commonwealth bank credit cards frequent flyer delta credit card promotion 2011 which credit card gives the best rewards in india the best credit cards to use abroad easy store credit cards to get with bad credit disney chase visa credit cards orchard secured credit card for bad credit compare credit cards travel insurance old orchard bank secured credit card lowest apr credit cards credit union how to apply credit card online in icici accept credit cards online square cash back credit card offers 2012 best cash rewards credit cards 2012 credit card minimum payment percentage how do i get approved for a credit card with no credit best cashback credit cards uae perks for disney credit card holders compare credit cards for foreign travel ach and credit card merchant account processing for small businesses old orchard credit card online chase credit card protection insurance limit on black visa credit cards axis bank lifetime free credit card rbs credit cards online india stolen credit card numbers free 2013 hdfc credit card reward points redemption catalogue what does cashback on credit cards mean sbi gold credit card limit credit cards for business owners with bad credit barclays credit card lost and stolen sams club discover credit card login falcon credit card fraud detection system what credit cards are issued by mbna icici instant credit card statement loans for bad credit to pay over 12 months benefits of accepting credit cards small business credit card validator c# money saving expert best credit card for purchases capital one secured credit card deposit cibc credit card services online sallie mae student loans bill pay post office platinum credit card amazon chase credit card deal best credit card deals 0 on purchases 0 interest credit cards purchases 12 months clothing store credit cards with bad credit prepaid credit cards td bank canada mastercard credit cards usa cash back rewards credit cards 2011 best credit card travel rewards 2013 bad credit unsecured credit cards no deposit average usa credit card debt unsecured credit cards for bad credit credit card application declined reasons philippines credit cards for good credit no annual fee different types of credit card companies bank of america credit card 5 cash back student loans with bad credit score td canada trust secured credit card application working visa card generator tesco credit card minimum payment 0 discover or capital one student credit card citibank credit cards for bad credit hsbc mobile credit card terminal do visa gift cards work the same as a credit card bad credit no credit loans real usa credit card number activate new cibc credit card get small business credit card bad credit no credit check unsecured credit card best cash advance places online direct online payday lenders only the best cash rebate credit card in malaysia firestone credit card pay by phone credit card frequent flyer points no annual fee best online prepaid credit card hsbc mastercard credit card ppi usb credit card scanner top 5 credit card companies in the world malaysia credit card review 2013 gnc gold card number lookup costco credit card processing iphone transfer credit card balance 0 halifax balance transfer credit card review apply for barclays credit card online delta skymiles? credit card companion ticket fia card services credit protection plus credit card machine till rolls apply credit card instant approval malaysia national cash advance stockport chevron credit card hold 126 citibank credit card online application philippines halifax interest free credit card barclay credit card application status hdfc bank credit card login page first time credit cards no credit hdfc credit card loan apply bank of america credit card balance transfer offers sample credit card authorization form template instant loans online no credit check apple credit card scanner for iphone united explorer credit card reviews online application for credit card bpi best premium credit cards canada good credit cards for first timers accept credit cards on iphone international 24 hour online instant cash loans south africa lloyds tsb student credit card balance transfer what is a purchase interest rate on a credit card advice for reducing credit card debt payday loan lender black credit cards wikipedia standard chartered credit card payment gateway how does credit card balance transfers work icici instant credit card activation time prepaid credit card canada reloadable random credit card number with cvv better to pay loans or invest disputing international credit card charges fast bad credit loans online check my credit score no credit card required best rewards credit card 2011 money magazine take credit card payments online without merchant account hdfc credit cards customer care number standard chartered credit card reward points redemption catalogue india how does paying with a credit card work online best credit cards deals 2011 tesco credit card uk online login easiest department store credit cards for bad credit wells fargo secured credit card cash advance american express credit card verification code is there a southwest credit card with no annual fee citibank government travel credit card login easy credit card to get approved for 2012 virtual credit card generator 2012 one vanilla visa card how to get free real credit card numbers free credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date 2013 pay hsbc online credit card payment get a credit card with no credit and no deposit credit card services bank of ireland contact best credit card for travel rewards uk what age can you get a credit card in canada credit score required for credit card canada fnb gold credit card interest rate standard chartered bank credit card promotions sri lanka balance transfer credit card bank rakyat best credit card rewards programme hrsaccount best buy credit card login why do i need a credit card for free apps kindle apply for capital one business credit card credit card calculator excel spreadsheet does arco gas station accept credit cards paypal credit card processing app payday loans online get a fast easy payday loan chase credit card services jobs direct cash advance lenders list gift credit cards walmart prepaid credit card to help rebuild credit student credit cards no credit personal bad credit loans in canada 5 what are some things to look for when choosing a credit card which bank offer best credit card in malaysia 0 interest balance transfer credit cards malaysia hdfc credit card limit status amex credit card number format hsbc classic credit card limit best credit cards canada no fee template letter to credit card company ge money bank walmart credit card phone number valid credit card number gold card national rail discounts how to get your name off a joint credit card ?5000 loan for bad credit no brokers natwest credit card online banking fidelity visa cash back credit card travel reward credit cards for average credit amazon visa rewards card worth it how to make a fake credit card number credit cards with fixed low interest rates using visa debit cards in india long term loans with bad credit history credit card scanner for android phone bank of america secured credit card graduation clark howard free credit report post office credit card contact telephone number hdfc bank credit card register and pay login bank of america credit card settlement agreement bad credit rebuilding credit cards best rewards credit card in the uk how to improve credit score when you can;t get a credit card reloadable prepaid credit card australia firestone credit card benefits 0 balance transfer and purchase credit cards payday loans no fees no phone calls first data credit card processing fees hdfc credit cards helpline number department store credit cards issued by capital one best credit card for a college student with no credit first horizon credit card australian credit card comparison prepaid credit cards no fees best apply for a visa credit card with bad credit sbi credit card apply online in salem visa mastercard prepaid credit cards lord and taylor credit card accepting credit cards small business get a credit card with bad credit today hsbc credit card settlement contact my next payday advance how do you calculate interest on credit card balances vcc virtual credit card indonesia best interest free credit cards for purchases www toysrus com creditcard login apply for credit cards with bad credit history credit card payoff calculator chart bad credit loan uk direct lender identifying credit card types by number sbi credit card online payment link credit cards for bad credit trying to rebuild average credit card merchant fees download ocbc credit card application form receive credit card payments on android credit card debt settlement letter template santander 123 cashback credit card review usa today best credit cards credit building credit cards with no deposit citibank business credit card login gnc gold card renewal best payday loan online lenders visa debit gift card commonwealth bank apple iphone 4 credit card swipe walmart 24 month interest free credit card sbi railway credit card application form virgin pay as you go credit card best credit cards for balance transfers 2013 platinum credit card corporation contact details how often can i apply for a chase credit card things you need to know before getting a credit card best american express cash back cards student no credit history credit cards citibank balance transfer credit card offers pnc bank national city credit card how to get credit card limit increase chase prepaid visa debit card canada credit card bank islam online low interest balance transfer credit cards for life citibank uk credit card application mobile credit card machines ireland orchard bank secured visa credit card credit card review singapore easy online cash loans how to check my citibank credit card reward points easy fast online payday loans credit expert uk if i apply for a credit card can i get it the same day old orchard bank credit card application payday cash advance online lenders what are some real credit card numbers vanilla prepaid credit card visa small business credit card comparison 2012 how do handheld credit card machines work can i accept credit cards over the phone with paypal best credit card with 0 percent interest how do i get a credit card with no credit score best canadian credit cards for travel best student credit card canada credit card canada no credit history does cibc have prepaid credit cards master credit card instant cash loans online in south africa payday loans online bad credit no fax get a credit card with no credit or bad credit gold delta skymiles business credit card instant pay day loans no credit check visa credit card machine rental bank of america credit cards customer service numbers usaa world mastercard? credit card review hsbc secured credit cards canada pay off credit card debt understanding credit and credit cards how can i get a credit card today with bad credit best buy master credit card payment chase business credit card no foreign transaction fee free guaranteed approval credit cards which credit card is best for college students visa rewards card points bank of america prepaid debit cards visa instant cash loans now bank of america credit card settlement offer 2012 best cash back no fee credit card canada commonwealth bank credit card rates what is the best prepaid credit card for online use how long halifax credit card application 12 month bad credit loans no brokers best intro apr credit card credit cards for really bad credit instant approval credit score needed for firestone credit card first premier platinum credit card login credit card transfer offers can you get an american express card with no credit history quick loans online south africa 3 major credit card reporting agencies barclays black visa card activate chase credit card rewards chase bank small business credit card processing instant approval credit cards in canada for bad credit unsecured visa credit cards for bad credit instant approval credit card 0 apr no transfer fee best cashback credit card personal loans ireland bad credit best credit card to get for someone with no credit american airlines credit card offer 2013 fnb online credit card application reloadable prepaid credit card usa prepaid credit cards business opportunity where do i send my belk credit card payment how to pay icici credit card bill online from sbi how to apply credit card in sbi bank online walmart credit cards accepted credit card numbers generator are credit card charges vatable how to apply for barclays credit card online credit cards with rewards no annual fee get real credit card numbers security codes usaa credit card score requirements best canadian cash reward credit cards union 76 gas credit card chase credit card payments credit card review website easy instant online loans united airlines credit card promotion 2012 best balance transfer credit card in malaysia costco credit card accepted canada what retail stores have reward cards barclaycard platinum credit card review visa credit card search interest free credit card transfer deals virtual credit card paypal 2011 can you get cashback on credit card credit card number and cvv validator download credit card zip code for canadian credit cards payday loan direct lender list uk what is a good credit card apr 2012 best travel credit cards rewards chevron credit card application status phone number how much does quickbooks credit card processing cost lowest interest credit cards available best bad credit credit cards uk accepting credit cards on your cell phone icici platinum credit cards offers i need a credit card fast and i have bad credit citibank business credit card application should i apply for paypal credit card streamline credit card machine rolls electronic stores that offer credit cards citibank small business credit card best rewards credit card no annual fee credit cards with no application fee for bad credit going over credit card limit hsbc 0 apr credit card offers balance transfers stores that offer credit cards for no credit free credit card information with cvv loans you can pay back monthly student credit cards with no credit instant approval online visa card registration barclays us airways business credit card fast short term loans online south africa how credit can beat prepaid cards instant gratification low interest credit card offers canada fast payday loans online direct lenders business loans no credit card sales best credit card compare best airline rewards credit cards 2013 ge capital art van credit card how to prevent credit card fraud at gas stations how to make a hdfc credit card payment online credit card with no credit history international travel tips credit cards payday online loans no credit check how to cancel a chase credit card online first premier secured credit card reviews best payday loans online no credit check 0 interest free balance transfer credit cards visa business credit card offers sears canada credit card services customer service apply for credit cards for bad credit citi credit card offers for bad credit best credit cards 2013 for travel paypal mobile credit card processing do you need a credit card for itunes best visa credit cards 2013 westpac black credit card review capital one credit card debt settlement minimum requirements for getting a credit card credit card app for ipad canada credit cards apply online ireland apply for barclays credit card india hdfc credit card payment from other credit card good credit card transfer deals best business credit cards 2012 unsecured loans with bad credit australia macy;s credit card cash advances ikea uk credit card charges cash back credit card comparison canada credit union lowest credit card rates prepaid credit cards business plan secured major credit cards credit card processing providers uk discover card with no credit history best credit card processing app for iphone citibank credit card interest rates in india credit limit t mobile bank of america secured credit card denied visa credit card processing charges compare credit cards with free travel insurance how does apr work on a secured credit card legitimate payday loans online visa cards wiki marriott credit card promotions uk apply for capital one unsecured credit card credit card compare uae is fast cash advance payday loans legit virtual credit card number capital one toys r us rewards credit card login paypal credit card scanners where is the credit card number located on an american express credit card american airlines credit card offer best iphone app for credit card transactions how many types of credit cards are there axis bank credit card apply very bad credit loans no guarantor citibank credit card rate of interest hsbc gold credit card minimum payment bad credit cash advance direct lenders usaa credit card rewards shop best small business credit card reviews hsbc bank bangladesh international credit card credit report experian government loans to consolidate credit card debt best american aadvantage credit card offer icici credit card bill payment best credit card rates canada how to get credit card online free hsbc uae credit card loan 0 balance transfer credit card poor credit chase credit cards for students with no credit history best place for a college student to get a credit card american express gold card review square credit card business model prepaid credit cards available at shoppers drug mart vanilla visa prepaid online shopping card credit card settlement process in india rewards credit card for average credit credit cards that earn airline miles with no annual fee credit cards visa signature citibank credit cards uae recurring credit card authorization form intuit citibank credit card travel promotion chase united credit card customer service how do you check the balance on a visa gift card online easy credit cards to get approved for ireland halifax student credit card review credit card protection paypal credit card debt settlement amazon visa rewards card car rental insurance sbi credit card offers 2013 hsbc credit card offers uae instant 3 month payday loans best bad credit card uk how to get a cash advance on a visa credit card 28 degrees mastercard exchange rate free credit card processing no monthly fee how long does it take to get a refund on your credit card best credit card usa holiday list of stores that have reward cards uk best credit card offer rewards uk credit card travel insurance pay my national city credit card online capital 1 credit card payment online online credit card processing companies how to get pre approved bdo credit card best rewards credit card no annual fee 2013 paypal seller protection credit card chargeback instant approval credit cards not prepaid best black credit card uk hsbc corporate credit card singapore virtual visa gift card canada td low interest rate credit card credit card debt consolidation loans for bad credit td canada trust visa lost credit card cibc credit card lost consolidate credit cards with low interest loan visa credit cards numbers and security code who offers secured credit cards in australia pre approved credit cards canada best credit cards with rewards 2013 united credit card comparison best credit cards for college students with no income
Home Media News Extra Innings Deal Makes Poor Long-Term Business Sense

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1059 guests online

Atom RSS

Extra Innings Deal Makes Poor Long-Term Business Sense PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 23
Written by Maury Brown   
Wednesday, 28 March 2007 06:21

Maury BrownYesterday saw several principle players in the Extra Innings saga testify before the US Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation at a hearing entitled Exclusive Sports Programming: Examining Competition and Consumer Choice. Rob Jacobson President and Chief Executive Officer for iN DEMAND Networks, Bob DuPuy President and Chief Operating Officer for Major League Baseball, Chase Carey Chief Executive Officer for DIRECTV Group, Inc., and Carl Vogel President & Vice Chairman EchoStar Satellite L.L.C. all had time at the microphone.

As the prepared statements provided here on The Biz of Baseball show, there are some key facets—namely the upcoming The Baseball Channel—that are creating the impasse on getting all the incumbents in a place to carry Extra Innings.

In a nutshell, DirecTV has offered to pay for the rights to show The Baseball Channel up-front, and now. Given the fact that ratings for NFL Network have not exactly been stellar (the heavily hyped debut game on the fledgling network pulled an averaged 4.2 million total viewers and a 2.3 household rating according to Nielsen, nearly one-third what Monday Night Football pulls on ESPN), you might understand why Robert Jacobson of iN Demand offered up a compromise deal in his opening statement. “If The Baseball Channel launches in 2009, we would give MLB the right to cancel the Extra Innings deal if it cannot reach a satisfactory agreement for carriage of the new channel with our owners,” Jacobson said. “This would put off the issue of The Baseball Channel until it actually launches and ensure that for the next two years at least, all baseball fans will have access to the Extra Innings package.”

After the statement was made, Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) asked Bob DuPuy, “"What's the matter with that?”

Well, here’s what’s the matter with that: If MLB re-negotiates with iN Demand, MLB has to renegotiate with DirecTV, and possibly EchoStar if they get onboard. The exclusive deal takes the risk off MLB and places it on DirecTV. As mentioned, if ratings for the NFL Network are not high by comparison to games shown on ESPN, how will MLB fair? After all, the NFL enjoys a vastly more popular product. Also, by DirecTV offering an up-front payment as opposed to iN Demand’s offer make The Baseball Channel available on a per subscriber basis, MLB has those funds available for any start-up costs involved in launching The Baseball Channel.

(Select Read More to view the rest of Maury Brown's article) 

Back to iN Demand, it seemed more than a bit ironic that they played themselves up as the “good guys” in this deal. After all, there are exclusive deals for cable that involve the Mets, White Sox, Padres and Phillies. As reported by Richard Sandomir of the NY Times in late February:

The owners will also have their own interests at heart. The Mets are partners in SNY with two cable operators, Time Warner and Comcast; the White Sox and Cubs are also partners with Comcast in Chicago. The Atlanta Braves are caught between being sold by Time Warner, which owns cable networks like TBS, to Liberty Media, which is taking over DirecTV.

The Padres' cable games are not licensed to satellite, so if their local fans switch to DirecTV to continue to watch Extra Innings, they will not get their own team's games unless they buy both services.

Comcast SportsNet in Philadelphia is not delivered by satellite as most regional sports networks like YES and SNY are, which leaves 300,000 or more DirecTV subscribers (at least 50 percent more than total national cable subscribership to Extra Innings) in that market without access to those cable games. Comcast's refusal to put its sports network on satellite has been challenged by DirecTV and EchoStar but affirmed by the federal government.

So, it’s not as if cable isn’t playing a roll in the exclusivity matter, as well. It should be interesting if you live in San Diego, have to watch the Padres on cable due to an exclusive deal with Cox, and you want to watch Extra Innings. In that instance, it appears you’ll have to have DirecTV, AND cable.

As for DirecTV, Chase Carey provided some analysis by dartboard. “DIRECTV estimates that there are relatively few viewers – no more than three percent of the cable segment (approximately 180,000 Extra Innings subscribers) – who cannot receive DIRECTV service,” Carey said in his opening statement. “This translates to roughly 5,000 subscribers – each of whom can access the games over the Internet.”

This is analogous to saying, “When a breeze blows through pile of leaves, 5,000 of them will be displaced.” It’s wholly arbitrary. How Carey and DirecTV came about this figure had to come with sticking their finger in the wind, but it did, none the less, create a case where the figure will be published and the myth will, in time, become engrained as revisionist history.

The other issue that got a lot of play regarded MLB’s willingness to offer a 20% ownership equity in The MLB Channel to DirecTV, while not giving this same offer to the incumbents. As Carl Vogel of EchoStar said, “However, in its entirety must be apples to apples, which will require EchoStar to acquire a pro-rata ownership of The MLB Channel,” Carey said in his opening statement. “In a letter dated March 22nd, from Major League Baseball, they state they are not in a position to offer any equity in connection with this ‘opt-in’ opportunity without DirecTV’s consent. It will be interesting to see whether that consent is forthcoming, and with what conditions, as DirecTV reconciles whether it wears its ownership hat for the MLB Channel or its hat as a competitive distributor.”

While DISH has seemed almost a secondary player in all of this, word came late yesterday by way of the Sports Business Journal, that EchoStar has offered up, what they feel, matches MLB’s terms as it pertains to financials, and distribution. For the deal to fly, EchoStar is asking for an ownership stake in The Baseball Channel, as well. The sides were reportedly mulling the offer over.

The biggest question is, what is MLB’s endgame in all of this?

As I’ve reported before, the exclusive deal does not make good long-term business sense. Limiting viewers is a poor growth model, beyond the ill-will that has been created in this process. No matter how many times you turn the deal over in your head, one asks if by not making the deal exclusive, if MLB would have come out financially in the long run.

iN Demand offered $70 million per-year in a non-exclusive arrangement. If DirecTV offered half of what they are offering in an exclusive arrangement ($50 million), MLB would come out $20 million a year ahead of where they are now, and that’s without DISH in play. Maybe it’s a matter of driving consumers to MLB.TV. After all Bob DuPuy said yesterday, “If iN Demand and Dish choose not to step up to the plate as DirecTV has done, fans will still have several options.  They can switch to DirecTV, they can subscribe to MLB.TV and watch the games on the Internet, and they can watch the roughly 400 games that every fan in every Major League market has available without the out-of-market package.” That’s convenient. MLB will pull in revenues from the displaced through their online offering. Still, is it going to be enough to offset the revenues that could have been pulled in by keeping all the incumbents in the fold?

Added to this, there is more of the “ill-will” factor as it pertains to the relationship that MLB needs to keep with cable. Is it simply not a matter of time before MLB comes to cable looking to get The MLB Channel carried?

So, to repeat, the deal makes poor long-term business sense, outside of fan ill-will.

Lastly, I should note (once again) that I’ve been a DirecTV subscriber for some time and chose to do so for reasons outside of Extra Innings. Still, I’ve subscribed to EI in the past, and will continue to do so in the future. With that, and the season on the cusp, I looked up the schedule. Sunday, there was a limited slate of games on tap. Now, DirecTV is showing a more complete slate of games to choose from. At least that’s one less matter to be critical of in what might be deemed “ExtraInningsGate”.

 Maury Brown is the founder and president of The Biz of Baseball and an author for Baseball Prospectus. He can be contacted here. 



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?