credit rating reports notice rights under fair credit reporting act pulling personal credit reports free credit report identity theft victim how to dispute credit report with equifax disclosure and authorization pertaining to consumer reports pursuant to the fair credit reporting act credit reporting agencies telephone numbers new credit report commercial do credit reporting agencies report each other run credit report tenant colorado reliable credit report what does it mean on credit report when it says charge off get my free annual credit report online fact act amendments to the fair credit reporting act how to read a transunion canada credit report how to read disputing a credit report equifax annual credit report website legitimate free credit report law wiki how to write a letter to credit reporting agencies my official free credit report information credit report gathered how to view your credit report for free where can i get all three credit reports free credit report bureaus us how do you report debt to credit bureau canada credit report bureau how to get a true free credit report how do i find out who i owe money to on my credit report credit report watch experian credit report number cancellation how to clear bad credit report free credit report.com band guys free credit report for equifax online one free credit report how does one get a copy of your credit report every free credit report commercial 2011 how to read equifax credit reports whats a good credit report change my address my credit report how to have negative items removed from your credit report get monthly credit reports happened band free credit report commercials lock my credit report experian anthem non traditional credit report how to find out your how to check credit rating in canada how to free report credit card agencies all 3 credit reports canada meridian credit union 2009 annual report request a free copy of credit report free report through irs credit scores other guys free credit report commercials run credit report tenant free companies asking for credit report government annual credit report free free credit report every 12 months calendar year free credit reporting act summary how to get a free credit report without mastercard information can i pay for a credit report does checking your credit report lower my score lawyers credit card for credit repair free credit report for renters free annual credit report credit scores yearly free credit report request long does info stay credit report canada medical bill collection on credit report after 7 years credit report canada debt settlement removal credit report transunion unlimited credit reports oft high cost of credit report see credit report canada dispute all 3 credit reports 3 in one credit report and scores transunion best credit report websites can you really get free credit report credit report problems com review how to fix a charge off on my credit report government site for free credit reports legitimate free credit report online how do i get credit report information average experian noodle credit score uk asking credit report job interview govt required free report credit card remove collection from credit report get free credit report from experian does free annual credit report give score royal bank free credit report is it safe to request credit report online credit report charge off how to update your credit report fast what is the timeframe for removing negative credit information with the exception of bankruptcies from a credit report weegy experian credit report agency address clean up your credit report after bankruptcy credit repair group garden grove california dispute credit reports equifax remove employment information credit report cannot get online credit report annual credit report.co.uk reviews credit report example (good) best credit report service consumer reports is the original free credit report band back secure payday loans borrow money online with bad credit background background and credit check services order my credit report mail free annual credit report service free annual credit report customer service sample cease and desist letter to creditors cash advance credit card anz us bank access instant online credit report free can access credit report original free credit report band lyrics free yearly credit report 2011 free credit report.com customer service phone number getting a credit report for a minor mortgage credit report companies free personal company credit report australia free credit report score government site bureaus phone numbers credit bureau credit reports new free credit report commercial future equifax application form for credit report does debt consolidation show up on your credit report fair credit reporting act disclosure statement form reporting bad creditors read credit report equifax how to check my credit card balance in hdfc free credit report band how do i unfreeze my experian credit report dispute item on credit report online how do i repair my credit government grants to buy a home top credit reporting services agency free credit report commercial cell phone free credit report every year capital one lost credit card reporting information death credit reporting agency small business reporting to credit agencies does bank of america secured credit card report to credit bureaus request removal collection credit report equifax free report canada online credit score transunion direct credit report login law enforcement systems on credit report how to fix a charge off on credit report how to get a free annual credit report in canada experian what is credit bureau report disputing inaccurate credit report information free credit report with transunion prepaid legal services credit report notice to correct credit report questionnaire annual credit credit report gov what is the best credit reporting agency to use how can i get my credit report online for free repair my credit report myself get copy of credit report free does does credit repair magic work federal trade commission credit report dispute how do i get my free annual credit report from transunion us credit report center equifax canada credit report mail obtaining credit report application for money advancement long debt settlement your credit report totally free credit report and score how do myspace get your free credit report yearly no credit check instant payday loans online lenders first credit report.com commercial pay loan uk california investigative consumer credit reporting agencies act free credit report mailed to me how long bad credit stays on credit report disputing experian credit report why should i pay for my credit report 3 free credit reports no credit card can my spouse request my credit report cheap credit reports for landlords annual credit report free online checking credit report child denied satisfied judgments credit report call equifax for free credit report annual credit report help forums unsecured visa credit cards for bad credit instant approval obtain credit report free online corporate amex credit report my credit report for free how do i get my credit report for free from equifax how long does bad debt stay on credit report how long can negative credit report dispute negative information credit report yearly free credit report transunion getting credit report job how do i remove a public record from my credit report best cash back credit card consumer report how do you remove charge offs from credit report guide to 7 steps to fixing your credit report which is the best place to get a free credit report credit report for free no charge can debt collector check my credit report credit reports and employment credit report lawyers virginia can i get a free copy of my business credit report experian credit report monitoring service credit report for landlords free credit reporting industry opt out get free credit report from trans union best buy report credit bureau dispute judgement your credit report what does key derogatory on credit report mean credit suisse group annual report 2009 define the purpose of a credit reporting agency how to get free credit report from experian consumer credit card reports free 3 in 1 credit report forms to dispute credit reports how long does it take to repair credit score after short sale equifax request credit report instant credit report find people australia free account paid in full credit report landlord check tenant credit report how do you remove dispute from experian credit report remove negative accounts your credit report free credit score report no credit card required find credit report canada is free credit report canada safe payday free copy credit report online best credit score reporting agency bureaus credit reporting agencies addresses phone numbers bankruptcy self credit repair forum government website free credit report the fair credit reporting act.amd 3 free credit report and scores pull customer credit reports all credit reports freeware best credit reporting company use report identity theft three credit bureaus get free gov credit report how to obtain your credit report online credit report sample equifax how do i report a dispute on my credit report best credit reporting service free credit report trial membership new york and fair credit reporting act and employment collection agencies reporting credit bureau accounts how to erase a collection on credit report credit card ratings 2011 consumer reports how to remove paid charge offs from credit report balance transfer credit card for poor credit experian free annual credit report how to block access to your credit report free government credit report how can you obtain free copies of your credit report information do you need get credit report credit report repair forms how to view my business credit report copy of credit report canada how do youtube get your free credit report yearly fair credit report act definition one free credit report per year cheap payday advance online approval credit report credit score my credit keeper hsbc credit keeper credit report privacy rules prepaid visa card reports credit bureau fair credit reporting act and bankruptcy how do i order free credit report credit reports usaa can employers pull your credit report credit report canada equifax transunion does eviction go your credit report california free credit report actors in commercials help rebuild my credit credit cards free credit check online tenant credit repair attorney toronto sealed credit report experian remove negative report credit report how to report a delinquent tenant to the credit bureaus how to get free credit report uk how do i remove incorrect items from my credit report best day to pull credit report effect of authorized user on credit report federal reserve annual credit report online removing erroneous information credit report is it possible to get your credit score for free credit reporting agencies list federal credit reporting guidelines consumer reports chase freedom credit card transunion small business credit reports credit repair companies hotels near 33312 monitor credit report and score free annual credit report web site small business credit reports applicants updating your credit report canada fico score credit report all 3 credit reports transunion free report usa personal solutions credit reports get free credit report all 3 credit bureaus score natwest credit check experian 3 credit score report negative credit report entries how long does it take to improve your credit report free annual credit report form payday advances payday loans from direct lenders only find my credit report credit report view free how long does it take to clear my credit report attorney general texas credit report fair and accurate credit reporting act section 312 best credit cards consumer reports 2011 credit repair auto insurance companies in ontario when does discover card report to credit bureau does experian update credit report equifax request obtain my free credit report transunion credit report and fico score cheapest 3 bureau credit report score disputes on experian credit report personal credit reporting agencies phone numbers cbc innovis credit reporting agency charge off on credit report paid soldiers sailors act credit reporting credit repair oil security companies in houston tx credit report login correcting credit report letter personal information included credit report much does experian credit report cost easy understand credit report credit report all three bureaus suze orman free credit report coupons order mail credit report addresses of credit reporting agencies order a free credit report from equifax how do you get a totally free credit report annualcreditreport instant cash advance cash loan online no credit check callahan and associates credit union report website for free credit report and score lock your credit reports free credit report and fico score how to remove foreclosure from credit report fair accurate credit reporting act dispute credit report error letter legit way to get credit report how to join the credit reporting bureaus one time 3in1 credit report bad credit report and employment 3 bureau credit report with scores obtain your free yearly credit report secured credit cards reporting does getting a copy of my credit report affect my score fix your credit reports long negative information credit reports does checking my credit report lower my scorecard which credit report site is really free free credit report commercial new active duty military freeze credit report american how much should credit repair cost how to remove information from your credit report free credit report site safe total credit union deposits what is a collection charge off on my credit report does mean says account charged off credit report the credit suisse global wealth report 2012 payday loans bad credit payday loans no faxing free credit report band search where can i get my credit report for free without a credit card authorization to obtain credit report for employment fast credit elevator repair companies in texas how to free credit report annual transunion fraud alert how long does bankruptcy stay on credit report canada credit report mortgage companies under investigation how to get a free credit report after being denied credit how to dispute equifax credit report repair credit report late payment can you get credit report bank annual free credit report required by law what is cbcinnovis on my credit report can you remove a foreclosure from your credit report transunion free annual credit report cash advances payday payday loans no credit check get free credit report from government direct payday loans online uk quick easy credit report i need all 3 credit reports for free stop people checking my credit report free denied equifax my credit report after how to order credit reports for free 1977 federal fair credit reporting act transunion credit report dispute forms how to do a dispute on my credit report find your business credit report where to get my credit report and score credit reports ?2 order transunion capital report denied credit completely free annual credit report get free credit report from 3 agencies how to get a cash advance on a credit card at an atm secured credit card reports all 3 credit bureaus credit reports 3 in 1 late payment remove credit report i need to buy my credit report best place to obtain credit reports unreliable credit reports credit information report is credit report and credit score the same thing experian free credit report annual equifax free credit report canada phone number how to report stolen credit card to credit bureau free copy credit report once year how do i find out if i have a security freeze on my credit report how to correct something on your credit report how to fix a charge off on your credit report when are items removed from your credit report free credit card report get corporation credit report free credit report commercial planet x good reasons to dispute credit report free credit report new car song lyrics best credit card deals consumer report no credit report car insurance free credit score reporting act service free annual credit reports email credit report clean up after bankruptcy equifax free report turned down for credit name band free credit report commercial see your credit report freeware where can i check my credit score for free in south africa get free copy your report canada credit rating pulling credit reports home loans how to put a security alert on my credit report better business bureau annual credit report info do need credit report premium credit bureau data login three in one credit report and fico score unfreeze credit report experian debt not on my credit report suze orman check credit report free credit report band free credit score free credit report uk no credit card experian the best credit reporting agencies equifax free debt report denied credit official government site for credit report credit report for employment law number of inquiries on credit report report stolen chase credit cards get incorrect info off your credit report order credit report by post free report all three reporting agencies credit scores free credit annual credit report trw transunion credit report contact credit repair group inc reviews my free credit report for the year free bureau reporting agencies credit scores how to get a collection removed from your credit report government once year credit report free credit report and credit scores credit agricole ile de france numero official annual credit report site 3 credit scores and reports fair credit reporting act agency information how do i dispute an address on my credit report free credit report mail form official site get annual credit report free credit report customer service credit report site safe letter to remove item from credit report how to view my credit report for free online equifax canada free credit report phone how to report credit fraud much does cost order credit report charge off credit report long personal credit reports uk agencies equifax canada business credit report i need to fix my credit for free which is the best free credit report company how do i get a free credit report without signing up for anything define report public credit 1790 how to how to get credit card details what is an employment credit report 3 credit reports experian how to cancel free credit report .com sign dispute apartment charges credit report online cash advance payday loan preferredpaydayloancom do business credit cards show up personal credit report secured credit card reports monthly free report online without card canada credit rating obtain my credit report score veda individual credit report how to get your credit report free once a year do you need credit report rent house triple credit report experian importance annual reports creditors ftc how to dispute credit report errors cheap credit report monitoring free unreliable credit reports how to credit reporting agencies credit report companies contact information credit report dispute uk obtaining a free report in canada credit rating obtaining credit report renters free credit report dispute form free credit report rating how to check business credit report i want to get a free credit report how do you dispute something on your credit report experience credit report phone number equifax credit report issues cleaning credit report after bankruptcy discharge
Home All Articles Who Owns Sports?

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 873 guests online

Atom RSS

Who Owns Sports? PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 52
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by John Thorn   
Thursday, 31 August 2006 11:12
John Thorn is a contributing writer for The Biz of Baseball 

From "Play's the Thing," Woodstock Times, August 31, 2006:

Money talks, bullshit walks. That coarse and yet so fine phrase, born of poker, soon became the byword of the business arena, particularly when delivered by the man with the money to the schnook with the big idea. But what happens when money comes as part and parcel with bullshit, as is so often the case?

A couple of weeks ago Major League Baseball Advanced Media (MLBAM) and the Players Association (MLBPA) lost a court case to CDM Fantasy Sports, a Missouri corporation legally named CBC that markets, distributes and sells fantasy sports products, including fantasy baseball games accessible over the Internet. Ho hum, you might say; just another argument about money in which John Q. Public has no rooting interest.

Not so. This truly fascinating case, in which Mary Ann L. Medler, United States Magistrate Judge, ruled on August 8, was about more than “Who owns facts?” — specifically here, whether a fantasy baseball game could depict the names and statistics of active players without paying for the privilege. In background a Greek chorus might have intoned not only “Who owns sports?” but also “Who owns fame?”
Without doubt a transaction takes place between and among owner, club, and fan.

The club offers its credible intent to play hard and, often if not reliably, win.

The owner provides (with the aid of the general public, silent partner in all of sport) an arena for entertainment on site and via broadcast that augments spectators’ experience of the contest. He, in concert with other owners, also provides a league structure in which a championship may be contested and determined. Owner and players, in short, combine to make the game.

What does the fan contribute, besides his cash for a ticket, concessions, and parking when he goes to the game, or his inert fanny and eyeballs when advertisers bombard him at home? The fan may be said to own nothing yet give everything, for not only fortune but also fame are at one end of that two-way street in which the fan’s approbation and reward are at the other. The athlete may provide the accomplishment but the fan creates the fame; neither Organized Baseball nor the players seem fully cognizant of the vital role played by the proles.

The fan, the ordinary Joe, has no property or intellectual rights in the game of baseball. But as Judge Medler averred, he cannot be made to pay in one context for something that a purported vendor acknowledges is free to all in another. Are player statistics property, or are they public information? If I say 511, .406, or 73, do you know the players I am referencing (Cy Young, Ted Williams, Barry Bonds, respectively)? How about the uniform numbers 3, 7, 24, and 44 (most famously Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, and Henry Aaron)?

In the legal proceeding neither MLBAM nor the MLBPA contended that numbers associated with players were anything but common facts in the public domain, beyond the proprietary interests of anyone who might look for the protection of copyright, trademark, or patent. If a company wished to depict the line below in a fantasy game it was OK with them:

G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG
161 591 129 195 38 2 41 117 16 2 97 65 .330 .430 .609


If, however, an “unlicensed” (i.e., nonpaying) fantasy league like CBC combined that line with the name “Albert Pujols,” well then it was violating the player’s “right of publicity,” depriving him of the benefit of his good name and constricting his future earnings. Mind you, the MLBAM/MLBPA position was not opposed to such conjoined use by newspapers, television, or internet media, as these uses were clearly First Amendment protected instances of free speech and, besides, provided free publicity that tended to boost rather than crimp player and league revenues.

As the court summarized the opposing positions, “... the Players’ Association and Advanced Media clarified that they are not claiming that CBC cannot use players’ playing records or biographical data; that they are challenging CBC’s use of players’ names in conjunction with its fantasy baseball games; that they are claiming that the identities of players are represented by their names; that they are concerned with protecting the players’ names; and that they are claiming that CBC uses players’ names in its fantasy baseball games in violation of the players’ right of publicity.” In response to this view, “CBC stated that its position is that players’ names and playing records, as used in its fantasy baseball games, are preempted by copyright law; that CBC’s use of players’ names and playing records in its fantasy baseball games does not violate the players’ claimed right of publicity; and that even assuming, arguendo, that CBC’s use of players’ names and playing records violates the players’ right of publicity, the First Amendment controls.”

Unlike the right of privacy, which is a personal right, the right of publicity is generally regarded as a property right. Indeed, the right of publicity is a curious notion of startlingly recent birth. Conceptually it may be said to go back to King Kelly's 1887 contract with the Boston Red Stockings, to whom he had just been traded by Chicago White Stockings. The contract called for $2000 in salary, in line with the league-wide salary cap, but also provided $3000 for the use of his likeness for advertising and promotional purposes. In reality, this was just a ploy to evade the salary limitations and induce Kelly to abide by the trade. As J. Gordon Hylton, Professor of Law at Marquette University, wrote, “What Kelly authorized was technically neither a trademark nor a copyright matter, but a waiver of what we today call his ‘right of publicity.’ The early history of the right of publicity is extremely murky, but this particular agreement seems to imply ... that Kelly's club could not use his image for commercial purposes without his permission. It would be interesting to know if early baseball card manufactures paid players for the use of their images. Honus Wagner's ability to stop the printing of cigarette cards with his photos in the first decade of the 20th century also suggests that something like the right of publicity was recognized prior to 1910.”

However, the term was never used in a legal context until 1953. As Judge Medler wrote in her opinion, “A fairly recent concept, according to the Sixth Circuit in ETW Corporation v. Jireh Publishing, Inc., 332 F.3d 915, 929 (6th Cir. 2003), this right ‘was first recognized in Haelan Laboratories, Inc. v. Topps Chewing Gum. Inc., 202 F.2d 866 (2nd Cir. 1953), where the Second Circuit held that New York’s common law protected a baseball player’s right [Wes Westrum] in the publicity value of his photograph, and, in the process, coined the phrase ‘right of publicity’ as the name of this right.’ Subsequently, in Zacchini, 433 U.S. at 573, where a performer in a ‘human cannonball’ act sought to recover damages from a television broadcast of his entire performance, the Supreme Court recognized that the right of publicity protects the proprietary interest of an individual to ‘reap the reward of his endeavors.’”

The poor devil Zacchini won his suit because his act, his sole means of livelihood, was expropriated. “However,” Judge Medler wrote, “CBC’s use of Major League baseball players’ names and playing records in fantasy baseball games does not go to the heart of the players’ ability to earn a living as baseball players; the baseball players earn a living playing baseball and endorsing products; they do not earn a living by the publication of their playing records. See Zacchini, 433 U.S. at 576. Moreover, CBC’s use of Major League baseball players’ names and playing records [unlike the complete depiction of Zacchini’s human-cannonball shot] does not give CBC something free for which it would otherwise be required to pay; players’ records are readily available in the public domain.”

On the free-speech front, the judge continued, “CBC argues, in the event it has violated the players’ right of publicity, that speech is involved in its fantasy games; that this speech does not differ from raw statistics published in newspapers; that the speech involved in its fantasy games is expression which is protected under the First Amendment; and that the First Amendment trumps the right of publicity in the circumstances of this case. The Players’ Association and Advanced Media argue that CBC’s games do not involve speech or the expression of ideas; that what is at issue in this matter is not speech; and that, therefore, the First Amendment does not apply.”

Wrong. Again from the ruling: “Speech which does not use ‘a traditional medium of expression’ does not receive less protection than more traditional means of speech.... As such, the First Amendment has been applied to flag burning, nude dancing, and wearing a jacket with obscenities. Id. (citations omitted). Moreover, the fact that expression appears in a novel medium does not preclude its being subject to First Amendment protection.”

An earlier landmark case in this area of nontraditional free speech involved the World Wrestling Federation (in Titan Sports v. Comics World, 87-0178). In 1989 Judge Peter K. Leisure ruled in the Southern District of New York that a poster bound into various wrestling magazines was not an infringement of the wrestlers’ right of publicity, even though the poster was bound and stapled into the center and could not be viewed without removing it from the magazine, which itself of course was first-amendment protected. “The constitutional protection of the freedom of the press does not stop at 8" x 11," the judge ruled.

Returning to baseball, a sport in which the conclusion is not scripted, Judge Medler added: “A defendant’s making a profit does not preclude its receiving First Amendment protection.... The court finds, therefore, that CBC’s deriving a profit from its use of the names and playing records of Major League baseball players in its fantasy baseball games does not preclude such use from having First Amendment protection.”

Baseball has always been, in the words of long departed Cubs’ owner Phil Wrigley, “Too much of a sport to be a business and too much of a business to be a sport.” Amen.

--John Thorn

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?