no credit check credit card applications credit card protection on purchases over ?100 small business rewards credit cards bmo guaranteed credit cards barclays apple credit card phone number credit card fraud for dummies - 44 minute documentary buy virtual visa gift card online first cash advance hours best no annual fee credit card 2013 platinum card american express limit compare all chase credit cards student credit cards with no credit no income capital one 0 interest credit cards sbi online credit card payment login paypal credit card verification not working chase freedom credit card cash back categories how long does it take to get credit card once approved hsbc apply credit card philippines neiman marcus credit card minimum payment visa credit card movie offers india credit card debt settlement process natwest credit card fraud centre virtual credit card number usa best southwest airlines credit card deals rewards canada credit cards 2011 travel rewards credit cards for bad credit capital one prepaid credit cards best visa card rewards request credit limit increase capital one citibank credit card interest rates in india best high limit credit cards to apply for how to get a secured credit card with no credit best secured credit cards to rebuild credit 2011 idbi credit card apply online charge credit cards online free credit score needed for firestone credit card what is the best secured credit card to get hotel reward credit card reviews best american airlines credit card 2012 joint credit card nationwide air miles credit card uk shoppers drug mart credit card easy to get gift credit cards online purchases credit card cash advance paypal compare bank of america credit cards walmart mastercard gift card hsbc credit card promotions for hotels hotel reward credit cards canada air canada credit card offers lost visa card uk mophie marketplace credit card reader for intuit gopayment for apple iphone 4 can i use discover credit card in canada charge free credit cards abroad retail store credit cards for poor credit call chase freedom credit card customer service remove credit card on file ebay does wi dmv accept credit cards valid credit card number lloyds student credit card ppi can you get a student credit card with no credit capital one credit card app iphone how to get refund on cancelled credit card free credit report no card details required car loan with bad credit and no cosigner canadian walmart credit card application best credit cards for good credit 2013 syndicate bank credit cards online apply capital one secured credit card no credit jp morgan chase credit card settlement compare business credit cards uk 4 major credit cards wells fargo joint credit card application icici credit card online payment billdesk icici credit card offer on ebay my next payday advance fast payday loans online south africa canadian tire cash back credit cards walmart prepaid credit cards canada barclays platinum contactless credit card master credit card standard chartered credit card offers in india where can i use my bp gas credit card high limit credit cards average credit best credit cards reviews compare can i pay for a money order with a credit card at the post office bank of america alaska airlines credit card canada can you sign up for amazon without a credit card how do 0 interest credit cards work easier get credit card credit union apply for a visa mastercard online get a credit card with no credit and no job online loans uk bad credit compare visa credit card australia home mortgages for bad credit visa credit bad credit credit card are capital one good credit cards bank of america credit card report lost barclays bank credit card eligibility aqua credit card online analysis on credit card fraud detection methods project - java citibank credit card cash advance singapore does arco gas have a credit card how bad does applying for credit cards hurt your credit bad credit credit cards guaranteed approval no deposit orchard bank credit card reviews 2011 real credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date 2013 0 percent credit card deals uk interest free credit card balance transfers australia toys r us credit card ge capital barclays visa black card best credit card processing for very small business purchase prepaid credit card usa canadian credit cards with no foreign transaction fee sears application for credit card airline reward credit card reviews virgin credit cards now mbna how to review my apple id without credit card hsbc canada credit card best small business credit card offers 2012 tips for choosing a credit card for travel benefits natwest black card login personal cash loans with bad credit best us credit card no foreign transaction fee credit card transfer balance no interest how to make a fake credit card number mini credit card reader - for iphone ipad ipod touch and android hsbc orchard bank credit card reviews capital one venture for business credit card business credit cards comparison no fee no credit credit card where to buy facebook credits cards best credit card deals 0 balance transfer apply for first financial bank usa credit card best credit cards to use abroad 2013 credit card helpline no halifax credit card cash advance fees citi debit visa card balance check standard chartered credit card points redemption philippines no credit check payday loans same day cash citibank cash rewards credit card offers walmart canada credit card interest rate balance transfer credit cards definition dbs visa debit card application form chase first usa credit card how to hook up a verifone credit card machine best unsecured credit cards to rebuild credit 2013 amazon consumer rewards visa card review wells fargo student credit card cash advance fee td secured credit card canada first gulf bank credit card loan interest rate paypal non-profit credit card processing fees moneysavingexpert best cashback cards hdfc credit card payment online american aadvantage credit card offer low rate credit card westpac home depot credit card services number does costco accept credit cards united cash loans login page cancel commonwealth bank credit card insurance pc mastercard app best credit card rewards programs australia rewards cards uk student credit cards with no credit no cosigner mastercard prepaid credit cards spain legitimate online payday loans online prepaid credit card number ez payday advance watertown sd fast payday loans online direct lenders hilton hhonors credit card uk login best reward credit cards for fair credit virgin 0 credit card balance transfer car loan payment calculator bad credit do you pay interest on cash advances best visa cash back credit card best transfer balance credit cards 2013 gas credit cards bad credit shell credit card promotions 2012 malaysia best bad credit credit cards unsecured hdfc credit card customer care toll free number ambank transfer credit card balance united credit card offer 50000 virgin credit card uk call centre apply for credit card 0 interest rate advance travel pay calculator report td visa card lost how can i accept credit cards over the phone lloyds tsb bank credit card services gold card provident shops african bank personal loans online credit card canada low interest rate my black card visa how to prevent new credit cards from being issued valid stolen credit card numbers is cashback on credit cards taxable business cash advance uk credit card payoff calculator uk tips for getting a secured credit card instant cash back credit cards singapore portable credit card machines for small business bank of america instant credit card approval number calculate credit card interest per month best buy total rewards credit card chase credit card settlement agreement what is the best credit card to build credit history sbi credit card status number search best buy credit card best platinum credit cards 2012 credit card app for ipad 2 bank of america credit card fees abroad how to get a personal loan with bad credit australia how does a credit card work yahoo answers new direct payday loan lenders 2013 chase credit card services jobs what is the best credit card rate available canadian credit card rate comparison home equity credit limit calculator credit card protection plan credit card company uk annual information report credit card getting a credit card with bad credit rating american express canada prepaid credit cards walmart credit card review canada prepaid credit card reviews usa southwest credit card application status instant payday advance online credit card applications online for fair credit square ipad credit card reader bad credit credit cards unsecured instant approval canada veda credit check southwest airlines credit card 2 free flights accepting credit cards online without merchant account how to know sbi credit card status mbna credit card canada review delta rewards credit card reviews store credit cards on iphone app staples credit card business login low interest credit card balance transfer nz applying for multiple credit cards on the same day cash back business credit cards canada paypal ebay credit card payment guaranteed approval credit cards credit card validator c# credit card search tool orchard credit card bill payment chase credit limit increase credit card to build credit rating get your credit card instantly getting a capital one credit card after bankruptcy alaska airlines visa? business credit card excel credit card apr formula lost visa card canada rbc zero interest credit cards no balance transfer fee hsbc international credit card bangladesh sainsburys credit card bank of scotland top 5 credit cards 2013 petrol cashback credit card malaysia at&t wireless credit card machine how to remove halo reach credit limit compare interest free credit cards uk british airways visa card uk best credit cards to have in india td canada trust online visa application pay your american airlines credit card online payday loans no credit check canada krungsri ge credit card online valid credit card numbers generator standard chartered credit card customer care singapore how far back can i reclaim credit card charges secure credit card holder secured canadian credit cards for bad credit top cashback credit cards 2013 bad credit card debt merchant credit card fees visa compare credit card processing uk best low rate credit cards australia apply for mastercard credit card with bad credit square credit card reviews visa credit card app iphone prepaid international credit card visa best online cash advance websites apply for a walmart credit card united air miles credit card uk easy to get credit cards with no credit history long black cardigan hsbc credit card quicken security key chase secured credit card application american first cash advance amazon visa rewards card car rental insurance dbs visa credit card exchange rate disney credit card account login goodyear credit card login account credit card account number location td canada trust student visa application independent payday loan lenders uk sacramento payday loan cash advance complete list of all credit cards pay target visa credit card online lowest apr credit cards credit union mobile phone credit card processing android household bank credit card customer service number psn credit card numbers for sale best small business credit card processing best and worst credit cards for travel insurance airmiles credit card td how to bypass credit card verification paypal bank of america credit card travel miles tesco credit card charges overseas free wireless credit card machines 1950-first credit card (diners) invented by ralph schneider walmart credit card approval can you pay belk credit card with gift card credit card for bad credit instant approval starbucks credit card processor interest free credit cards bad credit rating secured mastercard credit card review best credit cards for poor credit 2012 how to pay hdfc master credit card bill best reward credit cards 2014 rbs credit cards online icici credit card statement online view virgin black credit card criteria best credit card processing companies for small business credit card with no annual fee and low interest rate in india capital one credit card for students with no credit bank of america credit card help phone best delta credit card deal store credit cards for bad credit 2013 apple credit card declined best rewards credit cards no annual fee direct payday loan lender sites capital one secured card credit limit increase uk fair credit loans uk what bank will give me a credit card with bad credit in australia easy department store credit cards with no credit best pay day loans direct lenders cheapest credit card processing companies free prepaid credit cards post office uk credit cards online compare cheap credit cards compare credit card interest rates australia can you get a credit card with bad credit in canada square card credit card reader for iphone ipad & android list of credit card companies victoria secret credit card reviews what credit score do i need for a toys r us credit card which credit card balance transfer how to get a cash advance on your credit card prepaid credit card to build credit score how to apply for credit card in hdfc bank online canadian credit card comparison tool no annual fee credit cards means creditcard post office credit card login icici credit card online payment gateway weekly pay loans best buy credit card protection plan best company to get a credit card with bad credit best credit card usa holiday best travel rewards points credit card canada app for rewards cards android credit card reward offers 2012 cash back credit cards canada comparison chase united credit card customer service number how to get credit card details from xbox bank of america credit card phone numbers citi aadvantage credit card review how does a credit/debit card work online hsbc credit card application status credit card with no credit history capital one best buy business credit card best interest free credit card uk instant virtual credit cards how long does it take to get a natwest student credit card vanilla prepaid visa card canada balance best gas credit cards to get best southwest credit card deal best credit card for business who has the best rewards credit card bank of america credit card travel rewards consolidate credit card debt canada bad credit online payday loans no teletrack hdfc credit card toll free number punjab can i use my business credit card for personal purchases american express gold card money saving expert secured credit card issuers valid visa credit card number generator mbna 0 interest credit card canada best credit card deal 2012 apply for a sears mastercard online how to apply credit card online in icici miles and more credit card switzerland how to apply for a gas credit card with bad credit visa business credit card limit compare prepaid credit cards us best rewards credit card with no foreign transaction fee counter offer credit card settlement android credit card reader best low interest credit card australia vacation pay advance form sites like magnum cash advance no credit credit cards for students cpa gold credit card american express pay a walmart credit card payment credit card visa mastercard american express get credit card bad credit no bank account premier credit card status online standard chartered credit card payment india ace cash payday loans online ace payday loans should i use my tesco credit card abroad business credit card with low interest rate reward credit cards review which credit cards use experian only credit card points rewards comparison how many ba gold card holders are there prepaid us credit card in canada best credit card rates for good credit credit cards with low interest rates for students credit card fraud concerns at schnucks stores virgin credit card offers for existing customers apple handheld credit card scanner is chase credit card a visa or mastercard best balance transfer credit card no fee fake credit card numbers that work 2013 best virtual credit card terminal non secured credit cards for bad credit canada best buy application for credit card low income credit cards canada fee free credit cards australia credit card apply online philippines shell credit card uk address free valid credit card numbers with cvv2 how do credit card companies attract new customers using a credit card for business expenses visa debit cards wikipedia best rewards cards canada 2012 top ten best credit cards for students hdfc credit card charges abroad best canadian credit cards comparison credit cards with airline miles for fair credit cash advance fee vanquis mastercard prepaid credit card uk average credit card debt uk 2011 marriott reward credit card promotion american express rewards cards review icici credit card settlement letter format best transfer balance credit cards compare credit cards india reviews sear credit card pay bill chase canada credit card processing list of credit card companies in canada westpac credit card travel insurance australia sbi gold credit card customer care number first modern credit card introduced 1950s low apr credit cards for bad credit chase credit card fraud prevention halifax credit card pays 5 cash back no fax easy payday loans options for accepting credit cards online chase credit card visa united online hdfc credit card login best time to sign up for southwest credit card hsbc balance transfer offers existing customer credit card offer opt out prescreened offers best canadian air miles credit card hsbc credit card balance transfer deals icici bank platinum credit card limit credit card debt relief companies how many credit cards should a person have for a good credit score kohls credit card do company credit cards affect credit score how do payday advance loans work credit cards for fair credit instant approval uk cash back visa card icici coral credit card mouthshut create virtual visa card online cash back credit cards with no foreign transaction fees check shell credit card application bank of america cash advance fee instant credit card approval with bad credit canada credit card fraud punishment can range same day cash loans to your door manchester united credit card maybank first premier bank credit card pay online emi offers on hdfc bank credit cards cash back rewards credit cards 2012 visa cash card international use direct payday loans compare credit card offers 2013 amazon store credit card reviews best credit cards with no annual fee and rewards best travel rewards credit card bonus get a payday loan with bad credit and no bank account anz credit card travel insurance claim what is credit card number font united airlines credit card offer 50000 sam;s discover card login credit cards united mileage plus credit card customer service phone number how do mobile credit card machines work
Home Maury Brown Miller's Snub: Time to Overhaul Veterans Committee (again)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1403 guests online

Atom RSS

Miller's Snub: Time to Overhaul Veterans Committee (again) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 03 December 2007 07:28

Maury BrownThe results of this year’s Veterans Committee vote has been released, and with that we see former commissioner Bowie Kuhn, former Dodgers owner Walter O'Malley, ex-Pirates owner Barney Dreyfuss and managers Dick Williams and Billy Southworth elected.

Snubbed (again) is Marvin Miller, the former executive director of the MLB Player’s Association, who’s shadow and mark on the game is so large, it staggers the imagination that he’s not been elected prior.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Marvin Miller)

Or, should our minds be boggled?

The time has arrived for the make up of the Veterans Committee to be reevaluated and overhauled. As Miller himself said to Murray Chass of the NY Times this past week:

“People have asked me about it,” Miller said, speaking of the committee’s makeup. “I don’t know why they did this except, other than me, it makes sense to have a group like this because they are a management-oriented group voting on management people.”

And therein is the crux of the problem. Therein lies the travesty.

If the committee’s makeup is wholly management-based (and I'm not talking former players, but rather representatives from the front office of the MLBPA) is to say that the influence of the MLBPA is nothing more than window dressing. At least consider adding someone like Dick Moss to the committee. Even a token member would remove at least a smidgen of what appears to be bias.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Dick Moss)

Shortly after I published this column, a statement by Donald Fehr, the executive director of the MLBPA expressed his disappointment, and placed an exclamation point on what I have expressed here:

“Because he was the Players' voice, and represented them vigorously, Marvin Miller was the owners' adversary. This time around, a majority of those voting were owner representatives, and results of the vote demonstrate the effect that had.  In the last vote, Marvin received 63% of the votes, this time he got 25%.  By contrast, Bowie Kuhn received 17% of the votes last time, but got 83% this time."

"I think it was rigged, but not to keep me out. It was rigged to bring some of these in,'' Miller said by telephone after being informed of the results by The Associated Press. "It's not a pretty picture.''

The interesting sidebar to this is the election of Bowie Kuhn, a man that can best be described as being a reactionary to Miller’s bold entrance and the player’s ascension into the most powerful sports union in history. Arguably, Kuhn was simply a man at a certain place at a certain time. The history was made by almost exclusively by others on his watch (the induction of O’Malley highlights this tremendously), not by the man himself. Kuhn fought tooth and nail against the changes Miller proposed.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Bowie Kuhn)

While it is good to see that at least this vote garnered inductions, Miller’s clear snub will be the focus today and until the time the next vote is conducted. Sadly, given Miller’s age, there are the odds that he will have passed away before then.

Maybe Miller isn’t concerned about not being in the Hall. After all, most anyone that knows the pulse of the game understands the incredible mark he has made on upon it – a mark that continues today. It seems that those on the Veterans Committee have chosen to look the other way, or have no understanding of the pulse of the game today, somehow bitter of Miller's change, or still stuck in the past to the point of ignoring the present.

Given that, it’s time to reevaluate the Veterans Committee makeup (yet, again. See changes made to this year's system from the system prior below). Until such day as key individuals from labor are on the committee, incredible gaffs such as the non-induction of Marvin Miller will continue to take place. Given the enormous influence that the MLBPA has had on the game of baseball, it is imperative that they have a seat at the table on the committee. How Marvin Miller could not be considered part of baseball’s “fame” staggers the imagination.

As Fehr closed in his statement today, “The failure to elect Marvin Miller is an unfortunate and regrettable decision.  Without question, the Hall of Fame is poorer for it.” 




Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members, Frick and Spink Award winners (total of 80-plus) cast ballots on Players ballot

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members, Frick and Spink Award winners (total of 80-plus) cast ballots on Composite ballot

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members (63) cast ballots on Players ballot

Electorate: Committee of 16 individuals (Hall of Famers, veteran writers, executives and historians) cast ballots on a managers/umpires ballot

Players ballot: Voted on every two years, in odd years (2003, 2005, 2007, etc). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast was elected

Composite ballot: Voted on every four years (2003, 2007, etc.). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast was elected

Players ballot: Voted on every two years, in odd years, starting in 2009 (2009, 2011, 2013, etc). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast will be elected

Managers/umpires ballot: Voted on every two years in even years, starting in 2008 (2008, 2010, 2012, etc.). Anyone to received votes on 75% of ballots cast will be elected

Eligible candidates: All players with 10 or more years experience. Any candidate on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list was not eligible for consideration Eligible candidates: All players with 10 or more years experience, whose careers began in 1943 or later. Any candidate on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list is not eligible for consideration
Pre-World War II Players: Part of Player ballot

Pre-World War II Players: Will be reviewed by a Board-appointed committee of 12 individuals (Hall of Famers, veteran writers, and historians) every five years beginning in 2009
BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrowed list of players to 200

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrowed list of managers, umpires and executives to 60

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrows list of players to 20; Simultaneously, a screening committee of six Hall of Famers choose five players; list of players to contain 20-25 names, depending on duplicate results

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrows list of managers and umpires to 10

A screening committee of 60 BBWAA members narrowed list of players from 200 to 25; Simultaneously, a screening committee of six Hall of Famers chose five players; final ballot contained 25-30 names, depending on duplicate results

A screening committee of 60 BBWAA members narrowed list of managers, umpires and executives to 15

The living Hall of Fame members, acting as its own screening committee, narrows list of 25-30, to a final ballot of 10, by paper ballot.

No screening committee for managers and umpires.

Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football and The Biz of Basketball (The Biz of Hockey will be launching shortly). He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?