westpac credit card travel insurance australia best student credit cards visa united mileage plus credit card review are department store credit cards good for your credit pre approved credit card offers bank of america toys r us credit card gecrb hdfc bank credit card online banking login best cashback credit cards 2012 canada bad credit loans no fees instant decision cibc visa credit cards canada barclays credit card application status check credit cards for very poor credit history how to get student loans with bad credit and no cosigner i need a credit card now and i have bad credit fast online payday loans o2 prepaid credit card ireland best credit cards to reestablish credit after bankruptcy pre approved credit card scams instant approval payday loans for bad credit best 5 cash back credit cards credit card debt relief credit score range uk suntrust visa business credit card best credit card online protection bank of america credit card for business hsbc credit card online protection prepaid credit cards uk free what the best secured credit card to rebuild credit mastercard amazon 15 device to accept credit cards on iphone visa credit card travel insurance coverage credit cards bad credit should i get a loan to pay off credit card debt fast cash loans online no faxing best secured credit cards to build credit 2011 accept credit cards free terminal cash advance loans online no credit check apply for a walmart credit card online cheapest way to accept credit cards 2012 santander 0 credit card balance transfers what;s the easiest credit card to get approved for with no credit cash advance instant approval online free credit card reader app android excel credit card apr formula samsung offers for icici credit cards lowest credit card rate australia best student visa card canada how do i pay hdfc credit card bill online citibank credit limit increase credit cards instant approval good credit business credit cards best rewards programs business credit card offers mastercard credit card company abuse complaints compare credit card offers in india icici instant credit card eligibility how to confirm paypal account with credit card unsecured credit cards to rebuild my credit list of top credit cards in india visa credit card low interest rates apply for credit card visa free credit reports without credit card uk how to prevent someone from using a credit card to open your door average credit card rate 2012 sears credit card application phone genuine bad credit loans uk how can i increase my chase freedom credit limit best credit card balance transfer options vanquis credit card uk contact number capital one apply for credit card online can you get a payday loan online good and bad aspects of credit cards instant virtual credit card paypal top canadian credit card rewards best department store rewards cards business credit card bank of america gold card national rail victoria secret credit card credit card amazon chase credit card application status valid credit card number with cvv us credit card use in canada hsbc credit card cash loan online loan no credit check nz lane bryant credit card reviews citi corporate credit card online mastercard credit card applications instant approval how to build a credit rating without a credit card va mortgage loans with bad credit best buy credit card payments number post office platinum card customer services icici credit card bill payment billdesk starbucks singapore credit card promotion contact help directory financial services credit card companies visa get credit card now get approved send money online using your credit card paul smith black credit card holder are us bank credit cards hard to get password to view icici credit card statement unsecured credit cards with bad credit history capital one credit cards login discover cashback bonus card credit score do visa debit cards work in canada random credit card number with cvv credit cards with cashback on gas super cash payday advance hours best free credit cards rewards credit card processing reviews for small business uk fast cash loans online with bad credit bad credit loans no guarantor no credit check credit card payment plan calculator canada credit cards easy approval cash loans to your door manchester visa debit cards in japan check my credit card score free credit card bank islam application bankruptcy credit cards vanilla visa card declined best visa cards canada manhattan standard chartered credit card helpline halifax bank student credit card rushcard prepaid visa debit cards website visa credit card number generator 2012 philippine credit cards online application belk credit card phone number capital one uk credit card login best interest free credit card offers compare credit card processing merchant accounts indusind bank credit cards apply online hdfc credit card statement apply online credit card citibank aqua credit card contactless pay shell oil credit card online loan through sbi credit card apply for easy approval credit cards veterans business loans with bad credit best platinum credit cards australia should i consolidate all my credit cards credit card calculator excel free credit card for students with no income apply for a credit card halifax standard chartered credit card offers on dining how to apply maybank supplementary credit card best cashback credit cards uk 0 percent credit card balance transfers credit card rates calculator credit card credit builder applied bank secured credit card reviews credit card interest on cash advances canada best credit card visa credit card cash withdrawal fees guaranteed cash loans for bad credit how to use hdfc credit cards reward points large credit card debt help best credit card comparison tool cash advance loans online no faxing icici bank credit card offer on samsung mobile most popular credit cards 2013 orchard bank secured credit card visa what is the easiest credit card to get approved for uk how often to apply for credit cards credit limit citi student cards real credit card numbers that work with security code and expiration date 2014 apple credit card reader case anz credit card transfer balance what does a nandos black card do credit card information form pdf citi premier credit card login applied bank secured visa credit card review unsecured visa credit cards for poor credit credit card exchange rates abroad installment loans online illinois online application for bdo credit cards paypal account verification virtual credit card how to redeem indianoil citibank credit card turbo points online application for credit card hdfc compare travel credit cards 2013 best flight rewards credit card australia barclays credit card online sign in credit limit on very account pay off credit card debt or save for down payment cheapest credit card for purchases standard chartered credit card status customer care personal loans online instant decision how do banks work out interest on credit cards barclays credit cards apply online best way to consolidate credit card debt with bad credit change iphone credit card detail who offers secured credit cards in australia bankruptcy credit cards no annual fee sign online payday loans uk hsbc credit card rewards air miles best credit card apps for ipad icici credit card online payment gateway vanilla mastercard gift cards cabela;s master credit card trust starwood preferred guest? credit card review 100 approval payday loans with bad credit valid credit card information 2013 credit card comparison tesco credit card balance transfer existing customers chase visa card united how do i calculate credit card interest with a formula bank travel reward credit cards check my bank of america credit card application hdfc credit card loan customer care citibank online credit cards bpi credit card online application for ofw cash back credit cards canada comparison purple payday loans british airways credit card avios points can you get cashback on your walmart credit card neiman marcus credit card services number chase reward cards access joint credit card company easy online payday loans no faxing i have no credit score and i want a credit card halifax credit card contact us intuit small business credit card processing pay standard chartered credit card bill online banking apply sbi credit card through online how to make payments on ebay with credit card visa cards start with what 4 numbers online apply for sbi credit cards in india navy federal credit card prime rate easy quick bad credit loans how to pay off credit card debt hacked credit card numbers 2013 no credit check payday loans lenders icici credit card bill payment through other bank debit card cancelling credit card affect credit score canada hsbc credit card processing charges interest free credit card offers 2013 personal loan with bad credit score airline reward credit cards review credit card logos intuit kotak mahindra bank credit cards offers best delta credit card promo capital one credit card cash advance limit delta skymiles credit card uk credit cards for small business with no credit history visa credit cards for bad credit canada visa credit cards for students western union gold card uae british airways credit card offer 2011 virgin credit cards online banking pay sears credit card credit card for no credit or bad credit american express student credit card uk best credit cards compare the market credit card with bad credit nz credit card comparison site au payday loans online direct lenders no credit checks black card amex concierge best rewards cards uk best cashback credit card offers what is a credit card issue number credit cards with no annual fee bad credit titanium plus visa prepaid credit card 0 interest transfer balance credit cards southwest credit card offers two free flights maurices credit card payment login canara bank credit card application form credit cards how do they work uk united cash loans best no annual fee credit card 2013 what is a fake credit card number with security code that work when does the halo reach credit limit reset address for household bank credit card payments credit one visa credit card for bad credit credit card protection services uk orange prepaid credit card paypal credit card fraud penalties in north carolina capital one secured credit card guaranteed approval pc credit card online frequent flyer miles credit cards no annual fee loans with bad credit low apr compare american express and discover credit cards best small business rewards credit card 2012 small cash loans uk secured vs unsecured credit cards credit score all credit cards list best credit cards to get after bankruptcy discharge best aadvantage credit card offer how to apply credit card in hdfc bank cash loans now australia hdfc bank credit card loans government travel credit card login best credit card rewards 0 interest why is it so hard to get a credit card today southwest credit card member benefits best credit cards with rewards 2013 sbi credit card apply online wells fargo credit card cash advance fees online long term loans no credit check commonwealth bank credit card rental car insurance american express cash advance pin get a non secured credit card with bad credit best credit card app for phone credit card poor credit rating uk uob credit card rewards rbs 0 balance transfer credit card best secured credit card in india credit cards canada visa how to settle credit card debt with a collection agency entropay virtual us credit card quick and easy payday loan online sbi credit card reward points value best travel rewards credit cards best rate credit cards ireland how to sign up to itunes for free no creditcard needed fidelity visa cash back credit card how much does advance america pay peoples trust vanilla prepaid visa card canada instant platinum credit card icici bad credit card debt stories compare premium credit cards in india credit card credit agreement loophole us bank credit card rates business credit card comparison canada best prepaid credit card with no monthly fees how do i pay sbi credit card bill online walmart prepaid credit card phone number amazon credit card payment mailing address citibank virtual credit card mobile bank of america power rewards visa signature card settlement figure credit card debt visa virtual credit card number secured credit card comparison chart hdfc super premium credit cards credit card apps for smartphones best travel reward cards 2011 non payday loans with bad credit top credit card processing for small businesses vanilla visa card not working credit card approval with no credit history care credit application and credit card account agreement top rated online credit card processing companies best credit card deals frequent flyer points visa debit card online registration visa 0 interest credit cards best credit card for travel miles 2013 best small business credit card rewards program credit card credit score age to apply for best buy credit card how do i sign up for netflix without a credit card top 5 credit cards in india 2012 how to calculate credit card interest payments in excel credit card app iphone reviews black credit card natwest does walmart credit card help build credit how to get an online payday loan icici credit card reward points scheme 0 balance transfer credit cards post office amscot cash advance amounts credit card offers money back does kmart accept sears credit cards credit card after bankruptcy discharge uk best credit card deal singapore capital one credit card bonus offer platinum credit card icici offers natwest credit card online banking getting a loan with bad credit and no job how to get credit card in hdfc bank best air mile credit cards in canada how do i accept credit cards over the phone online visa card instant get credit cards with bad credit history visa platinum credit card offers india how to use credit card on ebay without paypal visa college student credit cards biggest credit card companies in the world need to apply for a credit card with bad credit best credit cards 2011 for good credit payday loan lenders only uk free debit visa cards credit suisse internship quick cash loans online uk bank of america credit card processing for small business how to get mastercard securecode square credit card app iphone amscot cash advance without a check best payday loans no brokers government travel credit card training processing credit cards online canada example black card nandos payday loans with bad credit history apply cibc credit card online best credit card to have what is the best credit card for airline miles 2011 cnn best credit cards bad credit best credit card transfer rates uk best unsecured credit cards for building credit best way to consolidate my credit cards sbi credit card reward points redeem catalog usaa american express secured credit card best credit card consolidation companies reviews capital one credit card payment online hdfc credit card balance transfer credit card merchant unsecured personal loans online does bank of america have prepaid credit cards compare visa credit cards uk offers sbi credit card reward points hsbc credit card interest free can you transfer from credit card to bank account best 0 apr credit cards uk prepaid credit cards no fees canada mbna credit cards canada review walmart mastercard credit card login chase credit card usa easiest credit card approval philippines cerulean discover credit card reviews credit card comparison chart india hsbc uk lost credit cards loans online with monthly payments who has the best travel rewards credit card sears city bank credit card login malaysia credit card comparison 2013 second mortgages for bad credit prepaid credit card uk money saving expert best way to refinance auto loan with bad credit fast easy online payday loans canada payday lenders no credit check pay as you go mastercard bad credit payday lenders uk credit limit calculator how to build credit fast without a credit card mastercard securecode secure trust bank how to get a bad credit mortgage is the southwest rapid rewards credit card worth it rbc visa cards comparison mbna credit card rewards canada amscot cash advance how it works installment loans online instant approval list of major credit cards companies how to calculate credit card apr calculator visa card exchange rates currency new credit card rules 2012 credit cards with airline miles for fair credit cibc lowest interest credit card 0 percent interest credit card canada compare visa credit card australia prepaid credit cards walmart paypal pay dillards credit card bill online anz credit card cash advance fee credit limit definition wikipedia visa credit card application status credit cards with no annual fee for no credit help paying credit card debt hsbc credit cards application philippines virgin credit card minimum payment instant virtual credit card approval iphone application for accepting credit cards credit cards poor credit can credit card companies garnish your wages in florida quickbooks online credit card processing rates can you pay sears credit card with a gift card ge capital city furniture credit card compare best credit card rewards best buy master credit card payment hsbc gold credit card interest rate store credit cards payday loans cash advance no credit check hbc credit card contact number debit card vs credit card merchant fees check target visa card balance credit cards deals usa credit card apply online in indian bank icici credit card helpline pune pay new york and company credit card online my capital credit card account ebay change payment from credit card to paypal walmart credit cards for bad credit payday loans online direct lender only credit card interest calculator india credit card balance transfer offers for life how to get credit card cash advance chase virgin 0 balance transfer credit card capital one secured credit card compare chase rewards cards united bank of india credit card premium credit cards india southwest credit card promotion 2 free flights travel credit cards no international fees credit card payments through ebay very bad credit credit cards bad credit bank accounts with overdraft best buy credit card canada application guaranteed instant approval unsecured credit card chase credit card online services virgin credit cards uk online banking installment loans online direct lenders business credit cards for new business canada first premier credit card login page settle unsecured credit card debt no annual fee credit cards best student credit cards uk pay my first premier bank credit card bill best credit card offers for new users secured visa credit cards canada when applying for a credit card do you use household income
Home All Articles Who Owns Sports?

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 707 guests online

Atom RSS

Who Owns Sports? PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 53
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by John Thorn   
Thursday, 31 August 2006 11:12
John Thorn is a contributing writer for The Biz of Baseball 

From "Play's the Thing," Woodstock Times, August 31, 2006:

Money talks, bullshit walks. That coarse and yet so fine phrase, born of poker, soon became the byword of the business arena, particularly when delivered by the man with the money to the schnook with the big idea. But what happens when money comes as part and parcel with bullshit, as is so often the case?

A couple of weeks ago Major League Baseball Advanced Media (MLBAM) and the Players Association (MLBPA) lost a court case to CDM Fantasy Sports, a Missouri corporation legally named CBC that markets, distributes and sells fantasy sports products, including fantasy baseball games accessible over the Internet. Ho hum, you might say; just another argument about money in which John Q. Public has no rooting interest.

Not so. This truly fascinating case, in which Mary Ann L. Medler, United States Magistrate Judge, ruled on August 8, was about more than “Who owns facts?” — specifically here, whether a fantasy baseball game could depict the names and statistics of active players without paying for the privilege. In background a Greek chorus might have intoned not only “Who owns sports?” but also “Who owns fame?”
Without doubt a transaction takes place between and among owner, club, and fan.

The club offers its credible intent to play hard and, often if not reliably, win.

The owner provides (with the aid of the general public, silent partner in all of sport) an arena for entertainment on site and via broadcast that augments spectators’ experience of the contest. He, in concert with other owners, also provides a league structure in which a championship may be contested and determined. Owner and players, in short, combine to make the game.

What does the fan contribute, besides his cash for a ticket, concessions, and parking when he goes to the game, or his inert fanny and eyeballs when advertisers bombard him at home? The fan may be said to own nothing yet give everything, for not only fortune but also fame are at one end of that two-way street in which the fan’s approbation and reward are at the other. The athlete may provide the accomplishment but the fan creates the fame; neither Organized Baseball nor the players seem fully cognizant of the vital role played by the proles.

The fan, the ordinary Joe, has no property or intellectual rights in the game of baseball. But as Judge Medler averred, he cannot be made to pay in one context for something that a purported vendor acknowledges is free to all in another. Are player statistics property, or are they public information? If I say 511, .406, or 73, do you know the players I am referencing (Cy Young, Ted Williams, Barry Bonds, respectively)? How about the uniform numbers 3, 7, 24, and 44 (most famously Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, and Henry Aaron)?

In the legal proceeding neither MLBAM nor the MLBPA contended that numbers associated with players were anything but common facts in the public domain, beyond the proprietary interests of anyone who might look for the protection of copyright, trademark, or patent. If a company wished to depict the line below in a fantasy game it was OK with them:

G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG
161 591 129 195 38 2 41 117 16 2 97 65 .330 .430 .609


If, however, an “unlicensed” (i.e., nonpaying) fantasy league like CBC combined that line with the name “Albert Pujols,” well then it was violating the player’s “right of publicity,” depriving him of the benefit of his good name and constricting his future earnings. Mind you, the MLBAM/MLBPA position was not opposed to such conjoined use by newspapers, television, or internet media, as these uses were clearly First Amendment protected instances of free speech and, besides, provided free publicity that tended to boost rather than crimp player and league revenues.

As the court summarized the opposing positions, “... the Players’ Association and Advanced Media clarified that they are not claiming that CBC cannot use players’ playing records or biographical data; that they are challenging CBC’s use of players’ names in conjunction with its fantasy baseball games; that they are claiming that the identities of players are represented by their names; that they are concerned with protecting the players’ names; and that they are claiming that CBC uses players’ names in its fantasy baseball games in violation of the players’ right of publicity.” In response to this view, “CBC stated that its position is that players’ names and playing records, as used in its fantasy baseball games, are preempted by copyright law; that CBC’s use of players’ names and playing records in its fantasy baseball games does not violate the players’ claimed right of publicity; and that even assuming, arguendo, that CBC’s use of players’ names and playing records violates the players’ right of publicity, the First Amendment controls.”

Unlike the right of privacy, which is a personal right, the right of publicity is generally regarded as a property right. Indeed, the right of publicity is a curious notion of startlingly recent birth. Conceptually it may be said to go back to King Kelly's 1887 contract with the Boston Red Stockings, to whom he had just been traded by Chicago White Stockings. The contract called for $2000 in salary, in line with the league-wide salary cap, but also provided $3000 for the use of his likeness for advertising and promotional purposes. In reality, this was just a ploy to evade the salary limitations and induce Kelly to abide by the trade. As J. Gordon Hylton, Professor of Law at Marquette University, wrote, “What Kelly authorized was technically neither a trademark nor a copyright matter, but a waiver of what we today call his ‘right of publicity.’ The early history of the right of publicity is extremely murky, but this particular agreement seems to imply ... that Kelly's club could not use his image for commercial purposes without his permission. It would be interesting to know if early baseball card manufactures paid players for the use of their images. Honus Wagner's ability to stop the printing of cigarette cards with his photos in the first decade of the 20th century also suggests that something like the right of publicity was recognized prior to 1910.”

However, the term was never used in a legal context until 1953. As Judge Medler wrote in her opinion, “A fairly recent concept, according to the Sixth Circuit in ETW Corporation v. Jireh Publishing, Inc., 332 F.3d 915, 929 (6th Cir. 2003), this right ‘was first recognized in Haelan Laboratories, Inc. v. Topps Chewing Gum. Inc., 202 F.2d 866 (2nd Cir. 1953), where the Second Circuit held that New York’s common law protected a baseball player’s right [Wes Westrum] in the publicity value of his photograph, and, in the process, coined the phrase ‘right of publicity’ as the name of this right.’ Subsequently, in Zacchini, 433 U.S. at 573, where a performer in a ‘human cannonball’ act sought to recover damages from a television broadcast of his entire performance, the Supreme Court recognized that the right of publicity protects the proprietary interest of an individual to ‘reap the reward of his endeavors.’”

The poor devil Zacchini won his suit because his act, his sole means of livelihood, was expropriated. “However,” Judge Medler wrote, “CBC’s use of Major League baseball players’ names and playing records in fantasy baseball games does not go to the heart of the players’ ability to earn a living as baseball players; the baseball players earn a living playing baseball and endorsing products; they do not earn a living by the publication of their playing records. See Zacchini, 433 U.S. at 576. Moreover, CBC’s use of Major League baseball players’ names and playing records [unlike the complete depiction of Zacchini’s human-cannonball shot] does not give CBC something free for which it would otherwise be required to pay; players’ records are readily available in the public domain.”

On the free-speech front, the judge continued, “CBC argues, in the event it has violated the players’ right of publicity, that speech is involved in its fantasy games; that this speech does not differ from raw statistics published in newspapers; that the speech involved in its fantasy games is expression which is protected under the First Amendment; and that the First Amendment trumps the right of publicity in the circumstances of this case. The Players’ Association and Advanced Media argue that CBC’s games do not involve speech or the expression of ideas; that what is at issue in this matter is not speech; and that, therefore, the First Amendment does not apply.”

Wrong. Again from the ruling: “Speech which does not use ‘a traditional medium of expression’ does not receive less protection than more traditional means of speech.... As such, the First Amendment has been applied to flag burning, nude dancing, and wearing a jacket with obscenities. Id. (citations omitted). Moreover, the fact that expression appears in a novel medium does not preclude its being subject to First Amendment protection.”

An earlier landmark case in this area of nontraditional free speech involved the World Wrestling Federation (in Titan Sports v. Comics World, 87-0178). In 1989 Judge Peter K. Leisure ruled in the Southern District of New York that a poster bound into various wrestling magazines was not an infringement of the wrestlers’ right of publicity, even though the poster was bound and stapled into the center and could not be viewed without removing it from the magazine, which itself of course was first-amendment protected. “The constitutional protection of the freedom of the press does not stop at 8" x 11," the judge ruled.

Returning to baseball, a sport in which the conclusion is not scripted, Judge Medler added: “A defendant’s making a profit does not preclude its receiving First Amendment protection.... The court finds, therefore, that CBC’s deriving a profit from its use of the names and playing records of Major League baseball players in its fantasy baseball games does not preclude such use from having First Amendment protection.”

Baseball has always been, in the words of long departed Cubs’ owner Phil Wrigley, “Too much of a sport to be a business and too much of a business to be a sport.” Amen.

--John Thorn

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?