mg bid buy zithromax 4rx 2 25mg of viagra prednisone ten mg clomid 100mg overweight penjual clomid online buy dapoxetine singapore prednisone 6 mg india viagra online posologia clomid 50mg mg of zoloft augmentin 625 mg prescription chinese 800 mg viagra thuoc cialis 20mg cialis 5mg rezept nexium 20 mg tabletten generic work levitra cialis 20mg faq order prednisone canada valtrex 500mg wiki buy metformin 500mg generic viagra wien generic lexapro identification fungsi lasix 40mg zoloft dose 250 mg lasix online pharmacy 20 mg levitra viagra clomid 200 mg 100mg zoloft dosage buy levitra chennai levitra 10mg bayer diflucan 200 mg day buy cialis 40online cheap nolvadex 20mg generic viagra work viagra schweiz online xenical 120 mg preis buying viagra shanghai pregnant 500mg metformin bfp 100mg clomid cialis 40mg overnight viagra online gefahr preise levitra 20mg prednisone dog mg 30 mg lexapro breastfeeding cialis 30 mg dosis propranolol la 40mg cheap quality viagra amoxil 500 mg cost cheap generic strattera wellbutrin xr 100mg lisinopril generic zestoretic about doxycycline 100mg buy viagra cardiff cialis generico foro lexapro generic coming lisinopril 30 mg 3762 buying 40mg cialis viagra for buy acquistare cialis 5 mg cialis cheap 200 mg generic viagra egypt cialis 200mg reviews generic synthroid cost cheapest propecia us prednisone 40 mg tablets prednisone 80mg eye tetracycline online uk cipro 500mg bula erythromycin 400 mg acne pastillas levitra 10 mg Levitra 20 mg Buy lexapro 5 mg prise cheap viagra walmart lexapro 10mg appetite pill zoloft 50 mg synthroid 0.2 mg get cytotec online prednisone 5mg ears stopping 50mg zoloft generic viagra comparisons priligy generico foro viagra 150 mg notizte xenical oral buy nexium generic image wellbutrin generic bupropion generic cialis names review online viagra generic cialis review teva hydrochlorothiazide 50 mg canada cialis 20 mg lexapro 20 mg controlled buy super viagra diflucan 100mg synthroid 75mg lasix 40 mg posologie levitra 20 mg viagra diflucan 150 mg globul tetracycline to buy ontario online cialis buy bactrim viagra online buy lexapro online 20mg prednisone 50 mg bid generic levitra 25 mg prednisone ratiopharm 5 mg 12.5mg of zoloft cheapest viagra 800mg online viagra advice xenical 120 mg 42 celebrex online coupon prague buy viagra amoxil 500mg paypal cheap cialis black getting wellbutrin online viagra acquisto online finasteride propecia 5mg nexium generic name order nolvadex cheap prednisone 40 mg m2 brazilian generic viagra cialis online utah 80 mg propranolol effects 1cheap generic cialis doxycycline 100mg tekenbeet farmaco cialis 10 mg buy propecia lloyds cialis generico 100 nebenwirkungen kamagra 100mg viagra jelly cheap cipro 250 mg harnwegsinfekt cialis online prodaja augmentin 125 mg prospect buy clomid discount generic med lexapro wellbutrin 300 mg price viagra canada orders 20mg lexapro dangerous panotile cipro 1 0 mg zoloft 50 mg wiki fake generic propecia metformin 500 mg online prednisone online order strattera bipolar 2 disorder priligy generico online cialis tadalafil generico lisinopril 20 mg overdose cialis 20 mg fiyat cialis 10 mg wirkungsdauer viagra 100 mg pdr splitting 20mg cialis viagra 50 mg etkisi levitra 10mg vidal propranolol online pharmacy buy viagra moscow acquisto cialis generic 150 mg wellbutrin sr 120 mg viagra price xepasone 5mg prednisone online apotheke levitra buy generic cialis generic levitra 2.5mg valtrex online cheap 40mg cialis effect generic levitra suppliers levitra price 20mg Levitra pill order viagra online sample amsterdam buy levitra cialis 5 mg preisvergleich cialis 5 mg cheap cialis generic version order Cialis 120 cytotec online philippines starting lexapro 2.5 mg buy phenergan suppositories cipro online buying cialis 40 mg kaufen cipro xl 500 buy medicamento levitra 10 mg canova 50mg viagra buy lasix mumbai purchase nolvadex online nexium astrazeneca 40 mg buy antibiotic bactrim legitimate cialis online propecia order canada buy clomid 100 levitra 10 or 20 mg buy doxycycline 100 online viagra 50 mg 2 tablet generic propecia dubai ordering zoloft nexium 20 mg prospect cipro 500 mg endikasyonu 5mg cialis daily cost viagra 100mg veterinary prednisone buy wellbutrin hcl generic diferenca viagra generico doxycycline 100mg cmd kegunaan nexium 40 mg generic viagra flavored cialis generico soft cialis lady 20mg cialis online al buy 5 day zithromax buy viagra nigeria cialis 200 mg tadalafil 100mg viagra last lisinopril 40 mg images cialis 5 mg opinion buy clomid emedzone amoxil 100 mg piqure levitra generic review viagra online rush 100mg viagra instructions buy clomid mexico cialis 20mg malaysia levitra 20mg jenapharm cheapest lexapro online
Home Maury Brown Marquee Value for A-Rod or Santana? Nearly Impossible

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1063 guests online

Atom RSS

Marquee Value for A-Rod or Santana? Nearly Impossible PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 4
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 22 January 2008 11:50

Maury BrownOn more than one occasion, authors and analysts have worked to try and assign a value of a player, beyond the wins that they may contribute on the field. Players like Alex Rodriguez, Johan Santana, and others have been talked about in terms of bringing in millions upon millions of dollars based upon their draw as a “star player”, or marquee value. The numbers lofted out have been extraordinary. In the case of Alex Rodriguez, agent Scott Boras said his value to the YES Network could be a half a billion dollars over the life of his contract, a staggering figure.

Books and articles have been written with large sections devoted to placing a figure on this Star Power dynamic. They roll a laundry list of revenue streams into the conversation… merchandising, television, radio, increase in repeat season-ticket purchases, increased concessions, all based upon deriving a figure based on some model (which is rarely revealed) to create some monetary figure. This may sell books, and may make articles that get read, but the problem is, the figures are derived from some overly simplistic model, or created from inaccurate data. The reason it sells is no one questions the methods or figures. Since there is little published on topic, most assume that the mysterious model is correct, and takes it as truth.

Here’s the problem with trying to tackle such a model: It’s vastly complex, and unless you work in the Finance department of some MLB club, or MLB Headquarters, odds are you have never been privy to data that would allow you to begin to get solid figures to work with.

In other words, it’s analysis by dartboard. (Hmm… $100 million sounds about right. I’ll use that).

Let's get into that list of revenue streams... 

Take sale of merchandising. Here’s how it is broken out:

  • Merchandise sold in the park or in a team store within X miles from the park is team local revenue based on retail margin (and subject to revenue sharing), but the team is subject to licensing fees, which are considered centralized (that figure is not subject to revenue sharing). 
  • Merchandise that is sold through MLBAM or team websites is BAM revenue. BAM retains the retail margin but licensing still goes to MLB Properties and then the teams (centralized).
  • Licensed merchandise sold by retailers is retailer's revenue but generates licensing revenue for MLB Properties, which is centralized.
  • In the case of merchandise with a player name on it, a portion of the sale goes to the MLBPA

Got that? Head hurt?

Now, one could determine figures for a player’s marquee value based upon the sale of a jersey with said player’s name on it, but how would you know if a jersey without a name was tied to the star player? Unless there is market research involved, or someone with ESP, it’s impossible to define -- a cacophony of other variables are at play.

What about the value that a player brings by way of television? At least here, we can try and use ratings metrics to begin with. If a star pitcher is taking the mound, one could look to the ratings to see if there are spikes on those days when he is up in the rotation (think Clemens, Schilling, Matsuzaka, etc.). In the case of a position player, the ratings figure become more difficult to associate. Are people watching because of the player? Because of the team he plays on (brand draw)? Because of the match-up? The numbers are flat in that regard. This much is certain: the value of winning is what drives interest. If the player with marquee value is adding wins, then it is the win, along with his star quality that has impact.

For example, let’s look at Alex Rodriguez when he was with the Texas Rangers. According to the Sports Business Journal, the Rangers saw “ratings drop 15 percent on FSN Southwest the season he joined the team as baseball’s highest-paid player. The RSN posted a 2.0 in 2000 and a 1.7 in 2001. Ratings jumped 19 percent the year after Rodriguez left, from a 2.1 in 2003 to a 2.5 in 2004.”

The argument Boras made was that A-Rod had not become iconic at that point. It wasn’t until he arrived with the Yankees that A-Rod’s star appeal was reached.

Maybe.

Now, this isn’t to say that there isn’t more interest when star players wind up on teams. It’s that it is lost in the surrounding noise (other factors that impact individual valuation). Back to the case of Rodriguez and YES Network ratings, ratings for Yankee games have increase 47 percent since he arrived in pinstripes. Now, is that because of A-Rod? The return of Clemens? The fact that the Yankees are the Yankees? Or, winning? It is, of course, all of the above.

Last thing… it’s not as if the day Alex Rodriguez was resigned with the Yankees, or the possible day that Johan Santana arrives on <insert new team’s name> doorstep, that an increase in ratings immediately translates to big bucks based on the deal for carriage. One would certainly see an uptick in terms of advertisement, but in terms of the television deal, by itself, the player would not impact it. That  revenue comes by way of subscriber fees from cable operators that carry the RSN. In the case of YES, according to the SBJ, YES pulls in about “about $2.25 per subscriber per month from operators.” For YES, that means that rate is locked in over the next 7 years. To try and determine how much a player’s value is worth in 7 years would mean trying to dissect that single player out of the winning and losing of the team, the cycling in and out of other possible players with star draw, and factoring brand draw, as but a few examples.

As I said, it’s all this background noise that makes claims of being able to define a distinct value to a player’s worth, outside of their win values on the field, anything but a way to sell books and articles. In some senses, you're double counting. If the player is adding wins (which increases interest in the team), and has marquee draw, then how do you define whether it was the player's win value, or marquee draw? Could be both. Could be one or the other.

There may be an exception. Someone rare. Someone new. Something wholly unique.

There is little denying that the arrival of Jackie Robinson in Major League Baseball was one of these players. A "new factor", which would parlay itself into star draw to the nth degree. Another case might be Fernando Valenzuela and the ensuing “Fernandomania”. Maybe, more recently, it has been Ichiro in Seattle, where the player, in that market, has spiked tourism from abroad to come see him play.

Maybe.

This is, after all, a discussion about the stars amongst the stars. When an author can show me how they derive the figures, and then can apply it to a case like when Wade Boggs went to the Devil Rays, and then it passes the smell test… then I think we’re getting somewhere. Someone may come up with this formula. Someone may actually be willing to publish it. If someone can come up with the data, who isn’t working for a club or MLB Headquarters… now that would be a feat that would rightfully sell some books.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?