como comprar proventil dutas online ordering acquisto glycomet sicuro online order amoxil from india without prescription bayer financial results 2012 how do i get propecia in the uk billig clonidine online kaufen is generic serpina effective the online drugstore digoxin buy actonel mexican pharmacies is solodyn better than minocycline cheapest zyloprim proventil coupons discounts shallaki online coupon code order furosemide from uk without prescription buy provera tablets uk buy sustiva metformin pcos weight loss pregnancy is it illegal to order generic isoniazid buy cipro lowest price buy revia tablets online purchase coversyl cheap buy evecare 20 buy kamagra online india ajanta how much does accutane cost albendazole by mail order minipress in the uk list of tesco stores selling singulair how to order cialis online in canada brittle asthma symptoms can you buy pharmacy online nizoral famciclovir famvir and valacyclovir valtrex order desyrel buy amaryllis bulbs wholesale canadian pharmacy prandin valacyclovir 1000 mg valtrex lipitor on line in the canada micronase no rx anafranil online overnight bystolic dosage schedule antivert prices cvs generic accutane sale high blood pressure medicine clonidine retail price proventil hfa can you buy fucidin cream over counter depakote india how long for zyrtec d to take effect filme onlain 2012 how to get imuran in australia eurax lotion for scabies buy tamoxifen online no prescription nolvadex zetia 10 mg cost trazodone tablets ndc order yasmin uk pharmacy viagra with debit card co irbesartan side effects where to buy alli canada why has atrovent been discontinued pills for erectile dysfunction otc buy buspar with visa prednisone pharmacies cod lozol mg tablet where to buy finpecia cheap generic buy glyset online usa transdermal estradiol patches buy lopid 100 is there a generic for aciphex levlen discount code torsemide express canada allopurinol class action lawsuit best online pharmacy generic zithromax side effects of losartan tablets paxil spain canadian beauty blog drugstore makeup advair diskus prescribing information brafix side effects uk pletal uk online one man one jar real video buy abilify uk generic micronase cost buy viagra online canada no prescription alli no prescription discounts generic india pharmacy prednisone how to buy aygestin in london erythromycin cost walmart suprax next day purchase lioresal cheap acheter livebox 2 orange oxycodone l368 best mexican pharmacies quality how to buy promethazine codeine syrup elavil ndc code leucistic alligator snapping turtle for sale brand viagra pfizer online dutas tablets 150 mg buy viagra 150 mg purchase biaxin in australia buy fmla hong kong forte liquifilm canadian alliance of british pensioners cabp where to buy cymbalta online lasix for men sale in uk buy nitrofurantoin online uk buy busbar lasix pills identify para que se usa el medicamento prilosec spironolactone heart failure dose canadian glucotrol xl cheap prescription order aciclovir online with visa femcare over the couter femcare sold over counter ranitidine tablets before c section what is in codeine cough syrup prescriptions in australia generic buy viagra online himcolin sale generic vpxl canadian medications without prescription periactin on line purchase zoloft 10 mg dosage what is promethazine with codeine syrup red used for strattera echeck lithium orotate buy uk fluoxetine hcl 20 mg capsule side effects where can i get some decadron skelaxin online from canada northwest pharmacy promo coupon code switching from propranolol to atenolol where to buy tamoxifen online discount alphagan for discount starlix delivery mexican online pharmacy .1 retin-a order actos 30 mg clomid success on cycle 2; buy diclofenac with paypal where to buy viagra super active online canada is accutane legal in uk phone in order for erexor can buy aricept online tricor buy on line slovenska viagra-cena allopurinol online prescription comprar brand viagra ginseng salem ct lasix buy no prescription buy viagra uk online over the counter mentat comprar propecia proscar finasteride gene'rico tratamiento benicar hct discount coupon tadalafil tablets 40 mg ponstel buy canada buy hydrochlorothiazide online usa cost of premarin without insurance floxin where can i buy it levaquin 250 mg tablet hay pastillas para abortar fast premarin deleviery what is estradiol used for can order ashwagandha canada actos from europe generic vermox canada how much wellbutrin do i need to take to lose weight purchase entocort pills how much does cipro 500mg cost buy cheap alli pfizer generic lipitor rosuvastatin online meds sominex sleeping tablets voltaren trusted online drug stores in canada venta de viagra en farmacias en chile buy generic propecia canada cialis prescription coupon decadron italiano propranolol dosage portal hypertension actos ships from india flomax from usa pharmacy seven second red pill spring valley acai berry reviews synthroid 50 mg price class action lawsuit against dilantin metformin recommended dosage pcos side effects of bystolic generic rogaine 5 for sale on line where coversyl erectile dysfunction vitamin deficiency online pharmacy no prescription required for albendazole, overnight delivery what if i missed a dose of coumadin cyproheptadine over the counter what does kamagra chewable bentyl tabletas 10 mg what are the side effects of xenical orlistat bupropion hcl sr 200 mg price one man one jar iphone video methotrexate to purchase without a prescription 100 mg acivir pills order viagra soft from mexico without prescription legal to buy buspar liquid duetact review cheap pills buy bentyl online irritable cialis viagra canada drugstore generic rocaltrol buy canada buy viagra riyadh over the counter promethazine codeine syrup pharmacy that sells remeron buy generic exelon online caverta online meds ponstel medication cost liv 52 generic reviews cephalexin over the counter canada lantus solostar in thailand trileptal suppliers overseas zoloft dose increase side effects clomid price at walmart buy accutane bulk atomoxetine hydrochloride vs. adderall dapoxetine brand order acai berry cleanse coupons is tamsulosin the generic for flomax can you buy allegra 180 mg over the counter customer reviews celadrin cream levitra 20mg buy doxycycline antibiotic dosage dogs diclofenac sodium enteric-coated tablets of 75 mg indian generics online voveran sr tadalafil 5 mg price imitrex without prescription vpxl mg canadian rx do you need rx hyaluronic acid piracetam powder uk trileptal tablets for purchase best prices buy prandin drugs comprar sinequan online generic zetia paypal buy zoloft online america amitriptyline purchase uk cefixime online bestellen zithromax sale online price of generic for clozaril 100mg plavix clopidogrel bisulfate seroquel xr canadian pharmacy prescription cod cordarone online cleocin gel results forum accutane cost canadian orlistat 40mg bula vitamin e deficiency erectile dysfunction how to by coumadin online safe to buy generic albendazole from usa dramamine tablets online over the counter aciclovir tablets uk ciplactin weight gain challenge buy mestinon hong kong clomid 50 mg tablets purchase fml forte orlistat next day delivery metoprolol side effects sweating buy generic cialis soft health canada yasmin purchase generic paroxetine buy cialis cheap uk discount atorlip-20 mg benadryl on line zoloft prescription drug adalat retard dosage how much will lipitor generic cost generic for cardizem la accutane 5 mg canada hunter rain boots promo code methotrexate canadian pharmacy what is colchicine for viagra professional order in the us viagra uk sale brand viagra online overnight shipping can order shatavari canada lisinopril in canada order viagra professional from india without prescription side effects viagra wiki best place to buy phentermine 37.5 vardenafil 20mg india orthotrycycline buy online Purchase abilify 1 pharmacy guaranteed bactrim online without rx xalatan dosage instructions alphagan pharmacies brimonidine ophthalmic ceftin max dose what is alliteration in poetry yahoo atarax cost without insurance que es la sertralina de 50 mg levothyroxine tablets and alcohol safe buy amantadine online serevent hong kong buy cheap domperidone dosage for inducing lactation what is blopress drugs bystolic common side effects paxil dosage range buy mentat online cheap what is dapoxetine motilium fast mexico saw mower sales service palmetto ga safe camagra jelly uk amitriptyline dose for insomnia buy cialis shoppers drug mart womenra wikipedia buy dramamine online cheap zovirax usa buy trazodone withwhere to buy flagyl metronidazole neurontin suppositories buy prednisolone online forum delivery is there a drug comparative to micardis zovirax 400 mg dosage baclofen without a script apcalis sx over counter uk baylor college of medicine allied health very cheap malegra dxt subsidized cialis nz lisinopril (prinivil zestril) 10 mg tablet biaxin low dose birth control buy proventil online us no prescription acai berry living xs side effect buy cipla products online how to get mircette drug buy tadacip online overnight delivery celebrex order on web canada drugs buy lamisil buy levaquin tablets mexico diclofenac sodium ta and alcohol buy cheap proventil buy ginseng 80 mg online entocort italiano chloramphenicol drug in canada pharmacy prevacid canada head office synthroid dosage forms buy motrin online overnight delivery zithromax 500mg chlamydia 1 channel how i met your mother season 8 episode 13 taking augmentin without food price of maxalt mlt 10 mg buy generic elavil with bonus tadacip for sale uk over counter menosan side effects of long term use of furosemide compare prices cipro cialis super active over the couter 24 medical hotline aciphex without food buy live ants australia phenamax prix en pharmacie en france eulexin refill pack the online drugstore hyaluronic acid us canada border prescription drugs suppliers of chloramphenicol in us cheap flomax online effexor xr overnight pharmacy zyban 10 order accutane 20mg fexofenadine alcohol plavix dosage children current price alli levothyroxine sodium 50 mcg buy actos online overnight pharmacy has best price depakote buy bystolic line bentyl no rx prometrium canada price very cheap ceftin what does nexium 40 mg look like mild anxiety medication over the counter how to take provera 5mg propecia with no prescription retino-a cream 0,025 with paypal payment ciprofloxacin side effects liver order benicar online with visa buy protonix with visa levitra cheap online better than fluoxetine zithromax 5 day dose pack instructions no prescription order buy medrol online non generic cheap buy atorlip buy prednisone mg buy acivir pills fast shipping como comprar na revista hermes pela internet tadapox online bestellen haldol decanoate price can you buy fucidin cream over the counter in ireland betapace direct pharmacy zovirax reviews get zestoretic las vegas indian pharmacy detrol order abilify 3 pharmacy what are the symptoms of chlamydia in the mouth terramycin order by phone colchicine pharmacy free shipping where to capoten buy over the counter motilium online buy pravachol new zealand online buy mobicool uk adalat tablets price cheap beconase aq pills cleocin medication treatment getting off wellbutrin weight gain zestril medication online keppra cost help pill rx health order lisinopril products giving methotrexate injections side effect of furosemide 40 mg atorvastatin generic coupons cheapest serophene buy aciclovir without a script walmart pharmacy discount drugs onlinecheappills.com flomax generic costco professional no prescription discounts levitra online statistics having twins clomid paroxetine hcl cost can i get in trouble for ordering viagra online hoodia medication side effects what is zantac tablets used for can bentyl be abused vardenafil hcl 10 mg tab what types of rumalaya forte are there bactroban online prescription venlor generic wikipedia drugs indian pharmacy graduate association augmentin user reviews atarax medication overnight delivery donde comprar acai berry en costa rica sky pharmacy leeds ventolin inhalers over the counter can you buy xbox live time with microsoft points can you get pregnant after methotrexate where can i purchase leanspa acai naprosyn tablets 1000mg motilium canadian online overnight pharmacy serophene from usa order suhagra-100 where to buy gar fish meat mail order generic lynoral deltasone cost without insurance hyzaar overnight delivery cialis soft canada no prescription what does ditropan xl treat valtrex 500 mg once a day generic lasix pictures discount canadian pharmacy flovent digoxin lowest price purchase adalat 5 pharmacy is it illegal to order generic celadrin long take nolvadex gyno orlistat tablets cymbalta fibromyalgia approval heartworm meds no prescription canada can order medrol canada order ophthacare cheap brand advair diskus tablets uk buy cialis canada pharmacy delivery buy diclofenac cash order viagra sublingual buy viagra over the counter uk brand amoxil without insurance femara canada overnight delivery canadian alliance of physiotherapy exam administers prevacid discount voucher femara drug store online buy clozaril 40 terramycin 40mg allegra over counter cost doxycycline hyclate vs. minocycline for acne brand amoxil pill shortage side effects of crestor 10mg tablets phenergan dosage too high buying glucotrol xl proscar tablets for hair loss cialis uses toprol xl dosage for arrhythmia brand viagra no prrescription toprol xl medicine buy erexor in singapore coumadin comprar lexapro lawsuit side effects antivert cost canadian ordering cytotec canada is it safe to use viagra every day midamor by mail doxycycline hyclate 100mg capsules for acne ciprofloxacin hcl 500mg dosage is there a discount card for plavix discount dostinex otc glucotrol xl from india where can you buy viagra online terramycin plus generic name what do aricept pills look like lisinopril no prescription zestril yeast infection treatment diflucan dose blue sky pharmacy in canada actos coupons free what is the dosage for claritin reditabs viagra online per nachnahme arthrotec w uk can i get astelin amoxil lowest price synthroid by mail cheapest evista paypal is sominex available over the counter buy famvir singapore
Home Maury Brown Miller's Snub: Time to Overhaul Veterans Committee (again)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 759 guests online

Atom RSS

Miller's Snub: Time to Overhaul Veterans Committee (again) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 03 December 2007 07:28

Maury BrownThe results of this year’s Veterans Committee vote has been released, and with that we see former commissioner Bowie Kuhn, former Dodgers owner Walter O'Malley, ex-Pirates owner Barney Dreyfuss and managers Dick Williams and Billy Southworth elected.

Snubbed (again) is Marvin Miller, the former executive director of the MLB Player’s Association, who’s shadow and mark on the game is so large, it staggers the imagination that he’s not been elected prior.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Marvin Miller)

Or, should our minds be boggled?

The time has arrived for the make up of the Veterans Committee to be reevaluated and overhauled. As Miller himself said to Murray Chass of the NY Times this past week:

“People have asked me about it,” Miller said, speaking of the committee’s makeup. “I don’t know why they did this except, other than me, it makes sense to have a group like this because they are a management-oriented group voting on management people.”

And therein is the crux of the problem. Therein lies the travesty.

If the committee’s makeup is wholly management-based (and I'm not talking former players, but rather representatives from the front office of the MLBPA) is to say that the influence of the MLBPA is nothing more than window dressing. At least consider adding someone like Dick Moss to the committee. Even a token member would remove at least a smidgen of what appears to be bias.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Dick Moss)

Shortly after I published this column, a statement by Donald Fehr, the executive director of the MLBPA expressed his disappointment, and placed an exclamation point on what I have expressed here:

“Because he was the Players' voice, and represented them vigorously, Marvin Miller was the owners' adversary. This time around, a majority of those voting were owner representatives, and results of the vote demonstrate the effect that had.  In the last vote, Marvin received 63% of the votes, this time he got 25%.  By contrast, Bowie Kuhn received 17% of the votes last time, but got 83% this time."

"I think it was rigged, but not to keep me out. It was rigged to bring some of these in,'' Miller said by telephone after being informed of the results by The Associated Press. "It's not a pretty picture.''

The interesting sidebar to this is the election of Bowie Kuhn, a man that can best be described as being a reactionary to Miller’s bold entrance and the player’s ascension into the most powerful sports union in history. Arguably, Kuhn was simply a man at a certain place at a certain time. The history was made by almost exclusively by others on his watch (the induction of O’Malley highlights this tremendously), not by the man himself. Kuhn fought tooth and nail against the changes Miller proposed.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Bowie Kuhn)

While it is good to see that at least this vote garnered inductions, Miller’s clear snub will be the focus today and until the time the next vote is conducted. Sadly, given Miller’s age, there are the odds that he will have passed away before then.

Maybe Miller isn’t concerned about not being in the Hall. After all, most anyone that knows the pulse of the game understands the incredible mark he has made on upon it – a mark that continues today. It seems that those on the Veterans Committee have chosen to look the other way, or have no understanding of the pulse of the game today, somehow bitter of Miller's change, or still stuck in the past to the point of ignoring the present.

Given that, it’s time to reevaluate the Veterans Committee makeup (yet, again. See changes made to this year's system from the system prior below). Until such day as key individuals from labor are on the committee, incredible gaffs such as the non-induction of Marvin Miller will continue to take place. Given the enormous influence that the MLBPA has had on the game of baseball, it is imperative that they have a seat at the table on the committee. How Marvin Miller could not be considered part of baseball’s “fame” staggers the imagination.

As Fehr closed in his statement today, “The failure to elect Marvin Miller is an unfortunate and regrettable decision.  Without question, the Hall of Fame is poorer for it.” 

CHANGES TO THE VETERANS COMMITTEE SYSTEM 

PREVIOUS RULE

NEW RULE

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members, Frick and Spink Award winners (total of 80-plus) cast ballots on Players ballot

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members, Frick and Spink Award winners (total of 80-plus) cast ballots on Composite ballot

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members (63) cast ballots on Players ballot

Electorate: Committee of 16 individuals (Hall of Famers, veteran writers, executives and historians) cast ballots on a managers/umpires ballot
 

Players ballot: Voted on every two years, in odd years (2003, 2005, 2007, etc). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast was elected

Composite ballot: Voted on every four years (2003, 2007, etc.). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast was elected
 

Players ballot: Voted on every two years, in odd years, starting in 2009 (2009, 2011, 2013, etc). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast will be elected

Managers/umpires ballot: Voted on every two years in even years, starting in 2008 (2008, 2010, 2012, etc.). Anyone to received votes on 75% of ballots cast will be elected

Eligible candidates: All players with 10 or more years experience. Any candidate on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list was not eligible for consideration Eligible candidates: All players with 10 or more years experience, whose careers began in 1943 or later. Any candidate on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list is not eligible for consideration
Pre-World War II Players: Part of Player ballot

 
Pre-World War II Players: Will be reviewed by a Board-appointed committee of 12 individuals (Hall of Famers, veteran writers, and historians) every five years beginning in 2009
BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrowed list of players to 200

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrowed list of managers, umpires and executives to 60
 

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrows list of players to 20; Simultaneously, a screening committee of six Hall of Famers choose five players; list of players to contain 20-25 names, depending on duplicate results

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrows list of managers and umpires to 10

A screening committee of 60 BBWAA members narrowed list of players from 200 to 25; Simultaneously, a screening committee of six Hall of Famers chose five players; final ballot contained 25-30 names, depending on duplicate results

A screening committee of 60 BBWAA members narrowed list of managers, umpires and executives to 15

The living Hall of Fame members, acting as its own screening committee, narrows list of 25-30, to a final ballot of 10, by paper ballot.

No screening committee for managers and umpires.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football and The Biz of Basketball (The Biz of Hockey will be launching shortly). He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?