triamterene cheap uk zestril 20 mg tab online pet prescription consultation how to by nootropil online xenical uk brand name i pill retin-a 0,025 website buy avodart mg online what drug category is atorlip-20 do you need rx lincocin bupron xl dosage buy over the counter hyzaar online carafate online overnight to buy estrace in uk purchasing arimidex online rogaine 5 prescription coupon cheap generic kamagra sale alesse methotrexate pregnancy men eulexin not generic buy cheap cytotec online possible side effects of metformin celexa coupon code where can i get paxil robaxin over the counter usa revatio order in the us advair diskus generic 100 42 how much does the depo provera shot cost without insurance order prednisolone on line usa order hydrochlorothiazide on line india cytotec dose elocon barato ophthacare online ordering hydrochlorothiazide side effects long term use refissa tretinoin cream reviews best digoxin prices caverta 100 mg price pharmacy technician top 200 drugs flashcards intensiteti i zerit nolvadex how to buy nexium 20mg tablets used cipro what is a good over the counter medication for anxiety cheap brand cialis pills levitra reviews uk clozaril online sales safe nizagara buy vpxl perth australia can you buy aceon online blood western drug albenza cheap drugs online australia can you buy aspirin in ireland does propecia work better than rogaine ranitidine canada buy forzest 10 how to buy cialis online in europe healthy manicotti spinach cleocin gel price india yellow flagyl pills minocin without insurance side effects of pulmicort respules atacand on the internet buy lipitor 20 mg zyban 20 mg allegra 40 mg dose what is imitrex injection used for anacin generic 2013 drugs ethionamide online in us can buy diflucan online jaco costa rica pharmacy to buy liposafe in uk prescription viagra professional colchicine injection discontinued propecia in the us doxazosin tablets online how to by viagra online suppliers of seroflo in us bactroban cream generic name nootropil by mail order evista looking for Purchase exelon 1.5 mg india cialis pills side effects noroxin no prescription canada venlor no prrescription exelon generic reviews revatio 40 mg buy celebrex kamagra jelly sale uk cheap ciprofloxacin side effects liver viagra soft mexico topamax buy india purchase prilosec kamagra chewable reviews for men how to take lithium mg tegretol phone orders precose delivery london nexium dosage forms wellbutrin xl vs. generic bupropion venlor from india claravis reviews 2012 where is artane in dublin pharmacies cabana prescription atarax uses in children buy rumalaya from india what is cefixime drugs levitra onlain viagra for cheap with no prescriptions cheapest proventil buy levitra online us no prescription micardis canadian pharmacy buy levothyroxine in uk what drug category is haldol terbutaline dose pregnancy there generic emsam buy zerit usa Purchase citalopram 20mg proscar in the uk terramycin from turkey reviews use relafen coupon online levlen side effects weight gain otc prevacid dose cognitive enhancement drugs work list of all birth control pills on the market what does dramamine have in it can you order eldepryl where to buy advair mg pharmacy has best price levitra plus safe to buy generic arimidex from uk ?? isoptin 40 mg how to get phexin in australia carafate tablets uses hyzaar side effects sun how should nitroglycerin be stored side effects of pilex tablets micardis coupons buy benzac 40 stromectol online pharmacy uk hyaluronic acid tablets do they work how to buy renagel buy online kamagra 100mg nexium 40mg prices clomid over counter australia what class of drugs is micardis where to buy nolvadex forum azithromycin dihydrate molecular weight sumycin cheap buy diamox boots pharmacy pediatric dosage of augmentin buy vpxl in ireland welfil tadalafil 20 mg cheapest celadrin tablets uk ultra low dose nootropil diclofenaco potasico plendil brand positioning lopid where can i buy it testosterone therapy for menopause wellbutrin to buy from europe buy venlor capsules what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat keflex uk buy generic for omnicef cost of viagra best site for synthroid what types of levothroid are there erection pills gnc mebendazole buy online comprar fincar original en madrid plavix without prescription medication keflex cost canadian purchase proscar in uk post cycle therapy viagra zestril on line no script can you buy frumil what is enalapril maleate 10 mg used for letrozole femara cost best place to buy benadryl buy trandate inhaler canada heart medication tenormin side effects of plavix 75 mg female cialis medication where to buy buy generic viagra jelly online viagra jelly comprar benicar pas cher italie doryx capsules uses zyrtec d rx omnicef dose child pariet recommended dose ephedraxin suppositories buy generic innopran xl lipitor dosage information without order aciphex online amitriptyline pharmacy zantac tablets side effects over the counter water pills for dogs pharmacy has best price lotensin buy xalatan hong kong ocular hypertension prednisone for sale sustiva from usa pharmacy aldactone prescription medication counter what is clomiphene 50mg used for in men cyklokapron pas cher isoniazid for sale online ventolin expectorant in india lloyds pharmacy online shopping chemist seroquel xr for sale 33 drugs online review discount toradol mg generic name for evecare amoxicillin 500 mg price cvs losec dosage for children cvs minute clinic viagra penegra prescription coupon order generic tadapox legal buy lipitor online canada how to buy ranitidine in london online pharmacy no prescription needed dipyridamole can you get probalan what is cephalexin usually prescribed for where to buy zyrtec d cheap where purchase voveran canada pharmacies online that sell paroxetine jual viagra usa di jakarta buy glucotrol xl online no prescription online brand advair diskus india betnovate ointment (betamethasone valerate) forzest 20 mg price can buy lanoxin online coming off sertraline 50 mg can you buy cyklokapron canadian pharmacy zithromax para que se usa lamisil available in canada singulair usa cvs prices us online pharmacy no prescription suhagra plavix buy no prescription trazodone paypal lithium lawsuit plendil free shipping noprescription-meds coupon code better than luvox zanaflex mg price order acticin rx indian pharmacies online getting seroflo in australia indian pharmacy online cheap meds canada where to buy brand advair diskus ointment order lisinopril online no prescription with a visa generic levitra super active buy canada eurax new zealand where to buy malegra dxt ointment ordering medrol online buy haldol 5 ginseng buy on line what is the medicine periactin used for fluoxetine order online no prescription allopurinol gout attack coreg to buy in australia buy cafergot online with no prescription pharmacy has best price viagra sublingual buying glyset from canada no prescription duphalac maximum dosage actoplus met 100 review comprar tadalafil mexico order medications online without prescriptions requip side effects elderly cheapest antivert to buy can you buy micronase in ireland kamagra oral jelly without prescription miami cheap aricept us buy brand levitra for daily use how much does cialis cost in canada medication bentyl side effects order mycelex-g tablets buy pletal online with mastercard price increase brahmi atrovent dose neb price increase orlistat risperdal lawsuit children hunter boots promo code 2012 augmentin prospect 875 walmart pharmacy jobs canada best site to buy nolvadex side effects of vytorin 10 10 levlen canadian pharmacy cvs pharmacy discount prescriptions list generic metformin not working inderal mg canada lamictal usa sale doxine medicine for abortion do you need rx suhagra lowest price fml forte zetia class action lawsuit settlement list of tesco stores selling artane prednisone causes panting in dogs buy zovirax in the usa online generic benzac betapace tablets uses medicine calandar pharmacy amoxicillin tablets for sale meclizine online sales can buy propecia online ondansetron dose in pregnancy buy diflucan uk prescription where to buy ceftin online mexico better than viagra professional what is valtrex for herpes retin-a 0,025 discount voucher comprar arava original en madrid decadron 0 5mg posologia nitrofurantoin online uk buy aciphex in uk rogaine boots chemist best prices next day cheap precose buy lisinopril 10 ciprofloxacin spc pharmacy has best price femara diclofenac without a script erythromycin alcohol side effect discontinued use of cymbalta buy cabergoline australia acai powder cheap synthroid generic levothyroxine lithium transdermal delivery wellbutrin lawsuit canada chlamydia symptoms men discharge western drug brahmi we buy alligators approved remeron generic mirtazapine collagen booster with hyaluronic acid reviews aciphex ordering no prescription prescription lasix furosemide buy clozaril online safely voltaren reviews for men how to buy vermox in canada what does alligator jerky taste like buy alesse cheap online canadian pharmacy lasix 40 mg po stat methotrexate tablets rheumatoid arthritis fluoxetine generic tablets duetact shopping dutas side effects long term use abilify 10 mg tablet medisch tretinoin cream usp .05 reviews buy zanaflex pills in the canada can you get dulcolax over the counter abana supplier in uk seroflo price in india buy extendaquin singapore coconut water is a natural alternative to viagra manufacturer of citalopram in canada amitriptyline tablets from buy yasmin pharmacy order what is exelon patches used for ordering colchicine famciclovir dosage for shingles clomiphene citrate for men reviews brand advair diskus online sales setraline online buying speman using paypal where can i buy prednisone for cats atarax where to get digoxin coupon code normal dose range lexapro duloxetine and bupropion combination mexico pharmacies online that sell periactin where is the inferior parietal lobe zetia online prices generic zyrtec not working something works like viagra coumadin 100 review order midamor online without rx are synthroid and levothyroxine the same drug prescription pain medicine for migraines trimox usa sale pharmacy that sells suhagra is there a generic for advair diskus 500 50 what is trileptal made of avodart discount no prescription keppra 100 mg lo"sung can you buy effexor xr online finasteride 5mg tablet myl prograf online meds flagyl er in the uk now buy brand etodolac ordering low dose zyloprim cost of ginseng buy sinemet mg cat allergy symptoms viagra mint soft tabs 100mg buy omnicef 200 neurontin weight gain information methotrexate medicine interactions buy lasix online overnight delivery canadian pharmacy coumadin best place to buy generic propecia zyvox sales drugs zenegra ordering no prescription where to recycle lithium batteries flagyl canada cost nexium 400 mg prescription drugs where to buy retino-a cream 0,025 drugs online glucophage 500 mg 100 film tablet viagra for sale vancouver where can i buy finasteride propecia prograf generico italiano danazol to buy in england augmentin side effects deltasone next day shipping doxycycline mist canada eutirox 50 mg efectos secundarios mobic online order cheap canadian alliance church worship non persciption capoten foro donde comprar viagra normal starting dose lipitor european pharmacy modafinil suppliers of lasix in us buy augmentin 875 mg lasix online pharmacy uk elavil cost without insurance canadian atarax casodex to buy in england india trazodone price piracetam uk law metoclopramide 100mg cheep erexin-v online in us donde comprar exelon does valtrex have a shelf life generic pills for forzest otc ed pills reviews generic revatio switzerland buy atarax hong kong canadian online lesofat price philippines baclofen withdrawal schedule rhinocort usa minocycline coupon code phenergan online sales purchae avapro flagyl 4 suspension buvable lexapro on line purchase seroquel costco price tricor medicine coupons levitra professional results forum prescription estrace menopause 2mg zoloft for sale online are alligators endangered animals cost of flovent hfa como comprar wellbutrin sr ventolin albuterol hfa vasotec online meds sumatriptan generic for imitrex atorlip-10 sale parlodel on line no script new types of antibiotics blood pressure medicine toprol xl real viagra online pharmacy amoxicillin uses for stds lipitor long term usage indinavir online bestellen can you buy cialis professional in ireland fucidin now low cost anafranil buy canada no prescription for desyrel differin for men sale in uk 1 cheap online aciphex mg valtrex uk no prescription azithromycin dosage for chlamydia treatment nimotop lawsuit canada atacand on line for sale no script moduretic without a script buy xeloda hong kong cheap genuine astelin online lamictal for sale online sex stimulant pills for men hydrochlorothiazide sigma all types rumalaya pills lipitor shipping overseas cr2032 lithium battery price india can women take proscar for hair loss buy retin-a 0,05 no prescription can you buy fucidin over counter uk proscar discount canadian pharmacy eurax accutane 40 mg a day albenza for sale australia para que sirve el aciclovir 400 mg cranberry juice and coumadin therapy buy rumalaya liniment in india online safeway pharmacy methotrexate error generic pills for femara haldol tropfen 10 mg minocycline mg price how to order atacand online pastillas para abortar en colombia 2011 resources for nizoral acquisto viagra professional sicuro online best site get nootropil biaxin drug schedule where to get propecia in south africa uroxatral side effects long term use can you buy zaditor over the counter in germany provera ships from india septilin shopping combivent inhaler dose stieva-a 0.05 moduretic tablets dosage doxycycline overnight shipping cheap tadalafil tadacip 20 mg does doxycycline hyclate work for acne wellbutrin woldwide shipping generic combivent no prescription buy glycomet greece buy celebrex from india lopressor over counter uk levlen 40 mg pharmacy cymbalta dosage cheap generic viagra super active diflucan rx for yeast infection altace tablets 150 mg what is ciprofloxacin hcl taken for how many types of viagra are there 10 mg bystolic cost buy hong kong cheap zyloprim online use bupropion coupon online fluoxetine medication interaction keppra from india better than zoloft silagra cost canadian canada drugs lamisil with prescription lexapro 20 mg vs 10 mg how to order lukol online beconase aq pill shop discount code buy viagra online in praha cardura cheap uk aygestin australia pharmacy coreg alternative drugs mail order nizagara buy metoclopramide discount vgr 100 street value no prescription lotensin sale order yasmin tablets buy amaryl in ireland tretinoin cream usp .025 side effects online urispas india coversyl consumer information cephalexin mexico no prescription prilosec price to buy viagra soft in uk premarin vag cream dosage xenical delivery uk my zestoretic coupons brand lozol for sale hydrochlorothiazide lawsuit settlements what are prednisolone tablets used for in dogs genuine trimox 100mg brand cialis for sale uk over counter minomycin albendazole without prescription pills dutas comprare what is ataraxia epicurus cialis jelly shortage 2012 where to buy abortion pills in the philippines buy flovent capsules lamictal from canada keppra price at walmart buy maxaman online from usa buy kamagra online uk skelaxin us companies only what is bystolic tablets used for generic diamox for sale on line order alli orlistat pharmacy where to buy generic viagra online in canada can you only get valtrex on prescription is it illegal to order generic l-tryptophan where cane you buy valtrex differin mail order discount code for seroflo where can i get keflex best viagra professional prices buy liv 52 new zealand online purchase cheap prescription fincar online lamisil tablets 250 mg side effects azithromycin zithromax price philippines order augmentin tablets pharmacy examining board canada pebc can we trust didronel online what is nimotop pills used for where to buy zestril drugs online can you take relafen daily buy pharmaceuticals online india citalopram medications for ocd generic uk paypal probalan buy tinidazole tindamax protonix now co uk buy zyloprim from mexico online buy promethazine codeine syrup with no prescription wellbutrin xl name brand vs generic sale zenegra tretinoin 0,025 overnight pharmacy triamcinolone cream side effects online canada meds coupon lopid shopping betnovate price india glucophage online with out prescription where to buy buspar online where to buy cialis online safely nhs job search zyrtec 10 mg and benadryl how much is serophene tablets legitimate canadian pharmacy no perscription clomid without prescription uk buy sinequan online pharmacy use apcalis sx coupon online atorvastatin vs simvastatin potency elavil 20 mg side effects best remeron dose for sleep 1mg finasteride canada actos discount these oregon state beavers football schedule kamagra jelly 100 mg viagra cipro xr 500mg bula wellbutrin pill shop discount code original viagra per nachnahme pulmicort from usa pharmacy what is sildenafil made from altace side effects weight gain can you get aleve over the counter floxin without prescriptions cialis in singapore where to buy toprol xl ordering no prescription nitroglycerin buy on line what drug category is metoclopramide hyzaar over counter uk dramamine reviews and dosage claritin maximum dosage cheap fincar pills discount canadian pharmacy aceon singulair cost 5mg strattera mexico discount order aceon without topamax reviews side effects pletal 100mg cheep where can i buy retino-a cream 0,05 cialis soft for daily use canada no prescription albenza sale cheap metformin buy generic pilex tablet/ointment (himalaya drugs) erectile dysfunction aids how long is withdrawal from effexor xr dramamine medicine online where to buy nizoral in canada where to buy nizoral in canada safely tricor pill shortage xeloda 500mg price india buy detrol boots pharmacy where to buy misoprostol abortion pill provera 2 5 mg best price cialis generic buy yagara for daily use best drugstore powder foundation for dry skin code red 7 pill male enhancement orlistat 120 mg price india can hydrochlorothiazide and lisinopril get you high is generic depakote available in usa foreign pharmacy price for atorvastatin atarax dogs uk discount acivir pills pharmacie de garde geneve champel what is hydrochlorothiazide tablets used for venlor where can i buy it generic flovent in usa cheap brand aceon 2 mg best overseas pharmacy forum aldactone tablet 100 mg 16 tb clomid drug store online 1 gbp to euro tesco ashwagandha shoppers drug mart canadian online pharmacy for antivert best place buy finast pct mail order generic myambutol fosamax on line no script brand yagara buy viagra dosage 150 protonix iv for gi bleed buy glucotrol xl with no rx what is ranitidine drugs what is diovan made of pyridium mg price prescription drug astelin voltaren 50 dosage acivir pills tablets price dilantin loading dose cheap car insurance donde puedo comprar una membresia de xbox live can you buy prescription drugs online without
Home All Articles Busch Corollary: Valuating Second-Hand Naming Rights

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 416 guests online

Atom RSS

Busch Corollary: Valuating Second-Hand Naming Rights PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 15
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Kurt Hunzeker   
Wednesday, 15 August 2007 16:19
 Busch Corollary Analysis
           Select the image to see a break
              down of the Busch Corollary

Kurt Hunzeker, of the Business of Sports Network, releases this intriguing article which looks to place a definative value on a secondary naming rights deal. Enjoy, The Busch Corollary:  Second-hand Naming-Rights Diminished Value Equation - Maury Brown, Founder and President - Business of Sports Network

When shopping for a previously-owned car, a prospective buyer should utilize all of the resources available (like CARFAX) to ensure he or she is not purchasing a lemon.  A car is a serious investment, and careful consideration and a thorough understanding of prices, safety reports and re-sale value should be paramount before a transaction takes place.

Sports venues’ naming-rights deals should be no different, but in today’s sports business and sponsorship marketplace, a CARFAX-esque report or analysis of a second-hand naming-rights agreement does not exist.  If one existed, corporate decision-makers might be able to sleep at night, knowing that their new naming-rights deal was secured at a favorable price.

Now, The Busch Corollary arms them with a second-hand naming-rights deal’s quantifiable “diminished value,” based solely on hard numbers about the venue and the previous rights holders.

In terms of distinguishing value, consider that the original rights holder reaps the benefits of branding a new sports venue, and one of the city’s most well-known landmarks.  The first name associated with a building automatically becomes the reflex standard; everyone remembers the building by its original name.  One does not need a mathematical equation to see this long-lasting value.

It does not matter if the name is corporate-based (i.e. San Diego’s PETCO Park) or a family name (Cleveland’s Jacobs Field); the first name will be the first answer when asked where does “insert-team-name-here” play.

This past February, I introduced the idea of The Busch Corollary in an effort to define the sports industry’s widely-accepted practice of re-selling a venue’s naming-rights sponsorships.  But one needs to measure this phenomenon in order to fully understand the ramifications of teams entering into agreements with financially-questionable companies, and the price companies pay in brand value when they rename a sports venue due to a merger or buyout.

Corporations see sports venues’ naming rights as a national advertising vehicle that expands their audience and their ability to communicate with a desirable demographic in a non-obtrusive environment.  Every naming-rights deal includes additional components like luxury suites, broadcast commercial time and other marketing opportunities.  Companies aim to maximize their investments by creating revenue-generating platforms and other programming (ticket giveaways, exclusive experiences, sweepstakes, etc.) around their namesake venue.

From a branding perspective alone, corporations utilize naming-rights agreements as a direct way to increase the value of its brand by aligning it squarely with that of the hometown team.

For second-hand naming-rights holders, does this perceived increase in team-transferred brand value offset the inherent loss of value in their hand-me-down naming-rights deal?

A study of existing, second-hand naming-rights agreements and a look at what a potential buyer would be receiving by renaming a one-owner/name venue suggest that a considerable loss of value is almost guaranteed with any “previously-owned” naming-rights deal.

(Select Read More to see the rest of this ground breaking research) 

THE BUSCH COROLLARY DEFINITION

When Anheuser-Busch purchased the St. Louis Cardinals in 1953, new owner August Anheuser “Gussie” Busch, Jr. wanted to rename Sportsman’s Park to Budweiser Stadium as part of a new, national advertising strategy.  Back then, Major League Baseball did not allow alcoholic beverage names to adorn their ballparks’ facades.

(The enterprising beer magnate then asked if he could change the ballpark’s moniker to “Busch Stadium” to honor to his family.  After receiving league approval, Gussie Busch green-lighted the development of a new brand at the brewery, and the very next year, Busch Beer entered the marketplace.)

But St. Louisians never used the new name for their old ballpark.  Sportsman’s Park was Sportsman’s Park, and the brewery’s renaming was not going to change their habits.

When the Cardinals began construction on its new home, Gussie Busch made sure that this new ballpark would be christened as Busch Stadium.  Since this new venue did not have any other name before it opened in 1966, fans always considered it Busch Stadium.

In the truest, mathematical definition of the term, The Busch Corollary suggests that any second-hand naming-rights agreement will always have perceived diminished value compared to the original titleholder’s initial agreement, unless the selling property sets its price comparable (if not equal) to the relationship between the former rights holder’s price, the number of names the venue has been known as, and the total number of years the building was known by a different name.

The question potential buyers must ask themselves centers on how much value are they willing to overpay for the naming-rights agreement, or better yet, how much value-added components must the team include in the sponsorship package to offset this loss in brand value.

And how does one quantify this diminished value?

THE BUSCH COROLLARY EQUATION

Using simple algebraic letters to denote naming-rights deals’ quantifiable variables, The Busch Corollary Equation calculates the percentage of diminished value percentage (dv, which will always be a negative number) for non-original, naming-rights agreements:

dv = s / [(p / n) / y]

The variables to solve such an equation remain the same regardless of sport:

s = second-hand rights holder’s annual sponsorship fee
p = previous rights holder(s)’ average annual sponsorship fee
n = total number of names the venue has held since its opening
y = total number of years the venue had a previous rights holder(s)’ name

THE BUSCH COROLLARY – HOUSTON ASTROS’ MINUTE MAID PARK

Here is an example using the Houston Astros’ two naming-rights holders for its ballpark:  Enron Field (2000-2002) and Minute Maid Park (2003-present):

s = Minute Maid pays $6,357,143 annually, per its naming-rights agreement
p = Enron paid $6,500,000 annually
n = The ballpark has had three (3) names, including the 2-month, interim solution, Astros Field
y = The Enron Field/Astros Field brands lasted only two (2) years before Minute Maid signed

dv = s / [(p / n) / y]

dv = $6,357,143 / [($6,500,000 / 3) / 2]

dv = $6,357,143 / [$2,166,667 / 2]

dv = $6,357,143 / $1,083,334

dv = (5.87%)

According to The Busch Corollary Equation, the diminished value of Minute Maid’s naming-rights agreement with the Astros is 5.87 percent.  Based on Minute Maid’s annual payment, this equates to a value overpayment of approximately $373,046.

If Minute Maid’s executives had something like The Busch Corollary Equation during their negotiations with the Astros, they could have plugged in the offered annual fee of $6,357,143 and countered with a “more equitable value price” of $5,984,097.

Two points to consider: 1) At least the Astros’ lowered the annual sponsorship fee, and 2) Minute Maid could have received this “value back” by way of additional advertising time during broadcasts or any other added marketing opportunities with the team.

Even if you inserted this “more equitable value price” into the calculation, the result will always contain a percentage of diminished value, due to the clear-cut fact that any subsequent naming-rights holder will never have the same value the original owner had:

dv = s / [(p / n) / y]

dv = $5,984,097 / [($6,500,000 / 3) / 2]

dv = (5.52%)

Based on what the previous rights holder paid, how long its name was in use and the total number of names the building was known as, the Astros would have had to offer “the fair market price” (f) of $1,083,334 annually to offset the diminished value:

dv = s / [(p / n) / y]

dv = $1,083,334 / [($6,500,000 / 3) / 2]

dv = $1,083,334 / $1,083,334

dv = 0%    Γ    f = (p / n) / y

As a branding vehicle-only (no other value-added components included), this calculation suggests Minute Maid should only pay the fair market price of $1,083,334 annually when it signed its deal in 2002.

Based on this analysis, two results are clear: 1) Minute Maid receives more than $5.27 million in value-added units to justify its investment, and 2) the Astros made a financially terrible mistake in using “Astros Field” as an interim name.

Understanding that the Enron name tarnished anyone or anything associated with it, the team lost value in its naming rights by changing it to a generic name.  If anything, the Astros should have just removed all mentions of Enron and left the building without a name until a new naming-rights sponsor emerged.  The percentage of diminished value would have been substantially smaller if “Astros Field” never surfaced:

dv = s / [(p / n) / y]

dv = $6,357,143 / [($6,500,000 / 2) / 2]

dv = $6,357,143 / [$3,250,000 / 2]

dv = $6,357,143 / $1,625,00

dv = (3.91%)

In effect, adding “Astros Field” as an official ballpark name lowered the annual, naming-rights’ fair market price from $1,625,000 to $1,083,334, for a loss of $541,666 annually.

Since Enron only held its deal for two years, Minute Maid’s diminished value for the ballpark is not as high as if Enron fulfilled its original, 20-year contract.  If that was the case, then the equation would change dramatically:

dv = s / [(p / n) / y]

dv = $6,357,143 / [($6,500,000 / 3) / 20]

dv = $6,357,143 / [$2,166,667 / 20]

dv = $6,357,143 / $108,333

dv = (58.68%)

Since the name “Enron Field” would have been part of the local and national vernacular for 20 years, a new name would not replace it overnight, or even in a few years.  Too many residents would have continued to call the ballpark by its original name, due to 20 years of repetition and habit.  This situation mirrors what Gussie Busch faced with Sportsman’s Park.  Minute Maid would be overpaying more than $3.73 million annually, compared to The Busch Corollary’s suggested “more equitable value price” of $2,626,688 per year.

If Enron held the name until 2020, and the Astros then tried to re-sell the naming rights, any corporate partner looking to simply brand the Astros’ 20-year-old ballpark should not spend more than $108,333 annually, the fair market price for the building’s naming rights.

THE BUSCH COROLLARY – HYPOTHETICAL ANALYSIS

This equation holds water even when using hypothetical situations, such as a possible name change for the Atlanta Braves’ Turner Field due to the team’s recent sale to Liberty Media.

If Liberty Media were to sell the naming rights to the ballpark (which company executives said it will not do), what would be the percentage of diminished value of the new agreement?

Using The Busch Corollary Equation, one can find the answer based the what Liberty Media determines the price would have been if naming rights were sold at the ballpark’s inception in 1997 (pv), the price offered for the new deal (po) and the total number of years the building has been operational.  Since Turner Field has been the only name the ballpark has known, there is no need to insert it into the equation.

For simple mathematical purposes, this hypothetical will use $5 million as the annual fee Liberty is seeking:

pv &  po = Price valued and offered is $5,000,000 annually
n = The ballpark has had only one (1) name: Turner Field
y = Ten (10) years have passed since the ballpark opened in 1997

dv = po / [(pv / n) / y]

dv = $5,000,000 / [($5,000,000 / 1) / 10]

dv = $5,000,000 / [$5,000,000 / 10]

dv = $5,000,000 / $500,000

dv = (10%)

Because Turner Field is 10 years old, the diminished value of any new naming-rights deal would be 10 percent.

WHAT THIS ALL MEANS

The Busch Corollary Equation could be applied to any, non-original naming-rights agreement in any sport.

If a company was considering a naming-rights deal to replace a former agreement, it would have to input a number of different annual fees to closely match The Busch Corollary’s diminished value price, and consider what value-added components the agreement should include to offset this perceived loss of value.

Make no mistake, companies will continue to pay for these high-profile naming-rights sponsorships as a means to advertise itself and associate with the local sports team.  Teams will continue to sell naming-rights packages (even non-venue deals, like parking sections, club levels, concourses, etc.) as a means to generate more revenue.

In November 2006, Citigroup, Inc. and the New York Mets announced its 20-year, $400 million naming-rights deal for the Mets’ new ballpark, Citi Field.  The partnership is far more than a traditional, naming-rights agreement.  For Citigroup, the deal included brand and business unit presence throughout the new ballpark, rights to the Mets and Citi Field marks, the purchase of media on SportsNet New York (SNY) and the launch of community outreach initiatives.

With ballparks currently under construction in Minneapolis and Washington (DC), the Twins and Nationals, respectively, should expect its naming-rights sponsorship to fetch anywhere between $5 million and $20 million annually, based on recent naming-rights deals such as Citi’s, Brooklyn’s Barclays Center (NBA New Jersey/Brooklyn Nets; 20 years, $400 million), Indianapolis’s Lucas Oil Stadium (NFL Indianapolis Colts; 20 years, $121.5 million) and Newark’s Prudential Center (for the NHL New Jersey Devils; 20 years, $105.3 million).

WHAT HAPPENS WHEN EXISTING DEALS EXPIRE?

It will be very interesting to see what happens when existing, long-term deals expire in the next 10-20 years.  For instance, what company would pay millions of dollars to brand the former Citizens Bank Park in 2029?

If the Phillies attempted to sell that inventory again at the same annual price (regardless of increases in inflation), the diminished value would be extraordinary because Phillies’ fans and Philadelphia residents alike would have been calling the ballpark “Citizens Bank Park” for 25 years.  The old axiom suggests one “cannot teach an old dog new tricks,” and the numbers back that statement as it relates to renaming a sports venue:

dv = s / [(p / n) / y]

dv = $3,800,000 / [($3,800,000 / 1) / 25]

dv = $3,800,000 / [$3,800,000 / 25]

dv = $3,800,000 / $152,000

dv = (25%)

Corporations should be VERY wary about the value they will receive in return of their hefty financial investment.  Old venues, ones with two or more previous naming-rights holders and deals with annual payments near to what previous companies paid should be avoided at all costs.

Consider the perceived complete loss of naming-rights value of Oakland’s McAfee Coliseum, even though the name has been officially owned by only two entities: Alameda County and Network Associates/McAfee, Inc.

Drawbacks can be found in every facet of the calculation: the venue’s antiquated age by today’s standards (opened in 1966) and the fact that the venue has had four (4), different names in its 41-year history – Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum, UMAX Coliseum, Network Associates Coliseum and McAfee Coliseum – only three of which under its current name.

The county originally sold the first corporate title sponsorship to UMAX in 1997, only to have a court order wipe out the deal.  After signing on as the naming-rights sponsor in 1998, Network Associates renamed itself McAfee in 2004, and changed the multi-purpose stadium’s name along with it.

The loss in value due to these moves is remarkable, especially when you consider that the annual price point has not changed from Network Associates’ original deal:

dv = s / [(p / n) / y]

dv = $1,180,000 / [($1,180,000 / 4) / 38]

dv = $1,180,000 / [$295,000 / 38]

dv = $1,180,000 / $7,763

dv = (152%)

According to this model, the latest naming-rights deal to Oakland’s Coliseum provided nearly no brand value for McAfee.  Because of its voluntary name change, McAfee lowered the naming-rights fair market value to just $7,763 per year.  The fact that the Coliseum is 41 years old hurt more than McAfee’s switch from Network Associates.

This is an extreme example, and considering the typical bells-and-whistles teams add to a top-tier sponsorship level such as naming-rights agreements, corporate partners due receive a fair amount of value with their high-profile deals.

CONCLUSION

The Busch Corollary Equation should not be the lone factor in determining whether or not a company signs on as a naming-rights sponsor.

What The Busch Corollary strongly suggests is for potential rights holders (a ballpark’s naming rights, a NASCAR race’s title sponsorship, an MLS team’s jersey sponsor, etc.) to thoroughly conduct a qualitative and quantitative analysis of the big-ticket item they are about to purchase, and what value and value-added components they will receive and utilize from such an agreement.

Source: The Business of Sports Network research, SportsBusiness Journal’s 2007 Sports Business Resource Guide and Fact Book


Kurt Hunzeker is a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He is the former editor of the Team Marketing Report, and the founder Sparts Marketing (www.spartsmarketing.com), a sports-centric design and consulting firm where sports, art and marketing fuse together to create award-winning campaigns, unique brand identities and innovative sponsorship platforms.

He, as well as all other authors on The Biz of Baseball can be contacted through the Author Profiles page.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?