low apr credit cards for bad credit best pay as you go credit cards compare travel credit card canada icici bank online apply credit cards natwest interest free credit card anz credit card travel insurance claim gas company credit cards bad credit average merchant credit card fees belk stores credit card payment authorize.net ipad credit card reader how can i apply for a orchard bank credit card barclaycard platinum credit card travel insurance hsbc platinum credit card travel insurance uk should i consolidate my credit card debt into my mortgage credit cards with low apr for bad credit apply credit card online india instant approval how to get free apps on kindle fire without a credit card student loans with bad credit sallie mae fast online cash advance good credit and credit cards bpi credit card cash advance charges visa gift cards walmart best low interest rate credit cards aaa international travel credit card tesco credit card cash advance limit best balance transfer credit cards 2012 malaysia easiest store credit card to get uk bank of america credit card rewards cash sbi credit card charges southwest business credit card 50 000 download credit card authorization form template fake credit card information that works 2013 how long does it take to get credit card from bank of america reducing credit card debt fast citibank first credit card visa credit card low interest rates best no fee travel credit cards canada credit card holder leather weekly credit card payment calculator student credit cards poor credit easy to get unsecured credit cards with bad credit good credit cards with low interest low interest credit cards for bad credit best travel credit cards october 2013 tesco credit card 0 offer anz credit card promotions singapore should i take out a personal loan to pay off credit card debt aqua credit card contact email get instant loans online best credit card transfer balance australia anz platinum credit card review best credit card reward program 2013 hsbc credit card points redeem india payday lenders online no credit check opt out of credit card offers gov american airlines credit card 50000 points check your standard chartered credit card status sears credit card customer service contact number is kohls an easy credit card to get post office credit card contact email how to get a bad credit loan for a house best bank to get a student credit card prepaid credit card australian dollars credit cards canada 2013 sbi credit card login bad credit auto loan calculator virgin money black credit card nationwide select credit card minimum payment payday loan online no teletrack direct lender hdfc bank chennai customer care numbers credit cards orchard bank credit card reviews 2012 amazon credit card bonus offer credit card machine for iphone canada costco credit card machine uk credit card numbers 2013 with cvv wells fargo student credit card credit score consolidate credit card debt td canada trust capital one credit card no annual fee halifax credit card login online payday loan lenders no credit check list safe unsecured loans with bad credit best air miles credit card canada credit card terminal rental ireland sign up for a credit card visa sbi credit card annual fee bad credit card loans features of axis bank credit cards best no interest credit cards no transfer fee best cashback credit card canada 2012 citibank credit cards apply online india credit card validator jquery best buy credit card customer service contact number how to use a mastercard gift card online sampath bank credit card promotions 2012 easy credit cards canada hsbc credit card air miles credit card interest calculator excel formula belk credit card application status instant paypal virtual credit card apply for a mastercard debit halifax credit card customer services email credit card numbers that work online 2013 visa 0 interest balance transfer credit cards australia how long does it take to get credit card in mail secured credit card citibank credit card application status bangalore net pay advance wichita orchard bank bad credit credit card apply for student credit card visa no interest credit card for 18 months ppi credit card calculator instant credit card approval for bad credit what is the best no fee credit card in canada tesco credit card application contact number guaranteed payday loan lenders uk best buy credit card annual fee tj maxx credit card information stolen applying for a credit card with no credit credit card a door lock open bank of america credit card services mailing address capital one visa platinum card what are the differences between credit cards and debit cards what does your credit score have to be to get a sears card ba gold card requirements amazon.co.uk mastercard credit card choosing a credit card processor cibc visa cash back credit card anz platinum frequent flyer credit card travel insurance canadian credit card companies that use transunion chevron credit card payment mailing address walmart prepaid visa card canada best cashback credit cards for gas and groceries student credit card credit union ocbc great eastern credit card application form plan to reduce credit card debt payday loans no credit check direct lenders only how do i get an american express black card how can i get a credit card today with bad credit credit cards with free transactions abroad using credit cards abroad orchard credit card review payday advance no credit check nz whats the average credit card limit sbi irctc credit card application unsecured discover card for bad credit hdfc credit card application form pdf capital one platinum card uk walmart credit cards online application using uk visa debit cards in usa credit union credit cards online how to apply credit card in axis bank canadian credit card rate comparison mastercard uk credit card for bad credit no deposit instant approval sear credit card rewards 0 interest balance transfer credit cards malaysia apply online for credit card pnb all ge money bank credit cards hsbc apply credit card philippines bank of america credit card cash advance check travel rewards cards compared best credit cards for business owners barclays credit card login page direct payday lenders online uk valid credit card information online icici credit card apply natwest credit card online banking credit card fraud detection project in asp.net wells fargo credit card services online do you need a credit card for itunes compare icici bank credit cards credit card with 0 interest on balance transfers for 12 months 0 credit card balance transfer no fee myer visa card apply online best credit card application pay orchard credit card by phone best american airlines credit card offer average credit limit on credit card compare business credit cards canada free prepaid credit cards no application fee chase virtual credit card number unsecured credit cards to rebuild credit activate orchard bank credit card number bank of america credit card services login best offer credit card square slices credit-card processing fees cheapest wireless credit card machine check status of bank of america credit card application tesco credit card login ireland free bad credit cards what is cash advance fee on credit card mbna platinum credit card uk best credit card to use for international travel best credit card bad credit unsecured business credit cards with cash back best unsecured credit cards for rebuilding credit free valid visa credit card numbers 2012 toys r us credit card ge online payday loan 100 approval does applying for credit card affect credit rating best credit card for european travel 2012 delta airlines credit card review check chevron credit card application status first progress secured credit card reviews new millenium bank credit card for bad credit top 10 cash back credit cards uk how do credit card consolidation services work can square take international credit cards perks for disney credit card holders best credit card rate us visa canada credit card exchange rate unsecured business credit cards bad credit credit card protection under ?100 credit card fraud detection project download visa credit card for bad credit canada visa credit card number generator with cvv virtual credit card number usa best credit card debt relief programs student credit cards 0 interest what are the best credit cards to have can you get cashback on a walmart visa gift card credit card apply online instant approval uk cash advance payday loan direct lenders travel credit cards best canada best corporate credit card for small business benefits of accepting credit cards small business best student visa card canada new york and company credit card payment number aadvantage credit card signup bonus hdfc bank online credit card payment credit card with best airline rewards good credit cards to apply for with bad credit business credit card no cash advance fee unsecured loans instant decision online citibank credit card cash advance philippines fake visa credit card numbers with security code online payday loan scams how to make sbi credit card payment online australian credit card rewards comparison compare interest free balance transfer credit cards best australian credit cards comparison british airways visa credit card usa ebay credit card on file prepaid credit cards free credit card scanner for android phone cash loans now uk fast payday loan no credit check how to get a car loan with bad credit in ireland installment loans online approval free valid credit card numbers with security code 2011 prepaid credit card no fees canada can you use credit cards abroad starwood preferred guest credit card bonus points best prepaid credit card for international travel no fee prepaid credit card canada reward credit cards uk visa debit card cash back india get a credit card with bad credit unsecured business credit card offers with rewards visa international travel credit card cash advance fee vanquis cash advance fee hsbc credit card credit limit td emerald visa card what are the benefits and disadvantages to the small business of accepting credit cards hdfc online credit card payment login prepaid credit card in canada using visa debit cards in india best credit card cashback singapore linking everyday rewards cards staples business credit card status citi corporate credit card customer service reward credit card review canada compare 0 credit cards balance transfers cancel intuit credit card processing new direct payday loan lenders are air mile credit cards worth it best credit card promotions 2011 credit card to help rebuild bad credit short term bad credit loan uk what is the best credit card on the market barclays apple credit card phone number paypal credit card verification unavailable 12 months interest free credit cards australia black and gold card provident inner fence credit card terminal uk online payday advance scams best student credit cards discover easy cash advances online 12 month bad credit loans lenders td canada trust apply for credit card best corporate credit card canada commonwealth bank credit card rates first credit card invented in 1950 discover student more card no credit history receiving credit card payments small business cancel hbc mastercard credit card buy prepaid credit cards online credit card rewards comparison 2013 7 best credit card for bad credit amazon credit card further review credit cards for bad credit uk how do i pay sbi credit card bill online best credit card for travel rewards singapore tesco credit card bank sort code credit cards in canada comparison how to negotiate a debt settlement with credit card companies will my chase credit card work in canada nordstrom visa credit card phone number platinum credit card uk employee uses company credit card personal use starwood business credit card offer citigroup american airlines credit card login best credit card approval compare credit card singapore 2011 12 month bad credit loans no brokers metrobank credit card balance transfer calculator how much does quickbooks credit card processing cost pay direct student loans credit card machine for iphone reviews visa credit card travel insurance canada how to use redeem points in citibank credit card standard credit card fees for businesses best virtual credit cards things to consider when comparing credit cards bank of america credit card apr pc credit card number hdfc credit card interest free emi debit card vs credit card protection average credit card interest rate charge credit cards online free how hard is it to get a natwest credit card set up credit card payment processing how to cancel credit card without hurting credit score square card reader international credit cards instant online approval business credit cards what;s the best credit card to get to build credit what kind of credit card should i get if i have bad credit what does cashback on credit cards mean how to use a credit card machine video best credit card comparison site bank of america secured credit card minimum payment business credit cards for new businesses with bad credit fake credit card number uk cheap interest payday loans online do any credit cards offer free travel insurance best chase credit card for students 5 different types of credit cards top rated cash reward credit cards wizard clear advantage credit card apply skymiles delta credit card login td us dollar visa cardholder agreement elavon credit card processing reviews new canadian credit cards 2013 amex credit card number format online payday lenders uk paypal online credit card processing top credit card companies apply for a mastercard debit card should i get a credit card to improve credit score offers on citibank platinum credit cards bad credit loan lenders best cash advance places online amazon credit card security breach free online credit card application in india how to check hsbc credit card points kroger us bank credit card hsbc uk credit card number chase credit card services elgin il best credit card apps for iphone 4 flight offers on icici credit cards how to view icici credit card reward points how can i get a credit card with no credit score dbs visa credit card exchange rate visa credit card number hack how to prevent credit card fraud on the internet credit card fraud online payment cash back visa best balance transfer credit card in malaysia payday online loans no credit check best credit card for bad credit buy gold uk credit card chase business credit card promotion calculate credit card balance transfer calculator marriott rewards premier credit card fee free credit cards australia best travel rewards credit cards canada 2011 credit card authorisation form template australia standard chartered platinum credit card malaysia platinum card emirates instant loans online no guarantor can you get a credit card the same day you apply payday loan lender list payday loan direct lenders only no brokers hsbc neiman marcus credit card login credit card interest free on purchases for 12 months horizon gold credit card catalog tesco online credit card statement fake credit card numbers that work 2012 how to apply for a us credit card from canada best credit card for no credit yahoo hdfc credit card bank credit card debt consolidation navy federal credit union routing number hdfc credit card reward points catalogue 2012 pdf credit card rewards programs what do cardholders think pc credit card processing credit card debt settlement uk bad credit credit cards unsecured instant approval uk how to apply credit card which credit card is the best in malaysia 2011 sams club discover business credit card login are there any good credit cards for bad credit is nab credit card travel insurance good chase freedom student credit card low interest unsecured credit cards for bad credit credit card machines for small business best rates fixed rate credit card definition barclays credit card application axis bank credit cards types can you buy prepaid credit cards at walgreens bank of ireland credit card balance transfers 15 cashback american express cards sign online payday loan uk canada best credit card for students pay vanquis credit card online cancel horizon gold credit card prepaid credit cards international use statute of limitations on credit card debt in india apply for credit cards to rebuild bad credit hsbc credit card rate of interest secured visa card canada cibc secured bad credit loans uk best credit card reward system uk credit card size can i accept credit cards over the phone with paypal best credit card deals rewards best value for money credit card india credit card interest free offers track icici credit card application status online best credit card offer april 2013 hdfc credit card bill payment by other bank debit card sbi visa card wiki hsbc neiman marcus credit card payment how can i reduce credit card debt quickly platinum card american express requirements prepaid uk credit card what is a real credit card number and security code application for credit card visa how does square credit card app work sign up for walmart credit card online platinum card emirates airline current limitation of online credit card payment system get a free credit card with no credit checks which credit card is best in india yahoo answers citibank business credit card payment secured business credit cards wells fargo credit cards for bad credit history good secured credit card to rebuild credit nandos black card timeout credit card payoff calculator excel 2007 best credit card with bad credit score rental car no credit card credit check pay american airlines credit card online chase freedom visa credit card customer service credit card amount checker online manual credit card machine staples what type of credit card is best for me top unsecured credit cards for bad credit military payday advance instant cash loan hsbc 0 credit card offers credit card fraud detection techniques pdf prepaid gift credit cards australia how to get your first credit card with bad credit bad credit loan lenders uk canadian prepaid credit card companies credit card protection insurance australia hack visa credit card number halifax credit card online decision secured canadian credit cards for bad credit travel reward credit cards for average credit credit card student natwest best travel credit cards rewards pay amazon bank of america credit card pre-guaranteed credit cards australia southwest chase credit card application status walmart credit card account login benefits of a business accepting credit cards from their customers credit card comparison frequent flyer points best us credit cards for international travel is it best to pay off high interest credit cards first best first credit card company united credit card united mileage plus review black patent credit card holder complaint letter to credit card company pay lic premium using credit cards hdfc credit card apply online in jaipur wells fargo credit card services merchant legit fast cash loans online paypal vs credit card merchant fees interest free balance transfer credit cards uk
Home Media News Opening Statement: Chase Carey Pres. and CEO of DirecTV

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 759 guests online

Atom RSS

Opening Statement: Chase Carey Pres. and CEO of DirecTV PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 5
PoorBest 
Written by Chase Carey   
Tuesday, 27 March 2007 03:54
Chase Carey
President and Chief Executive Officer, DIRECTV, Inc.
Before the
Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation
March 27, 2007

Chairman Inouye, Co-Chairman Stevens, and members of the Committee, my name is Chase Carey.  I am the President and CEO of DIRECTV.  Thank you for inviting me to testify today regarding DIRECTV’s recently announced agreement with Major League Baseball (“MLB”) to continue to carry MLB’s Extra Innings package of out-of-town baseball games.

I would like to address four issues today.  First, I’ll describe the fair, open, and arm’s length negotiation for carriage of Extra Innings – a negotiation resulting directly from the pro-competitive, pro-consumer policies Congress has put in place.  DIRECTV has entered into a carriage agreement with MLB, while EchoStar and a consortium of the biggest cable operators remain free to match DIRECTV’s offer until Opening Day.  So when our competitors complain that they don’t have rights to Extra Innings, what they’re really saying is that they’d like to pay less for those rights than DIRECTV – a lament common to many MVPDs in many circumstances.[1]
          
Second, I will address another aspect of competition at work – DIRECTV’s plan to transform Extra Innings from a mere collection of games in low definition to a truly compelling, high definition experience for the most avid baseball fans.  Regardless of whether our competitors step up to the plate, DIRECTV intends to make more baseball available to more fans in a more compelling format than ever before.  This is a big win for baseball fans.

Third, I’ll explain how the competitive marketplace Congress created will ensure that fans of our Nation’s pastime will not be left behind.  If EchoStar and the cable consortium step up and match DIRECTV’s offer, their subscribers will continue to have access to this programming from those providers.  If they don’t, subscribers who want to switch to DIRECTV can do so seamlessly.  The small number of subscribers who do not or cannot switch will be able to watch games over broadband – an increasingly viable alternative to traditional television.

Fourth, while DIRECTV’s agreement with MLB is entirely consistent with the policies Congress established to create a competitive marketplace, Congress can always change those policies.  But I would respectfully suggest that, if this Committee is concerned about competition and access issues, these issues should be examined within the broader context of communications and competition policy.  Such an examination might address topics such as the tying of video and broadband access services, the “slow-rolling” of access to Internet video, tying arrangements for programming imposed by competitors with market power, and home-team sports exclusives.  DIRECTV would be happy to participate in such a discussion.

(Select Read More to view the rest of Carey's opening statement) 

I. DIRECTV Negotiated a Fair and Arm’s Length Agreement With MLB; Cable and EchoStar Can Have the Same Deal if they Want It.

It is sometimes difficult to remember that, little more than a decade ago, Americans had only one choice of multichannel video provider – the cable monopoly.  Today, nearly every American can choose among their cable operator, DIRECTV, and EchoStar.  Verizon and AT&T now also offer service in many parts of the country.

These competitors have differentiated themselves in the marketplace.  Cable, and now Verizon and AT&T, compete by offering a “triple play” of voice, video and data – a bundle that DIRECTV cannot yet offer on its own.  EchoStar has carved out a niche as the low-cost provider, and offers a host of foreign language exclusives.  And DIRECTV differentiates itself through an unparalleled selection of sports programming and unmatched technical innovation – including an investment of hundreds of millions of dollars on new satellites to offer consumers their local broadcast stations in HD and over 100 national HD programming services.  These unique offerings helped DIRECTV to differentiate itself and begin to break the stranglehold of the cable monopolies.  The cable industry, in turn, found itself forced to spend billions to innovate and become more responsive to consumers’ desires – today offering a competitive, attractive package that includes its own differentiated video-on-demand and bundled Internet offerings.

Cable, to be sure, still possesses an overwhelming market share, which distorts competition to this day.  But the fact remains that today there is competition where before there was none.   This is the success story Congress – and this Committee, in particular – helped write.
    
And this is the context in which DIRECTV negotiated its agreement to carry Extra Innings.  Several months ago, MLB initiated discussions with a number of MVPDs and their affiliates – including DIRECTV, EchoStar, and iN DEMAND (owned by Comcast, Time Warner, and Cox) – regarding carriage of Extra Innings.  These discussions concerned both exclusive and non-exclusive carriage.  Each competitor was given the opportunity to compete for Extra Innings.  And each did.

In the end, despite the fact that it has a modest nationwide market share, only DIRECTV showed an interest in carrying Extra Innings on terms acceptable to MLB, including helping to launch the MLB Channel and carrying it widely to our subscribers.  So earlier this month, DIRECTV and MLB announced that they had reached agreement for carriage of Extra Innings and the MLB Channel.

That agreement gave DIRECTV’s competitors – all of whom had a seat at the table during the first round of negotiations – yet another turn at bat.  Until Opening Day, MLB will allow incumbent MVPDs willing to agree to terms equivalent to DIRECTV’s carriage arrangement to offer their subscribers this programming.  In other words, Comcast and Cox and Time Warner and EchoStar can provide out-of-town games to their subscribers if they want to.  The agreement says only that they cannot do so on the cheap.  So if they agree to pay the price DIRECTV pays, agree to carry the MLB Channel in the same manner as DIRECTV, and agree to comply with the other terms and conditions that apply to DIRECTV, they can carry Extra Innings.  It’s their choice.  This is why Time Warner’s top programming negotiator recently said she was not sure why people have criticized the deal as if it were “rigged” against competition, when the issue really boils down to the “evaluation of whether acquiring programming is too expensive or not.”[2]

Now that both iN DEMAND and EchoStar have access to Extra Innings on comparable terms and conditions as DIRECTV, we expected EchoStar and the cable industry to stop complaining and start competing.  But they haven’t.  Now they’re claiming that MLB’s offer to match DIRECTV’s terms isn’t fair.
 
They first contend that the agreement is unfair because DIRECTV will have an ownership interest in the MLB Channel (not in MLB or the Extra Innings package).  But this isn’t unfair at all.  To begin with, because of DIRECTV’s ownership, MLB cannot offer DIRECTV the MLB Channel on an exclusive basis.  If DIRECTV’s competitors think DIRECTV’s ownership interest is inconsistent with this obligation, they already have an avenue for redress at the FCC.[3]  Moreover, granting DIRECTV an ownership interest in exchange for its willingness to be the “first mover” in carrying this channel is a very common industry practice.  The FCC reports that cable operators own dozens of channels, including many of the most important regional sports networks (“RSNs”) such as those in New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, San Diego and Washington D.C.[4]
   
DIRECTV’s rivals also complain that the distribution requirements for the MLB Channel that DIRECTV agreed to are too onerous.  This is nothing but a public relations ploy.  If anything, the distribution requirement actually favors cable operators.  Based on the distribution formula in the agreement, DIRECTV has to distribute the MLB Channel to roughly 80 percent of its total subscribers, while cable operators would have to distribute it to approximately 40 percent of their total subscribers.  The very terms for distribution cable denounces as unfair are equivalent to, or in many instances less stringent than, the requirements cable operators demand for the programming they themselves own.

DIRECTV’s rivals may not like these terms.  But parties who do not like terms of carriage cannot cry foul on that basis alone.  This is how programming negotiations work.  If an MVPD believes that programming is too expensive, it can choose not to carry the programming.  This happens all the time.  EchoStar, for example, doesn’t carry the YES network for this very reason, so EchoStar subscribers in New York can’t watch most Yankees games.  MLB’s insistence that other MVPDs live by the same deal DIRECTV did isn’t unfair, it is simply the marketplace at work – and surely isn’t a subject worthy of Congressional intervention.

II. DIRECTV’s Carriage of Extra Innings Will Be a Big Win for Fans.

I do not know whether EchoStar and the cable industry will ultimately match DIRECTV’s offer to carry Extra Innings.  I do know, however, that DIRECTV has big plans for Extra Innings – which is one reason why we have (so far) been willing to pay more than anybody else for it.  DIRECTV will make more baseball available to more fans in a more compelling format than ever before.

For starters, DIRECTV will add a mosaic channel and a Strike Zone channel (similar to the NFL Sunday Ticket Red Zone Channel) that will deliver live cut-ins of games throughout the country.  We will also provide great entertainment to fans with real-time scores, player and team stats and other innovations that complement the sport of baseball.  Most importantly, DIRECTV expects to provide most, if not all, games in high definition for the 2008 baseball season – an innovation that most cable operators cannot match.

Moreover, as part of the Extra Innings agreement, DIRECTV will also make The MLB Channel widely available when the channel launches in 2009.

DIRECTV’s transformation of Extra Innings should come as no surprise.  This, after all, is what DIRECTV has done for other programming.  For example, DIRECTV recently completely revamped supplemental coverage of NASCAR races.  The cable industry had the rights to NASCAR content for years, but did little with this programming and attracted only 30,000 customers in 2006.  DIRECTV obtained the rights this year to what is now NASCAR Hotpass, and debuted a service at this year’s Daytona 500 that bears little resemblance to cable’s bare-bones offering.  DIRECTV’s NASCAR Hotpass features five dedicated “Driver Channels,” each focusing on an individual driver and offering multiple camera angles, real-time stats, team audio communications and dedicated announcer teams.  Although the NASCAR season started only recently, DIRECTV already has more than three times the subscribers to this programming than the cable industry had in 2006.

DIRECTV expects that once it adds interactive features, high-definition service, and the MLB Channel, many new subscribers will sign up for Extra Innings with DIRECTV. This will make DIRECTV’s service more attractive than our cable competitors.  Those competitors, in turn, will have to improve their services to keep up.  This, again, is the vibrant competitive marketplace that Congress envisioned at work.

III. The Competitive Marketplace Envisioned by Congress Will Provide Numerous Alternatives for Baseball Fans.

The same competitive marketplace that permitted DIRECTV to obtain the rights to Extra Innings in a fair and open manner will also ensure that baseball fans will continue to be able to watch their favorite teams.  Right now, both EchoStar and iN DEMAND have the option to continue to provide this programming to their subscribers – if they are willing to pay the fair price negotiated at arm’s length between DIRECTV and MLB.  Even if DIRECTV remains the only MVPD to carry Extra Innings, however, non-DIRECTV subscribers will not be harmed in any meaningful way.

First, consumers can switch to DIRECTV with no start-up costs, no equipment to buy, and no installation charges.  When they do so, they will get a better service at a better value than is offered by cable.  DIRECTV, unlike cable, is 100% digital.  DIRECTV offers more programming than cable.  On average, DIRECTV costs significantly less per channel than cable.  And DIRECTV’s customer service is second to none – having surpassed the cable industry average in each of the last six years.[5]  This, again, is how a competitive marketplace is supposed to work.

Unfortunately, cable operators are doing their best to prevent this.  Cable, for example, penalizes customers by dramatically increasing the price of Internet service if the customer drops cable’s video service.  To overcome cable’s barriers, DIRECTV has chosen to offer customers who want to switch no upfront costs and more compelling content.
 
Second, every single game carried on Extra Innings will remain available online through MLB.com.  Internet video is improving dramatically,[6] and MLB announced its intent to offer upgraded picture quality this season. Thus, subscribers who choose not to (or cannot) subscribe to DIRECTV will still be able to watch the games of their choice.  Here again, however, cable operators are attempting to hinder the marketplace.  If cable did not prohibit a direct connection between the Internet and the set top box, MLB.com could easily be viewed on television sets.


Third, the arrangement will not disrupt competition among MVPDs.  To begin with, relatively few subscribers are affected at all.  Only 230,000 non-DIRECTV customers subscribed to Extra Innings last year – less than one half of one percent of all television homes.[7]  DIRECTV estimates that there are relatively few viewers – no more than three percent of the cable segment (approximately 180,000 Extra Innings subscribers) – who cannot receive DIRECTV service.  This translates to roughly 5,000 subscribers – each of whom can access the games over the Internet.  Moreover, this agreement does not deny a single fan the right to follow his or her home team.  In all of its programming arrangements, DIRECTV has been respectful of fans’ rights to view their home team sports.  Extra Innings is a premium package of out-of-town games – designed to serve baseball’s most avid fans without adversely affecting viewership of MLB’s national and local telecasts.  By contrast, our cable competitors have withheld core home team sports programming from nearly half a million satellite customers in Philadelphia and San Diego.


Fourth, the marketplace will continue to provide subscribers without Extra Innings a wealth of options for watching their favorite sport.  If Extra Innings were to disappear tomorrow, MLB would still offer more televised games by far than any other U.S. sport.  Regardless of the MVPD to which they subscribe, fans throughout the country can watch their home team on broadcast television or RSNs – assuming that cable-affiliated RSNs continue to make their programming available to all MVPDs at non-discriminatory rates.  In addition, fans without Extra Innings can still watch an impressive number of out-of-town games.  On average, more than 400 games are televised in each market – on local broadcast television, RSNs, and MLB’s national partners FOX, TBS, and ESPN.

IV. A Broader Review of Competition Policy May Be Appropriate.

Members of this Committee are naturally concerned about consumer choice and access to content.  So is DIRECTV.  But Congress cannot examine these issues in a vacuum – and certainly should not start with this arm’s length, pro-competitive deal.  If it truly seeks to ensure that every American has a choice among video providers and access to content, this Committee can choose among any number of issues that affect far more consumers.
If, for example, this Committee is concerned about the ability of subscribers to switch MVPDs, it might examine why cable operators dramatically increase the price for their broadband service to subscribers that switch from cable to satellite for video service.  In Washington DC, for example, Comcast charges $33.99 for Internet service when bundled with video and voice, but $57.95 for stand-alone Internet – a 70 percent increase in price.  Even though DIRECTV offers a lower price for a better video service, consumers with cable modems lose money by choosing DIRECTV.  If Congress seeks to maximize consumer choice – as it should – cable’s tying of Internet and video services is worthy of review.
   
If this Committee is concerned that viewers might be denied access to content they wish to view, it might examine whether cable operators should be able to degrade the service their broadband subscribers receive when accessing video content from non-affiliated websites (or entities that do not pay to ensure access), or preclude such access altogether.  As more and more video content migrates to the Internet, cable operators will increasingly have the incentive and ability to determine what their broadband subscribers can and cannot see.  A cable operator could even, for example, prohibit a baseball fan from visiting MLB.com (or, more likely, could “slow-roll” communications to that site compared with communications from its own site).
 
If this Committee is concerned about bundling channels in contract negotiations, it might wish to focus more broadly on tying arrangements imposed by parties with market power.  For example, Comcast recently required DIRECTV to distribute its “G4” gaming channel to 80 percent of its subscribers in order to continue to carry Comcast SportsNet Mid Atlantic at market rates.  A broader examination of arrangements like this would consider the pros and cons of today’s programming marketplace and possible ideas for revising it.
 
And finally, if this Committee is concerned about sports programming, it should begin by examining the worst instances of sports withholding.  Congress and the FCC have found repeatedly over the years that cable operators can abuse their formidable market power by arranging to withhold programming they own.  And they do that today in Philadelphia and San Diego, where half a million satellite subscribers cannot watch their home teams.  Surely that – and not an arm’s length, non-exclusive, pro-competitive deal such as that between DIRECTV and MLB for carriage of out-of-town games – is worthy of this Committee’s consideration.

*                         *                         *

The video marketplace continues to evolve as competition takes hold under the regime Congress has put in place.  DIRECTV’s arrangement with MLB is part of that process – the result of fair and open competition for programming that even today remains available to DIRECTV’s rivals.  DIRECTV intends to upgrade Extra Innings significantly, giving avid baseball fans more than they have ever had from this package before.  We will also make the transition of any subscriber who wants this programming from DIRECTV as seamless as possible.  In the end, then, DIRECTV’s agreement with MLB is an example of how the competitive marketplace created by this Committee is working – not how it needs to be changed.

[1]       Time Warner’s top programming negotiator recently said as much – stating that she was not sure why people have criticized the deal as if it were “rigged” against competition, when the issue really boils down to the “evaluation of whether acquiring programming is too expensive or not.” SkyReport E-News, Mar. 13, 2007.
[2]       SkyReport E-News, Mar. 13, 2007.
[3]       General Motors Corp., Hughes Electronics Corp., and The News Corporation Limited, 19 FCC Rcd. 473 (2004) (“News-Hughes”).
[4]       Annual Assessment of the Status of Competition in the Market for the Delivery of Video Programming, 21 FCC Rcd. 2503 App. C (2006)
[5]       See Steve Donohue, “DirecTV Tops J.D. Power Survey,” Multichannel News, Aug. 16, 2006, available at http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6363083.html.
[6]       See, e.g., Peter Grant, Plugging the Web Into the TV, Wall St. J., Aug. 4, 2006, at A11 (describing the rapid advances in online video, and stating that, with a TiVo device, one “can’t even tell whether it came from the TV or off the Internet.”).
[7]      Not to minimize the inconvenience to these customers, but it is worth noting that that tens of millions of  subscribers “churn,” switching video providers every year.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?