incorrect information on credit report canada which is the best free credit report service challenge credit report quick credit reports online us government free credit report website how to remove an error on your credit report freed credit report free 3 credit bureau report identity theft how to obtain a truly free credit report credit reports equifax experian transunion collections credit report canada fair credit reporting act form accuracy fcra what;s the best way to dispute a credit report credit card balance update credit report credit one report long does take debt clear your credit report order my credit report post check my credit report free best site to get full credit report companies give free credit reports how to read reading a credit report score reports credit information equifax credit report free copy free credit report and score from all 2 bureaus does checking your report hurt your score own credit quizzles annualcreditreport free credit report capital one do not report credit limits credit reports uk all credit reporting done federal government best way monitor my credit report does kohls credit card report credit bureaus get free credit report without free trial equifax credit report free annual equifax credit report update form free full credit report no credit card equifax free credit report nj how to find credit score from credit report obtaining credit report renters bank of america credit report service free credit report toronto ontario check credit score and report for free online money loans where can i borrow money without a credit check free credit reports government program how to write a credit report dispute letter credit report 3 bureaus one time how to dispute credit report collections how often do credit cards reported to credit bureaus free credit report commercial predictions dispute apartment credit report canada credit report online which credit report is most important insurance companies dont use credit report how to get negative items removed from credit report credit report background check landlords long does hard credit check stay your credit report top rated best cash back credit cards for 2014 report someone credit bureau canada 3 free bureau report credit score credit report agencies freeze consumer credit report 2012 debt collection credit report free credit report free credit check is a credit is fico score of 700 good fix judgements credit reports how to have something removed from your credit report my annual free credit report score consumer protection laws credit reporting remove collection account from credit report get totally free report credit card need a credit report without card notice eviction credit report sample letter to remove collections from credit report collection agency credit reports fair credit report form how to obtain a free credit report after being denied credit employment what happened to the old free credit report band unfair credit reporting attorney federal fair credit reporting act dispute items on credit report online best place get your credit report freeware ordering your credit reports free government free credit report check download credit report songs what is a fair credit reporting act report rent to credit bureau credit card application for bad credit scores free 3 1 credit score report wells fargo business credit canada ulc credit repair best airline airline miles credit cards reviews where can i get a free credit report no strings attached credit union australia 2009 annual report i need to get my credit report free yearly credit report from equifax secured credit card report to credit bureau how do i check my child;s credit report ordering a transunion credit report address to dispute credit report equifax does ordering credit reports hurt credit can bankruptcy be removed from your credit report craigslist apartment scams credit report annual credit report credit karma order my credit report through mail american express credit report log us credit report jobs in usa for foreigners colorado credit report law consumer credit reports for businesses starting credit reporting business get free credit report maine does debt consolidation show up on your credit report protect my id credit report card companies report all 3 bureaus credit history experian credit report 2 pounds sears credit protection plan reporting medical debt to credit bureau mall credit reports free federal trade commission credit reporting agencies can get free capital report if denied credit best place to get credit reports how do you get a totally free report annual credit what is considered a good credit report secured credit card reports all three bureaus getting your free credit reports current closed accounts on credit report what are derogatory items on credit report best free credit report and score how to remove bad credit from my credit report 100 free credit report without credit card tulsa credit repair lawyers in chicago how can i request a copy of my credit report for free how do i get a free debt report if i have been denied credit best credit report bureau checking credit report potential tenant how do i remove hard inquiries on my credit report credit report repair forums free credit report dot com reviews free equifax credit report by phone what credit reporting agency does chase use can payday loans be put on your credit report consumer three free credit reports free annually get free fico credit report how do you clear your credit report bank of america remove from credit report get paid judgement off credit report 11 credit bureau report scores free credit reports online job application wants credit report apply for a credit card uk see my credit report score removing inquiries off your credit report free credit report commercial lyrics dream girl free annual credit report service remove credit report collections credit report freeze california how to find out my credit report remove eviction judgement credit report credit report information inaccurate obtain credit report rental property free report usa online annual credit government web site free credit report how do i check my credit report without a credit card free credit report scores all 3 get credit report deceased parent how long does paid collection stay on credit report canadian credit reports international business why is there a security freeze on my credit report free credit report contact phone number request free copy transunion credit report dnb view your personal credit reports equifax credit report one time free credit report credit report numbers where can i get annual free credit report how doo i freeze my credit report prevent get free report irs credit card fair credit reporting act background check release form free credit report all three credit reporting agencies remove negative accounts your credit report report stolen credit card bank of america resolve credit report issues information needed obtain credit report free credit report how to cancel membership dispute bankruptcy my credit report long chapter 13 bankruptcy credit report long does chapter 13 stay credit report credit report employment illinois credit report from government site best place to get home equity loan with bad credit report id theft credit reporting agency ii credit bureau report monitoring free annual 3 credit bureau reports is your credit score on your credit report how do i get a loan with bad credit and no job safe way to get free credit report free credit report best use will a collection agency remove from credit report free transunion credit report and score report to congress on the fair credit reporting act dispute process disputing charges my credit report how do i request free credit reports how to contact credit reporting agencies by phone check your credit report freeware without credit card explanation of credit report inquiries letter free credit report golf song lyrics report violation credit card act 2009 free credit reports and credit scores calculate credit score credit report advance america cash advance locations fl gov credit reporting services free credit reports equifax experian transunion all report and score free credit how do i obtain a credit report on someone else annual report credit union uk order transunion credit report by mail sample credit reports spanish free report experian equifax annual credit order credit report without monitoring order a credit report online report on credit hamilton 100 free credit report can collections remove from credit report 10 year credit report credit karma credit climate report best free credit report website chase credit card report theft 3in1 credit score reports wisconsin free annual credit report remove consumer statement credit report quizzle no more free credit reports top 4 credit reporting agencies checking long does key derogatory stay your credit report how fast can i rebuild my credit score what does it mean when it says charge off on your credit report highest what do credit scores range from federal government website free report credit scores why would there be a security freeze on my credit report ce credit report charge free 3 bureau credit report no credit card how to remove a judgement on your credit report how how do i know if i freeze my credit report equifax how do i get an instant credit report improve fha low credit loans free credit report uk equifax identity how to report a credit account to a credit bureau reliable credit reports legal what are the best credit repair companies actual free credit report once year can get free credit report credit bureau report stolen credit card to police equifax free credit report for dispute federal free credit report once year reputable credit report companies does requesting your credit report hurt your credit score usa credit repair nyc authorized user on credit report remove free credit reports transunion how do you run a credit report on a business my free annual report online credit card free credit report no credit card canada which is the best credit report company review credit report free get private mortgage credit report free transunion credit report annual credit score rating gas mileage chart canada transunion free report credit denied free credit report gauteng california credit reporting act how does cash advance what's it like to work at wells fargo 3 credit reports monthly govt sponsored free credit report today credit reporting laws oregon official government website for credit report free credit report wisconsin residents how long before credit report updates negative information credit report long transunion canada credit report mail does the american express prepaid card report to credit bureaus is free credit report legit free credit report annual credit report legal right free credit report consumer reports credit scores free example credit report canada fair credit reporting act debt collector harassment quizzle free credit report often credit report government canada where to get three free credit reports where can i go to get my free credit report do life insurance companies run credit reports consumer credit report.com credit suisse ag annual report 2008 order credit report equifax phone my credit history check for free judgement credit report south africa free credit report uk moneysavingexpert cash official credit report free website free credit report commercial invoice the club free 3 in 1 credit reports best credit report dispute reasons 7 year old debt credit report equifax canada free credit report get a copy of my credit report for free three credit bureaus reports with scores sarma credit reporting agencies dun and bradstreet commercial credit report anual credit report free free credit reports without credit card info free credit report california credit agricole languedoc english speaking how to report a debt to the credit bureau credit report codes ecoa how do i contest items on my credit report getting free credit report once year credit card late payment report credit bureau fair credit reporting act agency consumer obtaining credit reports for renters does colorado allow you to freeze your credit report veda credit reporting agency business free credit report equifax guaranteed credit repair freeware does checking credit report lower score how long does a dismissed chapter 13 bankruptcy stay on your credit report obtain your credit report free equifax obtain credit reports prospective tenants my free credit report best credit report agency credit monitoring comparison consumer reports new york and fair credit reporting act and employment 3 in 1 credit report free request a credit report free better business bureau top highly rated credit repair companies obtaining credit reports dispute items on my experian credit report who can pull my credit report quick check credit reports inc get credit score all 3 reporting agencies transunion free credit report all 3 bureaus no credit card shared national credit reporting obtaining a free credit score report one time fee credit report score best way to get all 3 credit reports consolidated credit report 1-800 number for free credit report how do you get a credit report on someone request my credit report free how to report to credit bureaus on tenants stays credit report 10 years credit report for employment oregon best reasons to dispute credit report credit cards reporting yours free credit report no fees uk access credit report online best place get credit report score free report government online credit scores credit report lock inc adding rental history to credit report credit report address change my free credit after being denied credit report online does free credit report affect your credit score view my experian credit report again credit annual report gov three credit reporting bureaus contact info bad debt not on credit report 3 in 1 credit report with fico company credit rating reports best three in one credit report equifax how to get your credit report in australia free credit report score without credit card experian small business credit reports credit report consumerist report private mortgage payments credit bureaus inaccurate credit report statistics first credit report 16 does checking your own credit report affect your credit score free online credit check for tenant application my credit report and score american express equifax free credit report reviews free yearly credit report future freeze your credit report texas remove collections my credit report view my credit report again investigative consumer report credit report how do you remove items from your credit report free credit report.com no credit card needed personal reports canada credit scores credit credit repair free consultation how to dispute collection agency on credit report what is not included in your credit report race contact information for all reporting bad credit agencies federal fair credit reporting act form do payday loans how does a short sale affect your credit report credit repair real estate lawyer philadelphia is it illegal to run a credit report on someone else how long does an eviction stay on your credit report how do i order my credit report by mail free equifax credit report capital one get free report irs credit rating how could i how to check my credit score request free credit report credit bureau correct credit report equifax how to dispute an error on my credit report long can collections stay credit report credit report consumer protection how can i run my own credit report where to go to get free annual credit report reeves lexington law credit repair reviews credit reporting service companies arizona usaa credit report free yearly credit report from equifax get my free credit report without credit card free annual credit report from transunion gold key total credit repair savannah ga reviews see credit report india credit report federal gov ftc how do i fix my credit report fast how to get credit score up fast no credit card needed free credit report equifax consumer credit report canada order a credit report from equifax free credit report itin number does charge off account mean your credit report getting find your credit score online credit report credit card obtain your credit report canada how do i get a free credit card report how to request my free annual credit report how to obtain your credit report canada get free credit reports all three us government free credit report score government sponsored annual credit report free annual credit scores reports credit to your account mean sample fair credit reporting act disclosure statement what does a judgement on my credit report mean what is hawk alert on credit report free report commercial club credit scores three one credit report canada how to dispute a debt on your credit report canadian credit reporting requirements credit report for landlords forms denied fico entitled free credit report report affect score checking your own credit transunion dispute credit report government credit report free once a year bad free credit home repair tips and tricks free credit report now equifax credit report dispute mailing address section 613 of the fair credit reporting act best way to get credit report online us government free credit score report how often do credit cards reported to credit agencies may view your credit report how to run credit report federal bureau of credit free credit reports can medical debt go on your credit report get my credit report without credit card what do you need phone numbers for cash loans best credit reports websites how to write a request for free annual credit report fair credit credit reporting act new band free credit report commercials free credit report from equifax canada best credit report website canada individual credit report cibil pay walmart credit card online business credit bureaus contact information fa credco on credit report should i pay off old collections on my credit report how do i get a free credit report by mail is there a totally free credit report with no fees can;t get my credit report online when does equifax update credit report which credit report what is best to use to clean windows dedicated credit repair tiffany de hazelaarboom suze orman free credit report what is the real free credit report site do credit card companies report late payment credit bureaus government website free credit reports allowed 1 free credit report year free credit reports for renters credit report for another person equifax free credit report canada post do payday loans show on credit report run company credit report free copy of your credit report experian does requesting credit report hurt credit chase report lost credit card phone number how do you dispute a collection on your credit report most reliable way get credit report federal trade commission building better credit report sample credit reports pdf yearly free credit experian report request credit repair marketing tools one time credit report fee obtaining a credit report in canada irs credit report can i get a credit report on someone credit report 100 free how to clean your credit report yourself free business equifax free credit report online experian importance monitoring credit report credit reporting law ontario what happened to the old free credit report guys
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews Interview - Mark Shapiro - Exec. VP & GM - Cleveland Indians

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1122 guests online

Atom RSS

Interview - Mark Shapiro - Exec. VP & GM - Cleveland Indians PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 16
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Sunday, 01 July 2007 17:00
Mark Shapiro

Build it from within… make every cent count… balance risk.

That might be the best way to describe how Mark Shapiro, the executive vice-president and general manager of the Cleveland Indians, conducts business. Since coming on-board with the Indians in 2001, he immediately set about restructuring the Indians model for success. High salary veteran players were dropped to give payroll flexibility, and the focus was shifted to developing young talent.

Shapiro has seen the game, as worked from outside the lines, since he was at a very young age. His father Ron, was a high profile lawyer in the Baltimore area that shifted to becoming an agent. In an interview on Baseball America, the elder Shapiro said, “For as much as he loved sports, he was disadvantaged in that genetically he was deprived because his father was probably the worst athlete in the world. But exposure-wise, he got to have a unique view of players and their lives outside baseball. I think that gave him a better understanding of how things work right from the beginning."

The rebuilding of the Indians paid off in 2005 when Mark was honored with the Sporting News Sports Executive of the Year by winning 93 games that year, while having a payroll that ranked in the bottom five of the 30 teams.

The following interview focuses on how Shapiro balances the resources that the Indians have available to continue to contend. Unsurprisingly, he mentions Billy Beane (read the Biz of Baseball interview with Beane), and Terry Ryan (read the Biz of Baseball interview with Ryan) who have been able to evaluate undervalued talent with budgets many times lower than clubs such as the Yankees and the Red Sox.

This year sees the Indians in the hunt again. As of this publication they hold a two-game lead over the Tigers for first place in the AL Central, with C.C. Sabathia leading the league in Wins with 12, Victor Martinez seventh in RBIs, and Joe Borowski tied for third in the league with 24 Saves.

Other topics in this interview include his views on the Draft system, whether the Indians will focus on re-signing C.C. Sabathia, how this year’s first draft pick Beau Mills might be developed, how the Indians approach risk as it pertains to pitchers, competing for free agents with a player payroll that is ranked at 23rd by Opening Day payroll ($61,673,267), and much, much more. 

Maury Brown for The Biz of Baseball: We’re very near the All-Star break, and with that, the Indians and Tigers are battling it out for the lead in the AL Central. Are you satisfied with where you are at, or are you looking to make a move before the trade deadline?

Mark Shapiro quote on looking for talentMark Shapiro: Well, you know it’s funny; I think in the moment, you’re not satisfied. You feel like you could have been better within the context of the season you played. If you would have flashed back to Spring Training and told me that we would have the third or fourth best record in the big leagues, we’d be fourteen games above .500, I would have signed up for it.

The second answer to the question that you asked is yes, it is our obligations to constantly, regardless of our spot in the standings, be attempting to improve the team. It is a challenging market to do that. The backdrop of our protectiveness of our young players always has to be there because that’s really our greatest ability to compete and win here, but with that being said, we are active, very active, and diligent in the area of trying to secure more talent.

BizBall: We just recently went through the First-Year Draft, and with that changes that were implemented with the new CBA were put in place on how the drafting system functions. What is your take on the new changes? Do you think it works well, or will there continue to be adjustments made?

Shapiro: Time will tell. I think it clearly creates slightly more leverage for the team, but it still doesn’t achieve the end result. Our draft system is extremely flawed. It does not result in the desired outcome, which is the best talent taken, strictly based on ability where it’s spotted on the board. Finances still enter into the equation at a very significant level. It is often the teams that lose the most that aren’t able — if they are a smaller market team to catch the best player that is on the board at that time. Until that’s the case, I don’t think the draft functions as it’s supposed to with the distribution of talent.

BizBall: With the Draft, the Indians selected 1B, Beau Mills from Lewis & Clark State College with the 13th pick. What kind of player do you see him as, and what roll might he be developed into for the Majors? Do you look for a particular role for him?

Shapiro: I think what we look to do in the first round of the draft is secure some level of talent that we basically have an inability to compete for on a free agent market. So, whether that’s a top of the rotation player, whether that’s a top of a rotation starter, whether that’s a middle of the order run producer, or a middle of the diamond talent, that’s what we’re looking to do. And in Beau we feel like we secured a potential middle of the order run producer and that’s how it will development. I think we’ll find the best fit for him defensively. Initially we feel that’s probably first base, but time will tell defensively. Clearly what we’re looking to get, what we feel most confident of, is that we have the potential to sign a run producing, middle of the order bat.

C.C. SabathiaBizBall: C.C. Sabathia is making a good case for a possible AL Cy Young award. He’s tied for first in Wins with Josh Beckett, Innings Pitched, has two complete games, we could go on… When you have a player of high caliber, which Sabathia clearly is, do you have to consider setting your budget out for the year in case you decide to wrap him up? How difficult is it for a market like Cleveland to retain high quality players as they hit free agency?

Shapiro: It’s a significant challenge for us in the market that we operate within because our threshold for risk has to be so much more finite than a larger market team. We have to be so much more careful and cognizant of what an injury on a large contract or a drop in performance will do to our ability to sustain a championship caliber team. So, I think it’s never a challenge to sign, and secure, and retain talent. The question is, if you do that, are you then creating too big of a challenge in creating a championship team around that player.

In isolation, we can look at retaining any player, the challenge is when you break outside of the isolation, the perspective, can we build a championship team around that player? Are we maintaining the balance to do that?

When I look at C.C. – what I chose to focus on instead – are his progression to a true number one starter. The things he’s accomplished, his maturation from an 18 year-old kid when we first drafted him into a man. He is a guy that is a tremendous father and husband and leader in our club house. His maturation as a pitcher as well, as a thrower, a power guy, to a true pitcher to me it is remarkable. I have immense respect for C.C. and all that he has accomplished. I enjoy watching him pitch now even more knowing the back drop of where he’s coming from.

BizBall: You bring up risk… One of the key acquisitions for the Indians this past off-season was Joe Borowski, who as of this interview is tied for third in the league with 22 saves. The Phillies backed out of a deal for him in the off-season after a physical, citing his shoulder, which was injured during the ’04 season. With small to mid-markets having to make every free agent penny count, are the risks rising when it comes to top or even mid-level pitching talent on the open market?

Shapiro: I think “risks” and “pitching” on the free agent market are just inseparable. You’re just dealing with levels Mark Shapiro quote on risksof risk.

I guess I would say this: like Kevin Millwood a few years ago – on a one year time frame – we are much more risk tolerant than we are in a longer time frame. There’s no one year deal that obviously we can’t overcome in time.

So you do two things: You look at the alternative. You look at what’s available out there.

We were going to wade into the waters of risk, but at what level while having to satisfy the back end bullpen issues that we had. There was no non-risk alternative. There was just levels of risk and off setting risks with multiple alternatives and we were well aware of what we were walking into in last year’s free agent market.

BizBall: This past off-season saw a spike in the market for free agents. Whether that was one GM setting the market, or the tone coming out of reaching a new CBA, what have you. What ever it was, the market spiked. You walk into the off-season and have to adjust as the market gets set. If you would, walk us through how you and the Indians go about strategizing and adjusting when the market gets set?

Shapiro: I think you want to internally frame values for players as you head into free agency. Some of that value is built upon external demand and some of that is built on your own payroll structure. You know what portion of that payroll you can allocate to different positions and players — both short term and long term team building... and growth. And then I think there are obviously sometimes exceptional contributions that you can look at as well; but all of that functions within an imperfect environment because one team’s desire for a player can skew the value and take it out of our realm. But we have to be disciplined when we enter that market.

Mark Shapiro quote on valuationYou know, the Red Sox could value a player identically to us and basically, just with their tolerance for risk and their level of payroll, they could both pay him more and offer him more years within an exact same evaluation.

All that accentuates is that we need to try to stay out of the free agent market whenever possible … and when we do enter into the free agent market, there is hopefully a realistic desire to supplement rather than build the core talent – because I just don’t see us ever being able to compete in the free agent market for core talent … it’s just the very rare, exceptional occasion when that is going to happen.

BizBall: That leads into my next question… Given the costs associated with competing for top-tier free agents and the costs and risks associated to them, is it fair to say that more and more clubs will be working to develop their own young talent, and with that, is there a growing emphasis in areas such as academies in Latin America?

Shapiro: I think what has become increasingly obvious in the last couple years is that regardless of your market, young talent is important. It’s always been obvious to the Oaklands, Minnesotas, Clevelands; it’s our only chance. Not that it’s just important, but it’s our only chance is to sign and develop our own talent and then bring them up internally – at least core talent. Then look for value propositions in free agency. That’s clear. Billy [Beane] knows that. Terry [Ryan] knows that. I know that. Without that internal supply of talent, we cannot compete at the playoff caliber level. I think what’s become increasingly apparent and where the change is, is that regardless of your market, no matter how big your market is, it’s still important to have your own internal young talent and if you have the young talent and you have financial resources, you have a chance to create a dominant team, like the Red Sox are doing now and like the Angels were able to do.

Mark Shapiro quote on internal supply of talentI think that’s where some of the teams that didn’t place as big of an emphasis or maybe lost sight of that importance over time, are realizing that we need to get back into that talent. We need to be more cognizant of that importance, be more careful when we consider trading it and place more emphasis on developing it.

As far as the question regarding Latin American... You’re going to find over time that there’s a lot less efficiency there right now because of the money being thrown out down there and the lack of information we have on the players and the success rate being so small. That is becoming probably more of an inefficient market at this point.

BizBall: Interesting. There has been discussion that given the costs associated with some of the signing bonuses in the drafting process Stateside, you could more economically develop in, say, Latin America. The theory being that regardless of your ability to find good talent -- due to lack of information; what have you -- you may come up with a diamond in the rough by pure volume.

Shapiro: I think that was true years ago and everybody reacted to that by throwing money down there and it has become more competitive by money on top of that money and the signing bonuses escalated as well of the cost of doing business down there escalated, then it became less and less efficient. We’re getting to the point now where I’m not sure if it is an efficiency any more. You might have more efficiency in the draft than you do in Latin America at this point.

BizBall: Many were surprised this off-season when the Giants offered pitcher Barry Zito a seven-year deal. Given the difficulty in projecting pitcher performance and durability the further out in time you go, do you have any hard and fast rules when it comes to matters such as contract length, especially when it comes to pitchers?

Shapiro quote on hard and fast rulesShapiro: I don’t believe in hard and fast rules in this game – it is a game of grays, there are no black and whites. That being said, I’m already being redundant when I state the risk of pitching is evident and clear and with every single individual case that we consider, we will do a very careful risk analysis and risk assessment. I can tell you just based upon the experience of where we end up with pitching in general, is that our tolerance for risk is not going to be high enough to allow for very many long-term contracts in that market, especially of high magnitude

BizBall: Lastly, the Indians recently hired one of my Baseball Prospectus colleagues, Keith Woolner, and I know that Vince Gennaro has worked with the Indians in the past. How do you approach the use objective analysis along with the advice from your scouting department? Some say that it is a black and white area, and it clearly isn’t...

Shapiro: That’s the biggest mistake. I risk the temptation to brand us as one type of organization and just call it a Mark Shapiro quote on using the best informationbalanced organization.

My philosophy has always been: Why limit yourself to one type of data? Why not seek to get the best information in every area? What we start to do is seek out the best objective analysis available and then frame it properly and utilize it. To seek out the best subjective analysis or scouting information available then frame that and utilize that in decisions. Medical; personality; and psychological; financial – all those variables that exist within a decision making framework. Then with the creative, or when the artistic side of that comes in, that is how you weigh those variables in the decision making process.

  • Interview conducted by Maury Brown on 6/29/07
  • Transcribed by William Jordan and Michael Elsen
  • Edited by Maury Brown

Maury Brown would like to extend special thanks to William Jordan and Michael Elsen for  their exceptionally diligent work in the transcription process.

To read other interviews with the likes of Billy Beane, Terry Ryan, Marvin Miller, Bob Costas, Charlie Steiner, Bowie Kuhn, Kevin Towers, and many more, select the Interviews link from any page on The Biz of Baseball. 

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?