instant online loans no credit check can you get a personal loan with bad credit western union prepaid credit card canada top store rewards cards pay sears credit card citibank credit cards for bad credit pay jcpenney credit card with gift card secured capital one credit card login credit card protection compensation how do i check the status of a us bank credit card application what is a secured credit card best way to get credit card with no credit mobile credit card machines for small business uk hdfc titanium international credit card login standard chartered bank credit card customer care online credit card processing companies instructions on how to use a credit card machine marathon gas credit card black card visa uk secured major credit cards google credit card compare credit card service providers uk td canada trust visa infinite rewards halifax credit card application process mastercard debit card philippines s&p credit rating how long does it take to get a lloyds credit card cibc mastercard credit card login venture capital one credit card limits prepaid vanilla visa card do i need a credit card to sign up for amazon what is a credit card cash advance rate city bank credit card apply india hdfc credit card helpline no chandigarh first premier credit card cash advance limit united mileage plus credit card customer service phone number typical credit card limits canada pay off credit card debt with student loans credit cards 101 what are credit cards black card points commonwealth bank australia visa debit card hdfc credit card online payment through sbi credit card nandos black card how to get best balance transfer credit cards existing customers how to get a credit card with very bad credit instant cash loans now credit card calculator apr interest pay standard chartered credit card payment credit cards with low interest rates for students visa credit card application instant approval sears master credit card login nab credit card interest free period valid credit card numbers with cvv online best online payday loans reviews credit card payments over the phone uk how to pay hdfc credit card payment options opt out of credit card offers gov westpac visa credit card travel insurance delta skymiles credit card baggage fee best rewards cards canada 2012 ge amazon credit card phone number update apple id credit card on ipad credit card banks in pune how to best use a secured credit card to build credit apply for halifax credit card online visa canada credit card no interest credit cards for fair credit apply for mastercard credit card balance transfer credit cards good credit rating how long does it take to get a credit card rbc how to get a black card in fifa 12 santander 123 cashback credit card annual fee elavon credit card machine rolls hsbc credit card rewards philippines visa card uk contact number discover card credit score tracker lloyds tsb student credit card apply online hsbc premier credit card hong kong citibank balance transfer existing card best credit cards for college students with bad credit citibank credit card customer service number usa credit card travel rewards comparison 0 apr credit card meaning orchard bank credit card application bad credit need a credit card list of online payday loan lenders balance transfer explained best short term cash loans credit card online abn amro ics apply for a walmart credit card online discover credit card reviews 2011 what is the best credit card deal at the moment barclays credit card ppi refund applying for credit cards with poor credit bank of america instant credit card approval number apply for maurices credit card online cheapest way to transfer money from credit card post office platinum card review uk payday lenders no brokers visa credit card return protection business credit card with cash back rewards how to check bpi credit card application status online are credit card consolidation loans good bad credit loan no broker lic online payment through hdfc credit card charges the best credit card transfer deal credit cards with low apr for life sunoco gas station credit cards low interest rate credit cards for college students walmart credit card number customer service interest free credit cards on purchases and balance transfers citibank credit card payment billdesk bad credit loans no guarantor no fees cerulean discover credit card application aspire credit card contact number how to apply for a hsbc credit card in the philippines how to allow credit card payments on ebay which is the best credit card to have in india transfer balance credit cards fair credit td us visa cards how to get a prepaid credit card under 18 best american airlines credit card 2013 free apple credit card reader first usa credit card login hdfc credit card reward points redemption gold easy fast payday loans no faxing citibank cash back credit card cash back credit card explained credit card apr rates average barclay bank credit card bill pay prepaid credit cards in canada with no fees virgin prepaid credit card uk halifax credit card online security prepaid credit cards travel abroad walmart credit card prepaid vodafone to airtel balance transfer code axis bank credit card reward points for platinum card what are some of the best credit cards to have how to pay sbi credit card bill online with other bank i have no credit but i want a credit card credit cards abroad compare prepaid credit cards freedom post office uk credit card store credit cards with instant approval capital one cash credit card reviews credit cards with cashback on gas best buy credit card accounthdfc credit card settlement process india chase british airways credit card hdfc credit card interest rate 2013 chase freedom credit card customer service american airline credit card promotions credit card merchant account no monthly fee pay direct student loans 5 best credit cards for travel chase british airways credit card customer service luma credit card reviews best credit card canada no annual fee horizon unsecured credit card reviews apply for nationwide credit card online credit card debt help forum best credit card interest rates south africa disney rewards visa credit card review visa low interest rate credit cards compare premium credit cards in india walmart credit card score requirements all of the following are limitations of the existing online credit card payment system except credit card with bad credit canada portable credit card machine iphone easy credit cards to get approved for with bad credit canada hsbc credit card travel insurance apply online for credit card with bad credit credit card bad credit rating ireland best low interest fixed rate credit cards corporate credit card policy guidelines capital one aspire world credit card lost gap visa card im 18 and have no credit how do i get a credit card coast capital credit card desjardins hsbc credit card 50 cash back payday advance no credit check apply credit cards online no credit does costco accept credit cards best credit cards bad credit no deposit make credit card payments with paypal online merchant credit card processing companies how to make standard chartered credit card online payment what is a credit card cash advance can i do a balance transfer from someone else;s credit card to mine does newegg accept international credit cards low rate credit card offers search bhs co uk credit card average credit card rate uk payday advance loan uk ann taylor mastercard credit card login prepaid credit cards no fees canada credit card processing app for kindle fire small business credit card offers best neiman marcus credit card approval best balance transfer credit card india does mobil gas station take credit cards credit card terminal app for blackberry visa credit card application no credit visa credit card for students bank of america bank of america credit card apr chase slate credit card international fees barclays lost credit card usa how to load paper in verifone credit card machine free credit card reader for android phones bank of america report credit card fraud delta credit card cash program credit limit calculator java program old orchard bank credit cards starwood preferred guest business credit card from american express open calculate credit card minimum payment excel hdfc credit card application form download american express black credit card india best buy store credit gift cards money magazine credit card ratings 2012 how to redeem icici credit card reward points online usaa credit card score requirements view hdfc credit card statement online 1 hour no credit check payday loans free credit card details 2013 uk opening new credit cards hurt credit score apply for credit card with bad credit in canada 0 interest credit cards for 18 months payday loans like speedy cash instant payday loans online uk your access to natwest credit card online services is locked out 0 interest credit cards no balance transfer chase credit card payment history manual credit card machine requirements for credit card application hsbc pay belk credit card sears credit card current interest rate credit card balance transfer no fee no interest guaranteed unsecured credit cards for poor credit calculate monthly credit card interest calculator secured visa credit cards canada how old do you have to be to get a credit card in ontario canada next payday advance reviews government travel credit card login payday loan no credit check no broker ny and company credit card payment address hsbc premier credit card minimum payment best buy credit card no credit how can i apply for payoneer mastercard starbucks platinum card sold out capital one balance transfer fee amex starwood credit card reviews small business loans for veterans with bad credit cash back credit card calculator tribute gold mastercard credit card application citibank credit cards online india can you pay sears credit card with a gift card is it illegal to charge customers for credit card processing fees american express black card no credit limit fbi credit card information form cash converters pay day advance nz the loan shop payday loan online post office credit card contact telephone number travel rewards credit cards uk credit card with good exchange rates suze orman new credit card rules generate us credit card number what do i need to accept credit cards online value city credit card customer service phone number walmart credit card credit card nhs black card code lowest rate credit cards 2012 african bank credit card limit increase online bank of ireland visa credit card services bank of america student credit card no credit history canada credit card comparison 2012 natwest credit card online services review email sagepay test credit card numbers indusind bank credit cards statement tesco credit card deals for existing customers secured credit cards for really bad credit new visa credit card fees best usaa credit card 2012 target debit visa card balance bad credit loans no credit check chevron texaco credit card payment login best balance transfer credit cards 2012 malaysia prepaid credit cards canada visa types of credit cards available for tourists signed credit card verification form best no foreign transaction fee credit card 2013 icici credit card status check amscot cash advance tampa fl disposable credit card numbers uk getting a credit card machine for small business what is a credit card number i can use anz credit card insurance cover compare credit cards for business holiday gas station credit card offers best credit cards for college students 2013 cibc visa reward cards what is the best credit card in canada for rewards pay as you go credit card processing canada chevron credit card login in biggest credit card companies get instant payday loan online how to pay sbi credit card bill online from citibank bad credit mortgage lenders 2013 no fee low interest rate credit card mobile credit card processing iphone uk top travel reward credit cards canada apply for apple mac credit card is credit card insurance necessary black cardamom curry payment protection credit card vs debit card easy payday loans online how to get an unsecured credit card with bad credit bpi credit card application form pdf how to get a black card from american express bank of ireland visa debit card locked new cash advance lenders uk store credit cards and bad credit how to verify paypal account with virtual credit card where is the issue number on a visa debit card best american airlines credit card signup bonus citibank credit cards offers in india starbucks gold card perks best reward credit card offers 2013 mbna credit card canada review gift visa card standard chartered credit card travel points online payday loan scams review same day loans online bad credit credit card types in canada best corporate credit cards in india hsbc credit card minimum payment percentage 10 top credit card for bad credit no fax easy payday loans retail store credit cards after bankruptcy icici virtual credit card india best uk credit card offers amex gold credit card uk credit card numbers master cards business cash advances website to pay maurices credit card payday loans direct lender no credit check online uk large personal bad credit loans bank of america amazon credit card terms and conditions clark howard best travel rewards credit cards quick credit card approval online chase credit limit increase chase disney rewards visa card login how long does it take to get a credit card once approved icici credit card customer care number kochi credit card terminal rental agreement bank of america student credit cards best small business credit cards canada ryanair credit debit card charges wireless credit card machine costco zurich credit card insurance australia best credit card app for ipad 0 apr credit cards offers us bank credit card consolidate credit card debt calculator how do you get a nandos black card can you sign up for amazon without a credit card anz platinum credit card travel insurance ebay change payment from credit card to paypal guaranteed approval unsecured visa credit card tesco credit card interest refund how do cash advances on credit cards work mbna credit card canada instant approval personal loan bad credit direct lender square credit card business model all types of hdfc credit cards natwest student credit card ppi best credit card cashback deals hdfc credit card payment by cheque wells fargo secured credit card no annual fee south west trains gold card customer service virgin credit card rate jacking costco business credit card application unsecured loan bad credit instant decision 0 percent interest business credit card goodyear credit card login in pay firestone credit card online how to get a joint credit card payday loan online uk american express gold card credit score credit card fraud punishment can range travel rewards cards barclays credit card login uae how to lower credit card apr rate world;s first credit card 1950 credit cards for those with bad credit rating best travel rewards credit cards canada 2011 hdfc credit card payment online from other credit card apply for barclaycard platinum credit card my first premier credit card customer service hdfc credit card reward points redemption business credit cards with cashback how to apply for a credit card online with hsbc best long term bad credit loans best unsecured credit card for no credit free credit cards with no annual fee best credit card rewards comparison chase visa business credit card credit card verification process india credit card with no annual fee real visa credit card numbers 2013 top 5 credit cards 2013 same day quick cash loans can i get a discover credit card with bad credit credit card reader app for iphone uk credit limit increase capital one credit card hdfc credit card verification form chase apply credit card how to improve credit score when you can;t get a credit card how is interest calculated on credit cards in canada credit card logos for website monthly apr calculator credit card credit card debt relief citi debit visa card balance check best no annual fee credit card 2013 apply visa credit card online india aib visa debit card fees which credit card charges chase credit card compare visa low apr credit cards how to apply credit card in bdo philippines singapore airlines credit card verification form what do i need for an amscot payday advance bank of america pay loans online low apr credit cards with rewards hdfc credit card offer on goibibo can i use discover credit card in canada fake visa credit card number with security code electronic stores that offer credit cards credit card reward points value best no fee credit card canada easy to get credit card ireland how does bank of america secured credit card work car loans with bad credit history mastercard business credit cards rewards ge capital bank credit card customer service best miles credit card for international travel how do thieves get credit card numbers hdfc instant credit card bill payment best 0 apr credit cards no balance transfer fee dbs credit card promotions singapore hdfc credit card payment by cheque drop box credit cards no foreign transaction fees 2013 santander 123 credit card cash back list best travel credit cards consumer reports credit card minimum payment formula citi corporate credit cards login new credit card apply online hdfc personal loans to consolidate credit cards discover cashback bonus credit card review direct payday loan lenders only no credit check old navy visa card application pay best buy credit card online standard chartered credit card online payment login student with bad credit need credit card online payday lenders california best unsecured bad credit cards credit card terminal for iphone 4 withdraw paypal virtual credit card cheapest credit card machine for small business what is my american express credit limit best fixed rate credit cards 2013 top 10 credit cards for bad credit uk should i consolidate credit cards visa credit card number 2013 with cvv free cash back credit cards india public savings bank open sky secured visa card make ann taylor credit card payment can you get store credit cards with bad credit top credit card issuers in malaysia chase credit card student sbi credit card online apply how to use provident gold card online credit card offer opt out website va loans with bad credit score free visa credit card number and cvv 100 guaranteed payday loans does applying for credit card hurt score best credit card with airmiles canada when was the first credit card issued in australia unsecured credit cards bad credit no bank account citibank credit card uk where is the credit card number located on a visa gift card mastercard credit card foreign exchange rates best credit card consolidation companies reviews zurich credit card insurance cba premium credit cards low rate credit card comparison australia credit card fraud detection project source code pay sbi credit card bill online icici online payday loan companies no credit costco elavon credit card processing best first credit card to get uk
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews Interview - Rudy Telscher - Attorney, CDM Fantasy Sports

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 843 guests online

Atom RSS

Interview - Rudy Telscher - Attorney, CDM Fantasy Sports PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
Written by Maury Brown   
Thursday, 08 November 2007 04:45
Rudy Telscher

In court cases involving professional sports, there may not be one in recent memory that will have the impact that CBC Marketing Inc. and the MLB Players’ Association and MLB Advanced Media is currently engaged in. CBC owns CDM Fantasy Sports, a fantasy sports company at the heart of the legal case.

In the simplest of terms, the case revolves around how the fantasy sports industry is able to use statistics in conjunction with MLB player names. The “Fantasy Stats” case, as it has been coined, will impact how rights of privacy, the First Amendment, and contractual obligation is interpreted. MLB, and other professional sports leagues that have filed supporting briefs, believe that by using a player’s name with their statistics, the player is being exploited. CBC has countered that name with the statistics is information protected by the First Amendment.

It also impacts revenues for both fantasy sports companies, and professional sports leagues looking to capitalize on the fantasy game frenzy. Online fantasy sports now constitute a billion-dollar industry, with between 15 and 18 million unique players participating every year in fantasy baseball or football, according to the Fantasy Sports Trade Association.

Rudy Telscher, with Harness, Dickey & Pierce, P.L.C. is CBC’s attorney in the case. Given the impact of the case (read from our Fantasy Stats Case section), the Biz of Baseball caught up with Telscher for this interview. It should be noted that the case is still not fully closed, and that the Business of Sports Network would like to present the opposing view of the case by way of the MLBPA and MLBAM to provide a balanced view of this important case. – Maury Brown

Maury Brown for the Business of Sports Network: The C.B.C. v MLBAM/MLBPA case has been referred to in some circles as "David vs. Goliath". How were you approached on the case, and what are the intriguing aspects of it?

Telscher quote on case being David v. GoliathTelscher: There is no question that this was a classic David vs. Goliath. Major League Baseball Players Association is a wealthy organization that staffed the case with multiple large national firms. The Players Association took a very aggressive approach, insisting that our client simply get out of the business. Further, if our client had lost, it would have meant that about 100-200 fantasy companies would have gone out of business. These are the same companies that helped build this industry to what it is today.

Bizball: With the 2-1 one ruling in favor to uphold the lower court's summary judgment, you gain yet another victory for CBC. Yet, even the judges ruling in favor raised concerns regarding CBC contractual obligations being broken. If for some reason the Supreme Court were to say that the case was certworthy, do you feel that the first amendment would continue to trump that aspect?

Telscher: The 8th Circuit's ruling is a major victory for our client, the 100 plus companies that built the fantasy industry and continue to run businesses that provide fantasy services (they would have gone out of business had we lost), and the fans who will not have to pay monopoly pricing and will greater alternative game formats that necessarily arise in a highly competitive market (imagine how few alternatives a consumer would have in the car market if there were only one or two manufacturers).

Telscher on First AmendmentThe 8th Circuit was unanimous that the First Amendment trumps player rights of publicity. Judge Colloton only dissented on the contract issue. That issue is specific only to whether CBC had the right to challenge MLB's rights, not whether the First Amendment trumps player rights of publicity. That issue is irrelevant to the overall issue and those companies that did not sign contracts with MLB.

I think the only reason the Supreme Court would take this case is if it is interested in the interplay between the First Amendment and state law rights of publicity. It has only decided one case in that area before and that was back in the 1970s. I doubt the contract issue will be enticing to it, especially given that the 8th Circuit ruled on state contract interpretation principles and not under federal preemption (the Supreme Court case of Lear v. Adkins).

Bizball: Was there a conscious effort by C.B.C. to sue before being sued, knowing that in doing so Missouri state law would come into play as opposed to New York state law?

CBC did not pick Missouri because of any legal difference. When the Players Association refused to grant it a license to operate its fantasy games, it had no choice but to sue to have its rights declared. CBC is based in St. Louis and that is why St. Louis was picked as the place to bring the lawsuit.

Bizball: Many have asked what the difference is between how information on baseball cards differs from the information that is provided through fantasy sports companies. Can you describe the difference?

Telscher: I think that fantasy’s use of baseball statistics is more akin to a newspaper because newspapers and fantasy provide and use the mass statistics for all athletes, not just some as with baseball cards. That said, baseball cards provide the same information as newspapers and I would think that baseball card manufacturers should receive the same First Amendment protections for their information products as do newspapers. I would not be surprised to see baseball and other sports get challenged on this point.

Bizball: While the case has focused on statistics and their use, the real issue at hand has been about the use of player names in association with the statistics. From your point of view, is that truly the case, or would any case involving information that is readily available via a host of mediums by way of boxscores, etc. never find the light of a courtroom?

Telscher: I interpret your question to be whether the resolved issue in this case has broader implications. In our case, the 8th Circuit affirmed the district court's decision that the use of publicly available statistics in fantasy games, even though it uses, by definition, the names of the players is protected by the First Amendment and supersedes any rights of publicity that the players might otherwise have. Similar situations already exist. For example, asking questions about the movies of Brad Pitt or Jennifer Aniston involve the use of their names and associated data/accomplishments in a game for profit as used in Trivial Pursuit and Jeopardy. So does Las Vegas' practice of betting on the accomplishments of individual players performances during a specific game. The broader holding of the case is legitimately interpreted to be that use of historical information that relates to famous people in any way they see fit (there may be some limits depending on individual fact patterns) is protected by the First Amendment.

Bizball: What preparations, if any, are you and C.B.C. doing now that the 8th Circuit has affirmed the lower court ruling?

Telscher: The Players Association and Advanced Media (the owners group) have both filed petitions for rehearing and rehearing en banc. These petitions are rarely granted. After that, the Players Association can file a petition for Supreme Court review, which is also rarely granted. Until it exhausts those final avenues, the case is not final.  When the process is final, all of the fantasy industry will be able to operate fantasy games without the Players Association interfering.

Telscher on NFLBizball: If MLBAM/MLBPA decides to drop the case, or the Appeals Court or Supreme Court decide not to take the case, how will it impact the fantasy sports industry?

Telscher: The 8th Circuit decision stands for the proposition that use of player statistics in fantasy is protected under the First Amendment. MLB would be bound by the decision and could not ever relitigate it. The implications of the decision extend to any fantasy sport though. The only caveat is that the NFL could sue some company in another circuit, for example, the 2nd Circuit in New York, and as a matter of federalism, the 2nd Circuit is not technically bound by the 8th Circuit's decision. It would be possible, although not likely in my view, that the 2nd Circuit could resolve the First Amendment issue differently than the 8th Circuit. If the latter did occur, however, the odds of the Supreme Court taking the case (split in the Circuits) would go way up. Given that the 8th Circuit's decision is consistent with some similar type cases (Cardtoons, Gionfriddo, and ETW), I think the odds are that other Circuits will follow the 8th Circuit's lead, but there are no guarantees.

Bizball: Do you think that those companies that have licenses with MLBAM may now reconsider?

Telscher:  Absolutely. Whether they can back out of those agreements and on what terms may be governed by the actual provisions, but most contracts would provide the ability to exit. Further, most contracts of this nature have relatively short terms and will therefore likely expire in the next year or so in any event. Given the ruling, I doubt that many, if any, companies will renew their contracts in the event that they cannot terminate immediately.

Telscher quote on monopolyBizball: Lastly, this will become key case law at some point, impacting not only Major League Baseball, but a host of other professional sports. What are your philosophical views on the outcome of C.B.C. v. MLBAM?

Telscher: The reasoning of professional players regarding why fans should pay them to play fantasy and why they should monopolize this industry is because they contend that their rights of publicity are being violated. Rights of publicity are designed to put more money into the pockets of professional athletes and famous people more generally. There are times when that is fair, for example, when a famous person is used to advertise and promote a product. With fantasy sports, however, consumers are not led to believe that professional athletes are endorsing the fantasy games. Everyone plainly knows that they are not. Thus, there is no legitimate reason to think that consumers should have to pay monopoly pricing to play fantasy sports, no more so than professional athletes should be able to charge for the use of their statistics in newspapers, which would drive up the cost of newspapers. Professional athletes played no part in building the fantasy industry and they should not be able to come in 25 years later and take over an industry that they did not build.

Interview conducted and edited by Maury Brown


Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?