where to purchase metformin without rx metazole medications buy doxycycline without prescription lamisil tablete carprofen for dogs dosage overnight zoloft viamax coffee miladin som medicin xalatan generic vs brand can i buy viagra in amsterdam pilocarpine drug penis picture citalopram 10mg for anxiety trimoxal 500 mg zyprexa relprevv reviews omoxycyclin pills amitriptylin on line buy eoro med online mens clinic toronto actos side effects pioglitazone seroxat cr 12 5mg hydrocodone morphine band posters zovirax without prescriptions salibet ointment for shingles retard d eregle order cialas zurich kwikmed inc search http mesinpromo arsw derive wintomylon vademecum argentina prinivil side effects doctor propranolol la dosage for anxiety rocket stoves for sale modafinil provigil reviews kentucky wesleyan betnoeate skin cream uses adderall side effects medication valacyclovir hcl sildenafil teva prezzo tizanidine online ordering craigslist canada viagra buy cheap propecia naprosyn side effects medication eltroxin 0 1mg alprazolam viagra sale online shop flagyl dalacin 300mg antibiotic top rated no priscriban drugs piroxicam side effects on dogs canadian cialas super active my canadian pharcharmy online minoxidil foam side effects tegretol toxicity icd 9 buy amoxicillin europe can i take diflucan during pregnancy thuoc alfuzosin 10 mg prevacid lansoprazole 30mg moduretic tablets low testosterone androgel reviews tadalafil 100 donepezil 5 mg tablets nizagara tablets singulair allergy medicine coupons prenisolone order india generic viagra order xlpharmacy complaints against dentists cialis ills fluconazole diflucan and breastfeeding meclizine 25 mg tablet directions pavitra rishta citizen tv podofilox gel medication cataflam medication dose remeron generic name canadian cialis buy online acquistare cialis contrabbando tadalafil 200 buy original cialis online plendil side effects taking order ciprofloxacin online retin a cream 0.1 tretinoin indomethacin 25mg and alcohol buy viagra usa html epogen procrit injection amoxicillin for sale in us cheap uti drugs cialis mit paypal bezahlen clomid buy online australia promethazine 12.5mg tab walgreens pharmacy drugs inderalici para que sirve allegra models zolpidem tartrate 10 mg tablet online pharmacy clindamycin side effects rash ampicillin side effects yeast infection hydroxyzine for dogs side effects cialis quick delivery uk legitimate cialis canada chewable generic viagra flagyl non prescription methotrexate for sale viagra uk 150 mg clomid twins cialis preisvergleich mexitil mexiletine neuropathic pain narcotic drug delivery no prescription aristocort a 0.1 cream for sale adhd pharmacy is zanaflex addiction norfloxacin prospectus vicodin and alcohol high avana skyway apartments review vimax side effects impotence canadian pharmacy norx com harga misoprostol ninth st pharmacy levitra tablete clindamycin 300 mg capsules side effects buy aciclovir tablets on line proviron 25mg tab mesterolone schering buy couch covers with a echeck arimidex dosage for men fentanyl patch withdrawal symptoms cialis paypal australia alli pills amazon buy clomid without prescription uk cabgolin 0 25 or 6 azulfidine sulfasalazine dog donde venten cytotec en estados unidos gabapentin fast delivery kamagra canadian subutex and suboxone difference clenbuterol side effects tablets no prescription dilantin aciphex rabeprazole sodium 20 mg 5mg generic levitra weather for medyka poland buy furosemide 20 mg over the counter arimidex for men doses cialis last longer in bed order maxalt migraine medicine tryptizol information systems elocon cream 0.1 doctor arthrotec 75 doxycycline hyclate side effects dogs cialis professional tadalafil levobiotic 500mg metronidazole maxaman caye caulker belize lodging in house pharmacy motilium general need cialis shipped in 2 days stendra avanafil tablets dove posso acquistare cialis generico indian generics online accutane salzarex vardenafil 20 cialis 100 mg strength of medicine buy valtrex without prescription topamax side effects topamax dosage for weight loss furolin tablets with keyboards cialis online nabp luvox reviews for depression crestor rx coupons printable ordering zofran decadron dosage information cytotec no prescription paroxetine 20mg treatment for hot flashes actos generic zenegra pills buy risperdal consta injection laxifen tabletas what does provera do stop bleeding kamagranow uk daily mail overnight valtrexz careprost eyelashes mirtazapine 30 mg for sleep flagyl antibiotic used to treat gum disease esomeprazole magnesium tablets sky pharmacy review probenecid drugs std drugs online microcidal 125mg equals ambien withdrawal symptoms how long when will dapoxetine be available cheap no script premarin accutane lawsuit class action diclofenaco de sodio 100 zoloft 100mg lasix sale clenbuterol for sale weight loss reviews the centurions nolvadex gynecomastia advair diskus without a perscription mebendazole drug store canada elimite cream no prescription albuterol nebulizer side effects cialis for daily use coupon cataflam 50mg tablets pain dosage zofran dosage for children age 7 sotalex medicine man seroquel dosage for depression valtrex dosage for cold sores reviews eldepryl medication administration tryptizol information now cheap propecia from india premarin coupon .625 minoxidil foam 2 womens viagra online tantalum long beach new years eve decadron injection generic viagra for sale online buy treatment for chlamydia spiriva inhaler printable coupons percocet 10 topiramate medication for weight loss cialis vietnam online antibiotics without prescription cialis 60mg commander americain diabecon himalaya products usa donormyl side effects amitriptyline online uk glucovance 5 500 cost viagra side effects viagra vs cialis lamisil cream treatment omeprazole 20 mg treatment imitrex injection instructions nolvadex for men where is generic viagra available why does cialis cost so much cialis direct mexico pilocarpine drug interaction robaxin dosage for women lexapro withdrawal symptoms oxybutynin 5mg tablets licensed mexican pharmacy online mercury drugstore philippines website viagra super p force euthyrox levothyroxine sodium side effect fungsi obat infatrim ordering motilium online rhinocort aqua couponsrimonabant misoprostol rezeptfrei kaufen bentyl for ibs diarrhea viagra casero isoptin retard side effects viagra from china amoxicillin for sinus infection during pregnancy voltaren gel over the counter minocycline hydrochloride treatment rxdiler store credit revia without prescription fluoxetine capsules 20mg side effects allpills pharmacy times can you purchase bactroban over the counter protonix generic hydroxyzine pamoate 50mg side effects hyzaar blood pressure hydrochlorothiazide side glipizide medication side effects synthroid without script cialis vs cialis professional cheap doxycycline 20mg online pharmacy review cart malaseb dog shampoo dogs clonidine 0.2mg picture aspirin and pregnancy first trimester nexium for 18 00 lipothin injections for weight no prescription nexium bactroban cream 2 mupirocin calcium prodotto 108 ranbaxy pharmaceuticals inc recall abilify without insurance kosovarja magazine peja diclobru tablets for kids cialis by mail order generic viagra sold in canada bactroban crema drugs without prescriptions venlafaxine et anxiete accutane buy synthroid dosage chart levothyroxine crestor side effects rhabdomyolysis kidney damage como usar levitra order decadron on line canesoral duoderm elomet cream ointment provigil 200 mg price at walmart marcumar alternative medicine real ciplox doxycycline hyclate 100mg pharmacie de garde luxembourg cheap sildenafil tablets www myservepharmacy reglan medication and pregnancy exocin eye dropsextenze keflex side effects 500mg increasing testosterone levels hormone che sono le sildenafil doc floxin otic prescribing information diflcan cheap lasix delivered overnight nexium generic brand johnson and johnsontretinoin a 05 cialis 36 hour pill atarax medicine erectile dysfunction pills online buy sibutramine hydrochloride monohydrate capsules sominex sleep aid nighttime betacin 25mg zoloft generic cialis from us pharmacy letrozole infertility birth defects levitra super active quick ship cialis no prescription kamagra jelly paypal beloc zok analogai clomid fertility drug decadron cheap sialis tablets with keyboards where to buy celexa mobic 7.5 mg treatment overseas promethazine codeine acheter misotrol minocycline uses and dosage flovent diskus 250 mcg coupons isotrinion sale moduretic 5 50 blood pressure medication viagra discover card india accutane 20mg bestellen rezeptfrei dopareel tablets 7 5 basketball ttsh pharmacy generic brand for alli online meds rx prednisone buy celebrex mexico budesonide ec 3 mg capsule luvox ocd doselynoral ciprobay antibiotic precose mechanism of action best price zenerx scam advair by mail low cost drugs where can i get antibiotics cialis anglais adipex 37.5mg adipex p dynamogen syrup of ipecac maxolon and breastfeeding doxepin for dogs side effects female viagra for sale voveran sr premarin side effects drugs zofran over the counter diclofenac sodium 75mg and ibuprofen hydrochlorothiazide online us pharmacy buy aricept online no prescription what is suprax medication tadalafil at a lower price best place to buy nizagara online buy fluoxetine 20mg in canada medications without a prescription benicar medication lawsuits cialis ireland no prescription lantus the erection company arlington how can i get some acyclovir lasix side effects in dogs buy spironolactone no prescription buy accutane mastercard buy cefixime au viamedic com vfw store supplies zyprexa 0 dollars 63 center no prescription cialis generic cheap finpecia by cipla vermox mebendazole suspension procalisx reviewed definition diroton 20mg adderall aristocort cream medication www viagraforsaleaustralia viagra very fast shipping condyline solution ciproxin 500 mg dilantin side effects seizures doxycycline hyclate uses drug zovirax ointment 5 come comperare viagra where to buy citolopram in canada minocycline expired 2012 caverta 50 mg erectalis 20 cymbalta philippines albendazole treatment drug topiramate 100mg weight loss imitrex for migraines drug prozac usa epogen side effects in dialysis staxyn reviews from patients microzide medication for anxiety apcalis tadalafil jelly obetrol drug mart cialis black market price 274 virectin reviews side effects norstan communications systems levitra cost at walgreens tedarise 20 online mesterolone proviron 25mg order from canadian pharmacy furolin medicine wheel cialis certified online pharmacy motilium dosage for breast feeding clindamycin for dogs with uti advair side effects advair diskus percocet withdrawal symptoms timeline buy clomid uk no prescription tretinoin cream usp 0.025 for wrinkles where can i get alli rhinocort aqua nasal spray directions rx site 24 buy cheap viagra products zovirax ointment medication where to buy herb viagra green box canadian pharmacies 24h mail order where to buy nitroglycerin thyroxine binding globulin tbg test albuterol buy super lavetra cep paulinia digoxina dosis amoxicilina micardis side effects reviews no rx needed cialis cialis kaufen rezeptfrei cialis a vendre quebec pil syntotec on line pharmacies us based periactin medication for migraines caffeine side effects in men lamotrigine 25mg depression liposafe testimonials for business subutex for sale online where to buy zoloft 25 nizoral shampoo coupon cuckold definition slang words temovate gel 05 generic viagra 25mg kesan pil perancang marvelon ropinirole drug information nolvadex tablets buy uk cardizem cd 120 mg order generic cialis cialis gratui onljne pharmacies vibramycin vs doxycycline hyclate reglan breastfeeding baby generic viagra canadian buy vardenafil 40 mg online flovent diskus 100 mcg side effects prazosin medication for cats side effect minoxidil for women at walmart advair coupons printable prescription viagra best legal online site to buy viagra prevacid vs prilosec side effects anafranil side effects treatment naprosyn side effects doctor online cialis overnight amlodipine order online sildenafil citrate 100mg side effects buy kamagra with paypal antibiotics order cialis billig bestellen brand name cialis from japan sildenafil soft tablets genuine viagra best price super cialis albendazole buy uk where to buy viagra in doha 41 www canada rx connection mupirocin 2 for acne dalacin cream 2 can i buy lotrisone cream over the counter where to buy clomiphene citrate best price cialis 20mg usa imitrex side effects stroke buy betnovate no presc uk venlafaxine side effects hair subutex for pain relief maxolon in pregnancy prednisolone for dogs 5mg cheap clomid dutasteride hair loss nizoral tablets canada benemid contraindications for tpa zovirax acyclovir online metallica lyrics onemetazolmetazole mexitil dosage of tylenol oxybutynin chloride 5mg what is it for quand le cialis ne fait plus rien chocolate cockapoo puppies for sale in michigan antibiotics for urinary tract infection cuvarlix capsules custom top kick 4x4 for sale over the counter substitute for bentyl seroquel online no prescription vistaril side effects dose bupropion hcl 150mg xl tab act dicyclomine 10 mg aciphex 20mg medication generic
Home Maury Brown Marquee Value for A-Rod or Santana? Nearly Impossible

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1060 guests online

Atom RSS

Marquee Value for A-Rod or Santana? Nearly Impossible PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 4
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 22 January 2008 11:50

Maury BrownOn more than one occasion, authors and analysts have worked to try and assign a value of a player, beyond the wins that they may contribute on the field. Players like Alex Rodriguez, Johan Santana, and others have been talked about in terms of bringing in millions upon millions of dollars based upon their draw as a “star player”, or marquee value. The numbers lofted out have been extraordinary. In the case of Alex Rodriguez, agent Scott Boras said his value to the YES Network could be a half a billion dollars over the life of his contract, a staggering figure.

Books and articles have been written with large sections devoted to placing a figure on this Star Power dynamic. They roll a laundry list of revenue streams into the conversation… merchandising, television, radio, increase in repeat season-ticket purchases, increased concessions, all based upon deriving a figure based on some model (which is rarely revealed) to create some monetary figure. This may sell books, and may make articles that get read, but the problem is, the figures are derived from some overly simplistic model, or created from inaccurate data. The reason it sells is no one questions the methods or figures. Since there is little published on topic, most assume that the mysterious model is correct, and takes it as truth.

Here’s the problem with trying to tackle such a model: It’s vastly complex, and unless you work in the Finance department of some MLB club, or MLB Headquarters, odds are you have never been privy to data that would allow you to begin to get solid figures to work with.

In other words, it’s analysis by dartboard. (Hmm… $100 million sounds about right. I’ll use that).

Let's get into that list of revenue streams... 

Take sale of merchandising. Here’s how it is broken out:

  • Merchandise sold in the park or in a team store within X miles from the park is team local revenue based on retail margin (and subject to revenue sharing), but the team is subject to licensing fees, which are considered centralized (that figure is not subject to revenue sharing). 
  • Merchandise that is sold through MLBAM or team websites is BAM revenue. BAM retains the retail margin but licensing still goes to MLB Properties and then the teams (centralized).
  • Licensed merchandise sold by retailers is retailer's revenue but generates licensing revenue for MLB Properties, which is centralized.
  • In the case of merchandise with a player name on it, a portion of the sale goes to the MLBPA

Got that? Head hurt?

Now, one could determine figures for a player’s marquee value based upon the sale of a jersey with said player’s name on it, but how would you know if a jersey without a name was tied to the star player? Unless there is market research involved, or someone with ESP, it’s impossible to define -- a cacophony of other variables are at play.

What about the value that a player brings by way of television? At least here, we can try and use ratings metrics to begin with. If a star pitcher is taking the mound, one could look to the ratings to see if there are spikes on those days when he is up in the rotation (think Clemens, Schilling, Matsuzaka, etc.). In the case of a position player, the ratings figure become more difficult to associate. Are people watching because of the player? Because of the team he plays on (brand draw)? Because of the match-up? The numbers are flat in that regard. This much is certain: the value of winning is what drives interest. If the player with marquee value is adding wins, then it is the win, along with his star quality that has impact.

For example, let’s look at Alex Rodriguez when he was with the Texas Rangers. According to the Sports Business Journal, the Rangers saw “ratings drop 15 percent on FSN Southwest the season he joined the team as baseball’s highest-paid player. The RSN posted a 2.0 in 2000 and a 1.7 in 2001. Ratings jumped 19 percent the year after Rodriguez left, from a 2.1 in 2003 to a 2.5 in 2004.”

The argument Boras made was that A-Rod had not become iconic at that point. It wasn’t until he arrived with the Yankees that A-Rod’s star appeal was reached.

Maybe.

Now, this isn’t to say that there isn’t more interest when star players wind up on teams. It’s that it is lost in the surrounding noise (other factors that impact individual valuation). Back to the case of Rodriguez and YES Network ratings, ratings for Yankee games have increase 47 percent since he arrived in pinstripes. Now, is that because of A-Rod? The return of Clemens? The fact that the Yankees are the Yankees? Or, winning? It is, of course, all of the above.

Last thing… it’s not as if the day Alex Rodriguez was resigned with the Yankees, or the possible day that Johan Santana arrives on <insert new team’s name> doorstep, that an increase in ratings immediately translates to big bucks based on the deal for carriage. One would certainly see an uptick in terms of advertisement, but in terms of the television deal, by itself, the player would not impact it. That  revenue comes by way of subscriber fees from cable operators that carry the RSN. In the case of YES, according to the SBJ, YES pulls in about “about $2.25 per subscriber per month from operators.” For YES, that means that rate is locked in over the next 7 years. To try and determine how much a player’s value is worth in 7 years would mean trying to dissect that single player out of the winning and losing of the team, the cycling in and out of other possible players with star draw, and factoring brand draw, as but a few examples.

As I said, it’s all this background noise that makes claims of being able to define a distinct value to a player’s worth, outside of their win values on the field, anything but a way to sell books and articles. In some senses, you're double counting. If the player is adding wins (which increases interest in the team), and has marquee draw, then how do you define whether it was the player's win value, or marquee draw? Could be both. Could be one or the other.

There may be an exception. Someone rare. Someone new. Something wholly unique.

There is little denying that the arrival of Jackie Robinson in Major League Baseball was one of these players. A "new factor", which would parlay itself into star draw to the nth degree. Another case might be Fernando Valenzuela and the ensuing “Fernandomania”. Maybe, more recently, it has been Ichiro in Seattle, where the player, in that market, has spiked tourism from abroad to come see him play.

Maybe.

This is, after all, a discussion about the stars amongst the stars. When an author can show me how they derive the figures, and then can apply it to a case like when Wade Boggs went to the Devil Rays, and then it passes the smell test… then I think we’re getting somewhere. Someone may come up with this formula. Someone may actually be willing to publish it. If someone can come up with the data, who isn’t working for a club or MLB Headquarters… now that would be a feat that would rightfully sell some books.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?