cost 40 mg paroxetine without insurance where purchase diclofenac is buying pain pills online legit cardura tablets from buy effective dose of topamax for migraines styplon pills buy online what is robaxin tablets for zentel tablets how to take over counter colospa buy purim online cheap oratane canada pravachol 40 mg fiyat? comment acheter une alliance dans fable 3 best site to buy diclofenac phone in order for blopress how to use duphalac over the counter alternative to betnovate vardenafil generico precio en mexico buy adderall uk legally uk online pharmacy no prescription what is prometrium tablets lotrisone generic release date ciprofloxacin 500mg side effects increasing returns to scale tutor2u how to purchase viagra in uk cheap endep buy online accutane order online from canada rogaine side effects long term buy seroquel paypal augmentin reviews skin infection lipitor sales us 2010 online pharmacy no prescription needed prograf atenol no prescription fast shipping buy alesse astrailia stromectol canada snovitra super power refills Purchase abilify 1 pharmacy aripiprazole kytril comprare tricor visa amitriptyline hydrochloride 10mg college of medicine and allied health sciences freetown diclofenac gel where can i buy it purchase generic lasuna metoprolol succinate coumadin alcohol inr generic tofranil no prescription mobic generic equivalent benicar hct missed dose premarin purchase cheap malegra fxt pills fluoxetine combination best starting dose zoloft ephedraxin canada arjuna for sale philippines vermox otc india pravachol price buy accutane in india online order diovan from uk without prescription resources for albendazole lexapro bonus pills levitra super active without prescription miami where to buy norvasc online how to buy amaryl what does prednisone do for dogs sleeping pills phenergan healthy bmi for 5;10 male where is the safest place to buy clomid online why is there a shortage of aspirin propecia where to get cefadroxil dosage instructions yagara medication side effects metformin and clomid chances of twins cialis soft canada pharmacy cialis online american express buy colchicine with canadian online where can i buy cephalexin keflex xeloda cost 2012 colospa with no rx can you buy vasotec enalapril blood zestril for sale online zyrtec generico italiano order zovirax no prescription acai berry capsules 500mg benefits buy cefixime online no prescription 100mg buy zestoretic 50 amitriptyline medicine online valtrex prior to delivery generic haridra us serophene low dose birth control what does promethazine make u feel like buy terramycin pills in the canada buy maxaman uk can you buy viagra over counter walmart over the counter medication for anxiety in dogs genuine colchicine what does the drug benicar do sinequan new zealand is lithium prescribed in the uk olanzapine by mail alli diet pill official website buy flagyl er overseas prices for januvia 100 mg accutane sale alli shop coupon code anti dandruff shampoo nizoral price in india list sports enhancement drugs price of zyvox 800 mg how much is topamax tablets lozol prices usa can you get erythromycin over the counter ibuprofen 400 mg how many to take amaryl m forte 1 mg purchasing lamisil online uk discount protonix overnight erection packs 11 prescription viagra for sale glasgow atorlip-10 tablets price topical erythromycin uses costco pharmacy website purchase lexapro 20mg online dostinex india no prescription what is the dose of doxycycline for malaria erectile dysfunction treatment options arjuna dose prilosec 100mg cheep valtrex order online canada ordering aspirin here in canada hrsa pharmacy support services effexor xr compared pristiq buyers of calan canada how to take uroxatral mg buy flonase hong kong cabgolin without a script coming off citalopram news orlistat pas cher how does viagra work for women motilium lawsuit toradol 10mg side effects buy live caterpillars canada philippines online pharmacy abilify suppliers overseas best prices on generic drugs the online drugstore astelin levaquin costco confido from canada low altace high blood pressure hypertension blum minipress m for sale permethrin uk pharmacy bupropion hcl 150mg tablets buy benadryl 40 what bacteria does keflex treat do i need a prescription for unisom phentermine 30mg reviews avodart tablets buy trileptal 100mg tablet what is dipyridamole used for how do i get viagra online buspar canada prescription aciclovir usa sale where to nootropil no rx mircette online where to buy zyrtec d allergy kytril online price contact lenses without a doctor prescription what does cephalexin pills look like where to buy levaquin online mexico can u get high from trazodone aid side effects of bupropion sr 150 mg shatavari mg tablet buy glycomet 5 orlistat dosage weight viagra farmacias sin receta argentina para que sirve la prednisona de 20 mg cost per pill buy zyvox viagra professional buy mexico v-gel to buy in england mexican periactin cleocin gel lowest price zestoretic 100mg buy ponstel sublingual dosage where can i get some altace phenergan tablets for dogs craigslist newcastle upon tyne hyzaar drug assistance program how long does it take for remeron to work for sleep where to buy tetracycline uk medicine lotensin online cheap what types of alesse are there prescription free buy viagra buy hoodia cheap cheap liverpool apartments to rent buy levaquin online overnight aldactone dosage high blood pressure xenical from philippines dostinex without a prescription from mexico buy oxytrol in singapore overnight pharmacy prescription bupron sr discount order tadacip 120 mg orlistat online cheap how to get zyloprim drug citalopram cheap no prescription buy cheap brand viagra using pay pal lov cost tricor what is the drug benicar hct used for fucidin over counter uk grifulvin v coupon code order glucophage online canada cheap viagra india online onde comprar o zyvox keppra from usa pharmacy generic name allegra allergy buy over the counter paroxetine online meclizine generic release date price of ventolin in canada protonix 40 mg uses what is the starting dose for synthroid colchicine from uk cheapest ephedraxin tablets uk free chlamydia treatment buy cheap cialis link online canadian pharmacy online no prescription what does norvasc brand levitra legal us walgreens vs walmart pharmacy prices non generic sumycin buy drugs without prescriptions generic birth control pills vs. brand name birth control pills how to import lisinopril flagyl er usa brand pyridium for sale pariet reviews and dosage where can i buy aldactone online zyrtec 10 mg/ml annostus angela women's ginseng online what is promethazine vc syrup for buy isoniazid for daily use allopurinol cost uk buy rogaine 2 cheap what does pyridium look like kamagra 50mg india buy toradol pills online stromectol australia healthy cheese manicotti recipe buy coreg 10 prandin billig kaufen where can i buy pariet online without a prescription buy zovirax uk side effects of long term lexapro use buy deltasone capsules order emsam canada albuterol steroid side effects differin online order buy generic indocin online no prescription healthy mango lassi smoothie buy oxytrol online cheap mircette legal in england how often to take procardia atarax online ordering amaryl pharmacy prices list buy brand cialis no prescription fast delivery sale phenergan herbal suppliers london avalide new zealand mexican pharmacy no prescription malegra fxt best place to order depakote in us find viagra in london capoten comprar sinemet for sale usa best generic proventil review avalide lawsuit phexin shortage buy allopurinol in usa buy keftab tablets avapro common side effects how long does it take for cardizem to start working cheap 1 pharmacy adalat online common side effects of doxycycline hyclate low cost drugs online buy prandin astrailia imitrex delivery london procardia tablets from buy can you get a rash from augmentin motilium not generic discount diovan coupons viagra mail order australia nymphomax drug store online best drugstore translucent powder 2013 allergy medicine zyrtec side effects generic evecare for sale on line flagyl medicine used for lipothin over the couter como comprar zyloprim buy ranitidine 40 best place to buy vpxl purchase nolvadex bodybuilding acheter tinidazole cheap aciclovir 300mg tablets alli cheap india pharmacy benzac ac 5 face wash reviews cheapest pariet to buy cefixime from europe viagra r online shop post cycle therapy desyrel buy remeron generic propecia shop for lowest price buying dilantin in manchester buy antibiotics fast delivery where do i buy lady era how long does it take for abilify to get out of your system what are the side effects of sildenafil citrate tablets buy allopurinol online from canada can you buy zebeta pharmacy jcb accutane lawsuit canada high off benadryl pills lithium 100mg cheap buy clomiphene tablets online buy pet medicine from canada cheap genuine keppra online how to get high off celexa kamagra chewable without script compare prices chloramphenicol zithromax cost in canada aciclovir cost without insurance femara canada drugs buy accutane tablets mexico order synthroid online buy nymphomax mexican pharmacies online cheap buy generic femcare buy domperidone without prescription buy fluoxetine hcl usp capsules doxycycline acne treatment dose lithium orotate in canada revia prices at costco generic uk paypal mirapex i pill amitriptyline website side effects drug order diflucan cheap uk version of cleocin zoloft prescription only 24 hour medical hotline nsw cheap generic malegra dxt safest place to buy cialis online most common side effects of alesse retino a .05 generic lincocin buy canada como se usa cytotec para abortar why can;t you take ciprofloxacin with milk pill identifier canada serophene prices usa american standard celerity sink use levitra tablets herpes outbreak while valtrex overnight online buy aldactone viagra for sale in australia chloramphenicol prix en pharmacie en france pharmacy drugstore meds net generic periactin buy canada what does keflex treat in dogs comprar female cialis en argentina buy fluoxetine online no prescription united states order risperdal online no prescription with a mastercard buy keftab fast shipping best site to buy aspirin methotrexate pills radio italia live in tv viagra cost without insurance celebrex drug in mexico pharmacy how to order ventolin online aciclovir birth control online uk generic plendil medication asacol enema effectiveness what is a good replacement for seroquel non persciption voveran online pharmacy uk digoxin singulair dosage instructions can order protonix canada uk law buying drugs online drh janssen cilag france prix de cialis en pharmacie en france ampicillin in the uk now roxithromycin purchase where can i buy venlor what is minipress prazosin casodex rxlist buspar reviews side effects nexium free trial coupon como comprar zofran orlistat xenical sibutramine meridia lamisil commercial on tv buy accutane with isotretinoin does celexa or lexapro cause weight gain glucophage discount code xenical shop online valtrex reviews patients pharmacy mexico cefixime discount aristocort can you buy clomid over the counter in south africa health net viagra buying doxycycline in vietnam gasex mg tablet exercise tips healthy weight management minocycline indian brands levitra professional generic uk artane buy online ireland is allegra generic over the counter noroxin discount claravis cost 2013 can you buy yasmin over the counter in germany vermox prescription canada free shipping bactrim online sales what is seroflo tablets where alligators live in the usa where can i get some brand cialis western drug tinidazole where to buy lipitor online uk mobic spain order indocin pill flonase brands india low cost terramycin zoloft price in india vasodilan order how long does it take for skelaxin to kick in buy topamax 20 bactrim prescription coupon canadian online pharmacy for viagra where to buy biaxin mg buy aldactone spironolactone drugstore low dose accutane for acne buy micronase 50 long time side effects benzac abortion pill online usa brand proscar for sale what type of blood pressure medicine is norvasc atarax compared to xanax is apriso better than asacol generic acivir pills for sale on line bactrim ds tablets purchase side effects of minocycline 100mg phenergan dosage too high is hoodia legal in uk voltaren retard 75 mg diclofenac sodium generic benicar for sale on line betnovate gm cream used vpxl weight gain does boots sell phenergan iv phenergan lawsuit where to get apcalis sx can you buy mifepristone and misoprostol online where do you buy liv dolls aspirin allopurinol interactions online uk pharmacy no prescription cheap cytotec 200mg online nitrofurantoin 100 mg tablets normal dose of cephalexin for dogs piroxicam side effects weight gain buy arjuna canada what does atarax how to order cialis jelly online relafen drug viagra prescription online uk where to buy finpecia ointment evista generic reviews cheap finpecia pills adalat cc 30 mg tablet why is alli no longer available metronidazole 200mg 5ml oral suspension rocaltrol drug classification pilex no prescription compare prices how to take mircette pilex shoppers drug mart seroquel australia price atorlip-5 uk buy best site get forzest ordering abilify canada depo provera price philippines depo medrol 40 mg lisinopril in croatia acheter evista order calander cheap proventil tablets 2mg vantin from usa pharmacy licensed pharmacy cefixime diclofenac genericon 100 mg za"pfchen zyrtec over counter canada discount voltaren of canada where do i suhagra in usa sominex perth australia xenical slimming tablets paroxetine on line augmentin plus 1000 dosage the chepest ditropan brand sumycin buy discount code for benicar is albuterol available over the counter in canada buy serevent australia side effects of diltiazem er +"neurontin" +600mg best price for deltasone where to buy vermox online mexico orlistat drug dosage combivent online store cvs caremark settles charges over prescription prices alli diet pills back in stock over the counter thailand viagra online can you take claritin while trying to get pregnant tadalafil cheap cafergot suppositories 2011 shortage dulcolax tablets dosage instructions canadian pilex tablet dapoxetine reviews for men canadian association of chain drug stores brand viagra shoppers drug mart buy plavix online in usa brahmi australia price mexican pharmacy no prescription nolvadex comprar desyrel portugal buy vasodilan mg rosuvastatin generic equivalent clozaril from india cymbalta and alcohol interactions retin-a 0,05 cost in canada cialis jelly for sale philippines premarin tablets 1.25mg furosemide cost purchase kamagra in australia zyprexa buy on line como usar benzac ac gel where to buy serevent ointment the online drugstore evecare septilin generic 2013 drugs proscar online order calan medicine children sarafem italiano nifedipine er and breastfeeding where to buy nexium with mastercard best place to buy terramycin med cab online pharmacy reviews what is the correct order of allied conferences potsdam to buy caverta prednisolone medicine online neurontin costochondritis how to get doxycycline for dogs zithromax pharmacy prices list top 10 online micardis sites better than neurontin blood pressure medication list names safe to buy generic orlistat from canada buy doxazosin online no prescription united states amaryl with no rx how long for robaxin to take effect us online pharmacy no prescription detrol ordering diflucan canada side effects of metoprolol succinate extended release buy with paypal pick up in store glucotrol xl max dose zithromax delivery uk legal to buy suhagra amlodipine besylate price walgreens medicine methylprednisolone tablets usp 4 mg what does tegretol dose for bipolar flomax lawsuit status desyrel 100 mg etkileri fluoxetine 10 mg get you high how to buy levitra professional in london celebrex target pharmacy prescription brand purim buy use of mobic 15mg tablets buy 5 mg abilify como tomar cytotec para abortar hyaluronic acid overnight pharmacy yasmin canada companies only can you buy lamisil prescription drugs thyroid medication weight gain dapoxetine on line no script what is feldene tablets buy levlen prescriptions how to get phenergan drug donde puedo comprar cialis professional cialis with no prescription needed all natural anti anxiety pills cymbalta copay discount online pharmacy uk lisinopril where to buy cheap generic ranitidine what kind of drug is tofranil zocor cheap uk purchase isoniazid in us generic viagra canadian antabuse without a prescription from us duloxetine and alcohol side effects generic valtrex at walmart can you buy brahmi over the counter where can i watch drugstore cowboy online for free amlodipine besylate 10mg tablets worldwide pharmacy torsemide list of tesco stores selling cialis prednisone dose pack day side effects of effexor xr 150 where to buy antabuse without a prescription what does the drug allegra dog furosemide mail order india iv furosemide infusion can you order silagra propecia with american express vermox dosage for kids cheap cymbalta mg topamax shortage 2012 can you take pamelor daily cialis super active 50mg tablets 2 nitroglycerin ointment over the counter cheap ventolin inhalrs generic erectile dysfunction drugs online reliable rx pharmacy reviews hcg paxil usa no prescription cymbalta side effects australia carbozyne for dogs buy where can i buy fluconazole over the counter how much will keppra cost buy voltaren astrailia buy urispas next day cheap avodart 0.5 mg can you buy aceon prescription benefits and side effects of american ginseng cheap viagra 100mg tablets glycomet 100 review zofran 8 mg tabletas viagra vs cialis vs levitra differences and similarities fertomid on line premarin no prescription online buy moduretic 5 canadian healthcare online drugstore compazine 10 mg tab what is augmentin used for toothache crestor generic drug generic amoxil usa pharmacy citalopram sale acetazolamide generic for diamox buy abilify 2mg prescription drugs buy alphagan us brimonidine prilosec buy on line buy zanaflex 100mg online where to aciphex ventolin mg canadian rx genuine elimite 100mg zyrtec rx dosage taking meloxicam and ibuprofen effexor xr online store watch sony tv serial adalat online no prescription didronel sale best site get viagra professional effects of prednisone on blood sugar levels buy viagra super active pills in the india what is nizoral shampoo florida allegra costo finasteride colombia remeron online sales long term side effects of diabecon kamatra gel sinemet uk online cilas laser particle size analyzer cheap australian viagra omeprazole dosage baby cephalexin 100mg tablet mentat is it illegal to order generic calan how to order ponstel atacand order doxycycline over the counter south africa what are the side effects of avapro chloroquine malaria dose free or low cost voveran sr what is dulcolax stool softener side effects of blood pressure medication lisinopril cipro generic name crestor interactions with other drugs avodart vs propecia for bph forum acheter cialis 20mg promethazine with codeine for sale peggy bayer 2012 buy trazodone pills in the mexico buy roxithromycin patch clomifeno 50 mg torsemide comprare prilosec pharmacies worldwide pharmacy singulair cheap kamagra supplier big discounts where can i buy testosterone cream can order zestoretic canada lopid wanted online review generic from haridra is generic zyrtec as good as brand name buy reminyl pills buy brand viagra 20 buy tadalis sx pills pharmacy has best price florinef indian generics online roxithromycin rogaine or propecia for women female cialis dose acheter aciclovir en ligne atacand side effects trazodone tablets uk apcalis sx tadalafil canbadian drugstore how to take provera to induce period best generic zestril review organic acai costco where to buy cheap generic aleve suprax 400 mg tablet los algodones mexico pharmacy procardia without prescription acai berry online india cytotec abortion pill take lopressor prescription only purchasing torsemide online buy zyban pills is mail order rumalaya gel safe actos weight gain diabetes viagra noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy unique hoodia reviews order etodolac from canada without prescription roche xenical singapore betnovate cream for sale uk seroquel 40 mg dose mevacor australia price french pharmacy online uk metformin reviews patient cheapest drug isoniazid discount betoptic do you have to be 18 to buy alli pills adults doxycycline pills drugstore buy aciphex 80 mg online zyloprim order canada cheap meds from canada buy fluoxetine online no prescription uk vermox discount pharmacy infestations generic alavert d-12 what is viagra for women called aciclovir over the counter india malaria medicine doxycycline metoclopramide shortage duphalac dosage for pregnant women how much is hydrea tablets no prescription levitra online bayer how to use alliteration prednisolone prescription light blue pain pills hydromorphone injection shortage purchasing viagra online for cheap over the counter medicine that acts as sominex liquid carafate review us pharmacy online pletal estrace cream generic erection packs 2 pharmacy online no prescription levaquin 500mg alli medication side effects suprax 100mg cheap phenergan suppository onset minoxidil rogaine side effects $4 atorvastatin kamagranow co.uk canadian online pharmacy for actoplus met motilium 10mg generico amitriptyline migraine dose can you order lotrisone antifludes tabletas costo brand viagra cost comparison medstore online coupon code viagra in france cheap generic keflex what is lasix tablet etodolac uk buy mobic meloxicam buy protonix usa trazodone from courier delivery discount colchicine medicine for gout information on strattera medication online pharmacy uk mentat ds syrup promethazine looking for alli over counter weight loss viagra in usa kaufen buy coumadin pills in the us where to buy dulcolax balance alternatives to coumadin blood thinner ciproglen 500 tabletas elavil on line in the mexico buy renagel quick what does zocor 40 mg look like healthy diet for 25 year old male best place to buy levothroid order allegra 120 mg amaryl generic drug stromectol brand order abana himalaya price what is the correct dosage of speman luvox reviews for men how to use viagra spray video what is detrol la what is triamterene 37.5mg/hctz 25mg tabs methotrexate medication abortion order flagyl canada arimidex australia price grifulvin v medicine online canadian pharmacy cialis super active+ tadalafil seroflo buy on line purchase accutane 40 mg online mega green tea water pills reviews comprar viagra generico barato is nolvadex legal in america fucidin nombre generico cheap metformin hytrin reviews and dosage anxiety medication amitriptyline clonidine 0.1mg tab mylan lisinopril online with out prescription generic adalat cc 15 mg where can i order requip fosamax 70 mg 4 tablet buy generic lioresal with bonus how to use himalaya pilex generic for lithium carbonate provera canada overnight delivery order plavix cheap prescription drugstore where can i get some tofranil viagras femininos naturais cheap etodolac 100 mg como comprar gold en marvel avengers alliance cipralex 10mg escitalopram side effects purchase alli pills buy tretinoin 0,05 australia risk ordering viagra online pill can i make viagra sublingual order zyrtec samples pariet buy online india antabuse uk online where can you buy promethazine codeine cough syrup can you order entocort discount buy 250mg ampicillin online elocon over the counter usa generic atacand canada dulcolax mg buy donde comprar las pastillas yasmin amsa fast precio en chile is bupropion licensed in the uk prescription drug effexor xr mestinon timespan coupons prandin for sale uk order deltasone pills buy zantac online canada can you order prinivil can i get viagra on prescription canadian online pharmacy for nizagara side effects of clozaril clozapine apcalis sx 40 mg pharmacy levaquin online from uk kamagra maximum dosage depakote and alcohol liver non generic olanzapine where to buy betapace accutane settlement update timber mills artane for sale 100 mg benadryl dose how much does aspirin cost at the hospital acivir pills for sale uk cheapest paroxetine in the uk worldwide pharmacy tadacip allopurinol price in india atorvastatin dosage range best place buy zantac pct over counter sinemet online pharmacy erexor minocin cost without insurance ic doxycycline hyclate alcohol to buy clomid can get valtrex over counter calan pharmacy prices list aleve class action lawsuit where to buy clomid online safely alesse pharmacy price pills buy baytril for rats online indocin from usa januvia maximum daily dose skelaxin overnight shipping cheap biaxin 20mg tab where can i buy differin cream brand levitra online usa diamox prescription drug information legal buy nexium online canada vantin dosage too high pastillas cytotec flagyl antibiotico compresse orlistat 100 review bentyl generic wikipedia drugs tinidazole tablets 150 mg sildenafil citrate brand names india where to buy diakof ointment walmart crestor price cheap cialis for sale what is azathioprine side effects omnicef online overnight shipping canada pharmacy boards what does coumadin treat current price lexapro current price noroxin best site to buy digoxin finast shoppers drug mart how to order bupropion claritin tablets instructions prednisone 20 mg get you high generic drug for accutane promethazine codeine 100ml what does requip dose for parkinson;s what is azithromycin good for strep throat clomid post cycle treatment omnicef 100mg cheap lozol to buy from europe lisinopril hctz side effects weight loss what is correct dosage for cialis tricor dose range compazine for sale philippines cialis medication class can you get lariam post cycle therapy zyprexa effective hoodia dose is generic cytoxan available in usa pharmacies cheap voltaren buy cefixime 400 mg orally in a single dose yagara shortage 2012 ipratropium bromide and albuterol sulfate nebulizer no prescription lamisil mobic direct pharmacy hyzaar buy online canada buy lexapro overseas medication assistance advair diskus inhalation powder what drug category is haldol in women in world war 1 what is aricept mg used to treat is it safe to order medicine from canada trazodone online bestellen drug market order keppra doxycycline online order buy roaccutane canada comprare vermox atorlip medication atorvastatin buy venlor mexican pharmacies lisinopril hctz patient reviews tinidazole uk boots cheap mobicosa meds espn radio viagra zestoretic purchase in canada no prescription what does provera 5 do how to get aricept in australia does decadron make you gain weight betnovate wikipedia order atorlip 10 cheap buy prednisolone 10 mg brand name duetact online what are symptoms of chlamydia in your mouth use abana coupon online mail order brand levitra canada pharmacy augmentin accutane side effects weight gain viagra super active paypal erexin-v online usa diclofenac sodium ta 50 mg side effects cheapest place to buy apcalis sx purchasing promethazine online uk lisinopril pharmacy coupons cheap altace uk ramipril 10mg indian pharmacy mirapex imitrex medicine online vermox plus precio mexico beconase aq on line no script doxycycline with american express where cozaar losartan potassium angiotensin ii is unisom available in canada amazon alli uk generic lipitor made by pfizer dilantin online overnight viagra for sale uk only prescription over the counter allegra dose safe to buy generic cialis jelly from usa cheapest tenormin without rx viagra online europe advair in usa generic eulexin in usa cephalexin capsules 250 mg remeron lowest price online propranolol shoppers drug mart protonix medication where to buy benicar 40 mg what is the brand name for tamoxifen alli coupon printable 2013 zyprexa 100mg cheap buy amaryllis plant kit meri adalat online retin-a ge tablets price of zithromax without insurance paxil 20 mg weight gain blue v15 pill oblong brand name motrin online what is tofranil for online canadian pharmacy no perscription buy albendazole no prescription fast delivery imuran 50 mg tabletas generic for lanoxin evista refill pack buy cheap benicar using pay pal order mentat ds syrup canada all types colchicine pills acticin walgreens what is emsam used for walmart pharmacy celebrex cost generic rosuvastatin crestor generic isoptin for sale on line where can i get toprol xl pills strattera from augmentin duo syrup for kids order allopurinol tablets finpecia overnight delivery kamagra soft pill shortage buy lorazepam no prescription online how to order vytorin what is arjuna tablets astelin to buy from europe generic nymphomax ordering viagra professional discount pharmacy xenical on line caverta generic viagra best minocycline prices where to buy prednisolone 5mg generic endep daily use reviews mentat ds syrup prix en pharmacie en france what are propranolol hydrochloride tablets used for welcome come dine with me desi tashan withdrawal symptoms from trazodone meds doxycycline hyclate 100mg treatments order lanoxin 120 mg online viagra scams canadian generic for allopurinol drug information buy xenical online cheap clomid and serophene (clomiphene) phentermine pills for sale online tamoxifen from usa pharmacy any long term side effects with viagra can i buy antibiotics over the counter in usa buy cheap nizoral pills wellbutrin sr mg usa speman where to get does walmart sell erection pills order lisinopril online uk endep dose for depression american zofran diclofenac costo provera now co uk medroxyprogesterone generic for provera cordarone medication class iii ordering brand generic cialis pills purchase femara canada where to buy pariet drugs online what is diclofenac gel made of buy vermox astrailia baclofen alcohol withdrawal dosage valacyclovir overnight best adalat prices doxycycline medicines.ie blood pressure medicine tenormin how long does trandate take to work benzac for sale australia no prescription plendil sale generic fluoxetine no prescription side effects of taking plavix and aspirin together buy canada no prescription for suhagra side effects of nolvadex in women isoniazid dosage instructions long term side effects of diclofenac sodium indocin pill canadian legal to buy diflucan cialis sublingual sale tadalafil prescription best cheap mascara for dramatic lashes my kytril coupons purchasing kamagra online erythromycin drugstore is ranitidine a prescription drug allopurinol delivery uk price of viagra pills in india to buy lynoral my revatio coupons trileptal canada prescription rocaltrol online forum celexa buy no prescription actos delivery topic click here walmart pharmacy discount drugs list endep medication 25 paxil side effects weight loss acheter aciclovir creme synthroid bonus pills lasix generic release date can you only get lamictal on prescription dilantin side effects liver accutane long term side effects eyes hydrochlorothiazide weight gain side effect lexapro buy without where can i buy cefixime tablets what does aleve do to your body buy glucotrol xl in australia where can i buy xalatan eye drops septilin without prescription comprar evecare original en madrid zenegra mg tablet get bentyl las vegas viagra plus 100mg cheap skelaxin dosage administration best place to buy erexor buy augmentin greece is mail order cleocin safe what is the use of confido aleve pain reliever reviews can you buy depo provera online where can i buy alligator meat in texas nizoral shampoo price philippines ipledge accutane program can you buy alligators kamagra price albendazole drug classification health canada tulasi purchase wellbutrin sr online buy zetia online no prescription united states sale xeloda cymbalta and maxalt combination canadian atacand tablet side effects of rocaltrol medication hydroxyzine tablets no prescription viagra professional beconase aq doctors online tofranil for social anxiety famvir dosage cold sores can you buy albendazole trusted prescription azulfidine 500 mg dosis is toradol a good pain medicine levitra professional discount code best price alli viagra para mujer chile mobic shortage 2012 tenormin usa cvs prices buy cialis australia buy baclofen boots pharmacy lotrisone cream online buy cheap diabecon next day delivery acheter viagra site fiable aldactone cost without insurance alli pills non persciption xenical how much does cialis cost on the street cialis tadalafil tablets viagra tablets for men uk voltaren cream muscle pain medicine buy cholestoplex cheap voveran 50 tablets used side effects of urispas 200 mg procardia discontinued unisom for sale liquid elocon review best price for real bupropion lotensin dosage 40 mg what is azithromycin tablets 250 mg used for purchase generic zocor a good web page to buy atarax with no script suhagra order tadacip ingredients aldactone comments buy toprol online from usa order detrol kamagra sildenafil citrate wirkung discount cephalexin lipitor refill pack reglan medicine accutane online bestellen canadian online pharmacy for bactroban lasix shopping site fiable pour acheter viagra metronidazole gel dose for bv# maxalt drug store online diclofenac dosage for neck pain cipro order online buy protonix fast shipping voveran tablets 150 mg zenegra cheapest order erection packs 3 no rx canadian pharmacy buying voltaren online cheap vantin no prescription order generic nitrofurantoin what drug category is rocaltrol can order fluoxetine online omnicef online in usa tadacip pille 20mg cialis generika liv 52 mail order how long does clonidine take to work for adhd ephedraxin medication where to buy sominex looking for phentermine 375 low cost actos pioglitazone hydrochloride order sinemet online in usa buy tramadol online canada pharmacy where to get dostinex pct health canada generic drugs switching from paxil to zoloft during pregnancy order lozol pill zyrtec canada prescription where do i buy vpxl alavert online pharmacy uk motrin drugs for sale cheap actos uk buy online canadian blood pressure medicine plendil prescription drug tofranil most reliable place to buy motilium online atrovent visa para que se usa el cordarone order augmentin 500mg canada pharmacy ed trail packs lopressor where to get order cream generic elimite free coupon for lotensin can we trust aristocort online biggest online pharmacy europe cheap ciplox buy amaryl with paypal what does zyrtec d have in it viagra by mail order from canada cheap cardizem buy online levitra bayer 10mg prix best pharmacy to order flomax ou acheter finpecia generic hyzaar name elimite pediatric dose comprar viagra generico no brasil flonase pills drugstore kamagra fast canada best place buy menosan pct levaquin for dogs buy baclofen overseas buy shampoo online malaysia lozol reviews and dosage buy avalide 20 tinidazole lyme treatment atorlip-20 no prescription compare prices max menzies facebook acquisto zyvox sicuro online how much does zyrtec d cost male enhancement drugs work without rx buy aldactone online med cab parlodel levitra professional buy without how to get albendazole levlen generic name flagyl uk buy nitroglycerin xr without prescription rhinocort from canada best pharmacy online no prescription lynoral uk brand name cost of generic crestor clozaril discount voucher what is kamagra 100mg oral jelly sildenafil tulasi in croatia cost of aygestin olanzapine withdrawal nausea canadian pharmacy albendazole actonel in canada como usar benzac ac wash where to buy purim cookies cheapest artane avodart dosage hair betnovate refills online pharmacy biaxin stromectol online store do i need a prescription for prilosec otc acheter clomid sans prescription sildenafil generico dr simi mexico canadian alliance terminals cat diovan dose define etodolac medication proscar finasteride dose lamictal delivery london accutane from usa pharmacy non prescription viagra online uk atacand maximum daily dose can you buy flagyl cymbalta online without rx cholestoplex in croatia rythmol no prescription needed cheap cytoxan india cheapest place to buy bupron sr ordering brand generic cialis pharmacy order kamagra 100mg chewable pfizer india viagra where to buy proventil online usa meds for men viagra where to buy remeron where can you buy domperidone indian pharmacy eulexin and when the truth hurts i pop pain pills online pharmacy canada safe buy levaquin without rx kamagra gold paypal floxin drug classification normal prednisone dose for dogs lasuna coupons sildenafil for sale uk side effects of erythromycin 500mg combivent looking for does elavil cause erections over counter zerit azulfidine uk brand name kytril without prescription tesco pharmacy bridgend extra zanaflex tablets food buy frozen acai berry australia where to purchase omnicef buy speman paypal accepted malegra dxt dose genuine paxil 100mg side effects of atenolol 50 mg in men flomax dosages available purchase relafen cheap what is the generic for micardis can buy over counter clonidine online atarax in croatia canada post shoppers drug mart hours surrey nymphomax where to purchase sominex medicine se vende el viagra sin receta medica neurontin side effects my aygestin coupons costco pharmacy noroxin price order digoxin free shipping cod buy kytril 100 ci cipro 55 sale can u buy meclizine over counter how to get digoxin drug buy zovirax online buy suprax canada cefixime buy compazine in india online buy keppra in usa levitra buy uk bupropion lawsuit settlements buy generic prandin online prandin side effects anxiety buying ophthacare using paypal purchase zoloft canada buy coumadin 2 mg seroquel pill shop discount code bystolic anxiety treatment buy femcare next day tetracycline 500 mg used albendazole over the counter buy online sale albenza purchase lisinopril 2.5 mg renagel ordering online pharmacy prescription drug flagyl lisinopril complications buy suhagra patch lowest priced colospa acquisto lisinopril sicuro online differin gel 0.3 reviews nike air max 1 leopard grey cheap zovirax cream usa brand sale cialis online tadalafil singulair pills reviews kamagra gold 10 mg cost shatavari side effects uk cheap suhagra uk buy plavix online overnight coumadin in italia how much does a bottle of aspirin cost buy meds online usa isoniazid pharmacies omnicef tablets uk ceftin sold over counter aetna rx mail order delivery yasmin lawsuit canada overnight delivery of viagra in the usa Purchase adalat 4 pharmacy over the counter apcalis sx order mobic online in usa where to buy penicillin ointment buying xeloda buy erythromycin without a subscription cleocin doctors online how to buy compazine can you buy clomid over counter australia buy tamoxifen 40 low cost clozaril buy top 10 best weight loss pills uk zentel kiedy druga dawka plavix fta 100 st buy abana pharmacy prescription is it illegal to order generic abana cost of prescription medicine without insurance ephedraxin precio mexico bactroban by mail order betnovate shelf life plavix rx coupon flomax dosage capsules zyvox 500 mg price what does zithromax cost generic female cialis no prescription cheap generic clomid bactroban order canada astelin buy hytrin lowest price what is cephalexin used for 500mg endep next day delivery viagra soft next day delivery citalopram hydrobromide depression i pill glyset website viagra with bonus pills how to by desyrel online post cycle therapy vasotec nexium on line purchase furosemide on line in the uk buy canada no prescription for finax genuine altace online is there a generic for plavix drug nolvadex and gyno buy mircette pills online amantadine drugstore levitra professional delivery buy hytrin online no prescription united states what is the cost of cialis daily roxithromycin cost comparison buy buy digoxin quick revatio with no perscription will public aid cover lamisil can you buy keflex over the counter wellbutrin vs generic bupropion weight loss differin gel wiki lithium 6 deuteride for sale viagra jelly from acquisto tadacip sicuro online arthritis cure news buy fucidin 200 buy purim without rx buy generic propecia canada can you online buy cheap diflucan what does lithium do when put in water do i need prescription for propecia top rated canadian online pharmacy albenza side effects uk cuantas pastillas de cytotec necesito para abortar buying levitra super active from canada no prescription adverse side effects of prednisone in dogs worldwide pharmacy lamictal generic fertomid overnite shipping online proscar overnight delivery buy crestor online no prescription wholesale prices generic forzest in usa i pill zestoretic website lisinopril buy alli online canadian pharmacy us buy cheap accutane without gyne-lotrimin generic 2013 drugs ordering low dose proventil lopid looking for where to get keppra generic acai uk paypal online sale of avapro xeloda roche patient assistance keppra barato zestril 10 mg tablets what is brand levitra drugs remeron delivery uk what does allegra d treat effexor venlafaxine reviews buy tulasi plant uk acai berry living xs supplier meloxicam 7.5mg what is it used for pharmacy directory aarp where can i buy permethrin uk us online pharmacy no prescription lexapro buy ayurvedic medicines online india best generic xenical review fucidin where can i buy bupron sr over the couter serophene cost canadian florida forzest eutirox efectos secundarios largo plazo purinethol over the counter diclofenac generico compresse ashwagandha not generic generic for zanaflex medication generic date for viagra do i need a prescription for crestor where to buy serpina drugs online online tadapox india zoloft no longer working-now what buy cafergot cheap pharmacie en ligne caen purchase tadapox online diovan price india arimidex dose men buy ashwagandha uk stromectol without insurance how to use saw palmetto claravis before and after pictures sale pilex arava generic wikipedia drugs alesse pharmacy prescription fedex cash cheap meclizine 40 mg roxithromycin tablets 150 mg side effects propranolol with or without food american viagra list of m pharmacy colleges in india azithromycin chlamydia single dose buy pletal without a script what is alesse generic for buy luvox in singapore fast lanoxin deleviery atarax capsules buy alliums can you buy brand levitra in ireland 20mg cheapest price where can i buy erythromycin in the uk where purchase decadron side effects of dulcolax overdose adalat buy cheap buy tetracycline without prescription buying pain meds from india best prices on generic viagra 100mg cyproheptadine syrup children brand advair diskus 100mg tablet bystolic medication interactions diclofenac pharmacies in side effects of taking aleve every day serevent usa trusted viagra sites comprar propecia pela internet pilex for sale philippines buy lisinopril online us no prescription diflucan price germany order amitriptyline online without propecia dosage form vente de fluoxetine au quebec lozol drug store online order generic procardia cialis from india online purchase u.s. online pharmacy for clomid meclizine hydrochloride 25 mg promethazine codeine syrup wiki buy letrozole canada generic rhinocort buy canada how much will unisom cost uk version of emsam online pharmacy no prescription needed risperdal trental tablets 400 mg genuine benadryl best price online generic finpecia que es y para que sirve la sertralina aceon how to buy aldactone canada overnight delivery lisinopril 2.5 mg price can clomid be bought over the counter how much will evista cost research grade shuddha guggulu ordering speman buy sarafem online no prescription us buy online doxycycline generic generic seroquel 2012 canadian drug overnight generic viagra delivery how to get benemid in australia ceftin cheap us pharmacy natural alternatives to viagra purchase snovitra super power cheap drug brand names whose generic name is aspirin canadian meds online no prescription liposafe shopping buy minipress online with mastercard comprar medrol portugal amaryl mg buy lasix without prilosec prices walgreens can you buy ventolin cheap rx 8 coilovers what is retin a cream 0.05 used for buy hydroxyzine kamagra now co uk kamagraoraljelly 100mg zentel 400 mg ulotka viagra to malta buy prinivil new zealand online imuran usa what are metformin tablets used for levitra schmelztablette online kaufen take cialis soft tab where can i order tamoxifen metformin generic cheap costs shipping lithium batteries to usa atrovent shipping overseas cheapest artane tablets uk no prescription cordarone sale elocon cream 0.1 uses dipyridamole order what kind of medicine is tegretol what is misoprostol tablets canadian pharmacy casodex pharmacy in canada toronto phone in order for diovan ordering accutane buy sildenafil citrate 50 mg how to get zovirax drug trichomoniasis metronidazole dosage advair printable coupon 100/50 where can i buy forum accutane mg pravachol without prescription medication carafate for sale can you buy cialis over the counter in canada cialis wanking top male enhancement drugs pastillas para abortar cytotec efectos original etodolac online side effects of stopping citalopram 20 mg innopran xl sale cheapest drug calan online forum methylprednisolone cod mexican pharmacy no prescription ditropan ephedraxin canada head office non generic clomid aspirin complex online kaufen donde venden cialis generico mexico canada pharmacy no prescription metformin viagra from tesco otc aleve tablets boots lopressor side effects uk diclofenac sodium side effects depression astrazeneca seroquel lawsuit viagra free trial offer myambutol pill shortage how many milligrams of aspirin is safe to take daily cefixime by mail fast lynoral deleviery safe to buy generic brand viagra from canada can you buy sublingual in ireland sildenafil pfizer viagra eurax shoppers drug mart buy floxin usa best price betnovate where to buy olanzapine drugs online buy cheap sumycin pills buy furosemide 40 mg no prescription buy protonix online irreputable mexican pharmacies online toradol uk online low price suhagra uk generic cialis professional 20 mg value pharmaceuticals scam where to buy cheap generic kamagra gold seroquel online from uk amitriptyline medicinenet alesse over the couter buy feldene online from usa all types trandate pills augmentin shortage 2012 buy 1mg finesteride strattera drugstore.com chloramphenicol medication buy fincar 100 buy styplon online no prescription usa asacol hd coupon best mac foundation for dry combination skin grifulvin v order on web pharmacy online canada getting paxil in australia torsemide prescription coupon allegra d medication where to get hytrin paroxetine hydrochloride diflucan 150 mg sale how long does it take for zyprexa zydis to work order online canadian pharmacy generic viagra colospa legal in england my synthroid coupons order no prescription buy accutane generic from leukeran effexor xr drugs for sale proscar 5 mg uses canadian generic adalat online best place to buy medrol in uk aceon delivery london calan cominelli what does inderal do lithium batteries in canada imuran prix en pharmacie en france aalesund vigra airport vgr 100 pfizer side effects cafergot sublingual dosage tamoxifen prices cvs phone in order for luvox methocarbamol dosage 750 mg maxalt 40mg discount drugstore strattera atomoxetine tramadol nights 4od cialis 10 mg cost health canada prometrium buspar dosage times depression anxiety medication and pregnancy can a walk in clinic prescribe viagra lipitor canada no prescription can you buy an inhaler over the counter differin online pharmacies with out prescription buy atrovent with e check canadian pharmacy pain pills pulmicort prescription coupon vienue testocell max testosterone cream men cialis standard dose 20 mg how to use combivent udv canadian rx drugs review bactrim is not working for my uti buy lansoprazole capsules zovirax fast canada flonase online pharmacy what bacteria does cipro cover half price antivert sale toradol motilium 100mg cheap claritin dosage chart for infants intravitreal triamcinolone side effects i pill arjuna website google stats on searched words bromocriptine side effects headache cheap finasteride. no prescription vitamin shoppe coupons printable august 2012 i pill nexium website propranolol uk brand name kamagra soft side effects long term use como comprar prednisolone antabuse tablets price safe astelin buy generic actoplus met 15 850 drugs without a script cod alphagan next yasmin 21 pills side effects online sale of celebrex walmart generic lipitor why has zyprexa been discontinued us pharmacy online bupron sr over counter cefixime 100mg sertraline high dose can amoxicillin treat chlamydia and gonorrhea best price for real differin buy selegiline canada acquisto cialis sicuro online cheapest rumalaya liniment allopurinol dose tumor lysis syndrome to buy tadapox how many times to take allopurinol betnovate pas cher italie reglan from europe what is xanax yahoo answers indian generics online levitra ampicillin for sale philippines bactrim tablets 150 mg viagra lawsuit canada robaxin usa cvs prices buy cephalexin 250mg capsules serpina for men sale in uk pharmacy buy drugs cephalexin pyridium for uti over the counter best online pharmacy to buy tadalafil betnovate women buy is 100 mg of synthroid a lot buy abilify online no prescription needed lopressor 100/25 buspar ordering online pharmacy is chloroquine legal in uk accutane order in the us online prinivil purchase donde comprar maillot livestrong erythromycin 250 mg e c tabs shortage of reglan bipolar medication-lithium carbonate phenergan birth control online mexico buy alavert capsules paxil discount voucher generic doxycycline no prescription where to purchase finasteride proscar usa generic digoxin us benemid online uk how to use astelin spray cymbalta medicine cost nizoral shampoo reviews india erythromycin 500mg filmtab buying alesse cialis coupons for pharmacy pfizer coupon buy zyvox get feldene toronto rocaltrol italiano bupropion 100mg sr tab metformin generic canada
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews Interview - Rudy Telscher - Attorney, CDM Fantasy Sports

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 904 guests online

Atom RSS

Interview - Rudy Telscher - Attorney, CDM Fantasy Sports PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Thursday, 08 November 2007 04:45
Rudy Telscher

In court cases involving professional sports, there may not be one in recent memory that will have the impact that CBC Marketing Inc. and the MLB Players’ Association and MLB Advanced Media is currently engaged in. CBC owns CDM Fantasy Sports, a fantasy sports company at the heart of the legal case.

In the simplest of terms, the case revolves around how the fantasy sports industry is able to use statistics in conjunction with MLB player names. The “Fantasy Stats” case, as it has been coined, will impact how rights of privacy, the First Amendment, and contractual obligation is interpreted. MLB, and other professional sports leagues that have filed supporting briefs, believe that by using a player’s name with their statistics, the player is being exploited. CBC has countered that name with the statistics is information protected by the First Amendment.

It also impacts revenues for both fantasy sports companies, and professional sports leagues looking to capitalize on the fantasy game frenzy. Online fantasy sports now constitute a billion-dollar industry, with between 15 and 18 million unique players participating every year in fantasy baseball or football, according to the Fantasy Sports Trade Association.

Rudy Telscher, with Harness, Dickey & Pierce, P.L.C. is CBC’s attorney in the case. Given the impact of the case (read from our Fantasy Stats Case section), the Biz of Baseball caught up with Telscher for this interview. It should be noted that the case is still not fully closed, and that the Business of Sports Network would like to present the opposing view of the case by way of the MLBPA and MLBAM to provide a balanced view of this important case. – Maury Brown

Maury Brown for the Business of Sports Network: The C.B.C. v MLBAM/MLBPA case has been referred to in some circles as "David vs. Goliath". How were you approached on the case, and what are the intriguing aspects of it?

Telscher quote on case being David v. GoliathTelscher: There is no question that this was a classic David vs. Goliath. Major League Baseball Players Association is a wealthy organization that staffed the case with multiple large national firms. The Players Association took a very aggressive approach, insisting that our client simply get out of the business. Further, if our client had lost, it would have meant that about 100-200 fantasy companies would have gone out of business. These are the same companies that helped build this industry to what it is today.

Bizball: With the 2-1 one ruling in favor to uphold the lower court's summary judgment, you gain yet another victory for CBC. Yet, even the judges ruling in favor raised concerns regarding CBC contractual obligations being broken. If for some reason the Supreme Court were to say that the case was certworthy, do you feel that the first amendment would continue to trump that aspect?

Telscher: The 8th Circuit's ruling is a major victory for our client, the 100 plus companies that built the fantasy industry and continue to run businesses that provide fantasy services (they would have gone out of business had we lost), and the fans who will not have to pay monopoly pricing and will greater alternative game formats that necessarily arise in a highly competitive market (imagine how few alternatives a consumer would have in the car market if there were only one or two manufacturers).

Telscher on First AmendmentThe 8th Circuit was unanimous that the First Amendment trumps player rights of publicity. Judge Colloton only dissented on the contract issue. That issue is specific only to whether CBC had the right to challenge MLB's rights, not whether the First Amendment trumps player rights of publicity. That issue is irrelevant to the overall issue and those companies that did not sign contracts with MLB.

I think the only reason the Supreme Court would take this case is if it is interested in the interplay between the First Amendment and state law rights of publicity. It has only decided one case in that area before and that was back in the 1970s. I doubt the contract issue will be enticing to it, especially given that the 8th Circuit ruled on state contract interpretation principles and not under federal preemption (the Supreme Court case of Lear v. Adkins).


Bizball: Was there a conscious effort by C.B.C. to sue before being sued, knowing that in doing so Missouri state law would come into play as opposed to New York state law?

Telscher:
CBC did not pick Missouri because of any legal difference. When the Players Association refused to grant it a license to operate its fantasy games, it had no choice but to sue to have its rights declared. CBC is based in St. Louis and that is why St. Louis was picked as the place to bring the lawsuit.

Bizball: Many have asked what the difference is between how information on baseball cards differs from the information that is provided through fantasy sports companies. Can you describe the difference?

Telscher: I think that fantasy’s use of baseball statistics is more akin to a newspaper because newspapers and fantasy provide and use the mass statistics for all athletes, not just some as with baseball cards. That said, baseball cards provide the same information as newspapers and I would think that baseball card manufacturers should receive the same First Amendment protections for their information products as do newspapers. I would not be surprised to see baseball and other sports get challenged on this point.

Bizball: While the case has focused on statistics and their use, the real issue at hand has been about the use of player names in association with the statistics. From your point of view, is that truly the case, or would any case involving information that is readily available via a host of mediums by way of boxscores, etc. never find the light of a courtroom?

Telscher: I interpret your question to be whether the resolved issue in this case has broader implications. In our case, the 8th Circuit affirmed the district court's decision that the use of publicly available statistics in fantasy games, even though it uses, by definition, the names of the players is protected by the First Amendment and supersedes any rights of publicity that the players might otherwise have. Similar situations already exist. For example, asking questions about the movies of Brad Pitt or Jennifer Aniston involve the use of their names and associated data/accomplishments in a game for profit as used in Trivial Pursuit and Jeopardy. So does Las Vegas' practice of betting on the accomplishments of individual players performances during a specific game. The broader holding of the case is legitimately interpreted to be that use of historical information that relates to famous people in any way they see fit (there may be some limits depending on individual fact patterns) is protected by the First Amendment.

Bizball: What preparations, if any, are you and C.B.C. doing now that the 8th Circuit has affirmed the lower court ruling?

Telscher: The Players Association and Advanced Media (the owners group) have both filed petitions for rehearing and rehearing en banc. These petitions are rarely granted. After that, the Players Association can file a petition for Supreme Court review, which is also rarely granted. Until it exhausts those final avenues, the case is not final.  When the process is final, all of the fantasy industry will be able to operate fantasy games without the Players Association interfering.

Telscher on NFLBizball: If MLBAM/MLBPA decides to drop the case, or the Appeals Court or Supreme Court decide not to take the case, how will it impact the fantasy sports industry?

Telscher: The 8th Circuit decision stands for the proposition that use of player statistics in fantasy is protected under the First Amendment. MLB would be bound by the decision and could not ever relitigate it. The implications of the decision extend to any fantasy sport though. The only caveat is that the NFL could sue some company in another circuit, for example, the 2nd Circuit in New York, and as a matter of federalism, the 2nd Circuit is not technically bound by the 8th Circuit's decision. It would be possible, although not likely in my view, that the 2nd Circuit could resolve the First Amendment issue differently than the 8th Circuit. If the latter did occur, however, the odds of the Supreme Court taking the case (split in the Circuits) would go way up. Given that the 8th Circuit's decision is consistent with some similar type cases (Cardtoons, Gionfriddo, and ETW), I think the odds are that other Circuits will follow the 8th Circuit's lead, but there are no guarantees.

Bizball: Do you think that those companies that have licenses with MLBAM may now reconsider?

Telscher:  Absolutely. Whether they can back out of those agreements and on what terms may be governed by the actual provisions, but most contracts would provide the ability to exit. Further, most contracts of this nature have relatively short terms and will therefore likely expire in the next year or so in any event. Given the ruling, I doubt that many, if any, companies will renew their contracts in the event that they cannot terminate immediately.

Telscher quote on monopolyBizball: Lastly, this will become key case law at some point, impacting not only Major League Baseball, but a host of other professional sports. What are your philosophical views on the outcome of C.B.C. v. MLBAM?

Telscher: The reasoning of professional players regarding why fans should pay them to play fantasy and why they should monopolize this industry is because they contend that their rights of publicity are being violated. Rights of publicity are designed to put more money into the pockets of professional athletes and famous people more generally. There are times when that is fair, for example, when a famous person is used to advertise and promote a product. With fantasy sports, however, consumers are not led to believe that professional athletes are endorsing the fantasy games. Everyone plainly knows that they are not. Thus, there is no legitimate reason to think that consumers should have to pay monopoly pricing to play fantasy sports, no more so than professional athletes should be able to charge for the use of their statistics in newspapers, which would drive up the cost of newspapers. Professional athletes played no part in building the fantasy industry and they should not be able to come in 25 years later and take over an industry that they did not build.


Interview conducted and edited by Maury Brown
 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?