lowest interest rate credit card 2013 australian credit card rewards comparison credit card interest rates 2012 canada all types of credit cards in india mastercard prepaid what is the best credit card for rewards points usaa american express secured credit card credit cards for low income earners with bad credit chase credit card business phone number myer visa card apply online virtual credit card number mastercard easiest store card to get with bad credit uk chevron gas credit card apply aqua credit card contact details best corporate credit card canada us bank credit card processing elavon i need a fake credit card number and security code old orchard credit card online best rewards credit card no annual fee same day cash online loans hsbc online credit cards australia virgin money credit card address uk bad credit credit cards guaranteed approval no deposit best department store credit cards 2012 best credit card 2012 usa square the iphone credit card machine goes mainstream how to get otp in hdfc credit card citifinancial credit card payment online reloadable credit cards canada credit card debt relief company reviews cash back credit card offers 2012 hdfc credit card payment online from other bank account apply for chase freedom mastercard what are the 3 best credit cards to have bank of america report credit card fraud how to get credit card limit increase chase credit card issuers in india black card visa uk virgin credit card 0 disney rewards visa credit card review payday loans for bad credit no upfront fees barclays international student credit card best travel reward cards payday title loans online wireless credit card machine india diners club international credit card switzerland does applying for store credit cards hurt your credit score standard chartered online credit card payment virtual credit card terminal ireland which credit card charges credit cards for bad credit scores cash advance online lenders uk canada post reloadable prepaid credit card hdfc credit card offers can you use a visa gift card to get cash back which credit card is best for international travel debit visa cards in trinidad visa credit card number generator with cvv best payday loans online no credit check do i need a credit card number to make an itunes account pay as you go credit card processing canada credit card emi calculator hdfc bank getting a credit card after filing for bankruptcy no annual fee rewards credit card australia credit card debt settlement macy american express credit limit easy cash advances online credit card issuers list credit cards for bad credit and no processing fee is it safe to apply for payday loans online getting out of credit card debt calculator american express blue sky credit card review canada which credit card is best for me 2012 credit card for international students singapore how to buy apps from google play store without credit card hdfc credit card reward points redemption procedure sbi credit card customer care number for hyderabad salary pay advance form consolidate credit card debt td canada trust citibank credit card payment through hdfc debit card amazon credit card payments paypal virtual credit card 2012 biggest credit card companies credit card with no credit history usa bad credit car loans low interest fast online cash advance lenders when do chase credit card payments post best credit card interest rates australia average credit card interest rate how do you apply for a credit card online 100 day pay loans southwest credit card car rental deals apply for discover credit card student low rate credit cards uk paypal accept credit cards without account capital one credit card canada review online loans in south africa no paperwork credit card rewards uk navy federal or usaa secured credit card home loan with bad credit 2012 how do i get a starbucks platinum card icici credit card offers on movie tickets what is the security code on a discover credit card costco american express platinum card benefits wells fargo payday advance how long does it take paypal to confirm credit card mastercard credit card companies virgin media credit limit letter instant short term loans online legit payday online loans easy online payday loans ontario credit card number and cvv number standard bank online application for credit card credit suisse internship best payday loan lender uk zero interest balance transfer credit cards canada online credit card generator best no interest credit card deals consolidate credit card debt bad credit student credit cards lloyds credit card calculator with 2 interest rates the best credit cards in canada bank of america visa reward cards southwest credit card offer phone number cash advance using bpi credit card westpac visa credit card travel insurance pre approved credit card offers forum bank of america business accept credit cards are credit card consolidation loans good best gas credit cards for students standard chartered credit card offers on dining should i get a 401k loan to pay off credit card debt sample uk credit card number tips for getting a secured credit card hsbc old orchard credit card best 3 month payday loans hdfc bank credit cards reward points how to get a us credit card outside us accepting credit cards small business company credit card policy nz bad credit loans online uk list best credit card processing companies best cash rewards credit card canada 2013 how to get us credit card for foreigners best cash back credit card canada 2011 virgin credit card ppi phone number planet fitness black card cancellation fee best business credit cards 2012 australia apply for a credit card hsbc loans similar to magnum cash advance best cash back rewards credit cards 2013 chase british airways credit card offer best credit card for no credit students best offer credit card india hdfc bank credit card payment by cheque banks that accept american express cash advance no foreign transaction fee prepaid credit card long term personal loans with bad credit contact cashplus mastercard small cash loans now new credit card charges law fixed rate credit card definition how to transfer balance to new credit card walmart credit card cash back rules natwest online credit card disappeared rewards credit card comparison canada cibc credit card balance phone number online payday lenders only credit cards for bad credit with no checking account required best credit card for purchases 2012 american express platinum card travel chase slate credit card ratings neiman marcus credit card payment where can i buy an american express prepaid credit card chase visa card application calculate credit card interest rate payment icici gold credit card limit payday loans uk direct lenders i want a credit card with bad credit natwest student credit card contact number us bank secured credit card myfico best canadian air travel credit card best visa travel rewards card hsbc direct rewards discover credit card credit card purchase protection under ?100 forbes best credit cards for college students top 10 credit cards in canada 2013 what is the easiest unsecured credit card to get approved for pre qualified credit cards offers walmart credit card application instant approval payday advance direct lenders south africa barclays us airways credit card application status bank of america air canada credit card pay sbi credit card bill online icici bank uob credit card travel promotion list of all credit cards legal requirements for storing credit card information can you make best buy credit card payments in store hsbc advance platinum credit cards charge for going over credit limit virgin credit cards uk post office prepaid credit card review hdfc credit card reward points catalogue 2012 pdf unsecured credit cards for bad credit not prepaid bad credit car finance bristol square credit card canada review do company credit cards affect credit score best secured credit card for no credit history stats canada credit card debt air miles credit card uk online application for credit card bpi the best credit cards to have 2013 car rental no credit card no credit check hdfc credit card rewards points redemption how to pay sbi credit card bill online from citibank square credit card app for windows phone free prepaid credit cards that build credit cash loans today with no bank account yes bank credit cards india what to look for when comparing credit cards can i pay my lane bryant credit card in the store cnn best credit cards for bad credit how do i redeem icici credit card reward points cibc visa debit card on paypal teachers credit union credit cards balance transfer calculator fee best payday loans for bad credit best cashback credit card malaysia 2013 credit card verification form (ccvf) easy cash loans online south africa buy prepaid credit card online preloaded credit cards australia check my visa gift card balance online paypal ebay credit card payment walmart credit card cash advance limit sears credit card application phone same day payday advance online cash advance ukraine gas station credit cards for no credit fast payday loans online direct lenders bank of america credit card processing for small business best prepaid credit card in canada credit cards with airmiles rewards credit card processing companies new jersey apply for western union gold card prepaid credit card online canada sears kmart credit card list of department store credit cards for bad credit android credit card app uk top 50 credit card processing companies what are the best credit card deals right now royal bank of scotland student credit card chase credit card rewards center best online cash advances reviews what is a credit card cvv security code how do you change your credit card details on ebay td emerald visa card benefits can you get a cash advance on a capital one credit card usaa college credit card review first horizon credit card business credit card machines cost student credit cards with no credit no cosigner best credit cards for students with no income where can i get a bad credit credit card where can i buy virtual credit cards unsecured credit card debt canada hdfc credit card online payment through sbi credit card apply cibc credit card online ann taylor credit card review sbi advantage credit card online apply payday loans no credit check no guarantor no fees no brokers venture capital credit card account pc financial credit card balance best platinum credit cards uk very bad credit loans uk platinum credit card icici offers balance transfer credit card student loan get a personal loan with bad credit online what is hdfc cash advance fee prepaid credit cards canada what can you buy with a horizon gold card applying for a credit card natwest halifax credit card online security pay day loans for bad credit barclays platinum simplicity credit card top credit cards in india 2012 tesco interest free credit card 13 month the best credit card balance transfer deals coach credit card holder visa credit card applications canada continental finance matrix discover credit card reviews prepaid visa cards with no fees visa virtual credit card number wells fargo credit card cash advance limit citifinancial credit card contact can you transfer from credit card to bank account credit card processing machines 0 interest balance transfer credit cards in dubai wells fargo cash advance fee bank of america visa cash card history first credit card issued need 5000 loan bad credit fast toysrus com creditcard 3 best credit cards for students in singapore cibc credit cards contact td visa student credit cards southwest credit card review 2013 visa secured credit cards to rebuild credit my toyota visa rewards card business credit cards for bad credit history apply for credit cards online hdfc titanium international credit card review icici credit card emi interest calculator alertpay not accepting credit cards best credit cards uk 2011 american express preloaded credit cards vcc virtual credit card indonesia ebay credit card payment processing best credit card 0 apr what is a no balance transfer fee credit card bmo air miles credit card usa prepaid credit card online credit card for small business with no credit canada how to calculate credit card apr calculator bmo secured credit cards in canada lowest credit card rate ever super cash payday advance hours hsbc orchard credit card phone number citibank credit card low interest sbi credit card login credit card processing comparison tool get credit card with bad credit score citibank balance transfer 2013 balance transfer credit card australia compare nissan visa cash card offer brought to you by edmunds com compare cheap credit cards barclay credit card app who has the best credit card processing rates quickbooks credit card processing login online credit card application for sbi bank rbc debit visa card best buy credit card application report code 25 credit report free uk new visa credit card fees kotak mahindra credit cards online apply american express black credit card bank of america business credit card login citi corporate credit card payment capital one credit card customer service cash advances payday loans nj credit card approval formula target visa credit card payment address can you get a credit card with bad credit in canada axis bank credit cards details business credit cards bad credit history jcpenney credit card payment options ge credit card list can you pay sears credit card at store long black cardigan sweater average credit card rate 2013 visa prepaid credit card no fees secure credit card bank of america student no credit history credit cards how to make a hdfc credit card payment online allahabad bank india card master international credit card capital one small business credit card rewards city bank credit card emi offers can you get store credit cards with bad credit citibank credit card offers on makemytrip public savings bank open sky secured visa card visa mastercard credit card processing fees how to apply for credit card in sbi bank balance transfer fee free credit cards credit cards for international students in usa free credit card details that work credit cards with bad credit rating in australia how do handheld credit card machines work best corporate credit card for small business barclays credit card payment options accept credit cards free machine apply for a halifax clarity credit card best air miles rewards credit card canada test credit card numbers with security code paypal sears mastercard credit card review credit cards for bad credit history myfico credit card finder business credit card reward schemes how to pay back wells fargo direct deposit advance southwest rapid rewards business credit card mortgages for bad credit what;s the best no fee credit card how to get credit card company to increase limit credit card score ranges best rewards credit cards in canada going over credit limit bank of america credit card banks usa aarp chase visa credit cards how to get credit card online free chevron credit card application status test credit card numbers india credit card with no credit check uk merchant visa credit card fees where to buy prepaid credit cards in toronto uk credit card size cash loans nowra poor credit rating credit cards 0 balance transfers iphone credit card processing why is my credit card limit reduced how to pay icici credit card bill online from hdfc credit card ways to pay off credit card debt faster chase credit card travel notification can you use visa prepaid credit cards online how do cash advances work on credit cards student credit cards 0 interest comenity pay lane bryant credit card canadian credit cards cash back first time credit card no credit history instant online loans no credit check nationwide online loan quote standard chartered credit card offers on mobiles best credit card company for first timers credit card settlement process diagram south west trains gold card oyster anz visa card protection circuit city credit card chase bank easy quick cash loans small business credit card processing reviews instant payday loan no credit check hdfc credit card login page india elavon credit card processing software where is the credit card number located on an american express credit card axis bank credit card easy emi offers best cash rewards credit cards best credit card offers 2012 canada offer credit card company settlement online payday advance uk sear credit card customer service unsecured discover card for bad credit im 18 which credit card should i get how to apply for barclays credit card online capital one secured credit cards bad credit how to download free apps for ipad 2 without credit card where can i pay sears credit card best credit card terminal for restaurants freedom credit card pay as you go chase credit limit increase transfer money from capital one credit card to bank account wells fargo secured credit card status hdfc bank credit card login page bank of america credit card merchant account credit card bank rakyat indonesia black cardamom curry usaa secured credit card anonymous virtual credit cards secured credit card canada compare bad credit loans no credit check unsecured credit card information form html citibank secured credit card visa get a credit card instantly with bad credit what is the average minimum payment on a credit card what credit card should i get for my small business credit cards after bankruptcy discharge uk us bank visa corporate credit card hdfc flight offer credit card best way to use a credit card to build your credit lufthansa miles and more credit card online-kartenkonto 0 financing credit card balance transfers instant bad credit loans canada secured credit card banks bmo prepaid credit card canada first premier bank credit card account access what about prepaid travel credit cards and overseas atms citibank credit card online application form india best credit card offers for travel what are the numbers on the back of credit cards online credit card payment system singapore dillards credit card payment center canada low interest credit cards balance transfer credit card payment processing fees good credit cards for students can you buy prepaid credit cards at walgreens bank of america credit card exchange rates walmart credit card credit requirements commonwealth bank cash advance rate lic online payment through sbi credit card easy credit cards to get approved for ireland disney world credit card canada prepaid credit cards no fees walmart icici credit card status online tesco credit card online payment starbucks credit card how can i get a credit card with no credit score easiest unsecured credit card to get with bad credit hsbc debit visa card issue number best credit card to get with no credit history what credit cards can i apply for with bad credit best travel credit card canada 2012 visa credit card numbers start with 4 free credit cards that works info barclays credit card contact number
Home BoB Documents PEDs Mitchell Report Scorecard: Tracking the Impact of the Mitchell Report

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 955 guests online

Atom RSS

Scorecard: Tracking the Impact of the Mitchell Report PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 5
Mitchell Report
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 17 December 2007 11:09

The flowing is a list of actions and activities in response to the Mitchell Report. Please check the "Updated" timestamp to see when this document was last updated.

This document can be accessed from the Mitchell Report section of The Biz of Baseball at any time in the future by selecting:

BoB Documents > PEDs > Mitchell Report from our navigation tier to the left of the site:

UPDATED: 12/18/07 (2:30pm ET)

Admitted Use of PEDs After Report's Release

What the report states:
Player Response:  Story Link
  • Paul Byrd
(Pgs. 245-246) On October 21, 2007, the San Francisco Chronicle reported that Cleveland Indians pitcher Paul Byrd had bought nearly $25,000 worth of human growth hormone and syringes from the Palm Beach Rejuvenation Center, one of the anti-aging clinics implicated in the Signature Pharmacy investigation, in thirteen transactions between August 2002 and January 2005. According to the story, Byrd used his credit card to purchase the substance and received more than 1,000 vials of human growth hormone in the transactions, which were sent to his home in Georgia, to the spring training facility of the Atlanta Braves, where he was playing at the time, and in one instance to a New York hotel.

In public comments in response to the article, Byrd admitted that he had been taking human growth hormone but said that he had been using it to treat a tumor on his pituitary gland. Byrd reportedly said that he had never taken “any hormone or drug that was not prescribed” to him by a doctor.The Chronicle reported that two of Byrd’s prescriptions had been written by a Florida dentist whose license was suspended in 2003.
Byrd met with baseball officials Monday (12/17/07) to discuss his use of human growth hormone.

It's uncertain whether Byrd will face any discipline from the commissioner's office or when a potential punishment might be handed down.

Among those at the meeting were Rob Manfred, baseball's executive vice president for labor relations, and Michael Weiner, general counsel for the players' association.
  • Brian Roberts
(Pg. 158) According to [Larry] Bigbie, however, in 2004 Roberts admitted to him that he had injected himself once or twice with steroids in 2003. Until this admission, Bigbie had never suspected Roberts of using steroids.

In order to provide Roberts with information about these allegations and to give him an opportunity to respond, I asked him to meet with me; he declined.

"I would like to address the allegations that were made against me in the Mitchell Report. I will begin by saying that I have worked very hard to develop a good reputation both on and off the field. I have always taken pride in being a man of integrity and values. I know that by being a professional athlete, I am held to a very high standard. I never have and never will take that for granted. However, I am also human and I have made mistakes.

"In 2003, when I took one shot of steroids, I immediately realized that this was not what I stood for or anything that I wanted to continue doing. I never used steroids, human growth hormone or any other performance-
enhancing drugs prior to or since that single incident. I can honestly say before God, myself, my family and all of my fans that steroids or any performance-
enhancing drugs have never had any effect on what I have worked so hard to accomplish in the game of baseball. I am very sorry and I deeply regret ever making that terrible decision. My only hope and prayer is that the Orioles, my family, friends and fans that have supported me so faithfully will forgive me."

  • Fernando Vina 
(Pgs. 213-214) While [Kirk] Radomski was working for the Mets as a clubhouse attendant in 1993, he
met Vina, who was then in the Mets minor league system. Radomski stated that he sold anabolic
steroids or human growth hormone to Vina six to eight times during 2000 to 2005. Radomski produced three checks from Vina. Radomski stated that these checks reflected a March 2003 purchase by Vina of human growth hormone, an April 2003 purchase by Vina of steroids, most likely Winstrol, and a July 2005 purchase by Vina of Deca-Durabolin.
"I never bought steroids from him. All I used was HGH," Vina said in an interview on ESPN... "I tried everything rehabbing," Vina said. "I came to a point that I was desperate." ... "Was it right? No. Obviously, it was wrong," Vina said. "I'm embarrassed by it."
  • Gary Bennett, Jr.
(Pg. 222) Kirk Radomski said that Denny Neagle referred Bennett to him. Neagle and Bennett were teammates in 2001 and 2002 with the Colorado Rockies. Radomski recalled one transaction with Bennett in July 2003 for two kits of human growth hormone. Radomski produced one check from Bennett payable to Kirk Radomski in the amount of $3,200 dated July 13, 2003.

"Obviously, it was a stupid decision," Bennett said. "It was a mistake. It was some-
thing that quite obviously, you regret now."

  • Andy Pettitte
(Pg. 176) [In 2002] [Brian] McNamee traveled to Tampa at Pettitte’s request and spent about ten days assisting Pettitte with his rehabilitation. McNamee recalled that he injected Pettitte with human growth hormone that McNamee obtained from Radomski on two to four occasions. Pettitte paid McNamee for the trip and his expenses; there was no separate payment for the human growth hormone.
In 2002 I was injured. I had heard that human growth hormone could promote faster healing for my elbow. I felt an obligation to get back to my team as soon as possible. For this reason, and only this reason, for two days I tried human growth hormone. Though it was not against baseball rules, I was not comfortable with what I was doing, so I stopped. This is it -- two days out of my life; two days out of my entire career, when I was injured and on the disabled list.
  • F.P.
(Pgs. 182-183) [Kirk] Radomski believed that Santangelo was referred to him by David Segui when both played for the Expos between 1995 and 1997. Radomski produced one check from Santangelo dated October 23, 2000 in the amount of $1,400, which Radomski said was payment for a kit of human growth hormone. Radomski also recalled selling Deca-Durabolin and testosterone to Santangelo once or twice during 2001 when Santangelo was with the Oakland Athletics.
"I admitted it and I faced the music. And if by me being embarrassed helps generations to come not have to make the difficult decisions that I had to make, then it's good that this all came out. But I don't want to be Mr. Public Speaker and go talk to every high school in the world. Through my radio show, I just hope to get the word out about how bad this stuff is."

Denies Use of PEDs After Report's Release

What the report states:
 Player Response:Story Link
  • Roger Clemens
(Pg. 169) Toward the end of the [1998] road trip which included the Marlins series, or shortly after the Blue Jays returned home to Toronto, Clemens approached [Brian] McNamee and, for the first time, brought up the subject of using steroids. Clemens said that he was not able to inject himself, and he asked for McNamee’s help.

Later that summer, Clemens asked McNamee to inject him with Winstrol, which Clemens supplied. McNamee knew the substance was Winstrol because the vials Clemens gave him were so labeled. McNamee injected Clemens approximately four times in the buttocks over a several-week period with needles that Clemens provided. Each incident took place in Clemens’s apartment at the SkyDome. McNamee never asked Clemens where he obtained the steroids.

"I want to state clearly and without qualification: I did not take steroids, human growth hormone or any other banned substances at any time in my baseball career or, in fact, my entire life," Clemens said Tuesday in a statement issued through his agent, Randy Hendricks. "Those substances represent a dangerous and destructive shortcut that no athlete should ever take.

"I am disappointed that my 25 years in public life have apparently not earned me the benefit of the doubt, but I understand that Senator Mitchell's report has raised many serious questions. I plan to publicly answer all of those questions at the appropriate time in the appropriate way. I only ask that in the meantime people not rush to judgment."

Clemens fires back, denies taking steroids or HGH
  • Brendan Donnelly
(Pg. 224) Radomski said that Donnelly was referred to him by Adam Riggs. Both Riggs and Donnelly played for the Angels in 2003 and 2004. Radomski recalled that Donnelly called him in 2004 looking for Anavar, an anabolic steroid. Radomski made one sale to Donnelly of Deca-Durabolin for which Donnelly paid $250 to $300.
"Upon learning that Anavar was classified as a steroid, I realized that was not an option," Donnelly said. "That was the end of it. Yes, I called him. But I did not purchase or receive anything from him. I never took Deca or Anavar. I do want to fully support the testing program of Major League Baseball, and I support wider testing."
  • Alex Cabrera
(Pg. 94) Sometime in mid-September  2000, a clubhouse employee with the Arizona Diamondbacks discovered a bottle of anabolic steroids and several hundred pills in a package that had been mailed to the Diamondbacks’ ballpark in Phoenix. Clubhouse attendants knew that the package had been intended for Alex Cabrera, then a player on Arizona’s major league roster, who had been searching for the package for several days. They gave the box to the team’s athletic trainer and told Cabrera that the package probably had been lost.
"I couldn't have used the substances that are identified," Cabrera said. "I never had possession of the alleged box that supposedly contained the pharmaceutical drugs."
  • David Justice
(Pg. 181) [Kirk] Radomski said he made one sale to Justice, which occurred after the 2000 World Series. Justice played for the Yankees that year. Justice paid Radomski by check for two or three kits of human growth hormone. Radomski said that he cashed this check. Brian McNamee recalled that Justice asked him about human growth hormone in 2000 or 2001, while McNamee and Justice were both with the Yankees. According to McNamee, Justice admitted in this conversation that he had obtained human growth hormone from Radomski.
"I've never seen Roger do anything nor have I ever had a conversation with him [about steroids]," Justice, appearing as a guest on the "The Herd" on ESPN Radio, said Friday. "He should be doing what I'm doing. He should be talking about it. If you really didn't do it, say something about it. At least have a conversation about it."

Other Public Responses After Report's Release

 Date Player Player Response:Story Link
  • Alex Rodriguez

(From 60 Minutes interview)

Rodriguez answered "No" when asked whether he's ever used steroids, human growth hormone or any other performance-enhancing substance.

"I've never felt overmatched on the baseball field," he said. "... I felt that if I did my, my work as I've done since I was, you know, a rookie back in Seattle, I didn't have a problem competing at any level."


  • Jason Varitek

(Regarding being on false "leaked list" of supposed names within the Mitchell Reports that was published on WNBC.com)

“I’d like to know where it came from, no question,” Varitek said yesterday by phone when asked if he was aware of the false report. “From what I know now, I guess (bad information) had been passed around all morning. More than anything, you’re just concerned about how something like that could happen.”

  • Johnny Damon

(Regarding being on false "leaked list" of supposed names within the Mitchell Reports that was published on WNBC.com)

"It sucks, I am wondering if there is any legal course to turn to," Damon said. "I walk around with my shirt off. If I had anything to hide I wouldn't do that. I really don't know what to say. There seems to be some people who don't like me...

"I asked my agent about legal action, but he said it wasn't worth it. Maybe the president [of NBC] will write me a nice letter."


  • Albert Pujols

(Regarding being on false "leaked list" of supposed names within the Mitchell Reports that was published on WNBC.com)

"It has come to my attention that several national and local news outlets have published false reports that associated my name with the Mitchell Report. I have never disrespected, nor cheated the game of baseball and knew without a doubt that my name would not be mentioned in the official investigation. I would like to express how upset and disappointed I am over the reckless reporting that took place this morning. It has caused me and my family a lot of senseless aggravation due to their inaccurate information."

 Research by Maury Brown  - From various sources.

Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football and The Biz of Basketball (The Biz of Hockey will be launching shortly). He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?