who has the best cash back credit card unsecured loans with bad credit canada compare credit cards with low interest rates mbna canada credit card reviews cibc debit visa cards balance transfer cards with no fee reloadable prepaid credit cards canada apply for store credit cards with bad credit factors to consider when choosing a loan or credit card low credit card rate activate td bank visa gift card barclays credit card lost and stolen credit card limit increase without permission credit cards for no credit and no bank account i want to sign up for a credit card is getting a walmart credit card a good idea best credit cards with no annual fee for fair credit all unsecured credit cards for bad credit dillards credit card application online hdfc master credit card offers lloyds tsb airmiles duo credit card interest rate td bank prepaid visa card credit card debt calculator cnn tesco credit card transfer balance mbna virgin credit card contact number credit card cash advance paypal united credit card bonus why do i need a credit card for free apps on itunes consolidating credit card debt into mortgage best low rate balance transfer credit card credit card fraud punishment can range online payment for hsbc credit cards in india new small business credit cards for bad credit student no credit credit card bank of america credit card login home loans applying for a credit card online vs in person discover student card no credit history best credit card cashback singapore starwood american express credit card bonus compare credit card processing for small business online long term loans no credit check zero interest credit cards australia credit card comparison tool canada starbucks gold card benefits soy jcpenney credit card activation credit card travel deals where can i get online loan rbc bank visa platinum credit cards visa credit cards numbers free best travel insurance credit card canada the loan shop payday loan online credit cards for business expenses store credit cards best online payday loans for bad credit best unsecured credit card for bad credit rating best credit card to have in canada how do i apply for a walmart credit card online in canada aircel to airtel balance transfer non profit credit card debt relief apply for a credit card online how do i cancel my maurices credit card hsbc credit card app for ipad toys r us gold card points how to reduce my credit card debt fast how to pay hdfc credit card bill payment online from other bank citibank indian oil credit card online application online payday loan no credit check business credit card no cash advance fee cash loans online south africa easiest bad credit credit card get visa credit card applications for fair credit 0 credit cards transfer balance credit card history pdf hsbc credit card application status online india credit cards to apply for after chapter 7 bankruptcy i have no credit but i want a credit card best credit card offers low interest rate walmart mastercard gift card subject united cash loans phone number vanilla visa prepaid debit cards visa card protection on debit cards monthly credit card rate calculator visa black card credit requirements air canada credit card offers orchard bank secured credit card apply online anz credit card balance transfer form best bank first credit card apply for credit card online natwest mbna credit card review canada credit card verification form (ccvf) which credit card is easiest to get approved for in canada aib credit card protection services does the chase liquid card help build credit cheapest credit card processing rates how to redeem hdfc titanium credit card reward points hsbc credit card offers hk cash back credit card offers 2012 verifone credit card machine manual hsbc discover credit card no foreign transaction fee credit card singapore zurich credit card insurance reviews sears canada online credit card application who has the lowest interest rate credit card credit cards for good credit rating tesco credit card deals for existing customers mastercard credit card number hack santander credit card travelling abroad best airmiles credit card singapore 2013 security credit card wallet philippines us credit card number sample fake credit card number with cvv new york company visa credit card 0 interest credit card balance transfer free sentence for credit card fraud uk ge capital credit card apply bank of america cash rewards visa signature card review how to negotiate credit card settlement canada uk credit cards with free travel insurance prepaid credit cards no fees canada how long does it take to get a credit card in canada venture capital one credit card login hsbc credit card business reply envelope credit card fraud detection using hidden markov model a asp.net project how to buy a house with bad credit and no money virtual credit cards indian banks orchard bank secured credit card bad credit wells fargo credit card rewards review credit card balance transfer calculator excel how to get a platinum card american express compare credit card machines student credit cards visa best personal bad credit loans does applying for credit cards lower credit score irs credit limit worksheet 2009 elavon credit card processing costco paypal canada virtual credit cards check application status for best buy credit card compare citibank and hdfc credit cards what is the best prepaid credit card for online use maybank online credit card application philippines visa credit card merchant rates hdfc platinum credit card cash advance charges business rewards credit cards neiman marcus credit card services number can you get cashback on visa gift cards taking credit card payments over the phone hsbc classic credit card online application how fast does a secured credit card help your credit united credit card bonuses secured credit card with no annual fee student loans with bad credit history best credit card offer rewards what is cash advance rate on credit cards hdfc bank corporate credit card login commonwealth bank credit card repayment calculator applied bank credit card for bad credit cash advance rate commonwealth bank 0 apr purchases credit cards list of 12 month payday loans suze orman paying off credit card debt jpmorgan chase british airways credit card air miles credit cards reviews eligibility for platinum credit card hdfc activate new cibc credit card barclay credit card customer service number easiest unsecured credit card to get approved for with bad credit cheapest credit card machines for small business credit card reward programs best canada credit cards direct payday loan lender sites td business visa cardholder agreement american express credit card with no credit history hsbc bank credit card customer care number hsbc student account credit card wireless rfid credit card scanner virtual credit cards using paypal pay advance agreement i don;t want to enter a credit card on itunes average household credit card debt 2013 credit card expiration date javascript validator best credit card points guy airline rewards credit cards review remove apple credit card credit card compare rewards td gold elite visa card travel insurance credit card rewards programs best travel rewards cards canada commonwealth bank credit card travel insurance cover ikea credit card apply chase canada credit card best unsecured credit cards for fair credit credit card offers uk best rewards credit card usa hsbc credit card offers uk best credit card company for first timers credit card prime rate definition legal requirements for storing credit card information report lost credit card cibc types of td visa cards 6019 - brandsmart usa credit card pay advance form army british airways credit card login offer credit card company settlement reloadable prepaid credit cards india sbi credit card apply online in delhi city bank credit card movie offers credit card bank of ireland credit cards with cash back rewards and no annual fee australian average credit card debt how long does it take to get credit card in mail visa credit card company 0 balance transfer credit cards for fair credit how to pay standard chartered credit card bill online banking standard chartered credit card customer care number noida what types of credits would best describe credit cards credit cards explained for dummies uk hdfc credit card helpline no chandigarh credit card helpline hdfc bank best travel points credit card australia what happens to my credit score if i close a credit card hdfc credit cards helpline number best spg credit card deal top 10 credit cards cash back processing credit cards online for small businesses i need to get a credit card fast apply for goodyear credit card will the government help with credit card debt top 10 credit cards in malaysia mobile credit card processing canada android gas credit cards for bad credit secured credit cards for bad credit chase application for credit card visa fake credit cards that work online 2013 halifax bank of scotland credit card services canadian prepaid credit card companies no credit check credit cards for students 12 month bad credit loans no brokers canada trust visa phone number complaints about first premier credit cards best international credit card uk credit cards to apply for when you have no credit how can i apply for a credit card online with bad credit chase bad credit cards amscot payday advance faq horizon gold credit card catalog credit sbi credit card status best credit card deal 2012 credit card helpline standard chartered bank can i get a company credit card with bad credit standard chartered credit card bank best online credit card merchant services free cell phones no credit check no deposit no credit card which credit card has the lowest balance transfer fee post office platinum credit card bank of america credit card 200 cash back how to activate anz debit visa card hello kitty visa credit check card national city bank credit card application how to apply for a credit card in axis bank minimum credit card repayment calculator credit card online validator 2.11 jquery credit card validator github biggest credit card companies in the world sears credit card customer service telephone number loans online fast bad credit order free prepaid credit card best air mile rewards credit cards ocbc titanium credit card application form contact barclay bank credit card canara bank credit card apply online in india capital 1 credit card ppi claims magnum cash advance payday loan post office credit card payment address best visa travel rewards card what is the best first credit card for me natwest credit card fraud claim best balance transfer credit card in malaysia online application for credit card hdfc bank how to pick a bedroom door lock with a credit card no credit history credit cards chase visa card services cibc visa cards lost balance transfer fee credit card credit card cash advance fee chase sbi corporate credit card benefits how to increase credit card limit sbi same day online cash advance bank of america apply online for barclays bank credit card credit card loans for debt consolidation granite credit card online login hdfc credit card helpline karnataka anz credit card application form pdf same day cash advance online no credit check mobile credit card terminal reviews hsbc premier credit card rewards catalogue o percent balance transfers credit card credit cards with no credit check td canada trust secured credit card application pre approved credit card offers bank of america credit cards online natwest ebay paypal vs credit card easy online payday loan reviews how to get a credit card for your business with bad credit make barclay credit card payment online how long does it take to get credit card from chase credit card applications canada instant approval first premier credit cards reviews discover card for students with no credit history private student loans with bad credit diy iphone credit card stand bad credit auto loan instant decision apply for department store credit cards with bad credit best airline rewards credit card 2011 canada business credit cards rewards reviews which credit card should i get singapore apply for a credit card with bad credit history in south africa standard chartered bank credit card promotions sri lanka payday loan lenders uk reviews unsecured credit cards bad credit no credit check bank of america business accept credit cards how to offer credit card settlement of debt what is an issue number on a maestro credit card credit card logos psd mba credit card canada cheapest prepaid credit card ireland mobile credit card machines ireland easiest unsecured credit card to get with bad credit virtual credit card us billing address company credit cards for personal use pcs pay advance military pay credit card banks in pune reloadable credit cards no monthly fee hdfc credit card loan apply can a credit card company take money from a joint account how to negotiate a debt settlement with your credit card company belk credit card levels amazon bank of america credit card contact number loans pay back weekly hilton credit card co uk bank of america credit card international fees discover? card virtual credit card generator credit card low interest how to use paypal credit card reader america first credit union best credit card to build credit fast best credit cards for airmiles usa how often apply for chase credit cards new credit card rules credit cards reward program comparisons does chase offer virtual credit cards credit cards to consolidate my debt citibank reward credit card review joint account credit card offers bad credit car finance td canada trust virtual visa debit marriott credit card authorization forms online prepaid credit card number maurices credit card ebay hdfc credit card emi offer coral icici credit card offers canadian low rate credit cards what is the best credit card to have with no credit first cash advance reviews can you get a victoria secret credit card with no credit history how do i get a starbucks platinum card credit card for no credit capital one united credit card offer instant no credit check payday loans uk online apply for hdfc platinum credit card can you buy prepaid credit cards at shoppers drug mart buy virtual credit cards with liberty reserve platinum card american express limit can i use a target visa card anywhere using a personal loan to pay off credit card debt balance transfer credit card calculator cibc aerogold credit card login absa credit card limit increase forms icici credit card settlement noc barclays business credit card contact unsecured credit card for no credit pay off your credit card debt calculator jcpenney credit card services login my premier credit card processing fee pc credit card online banking rental car no credit card credit check cash back visa credit cards canada pay citibank credit card online payment hyatt summerfield suites credit card authorization form best buy rewards credit card payment get a free credit card with no credit checks apply for a visa credit card for students paypal charges for using credit card which credit card is easiest to get chase amazon credit card help 1 year post bankruptcy credit cards long term online loans for bad credit visa business credit card no personal guarantee how to make cash advance in bpi credit card best credit card balance transfer offers 2013 malaysia black cardigan coat hdfc virtual credit card charges do credit card gift cards work online best airline rewards credit card uk mbna launches new rate for life credit card cash advances on credit cards best credit card machine for small business uk get free credit card details online cash advance fee halifax credit card platinum credit cards hdfc furniture store credit cards canada apply for staples business credit card virgin credit cards uk login easy store credit cards to get approved for with no credit best way to get first credit card visa credit card travel insurance coverage credit cards that offer cash back rewards high interest credit cards apply for credit card with no credit no annual fee wells fargo secured credit card status best credit cards with low interest rates bank of america credit card offers for balance transfers best credit card company for bad credit credit cards for new business owners i need to apply for a visa credit card credit card apr explained bbb list of payday lenders paypal credit card fees ebay new credit card offers orchard credit card application status icici instant titanium credit card benefits barclays platinum simplicity credit card secured credit card for no credit history 100 credit card approval with bad credit example nandos black card tesco bank credit card login american express credit card application check citi credit cards rewards programs hsbc gold credit card interest rate low rate credit card anz mis sold ppi credit card calculator help paying off credit card debt zero percent interest credit card offers barclaycard credit card charges abroad park hyatt credit card authorization form payday loan bad credit lender only walmart mastercard login jewelry stores that offer credit cards how do credit card companies make money list of uk credit card companies first premier bank credit card login page bank of america travel rewards cards best credit cards with rewards uk how to load paper into verifone credit card machine how to get approved for a credit card with no credit stolen credit card numbers free 2013 first premier bank credit card account halifax credit card change of address how do you apply for a credit card can international student apply for credit card in australia best place to get a credit card for the first time cash advance credit card chase paypal mastercard credit card login hdfc bank credit cards redeem reward points credit card reward points value sbi platinum credit card activation how to apply for credit card with bad credit in india mbna canada credit card rewards woolworths everyday rewards credit card review coast capital business credit card bad credit loans no fees upfront best credit card business how do i get a us credit card in uk canada best credit card points can you get a payday loan online new york and company credit card application airline credit cards with no annual fee apply for capital one credit card in canada pay target visa credit card online credit card number format best cash back credit card what are credit cards made out of united credit card bonus points united cash loans online black card points care credit credit card agreement best credit card to build credit history best business credit cards 2013 canada credit card comparison sites uk apply for credit card visa standard chartered credit card status tracking loan with bad credit uk how to apply for credit card online in india post office 0 credit card balance transfer long black cardigan loan sharks online uk pay walmart credit cards online minimum payment credit card calculator uk best bad credit loans reviews best buy reward zone credit card online payment
Home Media News Opening Statement on DirecTV Deal: Carl Vogel - EchoStar

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 686 guests online

Atom RSS

Opening Statement on DirecTV Deal: Carl Vogel - EchoStar PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 10
Written by Carl Vogel   
Tuesday, 27 March 2007 04:02
President and Vice Chairman,
Echostar Satellite L.L.C
before the
U.S. Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee

Hearing on Exclusive Sports Programming: Examining Competition and Consumer Choice

March 27, 2007

Chairman Kerry, and members of the Committee, on behalf of EchoStar Satellite, I want to thank you for inviting our company to discuss the important issue of exclusive sports programming.

My name is Carl Vogel, and I am President and Vice Chairman of EchoStar. Since we began offering service 11 years ago, EchoStar’s DISH Network has grown to become the 4th largest multi-channel video provider in the country serving more than 13 million subscribers.

Exclusive content distribution deals in any major sport today do not promote competition. They harm existing consumers while limiting choices in the future.

As we sit here today, the deal presented by Major League Baseball is designed to be an exclusive deal for DirecTV in substance, despite statements to the contrary regarding form and the opportunity to “opt-in”.

The terms offered by Major League Baseball effectively tie the carriage of the Extra Innings package TODAY to a firm commitment to launch The MLB Channel to over 10 million of our subscribers in 2009. We find these demands inconsistent in a climate where Congress, the FCC, and the American public are asking for more a-la-carte choices.

(Select Read More to read the rest of Vogel's opening statement)

Despite these onerous terms, we stand ready to match the current offer in its entirety to protect our consumers and remain competitive. However, in its entirety must be apples to apples, which will require EchoStar to acquire a pro-rata ownership of The MLB Channel. In a letter dated March 22nd, from Major League Baseball, they state they are not in a position to offer any equity in connection with this “opt-in” opportunity without DirecTV’s consent. It will be interesting to see whether that consent is forthcoming, and with what conditions, as DirecTV reconciles whether it wears its ownership hat for the MLB Channel or its hat as a competitive distributor. With only four short days to bring this to conclusion, it appears the negotiations for the Extra Innings package may need some extra innings themselves.

Given this set of circumstances, the deal with Major League Baseball and DirecTV regarding the Extra Innings package will likely proceed as an exclusive deal, disenfranchising over 300,000 consumers nationwide. Numerous distributors, including EchoStar, were part of building the Extra Innings brand and consumer appeal over the past ten years. Creating exclusivity with sports content is anti-competitive; however, it is particularly problematic when that very programming has been available to a number of consumers, on a number of platforms, for a number of years.

The Extra Innings package became available on DISH Network three years ago and many of our 55,000 subscribers who have chosen this season ticket live in rural areas. These consumers most likely have chosen DISH Network as a result of our low prices and flexible packaging. The incremental increase in Extra Innings subscriptions clearly represents the best example where increasing, rather than restricting access to sports content has worked in favor of consumers.

Major League Baseball now wants to limit access and has rationalized the fan displacement by stating DirecTV will provide equipment and installation free of charge. This analysis fails to recognize any price difference between EchoStar and DirecTV. In many cases, a switch to DirecTV is tantamount to a 33% rate increase just to gain access the Extra Innings package. For Major League Baseball to reach into consumers pockets and suggest this is a reasonable choice is not only disrespectful but clearly points out that Major League Baseball has in this instance, relegated themselves to a well compensated sales agent for DirecTV.

Our motives are very straightforward. We want to compete.

In conclusion, we are quite certain that consumers would far prefer a world where exclusives over regional sports, the NFL Sunday Ticket and the Extra Innings package did not exist. Such relationships do not currently promote competition, but rather limit consumer choice to one provider. This proposed Extra Innings exclusivity with DirecTV does not expand the market; it merely provides for a migration of subscribers from many providers to one. Certainly, exclusive content relationships may today be within the letter of the law, but they cannot possibly meet the spirit of Congressional intent.

Thank you, and I look forward to answering your questions.



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?